Update: Lisa McBride

0:00This episode of Voices for Justice is brought to you by Shopify. When I started this podcast, it really seemed like I had to figure it all out on my own. Scripts, setup, logos, schedules, it was really overwhelming. When you're starting off with something new, it seems like your to-do list keeps growing every day with new tasks. So finding the right tool that not only helps you, but simplifies everything, can be a game changer. For millions of businesses, that tool is Shopify. With Shopify, you can get started with your own design studio. They have hundreds of ready-to-use templates. That way you can build a beautiful online store that matches your brand style.

0:37You can also get the word out like you have a marketing team behind you. Easily create email and social media campaigns wherever your customers are scrolling or strolling. And if you get stuck, Shopify's always around to share advice with their award-winning 24-7 customer support. Start your business today with the industry's best business partner, Shopify, and start hearing... Sign up for your$1 per month trial today at shopify.com slash justice. Go to shopify.com slash justice. That's shopify.com slash justice.

1:15Voices for Justice is a podcast that uses adult language and discusses sensitive and potentially triggering topics including violence, abuse, and murder. This podcast may not be appropriate for younger audiences. All parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Some names have been changed or omitted per their request or for safety purposes. Listener discretion is advised. My name is Sarah Turney and this is Voices for Justice.

1:48Today I have a major update in the case of Lisa McBride from Vernon, New Jersey. If you've been listening to this show for a while, you know that there are certain cases that stay with me because the response seemed almost immediate. The family reacted right away. Law enforcement reacted right away. The community reacted right away. Lisa's case was one of those. When 27-year-old Lisa McBride disappeared in June of 1990, she was reported missing within hours. Her family was immediately alarmed. Police quickly believed they were looking at foul play, and a 17-member task force was formed. Her family offered a massive reward and thousands of flyers were printed and distributed.

2:33Despite all these amazing efforts, for more than three decades, Lisa's case remained unsolved. In my original episode, I asked a question that I think sat at the heart of this case. With what looked like such a strong initial response, with so many resources, so much media coverage, and so much community effort, how was Lisa's case still unsolved? Well, now after 35 years, there may finally be an answer. In April of 2026, authorities announced that a man had been charged in connection with Lisa's murder. The new public findings and hearing coverage give us the clearest picture we've ever had of what investigators believe happened to Lisa McBride, what evidence may have finally move this case forward, and what questions still remain?

3:22This is an update in the case of Lisa McBride. Lisa McBride was 27 years old in 1990. She lived alone in a home on Glen Road in the Highland Lake section of Vernon, New Jersey. And when I first covered her case in October 2024, one thing that really stood out to me was how full her life was. Lisa was independent, social, and active. She was a dancer. She'd performed as a part of a troupe called the New Generation of Dancers when she was younger. She worked as an executive secretary at Lakeland State Bank, but she also taught ballet on the side where her students knew her as Miss Lisa. She was an avid hiker, a competitive shooter, a member of the NRA and the Sierra Club, which I think kind of says a lot about how multifaceted she was.

4:14She also loved animals and was known for bringing home stray or abused cats. She had a tight friend group. She had bought her own home and fixed it up with the help of her friends. She wasn't someone people described as lost or reckless or disconnected. She was building a life she seemed genuinely happy in. She also visited her parents, George and Norma McBride, often, and her brother Douglas had recently become a father, and Lisa had become a godmother to his daughter. Her mom's last photo of her was taken just two days before Lisa disappeared. She'd gone to her parents' home while they were hosting friends, and when Norma was taking photos, Lisa teased her, basically saying, you didn't take my picture.

4:55So Norma did. She didn't know it would be the last photo she would ever take of her daughter. On Friday, June 22, 1990, Lisa went with three friends into Manhattan to see a concert at the Beacon Theater. Afterward, they stopped at Big John's Pub in West Milford. Lisa was seen talking with people, having a good time, and catching up with old friends. She also reportedly gave her phone number out to a few people. But she did have work the next morning, so at around 1.30 a.m., she left and drove home alone. At least one neighbor reportedly saw her arrive home around 2 a.m. Then, just a few hours later, at around 7.30, Lisa's co-workers began calling her.

5:39she hadn't shown up for work. And that was immediately alarming, because she hadn't missed a single day of work in three years. So her co-workers immediately contacted her family, and by around 10 a.m., her brother Douglas went to her house to check on her. Lisa's car was still in the driveway, but when Douglas went inside, something was very wrong. Lisa was gone Her purse and keys were missing Her bed had been stripped of its sheets and blankets A light was on The couch had been pulled several inches away from the wall And one of her two cats was gone When police got there and investigated further They found that the phone line outside her house had been cut A window screen had also been cut With slashes large enough for someone to get inside So police immediately suspected foul play, and a major search and investigation began.

6:38A task force was formed with the FBI, state police, local investigators, and the Sussex County Prosecutor's Office. Lisa's family helped a lot too. Her parents created a dedicated tip line, her father George owned a plastics plant, and had his employees help print thousands and thousands of flyers. Soon the reward grew to$100 ,000 for Lisa's safe return Investigators spoke to hundreds of people Lisa's friends from the concert were ruled out quickly Police also looked into a man who had been pursuing Lisa romantically And had reportedly made her uncomfortable by showing up at her work and leaving flowers on her car But he was eventually located And investigators determined he had an alibi for the night Lisa disappeared So months went by without answers Then, on October 20, 1990, just hours before a massive planned search of 30 ,000 acres was set to begin, Lisa was found.

7:37A hunter named Robert Cole was birdwatching in a wooded area near Old Mine Road in Sandison Township in or near the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area when he discovered human remains. Lisa was found about 30 miles from her home, and her remains were nearly skeletal. Ultimately, she was identified through dental records. Her death was ruled a homicide, but for decades, investigators withheld many details about her cause of death and the evidence recovered. For Elisa's family, the search for her became a search for justice. Her parents, George and Norma, gave interviews over the years.

8:17They kept her name in the public eye, and her friends honored her each year by climbing Canoes Mountain and placing a wooden star on a tree near the top, fulfilling something Lisa had always wanted to do, just bring Christmas cheer to the area. But we know how these things unfortunately go sometimes. The years just kept passing. By 2003, investigators had conducted around 1 ,500 interviews. In 2004, Sussex County created a cold case unit, and Lisa's case was one of only six cases assigned to it. By 2010, our case file reportedly had filled two cabinets at the prosecutor's office. Then, George McBride died in 2015, and Norma McBride died in 2018.

9:03Neither of them lived to see an arrest. This episode of Voices for Justice is sponsored by HERS. If you've ever felt stuck trying to lose weight, you're not alone. Enter Weight Loss by HERS. It's designed to support you in reaching your goals. And HERS now offers access to an affordable range of FDA-approved GLP-1 medications, including the WeGoV pill and the WeGoV pen. And everything's 100 % online through HERS. You'll connect with a licensed provider who will determine if treatment's even right for you. If prescribed, your medication is delivered right to your door. No insurance necessary. And it goes way beyond that.

9:41They offer 24-7 messaging with your care team and tons of in-app lifestyle and nutrition tips, like recipes, meal plans, fitness videos, sleep content, and more. Ready to reach your goals? Visit 4hers.com slash crime to get personalized, affordable care that gets you. That's 4hers.com slash crime. 4hers.com slash crime. Weight loss by HERS is not available in all 50 states. Wegovi is the registered trademark of Novo Nordisk AS. To get started and learn more, including important safety information, Wegovy clinical study information, and restrictions, visit ForHers.com.

10:23When I covered Lisa's case before, the newest update was that in 2022 her body had been exhumed. And at that time we didn't know much. Authorities said they believed there was an additional investigative step that needed to be taken, and that step required them to exhume Lisa's remains. They also said DNA evidence was taken and sent for testing, and then publicly, the case seemed to go quiet again. This is literally the perfect example of what I always say. If something was happening, they weren't telling the public about it. Because behind the scenes, that forensic work appears to have become central to the charges now filed in 2026.

11:04According to the new report and public charging documents summarized in it, evidence from the bed or headboard area in Lisa's home was resubmitted for advanced DNA testing in 2020. Then in 2022, Lisa's remains were exhumed so investigators could obtain a definitive victim DNA sample. And that really does matter, because the item they were testing reportedly contained a mixed DNA profile. Then in February of 2026, a male DNA profile was authorized for entry into Dakotas, and that profile reportedly hit to a man named Robert W. McCaffrey Jr. So let's get into it. Authorities say McCaffrey was living in Sussex County in the summer of 1990 and worked in northern New Jersey.

11:50According to the 2026 report, investigators also found no known ties between McCaffrey and Lisa, at least based on the public record available right now. And this is also important because it suggests that this may not have been someone Lisa's family and friends immediately connected to her. Either way, on April 6, 2026, a complaint warrant was sworn charging Robert W. McCaffrey Jr. with first-degree murder, first-degree kidnapping, and second-degree burglary in connection with Lisa's death. On April 10, he was arrested in Manteo, North Carolina. On April 20th, he appeared in court in Sussex County and pleaded not guilty.

12:31On April 27th, Judge Jeanine Allen ordered he be detained pending trial. A pre-indictment conference was scheduled for May 18th, 2026, but as of the report I reviewed, no public indictment number has been located yet. Again, this is early, but the public court coverage gives us more insight into what prosecutors believe ties him to Lisa's case. In the detention hearing, prosecutors argued that a washcloth found on the headboard contained DNA from both Lisa and McCaffrey. And what it's intended to be used for. And ultimately, through dental records, those skeletal remains are identified as Lisa Ubright.

13:12There was a washcloth on the headboard of her bed. Unfortunately, we were able to get an order from the surrogate to exhume Lisa's remains to get enough of a sample to confirm her DNA. And it got an immediate match, an immediate hit. It went back to the defendant, Robert W. McCaffrey Jr. That detail is huge because it potentially connects him to evidence found inside Lisa's home, from an area that's always been central to this investigation. Remember, when Lisa's family and police found her house disturbed, her bed had been completely stripped of the sheets and blankets. For decades, we knew investigators believed that the state of the home mattered, but they'd kept a lot of details private.

13:56Now we know that at least one item from the bed or headboard area was apparently preserved and retested decades later. Prosecutors also reportedly pointed to the signs of forced entry at Lisa's home again. That cut phone line and the cut window screen. And then there's another piece of evidence that, if true, is extremely significant. According to the new case report, investigators interviewed a witness in 2019 referred to publicly as R.I., and that witness reportedly told investigators that McCaffrey confessed in 1995 that he killed Lisa because she would not go out with him. That is the allegation, but according to prosecutors, that witness is part of the evidence against him.

14:44There are also defense arguments already emerging. The defense has reportedly argued that DNA on a portable item like a washcloth does not necessarily prove when or how the DNA got there. They also appear to be challenging parts of the medical evidence, including issues around an amended medical examiner report. and that's why this case isn't over just yet. We all know that an arrest is not the same thing as a conviction but after 35 years, investigators are saying they have enough evidence to charge someone in Lisa's murder and that alone is an enormous development. It is extremely worth noting that there's another case connected to Robert McCaffrey's public history that I think deserves more than a passing mention.

15:32That's the case of his wife, Gail McCaffrey. And I do want to be very careful here. Gail's case does not prove what happened to Lisa McBride. It does not prove that Robert McCaffrey killed Lisa, but it is legally relevant right now because prosecutors brought up his obstruction conviction from Gail's case during the detention arguments in Lisa's case, and the judge cited that conviction when ordering him detained pending trial. But of course, Gail's not just a footnote in Lisa's case. She's not just a legal argument. She's another missing woman whose loved ones have been waiting for answers. So let's take a moment to talk about Gail's case.

16:12Gail McCaffrey disappeared from Charleston County, South Carolina in 2012. At the time, she was married to Robert McCaffrey. Years later, in 2018, the Charleston County Sheriff's Office arrested him in connection with Gail's disappearance. But that murder charge didn't ultimately move forward. because a grand jury no-billed the case. That basically means that at that point, the grand jury did not return an indictment on the murder charge. However, he was convicted of obstruction of justice in connection with that investigation. According to the new Lisa McBride case report, the South Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed that obstruction of justice conviction in 2021.

16:53He'd been sentenced to 10 years. The appellate opinion reportedly cited evidence that he lied about his whereabouts, encouraged a woman he was involved with to lie, and created or authored what was described as a supposed farewell letter from Gail. And I really just want to pause here because that detail is haunting. A missing person's case is already difficult enough. Families are already trying to figure out what happened, whether their loved one left, whether something happened to them, whether they're alive somewhere, whether they're being hurt, and whether they can be found. And then, according to the court record summarized in the report, there was allegedly a fake or supposed farewell letter from Gail.

17:37We know how that kind of thing can completely shift how people perceive a disappearance. It can create doubt. It can waste time. It can make people question whether someone was really in danger or whether they chose to leave. And in Gail's case, Robert McCaffrey was convicted of obstruction, not murder. But a court did uphold his obstruction conviction, and that conviction is now a part of the public record prosecutors pointed to in Lisa's case. So that's where the two cases intersect legally. At McCaffrey's detention hearing in New Jersey, prosecutors argued that his prior obstruction conviction showed he could pose a risk of obstruction in the Lisa McBride case if released.

18:21According to the report, Judge Jeanine Allen cited that obstruction history when ordering him held pending trial. And I think that distinction really matters. The prosecution was not saying he was accused in Gail's case, therefore he killed Lisa. That's not how this works. What they were arguing was more specific, that his prior obstruction conviction was relevant to whether he could be trusted to not interfere with the current case. But that legal caution should not erase the person at the center of the case. Gail McCaffrey is still missing. and now because Robert McCaffrey has been charged in Lisa McBride's murder, people are understandably looking back at Gail's case with new attention.

19:01That doesn't mean we get to collapse the two cases into one story though. Lisa and Gail were two very different women, in two different states, decades apart, with two different investigations and two different legal records. Lisa McBride disappeared from Vernon, New Jersey in 1990. Her remains were found months later in Sandiston Township. In 2026, Robert McCaffrey was charged with murder, kidnapping, and burglary in Lisa's case, and has pleaded not guilty. Gail McCaffrey disappeared from South Carolina in 2012. Robert McCaffrey was arrested in connection with her disappearance in 2018. The murder charge was no-billed by a grand jury, and he was later convicted of obstruction of justice.

19:47Those are the facts we can responsibly say right now. But emotionally, I think it's really hard not to sit with the weight of that. We have two women, one found after months, one still missing. Two families left waiting for answers. And now, one man's name is appearing in both public records. It obviously raises serious questions about Robert McCaffrey's history, his credibility, and why a New Jersey judge ultimately decided he should remain detained while the Lisa McBride case moves forward. Get that I'm kind of harping on this, but you guys know how I feel about these things. Gail herself deserves to be remembered as more than just a prior case, more than a court record, and more than a piece of another prosecution.

20:34She deserves answers too. So with that context, we come back to Lisa. because as much as Gail's case is relevant, Lisa's case still has to stand on its own evidence. And according to prosecutors, that evidence includes DNA allegedly found on an item from Lisa's bed or headboard area, signs of forced entry at her home, and this witness who reportedly said that McCaffrey confessed years later. We also have confirmation that he lived in Sussex County in the summer of 1990. That is the case prosecutors are now trying to move forward. and that is the case a court will have to decide. So here is what we can say right now.

21:17Robert W. McCaffrey Jr. has been charged in Lisa McBride's murder. He has pleaded not guilty. The defense is already challenging the strength and interpretation of the evidence I mentioned and as of right now, there are still major unanswered questions. We don't have the full autopsy report. We don't have the full forensic anthropology report We don't have the DNA lab packet We don't have the complete chain of custody for the item tested We don't know exactly how the DNA mixture was interpreted We don't know what the witness R.I. said in full How that statement was documented Or what corroboration exists And there are discrepancies in public reporting About how and when McCaffrey's DNA entered CODIS Those questions matter, not because they mean that the case is strong or weak.

22:10We just don't know yet. They matter because this case is now moving from the realm of a cold case mystery into the realm of a criminal prosecution, and that means the standard changes. It's no longer just about what investigators believe. It's about what prosecutors can prove. I can't help but keep thinking about Lisa's parents. George and Norma fought for answers for decades. They kept her case alive when it would have been so easy for the public to move on. They gave interviews, they handed out flyers, they spoke with investigators. They allowed themselves to relive the worst thing that ever happened to them because they wanted someone to be held accountable for what happened to their daughter.

22:53And they both died before this arrest. That is devastating. But, according to the 2026 update report, after the arrest, Lisa's brother Doug released a family statement thanking the agencies involved and asking anyone with information to still come forward. And that is really important, because even with an arrest, even with charges, even with DNA, this case may still need people to talk. If you knew Lisa McBride in 1990, if you knew Robert McCaffrey in 1990. If you saw something, heard something, or told something, or even have the smallest piece of information that may help investigators understand what happened, this is the time to come forward.

23:39There are also still items connected to Lisa that have never been recovered. In the original episode, I talked about Lisa's missing purse and keychain. Her purse was described as a medium-sized black oval purse, but the keychain on it was a lot more unique. It was a brass nameplate engraved with her nickname, WESA. W-E-E-S-A. For years, I think a lot of us wondered if that keychain could be the kind of thing that survived. Something tucked away, thrown into a drawer. Maybe it would be found in an attic, a box, a thrift store, a storage unit, or a home clean-out. Now, after this arrest, those missing items may be even more important.

24:21According to the new report, investigators in North Carolina searched for items that may have belonged to Lisa, including her purse, license, and keys, though the public reporting did not show that any of those items were recovered. So the call to action is different now, but it is still a call to action. Lisa McBride was 27 years old when she disappeared from her home in Vernon, New Jersey, on June 23, 1990. Her remains were found on October 20, 1990, in Sandison Township. In April of 2026, Robert W. McCaffrey Jr. was charged with murder, kidnapping, and burglary in connection with her case. He has pleaded not guilty, and the case is pending.

25:05Even though the case finally has an arrest, please keep sharing Lisa's name. Because this is far from over. And for Lisa's family, justice is something they've waited for since 1990. Lisa McBride wasn't just a cold case. She wasn't just a file that filled two cabinets. She was a daughter, a sister, an aunt, a godmother, a dancer, a teacher, a friend, and the kind of person who brought home stray cats and made silly faces in photos. For more than three decades, people asked what happened to Lisa McBride. And now, we may be closer than ever to finding out.

25:53As a reminder, Lisa McBride was 27 years old when she went missing from Vernon, New Jersey on Saturday, June 23, 1990. Investigators believe she was likely killed shortly after. She was white, with brown hair and brown eyes, was 5 '7", and weighed approximately 135 pounds. She was last seen wearing blue jeans and a white shirt with a shoelace-type black tie in the back. Anyone with information is asked to call the Sussex County Prosecutor's Office at 973-383-1570. Marjorie Gail McCaffrey was 36 years old when she disappeared from Charleston, South Carolina. She was last seen at her home at 2829 Limestone Boulevard in the West Ashley neighborhood on March 17, 2012.

26:46Detectives are investigating her disappearance as a homicide. Gail was white with brown hair and blue eyes, about 5 '2 and weighed approximately 155 pounds. She has never been found. Anyone with information is asked to contact the Charleston County Sheriff's Office at 843-554-2241.

27:12But, as always, thank you, I love you, and I'll talk to you next time.

27:22Voices for Justice is hosted and produced by me, Sarah Turney, and is a Voices for Justice media original. If you love what we do here, please don't forget to follow, rate, and review the show on your podcast player. It's an easy and free way to help us and help more people find these cases in need of justice.

28:25Welcome to the secret after show, the studio door is open, and our emotional support puppies Popcorn and Heber are in the room. Let's go right into the case. This feels like one giant segment of hope. And you guys know that I don't cover solved cases, but I do think that covering the updates on unsolved cases is just an important reminder that this is exactly why we do what we do, why we keep pushing for these cases to get more attention and more resources. Of course, I think we're going to learn a lot more in time, and I'm sure I'll be back with another update, but so many of you reached out about Lisa's case that I really just wanted to jump on it and give you what we know.