In short
Chloë Sevigny discusses her path from a Darien, Connecticut outsider to a fashion-forward indie icon, how early media attention shaped her, and the career choices that led to TV prestige and her Emmy-nominated role as Kitty Menendez in 2025’s Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story. She also revisits key turning points: Kids (1995), Boys Don’t Cry (1999), and later film roles, plus controversies and casting decisions.
Guest backgrounds
Chloë Sevigny is a Golden Globe and Spirit Award winner and Oscar/SAG Critics’ Choice/Emmy nominee, known for arthouse films and for HBO/Ryan Murphy series (Big Love; American Horror Story Asylum/Hotel; Feud; Capote vs. the Swans). She is currently shooting a project in the Hollywood Hills.
Key claims
She says New Yorker fashion writer Tina Brown’s team tracked her down via her retail work at Liquid Sky and scene connections, leading to “Chloe’s Scene.” She credits producer Carrie M. Vachon and director Larry Clark’s follow-through for launching her. She emphasizes “keeping it real” indie when turning down studio roles. She denies rumors that she was fired over The Brown Bunny.
Notable examples
New Yorker (Oct 31, 1994) profile; Kids; Boys Don’t Cry (Oscar Best Actress for Hilary Swank; Sevigny Best Supporting Actress nomination); Dogville; Shattered Glass; The Brown Bunny; Big Love; Monsters (Kitty Menendez).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOChloë's Early Life and Background
2:48 to 4:39
Chloë discusses her upbringing in Connecticut and her family background.
“Chloe, thank you so much for doing the podcast.”
Feelings About Growing Up in Darien
4:39 to 6:10
Chloë shares her conflicted feelings about growing up in a wealthy town.
“And when we moved to town, we kind of moved to one of those neighborhoods.”
Exploring New York City
6:10 to 7:42
Chloë describes her early experiences in New York City and how it influenced her.
“Like, so how did, how did that become a antidote to that?”
The New Yorker Profile
7:42 to 9:30
Chloë discusses the impact of her profile in The New Yorker at age 19.
“I was always obsessed with going into the city.”
Fashion and Identity
9:30 to 14:03
Chloë reflects on her identity and style evolution throughout her youth.
“This is seven pages in The New Yorker, October 31st, 1994, Jay McInerney, titled Chloe's Scene.”
Chloë's Early Influences and Fashion Journey
14:03 to 18:15
Explore Chloë Sevigny's early life, fashion experimentation, and influences.
“I thought it was because I was surrounded by this whole homogenous community.”
The Path to Acting and Early Ambitions
18:15 to 21:03
Chloë discusses her early ambitions to act and her initial experiences in the industry.
“catalog work, but not a lot of like moving picture work.”
Getting Cast in 'Kids' and Its Impact
21:03 to 23:25
Learn about Chloë's casting in 'Kids' and the film's significance in her career.
“never acted in front of cameras really before maybe like as we said a tv special or a commercial or something but like this is different yeah but everybody was in the same boat everybody nobody had.”
Navigating Fame After 'Kids'
23:25 to 28:00
Chloë reflects on her rise to fame following the release of 'Kids' and its implications.
“hoping to spare, I guess, others from the same kind of situation and maybe also because she's rightly pissed and whatever.”
Early Career Journey
28:00 to 29:28
Chloë discusses her early experiences in the film industry and her challenges as a young actress.
“I mean, they might've been the same casting directors, Carrie Barton.”
Show all 31 chapters
Finding Confidence in Acting
29:28 to 31:20
Chloë reflects on her journey to gain confidence in her acting abilities and the impact of her family responsibilities.
“I'm going to really, this is, I'm like, you know, I've got to like zone in on this and take advantage of this because it was probably, you know, more fruitful than, than, you know, working behind the counter.”
The Impact of Boys Don't Cry
31:20 to 33:28
The conversation shifts to her role in Boys Don't Cry and the significance of the film's message.
“And I know they had offered the part to Sarah Pauly.”
Awards and Recognition
33:28 to 35:32
Chloë shares her experiences at award ceremonies and the recognition she received for Boys Don't Cry.
“And I guess at that stage of your establishing yourself, maybe you don't feel as confident telling somebody to go after yourself.”
Career Post-Boys Don't Cry
35:32 to 37:51
Chloë discusses her career trajectory after Boys Don't Cry and the challenges she faced in finding new roles.
“Well, so that Oscar ceremony happened in early 2000.”
Balancing Indie and Commercial Roles
37:51 to 41:17
Chloë addresses the balance between maintaining her indie identity and opportunities in commercial films.
“And yeah, her part in Girl Interrupted was definitely not supporting.”
Reflections on Choices
41:17 to 42:07
Chloë reflects on her career decisions and the impact of personal circumstances on her acting choices.
“Does that also apply or did it at that time also apply to movies?”
Reflections on Career Choices
42:07 to 43:12
Chloë Sevigny discusses her regrets and career decisions in Hollywood.
“I was very into keeping it real and indie.”
Exploring Early Film Roles
43:12 to 44:41
Sevigny reflects on her early films and collaborations with notable directors.
“Well, so American Psycho did come out in 2000.”
The Impact of Shattered Glass
44:41 to 46:08
Chloë discusses her role in 'Shattered Glass' and its significance.
“And if I wasn't who I was, I think there was some behavior that might have been hard for me.”
Controversy Surrounding The Brown Bunny
46:08 to 48:36
Sevigny shares her experiences and feelings about the controversial film.
“and I hadn't read something like that before.”
Transition to Television: Big Love
48:36 to 50:44
Chloë talks about her breakthrough role in 'Big Love' and its unique challenges.
“But it has been a hard thing to live with.”
Working with David Fincher on Zodiac
50:44 to 55:58
Sevigny reflects on her experiences filming 'Zodiac' and working with Fincher.
“Like, you end up doing Big Love for HBO in this kind of, like, the new golden age of TV.”
Challenges on Set and Admiration for Fincher
56:00 to 57:30
Chloë Sevigny discusses the demanding nature of working with David Fincher and her admiration for his storytelling skills.
“I don't know if he did that so much before.”
Diverse Roles and Ryan Murphy Collaborations
57:30 to 59:32
Chloë reflects on her varied roles in television and film post-Big Love and her continued collaborations with Ryan Murphy.
“Then guest bits in Portlandia as the roommate who Fred and Carrie are both dating in 2013.”
The Impact of Ryan Murphy's Work
59:32 to 1:01:25
Sevigny shares her thoughts on Ryan Murphy's impact on storytelling and social commentary in his projects.
“And that leads us up to Monsters, the Lyle and Eric Menendez story, which is Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan.”
Portraying Complex Characters in 'Monsters'
1:01:25 to 1:04:06
Chloë discusses the complexities of portraying Kitty Menendez and the emotional challenges of her character's backstory.
“And I think like Versace and Dahmer were really important pieces of work.”
Exploring Motherhood and Abuse in 'Monsters'
1:04:06 to 1:06:16
Sevigny reflects on the challenges of portraying a mother dealing with abuse and the nuances of her character's dilemma.
“I mean, there's just so many things that come into play that make it a very heavy experience.”
The Ethics of Portraying True Crime
1:06:16 to 1:10:02
The discussion shifts to the moral implications of portraying true crime stories and the perspectives in 'Monsters'.
“Like how often do you see women mothers being able to say that and how many women can identify with that?”
Chloë Sevigny on Career and Recognition
1:10:02 to 1:14:48
Chloë discusses her career trajectory, recent recognition, and the nature of her roles.
“Like, unfortunately and inexcusably, like a lot of people have been abused that don't then go and kill their families.”
Reflecting on Recent Projects
1:14:48 to 1:15:56
Sevigny shares her thoughts on recent lighter projects and the enjoyment they bring.
“So anyway, bottom line, here we are that far into a career with this much of a body of work to look back on.”
Reflecting on Recent Projects
1:16:44 to 1:17:01
Sevigny shares her thoughts on recent lighter projects and the enjoyment they bring.
“This is the love story of real hinge couple, Carti and Rocker.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Get business done with the new American Express Graphite Business Cash Unlimited card. With unlimited 2 % cash back on all eligible purchases, unlimited 5 % cash back on flights and prepaid hotels booked through American Express Travel Online, and a flexible spending capacity that can grow with your business, you'll have the confidence to keep building. Apply today and earn a welcome offer of$1 ,500 cash back after you spend$50 ,000 in qualifying purchases on your new card within the first six months of card membership. Terms apply. Learn more at go.mx.graphite.
0:38Hi, everyone, and thank you for tuning in to the 595th episode of the Hollywood Reporters Awards Chatter Podcast. I'm the host, Scott Feinberg, and my guest today is a Golden Globe and Spirit Award winner and Oscar SAG Critics' Choice and Emmy Award nominee who has been described by the New York Times as one of her generation's finest character actresses, as well as an arthouse queen, fashion muse and icon chloe 70 during her 30-year career 70 has starred in films directed by seemingly every auteur of her era including woody allen david fincher whit stillman jim jarmusch lars von trier kimberly pierce harmony corinne olivier aseas verner herzog andrew haig and luca guadagnino and at a time before very many people who first established themselves in film were choosing to work in TV, she did just that and helped to usher in a new golden age for the medium via her work on HBO's Big Love, as well as a host of Ryan Murphy shows, including American Horror Story Asylum, American Horror Story Hotel, Feud, Capote vs.
1:42the Swans, and most recently, 2025's Monsters, the Lyle and Eric Menendez story, on which she played Kitty Menendez, the wife of Jose and Mother of Lyle and Eric, and for which she recently received the first Emmy nomination of her career in the category of Best Supporting Actress in a Limited Series or TV Movie. Over the course of a conversation at the Hollywood Hills home of one of Seventy's friends, where she is currently staying while shooting a project in town, the 50-year-old and I discussed the odds-defying way in which she first became a well-known person, the ways in which her Best Supporting Actress Oscar nomination for Boys Don't Cry did and didn't impact the way the industry regarded her and she regarded herself, how she wound up working on TV limited series with Ryan Murphy, and the unique challenges of starring in Monsters, the Lyle and Eric Menendez story specifically, plus much more.
2:37And so without further ado, let's go to that conversation.
2:48Chloe, thank you so much for doing the podcast. Great to have you. I am terrified of podcasts. I'm just going to put that out there. No, there's no video here. Those are the ones that are intimidating. Audio is also intimidating because I listen to a lot of them. Oh, do you? Okay. Well, we'll try to make it as fun as possible. Okay. Going back to the very beginning, as we do on every episode, can you just share with our listeners, where were you born and raised and what did your folks do for a living? I was born in Springfield, Massachusetts, because it was the closest hospital to the town my family was living in in northern Connecticut called Summers.
3:22My father was from actually Hingham, Massachusetts, so I do feel like I can claim Massachusetts as my home birth state. I was born there, even though we weren't living there, just because my father's, so it's by proximity. And my mother's from inner city, Philly. um her parents are like her grandparents were Polish immigrants her dad was a butcher it was a butcher shop her house was above the butcher shop um so my parents lived in summers for like two the first two years of my life my father worked insurance and my mom was like a housewife she also had my older brother who was a couple years older than me and then they moved to Darien Connecticut to my chagrin well I'm gonna stop you because I am also from Connecticut I'm I'm from New Haven area, but I'm familiar with Darian.
4:10Okay. And along the Metro North, I believe. I can recite the whole line. Yes. As if I was in, what's the movie? Ice Storm. Oh, yeah, right. Exactly. Well. My son calls it the red line because the Metro North New Haven line is the red train, or he calls it the red train and the blue train's the Hudson. So he's like, I want to take the red train to see Nina, his grandma. I've always followed your career in red bits and pieces, but obviously you went deep diving ahead of this. And it seems like from as early as you were ever being interviewed, you expressed very conflicted feelings about being growing up in Darien.
4:48What was that about? well when when my family first moved there my father really wanted us to have like a very safe environment to grow up in and though i mean people associate the town with a lot of wealth there is kind of like the sides that maybe are a little more you know lower middle class and or like townie working class and those are generally the areas like around you know between the highways and the train tracks and certain areas of town. And when we moved to town, we kind of moved to one of those neighborhoods. And of course, it's immense privilege and all of that. But like, I was very aware of like our status within the social hierarchy and the town from a very young age.
5:34I think I was also from a very young age, very aware of like the lack of diversity, even though that wasn't something that was really a part of the conversation then. And I could still remember like going to the town over like Stanford or going to Norwalk to go to different shops and being like, why am I seeing all these different kinds of people I don't see at home? So at a young age, I was always like very curious about that and thought it was a little alarming. And how did your way of dealing with that end up being, I think, spending a lot of time, at least on the weekends in New York? I mean, from a pretty early age and by yourself.
6:13Right. Like, so how did, how did that become a antidote to that? Right. Well, my father, he commuted to the city every day. He walked to the train station. He was one of those guys playing poker, you know, on the Metro North on the way home, smoking cigarettes in the bar car. And he worked in insurance and, you know, pretty average, you know, kind of working man's job. And my mom worked at the local nursery school. And then she ended up working at like a stationary store in town, helping people with like invitations and birth announcements and wedding invitations all those things that are very um you know kind of commonplace in those kinds of towns and neighborhoods and so because my father commuted to the city he would bring me in a lot and also my parents knew the you know they took advantage of new york they loved new york my mother loved going to manhattan she would bring me into shows and we my father would bring me in once a year to go shopping at sacks and it was like he would bring me to feo schwartz and i'd have like go to the office with dad you know and like and we would go in like at christmas time to see the tree and so like new york was always like a very big part of my life and it was only a you know 45 50 minute train ride away it's really close and it's closer than some parts of queens it was just this ever pleasant ever present you know place in my life and the something that i always kind of like you know was shiny and aspirational and, you know, magical and held all this, you know, allure for me from a very young age.
7:42I was always obsessed with going into the city. And I like, I knew that Madonna and, and Cindy Lauper shopped at Fiorucci. So I was like, damn, we have to go to Fiorucci and stand outside all day until we see them. And, you know, and, uh, and then of course, as I got older, my brother was going in a lot. I had an older brother who was very hip and very into like all alternative cultures of the day was being hip-hop skateboarding hardcore you know the music scene and punk and he would go in for like sunday matinees which is like a hardcore kid thing and so i saw him doing it and his friends and kind of followed suit and then of course like around this time was like the big earth day celebrations and then like pot rallies So somehow those kinds of activities or hearing about those things kind of trickled out into the alternative kid scene in Connecticut.
8:31And it was like an onus to go in and kind of check something out and be like, oh, mom, I'm just going to the Earth Day celebration. Which might have then evolved to mom, I'm going in to do something, but actually doing other things. Sure. Well, then you find yourself in a park and then you meet all the kids. And, you know, it was like a very natural, it was seen very natural in the day. I mean, I don't know how, I mean, young kids, I'm sure do the same. I love going to Washington Square Park now and like sitting there, my son is fascinated by the skateboarders. He's five and like, we'll sit there and we'll watch.
9:05And I'll be like, I wonder if these kids have any idea who I am. I ran this place. We might have shot a seminal movie. Well, before you had shot, I believe this is correct, a single scene of anything on camera, at least, there was this article, which I'm going to remind people about. This is seven pages in The New Yorker, October 31st, 1994, Jay McInerney, titled Chloe's Scene. You're 19 at the time it comes out, working a retail job, right? I always worked retail and never restaurants. Well, that's not true. One of my first jobs was as a bus girl at my friend's father's restaurant in New Canaan.
9:53But then I quickly realized I didn't want to work in restaurants. So I shifted to retail. retail. This article describes, this is the New Yorker, describes this 19-year-old retail working girl as, quote, the coolest girl in the world, close quote. Not because, again, I think people might assume, oh, maybe you'd done some early small films or something that caught their eye. This was largely just somehow they were aware of that you were this fashionable, stylish, hip. Like, how'd you even get on their radar? And it just seems like kind of crazy, in hindsight, to me at least. Yes, it was kind of crazy.
10:37Tina Brown had taken over The New Yorker and she was doing the first, quote unquote, like fashion issue. And I think that she maybe had this idea of writing a piece about like, and kind of like an it a new it girl even though he never uses the term it girl in the um i think just because people are obviously obsessed with youth and um i don't know if she was friends with like ingrid sishi who is the editor of new of interview magazine who knew of me because of people she was friends with this is so convoluted no this is good i really want to Because I read so much and I couldn't get to the bottom of how this even happened.
11:23So I guess it goes back further to when I was still in high school going into New York and going to raves. Namely this one called NASA, which is in the movie Kids. And I became friends with the doormen or the doorboys because I was a smart young lass. And they became my friends. And they were working at the store called Liquid Sky. and I procured a job there before I even graduated high school because I moved to New York the day after I graduated from high school. Actually, after graduation, I took a train into the city to see a concert. Yes. It was Sonic Youth and the breeders at the academy.
12:01Anyway, so the next day I moved to Brooklyn and I started working at Liquid Sky because I had it all set up and this woman, Mary Fry, was kind of running the store and Carlos Soul Slinger and they were a couple at the time and he was a big like um jungle DJ and kind of ran the scene a little bit in his own way or was part of one of the kind of major you know constructors of the scene and Mary had worked the door at limelight and she had a lot of friends that worked in fashion and she was like a little bit of the older guard and so I think all of her friends would come to the shop and they were into me because of my looks.
12:38And I was already doing like some modeling and had done some acting and done some music videos. So I was already kind of like ambitious and doing like test shoots and things like that. So I think that some of those people told Ingrid about me and then Ingrid told Tina about me and then Tina got Jay to write about me. Now, was this sort of like up to that point, you leading a bit of a double life because like back at high school in Darien were you seen as like cool stylish no no I mean I don't know if they thought I was cool because I knew them all since kindergarten they're just like oh there goes Chloe again wacky Chloe like I think I got voted like most changed because I has was so into style so you were all where did that come from that came from a very young age.
13:28I think I like out the womb was just into like style and fashion and also kind of like lifestyle. Like I got very into, I say this all the time. It seems so boring, but maybe hopefully somebody who's listening to this has never heard of me before. I was really into Little House on the Prairie, like obsessed. And I would sleep with the nightcap and would only wear calico dresses. And like when I was into a scene, whatever it was, I would fully immerse myself so like and I got into the new new wave soon scene it was all like Doc Martens and striped tights and then I got into like the hippie scene and acid and I was always like you know hair to my waist and never showering and then I got into like the hip-hop polo kid you know scene and then it all became like a whole jumbled thing and then the so I was very like I was always like kind of changing my look and or experimenting with my look I think because I was so unhappy with being a blonde haired blue highest child in this town that I thought that I wasn't interesting.
14:28I thought it was because I was surrounded by this whole homogenous community. And I like, not that I really wanted to stand out. I mean, my father and mother weren't really that involved in the community for a myriad of reasons. They had some friends, but I, you know, I was really like kind of fell in with more of the misfit pack, probably because of like friends who were from divorced families or alcoholism or things, you know, you often find each other in that way. And also my brother's influence, of course, carrying over. And, and my father was pretty radical. And, you know, he gave me like Giovanni's room when I was in high school, and would like listen to the Flying Lizard and Blondie and, you know, Marian Faithful.
15:09And he was cool, you know. But the other thing that way you're describing, like you were a chameleon and could acclimate into any group. I mean, sounds a bit like acting, right? I mean, were you thinking? Sounds a bit like I was bored and I just like was really into trying things out and trying. Yeah, I guess I was trying, I mean, trying to find myself and also just like playing. Like, I think I just, I don't know if I would, I don't know if I would say I was like so much of an imposter. I just think I like just got so immersed in whatever scene I was in. And at that time, And like those uniforms were so defined, especially in my earlier teen years, that I kind of went through some different, you know, kind of looks.
15:52And but so I was always very into fashion. My mother was thrifty. She's a New England, you know, my father's a Yank. It was very thrifty in my home. My mom would like toast the crackers when they were stale thrifty wise coupon cutting. So we shopped at thrift stores. So I was exposed to like all these different kinds of things that maybe I wouldn't have been if like I was only like buying a spree at Saks or whatever it was. Like those were special occasions, you know. If we then flash forward to this, I don't know how, I guess 20 years older than you, man, Jay McNerney like tracks you down at your, at the retail place where you're working.
16:32Yeah, the quits guy. Yeah. And then he follows me around a bunch. I think we'd already shot kids and it was about to come out. So there was, I think, I think there was all that already happening. And like, I was friends with like, you know, a lot of people that were kind of making their way in whatever fields they were in being music, filmmaking, fashion, art, you know, fine artists. I was just, I was just like about, and the scene was smaller than, or so it felt. And I, you know, I'd always been interested in just kind of like being around people that were doing stuff even from a young age and creative types were very attractive to me maybe because I wasn't very academically minded I don't know well when this article comes out again October 94 ahead of the release in 95 of kids so nobody's that really I think started to put you on the map uh in a different way but like when this came out how did how did you react to it?
17:30How did it affect, if in any way, your life? Just what did you make of the whole thing? Well, I'd wanted to be an actress since kindergarten, when my mom would bring me to shows. And I saw Annie. And of course, I was watching shows on TV, like Little House, and seeing other kids doing it. And there was, more importantly, a girl in my town called Carrie Nicks, who was doing commercials and catalog work. And I was like, I want to do what she's doing, she, my mom also had me doing all these like focus groups, like to make money on the side. Like she was kind of hustling. It was weird. And so I was doing like some commercials.
18:06I did a Voltron commercial. That's kind of somewhere on the internet, a couple afterschool specials that I've never found, but I didn't get a lot of work. You know, I got a lot of like local catalog work, but not a lot of like moving picture work. And it was the cattle call casting for kids at that time was pretty strenuous and exhausting. And I think my mom saw the rejection and was like, okay, you can do this like when you're 18 professionally, but for now you can do like summer camp and school plays and stuff like that. So thank God that she did that. And when you say for kids as in children, not kids.
18:38Yes, sorry. And then Harmonia and I had met between my junior and senior year and we'd become very close. We were like best friends. We were immediately really drawn to each other. We would talk for hours on the phone every night and it was before like any romance blossomed between us we were just buddies and he met larry and then he wrote the movie and i had actually moved to san francisco for a minute chasing a boy named robbie and that ended up being a bust i was like what am i doing in san francisco this sucks i'm gonna go back to new york and harmony actually called me he's like you gotta come back we're gonna make the movie and they had cast mia kirschner as jenny um who's a great actress a great canadian actress and she had been in this movie exotica that everybody loved by adam mcguyen and she was stunning in it and magnetic and um so they brought her to new york and they wanted me to show her around and show her the ropes and i was like please originally they cast me like as one of the smaller parts joy that i think eventually michelle lockwood played this is a girl in the pool yeah the redhead girl played her i think in the end um michelle and then And I guess during the rehearsals and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
19:50They're like, okay, Michelle. I mean, during the rehearsals, they were like, I think they were saying that Mia just was too professional next to all these kids. And it just wasn't working for Larry and Harmony. And so then Larry said to Harmony, like, who do you think you were thinking about? You know, and Harmony said, Chloe. And so they called me and they offered me the part, me the movie. I'm going to stop you for a second. Just because, here's just to keep the chronology in the side. I know, I was giving backstory before. No, it's all good. I hate to interrupt because it's great to listen to you tell it.
20:27But I want to just note, so Christine Vachon, who would also, she produced that, Kids, and then also Boys Don't Cry, which you were in and will come to. Yeah, and maybe American Psycho? Did she produce that? I think that's right, yeah. She has recalled, quote, Larry called me and said, you know what? It should have been Chloe all along. she's perfect and i don't know why i didn't see it when i took a closer look i saw he was right uh she referring to larry she was pretty amazing she had tremendous energy and her style and look and presence were very original you felt like you hadn't seen it before close quotes so you having never acted in front of cameras really before maybe like as we said a tv special or a commercial or something but like this is different yeah but everybody was in the same boat everybody nobody had.
21:14And this includes Rosario Dawson. Yes. Yeah. And Justin Pierce and Harold Hunter and everybody else in the movie. None of us had been in front of a camera in that way. Did you immediately kind of feel at home doing it or was it a learning curve? A little bit of both. I think that like Eric Edwards who shot, he had shot my own private Idaho. And so I automatically felt like safe in his hands because I was such a fan of that movie and I had worked kind of like a lot like Larry had taken photos of us like in the year leading up he had kind of shot us for different things for himself and like for this German magazine photos are crazy and of course Harmony was my friend and he was an insane cinephile at a very young age and so I just felt like and the script was I mean it was an exaggeration of the way all of us talked and there were some pretty high stakes scenes that seemed a little ridiculous at the time but I like just had to like give myself over to them and I felt like they had the taste level that they wouldn't make us look like idiots and Carrie Woods was a producer on the movie and who actually he was instrumental in my career after.
22:32And I have to say, like, I think the argument of, you know, exploitation versus opportunity is a really interesting one. And I think it really falls on the producers and the follow through and how they take care of, you know, unknowns. And he really took care of me and introduced me to like, you know, my agent and my manager, who's still my manager, like, you know, and a publicist. And like, you know, he was very hands-on with a few of us and the core cast. and I really respect him for having done that. And Larry, like I was in Larry's life forever. I went to his kids' bar mitzvah. I was like, you know, at all of his art openings.
23:08We should say you're playing in this movie. Jenny's a 14-year-old girl, I think, even though you were obviously a few years older, but she's, I think, 14, loses her virginity and acquires HIV in the same single sexual encounter and then pursues the guy who did this to her, hoping to spare, I guess, others from the same kind of situation and maybe also because she's rightly pissed and whatever. But it comes out distributed by Harvey Weinstein's Merrimack's, which— Well, they had to start Dimension to distribute it because it was NC-17. That's right. That's why Dimension came about. Okay. And, yeah, it gets this NC-17, which was maybe the first, but definitely not the last time they milked the ratings of a movie for publicity, which is, you know, whatever.
23:59Well, the Miramax machine was very famous then. Yeah. And in fact, you've said that the reason that, so the movie goes to Sundance, to Cannes, maybe other places as well. You and the other kids were not along for that journey. Well, Harmony was because he was the enfant terrible. He was the most charismatic, actually. Well, Justin and Harold were very charismatic as well, But Harmony was a star. But you think that was a kind of deliberate decision by the Weinstein. I think that's pretty public knowledge. They wanted people to think that we were still on the street. They wanted people to think, oh, wow, this is such an expose.
24:33And it's not that long after a documentary that I actually just recently watched for the first time. But it seems maybe to your point, like Streetwise, which was about these Seattle teenagers. And I mean, there's you can see maybe some influence there. but those kids were anyway probably teeny yeah mariel yeah exactly oh yeah classic good memory yeah okay so the movie though comes out gets a lot of attention you get a spirit award nomination and yeah and then then you get another one later uh which we'll come to but and the boys i think justin won one or harold won one or the movie got nominated or movie got one yeah and this is all this is 30 years ago and why my memory is so fuzzy but i remember meeting jenna roland's oh wow and yeah harmy and i had our picture taken with her and i remember we were staying at the chateau in a bungalow and all the kids were there and my mom was like the only adult present and there was some famous screen reader by the pool and she was taking my picture i was squinting and he's like you better learn to look into the light if you want to be an actress darling it was uh oh my god taxi driver oh schrader schrader yeah okay i'm glad it wasn't worse he's done some crazy well so and harmony had actually worked for him on some movie some summer i think that's how i knew that maybe that's why he was there i don't know well so you're pretty quickly you know now somebody people are aware of and you mentioned that the producer carrie woods is kind of helping you to get going but from your point of view having not even necessarily really I don't know if you were even looking to be a screen actor prior to this opportunity where is this was it something where you're like I now this is my calling in life or would you just have been just as happy to get some traction solely in you know fashion or music or other things like what was your outlet coming out of kids I think I was like okay this is my opportunity but I would also if this doesn't work be really happy doing costume design oh really so because there were a lot of movies that I loved in that time frame that were very like fashion driven like all the Fassbender films of Picnic at Hanging Rock and like Robert Altman movies and like all the movies that I was really into had really spectacular costumes and so that was something that I was really and I was also very into fashion so I was very drawn to it and I thought that being an actress seemed so unattainable um that I was like this is I love movies I love fashion this is something that would maybe be an interesting career path for me, which is why I ended up then doing the costumes in Gummo, because I still didn't know if I would actually become an actress, even though I was on my way to that.
27:21Yeah. And so Gummo and Julian Donkey Boy, these are two that you then do with Harmony, 97 and 98. 98 is your first one with Whit Stillman, Last Days of Disco. Oh, I think before that also I did Tree's Lounge. Yes. Yeah. with Boucher M. Boucher M. directed, yeah. So you're, you know, clearly like building some traction, but then I guess the one that I think came about to some degree because of Last Days of Disco was Boys Don't Cry, which what I'd read is you'd initially been approached a few years earlier when this is Kimberly Pierce's first time directing a feature, right? And she tried to get it going a few years earlier and has said that at that time you were maybe too young to play Lana, this character who gets involved, small town girl who becomes girlfriend of a trans woman, but that after seeing you in Last Days of Disco, she says she came back to you and asked you to audition.
28:23And does this sound right to you? You're making it... It doesn't sound right to me. No, let's get your version. Let's get your version. I mean, they might've been the same casting directors, Carrie Barton. It's possible. It's possible. They did a lot of casting in New York when there was, you know, there was like a real film scene in New York pre 9-11. And you could be an actress, indie actress. And after Kids I did, I was getting a lot of phone calls at Liquid Sky, the shop where I was working, asking me to be in movies. That's how they'd reach out? Yeah. Maybe because of the Jay McInery piece, they knew they could find me there.
28:59And I was like, this is getting a little hectic. and Carrie, you know, then got me the manager and I was, you know, being, he was helping kind of figure all that stuff out and agent at William Morris. Cause he had worked at William Morris. Then I got trees lounge and that I was like, okay, this is like some, I'm like a real actress now. And then my father passed away. And so I was like, well, now I had to help support my family. My mother was kind of in a precarious financial situation. So that's when I was like, okay, I'm going to really, this is, I'm like, you know, I've got to like zone in on this and take advantage of this because it was probably, you know, more fruitful than, than, you know, working behind the counter.
29:41So I guess maybe that was kind of the more the, that was part of the onus or the impetus to really like. Get serious. Yeah. And also the opportunities were presenting themselves and they were with good people. And I was like, people actually made me think that I can act or maybe, you know, and, and And I started like believing in myself more. And I was going to say, did you, it seems like there might've been a little imposter syndrome at the beginning. I think until Boys Don't Cry. And then I felt like I really like, but I also feel like that was the first part that really landed for me that I really like there are certain parts of Alice in Last Days of Disco, but Wit is such a particular director that is almost impossible to inhabit the character because she's his own.
30:23I mean, every director works differently and it's very interesting to see everyone's process, but that was a little tricky. And maybe there was some of it that I didn't even understand what was happening. We should just say this was club goer, club going girl with kind of a frenemy and Kate Beckinsale. Yeah. Working in publishing and yeah, early twenties, living in like a railroad apartment and trying to make their way in Manhattan. so then yeah so then i remember drew barrymore coming to me in harmony and show sending these photos that like herb ritz had done of her like in drag and being like i'm really interested in this brandon tina story and sending harmony the playboy article and we both poured over it and we're like wow this article is incredible and then i think the documentary came out and we were just you know really taken by this person and the story and and then yeah and then I found out about this audition I think I originally went and auditioned for Brandon that I was gonna say so you you were and this was with now you find you you're following the story you're interested in the story then you find out that Kimberly's already doing it yeah and you would have initially preferred to play Tina Brandon so I thought I don't know because I had actually like auditioned for a part in high school as a boy because I had a shaved head and they were like I think they were doing um it doesn't matter West Side Story and so I auditioned for one of the boy parts and I didn't get it yeah I ended up doing costumes um in high school and so so yeah so I auditioned for Brandon and this is my recollection Kimberly was like I don't have you ever wanted to be a boy like I I don't feel any male energy coming from you or like even in the audition, I thought I had done a fine audition and she said, why don't you come back tomorrow and read for Lana?
32:19And I know they had offered the part to Sarah Pauly. Sarah was getting a lot of the parts that I had wanted at that period. We were a little like neck to neck and she quite often beat me out for parts. It's funny because we've just, she'd never come up on this podcast and then she came up recently where I I guess she had the part in Almost Famous that Kate Hudson ended up. So anyway, it's funny because. Yeah. Anyway. I think that she really, because she was a child. I mean, I'll let her speak for herself. I think she didn't really. Yeah. She had a complicated relationship with acting, especially in that time.
32:51Being an actress at that time was a very different thing. How so? Just the way what people expected of you, you know, you know, promotional wise and just like being in those rooms as a young woman. It was very vulnerable. It was really challenging to navigate. And even the people that were holding your hands were saying things that were inappropriate. And it was not easy. I think you said like somebody in an audition made a weird comment once. Yeah. Even like one of my representation was like, you know, saying things about how I should dress for the audition or, you know what I mean? Like it was, you know.
Read the full transcript
33:29And I guess at that stage of your establishing yourself, maybe you don't feel as confident telling somebody to go after yourself. Luckily enough, I was comfortable in myself enough to not let people take advantage of me, but I can see how people did. And people and women obviously were taken advantage of and have been since the beginning of cinema. It's not like it was just a 90s thing. but i feel like now it's much easier or women can stand and there's more women in position of power that are protecting you and you know just you know post me too i think these girls are like you know they can go into like i can even now go to a party and not feel like as you know well plus i'm 50 so well it's not like you not feel like oh my god all these people are pulling the strings and i'm just some cog in the you know what I mean it's like a different yeah well so boys don't cry I think you're saying could have been a turning point because not only did you luckily Sarah passed and then Sarah passed you get the part but also like so it's you and Hilary Swank who something special was really happening there and obviously the response from critics from audiences from the Academy.
34:49We got to remind people, she gets nominated for best actress. You get nominated for best supporting actress. You also, that's for the Oscars, but you'd also been nominated at before that for golden globe and SAG awards. You went on and win the spirit award for that. Like it must've made you feel a little better in your own skin to have people saying, you know, you're, you're not just some kid off of Washington square park. Who's we've thrown into something, but like you belong. Yeah. And I think a lot of people had been discovered and weren't, you know, classically trained, a lot of great actors, but like there was still, I felt like something that I had to prove.
35:26And I mean, I, that experience was incredible. And Peter Sarsgaard and, you know, all the other actors in the movie, um, were so strong and we were, we all were so emotionally invested in the material and, um, as still like the greatest experience of my life as far as like you know an acting experience also you know nobody had like families or loved ones at home that you're like worried about like you can really immerse yourself in something and not have to be concerned with other people's well beings necessarily I think that's maybe why young people also prevail in a way and can can be so great at art when they're pursuing it at that age because you can be as selfish in a way that's not as harmful to others which can give you more kind of wild abandon which obviously serves art more than even like me getting the record I was just happy that the the movie hit like the zeitgeist and I thought it was really an important film and story and people weren't really talking about trans rights so much then and it was like a horrible tragedy And I, you know, I was hoping that would raise awareness, which we still hope and we're still fighting for.
36:40And, you know, insane. However, many years later. Yeah. That, you know. Yeah. Well, so that Oscar ceremony happened in early 2000. You had already shot American Psycho, which you did after having, I believe, passed on Mary Herron's previous movie I shot. Andy Warhol. Well that's because I was obsessed with Valerie Solanas and I was like even though I love Lily Taylor I was just I was like somewhat skeptical of some of the other casting and I think that like Warhol and his scene to me was so precious like it meant so much to me I'll start crying like. You would have been in that if you'd been around right like if you'd been a few years.
37:26I mean maybe like Edie Chow Manhattan and like the Warhol Diaries and just like it was like to me everything that meant anything and so it was too precious for me to even though the movie's a great movie and and the part that she had offered me was a small part it was like some girl on the phone and a couple scenes i could have done it whatever but like i think also it was like i don't know if i want to do that small of a part after having done you know more substantial role and in the ensemble of kids and um so i passed yeah well so i bring up American Psycho just because that's in the can by early 2000 you have the Boys Don't Cry Oscars where just for to save people Wikipedia and yet the Oscar went to Angelina Jolie for a performance that I'm not sure was even a supporting you agree not to be bitter but it was a really tough competition that Tony Collette for Sixth Sense Samantha Morton for Sweet and Lowdown, Catherine Keener for Malkovich, me and Angie.
38:29I mean, that's stiff comp. Yeah. And yeah, her part in Girl Interrupted was definitely not supporting. I think because they campaigned for Winona for best. That's right. Yeah. That happens every year or something like this. Yeah. But I guess the - She deserves it. I mean, what a moment. Her and her brother and all that. You had a brother at the Oscars. Angelina Jolie more than I can't even tell you how much loved that woman. So my brother did come with me and he cried after it was really emotional. That's very sweet. Well, what's interesting, though, is that you didn't really, even though American Psycho came out after Boys Don't Cry, after the Boys Don't Cry Oscars, you did not make another film, I think, for a few years.
39:14And I wonder if you can pinpoint what that was about. were you kind of in a uh with i mean award season even then 26 25 years ago was probably a jarring thing especially for somebody who had been such an indie person up to that point do you remember what if that was part of it i think i did a show i think i did an hbo movie if these walls could talk to maybe in that time frame i don't know if i have an eye it's possible yeah for money because I had taken a loan from William Morris and I owed the money. And the Indies weren't really, yeah, paying the bills necessarily. But then I think, you know, I think I was up for a couple things.
40:01Like there was a couple things that I was attached to that were going to be kind of like the thing one would expect to happen after. I think there was like a Walter Salas thing and somebody else. They were like big things. and they both ended up like falling apart and that was pretty jarring and and and and heartbreaking and then i was offered like some kind of like teen comedy things and then i decided to do like a play in new york and yeah i don't know it's a little fuzzy the timeline but it wasn't like it was like oh I don't want to act anymore. Or I don't you know you wait for what you think is supposed to come your way after an Oscar nomination.
40:46There might have been a little bit of that and I think that there were those two things and they both fell apart and they would have been like big things and more kind of mainstream arty kind of more Oscar caliber kind of things and yeah and sadly one was like maybe even like Agneska Holland. Oh wow. There were some big things and then yeah. Well, so, okay, not, my sense is in the fashion world, there are things that someone hip like yourself would not wear or do because it would be seen as selling out. Yeah. Does that also apply or did it at that time also apply to movies? Only because I have read that you turned down some pretty big paychecks for supporting roles in studio movies that might have included.
41:37You can correct or rebut any of these. Never Been Kissed, 1999. Legally Blonde, 2001. Mona Lisa Smile, 2003. Mr. and Mrs. Smith, 2005. And by the way, I'm not saying. I'm not saying even if that these would have been things, I'm not saying you were wrong if you did turn, but I'm wondering, was there a sense like I have a kind of a brand or even just a self-identity and I don't do this kind of a part or this kind of a film or whatever? Would that have been a consideration? Yes, very much so. Yes. I was very into keeping it real and indie. And I think that I really like, you know, shot myself in the foot.
42:21But at least for sure, like there was an opportunity in Never Been Kissed and Legally Blonde and these smaller parts. And back then there was this whole ratio of like how much money your movies make and then you get parts and, you know, and, you know, so on and so forth. And so I think if I had done those movies, I would have then been getting more opportunities after that some other actresses got that I didn't. But what can you do? It's all worked out. Yeah, and I also didn't come to Hollywood because my father had passed. I wanted to stay in New York to be close to my mother. And then post 9-11, there was no industry in New York anymore.
43:01Everybody was out here. So there was also that time period where I was missing because we weren't sending in tapes and stuff. It was, you know, you were just not, people weren't seeing you. Well, so American Psycho did come out in 2000. And then you had, I think, a 2003 or at least the movies, three movies come out in 2003 that, you know, this could have been a New York article, just the variety and the kind of provocativeness. Is that a word of each of these? Yeah. So let me mention if I can, I'm going to throw out each one. And if you have a thought or two to share about as you look back all these years later.
43:43To begin with, one of the residents, Liz, of a small Depression-era American town in Lars Montrer's Dogville. I think the thing there, just if people need a reminder or they don't know, there were literally no sets. It was all chalked, I think, on the floor. It was a high concept. Yeah, and I actually, I remember loving it and thinking it was great and what a cast. But what are your thoughts on that one when you look back? Well, Lars was my favorite filmmaker at the time, so I was like, I couldn't even believe that I was getting the opportunity to work with him and Anthony Dodd Mantle, who had shot Breaking the Waves, which was my favorite movie of that era.
44:20And I mean, Nicole Kidman and all these legends. Bacall. Bacall, Ben Gazzara, Udo Kier, Stellan Skarsgård, like all these people that I just was, you know, utterly in awe of. so I was yeah I was thrilled to be there I just yeah I mean I couldn't get enough of it and he was really I mean you know he was playful in a way that might be questionable but I liked that in a way like I was kind of also twisted maybe was that allowed to can I say that I don't know you know I could see that That's why some actresses had a hard time with him. And if I wasn't who I was, I think there was some behavior that might have been hard for me.
45:10But I kind of encouraged it because I'm also kind of a sicko. All right. Well, that's doggo. Let's go. Also that year, number two of three, Shattered Glass. This is, I think, Billy Ray's directorial debut. I certainly had been writing other things. But also you're playing one of the kind of a composite of a number of female journalists at the New Republic who worked alongside. Yeah. I mean, this movie should be seen now. Yeah. Yeah. And in fact, it was just shown at the Carlo Vivari International Film Festival because Peter was being honored. But it's it's terrific. And but you're kind of I think he had said he'd been looking for an actress, quote, who could convey the idea that her character was the smartest person in the room without having to say anything.
45:56working alongside this. I think Rosario was in that movie too. Who was? Rosario, maybe. Oh, that sounds right. Somebody's in it then, yeah. But yeah, anything on that one? I think I just thought the script was really smart and I hadn't read something like that before. And I think I just wanted to work. I was like, okay, if I'm not going to be a star, if I'm not going to get the opportunity to be like a movie star, which I'm not sure I ever really wanted to be. I was like, I'm just going to be a working actress, which is what I originally intended to be before the Boys Don't Cry kind of hoopla happened.
46:33So I was like, I just want to be like a character actress. I want to be a working actress. And this seems like a good opportunity to just do good work. Yeah. And a good movie. Number three of three, Daisy, a woman who gets involved with a biker on his way back to LA from a meetup in New Hampshire in Vincent Gallo's The Brown Bunny, which from the first time it screened at Cannes was a very controversial movie. I don't know how many of the people who actually opined about it ever saw it, but I'm sure you have feelings about that one. Yeah, I'm sure it took like 20 years off of my life. I'm still struggling with it to this day, and I'll ever live it down.
47:15But we had had a relationship. like we were friends for like 15 years before I think I knew him before I even made kids and he I think he had actually even given me some like acting advice before I started kids and um because I was really nervous about you know and I knew that he had done acting and we were friends and I thought you know I think I had actually even like helped him a little bit Buffalo 66 but I didn't end up making the movie for some reason and I just I don't know I believed in him as an artists and I also was like if Hollywood's not going to embrace me then I'm just gonna do something as subversive as possible maybe and just like be as punk as possible and unfortunately it came in something that's very taboo and still very taboo you know I've been in one of my favorite podcasts being a podcast is you must remember this and listening to the last two seasons prior to the old man um on sex in the 80s and 90s was so moving and like what a roller coaster to hear all these actresses stories and and and what it meant in the movies and and there was still a bit of that then you know um but yeah it's it's i mean i have to stand by it as something i did now I don't want to say I deny doing it or not deny, but, you know, regret.
48:40But it has been a hard thing to live with. I think part of it, though, is that you I think you've stated like it was in some ways misrep. Like it would have been a provocative movie no matter what. But then people reported things that I think you've said are not accurate. Like your representation dropped you. Yeah. That is not correct, right? No, it's not correct. Yeah. Yeah. I think I switched from like, John, I was a John Sloss, not John Sloss. I had like two different agents at Lori Morris at the time. And I think like somehow I switched agents at that time or I can't even remember how that rumor came up.
49:20But no, I was not fired by my agency. And stuff. I mean, and even though, as you've said, like there may be things about it that you that are not fun. It's not like, damn it, do you think it hurt your career? I don't know. I don't know. I mean, I don't know. Did not doing Legally Bond also hurt my career? Depends what you're trying to accomplish, I guess. Yeah, I mean, I don't know. I mean, I afterwards got some good work. Yeah. I'm sure you're going to recount for us all. Yes. Um, but I think that people that were making the kind of movies that I wanted to make would not have had, you know, an unfair judgment on it or, you know, a negative judgment.
50:11So I think that was kind of my way of really carving out like, oh, this is kind of, you know, who I am. Well, the, the, it might, what it might have done. And I wonder, maybe this is not correct, but like maybe it made you more open to considering TV opportunities at a time when we forget. It's not that long ago, but like if you were a person who had established yourself in film and were going to do TV, the assumption was your career is not going in a good direction. And yet, at almost the same time as The Wire, Sopranos, you know, a bunch of these shows, The Mad Men, right? Like, you end up doing Big Love for HBO in this kind of, like, the new golden age of TV.
51:01I think everybody else involved with that show went through a pretty crazy audition process, but these guys say they had seen you and loved you in Boys Don't Cry and somehow associated that with Nikki, this daughter of a Mormon, or inspired them to write Nikki, daughter of a Mormon prophet, played by Harry Dean Stanton, one of three sister wives, Gene Triplehorn and Jennifer Goodwin are the other two married to the same middle class man, Bill Paxton, right? Why, when other people, before other people were open to treating TV as a serious art form, were you willing to do that? Well, first of all, I think it was HBO and the caliber of work that they were putting out, like Sopranos, like you said, Six Feet Under.
51:49I think the cast that they were getting together for big love, like Harry Dean, you said Bruce Dern, Grace Sabrinsky, like all these incredible actors, Bill, and most importantly, the subject matter, I just found fascinating. also the financial because I had been living check to check I had never done a studio picture and I'd never wanted to up until that point I'd made some little paychecks like doing fashion stuff but I wanted to have some security I wanted to buy an apartment I was like you know um nearing 30 and I was still supporting my mother still am have been since my father passed and, you know, from her car to her phone to her house, you know, and myself.
52:37And so I thought that, and my agents convinced me at the time that it would only be a certain amount of time and then your downtime, you can make movies. Was that, it was too all-consuming to really do that? I mean, you can, but then they're like, everybody assumes that you're not available or that you only have the small window. And I would get some, I would squeeze some in there. But I mean, what a fulfilling, you know, project and character. I mean, I love that character so much. I love that show and the acting I got to do on the show. And like, I really feel like I came into my own playing Nikki and how they would write for me.
53:15And, you know, and the emotional roller coaster that she goes on and the different colors I got to play. And like, it was just like an exercise in acting. We were shooting on film every day, hundreds of takes, and, like, because the coverage was insane because the cast was so big, and it was just, like, we would go in, and we have, like, these blocking rehearsals that would be, like, two hours long. It was, like, nobody does that now. It was insane, the process back then. It was, like, I can't even believe, like, how involved we were in the acting of TV. Like, now it's, like, TV acting is, there's no time.
53:49It's, like, you're just, like, you're going in. like it was really it was really like a process and people respected the process and Tom Hanks and Gary Getzman were producers and they were around a lot and you know I just thought this like and around the time the book came out what is the Under the Banner of Heaven oh yeah and then Warren Jeffs was caught and like there was just all this stuff happening around I was like how are there these communities in America and like nobody's talking about it and these girls are like what is going on like it was like I was flabbergasted and so intrigued I read like every book I could find on polygamy and did like so much research and just like delved so deep into the world and got so emotionally invested in the character I remember like one season when everybody's mad at Nikki and like she's they think she's having an affair and everything just like it was so painful I was like processing it in such a way that like I didn't I hadn't learned yet to not or I didn't like it was a very draining year um doing the show um and the whole thing was five seasons for you I think it was five seasons and you were able to do and or chose to do a number of things during the off seasons including maybe most notably the largest scale thing you'd ever been a part of as far as a film right was zodiac yes my first studio picture first studio picture comes out in 2007 this is david fincher directing you're playing the wife of robert braismith melanie this is he's the journalist played by jake gillenall who's upset becomes obsessed and to the point of screwing up his life with solving the case of the zodiac killer.
55:41I always have to ask whenever Fincher comes up, I mean, I don't know exactly what the count would have been on Zodiac, but you hear about these like dozens upon dozens of takes and not ever, some people love it. Some people say they want to blow their brains out. How did you, had you ever had anything like that where somebody is asking you to do that like dozens of takes? I don't know if he did that so much before. I think this was kind of around when he started doing it i think it was the first film that he shot on digital okay we shot on the red harris avidas was the dp and um yeah i mean i was wrecked the first day i went home crying i'm gonna get fired and he called me and told me that was his process and it was strenuous it was hard and jake was hard and it was a hard shoot and i think he had been on like three movies back to back and And I think there was like tension between that.
56:37It was just like, it was a hard shoot. And I remember Mark Ruffalo just being like the nicest, warmest, most loveliest creature one could ever, you know, and, but yeah, I wasn't on at that. I mean, it was a long shoot and my, my days were pretty condensed. So yeah, I didn't have to, you know, bear the real brunt of it, but I just loved watching Fincher. I like fell in love with him and he looks like a forties boxer. so you cannot. And yeah, I'm a huge fan of his movies. And I love how inventive he is. I mean, from his music videos on, you know, I just think he's a great storyteller and a master of his craft.
57:15And I think very early in my career, I was like, I would just want to work with like, you know, auteurs or people that are pushing the form, you know, and, you know, want to tell original stories and hence me being afraid of falling into the studio system even though now I recognize that some of those you know things were actually also kind of fresh and fun and new in a way and you know so yeah well and and you screwed the pooch on that one no no no no I mean it's but it has been interesting that over the years since then let's say you've done all kinds of different film things I'm going to mention just a couple of random but like back with Whit Stillman and Kate Beckinsale with Love and Friendship 2018 the same year that I think you produced for the first time to have a you've said like you know maybe others were not giving you this sizable opportunity to show that you could carry a film or whatever with with in this case playing Lizzie Borden and Lizzie that same year but what's been really interesting to me is just and this kind of picks up almost right after Big Love ends in 2011 is a lot of different, you know, key things of varying sizes of this like TV new golden age that we started to talk about where just to mention really quickly a bunch, American Horror Story Asylum 2012, which I guess would have been your first interaction with Ryan Murphy.
58:45Then guest bits in Portlandia as the roommate who Fred and Carrie are both dating in 2013. Also in 2013, the Mindy Project, the ex-wife of Mindy's love interest played by Chris Messina. Then you have Bloodline, several seasons, which I thought was really an underappreciated great show on Netflix, 2015 to 2017, Bloodline. We've got another American Horror Story Hotel, the one with Lady Gaga as well in 2015, 2016, back with Ryan Murphy. I know you're friends with another past podcast guest, Natasha Lyonne. You guys did, or you were her character's mom on Russian Doll. Then back with Ryan Murphy again with Feud, Capote versus the Swans.
59:35And that leads us up to Monsters, the Lyle and Eric Menendez story, which is Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan. I guess before we go any further, like what is it about him that, how did you guys first connect? And it would seem like have some kind of a bond. Yeah, I got an offer for, I think I got an offer for Asylum for that part, which I read as being very small. and we talked and he convinced me to be pivotal and he was very charismatic and they sent me the first season which i hadn't watched when it was on i was like that was really terrifying and really good and i was like maybe i should do this because i felt like there's like a big audience of young people who maybe haven't been exposed to me or know who i am and i mean still to this day people only know me from American Horror Story.
1:00:29Really? Some people, not all people. And I, yeah, and then I just kind of watched as his shows just kind of kept hitting. And I was like, wow, who is this guy? He's making these movies, making these shows. And he's, you know, outspoken and writing all these incredible parts for women. You know, I think really what hit me hardest was the OJ American Crime. American Crime. I know, it's hard to keep track of. American Crime, sorry. Which was also produced by Brad Simpson, who had produced Boys Don't Cry. Oh, right, right, right. And, because he had worked at Killer. And that's when it really shifted for me that, well, this guy's having some interesting conversations, or he's trying to start interesting conversations and expose aspects of society or, you know, that maybe people are afraid of delving into.
1:01:26And I think like Versace and Dahmer were really important pieces of work. So Feud held its own allure for many different reasons. But, you know, when he came to me with Monsters, the Menendez story, I was like, well, the vein of the social commentary kind of stuff is very important. And I think you're really, you know, starting these really challenging conversations and, you know, approaching very taboo subjects in a really smart way that's digestible, but disturbing at the right level. I don't want to minimize them in any way. So, yeah, I'm trying to. But so he called me. I was on the set of my friend's movie, Atropia, doing a day.
1:02:11And he pitched me the part. And I was like, of course, you know. And this, just for anyone who hasn't yet checked it out and is going to listen to this, Katie Menendez was the wife of Jose, who was played in this by Javier Bardem, the mother of Lyle and Eric. And as I think you'd have to be living under a rock not to know, was then back in, is it 89 or 91? Somewhere around then was murdered by her children. I wonder first of all you've I think you said it was a pretty grueling shoot like six months so that's maybe that's just the nature of a limited series but um maybe a little shorter because of writer's strike I mean we had to cut an episode yeah and you're coming in from New York where you live to do this in LA back and forth um but also I just wonder you know yeah like on And it's got to be, I could see this being a particularly tough character to figure out because on one level, you know, you have to figure, I'm sure for yourself, like, how much did she know about the alleged abuse that her husband was inflicting on her children?
1:03:26How much was she abusing herself? Right. Yeah. What, was she being subjected? Yeah. Like, so I guess what was your. I think it goes back to something even prior to that, starting with like, even Boys Don't Cry, when you are telling a true story, just how tricky that is and how, especially crime, how many people have opinions and how many people are opinionated about one profiting off of those crimes and how sensitive it is and emotionally draining it is. and how much responsibility you feel to like, is it right? Are you telling the story right? I mean, there's just so many things that come into play that make it a very heavy experience.
1:04:15And how did you, in your own mind, in order to play somebody like Kitty, do you have to kind of feel that she did, like in your view, did the right thing or whatever? No. She didn't do the right thing. I mean, I don't think. But also what was more challenging about the way they told this story was through different people's, you know, perspective. So I kind of had to shift who she was per episode or every two episodes. And I'd never had to be tasked with kind of that sort of performance. And that was confusing. And then having to play, you know, the truth of her son's interpretation, which may have been more exaggerated than I would have played it if I was playing her truth.
1:05:09And so having to try to have that be rooted and have dignity in it was really hard. Yeah, I bet. And luckily the writing was really good and the director's really good. I love Max Winkler. He's like one of my favorite people in the world and he's a great director and he directed some of my favorite episodes of Feud too and Gus Van Sant obviously directed all the rest and he was incredible. But my big episode of Feud was Max, I mean of Monsters was Max and he was really a great like hand holder. But yeah, Javier and I talked about like just the subject and how it's not really, you know, people, even though people have told this story before many a times still this kind of abuse isn't really that often kind of dissected in a way on such a big platform as what Ryan was giving it and we thought that maybe that was important but But yeah, I also thought like other aspects of playing like her, I guess in her episode where she's like, I hate my children.
1:06:21Like how often do you see women mothers being able to say that and how many women can identify with that? And like, I can't tell you how many women I know that have said my body was ravaged by my child. I can never have my figure back. And like people don't really say that out loud a lot. But like to be able to say that as a character on TV, I thought was, you know, kind of a great opportunity, you know, for women to tune and be like, I feel the same way.
1:06:52I don't know. Was there, as you think back on it, was there a, because it is almost like however many different performances you had. It's not one performance because of all these different perspectives that you're talking about. Was there one of those perspectives or even a scene within one of the perspectives that you felt was the most complicated for you as an actress? I mean, there was like the one where there's the flashback to when they're little and she's walking. It's a very simple scene. She's walking down the hallway with the laundry and she knows something's going on and she just keeps walking.
1:07:29Like, how can, you know, I have a five-year-old. I can't. yeah yeah like how can a mother and it's you know ever present and these women just don't know what to do or have anywhere to turn to or like you know anyone to tread and like they just stay in it like the cycle of abuse is so intense and she had come from you know an abusive family and like just that simple scene i'm just like can you ever you're like so that was one of the more disturbing days well so the show i don't even say anything no no it's that's that's doesn't mean it's any easier yeah the show when it came out was number one most popular thing on all of netflix which is a pretty big deal and it definitely revived the conversation about you know should these guys be or not be incarcerated still um some of your collaborators on this have uh argued that they should be out that's apparently being looked at to some degree do you have any thoughts on that right but then didn't the attorney i think it's been there's been uh a change in the attorney general yes that's what i meant yeah so something but i don't know where it stands right now but do you have any feelings you know what i'm really conflicted i like i don't want to sound trite at all but like did they have to kill the mom you know what i mean like she was complicit but like they still murdered these two people you know i just i know there's remorse i know they've been incarcerated for a really long time And the behavior post was just so wrong.
1:09:32Yeah, I'm really, like, also, like, just because they're the white privilege boys that did this, they're getting focus on it. I mean, I'm sure there's been cases of this, you know, hundreds of thousands of them that don't get this kind of attention. But yeah, I don't. I'm kind of with you. I don't get it. I mean, like, I mean, if they were abused, which is not that's disputed. Right. Yeah. Like, unfortunately and inexcusably, like a lot of people have been abused that don't then go and kill their families. families no so i don't know i i but anyway that's on a happier note uh for for big love you won a golden globe back in 2010 but you did not ever for any of these five seasons receive an emmy nomination in fact i think that i think that the subject was just a little trickier skirting on too progressive for them well i think that was kind of the overall arching thing of big love was like kind of like how liberal are you liberals right it's true well meanwhile last month that that was corrected in that you joined a lot of your co-stars in receiving one and i just wonder you know i clearly that's not why you do this stuff but that's got to feel kind of nice feels really nice i mean it's you know my fellow actors voting which feels the most nice of all i mean i think the second stage is maybe a little different with the members but like the original voting is a wider breadth and um um i get to vote uh so that to be singled out i think in a very competitive field because television is so incredible right now and streaming and there's so many different shows across so many platforms that are, you know, even, you know, even in the limited category, um, to be singled out felt incredible.
1:11:41And, you know, I, I take my craft very seriously. I think, I don't know. I mean, I hope people see me as that. I'm a very serious actress. I'm very serious about my work. I have been working steadily since, except for those two years I dropped off, which I didn't even think about. Thanks for reminding me. you're allowed you're allowed there's a lot of other tv things and movies which you didn't mention i know like hit miss and england and louis and so many other shows and things but um i rush a doll i just i just love working and i love i love creating and i love i'm very attracted to people like you know like fred and carrie like you know you know different you know will mark different people that have like you know real stories to tell and um i'm very committed to my performances and so to have someone recognize it felt really like meaningful for me um because i think sometimes it gets clouded because people think oh she's so fashionable or she's so much of a personality as i put you've said the the it girl thing which is used in the majority of articles that have ever been written about that's actually not a not a great thing in your view to have i mean i don't know i mean i love claire bow she was originally a girl it's one of the best books actress bios ever written um but um i think i think in the early days maybe a clouded stuff but yeah i just want to be taken you know taken seriously as you know i did you know we are who we are with luca guadagnino and then he's cast me in two of his movies you know post that so um i think the return business is really good jim jarmusch yeah i've done a bunch of movies with jim um yeah i mean the two with wet stillman multiple with laurs von treyer on and on no it's pretty i don't know how many people can match these uh match david fincher would call again yeah that's true i mean he's shooting in town right now let's get him up get him going but uh no but all right so when we're here we are talking though uh as we said 30 years into a career at the moment you came and i'm sure you're very tired so thank you for still doing this but from an early call for a project called the five star weekend you have coming up at these fall fests after the hunt the most recent with Luca Guarnino, which is also with Julie Roberts and Ayo Edebrey.
1:14:18I don't know if I'm saying correct. I certainly know. Andrew Garfield. And Andrew Garfield, right. You have directed three or four shorts. And I think you've said you want to do a feature. A feature if people stop asking me to act for a minute. And also, I don't know, maybe the It Girl thing kind of, there's a full circle where it actually becomes a cool thing because within the last year, I believe, You were part of the Hall of Fame ensemble of it girls in Charlie XCX's 360 music video. So anyway, bottom line, here we are that far into a career with this much of a body of work to look back on.
1:14:55Just any final thoughts? Final thoughts? I don't know. I mean, yeah, just it feels nice this year, like 50. I'm doing a lighthearted comedy called The Five Star Hotel with Jennifer Garner and Regina Hall, Gemma Chan and Darcy Carden. And like, I was like, oh, this is why people do this. And it's also challenging and like to be present in those kinds of moments, but enjoy yourself. I was like, this is the first time that I've done a project where I've been able to kind of just like enjoy it and not have to take it home and be like absorbing it in a way. Like feeling like there's such a, I really have to bring the, you know what I mean?
1:15:45The stakes are really high today. And like, even though there's stakes in the show, it's more like fun. Yeah. I was like, this is really nice. We got to get you on a white Lotus or something. That would be great. I may God willing, yes. No, but it's really a pretty unique, cool trajectory, and I really appreciate you doing this. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for taking the time to come and talk to me.
1:16:26app and to follow us on Twitter and Instagram, where our handle is at Awards Chatter. On those platforms, we announce upcoming guests and provide details about special live recordings of the podcast that you can attend. Until next time, thanks again for tuning in.
1:16:44Chloë Sevigny:I want to date with Rawls, Carty says. Rawls? Rucka asks. This is the love story of real hinge couple, Carti and Rocker. Written and read by me, Nicola Dynan. Listen to the free audiobook now. This episode is brought to you by ChatGPT. Hey, it's Bill Simmons from the Bill Simmons Podcast. Have you guys heard about ChatGPT work? It's the new way to use ChatGPT for bigger multi-step projects. And when you need more than just answers, give ChatGPT work access to your apps and files, and it can create real work documents like spreadsheets, slides, and structured reports. Get started at chatgpt.com by selecting work mode available on plus and pro plans.
From the publisher
The Oscar- and Emmy-nominated indie darling reflects on her unusual path to prominence, the backstories of some of her more provocative projects (including 'Kids,' 'Boys Don't Cry' and 'The Brown Bunny') and why she has increasingly been drawn to TV projects (from 'Big Love' to numerous Ryan Murphy projects including his latest limited series, in which she plays the Menendez family's murdered matriarch).
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
