


The episode argues that the GOP midterms strategy is to “ignore Trump” because he’s unpopular nationally and Republicans are avoiding debates and press events. It cites MSNBC reporting (Michael Schnell) that GOP candidates skip debates, press conferences, and town halls, and it frames this as an “ostrich strategy.” It also claims Republican voters are increasingly mixed about Trump due to high gas prices and an Iran war that hasn’t ended as promised, while some still rate his term highly locally. Notable examples include interviews with Parma, Ohio Republicans (Sue, Dave Carlson, John Renacello/Buddy, and others) and a town hall with Vivek Ramaswamy, who avoids Trump in his speech, focuses on Ohio issues like public education and data centers, and pitches using abandoned industrial sites for AI/data centers.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore the current chaos within the Republican Party and its struggles with Trump.
“Donald Trump's Republican Party is currently in chaos.”
Hear direct feedback from Ohio Republicans about their views on Trump and the upcoming elections.
“it was pretty clear that the people at this event were overwhelmingly diehard Republicans, the type of people who usually never have a bad word to say about Donald Trump.”
Examine Vivek Ramaswamy's approach to campaigning in the shadow of Trump.
“After talking to a bunch of Republican voters, I was even more interested to hear Ramaswamy's town hall.”
Discussing Ramaswamy's speech and focus on local issues in Ohio.
“On one hand, I get that his focus is local.”
The audience's concerns about education and Ramaswamy's responses.
“The biggest difference was his focus on public education, an issue that we don't hear that often from congressional midterms candidates.”
Audience skepticism regarding data centers as a solution for industrial sites.
“Can we put them on airport property where there's already turbines making lots of noise?”
Voter sentiments about distancing from Trump and their political strategy.
“I think personally, I haven't seen the value of data centers for our society.”
Discussion of Ramaswamy's polling numbers against the Democrat candidate.
“But to this point, there's little evidence that it has.”
Discussion of Ramaswamy's polling numbers against the Democrat candidate.
“There is a scientifically documented correlation between listening to podcasts and curiosity.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Today, Explained, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Astead Herndon: Donald Trump's Republican Party is currently in chaos. The president is massively unpopular. Prices are up everywhere. And few people support the Iran war. In fact, in the last couple weeks, it seems even Republican candidates are getting the message. Republican revolt with just 47 days until the midterms. They have to find some way to get away from this president. Democrats are actually the favorite now to take back the United States Senate. With a growing number of Republicans now distancing themselves from his actions. Here's the thing. It's hard to even find Republicans on the campaign trail right now.
0:36Astead Herndon: And it's even harder to get them to talk about Donald Trump. Republicans aren't answering our calls and texts. But more importantly, they're also not answering their own voters. New reporting by MS Now's Michael Schnell finds that when the going gets tough, the tough hide behind a telephone. They're skipping out on debates, not holding press conferences, avoiding town halls. And there are other avenues to do it than just going in to try to give the other side soundbites. I mean, they're doing this for the cameras. We all know it. It's honestly crazy. But there's at least one Republican right now who seems to be trying a different strategy.
1:16There will be a bright red Ramaswamy tsunami. Ladies and gentlemen, bring up the next governor of the state of Ohio, Vivek Ramaswamy.
1:26Astead Herndon: Vivek Ramaswamy, the former businessman and presidential candidate who was most recently associated with Trump's efforts to gut the bureaucracy, is running for governor in Ohio. I love the energy in this room. If you take this out and 44 days from today, we're going to win this thing in a decisive victory. Who's ready for that? And if there's one thing Ramaswamy is best known for, it's probably his willingness to talk about anything and everything. Let's get this done. All summer long, Ramaswamy has kept up an unusually ambitious calendar full of fairs, rallies and town halls. So a few weeks ago, we went to see one of the few Republicans who's actually stumping for votes.
2:09Astead Herndon: This week on America Actually, we're in Ohio. What is the GOP message for the midterms? And how are Republicans dealing with the elephant in the room? Trump 2.0 has flopped.
2:30Support for the show comes from TikTok. There is a scientifically documented correlation between listening to podcasts and curiosity. So since you're here, you probably enjoy discovering new things. One great place to indulge your curiosity is TikTok. Whether it's how to forecast volcanic eruptions, strange phenomena that the James Webb Space Telescope picked up near the beginning of time, or a literal deep dive on the ocean's deepest reefs, TikTok has a wealth of fascinating videos just waiting to be discovered. Your next discovery is waiting on TikTok. Learn more at tiktok.com slash discover more.
3:44Astead Herndon: When we got to Parma, a suburb just outside of Cleveland, it was pretty clear that the people at this event were overwhelmingly diehard Republicans, the type of people who usually never have a bad word to say about Donald Trump. So I wanted to know, is this still true, considering all of this? Can you tell me your name? Sue. Sue. Dave Carlson. Dave Carlson. Are y 'all Cleveland, Parma? Yeah. Lifelong, we live in Euclid. Have y 'all always been Republicans? I have. Yeah. One of the questions we're asking people is, what do they think the Republican message should be for the midterms? What should Republican candidates be saying to motivate people right now?
4:27Astead Herndon: I like low taxes and more jobs. Low taxes, more jobs. What do you say? I would say the same. Partly what we were talking to people about is how they're feeling about the second Trump administration. We asked somebody earlier, what would you rate Trump's second term from one to ten? Ten. Ten? Nine. Nine? Okay, that's pretty high. I mean, hey, we got a six earlier today because people were mentioning gas prices, things like the Iran war. I would love for you to say, like, those things don't seem to be bothering you all? I hate paying high gas prices, but the tradeoff for dealing with Iran, you know, there's seven presidents before Trump who swore that Iran is an enemy.
5:11We need to get rid of him. And nobody did anything until he did. It was bold.
5:20Astead Herndon: Thank you for hosting us in Parma today. Yes, glad you could make it. How enthusiastic would you say are Republicans for the upcoming votes? I think they're very enthusiastic. You see folks motivated. Yes, definitely, because it's all about lower taxes and our Second Amendment rights, and we're pro-life in Parma. And you might not know this, but Parma was the biggest city in Ohio that voted for President Trump. The biggest city in Ohio that voted for President Trump. That's a good fact to know. Three times. Three times. If you could rank the issues that you think matter most to you, what would they be?
5:58Well, the economy for sure. Lower taxes. Something, you know, that's affordable for people. But people are concerned about their Second Amendment rights, too.
6:07Astead Herndon: That's a big issue also. Big issue. Yes. Last question I have is like, we have seen a lot of at least numbers tell us and it's come up as we've traveled. It says Trump has gotten a little more unpopular over the last year. I would say, like, how would you explain that? And then how do you manage that leading into November? Well, he's human, OK? He makes mistakes, too, like we all do. But I think that he's got good people around him, people making decisions. J.D. Vance, we really support J.D. This is about what I expected, because there are some voters who are going to support this president no matter what.
6:49Astead Herndon: But as we talk to more and more people, we started to hear some more acknowledgement of what's been clear in the numbers. These days, even some Republicans are turning on Trump. I guess I keep asking around the same things, but I mean, he said prices were going to go down. He said the Iran war would be over by now. Like, those things haven't happened yet. Like, isn't that hurting Republicans more than anything else? Well, I think what you're listening to are the polls, and I don't believe in the polls. Got it. That's the problem. This whole country is addicted to these polls. So do you feel confident that come election day, Republicans will turn out?
7:28I'm not 100 % confident. Yeah. But if ever there was a midterm election cycle that things were going to change, it's going to be this one. Tell me your name. John Renacello. I hear the name is Buddy, though, too. That's my nickname. Tell me what you did, Buddy. I'm a maintenance person for a company called Ranch Village Properties.
7:48Astead Herndon: I want to ask a couple questions about President Trump. How do you think the second term is going?
7:55I've got to flip the coin on that one. 50-50. 50-50? Yeah.
7:58Astead Herndon: Why would you say 50-50? Because some things I don't think he's doing right. Some things he is doing right. Yeah, when we talk to some people, we hear a mixed bag, even more so than we may have heard last year. It seems like people are maybe feeling a little differently about him this summer than they were feeling last summer. That's true. What do you think changed? That's just basically the economy and everything else. So you think the economy is the number one issue? There's been that flip. Right. We're talking gas prices. Are we talking like, what is it? Well, we're talking about everything in general.
8:28But I'll be very honest with you that many years ago, my parents grew up, everything else. And they were able to make ends meet with the money, wages they were coming in. But nowadays, people are overextending themselves. Yeah.
8:40Astead Herndon: And that feels like more than just one party of a problem. It feels like both parties have may have contributed to that. They have, yes. You know, Donald Trump ran on the promise of making stuff cheaper and better. What do we think went wrong? He's not listening to everybody. That's what I'm feeling.
9:02Astead Herndon: My question would be, what do you think he should be saying on Iran to maybe make people feel a little better about the situation? Well, he keeps saying prices are going to go down. The war is going to be over soon. and I heard him say the other day we're either going to end it all over there or we're just going to pull out. And I think he needs to make up his mind on what it is and I don't know what it should be, to be honest. Do you worry that if the war is still going and gas prices are still high come the midterms that it could be a bad night for Republicans? Yes, I do. I worry all the time.
9:39I always worry about it.
9:41Astead Herndon: How do you kind of feel about where the National Republican Party is right now? Oh, I think the Republican Party is not looked highly upon right now, and I think everyone knows it. I'm curious, like, when do you think that changed? Because obviously, like, Trump had a big win in 2024. Like, he's really popular in places like Ohio. What do you think has shifted the energy? It's changed, I think, just because people have seen it more when they're shopping. It's just the prices? Yeah. So, as you heard, there are Republicans who are disappointed in this administration about the war, about the economy.
10:12Astead Herndon: But I still wondered how Vivek Ramaswamy would deal with the Trump pickle in his speech. I mean, here's someone who helped create one of Trump's signature initiatives when he got back into office, the Department of Government Efficiency. So would Ramaswamy mount a defense of this administration, or would he ignore Trump altogether? Up next, Ramaswamy takes the stage.
10:42Support for the show comes from TikTok. There is a scientifically documented correlation between listening to podcasts and curiosity. So since you're here, you probably enjoy discovering new things. One great place to indulge your curiosity is TikTok. Whether it's how to forecast volcanic eruptions, strange phenomena that the James Webb Space Telescope picked up near the beginning of time, or a literal deep dive on the ocean's deepest reefs. TikTok has a wealth of fascinating videos just waiting to be discovered. Your next discovery is waiting on TikTok. Learn more at tiktok.com slash discovermore.
11:26Brussels clean up nicely at Sweetgreen. maple glazed roasted and edges perfectly caramelized sweet greens fall harvest is back on the menu and the season's most overlooked little green vegetable is dressed to be devoured you know what to do order on the sweet green app fall savings are happening now at the home depot save up to 500 on select appliances plus enjoy free delivery when you spend 998 or more from From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom flex temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes, including stone-baked pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant-quality pizza in as little as two minutes.
12:06Then clean up with the Frigidaire dishwasher featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop false savings now at The Home Depot. Off and valid for October 21st. U.S. only. See store online for details.
12:17Astead Herndon: After talking to a bunch of Republican voters, I was even more interested to hear Ramaswamy's town hall. I mean, nobody in this room liked Democrats, but there was acknowledgement that Republicans were in a weak position this November. A brand problem made worse by an unpopular president. Bless our time. And of course, we ask that you bless Vivek and his family and his team. But as soon as Vivek took the stage, it was clear that his strategy for dealing with Trump was not to deal with him at all. And if we celebrate success, we get more of it. If we villainize success, we get less of it. It is that simple.
12:59That is the choice between socialism and free enterprise, between success and failure, between American greatness and, God forbid, American decline. That is the choice on the ballot this November.
13:12Astead Herndon: And in fact, if you listen to his speech, you would have no idea that Republicans are in power right now in Ohio, in Congress, and especially in the White House. An open border is not a border. Parents should determine the education of their children. The nuclear family is not a bad word. It is the greatest form of governance known to mankind. Capitalism is not a bad word. It is the greatest system we have to lift people up from poverty. There are three branches of government, not four, not the administrative state. And the U.S. Constitution, it is the strongest and greatest guarantor of freedom in human history.
13:53That is the truth. And we stand up for the truth. That is who we are as conservatives. And I want Ohio to be the state that leads our country back to greatness, for us to be the state that Texas and Florida and Tennessee look up to rather than the other way around.
14:12Astead Herndon: On one hand, I get that his focus is local. It is a governor's race, after all. But I still think it's notable that when Ramaswamy talks about things like bringing jobs back to Ohio, he makes no mention of Trump's tariffs. The administration's signature economic policy aimed at regions just like this one. At the turn of the last century, we were the wealthiest state of the union. We led the first industrial revolution. Even in 1950, six of the top 15 wealthiest cities in America were here. Dayton led in computing. My hometown of Cincinnati was known around the world as the Queen City, the machine tools hub, the consumer products capital.
14:53Astead Herndon: In fact, I had heard a lot of this speech already. It's basically the same one that Ramaswamy would give back when he was running for the Republican presidential nomination in 2024. I will still say, as a father of three young kids myself, there is no other country on planet Earth where I would rather have been born and raised. There is no other country on planet Earth where I would rather be raising our kids than this one. There is no other time in human history where I would rather have been born or be raising our kids than at this moment now. And for that, we must be grateful. The biggest difference was his focus on public education, an issue that we don't hear that often from congressional midterms candidates.
15:41Astead Herndon: Ramaswamy mentioned it several times in his speech. And when he started to take questions from the audience, it was clear the issue was on their minds, too. So my mom is a first grade teacher in inner city Akron, and there is a literacy crisis. What will you do to guarantee the third grade reading guarantee, which is the biggest predictor if a child will graduate literate from high school? Love your question. So your mom is teaching what grade? She teaches first grade in Akron in the inner city. Amazing. Give your mom a round of applause for everyone here. Is she here with us? No. Okay, okay. We'll tell her we appreciate her.
16:09Yeah, we'll do.
16:10Astead Herndon: And I also found this question about data centers to be particularly interesting, given our previous reporting. The candidate pitched data centers as a solution for abandoned industrial sites in Ohio. But when the audience questions began, it wasn't clear they were buying it. Data centers. Okay. Can we put them on airport property where there's already turbines making lots of noise? Which, which is it, Wayne? Yes. So, so look, I had a question about this coming in. I'll give you the short answer. I've laid out a full policy on this, but short answer is put them on abandoned industrial sites. If you're going to put them anywhere, it just makes a lot of sense.
16:48We got a lot of abandoned industrial sites. Don't interrupt farmland. It doesn't make any sense to use virgin farmland or residential communities. We have a lot of abandoned industrial sites. De-industrialization.
16:59Astead Herndon: After the event, I wanted to see how Ramaswamy's pitch landed with the voters in attendance. You know, there is a lot of, you know, hollowed out industry in these areas. And one of what Ramaswamy was saying was that you could use those places to kind of bring in different AI firms or things like that that could help folks. I know that sometimes makes people a little scared, though. Like, I was wondering for you, like, when you hear someone say that, does that make you think, you know, hey, this could be something that helps Ohio? or when you hear things like AI and what its impact on jobs, do you worry about how it could hurt Ohio?
17:33Right. I think personally, I haven't seen the value of data centers for our society. And in the long term, you know, I don't know if those are going to be good, good for our society or used the right ways. And I have a lot of concerns about their energy usage and their water usage and their noise. You know, it seems like no one's worried about the global climate change anymore all of a sudden. These things have a big impact for sure.
18:05Astead Herndon: In large part, attendees defended Ramaswamy's decision to avoid Trump. Did that surprise you? No, because it's his own governor. Yeah, you're saying he's focusing on his own vision. Yeah, it's his race. Well, this is an Ohio race for Ohio governor. Donald Trump's name didn't come up in there. Did that surprise you? No, because Donald Trump ain't running the campaign. You said it's about governor. It's about Vic Ramaswamy. And when I asked whether it would be beneficial for Republicans to just distance themselves from an unpopular president, the voters provided a familiar excuse. No, because it's all Joe Biden's fault anyway.
18:42Astead Herndon: We've talked to people who seem to be contending with some uncomfortable numbers. Donald Trump's gotten a little more unpopular as the war gets worse, as gas prices go up. What do you think Republicans should be saying to win votes in November? Well, without a doubt, they need to be bragging about what we've accomplished so far. And what people are forgetting is how bad, and I emphasize the word bad, things were under the Biden regime. If you could list the Trump accomplishments that matter the most to you, what would they be? Well, we've got inflation under control for the most part. And we've got new jobs coming here.
19:19We have new companies moving back. You know, under Biden, prices went up. When prices go up, they stay up. The inflation was inherited. Trump's inflation, three, you know, much lower than historical. I don't know. I don't know if you're baiting me to—
19:37Astead Herndon: No, no. I guess I was just asking, how long does that window of basically deference last? And not to mention my IRA has, it's unbelievable. It's just unbelievable. It happens. It happened under Biden. Happens under every president. The price goes up. Shit happens. It is what it is.
20:04Astead Herndon: We have gone to this event in hopes of speaking with Ramaswamy directly. I mean, he's usually the guy who talks. And he's usually happy to talk about Donald Trump. But his team turned us down for an interview at the event, and they ignored several requests for a follow-up. But I think that speaks directly to the pickle Republican candidates are in for the midterms. I mean, Donald Trump is still the most popular figure among their most committed voters, so they can't distance themselves. But at the same time, he's increasingly disliked nationally. So they can't really defend him. Instead, they're taking what I call the ostrich strategy, just hiding their heads in the sand, hoping everything works out for them.
20:50Astead Herndon: But to this point, there's little evidence that it has. Just this week, new polling showed Ramaswamy trailing Democrat Amy Acton by nine points in the governor's race. A shocking number, considering just how red Ohio has become. So when Trump says, Pretend that I'm on the ballot. I think that's a bet Democrats will gladly take him up on. He's driving the enthusiasm among their base. And he's depressing the enthusiasm among the Republican one.
21:24Astead Herndon: America actually will be in your feeds every Saturday with an interesting interview in Culture or Politics. You can also watch these episodes at the Vox YouTube channel. Just go to youtube.com slash Vox or click the link in the show notes. If you enjoy our reporting and you want to learn more, sign up for my weekly newsletter, Midterms Actually. Go to Vox.com slash Midterms Actually to learn more. That's Vox.com slash Midterms Actually. This show was edited by Kasha Brasalian, fact-checked by Esther Gim, and mixed by Shannon Mahoney. Christopher Snyder is our video editor, and Koon Nui is our senior art director.
22:02Astead Herndon: Our executive producer is Christina Vallis, and our theme music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Additional support from Miranda Kennedy, David Tadashore, and Nisha Tuttall. I'm Estet Herndon, and this is America Actually.
22:21Support for the show comes from TikTok. There is a scientifically documented correlation between listening to podcasts and curiosity. So since you're here, you probably enjoy discovering new things. One great place to indulge your curiosity is TikTok. Whether it's how to forecast volcanic eruptions, strange phenomena that the James Webb Space Telescope picked up near the beginning of time, or a literal deep dive on the ocean's deepest reefs, TikTok has a wealth of fascinating videos just waiting to be discovered. Your next discovery is waiting on TikTok. Learn more at tiktok.com slash discovermore.
23:26menu has returned to Sweetgreen featuring fall's best dressed. Make your move. Order on the Sweetgreen app.
Can a Republican candidate run for governor in a red state without bringing up Donald Trump a single time? We went to Ohio to find out.
This show was edited by Kasia Broussalian, fact checked by Esther Gim, mixed by Shannon Mahoney, video edited by Christopher Snyder, and hosted by Astead Herndon.
Photo caption: Republican Vivek Ramaswamy speaks during a town hall. Photo by Arden S. Barnes/For The Washington Post via Getty Images
You can also watch this episode on youtube.com/vox. Listen to Today, Explained ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: vox.com/members. New Vox members get $20 off their membership right now. If you enjoy our reporting and want to learn more, sign up for Astead’s weekly newsletter, Midterms, Actually. Just go to www.vox.com/midtermsactually to learn more, and get in-depth analysis about this year’s election right to your inbox.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices