The Borrowed Nature of Biomimicry

0:00Say you've always wanted to have a backyard oasis. this. Here's the thing. If you get smart with your money, you can do things like that. With Empower, you can start making the most of your money so you can go out and live a little. Isn't that why we work so hard? To have a little fun with our money, like treating yourself to something special or spontaneously doing something extra for a loved one. So use Empower to get good at money so you can be a little bad. Join their 20 million customers today at Empower.com. Not an Empower client paid or sponsored. The key to running a small business is to be available and reliable.

0:35AT &T Business helps small businesses stay connected with reliable internet built to support daily operations. Connectivity keeps everything moving from communication to transactions to daily workflows. AT &T Business is designed to be a reliable provider, helping small businesses stay up and running without added stress or disruption. Powered by AT &T Business, built to work. Get AT &T Business at business.att.com. This is 99 % Invisible. I'm Roman Mars.

1:11Back in 1989, the engineers of Japan's famous Shinkansen bullet train realized they had a problem. The train was moving so fast that when it went into a tunnel, it basically punched the air out the far end, creating little sonic booms. All across Japan, the Shinkansen was rattling buildings and disturbing residents in the neighborhoods it passed through. An engineering team was brought in to design a quieter and more efficient train, and they had a secret weapon. Eiji Nakatsu, the general manager of the technical development department, was a birdwatcher. As he thought about the redesign, Nakatsu took inspiration from elements of his favorite birds, including owl feathers, and penguin bellies.

1:57But the bird that inspired the most important element of the redesign was the kingfisher. Kingfishers are famous for the elegant way they dive into the water to catch fish. Their uniquely shaped beaks allow them to break the surface of the water with barely a splash. And so Nakatsu and the Shinkansen design team decided to model the nose of their bullet trains off the kingfisher's beak. And it worked. The new Shinkansen trains were quieter and more efficient. That Kingfisher redesign is now seen as a classic example of what's known as biomimicry, the act of looking to the non-human world for solutions to human design challenges.

2:39Biomimicry is simply design that is inspired by nature. Right, and I have to say that stories about biomimicry are catnip to design journalists like me. That is Kurt Kolstad, our resident design guy. Yep. And biomimicry, it's just this really inspiring concept, right? With all these fascinating examples, like the invention of Velcro being inspired by someone noticing how burrs stuck to his dog's fur and to his jacket while he was out on a walk. Yeah. I mean, I love these stories. We love these stories on the show. we've covered biomimicry a lot over the years because the stories are just very catchy.

3:22Like there is something so seductive about the idea of designers borrowing from nature to solve a human problem. It's just a very neat, simple, and just compelling narrative. Yeah, for sure. But recently I've been digging into a bunch of biomimicry stories and they are not always quite as neat and simple as that bullet train story. The causality is often quite a bit murkier than the headlines would have you believe. And the relationship between nature and human inspiration is often a lot more complicated. Yeah, and that actually makes biomimicry sound more interesting to me, not less. Like, I like that idea of a complex story way better.

4:00Yeah, I agree. Same here. So today we're going to dive deeper, go beyond some simple headlines, separate some fact from fiction, and yeah, go into some more nuanced cases. But to kick things off and ground us in the concept, I want to start with a relatively straightforward yet lesser known example of biomimetic design. So this story takes place in the early 1800s in London, England, which was not yet that modern city that we know with its sophisticated transit network or really even basic sanitation. But it was already the largest city in the world and the largest port in the world. And when people needed to cross the city's famous Thames River near that port, they took the London Bridge.

4:52But that bridge was notoriously crowded. It was like a choke point for everyday citizens and also commercial traffic, which really burdened people as well as, you know, the city's commerce. And so over time, it became clear that another crossing downstream was desperately needed. Yeah, that makes sense to me. They needed another bridge. Totally. Except with the geography of the river and the port and the existing bridge, another bridge would have interfered severely with shipping access. So that solution was a non-starter. And the only real alternative was to tunnel under the river. But this is way before the tunnel to France or even the London Underground.

5:35So there was no precedent for tunnels going under active waterways. Tunneling technology at this point was essentially an extension of mining technology, right? Dealing with solid rock and soil, but not the undersides of rivers. And so they tried to use those surface traditional mining techniques to tunnel under the Thames, but it ended in disaster and in some cases the deaths of workers. And experts eventually came to conclude that this type of tunnel represented an impossible challenge. An engineer named Mark Brunel even wrote that prior attempts, quote, had so completely failed that he conceived all further exertions on the subject quite fruitless, as in it would be pointless to even try.

6:23But Brunel was about to have an experience that would completely change his mind. Okay, so what happened? Well, I think it's best if I let him explain it. So here's an excerpt from a letter that he wrote to his granddaughter later on, recalling his time working for the British Royal Navy. And I'm just going to have you read it. About the year 1812, being then employed in the dockyard at Chatham, I happened to see before me a piece of condemned timber, a portion of the keel of a ship, wherein the worm, the Toretto Novalis, had made many erosions. And by erosions, he means tunnels, like tunnels through the wood.

7:02So in modern English, like he saw a piece of timber that had been worm-eaten along the docks. Yeah, pretty much, pretty much. Except that the so-called naval shipworm is not actually a worm. In reality, it's a strangely adapted bivalve mollusk. Oh, like a clam. Yeah, yeah, except specialized for boring holes. And it works like this. Like its shell has evolved into a pair of grinding plates. And behind those plates trails this long, soft, elongated body that can reach a couple of feet in length. I mean, it sounds terrifying. It sounds something that I would eat eventually. Hopefully, right? Hopefully it wouldn't eat you, right?

7:48I mean, you put some mignonette on it. You know, like you scrape it out. It's going to be tasty. Well, yeah. He didn't go quite that far, but he did pull out a magnifying glass, which is a thing that he was known to carry around, and went in for a closer look. And as he looked, he noticed that the walls of these boreholes that were carved by these worms seemed remarkably stable. Even when they were in waterlogged and like rotting chunks of wood from old ships, they were protected. So here's Brunel again from that same letter. I then said to myself that these little things have made little tunnels.

8:25So might we by adopting some corresponding means of protection. I mean, that's basically like the textbook definition of biomimicry. So what did Brunel notice about how the shipworms made their tunnels? So the trick that he recognized and then set out to copy was that shipworms do two things at the same time. Even as they scrape out the wood in front of them and move forward into that hole, they extrude a lining that coats and reinforces the tunnel around and behind them. Okay, so while they dig, they also immediately shore up the tunnel around them, which describes basically all excavation. So how is this different from other attempts?

9:08Yeah, well, so think of it this way, right? Right. Miners used to working in hard soil could get away with digging for a stretch and then stopping for a bit and then going back and putting up supports behind them. Right. And Brunel recognized that that kind of iterative system just was not going to cut it under the Thames because any gap in space or time between digging and shoring up invited disaster. And so with that in mind, in 1818, he went and patented a machine that would work more like a shipworm, digging and then reinforcing simultaneously. So how did Brunel's machine do that? Well, the crucial piece was what he called a tunneling shield.

9:49Basically, it was this massive cast iron frame that was pressed flush against the face of the excavation. And under that shield, you would have dozens of miners chipping away at the front of the tunnel while bricklayers shored up the tunnel behind them. So as the excavation progressed, the shield would be pushed forward and the newly exposed sections were immediately lined with cemented bricks. And so it was all part of this smooth and continuous effort like the shipworm tunneling and shoring up behind itself simultaneously. That's so cool. Yeah, and really challenging because, you know, Brunel had to piece together this system from all these moving parts and people because the technology at the time was not up to making like a machine that could automate all of this, right?

10:37It had to be people doing manual labor. And ultimately, it worked. It took a really long time and it did not always go smoothly. But eventually Brunel completed the tunnel spanning over a thousand feet under the Thames in 1843. And that was the first tunnel built underneath a river anywhere in the world. Yeah, I mean, no, it was literally, pardon the pun, groundbreaking. Nobody on Earth had ever made and walked through a tunnel like this before. And it didn't stop there because Brunel's design, that tunnel shield, shaped subsequent tunneling technology. Years later, when they built out subway systems in London and across the pond in New York, they used that same basic tunnel shield.

11:24That's so cool. And the funny thing is, modern machines have, if anything, converged even more on those mollusks that originally inspired Brunel. Because now we have machines with attachments that place precast concrete panels as the borer tunnels onward. So it is like that all-in-one thing. OK, so despite all the setbacks, we are really talking about a very straightforward case of biomimicry, like nature inspiring a human design. A guy sees something in nature, copies it, perfects it. Boom, success. Yeah, and that's why I wanted to start here, honestly, because I wanted to ground us in a success story where nature really was this direct inspiration for a human design.

12:07But there are a lot of other stories that don't perfectly follow that neat direct trajectory. Stories where the relationship between nature and human design inspiration is not quite so clear cut. Okay, so I'm very excited to muddy the waters a little bit. So what is next? Well, a different sort of fishy biomimicry with some real twists and strange turns. starting back in 2005 when Mercedes-Benz made a big splash with their Bionic, which was this new concept car that boasted a biomimetic origin story. They claimed their design was the first of its kind to attempt a, quote, complete transfer from nature to technology, end quote.

12:54Well, that sounds like vague nonsense. Yeah, a little bit. I don't even know what that means. Yeah, well, the argument was essentially that biomimicry usually involves borrowing like a single feature or behavior from an animal, like a bird's feather or a whale's fin. But that their new car was modeled on an entire organism, the boxfish. Here's a picture of it. If you're picturing a boxy fish because it's called a boxfish, you're right on the money. I mean, like it is a floating cube with fins. Yeah, exactly. And it's part of this family of really awkwardly angular fish, including the cow fish and the trunk fish.

13:33Yeah. I mean, you know, compared to the naval shipworm, this thing is adorable. I mean, it's like bright yellow with spots on it. But I have to admit, this thing doesn't look aerodynamic at all. Like, this seems like the opposite of an animal that you'd model a car on. So what was the logic behind modeling a vehicle on this boxy shape? Well, big picture, you know, the engineers at Mercedes were into this idea of biomimicry. And so they started scouring the animal kingdom for inspiration. And they wondered if a fish, for example, could provide that inspiration for a car design. But cars have to be boxy.

14:12They're spaces that house humans. And a long, sleek fish is just never going to translate into a functional car. And so if there is a boxy fish that has evolved to be aerodynamic and boxy, that really could be a breakthrough that works all around. OK, but what made them think that the boxfish was aerodynamic? Yeah, well, it started with some real serious scientific research that they came across that was being done into the boxfish. In particular, a study being run by a team spanning UCLA, Caltech and Woods Hole. And so they discovered that there are nuances to the shape of the boxfish that help stabilize it.

14:55Basically, boxfish have these ridges that are called keels that run along their sides. And these help create little eddies which help them course correct as they swim through the water. Which I suppose is what you want to keep a car running smoothly, like on a highway. It's like you want it to be stable. So that makes some sense. Precisely. And after reading the peer-reviewed research papers, Mercedes engineers even reached out and called up one of the researchers to learn more about their study. And then they took it a step further and did research of their own. They had drag tests around 3D models of these fish that suggested that despite their squarish face, they were surprisingly streamlined, at least in controlled conditions.

15:38And so, in the end, Mercedes designers concluded that the boxfish, for all of its boxiness, represented a, quote, aerodynamic ideal, end quote. And the bionic is the car that they built, the Mercedes built. Yeah, exactly. They didn't just design it, they actually built it. And here's a picture of what it looks like, right? It's a car which, true to its inspiration, is relatively boxy, as you can see. And it also has these angled ridges along the side that came from the boxfish, more or less. Yeah, yeah. I mean, so I'm looking at a picture now. It is definitely boxy. It's pretty cute. I mean, it sort of looks like a lime green VW Bug with, you know, some more squarish features.

16:24Kind of like a van bug, you know, kind of. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's a great description. And honestly, I also think it's pretty cute. And I'm not the only one. when Mercedes put this car out into the world in the spotlight at a big public event, it was a hit. The bionic design got featured in Nat Geo. It was, like, installed in the MoMA. And for a while, it was probably the most widely circulated example of automotive biomimicry in the world. Yeah, but I haven't seen one of these, so I'm assuming it never got out of the concept car stage, right? Yeah, that's right. There is no commercial car that evolved out of this.

17:02The Bionic was really never truly made to go on the roads. It was just a concept car that got a bunch of attention and had a bunch of stories written about it. But, you know, like that from their perspective was kind of the whole idea in the first place. Mercedes might not have gotten a commercial car to sell, but they did get this great story that helped associate their brand with being like eco-friendly and cutting edge and tied into this legacy of natural design that had evolved. in, like, the organic elements over the eons. Okay. But so far, this seems like a pretty straightforward biomimicry story.

17:40Well, it would be if the story ended there. And for Mercedes, it basically did. But the fish scientists, like scientists do, kept going. And 10 years after the bionics' big reveal, researchers with new technologies published new findings that painted a very different picture. The old data wasn't wrong exactly. It was just woefully incomplete. And long story short, it turns out that the boxfish, in its totality, is definitely not a, quote, aerodynamic ideal. In fact, if anything, it's basically the exact opposite. So what did they find out? Well, the new team led by a biomorphology researcher named Sam Van Wassenberg modeled that blunt boxy front plowing head on through the water.

18:32And look, it does do okay aerodynamically, as Mercedes had concluded, if it's going straightforward. But as soon as the fish turns its head, its aerodynamics are totally destabilized. Which doesn't sound like a great model for a car. Yeah, or definitely not the one they were envisioning, because it turns out that the boxfish's superpower is maneuverability, not aerodynamics. And if you actually watch them, they're not straight-line swimmers or speed racers. They are these reef fish, and they spend their days threading their way through reefs and evading predators. These are animals that need to turn on a dime.

19:12So they're super agile, and they flick their fins and rotate themselves in three dimensions, which is very cool and totally useful to them. But, yeah, it's not what you're looking for in a car. But the car, you want a shape that can travel fast and, you know, run smooth in one direction, even in high winds, just sort of stay on course. And the box fish, for those purposes, was essentially the worst fish to choose. So the Bionic, it came out. It had a big splash. It was, like, sent around, I'm sure, online a lot. When the new research came out, did Mercedes respond to it at all? Oh, no, not at all.

19:47And in fact, the Bionic's official web page still describes the boxfish as having a, quote, highly streamlined body shape. Wait, so they still have a web page for this thing? Yeah, it's still up there. It's still like part of their marketing material. It's like the story of this thing was always the point. It was never about whether the car actually worked. So this kind of biomimicry story, would you classify it as more typical than like the TAM's tunnel success? Like is this the type of thing that is mostly what happens when we try to use biomimetic design? Yeah, I would say that, you know, failures are definitely more common than successes.

20:26But there's also like other kinds of non-successes, like basically sort of fake stories of having biomimetic inspiration. or at least like vastly simplified ones, right? Right. Like just telling a biomimicry story about a product just so it sounds more interesting. Exactly. And there are a lot of those. And a classic example is this startup that claimed to have invented a water bottle based on the Namib Desert Beetle, which is this insect that has actually evolved a way to capture water out of thin air. It collects and combines droplets on its back and then those trickle down to its mouth so it can drink them.

21:07And so these water bottles were, you know, going to do that same thing, essentially, and fill themselves up. Right, but since I haven't heard of a self-filling water bottle, I assume that just didn't work. Yeah, no, no, it did not actually work. But it did get so much coverage in Wired and NPR and BBC, and, like, the list goes on. They even raised millions of dollars on the backs of those beetles. So, yeah, the water bottle, like the Bionic, Like, it was really more about PR than real biomimicry. And honestly, it had less pretensions to even tie to science, I think, than the bionic did. Yeah, yeah.

21:45Okay, so we have one example of successful biomimicry with the tunnel. We have the Mercedes example, which is really, you know, a success in marketing, but not really successful as a product. So what's next? Something that is honestly a little more complicated and less straightforward than either of those. Okay, we'll get to that after the break.

22:33Create your personal command center by connecting Claude to your calendar, emails, and tools like GitHub, Jira, and Google Workspace. Save time by delegating tasks. Claude can run automated security reviews for your pull requests and fix vulnerabilities. So I wanted to buy this one-room cabin that I had my eye on. And it had been on the market for years and years. And it also had, you know, some things that needed to be fixed. And it was in a weird market. And I kind of didn't know where to start in terms of my negotiation. So I asked Claude, here's the list price. Here's the location. Here are the issues with the place.

23:05What should be my opening offer? And it broke down all the sort of logic of things and presented a range of what I should offer without insulting the seller. And it ended up, that offer got accepted and I bought the place. For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at Claude.ai. That's Claude.ai. If you're ready to upgrade your home, Article makes it easy with stylish, high-quality furniture at an unbeatable price. Whether your style is mid-century, modern, coastal, industrial, Scandi, or boho designs, article has something for every home. Every article piece is thoughtfully designed, well-crafted and made to last.

23:39They offer expert customer support, free design assistance, and a 30-day satisfaction guarantee. So you can shop with confidence. I have so many pieces of article furniture in my house, but still my all-time favorite is the Geome sideboard. It looks really, really cool and it houses all of my CDs. So if you have precious objects, Thanks. Get a genome sideboard to put things into. You'll be glad you did. Article is offering our listeners$50 off your first purchase of$100 or more. To claim, visit article.com slash 99 and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout. That's article.com slash 99 for$50 off your first purchase of$100 or more.

24:20This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace. Squarespace is an all-in-one website platform that helps you stand out online. Whether you're just getting started or growing your business, it's got everything you need from securing your domain to building a professional site and showcasing your work all in one place. Bring your vision to life with AI-powered design or curated templates, plus flexible editing tools that help you create something that truly reflects your style. No experience neither. Squarespace makes it easy to share your work, book clients, and get paid with built-in tools for scheduling, invoicing, and email all in one place.

24:55I've had a Squarespace site, romanmars.com, for 12 years or so. And the key for me isn't that it was easy to build, although it was, is that it's easy to maintain. It never gives me any trouble at all. It's great. Head to squarespace.com slash invisible for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use offer code invisible to save 10 % off your first purchase of a website or domain. When you're at work, you never know when you'll be interrupted. But with the Dell Pro, powered by Intel Core Ultra with vPro, no matter what distracts you, your laptop won't. It's battery-optimized for the way you work, with built-in intelligence that quiets distractions when you need to focus.

25:35Your laptop will help keep you locked in, even when it's bring-your-dog-to-work day. Built for those who stay in the flow. The Dell Pro. Built for you. Dell.com slash Dell-Pro.

25:52So we're back talking about biomimicry with Kirk Holstein.

26:00So our final story is about a structural design that you can find basically anywhere in the aerospace industry. If you peel back a panel on a Boeing plane or a NASA shuttle, you'll see an array of hexagons. And these are called honeycomb sandwich panels. They look like and will instantly remind you of beehives. Yeah, so honeycomb panels, I've definitely seen them before. I think anyone who's paid attention to structures at all have seen them before. Were they inspired by bees? Well, that seemingly simple question is actually surprisingly difficult to answer. Because if you think about it, people have been admiring and examining honeycombs since ancient times.