Jennifer Harris

0:00This episode of Voices for Justice is sponsored by Shopify. I think most people have a dream of starting their own business, but what they don't tell you is that you're going to be wearing a lot of hats and that your to-do list is never-ending and always growing. Finding that right tool that not only helps you out, but simplifies everything can be a game changer. For millions of businesses, that tool is Shopify. They're the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world, like Mattel. They also help you build your online store with hundreds of ready-to-use templates. They can even help you write product descriptions, page headlines, and enhance your product photography.

0:38And marketing, they've got that covered too. You can easily create email and social media campaigns wherever your customers are scrolling or strolling. If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify. Turn your big business idea into with Shopify on your side. Sign up for your$1 per month trial and start selling today at shopify.com slash justice. Go to shopify.com slash justice. Shopify.com slash justice.

1:13Voices for Justice is a podcast that uses adult language and discusses sensitive and potentially triggering topics, including violence, abuse, and murder. This podcast may not be appropriate for younger audiences. All parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Some names have been changed or omitted per their request or for safety purposes. Listener discretion is advised. My name is Sarah Turney, and this is Voices for Justice.

1:46Today, I'm discussing the case of Jennifer Harris. When 28-year-old Jennifer Harris went missing on Mother's Day in 2002, rumors swirled in the small town of Bonham, Texas. And all eyes were on two men. One was her ex-boyfriend and business partner, and the other was her ex-husband, who she'd recently started seeing again. But nearly 23 years later, between odd witness statements, missing evidence, and a pretty strong conflict of interest, residents of Bonham and Jennifer's family are left baffled and frustrated by her case. This is the case of Jennifer Harris.

2:28On Mother's Day in 2002, Jennifer Harris was visiting her friend, Christy Farr, when, at about 8 p.m., she abruptly left. She basically just said that she had to go, without providing an explanation, and didn't tell Christy where she was going or who she was meeting. The next day, on May 13th, Jennifer's 2000 green Jeep Wrangler was found abandoned on Country Road 2610 near Lake Bonham. It's definitely a more rural area, but also down the road from a local music spot called Lake Bonham Hoedown. So it's rural, but Bonham is also just a really small town, with about 10 ,000 residents. So it's not like it's in the middle of nowhere.

3:09Obviously, her Jeep was found pretty quickly. And when deputies from the Fannin County Sheriff's Office get to the Jeep, nothing really appears to be wrong. There's no evidence of a crime or a struggle, the vehicle just appears to be abandoned. so the scene is not secured. Deputies get in her jeep, look around, and call for it to be towed. This is really how her family discovers that Jennifer appears to be missing. Again, it's a small town and word travels fast. So Jennifer's younger sister Alyssa decides to take a look around Jennifer's place. Well, their grandmother's place. See, Jennifer and her ex-boyfriend slash ex-business partner, James Hamilton, broke up about two months prior.

3:53They were living together in the Dallas area, but Jennifer moved back to her hometown of Bonham about six weeks prior for a fresh start. Or so it seemed. When Alyssa peeks around Jennifer's room, she sees Jennifer's wedding album open like she'd been going through it, and she finds a video of her sister's wedding in the DVD player. Alyssa didn't know it yet, but Jennifer had been seeing her ex-husband, Rob Holman. And as Alyssa continues to look around, she finds something even more shocking. A pregnancy test kit with one test removed and a bottle of prenatal vitamins. Jennifer was pregnant. Now, to make sense of this, we need to go way back to how Jennifer got to this point in her life.

4:37Jennifer was raised in Bonham, Texas, as was Rob Holman. He was about a year younger than Jennifer. Some sources say that they began dating as early as 4th and 5th grade. but Alyssa says it was closer to 7th and 8th. Jennifer and Rob continued dating all throughout high school. But Rob didn't distract Jennifer from her educational aspirations. After high school, she moved about three hours away to attend Stephen F. Austin University, where she obtained her bachelor's degree in biology and her master's degree in kinesiology, wellness, and nutrition. Jennifer was incredibly intelligent and ambitious.

5:14About three years into Jennifer collecting her agrees, Rob decided to follow her and move to the same area. They continued dating, and in 1996, they had their dream wedding. Alyssa says it was meticulously planned. Jennifer had the huge wedding dress and said her vows at a beautiful mansion out in the country. It was perfect. About a year later, unfortunately, Jennifer and Alyssa lost their mother to cancer. It's something Alyssa says Jennifer never fully got over or processed. In 1999, Rob and Jennifer bought their own home together in the suburbs of Dallas. But unlike their perfect wedding, this was not the perfect life that they dreamed of when they exchanged their vows.

5:55Rob worked in landscaping and really wanted to move back to Bonham, while Jennifer was embracing a new lifestyle in the city. She became extremely interested in holistic healing and enrolled in massage therapy school. Her dream was to start her own clinic someday. And at that school, she met a man who shared the same dream, James Hamilton. At this time, James was living with the mother of his first child with a second on the way. It seems that it's around this time when Jennifer and Rob's relationship really began to crumble. Jennifer's father, Jerry Harris, says that when he went to visit Jennifer and Rob, he became extremely concerned when he found what appeared to be five holes punched into their living room wall by Rob.

6:40And Jennifer's sister Alyssa shared another concerning story in her interview with 48 Hours. She says that one night Jennifer called her and her voice was shaking. She said Rob came home drunk and forced himself on her. In October 2000, Jennifer and Rob got divorced. Rob moved back to Bonham, and James moved in with Jennifer. From here, they created their dream business together, Stonely Massage in Dallas. but things didn't go as planned. James wanted to marry Jennifer, but she refused. It was a really rocky relationship and ultimately the business failed, forcing Jennifer to file for bankruptcy since all the loans were in her name.

7:23Basically, it was the worst case scenario. In about two years, her business and new relationship both failed. And it's around this time that Jennifer tells her cousin Susan that she's been seeing her ex-husband Rob, who at this point was dating someone else. Susan is not happy about this, and when Jennifer tells her that she's planning to move back to Bonham, she immediately suspects it's so that she can be closer to Rob. Now, Jennifer's sister Alyssa doesn't seem to know all the details that Susan does. Jennifer knew that Alyssa didn't approve of Rob for obvious reasons, so Alyssa sees Jennifer's plans to move as a fresh start.

8:03She says Jennifer began applying to new jobs and was looking at possibly moving out of state to somewhere like Colorado so she could spend more time outdoors. But then Jennifer found out she was pregnant. Alyssa doesn't find out until after Jennifer goes missing. But we know this not only because of what Alyssa later finds in her room, but also because Jennifer told a friend, Jill Wagner. Jill would later tell investigators that Jennifer confided in her about the pregnancy and told her who the father was. It was Jennifer's ex-husband, Rob Holman. This message is sponsored by Greenlight. Money is this invisible thread that ties us all together.

8:44It's something everyone has to deal with. That's why teaching kids about money isn't just smart, it's essential. Greenlight is a debit card and money app for families. It's a safe way to teach kids and teens about money. With Greenlight, parents can send money quickly, get spending notifications, and even assign chores. Greenlight turns responsibility into real-world learning. Kids and teens learn how to save, invest, and build money confidence. Skills that can really make all the difference in their future. If I had Greenlight growing up, maybe I would have learned that money is a tool I could use for my future.

9:18Not something to fear or fall for. Not to mention the magic of compounding interest. Give your kids the financial education many of us didn't get. Join millions of parents already using Greenlight, the number one family finance and safety app. Start your risk-free Greenlight trial today at greenlight.com slash justice. That's greenlight.com slash justice to get started. Greenlight.com slash justice.

9:48When it comes to what your family eats and drinks, you know your choices matter. You're the expert because you know what fits your life. And getting it right starts with good information. That's why America's beverage companies are sharing more information about our ingredients at goodtoknowfacts.org. No spin, no judgments, just the facts straight from the experts for more than 140 beverage ingredients. Visit goodtoknowfacts.org. When 28-year-old Jennifer Harris went missing on Mother's Day in 2002, there were many searches for her near where her Jeep was found and in the surrounding areas. Her father, Jerry, spent day and night searching for her as well.

10:32He says that around that time, he got about three to four hours of sleep at best and spent the rest of his time driving around anywhere he could, specifically keeping an eye out for buzzards in the area. And within about 48 hours of Jennifer going missing, what appears to be crucial evidence is found. Fannin County resident Jack Atkinson finds a set of keys. Now, I can't stress enough that this is a small town, and things work a little bit differently than we've seen in other cases. Jack doesn't call the sheriff's office to pick up the keys. Instead, he tells two deputies having lunch at a cafe south of the Red River Bridge that the keys would be hanging on his porch for them to take his evidence.

11:14It seems like he found the keys, hung them up, and when he saw these officers, he brings it to their attention as maybe a clue in Jennifer's case. And when he gets home, the keys are gone. He assumes all is well. Now, Jennifer's dad, Jerry, catches wind of this discovery. And from the description, he believes the keys are a match to Jennifer's. So he goes out to the area to look for himself. And here he finds a shirt, jeans, and a bra that he also believes are Jennifer's. These items are taken by the Fanning County Sheriff's Office and sent off for testing. What doesn't get tested are the keys.

11:52According to the Fanning County Sheriff's Office, they never got them from Jack's property, and they were never admitted into evidence. Where they went is still a mystery to this day. Of course, while they are physically searching for Jennifer, the Fanning County Sheriff's Office wants to speak with her ex-boyfriend and her ex-husband. They conduct these interviews about 72 hours after Jennifer went missing. When they speak to her ex-boyfriend, James Hamilton, he denies seeing Jennifer on Mother's Day. He said he was over an hour away, and can prove that he visited a McDonald's near the time that she left her friend's house.

12:28Two witnesses also confirm James' story, and he passes a polygraph. Rob Holman's interview goes very differently. He admits that he was seeing Jennifer and said that they had sex about four to five times since Christmas, the last time being in February. But this doesn't seem to be the last time he saw Jennifer. He also mentions meeting up with her near a local drive-in about a month earlier. He says this is when Jennifer told him that she was pregnant with his child. He tells investigators that he offered to pay for an abortion should Jennifer want one. And as far as the day Jennifer went missing, Well, he says that Jennifer did call him to meet up.

13:08It was Mother's Day, she was pregnant with his child, and she wanted to see him. But Rob says that he refused. He had plans with his current girlfriend. So he says that he never met up with Jennifer. It's unclear who this girlfriend was, or if Rob and her really did have plans to see each other. She's mostly been kept out of the public eye. But Rob does say that he has an alibi for when Jennifer went missing that night. so again around 8 p.m. He says he bought some beer and drove around on country roads for five and a half hours. He also expresses concern to the investigators that he doesn't have anyone that can confirm his whereabouts.

13:51He says he bought the beer with the intention of drinking with his friends, but when he drove to their house, they weren't home, so he decided to just drive around and drink instead. Again, no idea where this girlfriend is But outside of not having anyone to vouch for his alibi, there was another issue Investigators confirmed with Rob that he didn't leave the county or the state He just drove around the same area And that's pretty crucial because Fannin County is a dry county Meaning on a Sunday, when Rob says he bought the beer, it would have been illegal for anyone to sell it to him Now, of course, it is possible that someone sold it to him under the table or that he bought it in some other roundabout way, but it's a red flag.

14:36And the rest of Rob's interrogation was as equally confusing. At first, Rob says that he did see a Jeep driving around, but wasn't sure whose it was. But one investigator pushes a little more and asks, where'd you see her Jeep? Rob explains that he and Jennifer were at the same intersection, and it was clear that she'd been coming from town. But he says that Jennifer turned one way and he turned in the opposite direction to avoid any drama. So Rob knows that Jennifer is pregnant. She wanted to see him on the day that she went missing and he does see her, but he does not engage. He apparently just keeps on drinking and driving until he eventually goes home.

15:20Now, like James, Rob also agrees to take a polygraph test. but it's never administered. According to the sheriff at the time, after obtaining a lawyer, Rob rescinds his offer. And I also think it's extremely worth mentioning that one of the investigators who spoke with Rob during this interview was married to his aunt. So we have conflicting statements, a conflict of interest, and not a soul to confirm Rob's alibi. But it's not enough to make an arrest, so he's let go Then, just a few days later, on May 18th, Jennifer's body was found Fishermen on the Red River found Jennifer She was face down and completely nude Unfortunately, her body was very badly decomposed So they weren't able to conclude much, not even a manner of death but her cause of death was determined to be homicidal violence.

16:20Her right eye was swollen and bruised and her uterus was missing. The small town of Bonham, Texas buzzed with gossip. Of course, all eyes were on Rob Holman, her ex-husband. Rumors that he and his girlfriend killed Jennifer and her unborn baby spread throughout town. But pretty quickly, this sensational story was put to rest, when experts concluded that Jennifer's uterus wasn't cut out of her body by her killer, but instead was likely eaten by turtles in the river along with other parts of her body. It's unclear how long she'd been in the river, but it was long enough for decomposition to set in pretty heavily and for creatures to get her.

17:04Whether or not testing was done for the pregnancy hormone HCG is unknown, but in the end, they weren't able to find any forensic proof that Jennifer was pregnant. Jennifer Harris was laid to rest on May 24, 2002 in her family plot. And really, not much happens to move the case forward. All eyes were still on James Hamilton and Rob Holman, especially after they both did some odd things and made some strange statements in the next few months or so. On June 20th, James Hamilton called Jennifer's father to ask about a$2 million life insurance policy he thought Jennifer had. The beneficiaries were supposed to be James and their shared business.

17:48But the policy doesn't appear to have existed or had since been terminated with the bankruptcy of the business. So James never gets any type of payout. He just essentially creates a potential motive for murder. But this also doesn't really go anywhere. As far as these initial investigators are concerned, James Hamilton is in the clear. His alibi checked out. Now let's talk about Rob. After Jennifer's remains were found, Rob asked Jennifer's family for her Jeep and her laptop. He offered to take over the payments on the Jeep, saying that he just really liked it. But they refused. He said something similar about the laptop, that he just really liked it and wanted to buy it.

18:33but that had been taken into evidence by the sheriff's office. So more red flags from Rob Holman, but again, nothing happens. There's no arrest, and nothing progresses in her case. In 2003, another rumor is swirling around Bonham, Texas. People around town are saying that they know who killed Jennifer, and it wasn't her ex-husband or her ex-boyfriend. They say it was the local district attorney, Miles Porter, who killed Jennifer. and that he was covering it up because her case was under his jurisdiction. Typically, I don't like to bring up random rumors in the cases I cover, especially when I know that they don't go anywhere.

19:15Investigators say that Miles Porter didn't kill Jennifer Harris, and Porter says that he'd never even met her. But this rumor effectively killed his career, which is why I'm bringing it up. In a 2018 interview with 48 Hours, he said that local residents were mad at him, so he thinks that they fabricated this rumor. He says it cost him his position as DA after he was not re-elected. He went into private practice after that, but he said that even 15 years later, people refused to work with him due to the rumors. So I just wanted to be a part of helping clear up this bit of misinformation. But that same year, 2003, a witness came forward with information that may be credible and could change everything.

20:03When did making plans get this complicated? It's time to streamline with WhatsApp, the secure messaging app that brings the whole group together. Use polls to settle dinner plans. Send event invites and pin messages so no one forgets mom's 60th. And never miss a meme or milestone, all protected with end-to-end encryption. It's time for WhatsApp. Message privately with everyone. Learn more at whatsapp.com. It's Hulu-ween on Disney+. Watch frightful family favorites like Hocus Pocus and Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas on Disney+. I am the Pumpkin King! Then take the terror to ten with a thrilling new remake of The Hand That Rocks the Cradle, Scream, and more with Hulu-ween on Disney+.

20:47All these and more screaming this Halloween season with Hulu on Disney+. Bundle subscription required. 18+. Select Hulu content via Disney+. Additional content on Hulu app. Terms apply. Visit DisneyPlus.com slash Hulu for details. One year after Jennifer Harris was murdered, a new witness named Deborah Lambert comes forward. She says that she and her mother were driving across the Red River Bridge on Mother's Day in 2002, and they saw something. She says they saw three men, two in jeans and one in shorts, restraining a young woman with reddish-brown hair by her elbows. It matched Jennifer's description, and she says that the woman looks scared.

21:25She recalls her mother turning to her and saying that that woman was, quote, fixing to get raped and killed, end quote. Deborah says that they didn't notify law enforcement because they were afraid to get involved. But after seeing a news report about Jennifer near the one-year anniversary of her murder, she put two and two together and came forward. At this point, the Fannin County Sheriff's Office presents Deborah with a photo lineup. And who does she pick out as the man who was absolutely restraining the woman that day? None other than Rob Holman, Jennifer's ex-husband. But there is one discrepancy.

22:03Deborah is sure that she saw this happen around 5 p.m. And remember, at that time Jennifer would have still been at her friend's house. She didn't leave until 8 p.m. Now, it's only a three-hour difference, so it does feel entirely possible that she was just off on her time. So investigators follow up, they reach out to Rob Holman, but he tells them that his lawyer advised him not to speak with them. So this is another potential lead that just sits. Around this same time, the investigation into Jennifer's case is officially suspended, pending more evidence. The reasons cited for this suspension are no specific cause of death, no credible witnesses, no physical evidence, and no link to any particular person as a suspect.

22:49Her case, again, seemingly just sits. In 2006, we do see some movement again, though. Fannin County Sheriff Investigator George Robinson tells the media that Jennifer's case was not closed and will never be closed until it's solved. There are also some news articles stating that Jennifer's family was pushing for Fannin County to ask the FBI to be involved in the case. See, the Red River where Jennifer was found is right along the border of Texas and Oklahoma. Her autopsy was actually done in Oklahoma. So since this murder seemingly possibly crossed state lines, it would fall under the FBI's jurisdiction.

23:29But as far as I could find, they are never brought in to look at the case. There's also a quick mention of evidence in Jennifer's case being sent to a Florida pathologist, but what was tested and any results are unclear. Now, Jennifer's family hasn't given up hope. They've hired a private investigator to look into the case and in 2009, this PI reaches out to the sheriff's office saying they want to retest the clothing that Jerry Harris found back in 2002 and the sheriff's office says that the clothing cannot be located. But after some digging, it turns out that the clothing was there at the department.

24:08It had just been mislabeled. The results of this testing, if any, have not been disclosed. In the end, we don't know if this clothing belonged to Jennifer. I know, I hate saying it probably as much as you hate hearing it. But as we'll learn, not only has this department kept a lot of information close to the vest, it seems that a lot of things just weren't documented. But really, it's around this time that Jennifer's case is reinvigorated. Whether it was just time passing or pressure from this PI, we don't know. But they start looking into the case again. Specifically, Lieutenant Daryl Parker from the Fannin County Sheriff's Office becomes involved.

24:48And he's determined to solve this case. He has a plan. He wants to talk to Rob Holman again. And he picks a very special day to do this. Mother's Day, 2010. The 8th anniversary of Jennifer's murder. On that day, he drives to Rob's house and knocks on the door. He doesn't really formally interview him, though. Instead, he shows Rob some pictures of him and Jennifer together, and some of just Jennifer. And as Rob is flipping through these pictures, Lieutenant Parker says Rob stops on one picture for a bit longer than the rest. It's a photo of Jennifer in muddy water. It's not evidence, but it definitely piques Lieutenant Parker's interest.

25:32After this short interaction, he basically tells Rob to call him if he wants to talk about the case. And Rob actually calls a few hours later. He says he wants to talk. Lieutenant Parker is excited. He knows it's a rare chance to speak with this man. And he wants to make sure it's recorded. So he asks Rob to come down to the station the next day so they can talk there. In his 2018 interview with 48 Hours, Lieutenant Parker has tears in his eyes. saying he knew he messed up, that he regretted not going out to Rob's house to interview him right then and there, because the next day, Rob comes to the station with his lawyer and denies all involvement in Jennifer's case.

26:14He even says he didn't believe Jennifer was pregnant and didn't believe that she thought she was pregnant either, basically that it was just a lie to get him back. Now, I want to pause in the timeline for a second and say that Jennifer being pregnant is a really good example of circumstantial evidence versus physical. Though there is an argument to be made that further testing could have been done, the medical examiner found no evidence to prove that Jennifer was pregnant. But we know that Jennifer told at least one friend and Rob that she was, and her sister Alyssa found prenatal vitamins in her room, and evidence that she likely at least took one pregnancy test.

26:53So take that for what you will. A state prosecutor once told me that the difference between physical evidence and circumstantial is just what you can prove. If you go outside and see that the ground is wet and the surrounding houses and vehicles are covered in water, how do you prove that it rained without seeing water fall from the sky? Either way, this did seem to move things along. That same year, the Fannin County Sheriff's Office asked Jennifer's family for their blessing to exhume her body for further forensic testing, And they agreed. Lieutenant Parker told NTXE News, quote, We believe these additional examinations could be crucial in proving elements of our case.