1. Podcasts
  2. Today, Explained
  3. Is Katseye ok?
Today, Explained

19 Nov 2026 · 26m · 14 chapters

In short

The Vox “Today Explained” episode “Is Katseye ok?” examines why the global girl group Katseye (formed by HYBE and Geffen via Netflix’s Popstar Academy) is struggling despite early hype and major appearances.

Guest backgrounds

Sean Ramos (host) and Brittany Spanos, a pop music journalist.

Key claims

Katseye’s rise is undermined by member hiatuses and injuries, plus industry pressure on young performers. The episode links the turmoil to work-to-the-bone schedules, mental-health strain, and racialized scrutiny (notably around member Mano).

Notable examples

Mano Bannerman goes on hiatus after being criticized for not “pulling her weight,” fueling conspiracy theories; Sophia (group leader) also goes on hiatus; Megan Scandiel suffers a sprained ankle and later a concussion, leading to canceled dates and her performing seated with protective sunglasses. They still perform at the Grammys and Coachella, release “Pinky Up,” and later the EP “Wild,” but face setbacks like pulling out of Olivia Rodrigo’s festival.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:04

Introducing Brittany Spanos

Host Sean Ramos introduces pop music journalist Brittany Spanos.

“They could describe everything with one single word.”
2:14

The Formation of Cat's Eye

Discussion about how Cat's Eye was formed as a global girl group.

“Brittany, tell us the origin story of Cat's Eye, because I think it's kind of singular, right?”
3:18

Popstar Academy and the Audition Process

Exploration of the Popstar Academy competition and its impact on Cat's Eye.

“And they held these global auditions to create a girl group where the members came from all over the world.”
4:36

Behind the Scenes of Cat's Eye

Insights into the dynamics and challenges faced by the members of Cat's Eye.

“I just finished watching the Popstar Academy documentary series on Netflix and oh my gosh.”
5:40

Fan Engagement and Social Media

Discussion on how Cat's Eye engages with fans via social media platforms.

“you know, kind of showing how these girls had these inner feuds.”
7:20

Introducing the Members of Cat's Eye

Details about the diverse backgrounds of Cat's Eye members.

“through how you interact with them online.”
8:04

Cat's Eye's Musical Style

Overview of the musical influences and styles of Cat's Eye's debut EP.

“I would say it kind of leans more American.”
8:57

Reception of Cat's Eye's Music

Analyzing the reception and unique elements of Cat's Eye's music.

“But it starts to get a little bit weirder with Beautiful Chaos and songs like Gnarly.”
10:39

Grammy Awards and Cat's Eye's Breakthrough

Discussion on Cat's Eye's appearance at the Grammy Awards and its significance.

“But I was kind of like, what are these girls about?”
12:23

Anticipating Cat's Eye's Future

Speculation on Cat's Eye's plans for tours and album releases.

“But, you know, this was the beginning of what I think people anticipated to be a very celebratory and triumphant year for Cat's Eye.”
Show all 14 chapters
16:19

Cat's Eye's Challenges

Discussing the challenges faced by Cat's Eye, including member hiatuses.

“This is the part where things start to break down a little bit for Cat's Eye.”
18:28

Touring Issues and Setbacks

Exploring the impact of injuries and cancellations on Cat's Eye's tour.

“They end up doing it and they continue on as a five piece for the time being.”
21:00

Industry Pressure on Pop Groups

Examining the pressures pop groups face and the impact on their members.

“I'm sorry, but Megan sitting on stage for the Catside concert is one of the dumbest things I think I've ever seen.”
23:18

Future Prospects for Cat's Eye

Discussing the future of Cat's Eye and potential strategies for success.

“I mean, obviously, they're not the first pop stars to have personal issues or creative differences or to, you know, have their rise derailed.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Today, Explained, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00There's a lot going on in the world right now. The International Court of Justice just ruled for the first time ever that a country, Myanmar, in this case, committed genocide. The president's meeting with the leaders of Russia and China and Thropic just had the biggest IPO ever. But also, Cat's Eye is having a tough time, you guys. If you don't know Cat's Eye, ask your favorite young person about them. Icons might tell you about their origins on a Netflix reality show called Popstar Academy Cat's Eye. We want to be the biggest girl group in the world. They might show you some gnarly dance moves.

0:36They might tell you about a girl named Gabriela.

0:42But what's most likely to come up is that for a group that was supposed to take over the world, Cat's Eye has been kind of cursed. Just two years after their formation, they seem far more likely to fall apart than top the charts. We're going to tell you about their troubles on today's Explain from Vox. Support for the show today comes from the International Rescue Committee. Are you familiar with their work? You've seen the headlines, wars, floods, and other crises that are forcing millions of families to flee their homes. Many are living in makeshift shelters without enough food, water, or medicine, and you can help.

1:15The IRC is on the ground in over 40 countries delivering emergency aid where it's needed most for a limited time. all gifts will be matched to make an even bigger impact. You can give now at rescue.org slash rebuild. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow none of them talk to each other. That's where Odo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all-in-one powerful platform.

1:48No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at odoo.com slash vox. That's odoo.com slash vox.

2:06They could describe everything with one single word. Today Explained, Sean Ramos from here with Brittany Spanos, pop music journalist. Brittany, tell us the origin story of Cat's Eye, because I think it's kind of singular, right? Yeah, so Cat's Eye was sort of formed as this kind of unification moment between the K-pop music industry and the American music industry. Well, for those who don't know us, hey everyone, we're Cat's Eye. Yeah! They were meant to be a global girl group. How many languages do you guys speak all together? All together? English, Korean, Tagalog, Spanish. Like eight. And this comes after, you know, about a decade of K-pop becoming a pretty dominant musical genre in Western culture.

2:53You know, it's created some of the biggest acts we've had. Artists like Blackpink. And BTS most specifically.

3:03Really set the tone for how K-pop can become one of the most commercially profitable facets of the music industry. And with Cat's Eye, it was a partnership between HYBE, which is a K-pop label, and Geffen, which is an American label. And they held these global auditions to create a girl group where the members came from all over the world. We went through a competition to form us. It was called Popstar Academy. And there were missions, there was global voting, and in the end it was the six of us. So they kind of created this X-Factor-esque show of having all the girls kind of go through the audition process.

3:38I haven't been in a mission with any of these ladies yet. So this was my first time, like, practicing and being, like, in rehearsal with them. Confident is such a physically hard dance by itself. All of us at some point got injured, especially me with, like, my back. And that has led to the cat's eye that we know today. Guys, give it up for your new global girl group, Cat's Eye! These girls were voted on by fans through Weverse and through YouTube, and they were following them on social media already, and they had built these relationships with them through the audition process for this group and chose them.

4:17And it was, you know, kind of essentially both the popularity contest mixed with they actually did have incredible singing and dancing talent that led to the formulation of Cat's Eye. Had anything like this ever been tried before? a Korean outfit, partnering with an American outfit to create the next pop supergroup and doing it all on Netflix, right? I just finished watching the Popstar Academy documentary series on Netflix and oh my gosh. I don't think there's been a project that's been done like this before. Taking the K-pop method of developing and training, but doing it in pop music. Yeah.

4:55Yeah, so by the time the Netflix series had started, of course, the Dream Academy version of the competition had already selected the members of Cat's Eyes. So these members already existed and had formed the group. But when Popstar came out, it offered the behind the scenes that the fans hadn't yet seen. It's like you think you're doing enough, but you need to like, no, it's like you need to do even more. It takes time to build a mental strength to endure the industry that you're going to go into. you. And this is hard. It's hard to work in this industry. The Netflix series was the kind of real world kind of version of it, of getting that inner workings of the drama between these girls that was going on well before they were competing for millions of fans around the globe to vote for them.

5:39But also while it was happening, you know, kind of showing how these girls had these inner feuds. I really do feel like a lot of our frustration, it's just being present and like paying attention and doing your part, like taking notes in class. Yeah, but I have been taking notes when I was sitting out. You know, I know like you try to listen instead of react to what she's saying. Try to just sit and listen. Ilya, you will not be receiving an invitation. Y 'all wanted me out anyways. You voted me out. You voted me out. Also, a lot of different dynamics happening that happen when you're a teen girl who wants nothing more than to be in potentially the biggest girl group of your generation.

6:26It's interesting, right? Because what you're explaining here is that, like, this group has fans before it has music? Yeah, you know, that part is not totally new in terms of our reality TV culture that we've had for the last 25 years, right, through all these singing competitions. It's very One Direction in that way, which is One Direction, we're formed on X Factor. Hello. Nice to meet you. What's your name? I'm Harry Styles. Okay. They, you know, were only known through their covers, but they had a massive fandom that was voting them through each week that even when they didn't win X Factor, they still were able to get a major label deal and still had fans waiting for them to release new music.

7:09So there is already a little bit of this culture of personality-based love for an artist and a lot of that grows through social media and through a very like parasocial dynamic, through how you interact with them online. You know, these girls are using the chat site Weverse to talk with their fans. They're using their Instagrams. They're using TikTok. They have their individual profiles. And, you know, I think a lot of people are able to get to know them even more so and continue to get to know them through those platforms and build those relationships with them. Okay, so let's talk about the cast of characters here because I think it's going to become important.

7:43Who is in the group, Katzai? We have... Daniela Avanzini. Hey, guys. I'm Daniela. Lara Raj. Hi, I'm Lara. Mano Bannerman. Hi, I'm Mano. Megan Scandiel. Hi, I'm Megan. Sophia Laforteza. Hi, everyone. I'm Sophia. And Yuta Jung. Hi, I'm Yun-Chan. And all these girls come from all over. I would say it kind of leans more American. Yun-Chan is Korean. Sophia was born in the Philippines. And Mano was born in Switzerland. Okay, I think it's time we talk about the music. When does it start to come out and what do people think of it? So the girls released their first EP in 2024. It's when they made their debut.

8:26That's the year that Popstar came out. It was called Soft is Strong or Sis. And the music kind of started sort of mostly leaning a little bit more towards our traditional sense of what K-pop music is.

8:42Which is kind of a little bit of a mix of sort of hyper pop with kind of like R &B kind of hip hop elements and sort of, you know, definitely kind of leaning towards a little bit more of the bubble gum that we kind of associate with early music from K -pop artists.

9:02But it starts to get a little bit weirder with Beautiful Chaos and songs like Gnarly. which is that these songs are a little bit silly. I think that's the thing that became very notable with Cat's Eye. These songs almost felt a little jokey in how the lyrics went. You know, they were kind of just saying things like, God, is this real? You know, there's like a song called like Hootie Fruity. on their latest EP, Wild, and on the song Internet Girl, they're saying eat zucchini, eat zucchini, repeatedly. So there's something that's like a little like, it's almost a little childish. Are they in with Big Zucchini, you think?

9:51Maybe, maybe they are. It's one of their latest brand partnerships with Big Zucchini. But the music is a little more EDM than I think people anticipated. It's very high energy, very high octane pop music. There are, of course, songs that are a little bit more mellowed out, a little bit more mid-tempo.

10:14But these are songs made for girls who are professional dancers. These are songs made to have really ecstatic choreography and really tough choreography with them. I bet it goes like this. Pinky up. And so the songs are really, really high energy in a way that I don't think people anticipated from a new girl group. Pinky up. Up. Pinky up. I think my first real exposure to this group, Brittany, was at this year's Grammy Awards, which I feel like they maybe opened with a song that sounded like, I'm going to be honest, to me, like a little like Timu Charlie XCX.

11:02I'm sorry. Yeah, I think that's fair. I'm sorry to all the fans out there. But I was kind of like, what are these girls about? And certainly it felt like it was supposed to be K-pop, but it definitely wasn't. But I guess, is everyone okay with that? And were the Grammys like the big coming out party for Cat's Eye? You know, they'd made a pretty big splash in 2025. They had the viral Gap commercial that they did where they danced to Khalil's Milkshake. They were kind of already setting the tone for a bit of global domination in that way. But, you know, this was a pretty big celebratory moment for them of being nominated for Best New Artist and being part of that medley.

11:46But, you know, I think that was sort of a moment of, OK, this could be truly the next Blackpink in this way. They could potentially become as big of a girl group as that.

12:00and of course following the grammys they were due to perform at coachella which of course we've seen coachella create really huge stars through the live stream and through also you know the fans who are at the festival but this was meant to be sort of a a big year for them of playing coachella playing other festivals going on tour ideally releasing um you know a full-length album but But, you know, this was the beginning of what I think people anticipated to be a very celebratory and triumphant year for Cat's Eye.

12:36We're heading to the desert where Cat's Eye's problems seem to start when Today Explained returns.

13:07Support for this show comes from Anthropic, the team behind Claude. Most good ideas start half-baked, a hunch, a rough sketch, a question you can't quite put into words. You don't need to know where to start. You can just bring Claude what you have, and it works to help you shape it, question it, and find that first step. You can try it at claude.ai slash todayexplained. That's Anthropic, the team behind Claude. You've heard of Claude, right? From Anthropic.

13:39Support for the show comes from ShipStation. We're all familiar with how hectic online shopping can get around Black Friday and Cyber Monday. If you're the one selling, it might even be more overwhelming That's why ShipStation is built to help you tackle peak season. ShipStation is an end-to-end order fulfillment platform built to handle the surge of peak season and bring all of your orders into one place. That way, your team won't be scrambling when volume spikes. Every part of the order process can get easier. For example, ShipStation can help you modernize your freight workflows. They offer comparisons between carriers and end-to-end visibility on all your shipments.

14:16when every order matters during Black Friday or whenever your busiest time of year is. ShipStation can help you save up to 90 % off through automated rate shopping so you're not overpaying when volume is highest. More than 1 million businesses have relied on ShipStation during their busiest periods because peak season doesn't wait and neither should you. You can get ahead of it today with ShipStation and get 60 days free at ShipStation.com with code TODAY. That's ShipStation.com, code TODAY. Taxes and fees apply.

14:48Support for the show comes from Framer, but don't expect your photo to come back in a nice gilded frame. This is the future of website building, folks. It's seamlessly blending all the tools we have available rather than siloing them. And you could use a platform that has it all and stays useful even after you launch. That's what Framer is. Framer is the AI website builder that helps creators, teams, and businesses ship production-ready sites faster than ever while getting every detail right. You're able to prompt, inspect, edit, and publish in one place at a whole new pace. On Framer, agents and humans work in tandem, and isn't that what it's all about?

15:31It all takes place in the same workspace where the real site is designed, managed, reviewed, and published. Learn how you can get more out of your site from a Framer specialist or get started building for free today at framer.com slash explained for 30 % off a Framer Pro annual plan. That's framer.com slash explained. Rules and restrictions may apply.

16:03Today explained. Brittany, Cat's Eye performs at the Grammys. They're part of this huge new artist medley. It's fun. It's a lot of attention. It's a lot of eyes on the group. Next big event for them is meant to be Coachella, I believe. Does everything look good leading up to that huge moment for them? This is the part where things start to break down a little bit for Cat's Eye. And I think also reels a much larger audience than a much larger audience that they had hoped to reel in, but maybe not for these reasons, into kind of caring about and paying attention to them, which is that the member, Minot Bannerman, who hailed from Switzerland, had been sort of an influencer prior, ended up going on hiatus from the group.

16:45Manol has been on hiatus, and we love her so much. We're really just rooting for all of us, like each other. She wrote to fans subscribe to her Weverse DMs on February 20th. I'm healthy, I'm okay, and I'm taking care of myself. Thank you for checking in. And that was, of course, a pretty big blow for this six-piece group where all the fans have these very deep relationships with each of them to lose one of their members. Do we know what happened to Mano? This is the part where everything gets a little bit tricky with Cat's Eye. It's been officially six months since Mano's hiatus. So what happens next?

17:21She's repeatedly posted on socials that she's healthy, leading to conspiracy theories about what's really going on. There is not really a lot of answers about the hiatus or why she's on it, whose idea it was, and also if she'll ever come back, Which has led to a lot of speculation about really major drama behind the scenes. And I think with someone like Mano, there was already a lot of drama lurking beneath the surface with her and the other girls auditioning for Cat's Eye. There's people that are so clearly passionate about this, but then there's some people like Mano. There was, you know, allegations and complaints from other girls who felt like she wasn't pulling her weight.

18:03She doesn't show up to rehearsals. She breaks the rules and she doesn't get penalized for it. She took a lot of days off. It's nice to see you, my dog. It's been a minute. Let's go. So, you know, there was already a bit of that lore kind of hovering over Cat's Eye as they had formed and clearly reached a bit of a breaking point in ways that we still don't really know or understand. Rough. Do they pull out of Coachella because they last a member or do they just go through with it? They do not pull out Coachella. They end up doing it and they continue on as a five piece for the time being.

18:41So where do we go from Coachella? So you play the Grammys, you play Coachella. Then what? You're supposed to become like the biggest girl group in the world? Yeah, they end up going on as planned. They release their single Pinky Up. And that video does not feature Minot. Still no answers on what's happening with her. But they continue to do their promotional duties and they end up launching an EP called Wild. But in early August, the member Sophia, who in a lot of K-pop groups, there's a designated leader, which, you know, I would say Cat's Eye sort of straddles the line of K-pop structure with kind of more Western pop group ethos.

19:23But Sophia was the designated group leader, and she ended up also going on hiatus from the group, leaving them with only four members. Sophia was MIA from the group's big movie premiere three days before she confirmed she needed a step back because health comes first. She knew her body was not capable of doing what is needed. She just needed to rest her body and rest her mind. And I believe the new date for her return is early next year. So this group of six is down to four before they even put out their first album. Yes. That is tough. And, you know, even before they do their headlining tour, which ends up kicking off as scheduled in September, but they were meant to play Olivia Rodrigo's Daisy Chain Fields Festival.

20:09And the day before, the member Megan sprains her ankle in tour rehearsals and therefore Cat's Eye pulls out of Daisy Chain Fields, which would have been a pretty big moment for them as well. Can't catch a break. Soon after that, end up going with the tour as planned, and Megan is at the tour at the beginning. But just a couple weeks ago, she had a concussion that led to some canceled tour dates. While ballots were being counted last night, little girls' cries were ringing out throughout LCA, all because the popular girl band postponed their sold-out show. Crying little girls because Cats had canceled on us last minute.

20:46They got our hopes up. They were at the VIP. They were at the soundcheck. But they returned to the stage last week. Megan performed in a chair with protective sunglasses on. I believe that there should be some concussion protocols. The girl sat there. She sang her lines wearing sunglasses. I'm sorry, but Megan sitting on stage for the Catside concert is one of the dumbest things I think I've ever seen. Megan's in a coma. Okay, but can't she sing and dance? Like, not? No. Well, what did the doctor say? I think Megan needs sleep and recovery. Sure! This is what caught our attention here at Today Explained, Brittany.

21:19because you don't see this every day. You really don't. It really screams like we need an intervention here for this girl group. And we should remind people just even to date, this is a group that has not put out an album, which is typically how you like engage fans. They do have three EPs. Three EPs.

21:44Are people losing the plot here with this group that has just this, host of issues and no album? It seems like a very complicated issue, which I can understand with any type of pop group, which is that, especially pop groups today, which is there's the relationship you have with the group itself, and there's a relationship you have with the individual members of the group as well. In K-pop, they call it biases, where you have one member in particular that you love the most. So, you know, I think with each of them, it's been levels of concern and alarm. And I think, you know, when it when Manoa went on hiatus, you know, she's the only black member of the group and kind of was being called lazy the entire time she was in Dream Academy.

22:28And so, you know, there's a lot of the racial elements of the girls who of young black girls watching this happen and watching this girl be told that she's not doing enough as the other counterparts in the group. And now all of a sudden being on a mystery hiatus that no one has explained, I think there's a relationship to that that feels really heavy and layered to it. I think Sophia being the most kind of enthusiastic and being this group leader not feeling well enough in her mental health to stay in the group rings a lot of alarm bells and I think caused a lot of concern. And of course, now with Megan, it's like these like back to back physical injuries are ringing even more alarm bells where the fans are very much just like we would rather Cat's Eye not go on stage than have someone risk their health to perform for us.

23:17What does this group's troubles tell us about the industry? I mean, obviously, they're not the first pop stars to have personal issues or creative differences or to, you know, have their rise derailed. I mean, obviously, Britney Spears still seems to be going through something from all of whatever she went through initially. Yeah. But this is a group, as we've now established several times over, that still hasn't even had their huge definitive moment or era. I mean, I think the trouble has always been with young pop groups in any industry have been sort of work to the bone in like any kind of level of we need to because of the expiration date, we need to get as much out of them as possible before this whole thing implodes.

24:05So, you know, this is something that the members of One Direction spoke about a lot, which is that their schedule was they were on tour for nine, ten months of the year. Then they were recording an album or then immediately promoting an album. They had like one month to go back home and then they were gone again. Yeah. And I guess I was bringing up Britney Spears, but like a member of One Direction is, of course, now dead. Yes. And Liam was the one who who spoke most kind of directly about a lot of that. He was the one who was very open about how taxing that was on his mental and physical health because they were so young.

24:41And it does seem to be that there is this desire to capitalize on this moment and keep pushing it forward because they're almost like they're like just at the precipice of being extremely huge. They haven't had like the big, big hit yet. They haven't obviously released the album, but an arena headline tour is not nothing. You know, a slot at Coachella is not nothing. A Grammy Best New Artist nomination is not nothing. Do you think it's too late or do you still think they have like pop domination somewhere ahead of them? I don't know. I mean, I think there's still a lot of fan desire to see the original six altogether, which is, again, a really big handicap for a new pop group, right?

25:23Like you already don't have your original band that people already wanted to buy tickets to see and watch perform and buy albums from. So that's going to be a big hurdle for them to overcome in the coming years. I don't really know. I think a lot of people are wondering how much longer the other members have in them. They seem to be otherwise pretty firmly in this, but it doesn't really look good unless there are some changes potentially made in how they strategize, how to promote and keep Cat's Eye going. And if that means kind of reconfiguring how they do everything and how they promote them and maybe finding something new that's not just the usual tour tour EP tour tour album type of structure, then potentially they can.

26:15Potentially they can have a huge moment of coming back. That's really triumphant and can make that debut album worth it and can make their next tour even bigger.

26:34Listen to Cat's Eye wherever you listen. Read Britney on her Substack Britpop. It's at britneyspanos.substack.com. Robert Pattinson produced, Robert Pattinson edited, Robert Pattinson fact-checked, Robert Pattinson mixed, and Robert Pattinson hosted for today's Explained. Heidi Mwagdi, Jolie Myers, Gabriel Donatov, David Tadishore, and Sean Ramos from Helped.

27:01Thank you.

27:30we've built a new kind of AI-powered HR platform, one that unifies all of your workforce data in one place and provides insights you can act on, so your people are at their best and your business is too. Learn more at BambooHR.com. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales, and somehow none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in, an all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together. From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform.

28:05No messy integrations, no bouncing between tabs, and best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at odoo.com slash vox. That's odoo.com slash vox.

From the publisher

The girl group is one of the biggest pop music acts in the world. But two members are on hiatus, another is performing through a concussion, and fans are wondering if it’s all worth it.

This episode was produced by Hady Mawajdeh, edited by Jolie Myers, fact-checked by Gabriel Dunatov, engineered by David Tatasciore, and hosted by Sean Rameswaram.

Lara Raj, Megan Skiendiel, Daniela Avanzini and Yoonchae Jeong from KATSEYE perform on NBC's "Today" at Rockefeller Plaza on Aug. 14, 2026 in New York City. Photo by Patricia Schlein/Star Max/GC Images via Getty Images.

Listen to Today, Explained ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: vox.com/members. New Vox members get $20 off their membership right now. Transcript at vox.com/today-explained-podcast.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Today, Explained

All episodes