


How Berkeley Hills’ “garden city” architecture and dense landscaping—rooted in early 1900s arts-and-crafts ideals—became a wildfire hazard, and how a 2025 Berkeley policy (“Ember Ordinance,” Zone Zero/home ignition zone) tries to reverse that legacy.
Emmett Fitzgerald (99% Invisible producer; returns to tell a “Not Built for This”-style story). Michel Thuati (Berkeley Hills homeowner; UC Berkeley grad; Navy brat; spent years building a lush garden; later becomes a Firewise organizer). David Mostardi (historian of the Berkeley Hillside Club). Dave Winokur (retired wildland firefighter/fire risk expert advising Ember). Brent Blackaby (Berkeley Hills city councilmember who pushed Ember). Jack Cohen (wildfire scientist who developed “defensible space,” referenced).
Wildfires often ignite homes via embers, so removing flammables within five feet (“Zone Zero”) reduces ignition risk. The Hillside Club’s principles (wood shingling, shrubs up to walls, seamless house-garden continuity) increased vulnerability.
1923 Berkeley Hills fire destroying Maybeck-designed homes; opposition on Nextdoor/recall efforts; Ember passing 9-0; Michel’s 150+ pre-inspections, volunteer clearing events, and replacing wooden fences with metal.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Introduction to Emmett Fitzgerald and the connection to previous series.
“Then this is a job for Indeed-sponsored jobs.”
Michel Thuati shares his childhood dreams and first impressions of Berkeley.
“Michel Thuati had been dreaming of California since childhood.”
Michel discusses the journey of turning his home into a dream space.
“I remember being absolutely awed by that phenomenal richness of plants.”
The growing concern about wildfire risks and its impact on Michel's life.
“But after grad school, Michel and his wife managed to find a fixer-upper that they could afford.”
Exploring the architectural history and development in the Berkeley Hills.
“And as he did more research, Michel began wading into a contentious debate that is playing out all across California about how to adapt our homes and communities for an era of increasingly extreme wildfire risk.”
Discussion on architect Bernard Maybeck and his vision for Berkeley.
“one that was more attuned to the area's unique landscape.”
How architectural choices in Berkeley Hills contributed to wildfire hazards.
“Maybach considered architecture to be as much an art form as a practical trade, And he thought that buildings should, above all else, be beautiful.”
Explore the historical context and design flaws that led to wildfire risks in Berkeley.
“and there a tower or a glimpse of roof to tell of the city underneath, a city of homes in an immense garden.”
Learn about the devastating fire of 1923 and its impact on the community.
“A fire started in the afternoon up the hill.”
Discover Michel Thuati's journey with his garden amidst increasing fire risk.
“But if you get rid of all that flammable stuff, then the ember threat goes way down.”
Understand the concept of defensible space and its importance for home safety.
“But the thing about defensible space is that it really only works if everyone around you does it too.”
Learn about the introduction of the Ember Ordinance and its impact on local regulations.
“And it just that responsibility, I just I couldn't live with myself if we just sort of said, hey, well, we're going to hope for the best.”
Explore how the Ember Ordinance aims to create a buffer against wildfires in high-risk zones.
“And Dave says that Ember makes an exception for mature trees, but otherwise you can have nothing flammable in Zone Zero at all.”
Examine the divided community response to the Ember Ordinance and its implications.
“When Michel Thuadi and his neighbors in the Firewise group heard about the Ember Ordinance, they were thrilled.”
Witness the tensions and debates surrounding the Ember Ordinance at city council meetings.
“Neighbors butted heads for months until a final vote was scheduled at the city council.”
Learn about the intense community discussion surrounding the Ember Ordinance and its implications.
“disturbance, speaking out of turn or in violation of applicable rules.”
Hear about the practical challenges and community efforts in implementing fire safety measures after the Ember Ordinance.
“The Ember Ordinance passed in June of 2025.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On 99% Invisible, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Some of the most important design choices are the ones that go unnoticed. The details that together make an experience feel intuitive, comfortable, and above all, exhilarating. At Acura, that means looking closely at how every detail can make your experience behind the wheel more rewarding. Every lesson learned and every idea refined becomes part of what comes next, and it lives inside every MDX, ADX, and Integra. That's precision crafted performance. That's Acura.
0:57That's indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed-sponsored jobs. This is 99 % Invisible. I'm Roman Mars. A couple years back, 99PI producer Emmett Fitzgerald created a series called Not Built for This. It was all about how the world we currently live in was not designed for the weather it's starting to experience. Emmett is back this week with an episode that has a lot in common with that series. And it takes place very close to 99PI headquarters in Berkeley, California. I'll let Emmett take it from here.
1:42Emmett Fitzgerald: Michel Thuati had been dreaming of California since childhood. As a little French kid, he was obsessed with cowboys and big mountains and the American West. And so when he finally arrived in Berkeley in 1984, he was totally prepared to fall in love with the place. But still, there was one thing in particular that exceeded his high expectations. The gardens. I remember being absolutely awed by that phenomenal richness of plants. Almost anything can be grown around here, you know, so the variety, the colors, the textures were extraordinary. It was almost like being in a fairy tale, you know, for me.
2:25Emmett Fitzgerald: Michel was a Navy brat. He grew up bouncing around French naval bases, many of them in North Africa. These were hot, dusty places without much in the way of vegetation. And looking at Berkeley was such a change, the lushness of the landscaping. Michel had come to California for a graduate program at UC Berkeley. And his advisor had a beautiful house up in the Berkeley Hills with an incredible view of the Golden Gate. And every time that Michel went over for dinner, he would look at the sun setting behind the bridge and think, someday I want this view for myself. I didn't really think I would ever be able to have it, but now I do.
3:11Emmett Fitzgerald: The Berkeley Hills are an expensive place to live. But after grad school, Michel and his wife managed to find a fixer-upper that they could afford. And we essentially spent the next 10 years investing every minute that we had and every dollar into turning the house into a place that we liked living in. The most important home improvement project for Michel was the yard. He planted a lush, unruly garden, just like the ones he fell in love with when he first got to Berkeley. There were dense blocks of shrubs right against the sides of the house, persimmon trees and figs, jasmine vines crawling up the walls.
3:54Emmett Fitzgerald: And Michel loved it. All was well in the garden, at least for a little while. A fresh look at the damage from the CZU lightning complex fire raging in Santa Cruz County. Between 2015 and 2020, California experienced 10 of the most destructive wildfires in its history. One of the biggest fires is threatening the city of Calistoga. And as fire risk grew more and more omnipresent in the psychology of Californians, Michelle's wife started to get nervous about their verdant hilltop dream home. It was around 2020. My wife realized the problems about wildfire much earlier than I did. So I was in total denial early on.
4:42Emmett Fitzgerald: At one point, Michelle's wife even suggested that they consider moving out of the hills and down into the flatter parts of Berkeley that were less vulnerable to fire. But Michelle was having none of it. Then I said, look, I'm going to research this and I'm going to prove it to you that you're wrong and that we're totally safe. And we know how it turned out because we weren't safe at all. It turned out that Michel's neighborhood was actually extremely vulnerable to wildfire. And part of the reason why was precisely because of all those lush gardens that had attracted him to the area in the first place.
5:22Emmett Fitzgerald: And as he did more research, Michel began wading into a contentious debate that is playing out all across California about how to adapt our homes and communities for an era of increasingly extreme wildfire risk. In Berkeley, it would eventually bubble over. There would be recall campaigns and accusations flying around online. But to understand how it all got so tense, it helps to know a bit more about the area. Because it's not just that these gardens are central to the character of the Berkeley Hills. It's that they're part of a very specific architectural history that has roots going back more than 100 years.
6:07Emmett Fitzgerald: Berkeley, California is synonymous with 1960s counterculture. But the city's bohemianism actually began long before the free speech movement and the Vietnam War. All the way back in the 1890s, Berkeley was a hotbed for artists and poets and intellectuals. Around the turn of the 20th century, a number of these free thinkers began moving up into the hills above the University of California, Berkeley, which at the time were grasslands speckled with oak trees. And as more and more people started to build houses up there, they formed a social organization that tried to shape what the development would look like.
6:47Emmett Fitzgerald: It was called the Berkeley Hillside Club. The Berkeley Hillside Club was founded in 1898 by a group of Berkeley women who fundamentally were interested in preventing the Berkeley hillsides from being disfigured. This is David Mostardi, who is the historian of the Hillside Club, which is still active to this day. And David says that the club's definition of disfigurement was basically what had happened just across the bridge in San Francisco. When San Francisco's famous hills were developed for the first time, they just laid a perfectly rectangular street grid down on the landscape and built Victorian gingerbread houses up and down the steep slopes.
7:30And the women at the Hillside Club felt that this was a desecration of what California had to offer.
7:37Emmett Fitzgerald: The members of the Hillside Club wanted a different kind of architecture for the Berkeley Hills, one that was more attuned to the area's unique landscape. And they found the perfect architect to realize that vision in an eccentric New Yorker named Bernard Maybeck. Maybeck was a bohemian sort of fellow. Gray Breckin, the historian, calls Maybeck the first hippie, you know, 80 years before the other hippies came to town. Maybeck trained at the École des Beaux-Arts in Paris before arriving in the Bay Area with his wife Annie in 1890. And Maybeck was a genuine oddball. He had a long, dwarven beard, and often dressed in red robes he sewed himself.
8:24Emmett Fitzgerald: When his first child was born, Maybeck called the baby boy, until the age the kid was old enough to choose a name for himself. And Maybeck's diet was like that of a teenage art school student. Somebody in a recent article said he was a vegetarian. He was not. He lived on fried potatoes, coffee, and donuts. This is Maybeck's daughter-in-law, Jacomina, in an interview with the Berkeley Historical Society. Jacomina also lived in the Berkeley Hills, and she frequently stopped by for coffee with the red-robed potato eater. I could not keep up with him, and I could not interpret everything he said. He was a great reader, and he threw it all in together like a big soup.
9:12Emmett Fitzgerald: Maybach was a Renaissance man. In one of the only remaining recorded interviews with him, he implores architects to seek inspiration outside the confines of their profession. From history, from different countries, and literature, and the theater, all those ideals you are to absorb. Maybach considered architecture to be as much an art form as a practical trade, And he thought that buildings should, above all else, be beautiful. Beauty is the essence of architecture. In other words, it isn't a question of the man living in the building or whether he has a refrigerator and all that sort of thing.
10:01But it's the man in the street who has to look at your building when it's done.
10:10Emmett Fitzgerald: Bernard Maybeck designed many beautiful buildings in a wide variety of styles, but his most enduring legacy might be the arts and crafts houses that he built in the Berkeley Hills. The idea of the arts and crafts movement was to simplify architecture back to its basics, to move away from the excess of the Industrial Revolution and Victorian-era frippery, and to build simple, beautiful structures that were in tune with the natural world around them. Maybeck's first commission in Berkeley was for a writer named Charles Keillor. And the house that he built, Keillor, was like a wooden temple. It had a steep vaulted ceiling with chunky exposed redwood beams.
10:53Emmett Fitzgerald: And in what would become a signature of Berkeley architecture, the exterior of the house, including the roof, was clad entirely in wooden shingles. Keillor, for his part, adored the house, and he bragged about it to anyone who would listen. In fact, he became something of a propagandist for Maybeck's arts and crafts vision. One of his most influential pieces, if not the most influential piece he ever wrote, was a book called The Simple Home. Keillor published The Simple Home in 1904. And around the same time, he was elected president of the Berkeley Hillside Club. And it became a manifesto of sorts for the Hillside Club.
11:34So basically, here's how you go about building a house in the Berkeley Hills.
11:41Emmett Fitzgerald: Bernard Maybeck was also a member of the Hillside Club by this point, and he and Keeler helped shape the organization's philosophy about architecture and also landscape. One of the primary tenets of this philosophy was that all new development in the hills should respect the area's unique geology. Instead of the symmetrical grid that had been laid down on San Francisco's hills, roads in Berkeley should be carved into the contours of the hillside. If there was a rock in the way... You don't blow the rock up into smithereens and go straight through. You go around the rock. If there's a huge old oak tree in the way, you go around the tree.
12:21You're integrating all of these things into the architecture and the landscape.
12:26Emmett Fitzgerald: The club had very specific recommendations for anyone who wanted to buy a house on the hill. David pulled out a pamphlet from this era that the Hillside Club gave to prospective homebuyers. This is the landscape architecture pamphlet from 1996. It's a beautiful document. It's a beautiful piece, yeah. Flipping through, I was surprised by just how much of the text was devoted to gardening. To the Hillside Club, the garden was the most important feature of any property, more important even than the house, which the pamphlet jokes was really only necessary as protection from inclement weather. This is the famous line, Hillside architecture is landscape gardening around a few rooms for use in case of rain.
13:14Emmett Fitzgerald: The idea was to have a complete continuity between the house and the garden, a seamless transition between indoors and outdoors. The club called for extensive planting of trees and shrubs right up to the edge of the house. They wanted figs and plums with trailing willows and ivy-covered walls. The pamphlet was an invitation to partner with the Hillside Club and help turn the Berkeley Hills into a lush California Arcadia. It reads, With the help of the Hillbuyer, the Hillside Club can lay out on the Berkeley Hills a perfect landscape, connecting green canyons with piling green forests, making of the barren place as a park, with only here and there a tower or a glimpse of roof to tell of the city underneath, a city of homes in an immense garden.
14:11Emmett Fitzgerald: The only problem with the Hillside Club's beautiful dream of a garden city was that the Berkeley Hills are a landscape that is meant to burn. And the earthy design principles that shaped the development of the hills were pretty much a nightmare from the perspective of wildfire risk. The wood-shingled houses were highly flammable, the twisted streets were hard to evacuate, and the dense, lush gardens grown right next to the house were the perfect fire fuel. Maybeck and company had unintentionally built a lush, idyllic fire trap. And in 1923, the inevitable happened. It all happened on one afternoon.
14:53This is September 17th, 1923. In fact, the Hillside Club was going to have its annual dinner that night.
15:01Emmett Fitzgerald: A fire started in the afternoon up the hill. and within six hours, it had burned all the way down to the flat parts of Berkeley. The fire destroyed many of the houses that Maybeck designed, including his own, and the Hillside Club's clubhouse, which he also designed, burned to the ground. In the following decades, the hills were rebuilt, and there were gestures towards fire safety. Many of the homes were remade with stucco rather than wood. And Maybeck himself started experimenting with fire-safe materials. But much of the Hillside Club's arts and crafts vision, and particularly the dense and beautiful gardens, remain intact to this day.
15:47Emmett Fitzgerald: When Michel Thuati first got to Berkeley in the 80s, it was this vision that he fell in love with. And over the years, he grew a garden that Bernard Maybeck would be proud of. It even had a few rooms in case of rain. But by 2020, he was becoming increasingly worried about fire risk. By this point, insurance rates in the hills were starting to skyrocket, and anxiety about fire was widespread. And so Michel did what he does best. I'm a thorough person. I have a little bit of OCD sometimes. And so I read, for a year and a half, I read every single paper on what I discovered was called Wildfire Science, probably four, five, 600 articles, I got in touch with some of the most prominent wildfire scientists in the country.
16:36Emmett Fitzgerald: And they all told him the same thing, that his home was in a high fire risk area and that the garden that he had grown right against the side of the house was only exacerbating that risk. It took me basically 2020 to 2022 to move to a psychological point when I was ready to actually do things. So in 2022, I realized that we had to change and I started slowly making changes. Michel learned that the most effective steps he could take to mitigate that risk would be to harden his home to wildfire and create what's called defensible space. Defensible space is a concept that was developed by a wildfire scientist named Jack Cohen.
17:20Emmett Fitzgerald: We actually did a whole episode about him that you can find back in the archives. But the idea at its simplest was that if you get rid of all the flammable stuff around a house, you make it much less likely for the house itself to catch on fire. Contrary to what many people imagine, in most cases wildfires do not consume houses in a tidal wave of flame. It's much more likely that a house catches on fire because of a single ember. As a fire burns, it launches a blizzard of embers into the air. They drift along on the wind, and if one lands on the dead leaves in your gutter, or the weeds growing in your alley, or the dry grass landscaping out front, it can easily burn down your entire house.
18:05Emmett Fitzgerald: But if you get rid of all that flammable stuff, then the ember threat goes way down. For Michel, this was going to be very difficult, because he had a lot of plants growing around his house. Well, you really couldn't see the bottom 10 feet of the wall pretty much anywhere because it was absolutely covered with shrubs. But Michel started hacking away. He cut down a lot of plants and transplanted others further away from the structure. It was hard work physically and emotionally. He had spent a lot of time and effort growing that garden. and he had deep feelings about many of the plants. The fig tree particularly.
18:47The fig tree, fig trees have a smell. I can smell a fig tree sometimes from 200 or 300 yards away and walking in my garden every time I would smell the fig tree and cutting it was very difficult.
19:02Emmett Fitzgerald: As painful as it was, Michel was committed and little by little he relandscaped the entire property with defensible space in mind. But the thing about defensible space is that it really only works if everyone around you does it too. Wildfire experts love to say that what most determines whether your house will burn down in a fire is whether your neighbor's house burns down. And so Michel started organizing with his neighbors. They created a series of fire-wise groups and began working together to try to make the entire neighborhood safer. Still, they didn't have any real political power to mandate changes.
19:42Emmett Fitzgerald: And so while they made some progress on defensible space with some houses, many other gardens remained overgrown and dangerous. Around this time, a new city councilor was elected to represent the Berkeley Hills. His name was Brent Blackaby. And on the surface, he didn't seem like a transformational political figure. On the campaign, he talked about the issues that every California politician seems to talk about. Building more housing, dealing with homelessness. Blackaby knew that wildfire was an issue in the hills, but just a few weeks into the job, the stakes were made very clear when the city of Los Angeles experienced the most destructive fire in its history.
20:27This morning, the firestorm officials had feared becoming a reality.
20:31Emmett Fitzgerald: In the coastal neighborhood Pacific Palisades, multiple homes completely engulfed in flames, with desperate residents rushing to get out. The parallels between the Berkeley Hills and the Palisades were obvious to Blackaby. They're both coastal hillside communities with perilous fall winds. And as he watched the Palisades burn on the news, Blackaby felt a growing sense of terror. Yeah, I mean, it was scary. I think you always kind of knew from an academic perspective, intellectual perspective, yeah, this is my responsibility. But it became really real, driving through the neighborhood, walking around with my kids.
21:08And it just that responsibility, I just I couldn't live with myself if we just sort of said, hey, well, we're going to hope for the best.
21:16Emmett Fitzgerald: At this point, the state of California was considering updates to state level defensible space rules. But it was taking a long time. And Blackaby was anxious to get moving. He got together with a small group of politicians and members of the fire department to talk about how to respond. And kind of the consensus in our little small group is like, this is the time. This is a wake-up call for us. We just can't afford to wait any longer. The risks just pile up. And if we're always going to wait for someone else to do it, we're never going to do it. Let's just go. And so shortly after getting into office, Blackaby introduced a bold new wildfire adaptation plan for the Berkeley Hills.
21:58Emmett Fitzgerald: An initiative called the Ember Ordinance. And there's a number of things to it, but the big one is Zone Zero, or the home ignition zone, which is the space within five feet of a structure. And that area has to be free of any combustible material of any kind. This is Dave Winokur. He's a retired wildland firefighter and a fire risk expert who was brought in to help with the rollout of the Ember Ordinance. And Dave says that Ember makes an exception for mature trees, but otherwise you can have nothing flammable in Zone Zero at all. No shrubs, no jute doormats, no wooden gates. Nothing burnable within five feet of the structure.
22:40Emmett Fitzgerald: In other words, basically the exact opposite of the vision laid out in that Hillside Club pamphlet over 100 years ago. Instead of a seamless transition between the house and the garden, the ordinance essentially calls for a protective moat of lifelessness around every home. Dave says that they knew this was going to be a hard sell. And so since this is so hard, and because the margin of failure is so thin at the individual parcel level or at the neighborhood level, it's critical that we focus on the absolute smallest possible distribution of the least amount of work to be effective. The fire department carefully selected a zone of about 950 homes right along the edge of Tilden Park, where a fire was most likely to start.
23:29Emmett Fitzgerald: This was a tactical choice to try and create a buffer between the city and the park. That way, if a wildfire were to start in Tilden, it would be much harder for the embers to catch houses on fire and burn down the entire hillside. In this high-risk zone, the ordinance also calls on residents to do things like install gutter guards and cover their vents with metal mesh to prevent embers from getting inside the house itself. And if we can get everyone in those areas to do everything, we will achieve the state of wildfire adaptation and we will form a non-burnable buffer by virtue of this program so that the other 10 ,000 homes that live downhill, there's about 950 up at the top and there's about 10 ,000 that are downstream.
24:18Those 10 ,000 are now free riders. That's a pretty good deal. That's achievable.
24:24Emmett Fitzgerald: When Michel Thuadi and his neighbors in the Firewise group heard about the Ember Ordinance, they were thrilled. We were overjoyed. You know, we thought this plan could actually save the neighborhood. But very quickly, we realized that the support was definitely not uniform. Right away, an angry debate broke out on the famously friendly platform Nextdoor. On the one side, you had people like Michel cheering their bold, progressive city councilor, who had the courage to act decisively. And on the other side, you had a lot of residents who were extremely pissed off that someone was forcing them to cut down their beloved Bougainvillea.
25:07Opposition was very, very strong and sometimes difficult to deal with. I've always felt at home in California ever since I arrived here. And one of the reasons I felt so at home is that people are mellower. And it was the first time that I was seeing a very bitter debate when that wasn't true, where personal attacks were rampant. For yourself, too? For myself, too.
25:35One of the big opponents of this rule has accused me on Nextdoor of having a landscaping business from which I'm profiting. You know, I never made a cent from any of this.
25:52Emmett Fitzgerald: The critics of Ember had a lot of very specific complaints with the ordinance. They worried that removing plants would cause erosion and lead to habitat loss. They argued that it was unfair for the city to single out this one group of residents to make all the hard sacrifices. And besides, the state of California was already working on its own Zone Zero regulations. Why did Berkeley feel the need to preempt the state? But fundamentally, I think this all got so emotional because people were understandably attached to a vision of the Berkeley Hills that goes back all the way to the days of Maybeck.
26:30Emmett Fitzgerald: They chose to live in a hillside garden city for a reason. And even if most residents knew that climate change was real and fire risk was escalating, the Ember Ordinance just felt like too much change. too fast. And at first, Michel had a lot of sympathy for this. And I understood very well that you can't go from loving your garden to having to radically change it quickly. It's impossible. You have to go through a period of grief and acceptance and all such things. It's very, very difficult. It took me a long time. It took me a year and a half to accept the fact that I had to make changes. So I totally understood that it would be difficult for some people.
27:15Emmett Fitzgerald: But Michel naively thought that once they had been presented with the science, his neighbors would be persuaded of the logic, that they would go through the same conversion process he had. Yet, as the year went on, the debate about the Ember Ordinance only got more heated. A new organization called the Alliance for Practical Fire Solutions launched a recall campaign of Rent Blackaby. Neighbors butted heads for months until a final vote was scheduled at the city council. When the Ember Ordinance came up on the agenda, the mayor read out a special disclaimer, warning people about behavior that would not be tolerated.
27:57Shouting, making disruptive noises such as boos or hisses, creating or participating in a physical disturbance, speaking out of turn or in violation of applicable rules. Just like that. That's a hiss. Not allowed.
28:08Emmett Fitzgerald: The debate lasted for over two hours. And if you're imagining over-the-top testimonials from residents who thought that getting rid of their ornamental grapevine was the worst thing to happen since 9-11, well... I'm reminded of 9-11. There was a terrible attack on our country. And in the rush to judgment, they bombed Iraq. There were also warnings that this draconian policy was just the first step down a slippery slope towards fascism, and that people should resist the tyranny of their local government. I'm not letting anybody inspect my property. Go get a warrant.
28:52Emmett Fitzgerald: But I have to say, I was surprised at the level of support for the Ember Ordinance in the room that night, including from people who lived in the mitigation area. Many of the residents who were going to have to do the most work to comply were begging the city council to vote yes. I live in a wood shingled house. I don't have the money to change the siding. I'm working on defensible space. The science makes sense to me. And global warming is something that I believe is actually happening. I don't want to end up like the Pacific Palisades or Altadena. And I see this as an extremely critical thing to saving my home, if it can be saved.
29:41And I support Ember. Please vote for that. Thank you. Thank you.
29:50Emmett Fitzgerald: In the end, the city councilors were convinced that even though this was a hard pill to swallow, it was worth it to try and keep the city safe. The Ember Ordinance passed with a 9-0 vote.
30:06After the break, we head back to Michelle's neighborhood to see what it's like to put a policy like Ember into practice.
30:19This episode is supported by Anthropic, the team behind Claude. Every design thing began as something someone imagined. a chair, a sign, whatever device you're listening to this on. Design is imagination with a plan. Claude is an AI built to help you with both. Start with your rough idea, then work with Claude to sketch it, shape it, test it, and build it. Anthropic built Claude to help you discover more. Learn more at claude.ai slash 99invisible. When your mental health is suffering, therapy can help. But sometimes it's not the whole answer. Talkiatry gives you access to real psychiatric care with licensed clinicians who can diagnose and prescribe medication if it's right for you.
31:04It's a simple way to get effective treatment right from home. Talkiatry is a 100 % online psychiatry practice that provides comprehensive evaluations, diagnoses, and ongoing medication management for conditions like ADHD, anxiety, depression, and more. You can meet with a licensed psychiatrist who takes the time to understand what's going on, builds a personalized treatment plan, and supports you over time with consistent, evidence-based care. All 800-plus clinicians are in-network with major insurers, so you can use your existing insurance instead of paying monthly subscriptions or out-of-network costs.
31:40Head to talkiatry.com slash invisible to complete the short assessment and get matched with an in-network psychiatrist in just a few minutes. That's T-A-L-K-I-A-T-R-Y dot com slash invisible to get matched in minutes. Takayatri dot com slash invisible. Support for this episode comes from Amazon Business. When it comes to your business, procurement shouldn't be a guessing game. Whether you're running a small business or managing a large organization, Amazon Business offers smart purchasing experiences designed to meet your unique needs. Smart tech, smarter decisions. Streamline your buying process, save time and money, and gain valuable insights.
32:21Amazon Business empowers you and your team to buy with confidence. Learn more at AmazonBusiness.com. The best pieces in your closet are the ones you can count on, whether you're heading to work, going out, or keeping things casual. And this time of year, Quince makes finding something great for everyone else just as easy. Quince focuses on high-quality staples made with premium materials like 100 % Mongolian cashmere, 14-karat gold, and Italian leather. All timeless, versatile pieces that feel special to unwrap and become everyday favorites long after the holidays. I'm a huge fan of the whole line of Quince sweaters.
32:58I have button-up ones, zip-up ones, black, gray, brown. I use them when I just go upstairs, when I get on a call, when I take the dog for a walk. These are favorites that everyone would love. Give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, let them know that it was 99 % invisible. It's the best way to support the show.
33:31Emmett Fitzgerald: We are back with Amit Fitzgerald. The Ember Ordinance passed in June of 2025. And a little over a year later, the state of California finally released its own statewide fire safety regulations. They're not as stringent as Ember, but they apply to a wider swath of the Berkeley Hills, meaning that even more people will have to get to work clearing out vegetation in Zone Zero. One of the biggest challenges here will be financial. Berkeley residents either have to do this work themselves or pay for it out of pocket, and not everyone can afford professional landscaping. Michel Thuati knows this is true.
34:12Emmett Fitzgerald: And so he and some of his friends in the Firewise group have been doing everything they can to help. We had that big clearing event. We had 350 volunteers working on clearing and rock mulching. We did a ton of rock mulching and all those things. And it's not that hard, you know, but, you know, when you're 86 and you've lived here for 42 years and you're starting to forget things a little bit, this is not something you can do on your own. They hosted a Gates and Fences Day, where contractors came to show off different non-flammable fences. And an anonymous donor offered to help pay for the installation costs.
34:50Emmett Fitzgerald: And we had 200 homeowners showing up, and to this day I'm still getting emails about it, going, oh, can I get the handout? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So it really paid off. Michel is also helping run an informal assessment program, where he or another Firewise member will come to your house before your official inspection from the fire department and give you an honest take about how you're doing. Michel says he's done over 150 of these, and he's gotten good at delivering the good news with the bad. He'll congratulate you on replacing your wooden gate, and then gently point out that the ivy growing against your chimney is probably going to have to go.
35:32Emmett Fitzgerald: He compared this work to a vaccine rollout. It's only going to work if they can get as many people as possible to buy in. I wish we could convince more people to let us help them, if that makes sense to you. Right, because I mean, there's a lot at stake. Yes, yes. And it's for them and also for us, quite frankly. There are two, both dimensions apply. It's very helpful to them, but it's also very helpful to the neighborhood. You know, herd immunity. Some people are still refusing to do the work. And Michel says that's why the mandatory aspect of Ember is key. The fire department wants to give residents time, but eventually they will start fining people for noncompliance.
36:22Emmett Fitzgerald: Ultimately, the most important arbiter of the success of the policy will likely be the insurance industry. Here's City Council Member Brent Blackaby again. You know, 18 months from now, when we've got a lot of our neighbors who've done the mitigation work, are the insurance companies ready to take all of this work and properly give attribution and credit to our residents for doing this hard work and make sure it shows up at the insurance rates? Blackaby is actively negotiating with insurance companies, and he's hopeful that they will recognize the risk reductions created by Ember and lower rates throughout his district.
36:58The insurance companies are saying, look, if you can actually do this across this entire landscape and get 60, 70, 80 percent of people in a neighborhood to do this work, it will look a lot different. Our response to that risk will look a lot different than it does now.
37:16Emmett Fitzgerald: On the day I visited Michelle, some contractors were putting the final touches on a brand new metal fence. So you're seeing basically it's almost done, but not quite done. Now, I gotta say, it looks pretty nice. It looks nice. It looks nice. And it's actually a very cost-effective way to build fencing. Looking around, it's obvious how much time and money Michel has put into making his own house more fire safe. He ripped out a massive wooden fence, rebuilt retaining walls, rock-mulched paths, and moved countless plants further away from the house, out of zone zero. So have you gotten your inspection yet?
37:55Not yet, but I'm sure I'm going to pass.
38:03Emmett Fitzgerald: Michel says that while there is still quite a lot of anger flying around online, you don't notice it as much on the ground. And quietly, little pockets of compliance have started to spread. He says that when the neighbors immediately around you are doing all the work, the work itself becomes less intimidating. You can ask your neighbor how to replant a shrub, or get a phone number for a contractor who might be able to help you out with your fence. Michel is clearly energized by the challenge of trying to reimagine the landscape to better fit the reality of our increasingly fiery world. Fundamentally, the landscape design today can't be the same as the one that was there in the 1920s, which is what we're all using.
38:49Emmett Fitzgerald: You're talking about kind of the aesthetic ideals that May Beck and the Hillside Club and these people. Exactly, exactly. So that everything modern would disappear behind nature and nature would be flourishing and otherworldly, etc. And they did a magnificent job. I love every one of those places. But you can't do this anymore. What you have to do is the opposite. Instead of integrating the home and the garden, you have to decouple them, surround the house with rocky paths, and move the plants further away. Adapting to wildfire means a complete rethink of the landscape architecture principles laid out by Bernard Maybeck and the Hillside Club.
39:31Emmett Fitzgerald: And there will inevitably be some sadness as that older chapter comes to a close. But Michel thinks that the Ember Ordinance doesn't need to be a loss, just a rearrangement. Same amount of greens altogether, but differently organized. And I think this can be gorgeous and magnificent. but revolutions don't happen in a day. Michel says that we shouldn't be too quick to judge what comes next. The Berkeley Hills can still be lush, but it will be years before all these redesigned gardens reach maturity. He's going to plant a new fig tree in a safer spot. But he'll need to be patient. It's going to take time to grow.
40:47Thank you. Built to Burn. There's a link in the show notes. Kathy Too is our executive producer. Kurt Kolstad is our digital director. The rest of the team includes Chris Berrupe, Jason DeLeon, Christopher Johnson, Vivian Leigh, Lashma Dawn, Joe Rosenberg, Kelly Prime, Jacob Medina-Gleason, Talon and Rain Stradley, and me, Roman Mars. The 99 % visible logo was created by Stephan Lawrence. We are part of the SiriusXM podcast family, now headquartered six blocks north in the Pandora building. in beautiful uptown Oakland, California. You can find us on all the usual social media sites as well as our own Discord server.
41:28There's a link to that as well as every past episode of 99PI at 99pi.org.
41:42Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change. Your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just$5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time. Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing. Hi, I'm Angie Hicks, co-founder of Angie. And one thing I've learned is that you buy a house, but you make it a home. Because with every fix, update, and renovation, it becomes a little more your own. So you need all your jobs done well. For nearly 30 years, Angie has helped millions of homeowners hire skilled pros for the projects that matter.
42:15From plumbing to electrical, roof repair to deck upgrades. So leave it to the pros who will get your jobs done well. Angie, the one you trust to find the ones you trust. Find a pro for your project at Angie.com. Some say Odoo business management software is like fertilizer because of the way it promotes growth. Some say Odoo is like a magic beanstalk, scaling with you while being magically affordable. And some say Odoo's programs for manufacturing, accounting, and more are like building blocks for creating a custom software suite. But I say Odoo is all of it. Fertilizer Magic Beanstalk Building Blocks.
42:49For business. Yeah. Odoo. Exactly what every business needs. Sign up at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.
Across the West, there's a contentious debate playing out over how to adapt homes and neighborhoods to this era of increasingly extreme wildfire risk. In Berkeley, California, it's become a particularly emotional fight because of a very specific architectural history that began all the way back in the 1890s. Emmett Fitzgerald reports on the new rules about what plants you can grow around your house.
Check out our previous episode on defensible space: Built to Burn
Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ to listen to new episodes of 99% Invisible ad-free and a whole week early.
Start a free trial now on Apple Podcasts or by visiting siriusxm.com/podcastsplus.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.