1. Podcasts
  2. TRIGGERnometry
  3. “I Hired Them. They Reported Me for Missing a DEI Meeting” – Oliver Malcolm
TRIGGERnometry

17 Oct 2026 · 1h 8m · 22 chapters

Episode artwork

“I Hired Them. They Reported Me for Missing a DEI Meeting” – Oliver Malcolm

In short

Oliver Malcolm argues that UK publishing has become a “monoculture” that suppresses ideas through “soft cancellation” (marketing/design/print decisions) and fear-driven compliance with DEI/identity politics, limiting authors’ opportunities even when books are formally acquired.

Guest backgrounds

Oliver Malcolm is a history graduate (modern history of Nazism, University of Sheffield) who worked in publishing across major houses: Random House (key account manager), HarperCollins (about a decade), and Hachette (a couple of years). He’s now building Highline Publishing Studio, a transatlantic publisher aimed at breaking monoculture.

Key claims

Publishing’s value chain (publicity, marketing, digital, production, sales reps, retailer placement) allows subjective decisions to quietly reduce a book’s chances. He says staff/HR-driven culture can punish dissent, including reporting him for missing a DEI meeting during the pandemic. He claims censorship-by-neglect is common, creating silence among less famous authors.

Notable examples

Francis Malcolm’s book being dropped from promotion and shifted to “digital sales” only; cancellation/withdrawal of deals for authors like Zuby; Roald Dahl backlist “reworked”; Salman Rushdie award night met with “chilling silence”; JK Rowling and Lee Child as tolerated exceptions; unionization and “sensitivity reads” controversies (e.g., The Salt Path).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:59

Introducing Oliver Malcolm

Oli Malcolm discusses the impact of DEI meetings in publishing.

“I was actually reported once for not attending a D &I meeting.”
2:12

Oliver's Background in Publishing

Oli shares his journey from a history graduate to the publishing industry.

“I really look forward to speaking with you about the publishing industry with some inside stories.”
4:51

The Monoculture of Publishing

Discussing the lack of diversity in publishing perspectives and practices.

“Because the reason I say this is we were talking before we started and we remembered our friend Sean Walsh who came on the show.”
6:50

Challenges of Publishing Today

Oli elaborates on challenges authors face in getting their books published.

“but also I'm propelled by creative expression, that I genuinely think the best ideas come out in environments where you have to synthesise different perspectives.”
9:20

The Evolution of the Publishing Industry

Examining how the publishing industry has changed and its implications.

“And you've got to be very careful, don't you, to suddenly sort of generalise in such broad terms about the whole of publishing.”
12:12

Caving to Younger Staff

Discussing how senior management navigates pressures from younger staff.

“smaller issues and maybe not even debating them is much easier than saying no.”
14:00

Fragmented Publishing Landscape

Explore the challenges and conflicts within the publishing industry.

“The market is just fragmented and fragmented and fragmented.”
15:08

The Book Buying Experience

Discuss the initial positive experience in publishing and subsequent challenges.

“And so for everybody listening and watching, we know each other because, Oli, you bought my book.”
16:09

Censorship in Publishing

Examine how authors face antagonism before their work is even read.

“So with your sort of Venezuelan connection.”
17:15

The Impact of Publishers

Understand the powerful role publishers play in marketing and author success.

“or was in the process of negotiating books with when I left were effectively cancelled.”
Show all 22 chapters
19:18

Surreal Publishing Experiences

Delve into shocking experiences authors can face with publishers regarding book promotion.

“Learn the history, understand the founding.”
21:52

Cultural and Identitarian Challenges

Investigate the cultural tensions and identity politics in the publishing world.

“But also when you're someone who's, you know, you've created this baby, you've put a lot of work into it, and then the rug is just pulled from underneath you, it's unacceptable.”
24:25

Fear and Censorship in Publishing

Discuss how fear of cancellation stifles creativity and expression in publishing.

“feel really quite, I guess, a bit more personally painful is that, I guess, back in the day, you'd just bring in staff because you thought they'd be good and you'd hire them based upon their meritocratic qualities.”
28:00

The Impact of Censorship on Publishing

Discussion about the censorship in publishing and its effect on artistic expression.

“What, they're not going to publish Othello?”
34:57

Freedom of Expression in Literature

Exploration of freedom of expression in literature and the implications of changing historical texts.

“Coming back to the Francis book and what you were talking about internally, somebody saying, oh, he's from trigonometry or whatever.”
42:00

The Complexities of Great Artists and Their Legacies

Explore the debate around the idea that brilliant artists must also be virtuous individuals.

“I guess the point I'm just making there is that we mentioned Lee Chao being slightly disjunct to the industry.”
44:00

The Hypocrisy of Modern Cancel Culture

Discuss the inconsistencies in modern cancel culture and its impact on artists like Julie Bindle.

“And one of the interesting things to me about all of this is Roald Dahl in particular, his sin was anti-Semitism, right?”
46:00

Opportunities Amidst Monoculture in Publishing

Analyze the current state of publishing and how it presents both challenges and opportunities.

“I mean, they tend to get put in Nashville or they tend to get removed from New York and from the scene and that they're not part of the gang.”
49:10

Corporate Response to Employee Dissent

Examine how businesses react to employee protests and the implications for leadership.

“What I've always thought is that if we talked earlier about, you know, staff, the youngest staff trying to impose their worldview through sort of collective protesting or threatening to resign over J.K.”
52:00

The Shift in Publishing Dynamics and Technology

Investigate how technology has changed the landscape of publishing and corporate responses.

“I don't understand when this thing happened, when the children started running the house.”
56:00

The Impact of Political Sentiment on Publishing

Explore how current political sentiments influence the publishing industry and its financial health.

“People aren't buying it and we I mean, look at the bank balance.”
1:04:42

Concerns About Anti-Semitism in Publishing

Discuss the potential rise of anti-Semitism in the publishing industry and its implications.

“In the end, a very small but brilliant publisher came to assist.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On TRIGGERnometry, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01When it comes to my policy, Farmers gives it to me straight, so there's no surprises. It's your coverage. You should never be confused. You hear that? An insurance provider with a conscience.

0:13Francis Foster: We're a choir, but yes, we have that too. Straightforward coverage you can literally understand. That's what you get when you have Farmers. Bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum. Learn more at Farmers.com. Underwritten by Farmers Truck or Fire Insurance Exchanges or Affiliate. Products not available in every state. Observe. The North American Dad. 50s. Great polo collection. He enters his vehicle information on Carvana. An offer appears in minutes. Remarkable. He squints, reads it again, smiles and says, Dang, that's a good offer. The highest form of approval. No haggling. No hassle. No one called him boss.

0:53He's still on the couch. Astonishing. Sell your car today on Carvana.com. Pickup fees may apply. I was actually reported once for not attending a D &I meeting. Caving into staff on some of these smaller issues and maybe not even debating them is much easier than saying no. It is a problem when the publishing industry and the thoughts and teams within that are almost like an Islington dinner party. What I really rage against is when there's a suppression of ideas. I kind of saw the real side of publishing maybe. I had this really surreal conversation where I sat down with the same editor and she said to me, we are not going to be promoting the book.

1:40We're going to focus on digital sales, which means they weren't going to print it. You had an experience which I've seen multiple times over the years. Part of the antagonism just came out, it's hidden from Trigonometry. Don't wanna do it. Do you want a little slice of Trigonometry for yourself? Then head over to our merch store, where you'll be able to buy hoodies, t-shirts, caps, prints, stickers, posters, and of course, the world famous Trigonometry mug.

2:08Francis Foster: Go to shop.triggerpod.co.uk. That's shop.triggerpod.co.uk and become part of the show. Oli, welcome to Trigonometry. Thank you very much. I really look forward to speaking with you about the publishing industry with some inside stories. Francis's book being cancelled is one of them, of course, that you were involved in and what happened to you as well. Before we get into all that, tell us a little bit about your background, your story, how you eventually ended up here. Sure. So first of all, I've noticed, by the way, I'm mimicking your body language, which hopefully is a good sign. yeah um but yeah i i was a uh originally a history graduate um i studied um fundamentally nancism well modern history of nancism at the university of sheffield um that was probably in the year sort of maybe around about 2000 um and i actually went to sheffield uni because i because ian kershaw was a bit of a bit of a hero of mine at school um he'd obviously written his incredible biographies of hitler um and obviously had a huge amount of exposure to a new framework of ideas And I found it incredibly motivating.

3:15And so having done that degree, I did the thing you'd always do is go and work for GlaxoSmithKline. I think I did about 18 months to two years there. And when I say I work for GlaxoSmithKline, really I was working as a sale rep for the Ribena brand. So what looked good on paper, the day-to-day wasn't quite so motivating. So it didn't last long in that sort of corporate world. but saw an advert to work as a key account manager for what was then Random House. Came down to London. I was obviously brought up in a very, very different environment. I was brought up in the Peak District. And actually, my father's, I guess, fairly itinerant in that he was born in Bombay.

4:01I worked in publishing for maybe four or five years at Random House, followed by a decade at HarperCollins, and then a couple of years at Hachette. But I think what was quite interesting...

4:13Francis Foster: These are for people who are not familiar with the publishing world. These are big publishers, really, really big. Some of the biggest publishers in the world. Sure, I mean, they are the biggest three publishers in the world. And I guess what's quite privileged about my experience is that I worked not only with different publishers in different houses, but I worked sort of cross-functionally. I worked in sales, I worked in editorial, and I worked as a managing director. I was also very fortuitous. I got to work on the board across the UK and Australia. But, yeah, I think I've got a fairly interesting insight as to what actually happens behind the curtain.

4:51Francis Foster: And what have you seen over the years that means you're sitting here today? Because the reason I say this is we were talking before we started and we remembered our friend Sean Walsh who came on the show. And I remember saying to him, you know, you've been on Live at DevPoly, you've been on this show, you've been on that show, you've been on... Mock the week. All of them, right? Yeah. And now you're on trigonometry, what happened? Sure, sure. And I think your story is actually very much along the same lines because you're reacting to things that were happening in your industry that have ended up in a very different place for you personally.

5:26Sure, sure, sure. Well, look, I think my corporate and professional motivation is, of course, that I'm setting up a new publishing house. We're setting up Highline Publishing Studio, which is a transatlantic new publisher. And I guess the motivation is that we're sort of sick of the monoculture of publishing. But look, if I was trying to explain it to someone who doesn't know our industry well, if you look at media, and particularly newspapers, I guess what you have is no matter who the owners are, you have the Times, you have the Telegraph, you have the Daily Mail, you have the Express, the Independent, the Guardian.

6:04you do have a spectrum of ideas. And I think you have a spectrum of people. But sort of almost by stealth, albeit slow, tectonic stealth as such a thing, the publishing industry now is almost, in effect, the Guardian, the Guardian, the Guardian, the Guardian, the Guardian. And what's unusual about that is that not only does it create what I think is an exacerbation of monoculturalism, but you ultimately end up getting the same publishing experience or the same sort of censorious behaviours, no matter who your originating publisher is. And I find that obviously deeply disturbing, and it was becoming more disturbing the deeper into my career I got.

6:45But yeah, I'm propelled obviously by, I guess, wanting to do something different from traditional publishing, but also I'm propelled by creative expression, that I genuinely think the best ideas come out in environments where you have to synthesise different perspectives. I obviously embrace the dialectic. I like an open forum for debate. I don't mind antagonism. What I really rage against is when there's a suppression of ideas and sort of a premeditation of curation. I just want to judge books by what's on the page, not by what I had as a sort of premeditated perspective.

7:20Francis Foster: But is that happening? I mean, you know, we were talking, you helped publish a couple of works by Douglas Murray. Sure. I had my book published, Francis eventually. and we'll talk about that at his book published. Lots of people with all sorts of different opinions are getting their books out there. Sure, sure. Is it really true? Also, look, that is the question, the best question. But why I'm rallying against it so much is that what you don't often realise as an author is that your book is not actually getting the best possible opportunity. Because even if an editor buys your book and even if your title gets acquired to be within that list, that ultimately every single book has to have a boutique team around it to make it successful.

8:06So nowadays, you have to have a great publicist. You have to have a brilliant marketing team and a digital marketer. You have to have a production team and sales reps. And the thing is that at any one time, any of these individuals can bring in their own subjective bearing into that publication. So what happens if your jacket doesn't get designed particularly well or it misses its on sale date? What happens if the rep doesn't actually decide to actually present that book to the retailer. What happens if the retailer doesn't even put it on sale in the space that they said they put it on sale on?

8:34And so I guess that when you look at these sort of micro-sensorious behaviours across the whole value chain, do I think that books of certain persuasions have as good opportunity as others? No, I don't. And that's a problem because ultimately if you want people to, again, get access to the full spectrum of ideas, I think that it's a lot more difficult for certain authors to actually achieve that.

8:57Francis Foster: And why is it that this is happening? You said publishing is the Guardian, the Guardian, the Guardian, the Guardian. Why is that? Because I imagine, I don't know, but correct me if I'm wrong, I always thought publishing is a business. So what you want to do is make money. The best way to make money is to publish books that people buy.

9:20You're completely right. And you've got to be very careful, don't you, to suddenly sort of generalise in such broad terms about the whole of publishing. Not least, it's ultimately the fastest growing components of publishing now, it's like self-publishing on TikTok and areas which aren't traditional publishing at all. In some ways, the actual global books market's incredibly buoyant. Look at the digital marketing, look at the growth of audio, and also particularly buoyant for English language publishing, because of course, people are now preferring to read in English languages. And so you'll often see, for example, in countries like Germany and Poland and France right now, sometimes the English spoken book is doing better than the native tongue, which is a huge change in our market.

10:00But look, the reason why things have changed so much, in my opinion, is that, look, publishing has always been slightly more on the left liberal side. And, you know, the old expressions like Bollinger, Bolshevism and champagne socialists. But, you know, it is a problem when the publishing industry and the thoughts and teams within that are almost like an Islington dinner party. But it's got worse and worse and worse because of the nature of, I think, the markets that are doing well. Because what's happened, you know, rapidly in some ways is that, for example, you know, romanticity or, you know, the new form of romance is doing so, so well.

10:43And so what publishers do is that they have to chase the market. And that can have a huge bearing on the mix of staff. And so, for example, I think publishing is now probably at 68%, 69 % female staff, which, look, you have to chase the money. Of course you do. But what if the net bearing of that is that it's no longer representative of the public or the readership, or rather to the point, what happens if in time that stops young boys wanting to read or them being a priority? That's not going to create a more sort of hospitable long-term environment between male and females, I don't think. So in some ways it's come about slightly organically by oddness.

11:23The other reason is a slightly more worrying one in some ways, which is that publishing, in my experience, has always felt like it's going to collapse. since for the 20 years, it's always feeling like, oh my God, this is the violinist on the Titanic, the string quartet. But what happens is that there's quite a large wealth gap between those at the top at publishing and those at the bottom. And so once you get to the top, and I had a huge privilege to do that, I was the pig in the trough. And you chomp at your swill and you enjoy your swill. But then if you want to appease the young staff coming through, it's much easier to appease them with things which have no commercial bearing on the actual business and ensures that you continue to get rewarded handsomely.

12:11So in some ways, you know, caving into staff on some of these smaller issues and maybe not even debating them is much easier than saying no. And I think over time, you know, we've seen, for example, a huge amount of unionization take place in publishing. So, you know, for example, in the US right now, one of the biggest publishers have now got a 500, 600 strong union. And that's when the youngest staff are being paid just under$60 ,000. I mean, for me, it's not, publishing is not like working down a coal mine. But, yeah, that's sort of, I think, the macro thing that's taken place over this time.

12:53Francis Foster: You know, one of the things that I've always struggled with, with that thing that you just said, which is people in positions of power caving to younger staff. Is there not a part of a person in that situation? It's because like, how fucking dare you? Who are you? Why are you telling me what I'm supposed to do with this thing that I've been working on for 15 years? Or even in some cases, this thing that I built from the ground up and I own. Sure, sure, sure, sure. Is there not a part of, there's a righteous indignation against this? Well, there is on my behalf. Yeah. But I think, you know, I don't want to sort of necessarily, you know, critique senior people saying that it's all down towards, so it's all down to their sort of defensive play.

13:36Partly it's just down to the fact that publishing has reached the point of being so manual, laborious, fragmented, that just getting through the day is almost like a huge achievement. And I know every industry says that. But of course, in the old days, it was simply getting a book on a shelf in physical form. Nowadays, it's getting a book on a shelf in physical form, in audio form, in digital form, through hundreds of fragmented ways around the world. The market is just fragmented and fragmented and fragmented. And so it's become incredibly laborious. And you'll have seen that, you know, in recent months, this huge sort of conflict around the salt path that it hadn't had a sensitivity raise.

14:16and in some ways you know people go into the politics of whether it should or shouldn't have had a sensitivity reach should have had a fact check on all these things and I sort of thought to myself probably one that's just slipped through the net just one of those ones where you know it seemed like a very reasonable sort of nice narrative piece of travel you know non-fiction and that it's sort of been caught up slightly in the culture wars but yeah that partly that the world of publishing has got very, very sort of fraught and frantic. But I do think there's also that, you know, people have been trying to get to the top all that time.

14:51And it's just easier to appease people by putting in, you know, big, big, big departments to deal with the problem. Hence why you've got massive, sprawling HR functions at quite a few of the publishers. So, yeah, hopefully that sort of surmises where I stand on it. And so for everybody listening and watching, we know each other because, Oli, you bought my book. I did indeed. Yeah. You bought my book for Hodder and Stoughton. And it initially went really well. I went, everyone in publishing is lovely. Sure. We're having this great time. I'm writing this book. There's loads of support. And then it ended up taking a bit of a turn.

15:30A nasty turn. Yes. And I kind of saw the real side of publishing, maybe. Yeah, I think so. I think that, A, I feel incredibly responsible in some ways because I'm the person who, having acquired that book, then left and went to a different publisher. So, look, there's always a degree to which don't sign with a publisher and have your book orphaned. Because, of course, sometimes books are successful because it's based upon the passion of the individual that published it. I was particularly passionate about Francis' book because, one, I love the podcast. to my parents, who are both teachers, and also because of your South American connection.

16:08Because when I left school, I did a year or so as a teacher in Chile. So with your sort of Venezuelan connection. But also it just taught common sense. It sort of said, look, you have to gain some discipline of the two or three bad apples in the classroom or the entire thing goes to the dogs. And so I like the fact that someone was actually coming up with a solution to how to get things back on track. unfortunately as we know I think that it was as much what you represented rather than what was read and that's one of the most difficult things for me because you know having as you guys know published the likes of Douglas Murray and and uh Piers Morgan um the a huge amount of antagonism comes prior to anyone I've actually read read the book so I was always fighting off arguments or having to stand in front of committees.

17:00And it was clear that literally nobody had read the book. So one might presume that the same thing happened to you, Francis, that part of the antagonism just came, oh, it's him from trigonometry, don't want to do it. And I experienced that a lot. And actually some of the other authors I tried to bring in or was in the process of negotiating books with when I left were effectively cancelled. I remember I got told the other day I tried to sign up Zuby. and I don't know if everyone knows or your listeners know who Zuby is but I think he's been on the podcast. I love Zuby because he's almost, he represents his own world view and he has opinions which are not popular and he's prepared to back them up.

17:41He's sharp. He's very worthy of a book and I like the fact that the book was different to everything else which was out at that time. Of course, in the midst of that deal, suddenly gone, no more what was happening. And so, of course, I have to always be careful when you talk about deals that you're working on because of, you know, privacy. But you weren't alone, and you won't be the last. But that's the sort of thing which, you know, really, really impacts me and motivates me that you've got to have a new type of publisher.

18:14Francis Foster: Most people think the American Revolution began with the Declaration of Independence. It didn't. It was built over years as Britain tightened its grip and the colonists defended what they had been doing for generations, governing themselves. Hillsdale College's new series, Revolutionary America, from subjects to citizens, tells us a whole story across six episodes covering the growing conflict with Britain through independence, the war, and the writing of the Constitution. You visit the historical sites, hear expert accounts from Lexington and Concord, Bunker Hill, and Valley Forge, and get material that didn't make it into the full-length documentary.

18:49Francis Foster: Watching this as a Brit is a strange experience. For six episodes you're essentially watching your own country get it wrong, repeatedly, and then lose. Very educational, not great for national pride. This is one of more than 40 free courses Hillsdale offers on the Constitution, the Roman Republic, the American Founding, Genesis, the Second World War, and more. All built the same way, taught properly, not dumbed down. I couldn't recommend Hillsdale courses more highly. Go to hillsdale.edu slash trigger to watch. It's totally free. Learn the history, understand the founding. Start right now at hillsdale.edu slash trigger.

19:50And then I spoke with Constantine because I was really shocked. I was taken aback because it was instantaneous. And then everything was fine. The processes were fine. And then I had this really surreal conversation where I sat down with the same editor. And she said to me, yeah, we are not going to be promoting the book. I'm sorry, but we agreed on serialization. He ended up getting serialization in the Times and in the Daily Mail and two-page feature. But she was just saying, no, no, no, that's not going to happen. Sure, sure, sure. And I was shocked. And she went, oh, and also the print run, we're going to focus on digital sales, which means they weren't going to print it.

20:33And I just felt as if it was this kind of surreal experience where everything you had been promised, we're going to do this and we're going to do this. And it was like, oh, no, no, we're not going to do that. Why not? Well, we just don't feel like it. Yeah. And it got me incredibly angry because, number one, it was my book and I put so much work into it. But number two, it got me so furious because if you're going to do this to me, which is one of the stupidest people to do this to in the entire country, what are you going to do to authors who don't have a huge YouTube channel? What are they going to do with people that they can't call on?

21:14One of the first people I called was Douglas Murray, asking for advice. Most people don't have access to that. Sure, sure. Well, look, you had an experience which I've seen multiple times over the years. Sometimes, actually, oddly, the authors who've been, you know, had the worst possible treatments are the ones who are not actually alive. And, of course, you know, with Roald Dahl having his entire backlist, you know, basically censored and reworked because of his historical views. and that in that instance I think the family tried to sort of intercept. But also when you're someone who's, you know, you've created this baby, you've put a lot of work into it, and then the rug is just pulled from underneath you, it's unacceptable.

22:02But it's also, you know, there are many, many, many examples like that. But it also shows you that publishers do have influence. People sort of can sometimes think, oh, if I'm a self-published author, I don't need a publisher anymore. And yet you see when you do have a publisher, the impact they can have when they really want to put the marketing and energy behind it, or equally what happens is they decide to drop it. What they were doing there is they were dropping it like a bull, and therefore all the ramifications, it wouldn't have been properly sold. It's not properly marketed. It's not properly PR'd.

22:33And that makes it very, very difficult to succeed in, unfortunately, an industry where you have thousands and thousands of new books coming out per week. And what that must lead to is a culture of fear and a culture of silence. particularly if you're an author, like I said, who doesn't have a huge public profile, maybe this is a first book, you're going to think to yourself, I'm not going to say this. I'm not going to actually push the boat in any direction. Because the moment I do, there is a chance that some individual in the HR team or the marketing team or whatever it may be, will look at it and go, I didn't like this.

23:08Sure, sure, sure. And we've seen that a lot. I mean, again, another example, when I published Wake Up which was Piers Morgan's book it's very hard to identify when someone's doing a piece of subjective cancellation within probably marketing and PR because that's just not doing work but you can't tell always but what if it is in the design department for example and they just refuse to do a front cover and so you're forced to go out of house to find a designer somewhere who will do you a front cover but I'm dealing with this right now with Highline Publishing Studio you know, trying to work with specific agencies or businesses, and they just look instantly at our mission and say, no, not doing that.

23:49So, you know, that sort of, they're welcome to work with whoever they want to work with. But within publishing, that sort of soft cancellation of individuals and authors is a daily occurrence.

24:02Francis Foster: And with your own experiences, how did this manifest for you? So I think it's probably no secret that I've always been on the cusp of cancellation. I was never overtly cancelled. But when you publish, you know, the likes of Douglas and the likes of Pears, you are going to make yourself unpopular. But I think the things which, you know, when I look back on my career feel really quite, I guess, a bit more personally painful is that, I guess, back in the day, you'd just bring in staff because you thought they'd be good and you'd hire them based upon their meritocratic qualities. and I hired a couple of staff maybe very early on at my time at one of the publishers and supported them hugely.

24:47Actually one of them I even wrote a letter to the bookseller to recommend that they were a rising star because I thought they were so brilliant. And so it was incredibly painful when the identitarian cultural war madness started that I was actually reported once for not attending a D &I meeting. I wasn't there on the Zoom call during the pandemic, and I was reported to my boss saying, he's not there, why wasn't he there, what are you going to do about it? And what makes it even more painful is that, of course, these guys wanted a bit of revenge for me publishing, you know, your Douglases and your peers.

25:24But oddly, at the same time, I was publishing Sia Khaleesi. so I don't know if you guys know who Sia is but Sia is was the first ever black captain of the South African rugby team, the first black captain in 128 years rugby has always been associated with apartheid, here's a guy who was born and raised in Zvide province, he's a Corsair and he was basically brought up in abject poverty incredible story, so I published this book thinking, oh my god, this is the thing I want to do I'm passionate about and there's part of you thinks as well that you know isn't this just proof that I'm not a racist uh no because it's not it's not the right type of person I guess in the way that when I did Pierce the first question in the Q &A afterwards was why are you publishing this and not Ash Sarkar so it's an interesting it's it's not about necessarily supporting a cause it's about having the right you know opinions of the cause because you know So Seer was an incredible icon, pushing ideas around unity.

26:34But he wasn't the right type of person. But doesn't it speak to just the culture of fear that exists in publishing that you didn't attend a DEI meeting and you got reported? They didn't know what could have happened. Your child could have been sick. There could have been a family emergency. Maybe you had to be pulled into another type of meeting. Maybe you weren't. And actually, it's a good point as well, because, you know, when you do fight the good fight, as it were, I speak to a lot of people who have fought the fight in environments where you're on your own. And sometimes it just it just becomes cumulative and you get slightly worn down by it all.

27:09And so you're missing of any meeting might be just do the fact that like, well, every time I go on to one of these meetings, I get an absolute annihilation from the 400 people who are on it. I remember once, for example, I said I used the word cancel culture. And someone shouted, you know, that's, they didn't say it was libelous. They said it was a pejorative term. You cannot use the word cancel culture. We were talking about American Dirt at the time. And I just said, as a moral argument or a philosophical argument, you know, American Dirt was such a huge book because the author had essentially written in the voice of an ethnicity that wasn't them.

27:45and I said I just said the argument well look do you just cancel that all together or do you just sell that book to people who aren't bothered about that particular thing because we just want them to be creative and it's fine you know there's always as long as not pretending to be that person it's it's fiction right we're just trying something out you're developing as a writer it's creative um but I was I was the uh you know woe is me but uh that's not the view within publishing absolutely no way should anyone be appropriating. But that's insane. What, they're not going to publish Othello? Well, it's happened many, many times, and appropriation also often only acts in one direction.

28:28It's quite a misogynistic work, if I remember correctly. Yeah, it is. Among other things. And this is why I always push back on this type of progressivism, woke, whatever you want to call it. because for many different reasons. But primarily for me, the thing that angered me the most is because it's the enemy of art. It's the enemy of free expression. It's the enemy of creating anything truly, truly significant because what you are doing is you are being utterly censorious. Well, I think I've said many times that for me, I'm not taking premeditated publishing decisions. What I want to do is just publish completely across the spectrum.

29:11I want to trust the readers to make the decisions for themselves. I think I've probably got a limit. I probably won't publish hate speech. And I'm sure there are people on the line as well where you sort of have to have a serious conversation, whether that's something you can or cannot publish. Obviously, it can't be something that's criminal. But ultimately, you have to allow synthesis of arguments. I mean, I believe that education is through synthesis of perspectives. As a historian, I would read Eric Hobsbawm, who's obviously on the left wing. But I'd also read Alan Bullock, or I'll read Ian Kershaw, or I'll read Anthony Beaver.

29:49The whole point is you build up your knowledge set through reading a real sort of eclectic range of views. And funnily enough, you know, in the old days, I think being well-read was something which was considered an incredibly important characteristic. That person's well-read. You don't talk about that that much more. and yet here we are as publishers maybe actually restricting the breadth of perspectives that you can actually read. Go into a bookshop right now and then look at the displays. You can really try to be as objective as possible and try to say whether that's because it's the best possible curation for the people in that area or whether there's a sort of degree of propaganda occurring.

30:29Francis Foster: Well, this is the thing about it. This is why I was asking you about this publishing being a business, but it seems to me like with many other industries, I mean, the BBC is a very good example of this, right? A formally great institution in my opinion. But what... And we saw this in the comedy world when we were in it. Once the people at the top feel that A, their position is secure, the business is secure, what they realize then is actually I have something that's much more valuable than money, which is power. I have the ability to impose my worldview on the world, and therefore I can prevent comedians from appearing on shows who are good comedians but have the wrong opinions, or I can prevent opinions being expressed on my program or on our channel that I don't wish to have, even though they may be very popular in the country.

31:22Francis Foster: And with books, I can prevent books from being published or, as in France's case, allow it to be published but with the clear communication that we're not going to do anything for anyone to actually buy this book, it's not going to appear in shops. And that is not being done because it's not a book that will sell. It's being done because I am able to say my worldview is this, this doesn't match, therefore we'll prevent this from going out to the public. And I completely agree that it's a status game and having the power to determine what doesn't get read is incredibly important. And I'm seeing this more and more at the moment, for example, because my kids are doing, they're 11 plus and so I'm looking around schools.

32:09And I feel unnerved as I go into some school libraries right now in that there's one thing having, I guess, some sort of propaganda in bookshops, but what about if it's in school libraries and how does that impact behaviour? and also trying to get a child to learn how to think, not to be told what to think. And there's evidence already that children are starting to be put off reading because it's been seen as a sort of a metric for success rather than an enjoyable entertainment exercise and enterprise. But of course, is that because the great and the good have been intercepting and putting in their ideas into those books?

32:50I don't know. but ultimately the data's there to show that for whatever reason over the last four to five years kids are being a little bit less keen on reading and that's a worry. It's a huge worry.

33:03Francis Foster: I imagine technology has a lot to do with that and the smartphone, etc. A while back I pushed myself in training because I'm a legend but ended up with a strain that took far longer to recover from than it ever used to. Nothing dramatic, just one of those moments where you realise your body isn't snapping back the way it once did. And as you get older, those moments start adding up. Turns out there's a reason for that. And it's not just getting older. It's something specific happening at the cellular level. That's the idea behind Qualia Senolytic, a science-backed formula built around a fairly new area of research called senolytics.

33:39Your body accumulates what researchers call senescent cells, sometimes nicknamed zombie cells. Cells that have done their job and are just sitting there using up resources instead of clearing out. The theory is that this build-up is a big part of what people describe as feeling middle-aged, lower energy, slower recovery after exercise, and general joint discomfort. Qualia Senolytic uses nine vegan plant-derived compounds designed to support your body's natural processes for clearing out these cells. And you only take it two days a month. It's vegan, non-GMO, and developed with input from research scientists working specifically in this field.

34:19Since I started taking it, mornings feel easier, workouts don't take as long to bounce back from, and I generally have more left in the tank by the afternoon than I did a year ago. Experience the science of feeling younger. Go to qualiolife.com slash trig for up to 50 % off your purchase and use code trig for an additional 15%. That's Q-U-A-L-I-A life.com slash trig for an extra 15 % off your purchase. Your older self will thank you. And thanks to Qualia for sponsoring this episode.

34:57Francis Foster: Coming back to the Francis book and what you were talking about internally, somebody saying, oh, he's from trigonometry or whatever. What does that mean? Like, what is implied in that statement? When you see these soft cancellations within publishing or hard cancellations within publishing, what is the stated rationale for why somebody shouldn't have their book published with a particular publisher? Again, it's a great question. But when you look at a publishing year ahead, you're publishing so, so many books. And the reality is that you almost need to see a publishing year like an old school CD, which is that you've got four or five major singles which you have to do brilliantly and the rest are tracks some of those tracks might unexpectedly break out and become the singles but for the most part you're governing the rhythm of the year by those singles now as long as you do the singles well you can pretty much get away with anything else it's a blockbuster market and you'll notice that if you really want to sort of find the hole in my argument here you know the three biggest authors in the world probably don't get on with or agree with what's going on in the industry and yet the industry is still backing them and doing you know you know hugely so you know jk rowling um as far as i understand she is um having probably the best sales of her entire career right now hugely different to what the media narrative is but you know massively successful um but she doesn't agree with the sort of group think um and publishing is sort of complied you We all know that X many years ago, 85 members of staff walked out because of her kids' book, because they didn't want to be working with her.

36:35Someone had different views on gender identity. But even so, she's now been tolerated. We're an incredibly privileged position on our board, our spokesperson's Lee Child. And he's got some fascinating ideas that he is incredibly against what he says is cultural boycotting. It makes no sense to him that to put pressure, for example, on Israel, the right thing to do is to boycott events held by Israeli writers or Jewish writers. The rationale being is that, you know, why would you boycott an entire community as if it's totally homogenous? And in fact, with the Israeli community and the Jewish community, it's anything but homogenous, the most pluralistic of all.

37:21and so his view is that again slightly different to publishing or I mean look the other classic example is Salman Rushdie at the literary end of the spectrum who has been super pro freedom of speech and yet I've attended an awards ceremony when he actually won an award for I guess at the end of the night for a long term commitment to free speech and it was almost a chilling silence in the room that he'd won that award

37:53Francis Foster: Why is Salman Rushdie controversial with woke people? Well, only because he backed freedom of expression and in particular he'd said that what was happening to the redaction of all the Roald Dahl novels was disgraceful. He believes that you shouldn't be changing history for the sake of modernist principles and ultimately Roald Dahl liked him or loathed him. He's a controversial guy but he got a lot of people reading and you have to weigh up the pros and cons of anyone We've been through this with Churchill and everyone else, right? But yeah, so Salman, despite the fact that it's a guy who's been stabbed in the eye, he's had a fatwa on his head and has written some of the most incredible novels of the last 25 years or longer, there was a chilling silence the day that he won an award for services to free speech in publishing.

38:42And it's quite a big moment for me. Don't you think it smacks of a... I'm going to be brutally honest about it. despicable arrogance that you look at somebody like Roald Dahl, who I believe is a genius. I believe as a children's writer, he is a man of unique brilliance. And you then go, I'm going to change works of brilliance purely because they don't agree with certain people's politics in, I think it was 2024. Well, I agree. I think that, you know, it's like going back to Picasso and this blue phase and then turning it green because blue's no longer in. It's unacceptable. It's a changing of the historical record.

39:26And I personally feel like if it was just Roald Dahl, but of course it's not. We've had lots of examples of that. You know, Dr. Seuss, we've had Agatha Christie. We've had truly iconic names whose works, their original creative works, have just been altered for modern sensibility. By the way, that modern sensibility isn't a sensibility. It's the priority of a specific group. And ultimately, you need to allow things, I think, to have the oxygen in which they're written. And actually, if you learn about that time, if the entrance into, for example, Agatha Christie was like, oh, she used to say this sort of thing, and that's how they thought, maybe that's good.

40:04Maybe that's actually the reader will get more insight into that period, more understanding of that phenomenon. And yet, No, the preference is just censorship, cancel. But how do you... I don't understand how you come to that, either in a kind of philosophical sense or a commercial sense. Roald Dahl's books still sell in their tens, hundreds of thousands. Sure. But children always loved Dahl. When I was a primary school teacher, we used to do reading time. I always used to read Dahl to the kids. Sure, sure. They adored it.

40:38Francis Foster: No wonder you got cancelled. Yeah. Well, look, I think that sometimes you can overestimate the precipice upon which publishing is standing, and you do internally as well, but publishing, for whatever reason, it always finds a way. And I think that's great in some ways because it means that people continue to read. But it's also slightly odd because the way you continue to do well as a publisher is you just publish more and more and more. And so what happens? Well, probably the quality of service for each individual book has to go down. But it also means if you do slice away at some of your back lists, like Agatha Christie or Roald Dahl, whoever else, well, it's OK because you then sell hundreds of thousands of the new Richmond-Ostman novel you've bought.

41:22And also, you don't just do one Richard-Ostman novel. You then encourage him to do two a year. And then you do the adjacent sort of short story one. And by the way, on the topic of Richard-Ostman, it's an interesting one, isn't it? that a guy who's emerged as by far the biggest fiction writer of the last decade in the UK, and he made it in America, by the way, who do we think he's selling to? I mean, he's not selling to the metropolitan London elite, is he? He's selling all around the UK to occasional readers. What he's doing is amazing. He's getting very occasional readers to read again, to become loyal to his books.

41:55He also writes them himself. It's not like they're reading, you know, what they would be reading instead is probably not of the same quality. I guess the point I'm just making there is that we mentioned Lee Chao being slightly disjunct to the industry. You mentioned J.K. Rowling, but also Richard Osman, who is now becoming one of the biggest fiction writers in the UK. He's very, very different in what he's writing and for whom and how big that is relative to what's happening in the metropolitan circles of publishing. But there's also this idea that the artist has to be a nice human being. And there's a lot of great artists I mean, we've talked about Picasso I mean, Picasso Yeah, of course Yeah, I mean, if he'd been around He might have had a Me Too moment or two Of course But undeniably a genius You had Dahl, who had pretty I would say, you know He'd be on a pro-Palestine march You know, he might be a member of the Green Party When it comes to his views on the Middle East Yeah And it carries on Hemingway, again, another great writer But why do we have this idea that if you are a brilliant artist, somehow you have to be this perfectly PC individual?

43:07Sure, sure, sure. I mean, the one example of that which always comes to mind, not as an artist, but obviously it's Mahatma Gandhi. Right. With, you know, Gandhi sort of tried to remain celibate by dissuading himself from being tempted and therefore having really young girls in his bed. And that was the way in which he would prove his resistance. And meanwhile, you've got...

43:30Francis Foster: I'd like to see him explaining that on Newsnight. Quite tricky.

43:38And, you know, obviously we mentioned Churchill earlier, but, you know, a similar figure who I guess has been through the sort of... I've lost my thread.

43:48Francis Foster: Sorry, I'm constantly joking around to interrupt you. But I think your broader point was that people who've achieved great things throughout history or written great books are not necessarily perfect human beings. And one of the interesting things to me about all of this is Roald Dahl in particular, his sin was anti-Semitism, right? It's what's fascinating to me is the very people who are canceling Roald Dahl for anti-Semitism are exactly the sort of people that would go on a pro-Palestine march and shall all sorts of actually equally. well not maybe equally but anti-Semitic things at the same time.

44:22There's no consistency about it. Sure, sure. Well, I think that's probably the biggest motivator for me is often the hypocrisy, which is that, for example, someone like Julie Bindle, who is described as a TERF and has been ostracised a huge amount in publishing and beyond. But for me, that's someone in the 70s and 80s who, as a lesbian, earn the right to essentially without, to basically babysit kids. Because before then, it's like, I can't have a lesbian babysit my kids. It's too dangerous. And so she's got to this point where over 20 years, she's become accepted. And yet now in the new world, because she's questioning different other values, she's literally cancelled.

45:08You can't engage with her. She has to have security for certain events. And I don't think that's acceptable because it's not because she's ferociously right wing. It's because the values that she stands and are so dear to her are under threat. And so, yeah, I think, again, would it be easy for authors like Julie to get published right now outside of a very, very small number of publishers? Well, no. And yet she's enriching the debate around certain topics around gender identity. So I guess that what we now have is there is this monoculture, but that also leaves room for opportunity, doesn't it?

45:50Sure. Because, I mean, like Andreas at Little Brown, who's one of the few people who took on my book, but also you starting your own imprint, that's exciting because that's a real opportunity, isn't it? I think so. And the market's there. That's the thing. The readership is there. The one thing I know which is definitely true is that having worked across those big three publishers I mentioned at the beginning and beyond, is that what's quite odd is often that those divisions often sell a lot of books who are incredibly lucrative. I mean, they tend to get put in Nashville or they tend to get removed from New York and from the scene and that they're not part of the gang.

46:31But there is a commercial opportunity there. It's made harder. For example, if you're Jordan Peterson, let's say, and the New York Times refuse ever to publish the fact that your book was the number one bestseller for basically years in a row. And it means it's like, with the pace of social media, you have fear of missing out, and that sort of accumulation of good news is so critical. So if all lots of outlets don't cover it, or someone just decides, oh, you're not going to be on our bestseller list, that harms the opportunity for that book. But Jordan's an interesting point. I don't love the books.

47:06I find them quite hard to read. But it's one of the biggest nonfiction books of the last decade. It's a huge book. I mean, 12 Rules for Life. I don't think there's many bigger nonfiction sort of polemics or books of the last decade. And yet, most of the publishing industry was resisting it. Most of the sales were taking place online and on audio because there's no resistance taking place. Do I think that a Canadian academic With a different worldview Has a, you know, should he be published? Of course he should Why should he be hindered from being published? Okay, we need to discuss underwear Not a sentence I ever imagined saying on this show Yet here we are The truth is most men have been putting up With mediocre underwear for years And decided it's simply part of life It isn't Which brings me to Sheath S-H-E-A-T-H Sheath.com It's underwear designed around a dual pouch system.

48:08In plain English, everything stays exactly where it's meant to. No sticking, no chafing, no readjusting halfway through a point while trying to look like a serious person. The fabric is breathable, the design keeps things apart. Apparently, there's an official term for the result, and that term is zen-like separation, which sounds absurd and is also annoyingly spot on. It was created by a veteran during his second tour, so it was built in conditions where comfort was a necessity, not a nice extra. More than 10 ,000 five-star reviews from people who clearly mean it. I've had them on for a few months now, not consecutively.

48:45And honestly, the improvement to my daily comfort is more than I'm prepared to go into on a political podcast. Those who know, know. Head to sheath.com. That's S-H-E-A-T-H dot com. Enter code TRIGONOMETRY at checkout for 20 % off. Your first pair is backed by a full money-back guarantee, so you've got nothing to lose. Sheath.com. Once you go sheath, you won't go back. Sheath.com.

49:12Francis Foster: What I've always thought is that if we talked earlier about, you know, staff, the youngest staff trying to impose their worldview through sort of collective protesting or threatening to resign over J.K. Rowling or whatever, What I don't understand is why there hasn't been one person, one man or woman at the top who actually owns or runs the thing, who just goes, OK, 80 people who are not mission critical don't like this, they've walked out. We're going to put a marker down. You're all fired. Bye-bye. Thank you. Thank you for your service. Bye-bye. Sure. Well, that has happened, Constantine. That has happened, which is what was fascinating, of course, and again, a slightly odd paradox here, is that, you know, Pen and Random House is owned by Bertelsmann.

50:03Bertelsmann, obviously, they are being the original publishers of Mein Kampf.

50:10Excellent. You've got Hachette, which is owned by Vivendi. Don't forget that Vivendi is owned by Vincent Bollaret. Vincent Bollaret is the sort of the, I guess, the tycoon who has always underwritten Marine Le Pen. And he's a very, very, very wealthy right-wing, I guess a right-wing Rupert Murdoch, but French. Of course, HarperCollins is owned by Rupert Murdoch. But so what's so, so odd is that you do have these companies owned by what is seen to be or probably are quite right-wing or right-leaning financiers. But the editorial has sort of total self-governance, which I guess it should do. However, in France recently, there was a case where a very senior, very liked publisher refused to work on a certain book.

51:02And he had a big fallout with that management who said he had to do it or that he couldn't refuse to do it. And the result was that 40 or 50 authors all left all at once. So, you know, the other example is actually, so one of our founders, or our founder is Neil Blair, who is J.K. Rowling's agent. He actually said, look, this is who I am. This is our business. If you don't want to work here, you don't have to. Four people did actually leave. Did his business survive? Business is thriving. Yeah, I imagine. Fantastic.

51:35Francis Foster: Well, this is my point. It's this sort of like revolt in the kitchen. Sure. Well, it's not that big a deal. And if more people had the balls to stand up to this, I don't think we would have had this entire woke moment that we've lived through and probably continue to because I don't understand this entire upending of hierarchy, actually, from just a broader perspective. I don't understand when this thing happened, when the children started running the house. But it was technological, right? as in there's always been you know the young have always um uh pushed against revolution but that when we saw you know hashtag me too when we saw black lives matter you had a genuinely the first global moments where entire countries of people were coming together online socially and the you know it's a generational thing where by the sheer weight of people all visible all at once shouting all at once but it's not like it's not existed before and i think that basically the publishers weren't used to that they weren't you know they're not brilliant technically or technologically at the best of times um and so what what you start to hear when these views come out on twitter the the way that you know comms teams work is like just just just just appease that person it might only be two people um because of course you know twitter is only a very very small population you know percentage of the population x um but the the rationale is always just path of least resistance that's just a piece a piece keep it quiet because it feels like oh that'll all go away that'll go away but but going back to francis's point is there an arrogance here an entitlement well i i was quite struck recently by two things one is that despite the fact for example that the salt path was proven to be fiction how has the publisher responded to that i've done nothing they haven't said it's fiction they didn't put a sticker on it saying by the way this is fiction in fact it sold loads of copies and they made loads more money from it you thought maybe they would have like said oh look you know issuing a statement singles no no no haven't done that um and then it also you know inevitably we'll talk about the jason harday but you know the the the uk publishers still pursued the publication of that book as a work of non-fiction you know the u.s publishing team decided not to and the you know that's still available to buy as a work of non-fiction now look you know wherever you stand on that particular topic it's more that publishers almost can feel a little bit like maybe because it's a sort of a slightly more the tectonic industry.

54:00They're almost like, oh, we don't have to do that. But I don't know whether other industries would sort of be so happy to not adjust in that way.

54:09Francis Foster: Yeah, I think one of the things that happened, I think it's interesting what you say because technologically perhaps that was a key part of all of this where big corporates just suddenly would shit their pants because 30 people on Twitter got upset about something. And I think there was a massive over-indexing of... online sentiment converted into real action in the real world from people who really, really didn't need to panic over this kind of thing. And I don't know if that's adjusted now or not. Perhaps people have kind of worked out that a bit of a social media storm, as you say, may actually be a good thing, and certainly not a terrible thing and not a catastrophic, destructive thing, which I agree in the sort of 2020 moment would have felt very real to a lot of people.

55:00No, I don't disagree with any of that. But I still keep coming back to the fact that the people were feeling very discombobulated at that moment and that they were feeling lost and that obviously they wanted to gravitate towards movements and things where they felt par or something. Particularly at a church, you know, they're not actually going into the office and realising that people who are not of their age group and not of their generation are actually okay. They're just in their little mad sort of bubbles. But I guess it's the continuity, because I actually think right now, politically, it's actually quite a nice moment, because you've got Labour and the Tories standing for different things.

55:37And like, for the first time in these party conferences, you've got, you know, Kemi Beynok stands for sort of old school, traditional conservatism. And then you've got Andy Burnham, who's standing for, I guess, in some ways, sort of standard labour values and that's great but the problem is is that publishing is still here in this identitarian madness where there's only one way to think and that's all about you know some of the big issues of the time critical race theory it's like okay it's always a little bit behind but it's a long way behind actually that the world's moving into some very clear spaces right now and that's good i think you know again we're starting to see that when things feel a bit amorphous politically uh people don't really know how to think because they just go to the loudest noise um whereas yeah the the i think we're in a situation where um the industry is behind the sentiment of what's happening in the uk do you think what they really need is to just feel the hit financially and then that's the moment they'll wake up like what has happened to a lot of movie companies like a lot of what's happened to people like disney etc etc and go we can't keep doing this critical race theory stuff.

56:45People aren't buying it and we I mean, look at the bank balance. Well, look, it's hard to do a net P &L on all the books that were acquired in the madness of 2020 onwards. Because one would suspect that they are hemorrhaging inordinate amounts of money. Because always with publishing, there's always a moment an unexpected moment which offsets it all. And that moment was the YA explosion, almost a category between adult and kids. And it's basically soft porn. And again, do I agree with it? I don't really know. But we know that the readership likes, rather than visual porn, they like essentially narrative porn.

57:27So they're women. I'm just kidding. The market's being sustained, right? The market's being sustained. And if you look right now, Now, every single, if you look at where employment's taking place in the market, the categories in which people are actively recruiting for, it's into a category which is essentially just dishing out soft porn. So my issue is that not only are we censorious, we're bringing the main crux of the people coming into the business are of a certain sort of preference. What's the long-term effects? Of course, I'm worried a little bit about the commercials of the here and now.

58:04What I worry about more is the necessity of having cross-spectrum views being published, making sure that all types of people want to love and read books in the future, and that includes boys as well as girls, and create an environment where, as I say, the only thing that really matters to me is, is this place creative? Can we debate and argue and have fun, or is everyone really quite similar now? And as I say, having just done a time as a consultant and working for the publishers, it's quite difficult even though they're all different. But they're all the same. They're all the same. It's not like Nike and Adidas and On with slightly different marketing campaigns and strategies.

58:43Or it's literally you can close your eyes and you couldn't tell the difference between any of them.

58:47Francis Foster: Can I be slightly pedantic, may I? Yeah, go on. Dean, fact check me on this with Venice AI. You've both used the word censorious. I looked this up. It doesn't actually mean practicing of censorship. It means very critical. Really? Yeah. Dean will fact check me on this, but it's a word that people like to use because we talk about censorship a lot. Yes, you used it, yeah. But it doesn't actually mean practicing of censorship. Doesn't it? Yeah. So what is the word that means to practice censorship? I don't know. Is that censorous? Censorious, perhaps. Oh, no, no, no. No, we just said that. Is there a separate word, yeah, for censorious?

59:21Is it censorous?

59:22Francis Foster: Yeah. Maybe. Yeah. Well, anyway, this is a literary aside that will interest no one, but it interests me. Yeah. Dean? It's a really good topic that you're getting into there because of the people mistake mastery of the vernacular in publishing for mastery of the art. And so people know how what to say, but they're not actually thinking. This is this whole idea of, I mean, we can go on. If you want to talk about that, we can. But it's fascinating that people think they're really good at publishing because they're embracing the ideas which exist. They should be finally opposite to the ideas that exist because the market's going to change.

59:54There was this really funny moment in publishing Where about 2020, 2021 When all these woke books started to be published Obviously we had the big boy The big book Which was obviously White Fragility But you know like Ibrahim X. Kendi's anti-racist baby And all this stuff And you go, this is mental Didn't sell very much as well, oddly Shocking What's quite, I mean I'm scared to say this I guess but the one that sold really well was called We Are No Longer Talking to White People About Race. Oh, yeah. Why I'm No Longer Talking to White People About Race. But the takeaway from that is it's like the one book that's definitely appealing to white people, right?

1:00:37Why am I no longer talking to white people about race? Then you get the other ones, which are not as overtly title-led like that book. They're selling far, far fewer copies. um but yeah going back to the um going back to how publishing operates certainly uh you know the the use of the vernacular and the words and keeping it incredibly complicated is part of the strategy right the more convoluted it seems um i mean when you look at publishing contracts um you know for example you get a three-fifths royalty on um you know your tpb escalator or like this is like this is stuff that is you know it keeps out uh new ideas yeah posting is not a lover of innovation i'd say um but oddly it's on this particular aspect it's been um hungry for political change but maybe not for technological or systematic or any changes actually improve the you know the number of uh readers and participants dean yeah you're right of course i am of course i'm right

1:01:44Francis Foster: So there you go. Censorious means very critical. It does not mean the practicing of censorship. Oli, great to have you on. We always ask the same question before we go to questions from our supporters. What is the one thing that we're not talking about that we should be? Oh, that's a great question. I think the one thing we have to be talking about now is whether, and this is a difficult topic, whether there's genuinely anti-Semitism taking place within the publishing industry. Because I didn't know the answer to that question when I embarked upon this. But I've had some really quite scary experiences.

1:02:26I'm not Jewish. But the one thing that really struck me about building Highline was when I went over to New York, I spoke to a young female editor. She'd been an editorial assistant. and then she got up to editor her whole life she'd wanted to work for a big company a big publisher and it's her passion um she started to do really really well um started to acquire books her career was going forwards october the 7th happens suddenly she doesn't get invited to lunch anymore um suddenly the books that she brought to acquisitions don't get through acquisitions the ones that people even approve start to get smaller numbers so that it's much harder to buy them and so what you're seeing is that are we building an industry now which is more or less likely to buy some of the most iconic names in publishing your phillip roth's um even your larry david's but i worry that you know there's a group that's played a huge over sort of overly delivered for the industry i worry now that that group has been so ostracized that it'd be very very hard for us to discover those next big name authors.

1:03:33Francis Foster: Ollie, you've been a little bit cryptic for my... Are you saying people don't buy books... Publishing commissioners don't commission books by Jewish authors because of what's happening in Israel? I think that is the big question. And that one of the reasons why we set up Highland Publishing Studio is that we've got a dedicated imprint called Odessa Editions to create a safe home for Jewish and Israeli talent because people have been essentially culturally boycotting that talent as if it's going to make an impact on something far, far away, which some of these authors or talents might not even sit on a particular side of the argument, but they're just being cancelled slowly or sometimes overtly.

1:04:22And if I show you one example of that, So Ellie Shirabi, who was the hostage, or one of the hostages, of course, when that book was on sale, not a single UK publisher wanted to buy it. This was a hostage for October 7th? Yeah, but not a single UK publisher. Why? Well, because of the difference in worldview, the difference in ideology. In the end, a very small but brilliant publisher came to assist. They don't necessarily have the infrastructure to make it huge. but I thought it was very, very revelatory indeed. I've seen it before. I mean, don't get me wrong. Like 20-odd years ago, George W. Bush, his autobiography, he couldn't find a UK publishing home.

1:05:03In the end, it ended up at Virgin Books and it made me laugh, actually, if you read Tony Blair's biography, which, of course, did get a huge amount of support. He describes George W. Bush as one of the most credible, brilliant men he's ever worked with. And yet you've got George W. Bush's autobiography, couldn't find a home. So, look, it's always been there a little bit And so it might not be solely the Jewish question. However, I have witnessed what I think is not anti-Zionism, but anti-Semitism. And I say that as someone who studied anti-Semitism at university, and it's a horrible, worrying trend.

1:05:37Francis Foster: Sorry to... well, not sorry. To dig in a little bit, horrific as I think boycotting a hostages book from October 7th would be. From an ideological perspective, I can understand it because it challenges directly the worldview of the pro-Palestine people, the pro-Palestine worldview. So when you say you see anti-Semitism, I can see how somebody might boycott that book without being anti-Semitic, I guess is what I'm saying. Sure, sure, sure. Is there more to what you're talking about? Maybe I'll go back again to the experience of that individual. So a young female editor who is working through the publishing industry and finds that the comms within the industry, the people working with her, that the environment is becoming cumulatively so, so intolerant or so overtly supporting in one direction.

1:06:34It can only ever feel like something else in the other. I mean, this is why, you know, for me, I'm now working with Highline and I want to support Jewish writers and I want to support... Look, during World War II, there wasn't a single institution, whether it's a charity or whether it's a business that supported the Jewish community. We've got the chance to do that now when there's a similar sort of situation occurring. And what's happening is that I'm picking up brilliant staff and hopefully brilliant books because it's not a safe space. And I'm sorry to use that very weird term, but it's not a safe space for some of these editors, some of these marketers.

1:07:07And I can only as well sort of speak from how they're treated at a personal level rather than the theory. and from a personal level they are sort of saying look I need to leave the industry because I can't work in this environment any longer so hopefully they don't leave the industry they'll come and work with us

1:07:24Francis Foster: Well no business has ever gone bankrupt employing Jews so you're in No country's ever succeeded when it suddenly turns anti-Semitic It's always a bad sign for the country itself as well as Jews themselves of course Alright Oli thank you so much head on over to triggerpod.co.uk where Oli's going to answer your questions. We have got a lot of people asking questions about George RR Martin. When's a book going to come out? Are we just going to wait till he dies and then take the unfinished manuscript and somehow bashing a book out of that?

1:08:12At Farmers, we go out of our way to keep you in the know.

1:08:15Francis Foster: Like by singing everything for emphasis. That and by providing you with coverage on a page, an easy to understand language, so you know what's covered and what's not. No confusing legalese that no one gets. In full transparency, we do have to put a disclaimer at the end of this ad, though. Just being honest. That's what you get when you have Farmers. Bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum. Learn more at Farmers.com. Underwritten by Farmers Truck or Fire Insurance, exchanges or affiliate products not available in every state

From the publisher

Triggernometry is proudly independent. Thanks to the sponsors below for making that possible:

- Take Hillsdale College’s online courses for free at https://hillsdale.edu/trigger

- Take control of your cellular health today. Go to https://qualialife.com/TRIG and save 15% to experience the science of feeling younger.

- SHEATH: go to https://Sheath.com. Use code TRIGGERNOMETRY for 20% off

- Venice gives you the best AI models in one place. Private. Unrestricted. No lectures. Get 20% off your first month: https://venice.ai/triggernometry/oliver-malcom/2026-10-17

Join our exclusive TRIGGERnometry community on Substack! https://triggernometry.substack.com/

OR Support TRIGGERnometry Here:
Bitcoin: bc1qm6vvhduc6s3rvy8u76sllmrfpynfv94qw8p8d5

Shop Merch here - https://shop.triggerpod.co.uk/

Advertise on Triggernometry: https://trigger-brands.com | or enquire at [email protected]

Find TRIGGERnometry on Social Media:

https://twitter.com/triggerpod
https://www.facebook.com/triggerpod/
https://www.instagram.com/triggerpod/

About TRIGGERnometry:

Stand-up comedians Konstantin Kisin (@konstantinkisin) and Francis Foster (@francisjfoster) make sense of politics, economics, free speech, AI, drug policy and WW3 with the help of presidential advisors, renowned economists, award-winning journalists, controversial writers, leading scientists and notorious comedians.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from TRIGGERnometry

All episodes