1. Podcasts
  2. 99% Invisible
  3. Know the Score
99% Invisible

17 Nov 2026 · 37m · 15 chapters

In short

Identity theft and the history and real-world effects of U.S. credit reporting and credit scores, plus a practical PSA on how to freeze credit reports to prevent new accounts from being opened in your name.

Guests/backgrounds

Roman Mars hosts 99% Invisible. Vivian Lay (producer) describes her identity theft experience after a data breach. Dan Egan is VP of Behavioral Finance and Investing at Betterment (ad segment). Josh Lauer is a communication professor and author of Creditworthy, studying the history of consumer surveillance/financial identity. Chi Chi Wu is director of consumer reporting and data advocacy at the National Consumer Law Center.

Key claims

Credit scores evolved from trust-based credit reporting into algorithmic screening (FICO) that is “objective” but still embeds inequality and misses context. Consumers aren’t the credit bureaus’ customers; Equifax/Experian/TransUnion profit from consumer data and have weak incentives to fix errors. Credit freezes block lenders from pulling reports, preventing “hard inquiries” and new fraud.

Notable examples

Vivian Lay’s fake-ID Mercedes-Benz dealership attempt; the Panic of 1837 leading to Louis Tappan’s Mercantile Agency; FICO’s categories (payment history, amounts owed, credit history length, recent applications, credit mix); Equifax’s 2017 breach; Wu’s point that errors affect 1 in 5 consumers and 1 in 20 seriously.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:23

Vivian Lay's Identity Theft Experience

Producer Vivian Lay shares her experience with identity theft.

“Last August, producer Vivian Lay received a voicemail that kicked off the first of several panic attacks that would span months.”
3:10

Understanding Credit Scores

Discussion on the significance and implications of credit scores.

“So even if it's fraud, it still hurts your credit.”
4:15

The Evolution of Credit Systems

Exploration of historical credit systems and their development.

“But as I started looking into it, I learned that the credit score is much less objective than it seems.”
6:05

Louis Tappan and the Mercantile Agency

The founding of the Mercantile Agency and its impact on credit.

“were interacting more and more with brand new borrowers they just didn't know.”
7:51

Character and the Credit System

Analysis of how character influenced creditworthiness in the past.

“They were mass-producing credit information.”
9:22

Rise of the Consumer Credit Bureau

The emergence of consumer credit bureaus and their implications.

“And these were sort of the stereotypical sins for debtors.”
14:00

Understanding Credit Worthiness

Learn how credit judgments are influenced by personal character assessments.

“and determine whether they were worthy of a line of credit.”
15:00

The Birth of FICO Scores

Discover the creation and significance of FICO scores in credit assessment.

“As a credit seeker, you are basically subject to some guy's opinion about you, your life decisions, and yes, your sex and race.”
17:40

The Equal Credit Opportunity Act

Understand how the Equal Credit Opportunity Act reshaped credit access and fairness.

“Basically what happened is you have the passage of the Equal Credit Opportunity Act.”
20:00

Limitations of Credit Scores

Explore the shortcomings of credit scores in capturing financial realities.

“But in the 30-plus years since the credit score became a fixture of American financial life, it has become clear that taking the subjectivity out of credit didn't actually fix the problem.”
Show all 15 chapters
22:30

Impact of Credit Bureaus

Learn about the monopoly of credit bureaus and their influence on consumers.

“And by using that number, lenders, whether intentionally or not, can embed that inequality deeper, even make it worse.”
24:30

Security Risks with Credit Data

Understand the security vulnerabilities faced by credit bureaus and their implications.

“One in five consumers has a verified error on their credit report.”
26:50

Protecting Your Credit Identity

Get practical tips on how to safeguard your credit identity after theft.

“are selling consumers a service to help them keep it safe or help you keep yourself safe.”
28:00

Understanding Credit Scores

Learn the importance of monitoring your credit score and its implications.

“Meaning no one is going to drive off in a Benz under your name.”
30:38

The Importance of Freezing Your Credit

Understand what a credit freeze is and why it's essential for security.

“So you just brought us this whole story about the history of credit reporting and the credit score, but now you're here to perform a little PSA for our listeners.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On 99% Invisible, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Lucky Land Casino. Imagine signing up and finding your welcome surprise already waiting. Spin free with gold coins or collect sweep coins. Plus daily login delights. Sign up now. Let the magic talk. Lucky Land Casino. Where the magic happens. No purchase necessary. VGW Group. Void where prohibited by law. CT &C's 21+. This message comes from Betterment. Dan Egan, VP of Behavioral Finance and Investing, explains how Betterment takes the time-consuming work out of smart investing. I grew up learning about finance and investing myself and realizing that I needed to reinvest dividends and rebalance my portfolio and if there was an opportunity to tax loss over time.

0:46And then I realized that I was doing all of these things that were pretty straightforward to implement. I just needed to spend my time doing them. Betterment automates the same good practices, so that I know I'm doing portfolio management and goal-based planning in a way that makes sense and is responsible without me having to spend hours of my life doing it. Learn more at Betterment.com. Investing involves risk, performance not guaranteed. Betterment does not offer tax advice. TLH may not be suitable for all customers. Learn more at Betterment.com slash TLH dash terms. This is 99 % Invisible.

1:23I'm Roman Mars. Last August, producer Vivian Lay received a voicemail that kicked off the first of several panic attacks that would span months. Hi, Vivian. This is Samir calling from Mercedes-Benz of Oakland. Please give me a call back. We'll get a chance. Just something came up. Someone submitted a lead under your name. Just wanted to give you a quick call. The manager of a Mercedes-Benz dealership had called me to let me know that someone had walked into their dealership with a fake ID in my name and tried to drive out with a zero-down loan on a brand new Benz. My identity had been stolen. That's the real Vivian Lay.

2:03I mean, I've been working in the car business a while and I can tell when something's off. And I just, the minute I saw their driver license and information and nothing really matched up. This is my man Samir, the manager who tips me off. After I got that call, I found out that at some point, my personal information had been leaked in a data breach. Most likely, several people had been pretending to be me and using my social security number to attempt to get car loans, register for utilities, get car insurance, and rent multiple apartments and houses, all under my name. When I see that, I feel for the people because it's a pain.

2:40It's not, you know, to go and clean up all the mess that they create. It was such a pain. Over the next several months, I needed to fill out multiple police reports, fill out FTC affidavits, assemble fraud packets, change every single password I've ever made in my entire life and deal with debt collectors. And I had to go through each of these tedious, stress-inducing steps because this whole identity theft situation was impacting one very important thing, my credit score. And like you, it's seller credit. So even if it's fraud, it still hurts your credit. It still does a bunch of stuff. A credit score is essentially a three-digit number that here in the U.S.

3:20usually ranges from 300 to 850. It's a metric that lenders can use to predict your ability to pay back a loan. The higher the number, the more likely you are to be approved for lines of credit. Aside from applying for a new apartment every few years, I almost never questioned what my credit score was or where it came from. But in the months that followed, I found myself hyper fixated on that number and how to make it go back up. Because as I learned very quickly, those three little numbers are weirdly powerful. If you have good credit, all they ask for is your name, date of birth, social security number, and address.

3:58If you have good credit, the system auto approves you and you just buy a car and move on. In the United States, your credit score decides where you can live, what car you can drive, and whether you can get a loan. And it's supposed to be objective, a precise, omniscient accounting of your financial health. But as I started looking into it, I learned that the credit score is much less objective than it seems. What started as a simple tool for lenders ended up embedding itself in the lives of most Americans and feeding the same bias it claimed to solve.

4:32Credit has existed for thousands of years in several forms. But up until the early 19th century, basically the whole first chapter of American history, there were no credit scores because no one really needed them. Much of the credit that kept the economy moving was between businesses, like a wholesaler selling goods on credit to a shopkeeper. And in those early days, it was easy to know who to trust. Communities were small, and chances are the wholesaler and the shopkeeper knew each other personally, or at least secondhand. For many, many years, it's okay because they're repeat customers. The networks of credit are relatively limited, so you could write a letter to somebody you know in a nearby town, and they could send a letter back and tell you whether they were trustworthy or not.

5:18This is Josh Lauer, professor of communication and author of Creditworthy, a history of consumer surveillance and financial identity in America. And he says that by the 1830s, that credit system built on trust was starting to erode. The country was getting bigger and more interconnected. Suddenly, a wholesaler in New York could be selling on credit to a shopkeeper from hundreds of miles away with no way to know if they could be trusted to pay back their debt. The problem that as societies get bigger, modern societies have more strangers, more opportunities to interact with people we don't know.

5:52it becomes a problem because you can't identify people. You can't know that you can trust them or not trust them. This was an era of industrialization. Cities were growing rapidly and lenders in places like New York were interacting more and more with brand new borrowers they just didn't know. With credit, it really comes to a head early in the 19th century. Basically opens the door to this whole industry devoted to trying to figure out who everyone is. And the precipitating event was the Panic of 1837. You could probably tell by the name, but the Panic of 1837 was not a great time for business lenders.

6:30It was a major financial crisis that led to hundreds of banks collapsing, currency losing its value, and skyrocketing prices. Thousands of borrowers were left unable to pay their debts. It was sort of the wake-up call where merchants realized, you know, this is not working. The impact of the Panic of 1837 left creditors feeling a bit irpy on the whole concept of lending. But they didn't really have a choice. The economy ran on credit, and lenders were stuck. So one guy stepped in to make a risky bet a little safer for lenders. The great, great, great, great grandfather of the credit score, Louis Tappan.

7:08He was a well-known New York merchant and abolitionist. And he and his brother ran a silk wholesaling business. and it was nearly bankrupted in the panic of 1837. And he looked at this and said, you know, there's got to be a better way. As a businessman, Tappan knew that there was one thing he could provide that would help other businessmen make better lending decisions. Information. He wanted to make it easier for lenders to understand who they were actually dealing with and what they were getting themselves into. In 1841, Tappan founded a company called the Mercantile Agency. It was the first large-scale credit reporting service in the world.

7:48Their job was to collect useful financial data about credit seekers and sell it to lenders. They were mass-producing credit information. They were mass-producing reputational information. And they were doing it just by collecting and compiling public information. Tappan collected this information by using a network of confidential correspondents that were scattered across the country. These correspondents were mainly attorneys with some knowledge about their local business community. And Tappan had an innovative arrangement with them. When a new merchant came to New York seeking credit, Tappan would ask one of these local attorneys to collect a bunch of information on the merchant and then send it over to him at the mercantile agency.

8:29And they would do this work for free. And in exchange, if there was a debt default, so suppose one of these merchants in their community defaults and somebody wants to sue them, then the mercantile agency would send them a referral for the debt collection. The purpose of these credit reports was to help lenders decide whether a businessman was creditworthy. And at this time, creditworthiness was determined by the three C's, character, capacity and capital. Capital, obviously, was a person's property and assets, while capacity boiled down to a person's work experience. Were they successful or unsuccessful in business?

9:07Character was something squishier to define, and yet it was often the biggest factor when considering creditworthiness. Character was always the main component, details about the kind of person you were. Is this a person who's well-liked? Is this a person who is honest? It's just a person who is known to be lazy or known to be a drunkard or known to be somebody who is a gambler. And these were sort of the stereotypical sins for debtors. And so therefore you would not be a good risk. The findings would then get recorded into one of several intimidating ledger books housed at the Mercantile Agency's office.

9:43This information was highly sensitive, personal, and often embarrassing. So the mercantile agency came up with a creative, discreet way of delivering information to subscribers. And so if you wanted access to this information, if you were a subscriber to the mercantile agency, you would go to the office and you would tell the clerk, you know, that you wanted information about a particular person. And then the clerk would not give you a report. They would read to the subscriber from behind a screen so the subscriber could not see the ledger and, you know, see other things that they weren't supposed to see, sort of like a confessional.

10:17It is like a reverse priest. Yes, it is. Yes. Predictably, the small-time merchants being reported on did not like this system at all. A lot of what went into these credit reports were opinions, hearsay, and incredibly subjective. They hated them because they thought they were systems of espionage, that they were peddling in gossip about their personal lives, and that some information that would not necessarily be true, or even if it was true and wasn't necessarily germane to their business practices, could destroy them. The credit bureau also had no obligation to share what was in these reports with the person who was being reported on.

10:55One merchant found out that his report included a rumor that his wife was about to leave him. He ended up suing Tappen for libel, and that case went all the way up to the Supreme Court. But for the business community, the service that the mercantile agency provided was gold. One satisfied customer wrote in the New York Daily Times, quote,

11:19Pretty soon, other agencies followed suit, and an entire credit reporting industry was beginning to emerge. They start in New York City, but it quickly expands to Boston and Baltimore and Philadelphia. And you eventually have credit agencies throughout the United States. Within a few decades of the mercantile agency, the credit reporting industry wasn't just expanding, it was evolving in a really crucial way. When Tappan first established his credit reporting service, it specifically focused on commercial credit decisions. Credit seekers were generally men of business, looking to do business things.

11:59For the LinkedIn crowd, I believe this would be called B2B. It was a pretty narrow cross-section of the population. But shortly after the American Civil War, some merchants, grocers in particular, thought, hey, this credit reporting thing could be super helpful for us when we have new customers coming into our shops and paying by tab. Many small merchants have these sort of running open book accounts with lots of people in the neighborhood and no longer know who their customers are. Grocers are sort of at the front lines of this difficulty. So in response, consumer credit bureaus popped up to fill in the gap.

12:34These were agencies dedicated to finding out who the everyday customer was and whether they could pay their grocery tab. Now, it wasn't just businessmen who were being tracked in some credit bureau's intimidating ledger. It was the average customer. And it would only explode from there. Because if grocers created the consumer credit reporting industry, department stores would supercharge it. Here is the familiar 5 and 10. In a recent survey, women told us 55 % of their purchases in these stores were things they had no idea of buying until they saw them, touched them, felt them, handled them. The whole business model of the department store is that you have lots of sales and you have smaller margins, but you profit through volume.

13:21So department stores and cities are inviting the public to come in to their stores. And one of the ways that they can get them to buy things is to offer them credit accounts, charge accounts. Buying on credit was fast and convenient and how consumers wanted to pay. In order to keep up with all of this demand, department stores created their own formal credit departments, equipped with dedicated employees tasked with approving these new credit seekers. And one of the sort of key figures in the development of credit reporting is this character, the credit man. The rise of the credit man marked a new professionalization of the credit reporting industry.

13:59He was most likely a white guy in a nice suit who would sit across from new customers and determine whether they were worthy of a line of credit. Credit has been defined as man's confidence in man. Millions of people use credit to buy the things that add up to a better living. Well, there's sure a lot of things that I'd like to buy for better living. How about giving me a little credit? Nobody gives you credit, John. It's something you have to earn. And this gets back to the idea of character. And the real skill that the credit man has is not just bureaucratic and administrative. It's meeting with individual customers, sitting them down at his desk, and taking the credit application and in the process interrogating them, looking at them, trying to see if they're trustworthy or not.

14:46And so the credit man who becomes an expert, especially in department stores, is really an expert in interrogation of personal character, which is the foundation of credit worthiness. This is where the pure subjectivity of credit reporting was put on full display. As a credit seeker, you are basically subject to some guy's opinion about you, your life decisions, and yes, your sex and race. This is a time where the assumption is that women should not have their own credit accounts and they don't have their own credit accounts. So women have to have accounts opened in a man's name. And also this is a white credit culture.

15:26So if you are non-white, you absolutely are going to encounter trouble and probably not going to even try to get a credit account in a major department store in 1900. So it's deeply unfair. And it would remain unfair decades deep into the 20th century. As long as humans were the ones making these types of character judgments, human biases would always be a factor in credit access. But eventually, in the 1950s, one company made it possible to remove some of the human from the equation. In 1956, an engineer named William Fair teamed up with a mathematician named Earl Isaac. They wanted to develop a more efficient way of screening creditworthiness using computers.

16:09Together, they formed the company Fair Isaac & Company, but you'd probably recognize it by a different name, FICO. So the FICO score was created by Fair Isaac, the company, and it really developed out of efforts to develop a pre-screening program for pre-screened credit card offers. Around this time, mass market credit cards were being launched to the public, and credit card companies were itching for a way to get them into the hands of consumers faster, cheaper, and easier. With the rise of computerization in the 50s and 60s, statistical modeling was something that could finally be applied to screening creditworthiness.

16:50Rather than considering things like drinking habits, marital issues, or the cut of a person's jib, Fair Isaac believed it was much more effective to use a scorecard that evaluated the following categories. Payment history, the amount they owe, the length of their credit history, their recent credit applications, and the variety of their credit accounts. When that numerical information was plugged into their statistical model, it would spit out a clean, efficient number. This was the credit score. So I think from the perspective of lenders, they realized that this is a really effective tool. It can streamline the application process.

17:26It's an important piece of information that we can use. Credit scoring gradually caught on with some institutions, but it wasn't until 1974 that lenders became fully motivated to embrace less bigoted screening practices. Basically what happened is you have the passage of the Equal Credit Opportunity Act. And some lenders realized that if they use credit scores, they can use that as a way to defend against claims that they're discriminating. When Fair and Isaac came up with algorithmic credit scoring, they weren't necessarily looking for a way to cut racial bias from credit screening. But it did end up being used that way.

18:05The Equal Credit Opportunity Act made it illegal for lenders to deny credit based on gender, marital status, race, color, religion, and age, none of which went into FICO's scorecard. Credit managers suddenly realized that an objective algorithm them was a great way to avoid future lawsuits. By 1989, all the major consumer credit bureaus started working with FICO to adopt their own standardized scoring models. And by 1995, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac began using credit scores to screen mortgage applications. In a way, this was good. No one was going to deny you a mortgage because you happen to be a woman or not white.

18:43But it also gave the credit score a tremendous weight. And this is when credit scores really begin to appear in discussions, public discussions about how it's affecting everyone's life. Credit scores caught on because they do something that no credit man could do. They turn a person's entire financial history into a quantifiable number that is a fast, cheap, and pretty accurate prediction tool to calculate repayment. So landlords started using credit scores to screen renters. Utilities companies used them to determine deposits. And some insurance companies use them to set rates. And this pervasive reliance on credit scores might have been a good thing for consumers if it weren't for one major catch.

19:24They aren't nearly as unbiased as they seem. Now, the thing about credit scores is they were created supposedly as an objective way to analyze the raw data in a credit report. And they are in some ways an improvement over just looking at the raw data, but it didn't remove all of the problems with credit reports. This is Chi Chi Wu. She's the director of consumer reporting and data advocacy at the National Consumer Law Center. She says that the credit score addressed one kind of unfairness. It removes enough subjectivity that no one is denied credit just because the credit man doesn't like the way you look.

20:05But in the 30-plus years since the credit score became a fixture of American financial life, it has become clear that taking the subjectivity out of credit didn't actually fix the problem. It turns out reducing the entirety of someone's financial health and personal responsibility to a three-digit number might miss some important context. A credit score can show that objectively, maybe you missed some payments on a loan, but it can't explain why or that the reason might not have anything to do with your financial responsibility. There's this idea that credit scores are somehow a reflection of your moral character or how responsible you are.

20:46That's just not correct. People have impaired credit for lots of reasons, including that bad things happened to them, that they got sick, they got cancer, they were in an accident, they lost their job. I mean, in COVID, we saw millions of people lose their jobs. I see the fallout of all of that on credit reports. Another important piece of context that a credit score misses is that we don't all start off on the same level. Here in the U.S., we have a long history of racial discrimination that has put Black and Latino consumers at both a wealth and credit score disadvantage to white and Asian consumers.

21:27Treating every person equally, in this case, does nothing to correct that ingrained disadvantage. This country has had 400 years of slavery and decades of Jim Crow. And that has had an economic impact on Black and Latino consumers and their communities. And that inequality gets embedded in systems. So getting back to this idea that credit scores are objective, you know, they're an objective if everyone started off on a level playing field, but people don't start off on level playing fields. And Wu says that wouldn't necessarily be a problem if credit scores were just statistics, but they're not.

22:09They have real world impacts on people's lives. If they were just some sort of socioeconomic indicator, they would do a pretty good job. But the problem is then you take that indicator and you turn around and use it as a gatekeeper to things like credit, apartments, insurance, and employment. So the credit score inputs all of the impacts of unequal access to credit and a long history of discrimination and spits out a single number. And by using that number, lenders, whether intentionally or not, can embed that inequality deeper, even make it worse. Most Americans have a credit score whether we want one or not.

22:51It's a number that follows us around to every rental application, credit card, car loan, or home. Yet we have very little power within this system. This is actually a big reason why I wanted to look into the history of credit scores in the first place. Because when my identity got stolen, the most frustrating thing about watching my credit report get whacked out wasn't necessarily the number itself. It was realizing I had so little control over my own financial identity, even though I wasn't the one causing the damage. Fixing it within this system felt like an uphill battle. And a lot of the reason why comes down to the big three credit bureaus we are left with today.

23:32Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. The big three credit bureaus, we've described them as an oligopoly. They're more of a functional monopoly because consumers don't have any choice. You want a mortgage? You want an apartment? You want a credit card? You have to deal with Equifax. You're a captive. Your data is a captive. You have no choice but to have your data be part of their system and for them to make a lot of money off of it. For the first 100 plus years of credit reporting, there were literally thousands of regional credit bureaus across the country. But after decades of consolidation, nearly all of those regional credit bureaus have been gobbled up one by one until finally, by the 1980s, we were left with just three.

24:19And Wu says that this matters because when something goes wrong with our credit reports, the lack of competition means that the big three don't have very much incentive to fix it for you because you don't have any other options. One in five consumers has a verified error on their credit report. And one in 20 has an error so serious that it would cost them more or cause them to be denied credit. And for something as important as your credit history, having 1 in 20 consumers with a serious error is really bad. I mean, think about if 1 in 20 cars spontaneously burst into flames or 1 in 20 airplanes fell out of the sky.

25:06That would be bad. But let's just say that you're one of the lucky ones and all of the information on your credit report is accurate and up to date. This is still your personal data that these companies are selling. One of the most important things to understand about the credit bureaus is that you, the consumer, are not their customer. Their customers are the creditors and other businesses that both supply them with information and then in turn use that information, pull credit reports, and pay the credit bureaus for that. So the consumer isn't the customer. Our data is their commodity. You know, we're not we're not the diner.

25:51We're the chicken. And lastly, although these three companies have chosen to be the brokers of our very sensitive data, they suck at keeping it safe. I mean, you know, Equifax had a major breach 10 years ago and, you know, it's it's an ongoing problem. Josh Lauer again. It was a concern in the 1980s. I mean, as soon as these big credit bureaus had all of their files in databases, you know, the hackers were like, this would be a great place to, you know, steal information. And they hacked them. And there were breaches in the 1980s. In 2017, Equifax experienced one of the largest data breaches in U.S.

26:29history that compromised nearly half of Americans. If you're an American listening to this, there's a very good chance your identity was compromised too. And these security vulnerabilities have led to the credit bureaus themselves selling identity theft protection services to protect against the issues they caused. It's a perverse way that the companies that are taking your data and can't be trusted to keep it safe are selling consumers a service to help them keep it safe or help you keep yourself safe. So it's fairly twisted. Getting my identity stolen and having my credit score wielded for evil was a very stressful situation.

27:08And I can't say that researching the dark history of credit bureaus really helped with that anxiety. But ultimately, I was fine and learned a lot of useful information along the way. If something similar happens to you, try your best not to panic. We may not have consented to being a part of this system, but there are a few things that we can do to protect ourselves. Do you have any tips for someone like me who maybe had their identity compromised. I always tell everyone, make sure your credit's locked. This is Samir from Mercedes-Benz again. He says that even if we can't control whether our data is being bought and sold, we can prevent it from being used maliciously.

27:49You can and should put a freeze on your credit reports with the big three credit bureaus. Most lenders require a credit check. So if your credit report is frozen, they can't pull that information without your consent, Meaning no one is going to drive off in a Benz under your name. Your information is obviously already out there, right? You can't change your name. You can't change your date of birth. You can't change your social security number. So there's nothing you can do about it. But all you can do is make sure you have all your, you know, alerts on from those different websites, but also have everything locked.

28:20But mostly, don't be like me. Understand what your credit score means. Check it regularly. And remember that it's not a reflection of who you really are. It's just a number.

28:40After the break, Vivian is going to come back with some news you can use. Stay with us.

28:50A KFC tale in the pursuit of flavor. The colonel never wanted to be the reason customers finished a meal unsatisfied. so he created the$20 build a bucket meal with your choice of eight piece chicken or tenders four sides and four biscuits that way if you weren't happy he could say don't blame me you built it or more succinctly you played yourself the colonel lived so we could chicken the$20 build a bucket it's finger licking good prices and participation may vary taxes, tips and fees extra charge for breast piece substitution now smaller than ever more powerful more accurate meet Pod 6 The sixth generation of 8Sleep's award-winning sleep system.

29:29The pod is an intelligent mattress cover that transforms your existing bed. It cools and heats on each side of the bed from 55 degrees to 110 degrees. As you sleep, it also measures your sleep stages, heart rate, and breathing. Then acts on that in real-time adjusting temperature. All you have to do is sleep. Shop now at 8sleep.com. Hi, I'm Angie Hicks, co-founder of Angie. From roof repair to emergency plumbing and more, when you use Angie for your home projects, you know all your jobs will be done well. Angie, the one you trust to find the ones you trust. Find a pro for your project at Angie.com.

30:05You wouldn't take financial advice from a 72 hours in a single day alpha influencer, would you? Same goes if you're in a car accident or any accident. Who you choose matters. That's why Morgan & Morgan exists. They're the largest injury law firm in America, and they've built a reputation by actually winning cases. not just talking about it. Over 1 ,000 lawyers across all 50 states and$30 billion recovered. Injured? Go to forthepeople.com slash podcast. That's forthepeople.com slash podcast. So we're back with producer Vivian Lay. Hey, Vivian. Hi, Roman. So you just brought us this whole story about the history of credit reporting and the credit score, but now you're here to perform a little PSA for our listeners.

30:50Yeah. Yeah. So as you know, because I said it about 40 times throughout this episode already, I had originally pitched this story because I went through this identity theft situation. Yes. And you all on staff were along for the ride with me as this was happening in real time last year. Yes. This was all unfolding. And when I first started dealing with this issue, I kept saying to all of you, like, freeze your credit reports. And then all of you were like, what is that? And then I would explain. And then a few months later, I'd reiterated to the team, go freeze your credit reports, please. And then a surprising number of you asked again, what is that?

31:35And then, you know, we'd go through the various edit stages. And every time the topic came up, people were like, I still don't seem to really understand what you were talking about. And so you thought that this could actually be worth diving into more. That's right. Because the 9-9-PI staff is composed of a lot of really smart people. And a significant portion of the team could not quite grasp the significance of a credit freeze and what it was all about. And I figured that there's a lot of smart people who listen to this show who maybe do understand credit freeze. Probably a bunch of them don't understand credit freeze.

32:06And so we thought it would be a nice service to have you come on and step through the process with us. Right. Yeah. I believe one staffer compared it to being told that they should open up a Roth IRA account. I know this is something that I should do, but I don't quite understand why. So, yeah, it is so easy. It's so much easier than opening up a Roth IRA account. Although you should open up a Roth IRA too. Like if you're over the age of 18 and you've made any income, like open up a Roth IRA too. I swear to God, a dollar saved when you're 18 is worth so much more money than a dollar saved when you're 40-something years old.

32:42But anyway, let's talk about credit freezing. So we talk about this a little bit in the main story, but let's do a quick recap. What actually is a credit freeze? Yeah. So in the most basic terms, freezing your credit is just making sure that no one can check your credit report without asking first. Okay. But I'm actually going to start by backing it up a little bit. Now, you remember that there are three big consumer reporting bureaus. There's Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. And if you have a credit identity in the U.S., that means that there is most likely a credit report with your name on it sitting in the database of one of these three companies.

33:21Right. Lenders check your credit report through these three bureaus. And in the case of identity theft, someone else could use your credit report to take out debt in your name. Yes. But we as consumers actually have this very powerful tool, which is the credit freeze. And what the credit freeze does is that it basically blocks any new lenders from accessing your credit report. So they might try to check it, but they would be blocked and they wouldn't be able to view it until after you remove that freeze. Right, which is important because most lenders check your credit report before they grant you a line of credit.

33:54So if your social security number or your name and address gets leaked somewhere and someone attempts to use it to open up a credit card in your name, the credit card company still has to check your credit report. And if your credit report is frozen, it blocks that important step. Yes, exactly. And, you know, the freeze is a consumer tool that seems pretty obvious. Like this is your data. You should be able to restrict who sees it. But it's actually a relatively new feature in like the grand scheme of credit reporting. Around 2018, the major credit bureaus were required by law to make a credit freeze free and available for all consumers.

34:32And this is at least in part because of that big Equifax data breach in 2017. And this really is the main reason to freeze your credit reports because, you know, fun fact, someone gets their identity stolen every 4.9 seconds. So the main episode clocked in at about 28 minutes, meaning that over the course of listening, about 342 people have had their identity stolen. Oh, that's a lot. Yeah. But in the case of identity theft, a freeze is also important because of our credit scores. You remember that the FICO score is an algorithmic model that's impacted by a bunch of different financial factors.

35:12stuff like if you're paying on time, how long you've had a line of credit for, how much debt you're actually carrying, stuff like that. One of the factors that impacts your credit score is something called a hard inquiry. And this means that a lender actually pulled a copy of your credit report. So every time a lender pulls your credit report, that lowers your credit score because it indicates that you're, you know, applying for all of this new credit. So freezing your reports actually, you know, protects against that aspect of your credit score, too. Got it. OK, so now how does one actually freeze their credit?

35:48It's honestly annoying to have to do it, but it's, you know, actually really simple. And I say it's annoying because it should really be the default setting on your credit reports. So, you know, to freeze your credit reports, you have to do it individually with the major credit bureaus, which is, you know, really only the three of them, Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. And the first step is just signing up online for a free account with all three bureaus and, you know, verifying your identity. The weird thing about credit reporting is that even though, like, even if you have not signed up for, you know, like a TransUnion account, if you have a line of credit, like a credit card or something like that, you will still have a credit report in your name under TransUnion.

36:34So when you sign up for an account, you're sort of claiming dibs to the report that's already out there and associated with your identity. So yeah, so when you sign up, you could view your credit report. You could, you know, see if there's anything wrong on the credit report and you could dispute it like, oh, I've never lived at this address. Remove that. I didn't open up that credit card line. You could please take that off. So I highly suggest you do that if you haven't done that yet. The process is going to vary a little bit depending on what company you're actually using, like TransUnion, Equifax, Experian.

37:03Um, but once you sign up for an account, there's a dropdown option where you could just basically find freeze credit report through the websites and it'll take effect immediately. Um, you could also call the companies directly after you verify your identity. You could just like over the phone request a freeze. You could do it by mail too. Um, I personally have the apps for all three credit bureaus because I'm constantly monitoring my identity like a hawk. So I could just freeze and unfreeze my credit from my phone. and this is all free and you could do it an unlimited amount of times. Right, and so the freeze blocks people from accessing your report, but does it have any impact on other parts of your credit just generally?

37:45Like, can you still use your credit card? I mean, it has no impact on your credit or your credit score. So if you already have credit cards that are open, if you have a car lease or something like that, it has no impact on those whatsoever. It just blocks new lines of credit. So nothing changes. And say you, you know, you want to open up a new line of credit, like you want to walk into a Mercedes-Benz dealership and you actually want to get a lease on a new car. That does require a credit check. And what you could do is just ask the dealer, what credit bureau do you use? And so you could freeze and unfreeze your credit on the spot.

38:22They could pull your credit report. You could freeze it back up. And it's really that easy and it's really that immediate. So there's no reason not to take advantage of something like this. I think when you say like freeze your credit report, I think people think of it as freezing their credit cards, like making it so they can't be used maybe. And that's one of the reasons why people are confused. But this is very simple. All it stops is from somebody taking out a bunch of money in your name. Yeah, yeah. It's really that easy. There's no reason not to keep it frozen. It keeps the control in your hands.

38:52Yeah, yeah. Well, I am sorry that it took our staff so long to catch on to what you were talking about. But I thank you for the lesson. It was a hard lesson for me to learn, but I'm happy to spread the news.

39:29John, Joe Rosenberg, Jacob Medina-Gleason, Talon and Rain Stradley, and me, Roman Mars. The 99 % of the logo was created by Stephan Lawrence. We are part of the SiriusXM podcast family, now headquartered six blocks north in the Pandora Building, in beautiful uptown Oakland, California. You can find us on all the usual social media sites as well as our own Discord server. There's a link to that as well as every past episode of 99PI at 99PI.org.

40:12We'll be right back.

40:29pain and damages were worse than expected. When someone hurts you, you deserve to be compensated fairly. Morgan & Morgan is America's largest injury law firm, fighting for the people for over 35 years. Injured? Visit forthepeople.com slash podcast. That's forthepeople.com slash podcast. Their fee is free unless they win. Imagine relying on a dozen different software programs to run your business. None of which are connected. Some say Odoo is like a magic beanstalk, scaling with you while being magically affordable. And some say Odoo's programs for manufacturing and accounting and more are like building blocks.

41:02And they're all connected on one platform. Doesn't Odoo sound amazing? Let Odoo harmonize your business with simple, efficient software that can handle everything for a fraction of the price. Sign up today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

From the publisher

A credit score is essentially a three digit number that here in the US usually ranges from 300-850. It's a metric that lenders can use to predict your ability to pay back a loan. The higher the number, the more likely you are to be approved for lines of credit. In the United States, your credit score decides where you can live, what car you can drive and whether you can get a loan. It’s supposed to be objective—a precise, omniscient accounting of your financial health, but what started as a simple tool for lenders ended up embedding itself in the lives of most Americans, and feeding the same bias it claimed to solve.

Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ to listen to new episodes of 99% Invisible ad-free and a whole week early.

Start a free trial now on Apple Podcasts or by visiting siriusxm.com/podcastsplus.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from 99% Invisible

All episodes