Sleepaway camp's nostalgia economy

0:11I'm John Glenn Hill. This is Explain It To Me. and today on the show, we're going to camp. Summer's sleepaway camp to be specific. Nerves are normal, whether it is your first summer with us or if you've been to overnight camps before. I'm so fortunate to go to sleepaway summer camp for two weeks. Bye guys.

0:33I always imagined that sleepaway camp would be adventurous and life-changing, kind of like in The Parent Trap. These long-lost twins meet each other for the first time at camp and decide they've got one shot to reunite their broken family. I wish I may. I wish I might. I wish come true tonight.

0:59Despite the fact that I never went to sleepaway camp, I'm very familiar with the concept. So how did camp get to be such a big deal anyway? I called up Leslie Paris to tell us. She teaches at the University of British Columbia and wrote a book called Children's Nature, The Rise of the American Summer Camp. It's never been the case that the majority of American children went to summer camps. But summer camps came to assume a really important place in American popular culture. They started in the late 19th century. The industry grew phenomenally in the early 20th century, and it continues today in many respects quite similarly to the way it was 130 years ago.

1:52Okay. Were there particular groups that developed this American summer camp as we know it, or lots of different types of camps? Like, how did we get camp? The first camps were founded by urban middle-class men who were concerned about boys. They were concerned about white boys who they saw as not getting enough outdoor adventure and the kind of manly experiences they would need to be in the minds of these adults, the nation's leaders for the next generation. They were worried about the effects of urbanization, and they were nostalgic for an earlier day when more boys had grown up in rural places.

2:46So this really began in the late 19th century, mostly in the 1880s onward. Very small groups of boys, but quickly the YMCA movement became involved in it. And by the turn of the century, the movement started really ramping up. And ramping up not only because more YMCA camps were founded, but because more different organizations got involved and more groups of American adults thought this camp idea would be great for my kids too. You've got small numbers of women leading groups of girls out into the wilderness and saying, this would be great for girls as well. They also need outdoor adventures.

3:43In the early 20th century, you've got a whole bunch of new movements, the Boy Scouts, the Girl Scouts, the Campfire Girls, and they all quickly start sending children out into the wilderness as well.

3:58Okay, so you write in your book that, quote, this triple nostalgia for the American past, for camp community, and for individual childhood experience is critical to understanding why camps have figured so influentially in American culture and in former campers' lives. I'd love for you to talk about that a little bit more. How so? Camps were a place where children learned nostalgia. And when they had a chance, many of those former children sent their own kids to camp. So this became a kind of a nostalgic cultural practice that for many adults reminded them of often the first time that they had an adventure away from their parents, away from their families.

4:48It's interesting. We asked our listeners to call in with their camp stories, and so many people met their partners at summer camp. Hi, my name is Nina Vallotto. Summer camp was the best thing that ever happened to me. I met my husband and some lifelong friends, and I'm not the only one that that happened to. My sister-in-law and brother-in-law also met at camp. Hi, my name is Tiffany Andrew. I grew up going to summer camp ever since I was seven and then all throughout college. Every summer I then worked at that summer camp and that is where I met my husband and we then got married at that same summer camp.

5:39Are these listeners, you know, special? Are they the lucky ones or historically have people made connections that last, you know, a lifetime at camp? Well, I'd say they're lucky, but they're not exceptional. Since the late 40s, early 50s, a lot more camps have been co-ed. Prior to that, there were camps that had a boys camp and a girls camp at the same lake, sometimes owned by the same people, with some degree of socializing. Camp is so specific. How did you choose this as an academic subject? I knew that I wanted to work on American childhood. So one of the things that I look at in my book is how camps illuminate the ways in which childhood was transformed.

6:30I imagine that changes at summer camp also reflect changes in American childhood overall. I'd love to hear in broad strokes about some of those changes. How have we seen camp and therefore childhood change over time? One of the main changes that I look at is the rise of the idea of protected childhood, that childhood should be a time apart, that children should be protected from the adult world. Some of the working class kids at the turn of the 20th century who attended summer camps had never been on a vacation outside of the city. They went on vacations before their parents went on vacations.

7:20I feel like nowadays we keep hearing about how important it is for kids to get away from their screens. Camp is probably one of the ways to do that, right? Yes, but some of the same kinds of concerns that adults at summer camps have had were expressed in different ways a century ago, but there were concerns even then that modern culture was hard on kids and that they needed some kind of break. They were very concerned about kids reading comic books in their bunk or showing up with silk stockings. Oh, the scandal of it all. Many camps have become quite exclusive and expensive and tough to pull off for parents and kids' cluttered schedules.

8:18Have camps always been big business? Originally, camps were not big business. There were a limited number of camps. elite private camps. And increasingly, there were organizational camps, charitable camps. Those camps were not hoping to pull in a large profit. Leslie, I'm curious if you have any favorite depictions of sleepaway camp in pop culture. Like, what's your go-to moment? I always think of the Simpsons episode, Camp Krusty. Bart and Lisa are sent to a camp that ostensibly is run by the local clown, Crusty the Clown, but actually really isn't. It's been franchised, and the kids have a horrible time, the counselors are cruel, and finally Crusty appears and makes amends when he realizes what's going on.

9:19Well, I'm going to make it all up to you. I'm going to show you kids the time of your life. But camps appear in a lot of modern American popular culture because I think this really gets back to this place of camps as spaces of adventure and opportunity for children and for young adults. because some of these movies are really focused on the counselors and the staff, that these are spaces where young adults and kids can have adventures that they wouldn't have had at home. All right. Leslie Paris, thank you so much. Thank you. Coming up on Explain It To Me, Sleepaway Camp is a big deal on the big screen.

10:14Stay with us.

10:45that support more spontaneous moments. Sounds fun. HIMSS says they offer access to ED treatment options, including trusted generics that cost 95 % less than brand names have prescribed. And since HIMSS is 100 % online, you can get the care you need from the comfort of your own home. No sitting around under fluorescent lights, reading a week's old magazine while you wait for an appointment. Remember magazines? You can get simple online access to personalized, affordable care for ED, hair loss, weight loss, and more by visiting HIMSS.com slash explain. That's HIMSS.com slash explain for your free online visit.

11:16HIMSS.com slash explain. Actual price will depend on product and subscription plan. Featured products include compounded drug products, which the FDA does not approve or verify for safety, effectiveness, or quality. Prescription required. See website for details, restrictions, and important safety information.

11:36Support for the show comes from BoxyCat. There's a lot to love about having a cat in your home. But there's one thing that even the most ardent cat lover could do without. Stinky litter boxes. Boxy says that they can help. Boxy wants to be the last kitty litter you ever try. They say the difference is in their formula, which includes probiotics that can stop bacteria that cause odors. Plus, Boxy says their clumping power is superior, making it easier to scoop, so your litter box can be less stinky without any of the fake fragrances. Here's our colleague, Andrew Melnizik, to tell us more. So my sister is that cat mom.

12:13She calls them her children. So when it comes to trying anything new for them, she's incredibly skeptic and always a little hesitant. That's why I was so excited to hear that she was really enjoying Boxy's cat litter. The first thing she noticed, there was just zero issues transitioning to cats. There was no drama from them, which, you know, cats can kind of push back and be a little bit drama. It was really a miracle. If you're tired of switching litters, looking for the one? Get Boxy at B-O-X-I-E-C-A-T dot com. It's the last letter you'll switch to. Enjoy 30 % off with code EXPLAINED at BoxyCat.com slash EXPLAINED.

12:53That's B-O-X-I-E-C-A-T dot com forward slash EXPLAINED.

13:06We're back with Explain It To Me and we're talking about Sleepaway Summer Camp Okay, so you're nervous, but you're excited You've packed your bags, you're ready to write your mom and dad But let's say you also packed some popcorn That's because we're talking about the classic genre of summer camp movies and we're joined by our producer, Devin Schwartz. Hey, Devin. Hey, JQ. So we already heard from Leslie Parris, who literally wrote the book on summer camp about the Simpsons Camp Krusty. But as we were working on this episode, our colleagues at Vox decided to share their summer camp movie classics with me.

13:46So I wanted to share a few of those with you and with our listeners. Okay, let's go to camp. Time to fire up that VHS. So first up is another one about a camp that's a bit of a mess. Wet Hot, American Summer. This 2001 cult classic is a favorite of Art Chung, who works with Fox's podcasts. What's so great about that movie was that it was both a parody of and a loving homage to both summer camp and the summer camp movie genre. It's also got an incredible cast of Janine Garofalo, Paul Rudd, Amy Poehler, Elizabeth Banks, and it was Bradley Cooper's first movie. Andy, have you seen my swimming buddy?

14:27I was busy. It's your job to make sure kids don't drown. Wet Hot American Summer. Okay, that is a throwback. So, Devin, did you go away to sleepaway camp when you were a kid? Well, JQ, like lots of the cast in Wet Hot American Summer, I am Jewish. Probably not a surprise for my last name, Schwartz. And so many of the camps felt a little too Christian-y for me. Okay, well, I used to go to this week-long thing for church called Sunday School Convention, and it was held at a 4-H facility, but my parents were the chaperones, so I was not getting too wild there. But unlike David Wayne, who directed the movie, I didn't go to Jewish camp either.

15:10But after college, I did work at a camp in rural Vermont, teaching playwriting and coaching soccer. It was the exact type of camp I probably would have loved as a kid. And on our last night together, the whole staff partied in a bit of a Bacchanal, and we watched Wet Hot American Summer. Okay, that is very cool. Wasn't there a movie about theater camp not too long ago? Yeah, that's right. So this is a 2023 mockumentary that Maeve Dunnegan from The Dodo, a Vox sister site, absolutely loves. As someone who went to theater camp every summer as a kid and treated our production of Seussical as if it were Shakespeare, I could really relate to the cartoonish levels of sincerity with which the characters in this movie approached children's theater.

15:54I'm not going to sugarcoat it. Emotionally, physically, and spiritually, this is our most complicated piece we've ever tried to do. You guys are so talented, so unbelievable. This will break you. This will fully destroy you. Congratulations on being the most talented kids I can.

16:10You practically feel like you're there, highlighting your lines and twitching your jazz hands right alongside them. Oh my God, jazz hands. That takes me back to show choir. And a good box step. Absolutely. And what's so fun is the stars of theater camp actually went to theater camp together back in the day. I imagine a lot of filmmakers went to some kind of theater or performing arts camp, so it kind of falls in line with the stories they'd want to tell. Exactly. Write what you know and all of that. And I'm not sure if that's the case with the 2003 film Camp, but it's also set at a performing arts camp.

16:45Box's culture writer Constance Grady brought this one up not because it's great cinema per se, but because of a shy, awkward camper played by a very young Anna Kendrick who finally breaks out of her shell at the end of the movie. That's when she sings... Ladies Who Lunch from Sondheim's company and she absolutely blows the rest of the movie out of the water. Let's hear it for the ladies who lunch Everybody rise, rise The story goes that sometimes I saw her do it and he went, she has great teeth. Okay, listen, there are weirder compliments that you could get. But I can really picture that moment of, you know, blossoming, of growing up and showing out.

17:33And that seems like a hallmark of these camp movies. So Leslie Paris told us earlier about how nostalgia and Sleepaway Camp, they're such big things. Did anyone bring that up with you? Big time. A lot of people brought up the nostalgia piece. So Carrie Keeter works with Vox's brand partnerships team, and she recommends the 1993 film Indian Summer. Oh, I want to be a kid again. Indian Summer. It has feelings of nostalgia. It's heartfelt. It brings together friends that have known each other from childhood through adulthood. And that is truly the meaning of camp. Oh, I think we got a future camp director in our midst.

18:19Yes, very much could be. But of course, not everything is seen with rose-colored lenses because, you know, JQ, camp isn't always safe. Not safe? What do you mean by that? Well, you see, nostalgia for Sleepaway Camp, it has a scarier side to it. Horror films set at camp. Ooh, spooky. Okay. Yes. See, it's a whole cottage industry at this point. You're out there in the woods, isolated. You don't know if those sounds at night are animals or something far more dangerous. Peter Balanon-Rosen is my fellow producer on Today Explained and explained it to me. Well, he shouted out the Friday the 13th movies, which center around Camp Crystal Lake.

19:11We've got horny teenagers getting killed. We've got the story of the lengths family will go for each other. And across this summer camp setting, we've got great jump scares. This is a movie that could only happen at summer camp. Ooh, no thank you. I do not want to get slashed at camp. I know. I'm not big on slasher films myself, but this one seems to have staying power in the culture. The first one came out in 1980, and the 12 or so films are all based on the mythology of a camper-turned-villain named Jason Voorhees. He drowned in the lake after his fellow campers threw him in. They were kind of bullying him.

19:48The counselors, they weren't paying attention because they were off having sex. Oh, and we all know that sex is the number one no-no in horror films, right? Yeah, that's a common trope. If you find love or at least lust, you're next on the list. Okay, the summer camp watch list is getting pretty long, and I admit that I am almost out of popcorn. Let's do one more. Okay, sure thing. Let's hear about Goosebumps from Anna North. She writes the Kids Today newsletter for Vox. Growing up, my brother and I loved the Goosebumps books by R.L. Stine and the TV show, and a big favorite of ours was called Welcome to Camp Nightmare, in which a whole bunch of really scary stuff happens at a sleepaway camp.

20:29Why is it just us? Why doesn't anybody else think anything happened? I gotta find a phone, call my parents, tell them to come pick me up and get me out of this hole. I don't know that I would sign up for that camp. What kind of scary stuff happens in that one? Sorry, JQ, no spoilers on this one. You're gonna have to get some more popcorn and add it to your camp watch list. Uh, okay, fine. But as it turns out, Anna herself isn't the biggest fan of sleepaway camp. You definitely do not need to send your kids to sleepaway camp. If you don't go to sleepaway camp, you will be fine as a person. Okay, I definitely want to hear more about that.

21:09And luckily for us, after the break, more from Anna on summer alternatives to sleepaway camp. Stay with us.

21:31Before the break, we heard from my colleague Anna North. She's a senior correspondent at Vox, and she covers family life. She has children of her own, so she needs to think about how kids spend their summer. And I wanted her theory about why camp looms so large in our collective imagination. It's this place where there are no parents, which is really fun and exciting for kids to think about and also scary for kids to think about. And those are just really important ingredients of a good story. Oh, that's so interesting. So how old are your little ones? Yeah, my kids are seven and two and a half, so they're definitely too young for sleepaway camp.

22:09What do their summers usually look like? So my little one still goes to daycare, and daycare is actually open most of the summer. So he will continue doing what he does. And my big kid is in school. So he is doing a combo of Lego camp and then also craft camp. And we'll travel a little bit in there too. Okay, is sleepaway camp worth it? You know, not every kid does sleepaway camp. It can be expensive. It's really not for younger kids. You know, a kid has to be a certain level of maturity to be able to handle it. when you talk about camp generally for the summer though just practically speaking a lot of families need camp because school is out and parents are still working this is like this huge conundrum that families face because like kids are not in school 365 days a year but american parents like what we get you know two weeks vacation it's not very much so it's a real mismatch i think one of the issues we've heard about is this intense planning that goes into kids summers these days.

23:12Like it's complicated, it's competitive, it's expensive. Can you talk about that pressure a little bit? That seems like a lot. Yeah, absolutely. So it's a huge source of pressure for families. Kids typically are off for a couple months every summer. People start signing up for summer camps in January. And that sounds like it's, you know, these type A parents, you know, being really extra. But actually, you know, a lot of camps will fill up really early. And that includes camps that might be more affordable. So, you know, you might actually have to scramble to get your kid into a camp that, you know, one might be a good fit and two is not going to like break your budget.

23:52And, you know, it's obviously about making sure that kids have a fun summer, but it's also just making sure that they're taken care of and that they're having an okay time while the parents are doing what they need to do. Okay, so summer sleepaway camp is not an option for everyone. Some people don't want to do it. What are other ways for kids to spend their summer that you would recommend? Yeah, I mean, I would say probably most kids do a day camp at some point. Certainly, like, you know, here in New York, especially among kids like my kids age, that's the most common option. A lot of them are expensive, but there are more affordable options.

24:30The YMCA camps tend to be more affordable than some of the others. Some camps have sliding scales. So, you know, depending on income, you might be able to pay less. It's also worth checking out a lot of school districts have summer schools and or summer schools that are like a little bit more fun and a little bit more camp like I know New York City has a program called Summer Rising that a lot of kids are doing. So these are all options to like there's definitely stuff out there at a variety of price points. It's just a matter of the parents having to kind of do like work, unfortunately, of looking it all up.

25:01What do you make of like, letting the summer be kind of chill? Like I think of it and, you know, my parents, they would do like, okay, here's a nature day camp or like, you know, we'll bounce you around some different vacation Bible schools like in the evening. But a lot of my summer was spent kind of like lounging, eating ice cream, watching VH1 and reading like chapter books. I wonder like, do kids like, is it okay for kids to get that unstructured time? because I know kids thrive on routine. Yeah, so I have a lot of feelings about this. So every summer, I feel like there will be an op-ed or a big viral essay about how you should let your kids be bored during the summer.

25:45Recently, the New York Times actually had a story about families that are choosing not to send their kids to camp and just kind of letting them hang around the house. I think there's a couple things to think about there. One is the parents' work schedule. If you have a lot of flexibility and you can say, okay, I'm going to work from home for the whole summer or we're going to take off a bunch of time and I'm going to travel with my kids, that's great and that really changes the flexibility of your summer. If all the adults in your family are working full-time jobs in the summer, it just becomes a lot harder, especially at younger ages.

26:22Is there anything going on policy-wise to help kids with summer? I mean, unfortunately, things are a little bit going in the opposite direction. I guess I will say that, you know, individual cities, I think, have been moving to try to offer more both after school and like school break camp options. So I think Los Angeles has like been looking at this. But at the federal level, President Trump has actually proposed to zero out federal funding for after school and summer learning. That's something that a lot of folks that are involved in after school and school break learning are really concerned about because there is federal money that goes to support some of these programs.