Why Some Songs Work Onscreen and Others Don’t: Pitch Perfect, The Devil Wears Prada + Wednesday

15 Sep 2026 · 1 h 3 min · 30 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

How songs get selected and adapted for film/TV (and why some don’t), with a focus on collaboration between music supervisors, songwriters, and vocal/arranging teams.

Key claims

Don’t “narrate” the scene in lyrics (example: Devil Wears Prada). Song placement is feel-based and scene-specific (example: Pitch Perfect’s “Toxic” and acapella/arrangement needs). Collaboration is constant and also business/politics management (solve issues before escalating to studios).

Notable examples

“Toxic” chosen via audience recon; “Paint It Black” cello cue for Wednesday; Wednesday requests for cello/arrangement; Barbie TV needing label artists; KT Tunstall’s “Black Horse and the Cherry Tree” (via Julia) changing her life after being heard on Venice Boulevard; Bette Midler remote session during COVID.

Guests

Julia Michaels (pop songwriter; co-wrote “Good Luck Babe,” “Sorry,” “Cake by the Ocean,” “Believer”; film music credits incl. Pitch Perfect, Star is Born; also working on Girl Group). Alana da Fonseca (songwriter/producer/vocal producer/arranger and music supervisor; worked on Pitch Perfect films and TV/film; working on Rebel Wilson’s Girl Group; known for vocal production and arranging for on-screen performances).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Introduction to the Podcast

0:41 to 2:02

Justin Tranter introduces himself and sets the stage for a discussion on music and collaboration.

“you do it all from athletic to athletic sierra's got it the movie i wanted with devil wears prada the devil i had read the book i'm like this is my movie everybody get up out of the way this is my movie.”

Introducing Julia Michaels

2:02 to 3:00

Justin introduces his collaborator Julia Michaels, highlighting her impressive work in film and music.

“I create it with my friend Morgan Stewart over there.”

Introducing Alana Da Fonseca

3:00 to 4:47

Justin introduces Alana Da Fonseca, celebrating her contributions to various popular films and shows.

“I think we were trying to remember, we think we met on Alvin and the Chipmunks 3.”

Collaboration in Film and TV

4:47 to 7:01

Justin and his guests discuss the dynamics of collaboration in the entertainment industry.

“Okay, so just before I ask questions about both of your different careers and the amazing journeys that both of you have been on.”

Career Paths in Music Supervision

7:01 to 11:03

Julia shares her unique journey into the music supervision industry and its evolution over time.

“I mean, Pitch Perfect is one of the most successful music forward movies of the last 20 years.”

Navigating Studio Politics

11:03 to 14:00

Julia and Alana discuss managing relationships and expectations within the film industry.

“But the cool thing was, people say, how did you get to work on these big pictures right away?”

The Journey into Music Production

14:00 to 16:49

Discover how a passion for music leads to unexpected career opportunities.

“How was your dream always film and TV or how did you?”

Creative Collaboration in Pitch Perfect

16:49 to 19:07

Learn about the collaborative efforts in selecting songs for Pitch Perfect.

“If there's your favorite story, if you can say it, if you can tell.”

Behind-the-Scenes of Film Music Production

19:07 to 20:12

Explore the chaotic yet organized process of producing music for film.

“And it was just like a big three-ring circus for like a month while we prepped.”

Vocal Producing for Actors vs. Singers

20:12 to 22:55

Understand the different approaches to vocal production for trained singers and actors.

“I always say I wrote every song alone until I was 33.”
Show all 30 chapters

Working with Legends: Bette Midler

22:55 to 24:17

Hear about the memorable experience of recording with Bette Midler.

“How about when you recorded one of the best singers in the world, Bette Midler?”

Common Mistakes in Writing for Film

24:17 to 26:30

Learn key mistakes to avoid when writing songs for film and TV.

“So please do me just a cute little favor and follow this podcast and share it and do all those fun things.”

Navigating Creative Collaborations

26:30 to 28:00

Gain insights on how to effectively collaborate in the creative process.

“So like, it's not going to make it past her.”

Collaboration Dynamics in Creative Work

28:00 to 29:10

Learn how collaboration between creative partners fosters successful outcomes.

“No, I would say like I get really comfortable.”

Success Stories in Music Collaboration

29:10 to 30:50

Discover specific projects where collaboration led to notable successes in music.

“I mean, our text chain, like you and I text as fast, that's how we text.”

Cohesion in Soundtracks and Projects

30:50 to 32:25

Explore strategies for maintaining cohesion across diverse musical contributions in projects.

“Like having Jordan sing a song that I wrote was crazy.”

Navigating Creative Feedback

32:25 to 33:25

Understand how to give and receive constructive feedback in a collaborative setting.

“And obviously, Star is Born, Gaga's the cohesion.”

Managing Expectations in Music Creation

33:25 to 34:25

Learn how to balance artistic vision with the realities of project requirements.

“Yeah, I think I've been really lucky to find people in my travels who we kind of speak the same musical language.”

The Power of Music Supervisors

34:25 to 36:15

Examine the significant role of music supervisors in shaping successful films and soundtracks.

“How, what, if you don't mind walking me through that process of like, Like, okay, it has to be good because this is a talented person, but the character's younger.”

Personal Anecdotes of Career Breakthroughs

36:15 to 38:00

Hear impactful stories of personal breakthroughs in the music industry.

“A lot of times I'll strategize with my music editor.”

Memorable Moments in Music Choices

38:00 to 40:00

Reflect on memorable decisions made in music placement for films.

“Sometimes I'll be honest with them and say, look, I think this needs, I had this just, I had it happen on Prada.”

Manifesting Opportunities in Creative Work

40:00 to 42:00

Discover the importance of mindset and hard work in manifesting career opportunities.

“I mean, the KT Tunstall, that, that, you putting that song in there changed her life and also changed so many people's lives because they love that song.”

The Power of Manifestation and Collaboration

42:00 to 44:29

Learn about the importance of mindset in achieving creative goals and the collaborative process in music.

“And so that was just my vibe for the next week or so until they called me back and they were like, you're doing it.”

Transcribing Music: The Takedown Process

44:30 to 46:58

Discover what a music takedown is and the role of transcribers in the music creation process.

“Who do you have on speed dial to find out if something's cello-y?”

Navigating Hard Conversations in Music

46:59 to 49:26

Understand the significance of having difficult conversations in the music industry and how to handle them professionally.

“different rooms, different countries, different states.”

Learning Through Experience: Creative Feedback

49:27 to 52:31

Explore the journey of giving and receiving feedback in creative collaborations and the importance of honesty.

“Or if a songwriter, you know, gets fired in the middle, it's never their fault.”

Songs That Changed Our Lives

52:32 to 55:13

Reflect on pivotal songs and films that inspired a passion for music and performance.

“Do you remember the song that was like, oh, shit, this is my life now?”

Gag or Drag: Music Industry Opinions

55:14 to 56:00

Engage in a fun game dissecting opinions about common industry phrases and practices.

“Okay, to end every episode, we play a game called gag or drag.”

Gag or Drag: Musical Insights

56:00 to 59:58

Explore the nuances of music production and collaboration in film and TV.

“Morgan's going to think that that's a drag, that you hate it, but a lot of times it's a lot easier to just fix it in post than do like a six-hour vocal session.”

Advice on Collaboration in Creative Projects

59:58 to 1:02:04

Learn valuable advice on collaboration and serving a story in creative works.

“Okay, to wrap this up, if you could give all these gorgeous people right here and the people at home one piece of advice about collaborating on a movie or a TV show, what would that piece of advice be?”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Justin Tranter:Propel Fitness Water with Gatorade electrolytes, zero sugar, and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade electrolytes. Sierra has all the best active and outdoor brands for the super athletic stuff. Like running gear for cruising up the trail. Woo! And the super athletic-ish stuff. Like fishing gear for chilling by the creek. Nice cast. fitness apparel to push for higher reps you got this and golf balls priced so you can afford to lose one or a few head to sierra or sierra.com for the brands you want at the prices that let you do it all from athletic to athletic sierra's got it the movie i wanted with devil wears prada the devil i had read the book i'm like this is my movie everybody get up out of the way this is my movie.

0:53A big artist wrote a song that we just couldn't get there. It really wasn't landing. It could be the best song that you ever wrote. They're not saying it's not the best song you ever wrote. They're just saying it's not right for right here. Don't narrate the scene. I think that is one of the biggest misnomers for people that don't do it all the time. Yeah. You know, it's like you're storytelling, but you're not telling what's happening in the scene. We thought Toxic, but we're not the audience. So we started calling people and like, do you know Toxic? Do you Oh, yeah. And they're like, okay, that's going in.

1:21They were like, oh, can you arrange for cello? Oh, and the same thing happened on Pitch Perfect. They were like, can you do acapella? And I was like, yeah. And I was like, I don't know, but I'm going to go for it.

1:35Justin Tranter:I am Justin Tranter, pop songwriter. I've written a couple little ditties, like, co-written, let's be very honest. Co-written some ditties like Chapel Roan's Good Luck Babe, Justin Bieber's Sorry, that fabulous Cake by the Ocean song, Imagine Dragons Believer. The list goes on and on and on. But now I'm a podcast host. God damn it. Songwriters aren't getting paid. I got to figure out a different job. Kidding, kidding. Also not. I love this podcast. I create it with my friend Morgan Stewart over there. And we celebrate and break down the art of collaboration, the unfamous and untold stories about how your favorite pod, not podcast, how your favorite pop culture moments get made.

2:29Justin Tranter:Now, as someone who's very frequently a guest on podcasts, my least favorite part is like sitting there while the host just like lists your credits. so what we like to do since this podcast is about celebrating collaborators is you two are going to introduce each other and brag about your collaborator to the audience here live and also the audience at home who would like to introduce their collaborator first? I'll do it! Go for it! Okay well this is Julia Michaels not to be confused with Julia Michaels she has worked on I mean hundreds and hundreds of your favorite films music forward films like Pitch Perfect Star is Born and we're working on a film right now that's going to be one of your next favorite films called Girl Group starring Rebel Wilson and all of your favorite girl group icons from the last couple of decades we're very excited about it wait I'm on a tangent already but she has been amazing she has been a mentor and an amazing collaborator and i love everything about her julia michaels oh that's such a nice intro okay i'm going second but alana da fonseca i mean there's no alana has worked on all of your favorite television shows and movies a lot of things with myself, luckily, all the Pitch Perfect movies.

4:03Woo-hoo! I think we were trying to remember, we think we met on Alvin and the Chipmunks 3. Slay! Shipwrecked.

4:11Justin Tranter:Slay. She was like, you were in town for Sex and the City, and you came to my, okay, now I'm on a tangent, but she used to live in New York. This is the thing I say about Alana. Alana is one of the greatest songwriter and producers and vocalists for film and television. She used to be my secret weapon. It is not the truth anymore. She is everybody's secret weapon. She's done all the on-campus songs with Amanda and Anna. We are working on Rebel Wilson's movie that she directed called Girl Group, which is like pitch perfect with music. That will be your next favorite movie. We've done so many movies we can't wait to talk about.

4:46Alana da Fonseca. Alana!

4:49Justin Tranter:Okay, so just before I ask questions about both of your different careers and the amazing journeys that both of you have been on. Just for anyone here and anyone watching this at home, because you're a writer, producer, vocal producer, arranger, all these things. You, of course, legendary, legendary music supervisor. What does a collaboration look like between someone with Alana's 100 skill set and a music supervisor. What does that daily collaboration look like when you're working on a movie or a TV show? Well, I have a cool one that just kind of happened recently on a movie we're working on.

5:38And there was a song idea that was temped in this one place and it was kind of the preferred vibe from the director. And I kind of wrote something in that vibe and it wasn't really feeling right for the moment. And then Julia and I just had several conversations about it. I was like, I think it should be kind of like this song. I think it should have this kind of instrumentation. And she was like, yes, I feel that. And so we like kind of co-conspired to make the song that we felt was perfect for this moment. And I ended up lining up all sorts of videos to the demo to kind of show the feeling of the moment.

6:15And we sold our idea. And we sold it. Yeah. So this is an example on a movie we're working on where we had an idea that we thought was great. The director had a different idea. director is of note and we collaborated like she said and then she's like i have an idea i'm gonna put it to picture so we put it to picture i was like oh my god this is exactly what i'm thinking and we sent it to the director and she's like yeah this is a better idea so that was kind of came out of her brain but that's because we were both like we had the same sometimes we have the same brain yeah we hive mind yeah um and and justin on our sake most there are times when i bring alana onto a project, there's times where she's brought me on and sometimes we come on together.

6:54Cool. So yeah, it's, we always wind up together though.

6:57Justin Tranter:I mean, that's, it's, it's working. It's working. I mean, Pitch Perfect is one of the most successful music forward movies of the last 20 years. So obviously it's working very, very well. Okay. So thank you for giving everyone a quick tutorial of how you, people in your roles can work together but let's back it up for a second how did you both not only get into the business what was your start in the business but also like when did you even realize that the jobs that you have were jobs that someone could get well it's interesting that we're here and you're asking me that question here because there was no guild of music supervisors there when i came to la which a long time ago.

7:43Justin Tranter:Be proud of your age. Be proud of your age. Yeah, there was no Grammy U. There weren't programs and mentorship programs for people that wanted to be music supervisors. I came to Los Angeles. I didn't know it was a job. I wanted to be in the music business. Right. So I have a very weird path. It's a very long story, but I worked it. Give me the short version. I know your path because we are friends. We are besties. But people want to learn from you. So going way back, I was a gymnast, and a choreographer. So when I moved to Los Angeles, I was like, oh, the music business, I'm going to work in records and all that stuff.

8:18But prior to that, I was working for USA Gymnastics and I was cutting my own music and producing all the competitions you see on television.

8:24Justin Tranter:See, I didn't know this part of your story. Yeah, I'm going a little bit back. So I used to... That's why it's good to have your friends on your podcast. Yes, yes, yes, yes. So I used to produce the competitions. I used to get to choose what music I wanted to use. I got to cut my own music on cassettes. I was doing live television. Yes. Very in my young 20s. And then I wanted to do something bigger and I wanted to get in the music business. So to me, the music business was records. So I came out here not knowing what I was going to do. I drove, packed up my car with all my CDs, drove to L.A. And for non-super industry speak people, records means to work at a record label.

9:00Yes, correct. And so here I am in Los Angeles, not having any idea what I'm going to do. I started go-go dancing. That's true. My band was basically go-go dancing. It was. With a little bit of singing.

9:16Justin Tranter:It was. I did. I go-go danced at the palace, if anyone is around to know there. Yes. And I also taught aerobics and I taught gymnastics. And I was like, what am I going to do? And I went on an interview and I got a job with a film composer agent. Now, I never paid attention to the background music in a movie. I mean, I subconsciously did, but I didn't think somebody wrote that music. Right. And so my first job in the business was learning that someone actually composed that score. Wow. So that was my first industry job. Cool. Yeah. That's it. And then when did you go, oh, wait, there's this music supervisor job.

9:54Justin Tranter:I'm gunning for that. So again, long story, but I'll go short. So after working there, I worked at a composer studio. So I learned how to manage the studio from the composer side and the writing side. Then I went to Capitol Records and I was the soundtrack executive. And I was doing all these records with all these putting out soundtracks for films that 20th Century Fox was releasing, Universal Pictures. And then Fox said, we want to tap you to come over and be a music executive. So I walk in as the vice president of music. I have no idea what I'm doing. I didn't know what post-production was.

10:28Pretty fabulous title. I walk in there. and but that's where I grew up I say I grew up at Fox which is maybe where we met but um I learned about how a movie gets prepped what happens in production what happens in post production and that was sort of my music supervisor tutorial cool experience and then I worked at a couple more labels and one more studio and then I became independent so half my career was in-house and I learned how to supervise from doing jobs in-house yeah and then I've been independent since before my son was born, like 2006.

11:03Justin Tranter:Wow. But the cool thing was, people say, how did you get to work on these big pictures right away? Well, I worked in-house and I had relationships and I had a relationship with directors. So then when I kind of hung up my shingle, oh, Julia's supervising, let's put her up for a couple jobs because we know that she knows what she's doing because I had this experience in prior. Right. Right, which is very different from what happens today. People come to LA and say, I want to be a music supervisor. Yep. Then we know we can say, oh, you need to go work for a supervisor or why don't you become a friend of the guild or become a member of Grammy U or be a mentor of one of a mentee of one of us.

11:37So it's a different world today. Yeah. I sort of stumbled around.

11:40Justin Tranter:But what I like about that is that you really learned the business from different sides. Correct. But, you know, and we, even though they'll come out a week apart, it just happened in real time interviewing Amanda and Anna about how they both worked for lawyers and they learned about the business from a different side. And I think there's something, you know, I was in a band for 10 years and had multiple failed record deals, which I'm honestly very proud of. Like I learned so much about making music and about the industry from the artist side that when it was then when it was time to write with and for artists, I understood their world really well.

12:20Well, and I think one of the reasons I pride myself on being a good supervisor is I know what the studio needs to know and I know what they don't need to know.

12:29Justin Tranter:Yeah. You know what I mean? I know what to tell them things and when not to tell them things. Can you, can you, and then I promise I want, I'm going to hear about your journey, but this is really, I think there's something to learn here. If you're willing to share some of that information, because you, you know, if you want to gatekeep the information, I respect that. Well, I guess. But like, what's an example of something that a studio executive doesn't need to know? They don't need to know the problems that are happening behind the scenes until you want to bring them in for the solution. if Alana and I have an issue on a film and maybe you know there's something going on where people are disagreeing or we or we're trying to record an artist and that artist is a little bit difficult we want to try to solve that problem first before we alert the studio or the you know whoever's you're working for because then it really escalates you just want to try to solve it first you know it and you know when they're you know when they're going to I guess freak out about something and You know when they're going to say, okay, I know you guys got this.

13:26So it's more, we're managing our filmmakers, but we're managing the people also that are, you know, hiring us to work on these projects. It's like, you know, the double, the politics.

13:35Justin Tranter:That's very helpful advice. Thank you. Alana, how did you get into this? Because it's what I love, and I can't wait to become your friend and learn more, is that all of us start as wanting to write music or make music. And there's, you know, my first vision was I was going to be a rock star and then that didn't pan out. And so now here I am, thankfully, gratefully writing songs for other pop stars, you know, to sing. How was your dream always film and TV or how did you? No, I don't think I even realized it existed. Kind of like Julia, like you watch the things and the things is happening and you're just like, oh.

14:18But I knew I always wrote and sang and I wanted to go to school for engineering and production. Cool. So I went to college for engineering production. And at the time, I was the literal. Where'd you go?

14:30Justin Tranter:Fellow music school geek. SUNY Purchase. Awesome. Berkeley, Berkeley here. All right. Yeah. And I was the only female in the program. And then for many years after, I was also the only female engineer anybody ever really had seen. and I was I graduated from college and I kind of opened the yellow pages wow to music producers and arrangers or something there was like a category for that in the yellow yes that was literally in the yellow pages yes and I went like this it was a big book that had phone numbers in it and I went like this and I recognized a name and I was like okay I'll work there I sent them my resume faxed them my resume yes no wait i think it was actually email but um keep it at facts it's more entertaining keep it at facts but it had like a giant watermark of my head shot on the front behind all the texts like i don't even know what was wrong with me at the time i love it honey yeah why not with those cheekbones work it do it so um they hired me to intern right away and then like the funniest thing happened like the engineer went to siberia on like a month long vacation.

15:41Justin Tranter:If someone wrote that in a script of like, she gets her big break because the person above her moved to Siberia. You'd be like, that's too much. That's not believable. Take it out. And when he was gone, I kind of like settled in with everyone and everyone started liking me and realizing I could also produce. So they would give me like half finished tracks because these guys were like 10 to 20 years older than me. And they were like, she's cool. And slow. And that. She's the fastest engineer vocal producer I've ever worked with. So, yeah, you know, I was in there like wreaking havoc, by the way, on the studio.

16:15Like I was 21. I had like crazy hormones and I was just like, anyway, so but it was really fun. And then when he came back, it was jarring. And then they hired me. So so I started there and then Ali started working there and he did film and TV. This place was a place for ad music. and then I started doing work for film and tv which was like writing songs when they couldn't afford like but Justin songs that he wrote we had to write a lot of songs and that was really fun because sometimes it would be like over the weekend we needed to do 11 songs um whoa yeah like fully produced and everything and we would do it because well no wonder you're so fast well

17:00Justin Tranter:Okay, so for anyone who is trying to learn about both of the jobs you guys do, so you're working together, can you pick a pitch-perfect moment for me and break down, you get the script, it says, this happens with this song. How do the two of you work together? If there's your favorite story, if you can say it, if you can tell. Well, on pitch three, I remember me, Julia, Angela, Julianne, Elizabeth Banks, a bunch of people sat around at a table. We had the script there and Trish, I think. And there weren't songs in the script. So we were figuring out. Song spotting. Like a musical. Yes. Yeah, exactly.

17:46We were like, OK, this goes here. What about Toxic for the opening? Wouldn't that be funny? And on Toxic, when we came up with Toxic, we called Julianne's niece and said, do you like this song? Do you know this song? and they're like, we know the song. Okay, it's going in the script. Oh, wow. Yeah, we did a little like recon.

18:02Justin Tranter:Walk through the thought process on that to make sure young people would connect to it. Well, we had to find the right song for that scene and we wanted a song that was old enough that was cool but the people that young still knew it. So we thought Toxic, but we're not the audience. We're not the one. So we started calling people and like, do you know Toxic? Do you know the song? Oh, yeah. And we're like, okay, that's going in. But it was feel-based because you know that movie starts out with this kind of spy vibes And I was like, obviously toxic is the vibe. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then, and it sort of panned out that way.

18:32And then the girls would, oh, this would be perfect for this moment. We, that, I, there, yeah, that just continued to happen until the end. Freedom was kind of like a hard, a hard one. Freedom was a hard sell. Yeah, I mean, going just to the Pitch Perfect movies, even in the first one, which Alana came on a little bit later on, everything was a placeholder. So for a music supervisor, it was Jason Moore, the director, julianne my partner you know who i do all the movies with elizabeth banks we were in a room really from page one to page 120 deciding what the songs were going to be because story driven i don't even know if anything that was in the script wound up in the movie because we wound up okay what are we going to do here and we are playing things for jason he's like i know exactly what i'm going to do i know what rebel's going to do there i know exactly like it was we started from the beginning cool and then of course we have to bring in the arrangers to arrange the songs for acapella right because not every song sounds good acapella right and and we had a bunch of arrangers on our movies that alana collaborated with as well because it was such a big project and you know it's like a three-ring circus the songs are coming in you're deciding what you're going to use and then alana would move i'm jumping way ahead but we would we would build what we call the boot camp and so we'd all go to set and the girls would go from record we would build a studio and And Alana was in the studio recording the girls and the guys on some of them.

19:53And then they'd go to choreography. Then they'd go to wardrobe. And it was just like a big three-ring circus for like a month while we prepped. So we have been in the recording studio on set together on all these projects. You know, we work like this, you know. And that's why we can be successful. I couldn't do it without her.

20:11Justin Tranter:Yeah. I mean, collaboration is, it's, I, when people are afraid to collaborate, I always say I wrote every song alone until I was 33. And I didn't make a dime until I was 34. Like collaboration changed my life. And it's in film and TV, the level of collaboration makes pop music look like a joke. Like the amount of people involved. Talking about, just because you mentioned recording everybody in Pitch Perfect, but it doesn't have to be Pitch Perfect. any anything you know so much of what you do is vocal producing for people who are actors first singers second how do you approach is your approach different when you're vocal producing someone who's a singer singer versus an actor singer yeah definitely I mean I would say in general I'm all feel based anyway so um but yeah of course somebody who's like a super trained singer i was just working um with lauren allred and she can literally do anything and i'm like okay more in the mask or that you know whatever she knows all the terminology you have to tell her that you know what i mean but yes so when you're working with an artist who's a trained singer you can you can direct them in a certain way but working with an actor sometimes who's not even a singer at all right when we did a film with an actor um who just didn't sing and i would say crazy things to him in the booth to try and get him to loosen up first of all because it's nerve racking to sing when you're not really a singer and you know you i'll sometimes clear the room yep you know so that it's just a little bit for people who don't understand so you know sometimes in a recording session for a film you'll have directors and producers and everybody wants to be there especially if it's a super a-lister who's singing and everybody wants to be on there and like give it and and that can be really nerve-wracking to be performing in front of all of these people and I feel like when it's just me and the actor there's such a it's just an easier to to unwind them into a space where they can take huge swings and not worry about first of all everybody's worried about their voice cracking right and I'm like I love it I'm like I'm like if your voice cracks I love it because that means you're trying something that's not necessarily comfortable for you and that's how we get to that next level so like I think for me also because I also engineer and produce so I'm I know what I have I'm taking like a mental tally while they're singing and I'm like okay I can tune that I can time that I can do this I can do that do I have the emotion?

22:40Yeah. I just spiked the camera sorry guys and when I have it I have it and that's it so directing an actor who isn't necessarily a singer is really about comfort I feel like that's what it is just like nurturing them into a space where they can try anything. Yeah. And I have a contrary to that. How about when you recorded one of the best singers in the world, Bette Midler? Shut up. Oh, my God. What? Yeah. Okay. Okay. So I'm working on a movie where Bette has to sing. And, you know, I got introduced. Is this movie out? It's, yeah, it's out. It was called The Fabulous Four. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.

23:19And I got introduced to Bette through Mark Shaman, who I'm very close with. A legend. And so Bette paid attention to me because, of course, Mark's her favorite. Mark said, be nice. She goes, oh, honey, you're family. You're family now because you know Mark. So I was like, who can I bring in? And it was remote because they couldn't, it was a smaller movie. And it was COVID. They couldn't afford to fly us to Savannah and it was COVID. And I'm like, who can I ask the famous Alana? Because Alana makes even actors that can sing that are nervous because she hasn't done it in a while. She said she was nervous.

23:50They also think, Justin, that they're used to like training and singing for weeks and weeks on a record.

Read the full transcript

23:56Justin Tranter:Yeah. One hour. Right. And she was like, I'm done? That's it? I'm done? Yeah. She was so shocked, and she was lovely. It was just me and you and her on Zoom. Wow. But, you know, Zoom was hard. She's not used to Zoom. She also didn't get any training, and Alana, it made the whole thing, like, a pleasant experience. And that was kind of like one of those moments. Oh, that's bucket list moment. Hello, my little unfamous friends. so um the thing about the algorithm little miss algorithm is that she um doesn't want to let people know about our podcast unless she thinks that people love it so if you follow this podcast what do the old school youtubers say like subscribe and follow um if you do that for me then you will help the unfamous message of the beauty of the art of collaboration reach more people.

24:48Justin Tranter:So please do me just a cute little favor and follow this podcast and share it and do all those fun things. Bye. Super bucket list moment and I gotta say like she, again she was saying like back in the day when she was recording there was a machine called the Russian Dragon which I'm, by the way obsessed with this, I have like a fake band that is now called Russian Dragon. There's a piece of gear called the Russian Dragon? The Russian Dragon you guys because if you were Russian it would drag you and if you were dragon it would Oh, wow. That's so brilliant. I totally forgot that. I can't with that information.

25:25Justin Tranter:That's really good. But she was perfect. She was like perfection, absolute perfection. All of her inflections were amazing. I was like, oh, my gosh, you're such an original talent. Yeah. So, yeah, that was a super honor. I had to call Lana for that because who else would I call? Yeah, I mean, of course. Okay, Julia, you do many, many jobs. I pretty much just do one, which is write songs. give us songwriters, give us a tip. What is the biggest mistake people make when trying to write for film and TV? I mean, an obvious one is, you know, writing exactly what's happening in the scene. Explain, explain.

26:06Yeah, so when you're writing for film and television, a lot of people think, oh, there's a woman and she's walking across the street in Devil Wears Prada and there's a car passing. and we know so they write oh you know i'm walking across the street in my high heels like don't send a song to me that say i'm walking in my high heels don't narrate the scene via lyric that's the way to say it yeah essentially is don't narrate the scene i think that is one of the biggest misnomers for people that don't do it all the time yeah you know it's like you're you're storytelling but you're not telling what's happening in the scene yeah so i think that's that's very helpful information yeah i think that's and you know you learn that you know when your song gets rejected because it didn't work and i actually try to give feedback if it's someone that i know okay this is why it didn't work or you know or you know your the vocals are too hot in the mix so can you you know it's not laying in the scene right can we mix it differently there's all kinds of feedback yeah but i think the one is like don't narrate what's happening yeah exactly

27:01Justin Tranter:what what is we we're a new podcast but people there's a rabid fan base and they they're here to learn if you're willing to share what is the biggest mistake that you've made writing for film and tv not not producing specifically a writing question is there a story that you can share with us you're like i can't believe i did that but i'm so glad i learned from it you know from a writing standpoint no because because you're perfect if you mess it up it's not going in oh right then it's just done yeah because there's like all these checks and balances along the way. So like, it's not going to make it past her.

27:40And if it makes it past her, it's not going to make it past the next guy. So like, no, I mean, writing wise, like.

27:47Justin Tranter:You can do producing then. If there's anything that you think that you like. Fumbled. Fumbled and now you know not to fumble like that. You know. I already love it. I think it's really just like what you say in front of who. That's my biggest. That's very helpful information. And I'm going to push. I'm going to Barbara Walters you. I want to learn more from that. No, I would say like I get really comfortable. Yeah, she does. And so I'm just like offering, you know, I'm always offering my opinion and solutions and all that. Don't do it. Don't do that. It's not your job to fix everything. But here's the thing.

28:26She can do that more than I can do that. Explain. So Alana is the creative, giving her opinion, doing that. And I might say, you know what, Alana, I have an idea. and I'll like pivot the conversation a little bit. So the director will maybe be a little bit on board with what you're saying, but kind of take you out of the hole. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Make sense? Yeah.

28:45Justin Tranter:Walk me through it. Cause this is very, I think it's very helpful information. Yeah. Well, I mean, it's, it's a, it's a play of like, who should this come from? Correct. And how's it going to land the best and give us the best result? You know? So we do work together. I think this should come from you. How many times do you say that to each other? This should come from you. She says that a lot. This should come from you. This should come from you. Yeah, we do. we strategize about that i mean that i think is such an underrated part of collaboration right so much of what we talk about in collaborating is on the creative side which of course we're all watching movies and tv shows and listening to records because we love the art but to get the art across the finish line the business collaboration is for better or worse just as important it just and how do you how often in the roles that you guys play how often are the two of you calling each other to strategize business stuff?

29:36Every five minutes. Sometimes several times a day, yeah. I'm not kidding. I mean, our text chain, like you and I text as fast, that's how we text. Yeah, yeah. You know, it's all the time. And Alana's, like, she's very fast, but she's sometimes got her head down. And so I'll wait till she, you know, surfaces, and I'll say, okay, we have to do this, this, this, and this. And she'll say, okay, you call so-and-so about this. I'll call so-and-so. You know, we just keep collaborating. It's like you said, you want to get your art across the finish line. and also in collaboration the whole project's a collaboration it's never our final decision but we just want to present our idea in the best light that it has the best chance and if they shoot it down they shoot it down yeah you know but then we know it got a good shot what is the

30:17Justin Tranter:proudest moment that you you have together of something that you collaborated on art wise but business wise that you actually got if you can name it if not tell me to fuck off and I'll move a new question. Well, something that was really amazing for me was on Barbie, which was the project I was working on. And they wanted to pull in the series, not the amazing movie was they wanted to pull in named artists through these songs. And I was like, I need Julia. And she came and she hand delivered me like Jordan Sparks, who's one of my favorite voices ever to sing one of the songs. Like having Jordan sing a song that I wrote was crazy.

30:58Taylor Parks. And then the collab with Taylor Parks was insane. Like she's such a brilliant. Legendary songwriter and singer Taylor Parks.

31:05Justin Tranter:Songwriter, singer, producer. Also actress in hair as a child. Everything about her is amazing. Like we were Zooming and she was like, okay, take all the snares out. I was like, yes, ma 'am.

31:18So yeah, that was super amazing. Well, that was an example where she brought me on on a project. Yeah. Because they wanted, and she's like, you got to get Julia. And I was like, okay, I know some people that are not on labels.

31:29Justin Tranter:Yeah. Because the Barbie universe, the TV show, they have some strict rules. So it's hard to get people that are on labels. So Alex, who do I know that was singing her amazing songs? And they were like, I'm in. Yeah. You know, because the songs are great and they want to be associated. And that was fun. Yeah. That was super fun. Yeah. I was lucky enough to write a song with Gaga for Star is Born. And my question is for both of you, when you're working on projects where, of course, for Star is Born, Gaga's co-writing all of it. So there is a through line. There's a serious through line, and the through line is one of the most talented people of all time.

32:10Justin Tranter:But on a movie, TV show, whatever, where there's a lot of writers, producers, blah, blah, and you both have to find a way to make this cohesive. What is your game plan to pull that off? And obviously, Star is Born, Gaga's the cohesion. It's not the best example. That's like an anomaly example. Yeah, yeah. But what, you know, in so many soundtracks that we all love, there are, forget about how many hundreds of people it took to make the movie. To make the soundtrack is so many people. What is the game plan to make this all cohesive? Well, we can talk about Girl Group because you had collaborators on all the original music.

32:50And maybe talk about your history with them. Because you work with them a lot. Because of this movie called Girl Group. It is going to Toronto, which is great. Rebel Wilson directed it. Congratulations. And it's super cute. And Alana wrote all the original songs. But the premise of the movie is they're singing Girl Group hits. Right. Okay, that she also arranged and recorded. But she has collaborators. and it's interesting because you bring in these people that write with you and there is a through line. I mean, you're in the center of it, but you have like three, some are like a little more comedy songs, but that's a huge hit.

33:23And she just brings these collaborators that sort of know your style. They get how you work. Yeah, I think I've been really lucky to find people in my travels who we kind of speak the same musical language. And I mean, you know, when you speak the same language as somebody and you're just like, something like this. and they're like, oh, I know exactly what you mean. And they like grab you out of the ether and ingest it and vomit it out. It's really kind of a beautiful -

33:50Justin Tranter:Love it, love it. What's happening right now? But yeah, so I do. And there's, you know, I think that's an interesting question. And on girl group, everything is kind of cohesive. It's girl group songs. Rebel had some lyrics in the script that I turned into like really ridiculous, you know, 90s girl group songs. But Off Campus is a really good example of something that's all over the place, right? You have, you know, the band songs, you have the singer-songwriter song from when she was in high school that has to be good, but not too great. And, you know, and then you have - Yes, I want to, if you don't mind me pausing.

34:25Justin Tranter:Yeah, yeah, yeah. Morgan wrote a question about that. And so you just brought it up. So I'm going to push on it. How, what is that balance? Yeah. How, what, if you don't mind walking me through that process of like, Like, okay, it has to be good because this is a talented person, but the character's younger. She's not really at her best yet. What do you do? I mean, like, I channel my younger self because I was writing songs at that age, and they were not horrible. Like, I thought they were, my mom thought they were great. But, I mean, it was just, like, a lot of really verbose, like floral language for one in her high school song that was like you know done well but also just didn't have a concept of how to make it make sense so like the whole song kind of has this it just grows builds and builds and builds and builds and it doesn't really like have levels and then it comes back down and does the same thing so it's like I it's good people like the song but but i think it's definitely reflective of that period of her life yeah yeah that's also like i feel like sometimes like the music supervisor correct me if i'm wrong you're kind of you're the a and r of the album it just has a different title yes yeah it's actually really great because alana said if she writes a song and i get it and i'm like huh um i'm not sure about this song can we change this and oh yeah i get that and see alana is so receptive and doesn't take anything personally which i think is why she's really successful in this space yeah because she's writing not for her own music she's writing about she's like okay i got i have another idea yep oh wait i have another idea okay let's change it's like super receptive to feedback you're serving the script you're serving the director it's it's a it's a job job it's a really cool job yeah but it's a job job i don't mind saying to her that i don't think this is right for the scene or can we try something else she's like yep i got you now when you obviously the reason you guys keep working together is because you're perfect when you have for people trying to learn of how to not fuck up what when you give notes to a writer producer ranger whatever title they're they're working on that moment and they can't take the note how do you if you can't fire them if they can't take the note they're gone well here's what i do she calls me i call you no but you know what I'll do if I get that feeling like they're not going to take a note well I'm like okay you do what you want to do and then I just take the material and then I let the director speak for this it then it's I kind of take it out of my lap and let maybe I'm wrong maybe I do feel maybe this is not maybe this is really what someone might be looking for but chances are I'll let that come back you know the director didn't love it or the producer doesn't love that you know and then I I just let them do their thing because I don't want to insult anybody and you know some people like I said film and tv is a different a different world yeah how do you if you're bringing something to a director and you know it's not right but you don't want to sabotage in case you have it wrong how do you protect yourself in that conversation or you just let it happen um yeah because you don't want them to think that I have terrible taste in what I'm setting them right now like like I know this doesn't work but that is a really good question.

37:49A lot of times I'll strategize with my music editor. I'll say, can you cut this song? But can you cut this other song in and say that I like this song better?

37:57Justin Tranter:Yeah. You know, I do try to, you know, I don't want to look bad. I don't want to present something that I don't think works. Sometimes I'll be honest with them and say, look, I think this needs, I had this just, I had it happen on Prada. I won't say who, but somebody wrote a big artist, wrote a song that we just couldn't get there yeah but i had to i mean it was a big artist and i totally respect the songwriters it was great but it just it really wasn't landing and i was kind of protecting it from it i didn't want to showcase i felt like it was better it just didn't get there yeah and i showcased i like no yeah i knew that was going to happen but i tried i tried so hard yeah the both both of your credits are so insane and i'm sure you get asked the same question the main question i get asked is

38:47Justin Tranter:what fights did you have to fight to get the first big break and you guys talked about your first jobs and your first ways in but is there a specific story you can remember like i need this yes yes so you guys heard my story when i became independent luckily i had some relationships that they put me up for movies but the movie i wanted with devil wears prada the devil i had read the book. I'm like, this is my movie. Everybody get them out of the way. This is my movie. So Justin, this is back in the day when we made CDs. So I'm like, I'm making my CD at home. I, I made, I put Vogue on it. I put Vogue on the CD.

39:26I walk in there. There were two other people that were meeting on the movie. I'm like, do I wear my Pradas to the meeting? Do I not wear my Pradas to the meeting? It's like when I met with Tom Ford, I'm like, do I wear my Tom Fords? Um, so I was like out of the way. This is my, and I just walked in there so fierce. And I was like, I sat down there and I got the job and cut to 20 years later. That was my seventh movie with that director. But I just knew I wanted that job. I love the book. I'm like, this is, this is, I know I can do a great job here. It was only my third movie as an independent, but that's kind of what put me on the map.

39:57Justin Tranter:I mean, the, the beautiful power that music supervisors have. I mean, the KT Tunstall, that, that, you putting that song in there changed her life and also changed so many people's lives because they love that song. Changed my life. Yeah. Changed my life. How does that make you feel watching that song become a phenomenon because you put it in a movie? Well, you know, it's interesting. We're very good friends, KT and I. Oh, really? Oh, cool. And at all her shows, she's like, there's Julia, she changed my life. Like, she says that. And I say, you changed my life. And we both got interviewed when this movie came out about that whole moment and how I found the song.

40:40and it was just really cool. It's just one of those zeitgeist moments. You know, it happens not often, but that's one that... How did you come across the song? I remember exactly where I was when I heard it. I remember where I was in my car on Venice Boulevard. Someone at Capitol had sent me an unreleased KT Tunstall album and I heard it. I'm like, this is the song. This is the opening song.

41:02Justin Tranter:You already had the scripts. You already were working on the movie. We were in the edit. Oh. We were in the edit. Deep in it. And I called David Frankel and I said, this is the song. Wow. And it's happened a couple times in my life. And boom, it went in. Wow. Have you ever stopped at that spot on Venice Boulevard and taken a picture? No, but it's like I get a feel. I think you should do it today. I remember what car I was in. And I remember exactly. It was a CD, people. Like, I put the CD and I'm like, oh, my God, this is a song. So. Wow. That is a great, great story. Can you remember a job that you fought hard for and it changed?

41:34So I think for me, it was like less fighting, but I really wanted off campus. I met with Amanda. We had never worked together before, but we had always like kind of peripherally. Well, no, that's not true because she was on pitch. So we had kind of peripherally worked together on Pitch Perfect. And she told me what it was about. And it was literally the thing that I had been trying to manifest into my life. And I was just like, I want it. I need it. It must be mine. And so that was just my vibe for the next week or so until they called me back and they were like, you're doing it. And I was like, yes.

42:11But I think that that like having your mind in that mind frame of like, I must have it, like not asking for it, but just knowing that it's yours. Yeah.

42:22Justin Tranter:Yeah. I mean, I think, you know, there's the Internet loves to talk about manifestation, which I think is important. But if the insane amount of hard work doesn't come with it, it doesn't really matter, you know. But with creating, you've both together and separately have worked on projects that have such specific sounds. Wednesday is such a specific world. You know, if you don't mind sharing your thought process. I mean, because obviously the world of off campus and the world of when, those are different literal planets. Yeah. You know, like. Well, I think I've also kind of grown up in a weird way with music.

43:06My musical journey, like, I grew up in a Brazilian jazz house. My dad's a Brazilian jazz musician. My stepmom's a Brazilian jazz singer. And I kind of grew up, you know, going to Jobim's house at his piano, being, like, listening to the band practice. And my dad toured with Astro Jouberto. So it was, like, at her show. You know, so I went from that, yeah. And then, like, discovered that I was in a punk band, playing drums in a punk band. And then I, like, got really into heavy metal and, like, you know. So then, you know, and then it was hip hop. Like I transitioned from metal to hardcore to hip hop, which was like an obvious transition.

43:44And and then got into pop. And I don't know. I love it all. So like for Wednesday, for example, they were like, oh, can you arrange for cello? Oh, and the same thing happened on Pitch Perfect. They're like, can you do acapella? And I was like, yeah. And I was like, I don't know, but I'm going to go for it. And same happened with with with Wednesday. I'm going like this because it's cello. So anytime I talk about cello, I go like this.

44:09Justin Tranter:I thought you were driving. It's the bow, you guys. So yeah, for Wednesday, they're like, can you do this? But I think that's what we're talking about, collaboration. It's like, I'm always going to run something by someone who is an expert. Even though I want to bring my perspective to it, I'm going to be like, is this cello-y? You know? And they're like, yeah, actually. So that was cool. Who do you have on speed dial to find out if something's cello-y? So on that, I called this girl, Essin, who had been doing Essin. Yeah, she's lovely. She had been doing a lot of notation for me. So she'd been transcribing all my takedowns and stuff.

44:46I would just send it to her. She's actually still in my phone as Essin Transcribe. To back down.

44:51Justin Tranter:So just for anyone who is trying to learn about these amazing jobs you guys have, what does transcribing a takedown mean? because also I just finished a whole animated movie musical that you helped me get. I've never heard a takedown. I don't know what that means. So teach me. So a takedown is when you send a piece of music to someone who just has to notate it by ear. So there's no like MIDI going along with it or anything going along with that that would help them. So they just do it all by ear, which is wild. And so she was doing that. So she has a crazy ear. She went to Berkeley also. So slang for just transcribing by ear is a takedown.

45:28Justin Tranter:Yep. Yeah. There we go. Love it. We send those out. We send out music to our copyists and they do a takedown. If we don't have an essence. Yes. Yeah. So she was, yeah, she was my guy. And then I was like, hey, you want to work on this? Can you put this? Because I gave her the MIDI that was all piano. And I was like, can you put this in a cello and do whatever you want? Yeah. And that was the first time that we had collaborated creatively. And she did it and it was awesome. Cool. And they loved it. And then Chris Bacon. it was like actually funny Chris Bacon who's the composer for the show I think what happened was this whole scene was playing out as a solo moment solo cello and then like 11 hours before they recorded the orchestra Tim Burton was like I want score on this like underscore this and Chris did it and like and then recorded it the next day with the orchestra and I heard it for the first time seeing it I think they sent me a clip and I literally threw my phone across the room because it was so good.

46:27I was like, oh my God.

46:29Justin Tranter:Do you know what scene it is so we can edit this together? It's where she plays Paint It Black on the cello. Morgan wanted me to ask about Paint It Black and you did my job for me. There you go. Yeah. So I didn't know Chris at the time. We basically met when we were nominated for a Grammy together. Shut up. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But yeah, we met and then we were like, wait, we're identical twins. We're best friends. Nobody would think that because he comes off really serious, but he's not. He's like, we're doing karaoke in the car together. It's weird. It is interesting in our jobs of like how certain things can happen in different rooms, different countries, different states.

47:06Justin Tranter:I, one of my favorite songs I ever got to co-write was Halsey, Bad at Love. And wrote it in the room was me, Ricky Reed and Halsey. But the track that we were writing to, Ricky Reed had made with a producer, amazing producer writer named Roger and didn't meet Roger for like, seven, six years after that song. I ran into him in an airport, but see him on Instagram. And I was like, hey, we have a hit song together. It's so nice to meet you. Yeah, yeah. I think something that people don't talk about enough in terms of collaboration is the very hard conversations. And would love for you guys to shed any light on some hard conversations.

47:51Justin Tranter:You don't have to name names and how you got through it. And one thing I will say is you're so good at it. I, speaking of like really wanting a job, I don't know if you remember this. I called you because I'm a Hunger Games super fan. Anything about the world ending, I love it. I'm in. And I've read every Hunger Games book. And so I knew there was a movie coming where a character was a folk singer. And then it was announced that you were the music supervisor. and I was like, I'm going to call her right fucking now. I don't care. This has to be my job. And you were like, I love you so much. No one's ever heard you write a folk song.

48:35Justin Tranter:And I was like, I can do it. And you were like, I love you and believe in you, but there's a lot of people involved and they're going to want someone with a folk track record. And I just respected that so much. You didn't go, let me make some calls. You were just like, I love you. and I'm going to let you down right now, this is not your job. And that is how you handle it. Because if you would have then given me a wishy-washy answer, I would have called you six more times. It would have been awful for me, too. It would have been awful for you. Yeah. Well, that's a skill that I've learned over the years.

49:10Justin Tranter:That's why I like to talk about it. So tell me about the journey of learning the hard conversation. Well, I would say at Fox, as a music executive, I had to fire people. People get fired. I shouldn't say I fire. And I always say when someone gets fired on a movie, it's never their fault, right? If a composer gets fired, it's because a producer and they don't get along and the producer's a scapegoat. Or if a songwriter, you know, gets fired in the middle, it's never their fault. It's circumstantial. And when you're a young executive, you take everything, oh, my God, I have to call this person or the supervisor didn't get the job and I have to tell him they're not getting the job.

49:43Then you realize it's not personal. so if you come from a loving place yeah and a supportive place of that person and you say this is why this is not happening you know don't let it crush your dreams in a nice way then it becomes easier yeah um but it is a skill you have to learn at the beginning it's hard to make those calls but i feel like i've gotten better just i've been doing it so long yeah and plus when there's people like you that you know that i love you and like i'll tell you the truth you know and you'll tell me the truth so um it becomes a little easier but it's hard do you think the only way is just practice

50:14Justin Tranter:You just have to do it. I think so. I mean, I think that's, you know, it's like I've had directors at the beginning, like make me cry in a scoring stage when I was young. And I'm like, that would never happen today because I'm like, I don't care what you think. You know what I mean? But when you're young and you're starting out as a supervisor, you know, you're navigating this big, wide world. Yep. And you want everyone to like you and you want to come off great at your job. And it's hard, you know, and and and there's also like we're kind of we're kind of Switzerland. but all the creatives out there have personalities and egos and you have to learn how they operate.

50:45Justin Tranter:Yeah. Have you, I mean, obviously you're, you're so accomplished that people as the creative, people have to have hard conversations with you, but you're in charge of departments and you're in charge of teams. And how have you learned to have the hard conversations? Yeah. I think like for me, when somebody comes with me, comes to me with like something critical, like if they're not liking something, like Julia said before, I don't care. I'm like, cool, let's make it what you want it to be yeah done um and then when i'm collaborating with someone who's kind of not getting it that's i mean i i'm not really that diplomatic so i'm always like julia you you do this one no but like but that's smart though for you to know that that's not your strength it's not my forte i'm just like i don't like that i can't turn that in like that you know what i mean so and then we fix my job yeah that's my job protect her and keep her clean yeah i love that i mean I love that.

51:36Yeah, yeah. I shouldn't be allowed to talk to anybody. But, like, the people that I collaborate with, they're used to me. Like, you know, so I'm just like, I don't like how that goes. But I also, by the way, on Girl Group, that whole final song that we're not going to talk about because the movie's not out yet. I was working on it with Ethan, one of my collaborators, Ethan Roberts. And he did this, like, re-harm that was so jarring to me. And we're both very honest with each other. We're just like, I don't like that.

52:04Justin Tranter:For any non-music geeks, Reharp means changing the chords underneath the melody. Yeah, it was so weird to me when I first listened to it. I was like, this is terrible, man. I don't know what you were thinking. Put the original chords back. And then the next day I listened to it again, I was like, you are brilliant. What was I thinking? And he was like, that's the first time I ever heard a woman say you're right to me. And I was like, and the last, my friend. No, I mean, I feel like creatively. Do not get used to it. Don't get used to it. but I think that's important too to like always take a second listen and like just make sure because once your brain is in a certain place with a song and you're used to it that certain way of course it's going to feel weird I'm on a whole other planet right now we ask this question of almost every guest do you remember I like to call it the song that ruined your life the song that you heard as a fan as a young person and were like oh fuck I have to work in music make music, work in music, dance.

53:04Justin Tranter:Obviously, you were a dancer. Do you remember the song that was like, oh, shit, this is my life now? I remember the movie. Even better for your career. Perfect. Well, two movies. Okay. I'm so like, you guys know me for an hour. Fame and Flashdance. Fame and Flashdance. I mean, those are two of the best music forward movies ever. I mean, those movies changed my life. It's like I have to be around, do something. I mean, the emotion. I knew all the dances and flash dances. What's your favorite song from fame? I'm more of a, if I had to pick one, I'm more of a fame girl over flash dance. So let's geek out on it for a second.

53:44Well, I mean, The Body Electric. Of course, The Body Electric. The Body Electric.

53:47Justin Tranter:If you have a soul, The Body Electric is one of your top ten songs. I mean, you know. Yeah. I mean, they're all so great. They're so good. But The Body Electric. Me too. It was probably the one I listened to the most. I sing The Body Electric for like every audition for a good seven years. Yeah. Oh my God, if I could sing. I mean, I can't really sing either. You can just decide that you can. Alana, do you remember the song that ruined your life? Yeah. Or album or? I think, you know, for me, because from Brazilian music, I went into musical theater. I was like a New York City theater kid. And Phantom of the Opera, stop.

54:27Stop. Just stop. Stop. And then after that, like weirdly, one of the most emotional experiences I had with a song was Nothing Else Matters by Metallica.

54:37Justin Tranter:Uh-huh. And it was like - Honestly, very similar to Angela Weber's stuff, though. Angela Weber's a huge metal fan. You can hear it. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. We know what we're talking about. We sure do. And Nothing Else Matters, I was like mourning the loss of a friend who had died in a car accident. And I just remember being like, oh, this is important. This song is important. It's getting to a level. It's like unfurling this grief in this really interesting and important way. So I would say that is a big one. Fianna of the Opera and Metallica, fame and flash dance. You guys both gave very good answers.

55:15That was the easiest question so far. That was very, very good.

55:18Justin Tranter:Okay, to end every episode, we play a game called gag or drag. If you don't have a lot of gay friends, I'll explain this to you. Gag means you love it. Drag means you hate it. Okay? And if, because we're all professionals here, if you need to say meh because you can't commit to a love or hate, I will allow a meh because we're in a professional setting. Okay, okay. Okay, gag or drag someone saying, we'll fix the vocal in post. Gag. That's my job, guys. That is total gag. I love it. When I, Morgan writes these questions, and when I read that, I was like, what I love about that is I think Morgan's going to think that that's a drag, that you hate it, but a lot of times it's a lot easier to just fix it in post than do like a six-hour vocal session.

56:10Justin Tranter:Okay, gag or drag. Gag is you love it. You love it. Yeah, gag is good. Yeah. Gag or drag, an actor decides on, sorry, Morgan, I'm butchering your question. Gag or drag an actor decides on shooting day that they'd like to change the key. Gag. Because guess what, guys? Gag if I have her. You just throw that thing in your pitch shifter and everything goes up. It sounds weird. I actually changed the key one time on the day after we had recorded like for hours. I was like, you know what? You guys sound weird there. I'm going to pitch it up a fourth. No. I pitch it up a fourth. Gag if I have Alana. Drag if I don't have it.

56:48Okay, great.

56:51Justin Tranter:Oh, I love this one, Morgan. Gag or drag? Can we make this sound more expensive? Oh. Drag. That's obviously a drag from Julia. That's a drag. I mean, like, I mean, I like a challenge. Ozone 11, drag. Drag, drag. We don't like it. For me, it's a drag because I'm like, I don't know exactly what that means. And also what you probably mean is you just want it mixed. Mastered, yeah. It will be. Yeah. Okay. But it is, people say that a lot. Okay, gag or drag, a songwriter completely ignores the brief and accidentally writes something much better. Gag. Gag. Oh, my God. That's brilliant. Gag or drag, a celebrity cameo turns into three original songs and six more months of work.

57:43Justin Tranter:Are the songs good? Morgan, you wrote the question, are the songs good? It's up to you. Are they? Let's say they're bad. Oh, major drag. Major drag, major drag. Gag or drag movie musicals where every character suddenly sounds like a flawless recording artist? Major drag. Drag, drag, drag. Big time drag. You got to have the real, you got to have the cracking. You got to have the cracking. You got to have that emotion. Yes, you have to. It can't sound overproduced, even though we've done those movies and some of them work. No. Yeah. Gag or drag karaoke with people who are professionally good singers?

58:20Major gag. That is my life, you guys. I have competed. She has gotten me to do karaoke, so gag.

58:30Justin Tranter:Gag or drag, somebody singing every word directly into your ear at a concert. Drag. Big drag. I almost got into a fight at a Fiona Apple concert for that one. Drag. Are you? Drag. Oh, yeah. Singing like that at a Fiona Apple concert is crazy. Okay. Gag or drag, a terrible movie with an incredible soundtrack. Gag. I love it as a fan it depends on the movie I mean gag at the soundtrack for sure yeah yeah true gag at the soundtrack if you can get through the movie oh right that's a good point because for you if you kicked ass on the soundtrack but then no one saw the movie not good that's a big drag big drag you're right I was just thinking as a fan yeah you just like wasted a year of your life I just did exactly did I get paid good point good point gag or drag The temp song is so perfect, everyone knows you're, but everyone knows you're never going to be able to afford it.

59:26I mean, drag, major drag, if we can't afford it. Yeah, because, you know, you work for about six weeks before they even pay attention to anything you're sending them.

59:34Justin Tranter:Yeah, yeah, that's a big drag. As the songwriter getting asked to beat a temp song when you know the director specifically is obsessed with the temp. Here's the solution. Don't be the first one that tries to be to be the 10th one because then they're exhausted. They're exhausted and they've let go of their wish. And you're like, oh, something comes in. You go, oh, my God, I love this. That is great advice. Be the 10th one in. And I'm using it tomorrow. Okay, to wrap this up, if you could give all these gorgeous people right here and the people at home one piece of advice about collaborating on a movie or a TV show, what would that piece of advice be?

1:00:16Justin Tranter:And if it's something you already said, please repeat it. Because I think that if there's something that you've learned that you really wish you would have learned sooner, it's worth saying twice. That I would say that you want to work with people that have better ideas than you do. I mean, better is a weird word, that have different ideas than you do. Because you can't do it all by yourself. It's not going to be a success if you do it all by yourself. Bring in people that you can talk to and bounce ideas off because it will elevate what you're doing for sure. I really love that you changed it to different ideas.

1:00:49Justin Tranter:I think that that's such a looking for collaborators that do something different than you, that think differently than you is such an... Because everyone just wants to like, of course we want to have a good time at work, but you're there to accomplish something major. And for you guys, film and TV is so much more expensive than pop music. that like you're there's high stakes and like bringing in people with different ideas is a really great piece of advice I love that and I would say um know that you're serving a story first and then you know the directors are showrunners and producers um but it's not about you really so if you write something that's not right for the moment like you really have to not come into that with any ego, not be offended.

1:01:38Like it could be the best song that you ever wrote. They're not saying it's not the best song you ever wrote. They're just saying it's not right for right here. You know, we had that experience one time on Trolls. I wrote a really cool song and they were like, and it was like literally my favorite. It got used the next season. So like, it's really just not about your heart in that moment or your skills or your ego. Yeah. I love that.

1:02:03Justin Tranter:Thank you both. Thank you. So much. That was so fun. Big round of applause for Alana and Julia. You can louder. Come on. Come on. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:02:20Hello.

1:02:21Justin Tranter:Hello. Everyone's favorite part of every podcast where we say, please follow and subscribe to this podcast, wherever you listen. so you don't miss future conversations. And also, pretty please take a cute little second to rate the show. It's one of the biggest ways you can support us. See you next Wednesday.

From the publisher

What makes one song perfect for a scene while another, even a great one, just doesn’t work?

Justin Tranter sits down with music supervisor Julia Michels and songwriter, producer and arranger Alana Da Fonseca to break down the judgment behind the music in Pitch Perfect, The Devil Wears Prada, Wednesday, Off Campus and more.

They get into testing whether “Toxic” would still connect with a younger audience, knowing instantly that KT Tunstall’s “Suddenly I See” belonged in The Devil Wears Prada, reinventing “Paint It Black” for cello, and why writing for screen means serving the story instead of protecting your song.

Along the way, they unpack taking notes without ego, navigating directors and creative politics, and why the best song you’ve ever written can still be completely wrong for the moment.

Credits:

Unfamous is hosted by Justin Tranter
Created by Justin Tranter & Morgan T. Stuart
Produced by Justin Tranter & Morgan T. Stuart
Written & Researched by Morgan T. Stuart

Director: Morgan T. Stuart
Co-Director + Cinematographer: Olivia McCrary
Audio Engineer: Mike Sabri
Camera Assistant: Kolbi Samantha

Special thanks to Mark Beavan, Jimmy Knehans and the Guild of Music Supervisors.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Unfamous with Justin Tranter

All 35 episodes
Why Some Songs Work Onscreen and Others Don’t: Pitch Perfect, The Devil Wears Prada + WednesdayUnfamous with Justin Tranter · 1 h 3 min
Listen in VO