Samantha Sperry

0:00This episode of Voices for Justice is sponsored by Shopify. When I started this podcast, I really did have to figure it out all on my own. Scripts, setup, filming schedule, logos. It was and still can be super overwhelming. When you're starting off with something new, it seems like your to-do list grows every day with new tasks. So finding the right tool that not only helps you out but simplifies everything can be such a game changer. For millions of businesses, that tool is Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10 % of all e-commerce in the US.

0:38They help everyone from huge brands like Mattel and Gymshark to brands just getting started. They truly can help in so many ways, like getting started with your own design studio. They have hundreds of ready-to-use templates to help you build a beautiful online store to match your brand's style. And they can help you get the word out like you have a true marketing team behind you. You can easily create email and social media campaigns wherever your customers are scrolling or strolling. If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify. Turn your big business idea into with Shopify on your side.

1:13Sign up for your$1 per month trial and start selling at shopify.com slash justice. That's shopify.com slash justice. Shopify.com slash justice.

1:54We'll see you next time. I'm Slasko Pilot.

2:00Voices for Justice is a podcast that uses adult language and discusses sensitive and potentially triggering topics, including violence, abuse, and murder. This podcast may not be appropriate for younger audiences. All parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Some names have been changed or omitted per their request or for safety purposes. Listener discretion is advised. My name is Sarah Turney and this is Voices for Justice.

2:33Today I'm discussing the case of 25-year-old Samantha Sperry from Graves County, Kentucky. She was last seen alive on March 27, 2018 when she went four-wheeling in the woods. Samantha's family calls and texts her phone, but it's off. The witness who last saw Samantha describes their interaction in a way that doesn't really make sense. This commences her family's unrelenting search for Samantha and the truth. This is the case of Samantha Sperry. Samantha Sperry was born Samantha Rose Jones in the small town of Murray in western Kentucky. She's surrounded by family from the very beginning. Her mother Tina, her aunt Amanda, and her father.

3:17Eventually, Samantha's joined by her little sister Kimberly and her little brother Tyler. As a toddler, Samantha is headstrong and enjoys playing dress-up like most kids. Her interest in grown-up items doesn't stop there, though. In a recent Facebook video, Amanda reminisced about young Samantha's misadventures with a perfume set her mom received as a Christmas gift. And you love to play dress-up. I remember one night someone had given your mom a perfume set for Christmas you were in bed I was going to bed and I had to walk by your room to get to my room and I could smell like all this old lady perfume and I was like what is that I opened the door I hit you with the door because you were behind the door and you had taking a sip of one of them decided that it tasted terrible and so you were just pouring the rest out in the floor so we had to call the boys in control um it was a big thing but you you were fine samantha's strawberry blonde hair and hazel eyes she grows up athletic headstrong and fierce she never hesitates to speak her mind amanda recalls how she and samantha argued sometimes because they had such similar personalities even so amanda sees how caring samantha was too Samantha's mom, Tina, tells WPSD News her daughter is very loyal and always willing to help.

5:13She would give you the shirt off her back if you needed it, go out of her way to help you. If you needed her help, she would be there for you. Within her family, Samantha is famous for her tight hugs, which she couples with calling the person by their nickname. During Thanksgiving and Christmas, Samantha loves cheesecake so much that she has an entire cheesecake made for her to eat and take home. When it comes to her own cooking, she isn't very good at it, and her family always teases her about it. But Samantha does seem to have a green thumb in the garden. Her grandmother gives her trimmings, and Samantha turns them into flourishing plants.

5:51While growing up, Samantha meets and becomes friends with a local boy named Wren Hendrickson. According to Wren's interview with the local news station WPSD, they become really good friends and wind up dating for a bit. At one point during her youth, Samantha gets involved in drugs, but she goes to rehab and becomes sober. I don't have a lot of information about this time in her life, but I do know that she's proud to be sober, and rightfully so. Battling addiction is a difficult and complicated journey, and Samantha does find happiness. She marries a man named Jacob Sperry and takes his last name.

6:28By the time she's 25 years old in In 2018, they have two young kids, who she loves more than anything. Being a mother is hugely rewarding for her, but Samantha and Jacob seem to have split by then. She gets a job at the local McDonald's and feels ready to love again. She messages her old flame, Ren, and they get back together. The relationship isn't perfect, though. Ren and Samantha break up and get back together a ton of times. Adding to the turbulence, Samantha argues with her Aunt Amanda. Now, it's kind of normal for this headstrong family to butt heads at times, but this is really serious.

7:04It's about Samantha's drug addiction. Now, there's not a lot out there about this case. I don't know if she relapses or just has a hard moment, but Amanda and Samantha send each other text messages, and I don't know what those say either, but by the end of it, Amanda wants to give Samantha time to cool off. Amanda plans on reaching back out to Samantha in a couple days to encourage her niece to return to rehab. And that brings me to March 27, 2018. I think it's incredibly important to note that right now, the only information we have about that day comes from Wren and his biological father, Dusty Holder.

7:40There are a lot of holes in this story. And Wren has admitted that his recollection of this day is not clear, because he was under the influence of meth. Graves County Sheriff John Hayden even tells WPSD News that the timeline doesn't quite add up. Quote, And then when you evaluate it and take a step back to look at it objectively, a lot of what we've been told just doesn't pass the smell test. It just doesn't make any sense. End quote. This episode of Voices for Justice is brought to you by Quince. I love giving gifts, and Quince really does make that so easy. They have something for everyone, from soft Mongolian cashmere sweaters for$50 that look and feel like designer pieces, silk tops and skirts for dressing up, perfectly cut denim for everyday wear, and outerwear that actually keeps you warm.

8:31And of course, what I love is that every piece is made with premium materials from ethical, trusted factories. And it's all priced far below what other luxury brands charge. I'm still using my older pieces from Quince that I got over a year ago now, and they look brand new. I also recently tried their candles, and I am obsessed. I feel like amazing luxury candles are one of those things that few people will buy for themselves, so that is my go-to gift. I promise you, I'm not just saying it, Quince really does have something for everyone. Find gifts so good, you'll want to keep them with Quince.

9:05Go to quince.com slash justice for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's q-u-i-n-c-e dot com slash justice to get free shipping and 365-day returns. quince.com slash justice.

9:28Close your eyes, exhale, feel your body relax, and let go of whatever you're carrying today. Well, I'm letting go of the worry that I wouldn't get my new contacts in time for this class. I got them delivered free from 1-800-CONTACTS. Oh my gosh, they're so fast. And breathe. Oh, sorry. I almost couldn't breathe when I saw the discount they gave me on my first order. Oh, sorry. Namaste. Visit 1-800-CONTACTS.com today to save on your first order. 1-800-CONTACTS.

10:22Offer for ad support in Disney Plus Hulu bundle only. Then$12.99 a month or then current regular monthly price. 18 plus terms apply. I'm going to break it down for you the best I can. That afternoon, Samantha and Wren went to his uncle Paul's house in Samsonia. This is about 30 miles away from Samantha's home in Murray. That's where Dusty lives. We don't know why they go to see Dusty or what exactly happens here. But we do know that Samantha does not bring her phone. According to the Graves County Sheriff's Department, and Dusty claims Wren and Samantha argue, but Wren denies this. Either way, Samantha's upset for some reason, and walks along a line of trees near the house.

11:01Wren is on his cell phone trying to get more meth. Soon, Dusty pulls up next to her on an ATV. Wren talks about this to WPSD News. I was busy doing something I shouldn't have been on the phone when she got on the four-wheeler. She's like, I'm going to go take a ride with your dad. I was like, all right. Didn't think nothing of it. About 10 minutes later, I was asked to leave. You know what I'm saying? I was like, well, what about her? He's like, you're high? Get out of here. My uncle said that. Wren then leaves Dusty's home and takes Samantha's car, a Ford Taurus, back to her home in Murray about half an hour away.

11:43From here, Samantha gets on Dusty's ATV and they head to a place called Kaler Bottoms, Formerly known as Kaler Bottoms Wildlife Management Area, it's a 2 ,000 acre wetland, and it's located within minutes of Dusty's house. Now, Kaler Bottoms is really rural, remote, it's swampy, and there's a lot of wooded area with low terrain. And when there's rain, the bottoms get extremely wet, limiting access to the area a lot. And March 2018 did have a lot of rain. Still, Samantha and Dusty rode off to Kaler Bottoms. And I feel like it's kind of a theme in this episode, but again, we don't really know exactly what happens here.

12:23Or how far they go into this 2 ,000 acre wetland. But it's safe to assume that it is muddy and Dusty says that the ATV gets stuck in that mud. Making matters worse, it's starting to get dark. Dusty tells Dateline NBC that he and Samantha decide to spend the night on the ATV. He says they stay warm by keeping the engine on. and Samantha doesn't contact anyone from her family about this situation. Now, this could be plausible, but it also doesn't make sense for several reasons. First, as I mentioned, Kaler Bottoms isn't too far from Dusty's home. It does seem kind of weird that they don't think they can make it back before the sun sets.

13:04Then again, like I said, to play devil's advocate, we don't know how far they drove into this 2 ,000 acres. but we do know that because of this recent rain, there is limited access around the area. Second, Samantha is a mom to two young kids, and she has a close-knit family that definitely notices when she does not come home at night. And that's exactly what happens. Her sister Kim and the rest of the family are texting and calling her non-stop, but nothing gets through. Samantha's phone is off. As I mentioned earlier, Samantha does not have her cell phone with her, But one question a lot of people ask is why didn't Samantha ask Dusty to use his phone?

13:45Third, I'm sure you've probably seen an ATV, but for those who haven't, they kind of look like a small car combined with a motorbike. Some even look like sleek, fancy golf carts. But unlike a car, sometimes there isn't a roof or hood covering it. There's typically no backseat to take refuge in. We don't know the size or make and model of this ATV, but it likely didn't have a lot of room to sleep in. And that's really another thing that I keep coming back to in this case. Why spend a cold night on an ATV when you're so close to home? Even if you have to walk. But, according to Dusty's account to Dateline NBC, that's what happens.

14:25Hours pass, the ATV runs out of gas, and their heat source is gone. In the morning, Dusty and Samantha venture out of the woods and arrive at Highway 131. This is a very busy state route that's basically like the main road in this area. From here, they walk off in different directions. And again, I can't tell you why. Dusty says he then walks to a nearby general store, and Samantha heads toward the highway to go to her cousin's house. But this is a direction that her mom Tina doesn't think Samantha would ever take, because it is such a busy highway. And if she does go that way, Tina thinks it's kind of odd that no one else sees her daughter walking on the side of the road.

15:06Tina told WPSD News, quote, There would have been parents taking their kids to school to drop them off and headed to work. There would have been someone that would have seen her. End quote. The Graves County Sheriff's Department also tells the media that they can't confirm Samantha took this route. There are no witnesses. Even so, Dusty is the last person to see Samantha alive And this is the only account that exists of Samantha's last known whereabouts During the next day, March 28th, Samantha's family is of course incredibly worried She's still not home or answering any calls or texts And now, Wren's concerned too She hasn't returned to her house in Murray where he stayed overnight Wren goes back to visit Dusty using Samantha's car Dusty tells Ren what happened with Samantha, but we don't know exactly what Dusty says.

15:59We do know that Ren becomes extremely distressed by it. In some interviews, Ren says he doesn't know Samantha's missing till later. Either way, Ren tells WPSD News he doubts Dusty's story. I've asked him numerous times. I asked him right after it happened, I said, Dad, what happened?

16:23I actually didn't say that. I said Dusty Island. It's like, man, we need to talk, man. I was like, look, dude, you need to give me some answers. He told me to shut up. Why are you asking so many questions? During the evening of March 28th, Wren's reaction is extremely troubling. He goes into a wooded area off Dooms Chapel Road and Highway 131, just down the road from Simpsonia. He uses his iPhone to FaceTime his mom and tells her that he just took a bunch of pills. Wren tells his mom he wants to die by suicide. Later, he tells WSPD News that he's high and thinks he's being followed, though he doesn't say by who.

17:10Naturally, Wren's family panics and they call the sheriff's office, where they are familiar with Wren and his history of being arrested for being violent and armed. Emergency Management Director Chief Deputy Davint Ramage takes this information into account and decides not to endanger his officers. Ramage doesn't send anyone into the woods to look for Wren. He says it's dark outside, and he doesn't know if Wren is armed or how the pills might be affecting him. He instead decides to send officers to search for Wren in the morning. And now, I really want to note here that no one knows that Samantha's missing, which is why no one is searching for her yet.

17:50Now, despite this lack of action, Wren's situation is discussed on a call to all law enforcement and services, like the volunteer fire department. And Samantha's brother Tyler is a volunteer firefighter. Luckily, he hears the call, and even clocks that Wren drove Samantha's Ford Taurus into the woods. This is when it hits him. If Wren is in trouble and has Samantha's car, something might have happened to Samantha, and it's obviously not good. Tyler immediately contacts his family. Their mom Tina calls Samantha's job at McDonald's to see if she ever arrived for her 9pm shift. Her co-workers say that she never did.

18:32So right now, both Samantha and Ren are missing. Her car is abandoned and soon impounded. And the only person who might have any inkling of what's going on is Dusty Holder. On March 29, 2018, Tina officially reports her daughter Samantha missing, and the sheriff's office immediately looks into Dusty. Deputies begin interviewing people to verify Dusty's whereabouts for the past few days, and to get more information. Samantha's car and apartment are searched, but they don't find anything out of the ordinary. According to Samantha's family, because of her history, the police basically assume that she's probably on drugs.

19:13The officer even tells them that she'll probably just eventually come back home. This is so unfair, not only for Samantha's family, but for Samantha. But the next day, March 30th, the police do launch their first search for Samantha in the woods Meanwhile, detectives and deputies meet with Dusty He tells them his account of that night The version I just took you through On March 31st, the police receive a tip from someone who thinks they saw Samantha in Callaway County Which is where Samantha lives in Murray The tip says that she was in a white Chevrolet Camaro from the late 80s to the early 90s with a loud exhaust.

19:54It's a bit of hope for Samantha's family. Around the same time, Ramage asks an unnamed, independent Kaler Bottoms expert to examine the area. Again, we don't know a lot about this guy, but we do know that he spent his life in this region and grew up hunting there, so he apparently knows it very well. He does find Dusty's ATV that broke down that night. He also finds proof of a small fire and two cell phones, both of which belong to Dusty. But most importantly, he finds footprints. And I feel like this part is crucial. He only finds one set of footprints. They go around the ATV and out of the woods.

20:36Obviously, this evidence does not match up with Dusty's story. And there's no way to prove that Samantha had even been there that night. It only proves that Dusty went off-roading into Kaler Bottoms with his ATV and started a fire at some point. While this doesn't provide us any information about what might have happened to Samantha, it does tell us that there's something wrong with Dusty's story. And this is followed by another major development. Two days later on April 1st, more people and police search for Samantha and Kaler Bottoms. That night, Ren Hendrickson walks out of the woods after spending five days there.

21:14He's taken to the hospital and treated for hypothermia and dehydration. After his treatment, deputies question Ren about his and Samantha's disappearance, but he doesn't seem to know any other details. As the search for Samantha continues, the last two men to see her, Ren and Dusty, sit for polygraph tests, and they pass. Now, we know that polygraph tests aren't considered trustworthy evidence that someone is lying or telling the truth. In fact, I think it's worth noting that the American Psychological Association says that there's no proof that lying correlates with any psychological reactions.

21:52There's a lot of junk science out there. Now, under certain legal conditions, polygraph test results can only be used as evidence in roughly half the states, and Kentucky isn't one of them. So the polygraph results aren't saying that Dusty and Wren are innocent, but the police do feel that they need to turn their attention to other people. As you might guess, this is incredibly frustrating to Samantha's family. Not only has she been missing for several days at this point, but the two people who say that they last saw her haven't been much help. Her family also believes that searching for Wren in the woods took away valuable time the police could have used to look for Samantha.

22:31Really, they feel like the sheriff's office didn't even take her case seriously until Wren resurfaced. And now an unreliable polygraph test seems to be clearing Dusty and Wren of any guilt. At the same time, no other evidence emerges to prove that either man is involved in Samantha's disappearance. Now, one other lead does crop up, but it doesn't last for long. A year later, on April 3rd, 2019, detectives walked around Kaler Bottoms with a canine unit, and the dogs find an underground bunker. Not only that, there's a man living there, a 41-year-old fugitive named Ernest Hendrickson. I know, but we don't know if Ernest has any relation to Wren Hendrickson.

23:15But Ernest is on the run from police for a long list of charges in graves and three other counties. Of course, deputies think that maybe he was involved in Samantha's disappearance, but they quickly find that Ernest was in jail during that time. Three months later, Graves County Sheriff John Hayden takes office. He brings in the Kentucky State Police and FBI to help, but it doesn't do much. Unfortunately, even after Samantha's case is featured on Dateline NBC, there still isn't any new information. This episode is brought to you by 20th Century Studios upcoming comedy, Ella McKay. From Academy Award-winning writer-director James L.

23:57Brooks, Emma Mackey plays Ella McKay, an idealistic young woman who juggles family and work in a story about the people you love and how to survive them. Featuring an all-star cast, including Jamie Lee Curtis, Jack Loudon, Kumail Nanjiani, Iowa Debris, Julie Kaffner, with Albert Brooks and Woody Harrelson. Ella McKay in theaters December 12th. Get tickets now. Hablas Español. Spreys to Deutsch. Condénosque. If you used Babbel, you would. Babbel's conversation-based techniques teaches you useful words and phrases to get you speaking quickly about the things you actually talk about in the real world.

24:31With lessons handcrafted by over 200 language experts and voiced by real native speakers, Babbel is like having a private tutor in your pocket. Start speaking with Babbel today. Get up to 55 % off your Babbel subscription right now at babbel.com slash Spotify, spelled B-A-B-B-E-L dot com slash Spotify. Rules and restrictions may apply. In the years since, Tina, Amanda, and the Graves County Sheriff's Office continue to talk to the media about Samantha's case. In 2021, Sheriff Hayden does tell WPSD News that the police are still putting effort into this case. As for Wren and Dusty, both men are in jail for unrelated crimes.

25:09According to the Kentucky Department of Corrections, Wren was convicted of tampering with a monitoring device in June of 2023. He was sentenced to five years in prison. A few months later, Dusty gets arrested and faces several charges, including firearms possession and possession of meth and cannabis. But Samantha's family is holding out hope that she might come home someday. Since April 2018, her family has maintained a Facebook page called Bring Samantha Home. That's where I connected with her family. It currently has over 10 ,000 followers. Many members, including Samantha's Aunt Amanda, post updates and memories about Samantha.

25:49Amanda also makes flyers, puts up yard signs, and holds yard sales all to spread the word about Samantha. They also commemorate the day that Samantha went missing and her birthday, August 20th. In 2023, Amanda posts a video to the Facebook page addressing Samantha directly. She ends with the following message for her.

26:14You just had so much opportunity ahead of you.