

Kathy Bates discusses her career arc and the making of key roles, culminating in her CBS drama Matlock (season 1, Sept 2024–Apr 2025), where she plays older-returning lawyer Madeline “Maddie” Matlock. She also reflects on acting’s origins, stage-to-screen disappointments, and experiences with major directors and films.
Kathy Bates (guest). Host: Scott Feinberg (Hollywood Reporter Awards Chatter Podcast).
Born and raised in Memphis, Tennessee (1948). Trained at Southern Methodist University; early influences included Memphis actor Ray Hill and speech teacher Gene Crane. Began in theater (including Actors Theatre of Louisville/Humana Festival), later moved to film/TV; directed episodes of Homicide: Life on the Street, NYPD Blue, Oz, Six Feet Under, and Everwood. Survived cancer twice (ovarian, then breast).
Misery’s Annie Wilkes was shaped with backstory and manic-depressive grounding; she was cast largely without audition. Night Mother stage-to-screen recasting was the most painful disappointment. Oscar didn’t change her job immediately; she still relied on momentum. Titanic filming in Mexico was exhausting and less enjoyable than the original trip.
Misery (Oscar win; AFI villain ranking), Titanic (unsinkable Molly Brown), Primary Colors, About Schmidt (nude scene with Jack Nicholson), The Waterboy, Bad Santa 2, Fried Green Tomatoes (friendship with Jessica Tandy), Dolores Claiborne, and Matlock’s Rotten Tomatoes 100% and ratings.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore the humorous conspiracy of lemon versus lime in sodas.
“For decades, a shadowy organization called the Lemonati has kept lemon on top and lime in the shadows.”
Bates reflects on her illustrious career and recent successes.
“She subsequently garnered three other Oscar nominations, all in the category of Best Supporting Actress, for Mike Nichols' Primary colors, Alexander Payne's About Schmidt, and Clint Eastwood's Richard Jewell.”
Setting the stage for an in-depth conversation with Bates.
“And so without further ado, let's go to that conversation.”
Bates discusses her upbringing in Memphis and family background.
“And on this one, we truly go back to the very beginning and start there.”
Bates shares how having older parents shaped her childhood.
“And I know you've said that they were a little older than usual when you came along.”
Bates reflects on family visits to Hollywood and early interests in acting.
“And I think that was the time for a lot of us when things changed.”
Bates talks about key mentors in her early theater career.
“So she was my favorite part of the trip.”
Bates recounts her journey of discovering her passion for acting.
“And he filled in that father generation.”
Bates shares her challenges and early successes in New York theater.
“But I was so clueless, and for a long time, I just didn't know what was what, you know?”
Kathy Bates discusses the challenges of obtaining an equity card for auditions.
“I was there for two years and there was this, it was a catch 22 really.”
Bates shares her journey in theater, including key roles and experiences in Louisville.
“wrote this fantastic play called Vanities.”
The conversation covers various productions Bates was part of and a tragic loss of a friend.
“Correct me, obviously, if any of this is wrong, but just to connect the dots and to remind people of, you know, you were, and of course remain, but in these early years, really distinguish yourself on the stage.”
Bates reflects on the disappointment of not being cast in film adaptations of her stage roles.
“Terrence McNally writing a show for you is not a small thing.”
Bates recounts her transition to film and the journey leading to her role in Misery.
“But I was lucky that Bill Goldman was sitting in the audience of Frankie and Johnny, because then that's when he gave Rob the idea to cast me as Annie Wilkes.”
Bates discusses the depth she brought to her character Annie Wilkes in Misery.
“Had you read, I don't know if many people had yet, but had you read the book?”
Kathy Bates discusses the creative process behind a pivotal dinner scene in 'Misery'.
“screenplay that you remember keeping in the back of your head that might have informed your performance?”
Bates reflects on her character Annie's background and the preparation involved in portraying her.
“As my mother said when she saw the movie, she thought he was watching a snake.”
Bates shares her initial reactions to seeing 'Misery' and how it impacted her.
“that lack of fulfillment in her life, I think, contributed to her loneliness and her isolation.”
Kathy Bates discusses her emotions and expectations during her first Oscar night.
“And I remember getting back, and then my agent had arranged for someone to make a gown for me, which just fit like a glove, wonderful seamstress, and a designer, Jeff Billings, who made costumes for Stars on Ice.”
Kathy Bates talks about the immediate effects of winning an Oscar on her life and career.
“And I was like, okay, this is real, you know?”
Bates reminisces about her role in 'Fried Green Tomatoes' and her friendship with Jessica Tandy.
“And so we were standing up the top of the theater after we were all like holding hands, jumping up and down because we were all theater ladies, you know.”
Kathy Bates shares insights into her directing career and experiences with various projects over the years.
“I was coming back from Japan, and I just didn't...”
Kathy Bates shares her journey into directing and experiences with actors.
“I just, one of my favorite movies is Seven Psychopaths.”
Kathy Bates discusses her challenging experience filming Titanic in Mexico.
“They asked me to do one last year and I felt it was too much because I didn't know what it was going to be like energy-wise and I was still developing the character.”
Bates reflects on her Oscar nomination for Primary Colors and working with Mike Nichols.
“It was a quart, no, it was a quart, quintet, I think it was.”
Kathy Bates recounts her initial hesitation about joining Adam Sandler's The Waterboy.
“I have asked them about that because I've gathered that there was something about the way he worked with actors, maybe because it was from theater and live performing himself or what.”
Bates discusses her notable scene in About Schmidt and challenges faced in the industry.
“There's another person who, when you talk to actors as an interviewer, it just seems like there's something about the way he writes and directs that brings out the best in the people he works with.”
Kathy Bates discusses the value of pursuing passions and the regret of missed opportunities.
“And I certainly wouldn't have gotten the part in Misery if I looked like Michelle Pfeiffer.”
Kathy reflects on the significance of authenticity in acting versus physical beauty.
“In addition to being great, you've also had to be tough.”
Exploring how beauty can be a trap and the importance of versatility in a long career.
“the remarkable thing is not that everyone doesn't look like Michelle Pfeiffer on screen, but that, you know, this makes more sense in a way.”
Kathy discusses her cancer journey and how it influenced her career choices post-treatment.
“My friend Jessica Lange, she was incredible, incredible beauty when she started out.”
Kathy reflects on her collaborations with Ryan Murphy and their significance in her career.
“I think that was your Emmy nomination for that.”
Discussing her transition to Matlock and the excitement of taking on new challenging roles.
“that 2013 first project with Ryan Murphy that sparked all the, you know, a number of years with him, understandably, you weren't in a happy place.”
Kathy explains the character of Madeline Matlock and the creative process behind her portrayal.
“People in their twenties say that doing a show for a broadcast network, even, you know, maybe gone are the days of whatever, 28 episodes.”
Explore the complexities of character development in 'Matlock'.
“He said, okay, well, we'll give you, you know, because I said, are you going to hire me now?”
Discusses themes of aging women and societal perceptions in the show.
“I guess thematically there are some similar, you know, law and all of that, but this is its own beast.”
The show connects with viewers across different generations.
“That women do reach an age where either they let themselves go or whatever.”
Review the overwhelming success and viewership of the first season.
“It's the number one most watched news series and the number two most watched series overall on television behind only CBS's Tracker.”
Kathy Bates shares her vision for the show's future and personal reflections.
“How long would you like to keep doing it?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Awards Chatter, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00For decades, a shadowy organization called the Lemonati has kept lemon on top and lime in the shadows. Look around, lemon forward sodas, even lemon forward songs. We ran the tracks, slowed them down, reversed them and squeezed out the truth.
0:19That's lemon propaganda right there. But now, 7up is fighting back with their new lime lemon soda. Join the 7up rising. Flip the sip.
0:37Scott Feinberg: Hi, everyone, and thank you for tuning in to the 593rd episode of the Hollywood Reporters Awards Chatter Podcast. I'm the host, Scott Feinberg, and my guest today is one of the truly great character actresses of all time, a powerhouse on the stage and screens big and small for the past 50 years, Kathy Bates. Bates won a Best Actress Oscar for bringing from the page to the screen, Annie Wilkes, the psychopathic number one fan of an author of romance novels, in Rob Reiner's Misery, a character that was later chosen in a poll conducted by the American Film Institute as the 17th greatest movie villain of all time.
1:14Scott Feinberg: She subsequently garnered three other Oscar nominations, all in the category of Best Supporting Actress, for Mike Nichols' Primary colors, Alexander Payne's About Schmidt, and Clint Eastwood's Richard Jewell. She also was a part of the film that became the biggest blockbuster of all time for 12 years, 1997's Titanic, which was awarded the Best Picture Oscar, and she starred in 2009's The Blindside and 2011's Midnight in Paris, which both were nominated for that same prize. She played the mother of Adam Sandler in 1998's The Waterboy and Billy Bob Thornton in 2016's Bad Santa 2. She directed episodes of Homicide, Life on the Street, NYPD Blue, Oz, Six Feet Under, for which she received a Director's Guild Award nomination, and Everwood.
2:04Scott Feinberg: She beat two different forms of cancer, and the list goes on. In short, there's nothing that Kathy Bates cannot do. But not even Bates, who is now 76, anticipated the massive success of her latest project, the CBS drama series Matlock, which shares a name with the classic Andy Griffith show that ran from 1986 through 1995, but is very much its own thing. On her version of Matlock, the first season of which rolled out between September 2024 and April 2025, she plays Madeline Maddie Matlock, a lawyer who returns to the workforce at an older age than most, ostensibly because she needs the money. but actually, we later learn, with other motivations.
2:48Scott Feinberg: The show received rave reviews. It's at 100 % on Rotten Tomatoes. It generated huge ratings. It was the most watched new series and the second most watched series overall during the 2024-2025 season. And it has already brought her a Best Actress in a Drama Series Critics' Choice Award with an Emmy nomination almost certain to follow, which would, in turn, represent a chance to add a third Emmy to her collection that already includes statuettes for Best Guest Actress in a Comedy Series for playing Charlie Sheen's Ghost on Two and a Half Men, and Best Supporting Actress in a Limited Series for playing a 19th century woman dug up from her grave in 21st century New Orleans on American Horror Story Coven.
3:31Scott Feinberg: Over the course of a conversation at her home in Los Angeles, Bates reflected on how she wound up becoming an actress in the first place, and why she stuck with it even as stage roles that she originated, with great success, were brought to the screen with more traditionally beautiful actresses, how misery changed her career, what her reaction was upon being asked to do a nude scene with Jack Nicholson in About Schmidt, and why she felt the passengers on the real Titanic had a more enjoyable time than she did on the film About It, why she almost walked away from acting before signing on to Matlock, and why she has found the show to be such a gratifying and rejuvenating project to be part of, plus much more.
4:12Scott Feinberg: And so without further ado, let's go to that conversation.
4:22Scott Feinberg: All right, Kathy, thank you so much for joining us on the podcast. Great to have you. And on this one, we truly go back to the very beginning and start there. If you wouldn't mind sharing for our listeners, where were you born and raised and what did your folks do for a living? I was born and raised in Memphis, Tennessee. I was born in 1948. At the time I came along, my dad, he was an engineer and he created, like for if there are people around the area that had problems with machine parts, like the cotton gins and all these other places, they would bring their parts in and he would blueprint and then they would pour another one.
4:59And mom was a stay-at-home mom.
5:01Scott Feinberg: Yeah, yeah. And I know you've said that they were a little older than usual when you came along. My dad was 45 when I was born, so I can kind of relate. But I wonder how you think it might have affected you as a kid to have parents that were a bit older, to have siblings that were quite a bit older, right, as well. Well, did you have brothers and sisters? I do, and I'm the oldest. So my brother was, the youngest was, my dad was 50. Okay, so your dad was 50? When the last sibling was born, yeah. So you're still close in age, you guys. Yeah, we are all within five years. That's what I missed is my sisters, one is nine years older and one is 15.
5:42So when I came along, I was, as my mother would say, depending on the day, an unexpected pleasure. It was very different. And also the time of history that we lived through. I was born in Memphis, as I said. it was segregated at the time and then the 60s and the hippies and all of that you know which more or less I embraced as I got involved with theater so all of those things were very different growing up and very different navigating because my sisters were gone and my parents were so much older they had very different views than I had about those different political events that came along during the time that I was a teenager and by the time I left the house.
6:32And I think that was the time for a lot of us when things changed.
6:37Scott Feinberg: Absolutely. And I know something else that was going on during those years when you were still at home was that you would occasionally come out here and see relatives, right? So what was that when you would come out to LA, Hollywood, whatever, were you at that point even aspiring to be a person who might end up out here or was that not yet interest? Well, I think I always had the gene. And when we came out here, we got to visit my maternal grandmother and my maternal aunt. And she was wonderful. She worked for a bookstore. I remember I have a wonderful photo of her with me in front of Grandma's Chinese.
7:18And I think it was eight years old. So she was my favorite part of the trip. Although as I got older, we'd drive about Highway 66, and I was learning to drive, and my dad had a really nice Cadillac, so I had fun memories about that.
7:35Scott Feinberg: Yeah. There are two names that anyone listening is not going to know, but I wonder if you can explain who they are and why they matter in your life. Ray Hill and Gene Crane. Those are the two that I want to come to you for. Ray Hill was a wonderful actor in Memphis, and I remember him coming to visit, Gene Crane was our speech teacher and he was involved in theater in Memphis. He was such a cool teacher. And I remember the day Ray Hill came to visit our class and Ray was actually standing in the aisle near me and I don't know why he did this, but he was very comic and funny and then all of a sudden he burst into tears And I thought, oh, my God, that's what I want to do.
8:23And I didn't realize that Annie Wilkes was standing next to me. But Gene was a big, big influence in my life. I remember going to a speech tournament down in Miami, and he worked with me a lot on my, I did a speech from Streetcar Named Desire. He was just so supportive of me. And he filled in that father generation. My father was more like a grandfather. you know I mean when he grew up his parents called each other Mr. and Mrs. you know so I think looking back now Gene really filled that gap but also he was somebody that that he could see you know I did plays for him when I was in high school he was a wonderful director they did musicals that were very successful there so I went back for his funeral not a few years ago now but he meant a great deal to me he was very excited when I won the Emmy and I mean when I won the Oscar.
9:19And I remember going back to Memphis and they celebrated. That's great. So the idea of
9:26Scott Feinberg: pursuing acting for a living or as a profession, I should say, just you went off to Southern Methodist University in Dallas. I guess it wasn't originally the major, right? What was your, or maybe it was a pretty quickly, pretty quickly change, but what happened that you have described as the best thing that ever happened to me. Well, you know, you have orientation and the head of the School of Humanities, I think his name was Kermit Hunter at that time. I'm not sure you'd have to check me on that, but whoever he was, he was talking to all of us and he was a wonderful speaker. And he said, this is where you're going to begin your life's work.
10:04And suddenly I thought, wait a minute, I don't want to be a teacher. I don't want to be this. I don't well, maybe, can I be in plays? Can I be, can I do this? And he was, I kept interrupting him, and he was so exasperated, he handed me my folder, and he said, you're in the wrong school. Go down the hall, last door on the left, which is so ironic. Go last door on the left. He said, that's where you belong. So I marched down. I had, mind you, my little villager, you know, shirtwaist dress, and my hair in a bob and a little circle pin. And I went down and my Ouija and loafers and I knocked on the door and opened and there were people with beards and hippies and long dresses.
10:52And I thought, here, that's where I belong. So I went back and forth. And also my father was saying, God, because we didn't have a lot of money and I didn't realize it picked one of the most expensive schools you can go to. And my father, God rest him, he really made that happen for me. You know, when I was changing back and forth, he said, aren't you doing chemistry? What about science? What about all these things that he would have loved to take, you know? So I said, no, no, no, this is it. But I was so clueless, and for a long time, I just didn't know what was what, you know? I mean, and so one day I went up to Dallas Hall, which is where they had this little, tiny little theater where they started out.
11:33When I left, they had the Bob Hope Theater and another theater. all those rich women you know with the oil company uh the wives you know it was very they were very involved in the arts there we thank god for them anyway i went up there to this dallas hall place and i were doing a play uh queen esther of the yellow ganders and i saw this man named garland wright young man and he was such a wonderful actor so elegant and so effortless and it was as though as I've gotten older, I realized that that's what happens to people with gurus, is that something just hits you in your solar plexus and it explodes.
12:12And just watching him, that's what happened. And I thought, I'll do anything. I'll do anything to be part of this. I know this is where I belong. This is it. I'll do it. I'll do anything. And I was so fortunate that this was the beginning of the transformation of that theater department into a proper conservatory.
12:32Scott Feinberg: And if I'm not mistaken, he and maybe somebody else as well who you were in school with later come back around when you're going, you know, professionally as an actress, right? So you graduate with the BFA in 69. You go to New York not long after that in your early 20s. And wasn't one of the, maybe it was somebody else, but Vanities, wasn't that the first? Yes. When I went to New York, I had friends that were in college two years ahead of me. And they were living in New York at the time, and they had an apartment. And they were going on to do Stratford and do the theater company there. So I was able to take one of their rooms and start there.
13:13And that was Jack Hefner, who later then wrote Vanities and really started my career. Because I did a lot of things in between, like a lot of us do, waiting tables and doing office work.
13:25Scott Feinberg: and you know and um I heard you were at MoMA yes counting quarters quarters that's that they cost way back then uh yeah and then when they asked me if I wanted to become a a proper um uh accountant I said well put the brakes on yeah I went home to Memphis for a for a summer and I had a cousin who had just purchased a house on Capitol Hill and so then I thought okay I gotta figure out how to do this. Maybe I'll start in Washington. And this was after having sampled New York and even done vanities, right? Or not yet. That was the first part of it. Yes. I was there for two years and there was this, it was a catch 22 really.
14:09It was that if you had to have an equity card to get into an equity audition, but you couldn't do an equity, you know, and it was, It was very difficult to get into the union and to figure out how to do this. And finally, I just thought, okay, I've got to start over.
14:27Scott Feinberg: So after that period in D.C. where I now remember you were doing some outside-the-box stuff, right? I think you said you were a duck or something. Yes, the story theater. Yes, the story theater. I played a duck. All right. Yeah, there you go. My first actor's equity contract. I was so proud. Great beginnings. It said duck and others. So then you come back to New York. Yes, and so finally I came back because I thought, you know, I've got it. And I went to New York and I discovered there was a theater company there that I auditioned to become part of and got a job there. And then from that, I mean, I was still going back and forth to, you know, waiting tables and the unemployment line.
15:09And then Jack, who was two years older than us, Jack Hefner, wrote this fantastic play called Vanities. And then I was okay. I didn't have to go back in the unemployment line.
15:20Scott Feinberg: Well, so that was 1976 when I was off Broadway. Then there's this interesting thing where I guess you're spending some time in Louisville. I was out here visiting with my sister, and I was doing vanities out here, the B team. And I just thought, you know, going back to school, we had a wonderful teacher, Dr. Hopgood, Dr. Burnett Hopgood. And I remember so clearly him saying to us, this is where you're going to begin. It's going to take you 15 years to do this. Just like if you were going to be a lawyer or a doctor, it's going to take that amount of time. So that focused me at school in looking at my talent in a very different way.
16:03And I really came from being afraid to open my mouth and learning lines and all that stuff too. over the years learning how to break scripts and such, but I hadn't completed that out here. And I knew that I didn't want to get involved in television because it was a different genre. And in my mind, what I wanted to do was more serious, more trained, more roles that had a variety and roles that had a depth and a learning how to sustain a performance from when the curtain goes up to the curtain goes down. And, of course, television is very like a mosaic. That was what led me to Actors Theatre of Louisville because they had that wonderful Humana Festival down there with all the new playwrights, and that gave me a real variety of roles to play.
17:01Scott Feinberg: Correct me, obviously, if any of this is wrong, but just to connect the dots and to remind people of, you know, you were, and of course remain, but in these early years, really distinguish yourself on the stage. And so we've got in Louisville, the original production of Crimes of the Heart, where you're playing the fantasizing sister, Lenny. We've got, as a result, I guess, of that, you meet in Louisville, Marcia Norman, who then writes Night Mother with you in mind for the divorcee who tells her mother she's ready to commit suicide. In between is Come Back to the Five and Dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean, which Altman directed on Broadway, and then in the same year as a film with you in both.
17:48Scott Feinberg: I mean, and these, Broadway, I should say, Night Mother was on Broadway, so that's a big deal. I know you'd add, I think you'd written a replacement or a smaller part, but like that was your first really big thing there right yes and I I have to correct you that the part was not written for me Marsha had done a wonderful play called Getting Out yeah and uh the woman who starred in that was Susan Kingsley and um Marsha had written that play for Susan Kingsley and for Ann Petoniak Susan was going to she had kids two babies um in Frankfurt Kentucky Jackie, and the producer, Marsha's husband, wanted her to commit six months, and she couldn't stay away from her babies that long.
18:34So she ended up bowing out, and then they cast me in the role, and I was not at all what they were looking for. Susan is this scrawny, long-bone country woman, brilliant. So I remember walking over to Marsha's house. I was at 72nd and Columbus near the station there, and Susan came there. She was right by me and came over, and she threw her arms around, because we worked in Louisville together and became good friends, and I was just so enamored of her and working with her. And I remember her throwing her arms around my neck, and she said, you're going to get it. And sure enough, I got the role.
19:22But then after we had been doing the play for a while, Susan was killed in an automobile accident. And I think I had a bit of survivor's guilt, although it was just, anyway, it was tragic.
19:40Scott Feinberg: Absolutely. And I know on top of the already heavy material of that show where this is a young woman who's telling her. Yes, exactly. And she came to see it. She did see it. I saw her, yeah. She came to see it. And I think it was one of those moments. She came to the dressing room and there was a moment where she was really absorbing what she had just seen and what she could have probably done with the role because it was written for her. Sure. The last of these that I'll mention from that theater run there, 87 Off-Broadway, the original, and this one I believe was written for you, Frankie and Johnny in the Claire de Lune.
20:20Yes.
20:20Scott Feinberg: Terrence McNally writing a show for you is not a small thing. No, it wasn't. And so, I mean, I guess on the one hand, you've got all this great momentum and response to your work on the stage. And yet a part of you, it seems like, would have liked to have been a part of the, you did the film version of Come Back to the Five and Dime. But with Crimes of the Heart, with Night Mother, with Frankie and Johnny, as you know, and I know you've spoken about, like, they go to Hollywood and they find somebody completely different and whatever. And it's heartbreaking. You hear these stories. I mean, they're probably the most famous.
21:02Scott Feinberg: And the reasons vary. But, I mean, we all know about Julie Andrews getting bounced from My Fair Lady for the movie version and things like that. So it happens. And Jessica Tandy. And Jessica Tandy. She was the only one from the stage production of Streetcar, and she didn't go and do it. Oh, my God. I have to measure my displeasure by those people. Were you even given a chance to audition for the film versions? What sort of feedback did they get? Was that really as tough as I imagine it might have been? As I got older, the one that hurt the most was Night Mother. Hurt is not really accurate. Disappointment.
21:40And because I felt that the material to see Ann and I, who had worked on this play for two years plus, just walk in and do, we'd have a record of those performances, which, if I can say so myself, were brilliant. And we were both nominated for Tonys and it won a Pulitzer Prize. And nowadays, with Indies, we would have been a shoe-in. And as much as I love Sissy Spacek and Anne Bancroft, well, I can't say this of Sissy, but of Anne, she does a No Country Roads.
22:20Scott Feinberg: Right, right. You know, and she'd be the first to admit that, God rest her. And the rest, I mean, some of them I didn't find out even until it was already a fait accompli, you know. But I was lucky that Bill Goldman was sitting in the audience of Frankie and Johnny, because then that's when he gave Rob the idea to cast me as Annie Wilkes. So just to step back for one more second, I know you'd sort of done toe dips in filmmaking with as early as the late 70s with Straight Time. That was the one with your first, I think, speaking part with Dustin Hoffman. 82, we mentioned you did with Robert Altman, come back to the five and dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean, the film version.
23:03Scott Feinberg: But you didn't actually move out to LA to really try your luck out here until 85, I read. And when you got out here, you know, there, I guess, in addition to auditioning or meeting or whatever for different things, you were still, you know, there's still a desire, I'm sure, to act and a need to pay the bills and all that. So you were acting in a place where I was just a few days ago before all the drama downtown, which is the Mark Taper Forum, right? So I didn't realize, so William Goldman, the great screenwriter, had seen you in Frankie and Johnny back in New York, but then I believe Rob Reiner maybe just separately was seeing you a lot at the Mark Taper when you were doing a show there?
23:50Actually, it was Taper 2. I did a terrible performance of Aunt Dan and Lemon. That was the one that Linda Hunt was so brilliant in. And I was just awful. He was dating Elizabeth McGovern at the time and she was in the show. So he'd had, he'd come quite often. And I guess, you know, he, he saw me ranting and raving as this, this lunatic. And, um, I don't know if, I think he saw me in other plays as well.
24:16Scott Feinberg: I read somewhere where he was coming a lot to that show because of Elizabeth. With lots of roses. With lots of roses. You were the beneficiary of that, I guess, but were you at that time getting people, sending you scripts or things like that for asking you to come in and audition for things, or was everything a fight to get? You know, I guess there was an audition here and there, but I don't recall very many of them, oddly enough. Yeah, I must have had auditions, but it was hard to get scripts, it was hard to get seen. I remember auditioning. I don't know. I just don't recall. That's fine. And so in this case, had you met Rob when he was coming back to see Elizabeth?
24:58Scott Feinberg: Or what led to you first becoming aware of something called Misery? Oh, it wasn't until a friend of mine in New York, the book had just come out. A friend of mine said, you know, when they do the movie, you and Martin Sheen should do this and I thought yeah in a million years and so it was quite a few years later when I was out here that I got this uh thanks to Bill I got this call to come in and meet with Rob and um so I had I don't think I really even laid eyes on him when we were doing Aunt Dan and Lemon you know um so it was all a big uh a big surprise and and and that I really you know I didn't really have to audition.
25:43I read with him a couple of times.
25:45Scott Feinberg: Had you read, I don't know if many people had yet, but had you read the book? Oh, God, yeah. You had? Oh, yeah, that's what I meant. Oh, from when you were a friend. Yeah, when my friends, because I was a big Stephen King fan. Yeah, sure, sure, sure. Huge. I think I read everything that came out and his short stories, all that kind of stuff, and wonderful characters that always made me feel that he more than anything he is such a you know horror genre but it's his characters that are so rich and I didn't realize until years later that uh his whole reason for writing that book was because he was getting off of cocaine and he was he I guess he felt like he was tied down to a bed I don't know all the specifics about it but um anyway interesting well so you go in and in the room it's rob and goldman or who's in the room when you were reading uh just rob just rob yeah and then andy scheinman came in and listened to me do a page or two and do you remember what they had to read oh gosh i don't i mean there are so many great options it could have been there's there's a lot of juicy.
26:58There was one I know where she was really angry.
27:01Scott Feinberg: Yeah. Yeah. So I'm sure that that was part of it. And how quickly did you find out that you had the part? Then? In the room? Yeah. I know he's talked about that you were skeptical even that that it was safe to assume that it was going to hold up that you were cast. Why was that? Had you had other experiences? Oh my god no. No? Are you kidding? It was hard to even get in the room. Right right right right. So it was just kind Kind of all surreal. Yeah. What was the first thing you did when you left the room? I think what was the first thing I did was I think I called my mother and said, you know, I've got this part.
27:36And it was really exciting.
27:39Scott Feinberg: So I know one of the things that both you and Rob have talked about is that there was a very conscious desire to not have her just be kind of one dimensionally crazy, quote unquote. quote, there was going to be, you know, triggers and a backstory and things that would inform what sets her off and why and all of that. Are there things that are not in the book or in the screenplay that you remember keeping in the back of your head that might have informed your performance? I know that the dinner scene, although I just did an interview with Rob, I could have sworn it was Warren Beatty, who was working on the script with them for a couple of months and I thought it was his idea to do the dinner scene but Rob said no no that was Andy and I so I said okay and because they they felt that you know Warren had said this is a prison movie and it's got I think that they went to every leading man out here into LA you know and we didn't want to be seen as a victim and uh they asked Warren to do it he said no no no he said but if you have a problem come back to me so that's the the difference that I've felt and in And in a way, some of the work that I did in Night Mother fed into who she was because she was manic depressive, Annie, obviously.
28:55But the depressive side of her, I felt, was very close to what I worked with on Night Mother. So there was that for me. And Rob really handed me that role on a silver platter. he was there every moment helping me shape that performance work with Jimmy because we came very different you know Jimmy was very instinctive and which I've become now myself but I like to plan things out and and well no that's wrong though Scott it's not that it's just that I didn't feel that we communicated very well. And Rob said, you know, that's what's happening between the two of them, is that she's having a relationship with who she thinks this guy is.
29:46So this is all in her mind and his reaction. As my mother said when she saw the movie, she thought he was watching a snake. He was watching a snake.
29:54Scott Feinberg: Right, right. So, you know, and I learned a lot, you know, from Rob and also hanging out on the set. I didn't want to stay in my trailer by myself and cool my jets. You know, I really wanted to be with everybody. And that might have planted the seeds for wanting to be a director, which you did some of, too. Yeah, you know, I think so, is that being comfortable on a set and learning a lot. And Rob had a fantastic crew, so it was really, it was great. I remember the costume fellow that came by, Tony Serrano, who they called Strunz, who worked with George C. Scott a lot. And he was sailing by and he said, get your Oscar dress ready.
30:35Scott Feinberg: So they could be out of... What? Because that had never entered my mind. Well, it turns out that was pretty prophetic. Prophetic. I guess just one quick follow. I had read that perhaps you and Rob may have discussed that this doesn't cause somebody to become necessarily like Annie automatically, but that if you were thinking of what was the trauma in her past, did you guys agree upon something? Yeah, I think, you know, there was so much. Kenny, and forgive me for not remembering, he's a wonderful prop guy, and he created a whole scrapbook for Annie. and for her background and her relationship with her mother.
31:20And the fact that she had murdered these children, it was based on that, whether it was babies or old people. I can't remember what it was. I think babies. And I read the book about that. And the fact that she really thought of herself as a nurse, as somebody she wanted to take care of people, that lack of fulfillment in her life, I think, contributed to her loneliness and her isolation. I mean, when you look, you know, that amazing house that they created, you look at it and it's like, who lives there? You know, and really it's a hermit's abode.
31:57Scott Feinberg: Well, so you go to see the film for the first time. I don't know if it was at a private thing or if it was at the premiere, but do you remember what went through your mind as you watch this? Yeah, I was really confused. and I mean, I thought it was a good movie, but it's the first time I've really seen myself on film like that for a long period of time. And it was such an out there, it was a bonkers performance. And because Rob is such a great comedian and comes from such a great comedian, Carl. And when we did this thing recently for TCM, we could hear people really howling in the audience. And he said, I forgot how funny this is.
32:38I think I was shocked. I guess I was a little shell-shocked when I left it was private and and I went out there and I
32:46Scott Feinberg: just didn't I just didn't know what to think well obviously I know shortly thereafter the reviews and the box office and all that starts confirming that it was it was very special and then the awards and I know I believe you said you were out of the country when the nomination happened. But Oscar Knight, you're 42 at that point, I believe. You have never been in this kind of a setting at that point. You've now, when we're talking today, you've been there many times, but that first time, what were your emotions? What were your expectations? Did you, in your heart of hearts, expect to win? Yeah.
33:26Scott Feinberg: You did. Okay. Good, good, good. I won the Golden Globe. Yes. And I remember getting back, and then my agent had arranged for someone to make a gown for me, which just fit like a glove, wonderful seamstress, and a designer, Jeff Billings, who made costumes for Stars on Ice. And he's passed away. And I remember being in the limo with my husband, and I said, do you think I'm going to win? He said, well, you know, he just he didn't want to, you know, I guess he didn't want me to be upset. Right. And I said, I think I'm going to win. You know, I just got this feeling I'm going to win. And since then I've realized you get that feeling every time.
34:14You know, and you don't win.
34:17Scott Feinberg: Well, that night of all great people, Daniel Day-Lewis comes out to present Best Actress. I just re-watched us this morning to be fresh and you gave a very poised composed speech I know the only thing I think you might have forgotten to thank your husband yeah I know it happens Hillary Swank did it too and some others but how would you describe the experience of and the impact in the months thereafter of winning an Oscar would you say that and I know you've been very involved with the Academy on the board and again as a repeat nominee many times and all of that but just what are the things that people might be surprised to learn an Oscar does or doesn't change?
35:01This is going to sound funny. The next morning, the first thing was, is that my right arm was really sore.
35:09Scott Feinberg: From carrying it. No, from waving it. Oh, from waving it. Yeah, yeah. Spagos used to be on Sunset. Do you remember that? We were getting out of the car and there were people screaming and my husband said, Kath, Kath, they're screaming for you. And I went, oh, oh. And so I was waving this thing around. So my arm was killing me when I woke up the next morning. But also I had it set right on this chest of drawers that we had. And I was like, okay, this is real, you know? And then, because we had got this little duplex over in Silver Lake and the rugs were awful. They were this baby shit yellow And we had asked the guy, can you change these for us?
35:54And he said, no, I'm sorry. So we called him up and said, can you change them for us now? And then I remember I was going to do fried green tomatoes. So I think that sort of took the curse off of not having a job right away. Right. You know, it is sort of like people think maybe, and there are people, I'm sure, that, you know, Brad Pitt and Colin Farrell and all these great people that have a stack of scripts by their bed. That was never my case. That was never my case. I had just this kind of luck to get from one project to another. And then after that, after that and Dolores Claiborne and things began to slow down.
36:44and I thought, you know, what's going to happen? You know, what's going to come next? And although I made myself a promise way back when I was in New York, and I don't know how I did this, but I met actors who a week before the show would close, they'd start worrying about the next job. And I just, I don't know whether it was my little angel on my shoulder, but I just said, you're not going to have to worry about that. Just don't worry about that. part of that for me was seeing them not stay in the moment and enjoy those last weeks you know always worrying about it I've just Scott I've been incredibly lucky that one thing has come after the other if you'll allow me I want to just for listeners
37:34Scott Feinberg: zoom through with some stops along the way just some of these other things that okay yes or no well you know so we'll go this has now been we'll do a speed through 35 years since misery between misery and matlock right the two m's and in between there's been a lot of good stuff so i just want to ask you for a thought or two about a few of these so you mentioned fried green tomatoes this comes out the year after misery but it's interesting you're saying it was in motion even before the oscar it was but probably somebody had seen because jessica jessica tandy was there at the Oscars that night. And so was Diane Weiss.
38:11And so we were standing up the top of the theater after we were all like holding hands, jumping up and down because we were all theater ladies, you know. So anyway, go ahead.
38:21Scott Feinberg: No, well, so so it's the amazing thing about Fried Green Tomatoes is that it did have the immediate two preceding Best Actress Oscar winners, you and Jessica Tandy. You're this kind of depressed middle aged woman who comes into the nursing home and meets this elderly woman who changes her perspective on everything. But this was John Avnett's directorial debut. I know it gets quoted back to you quite a lot in different, I'm sure a lot of your roles actually, between Misery and all these, you've had a lot of quotable lines. But just for this stop on the race to Matlock, what stands out when you think back to Fried Green Tomatoes?
38:57What stands out is my friendship with Jessica Tandy. And actually, years later, when I started directing. I had my first directing opportunity. I asked her to be in it, but she was dying at that time. But when we were doing Fried Green Tomatoes, just watching her work, working off of her, and I was feeling a bit lost. I was doing publicity for Misery. I was coming back from Japan, and I just didn't... Theater-wise, you have more time to prepare, and I just really felt like I wasn't plugged in and it's a performance I'd like to go back and redo but you know I remember going to see Jessica and she said oh you've come to see the wise woman so she gave me some advice I didn't follow it which was to go to back to the theater but um so that's my strongest memories working
39:47Scott Feinberg: with her nice back with Rob Reiner on bit of a less successful than misery one with North in 1994 but you know you had a you're shaking your head I don't even know what to say about that movie I can remember trying to I think they were styrofoam what do you call it the ice flows I think they were styrofoam ice flows and that well I mean so it all balances out I guess there was misery there was that and then years later rumor has it again with Rob right so you've had a few different times with Rob but then as you mentioned the next real milestone I think has to be Dolores Claiborne which again Stephen King adaptation.
40:32Scott Feinberg: This is directed this time by Taylor Hackford, written by, I didn't realize until recently when I went back and looked, a young Tony Gilroy who's having some success. Brilliant. Because you know that whole, I don't know if you know that it's a novel. I didn't. It's a confession. Wow. And Frances Sternhagen, who actually did, you know, the wife, Farnsworth, in Misery, she does the reading of it and brilliant actress and tony just opened the whole thing out brilliantly and taylor created with the film stock that he used i mean his concept for that and i remember the whole we we had to be very careful about makeup and age because he wanted to cut you know right away in between the past and the present he did a brilliant job with that It really is like two different performances.
41:27Scott Feinberg: And I just had a similar conversation with another person who's having a heck of a year in TV, Sam Rockwell, where there was a movie years ago, Conviction, where it does the same thing, cutting back between the younger and the older versions. Which one was that? It's called Conviction. Tony Goldwyn directed him. And he's a guy on Death Row, but then it goes back to when he was a young, carefree— And it's called Conviction? Conviction. And Sam is in it? Sam's in it. Oh, God, I can't believe I missed both of those guys. I think you should check it out. But you both had, you know, that's, I would think, a kind of unusual thing.
41:59Scott Feinberg: It's really like giving two different, playing two different people. I just, one of my favorite movies is Seven Psychopaths. Oh, yes. Oh, yeah. I just had to watch that. I needed a really good belly laugh. Oh, God, I love Sam. He's working again with McDonald's. I'm going to watch that then. Yeah, enjoy. I hope you do. No, it was fantastic. And he gave me all the tools. You know, we had months to prepare and dialect coach, movement coach, great wig people, the whole nine yards. It was just, he knows what an actor needs. Working with Taylor was brilliant. The same year that Dolores Claiborne came out was the first time you had a directing credit.
42:37Scott Feinberg: This was, again, 1995, starting off with sort of PBS and then some episodic stuff, episode of Homicide Life on the Street, NYPD Blue, Oz. then by 1999 a feature Dash and Lily then five episodes of Six Feet Under an episode of Everwood the list goes on were you interested in directing because you were in some way frustrated with acting or was it just like what led you to it just fell in my lap uh that great great performances did and it was um it was actually a collection of monologues that were done down in Louisville So I was familiar with them. So I just decided, okay, I'll give it a go. But my mantra was always, there are so many people who are trying to be directors.
43:24And I had a leg up. And I just wanted to make sure that I really was good at it and that I wasn't just taking somebody else's place. as one led to another I felt okay I can do this I can do this and I love working with actors especially on um Six Feet Under oh my god they're all theater actors brilliant every single one of them so everybody was prepared and Lauren Ambrose was just starting out so I could really work with her and you know I used to sit under the camera because I just didn't like being back at watching a little tiny screen and and it was still one of my happiest experiences and and uh and then you probably know I I got cancer in 2003 and and had to go through chemo for quite a while and then I just never got back to it and my favorite thing was working with the actors do you think I know
44:17Scott Feinberg: it wasn't just in 2003 I believe you said the ovarian cancer but then you're you know just when you're bounced back from that in 2012 breast cancer so I but now that thank God you're healthy it's and uh knock on wood and uh and you know I guess it's pretty hard when you're when you're starring on a network show with a 18 episodes a season or whatever but would do you have a desire at some point to go back to directing it seems like you enjoy it well actually I mean I don't know if this has been I'll give you the scoop okay so uh so far I'm planning to direct one this year. They asked me to do one last year and I felt it was too much because I didn't know what it was going to be like energy-wise and I was still developing the character.
45:03But I'm going to try to direct an episode of it this year. That's great. I'm probably going to get given a lot of crap from everybody.
45:11Scott Feinberg: Coming back to directing. In the meantime, amidst those 1995 to 2003 directing credits. I'm going to keep the race going here. There was a TV movie that you were excellent in, The Late Shift, playing Jay Leno's crazy agent. That was in 96. The year after that, a little movie people might have caught called Titanic for James Cameron. You were the unsinkable Molly Brown. Everybody comes to you and is expecting stories of all the fun and joy of this, but you're in Baja, Mexico for three weeks. Other people were there for months. No kidding. Three weeks. And you have said it was not a particularly enjoyable experience.
45:50Well, I can't complain because I shouldn't complain. I did complain, but I shouldn't complain. Because, you know, Kate, I think for the first six weeks had forced calls every day, every night, every night forced calls. So which meant that they would sometimes have like six hours to sleep, nine hours to sleep, something like that. and one of the reasons that they did it in Mexico was to get around a lot of the union stuff for people that were coming from England to do the wigs and the makeup and all of that stuff I found it difficult because the ship goes down at night which means you get to the set you get to your dressing room at 5 30 and you get suited up and then you sit there till three o 'clock in the morning I you know as I said I had a small part I had no right to complain, but that was difficult.
46:40And I have complained about, you know, other things, which I won't get into right now.
46:47Scott Feinberg: Well, I loved your quote. The people who went on the original trip had a better time of it. Yes, exactly. Exactly. There were guys that played the, I don't know if we have time to say this, but there was the band that they banned. It was a quart, no, it was a quart, quintet, I think it was. And they were brought from Switzerland. Yeah. I think from Bern. I'm not sure. Well, the oddity was, is they could play, but they couldn't, you couldn't hear them. You were never supposed to hear them. Oh, God. So they came in from Switzerland to do that. Yeah. Yeah. And but these guys were the real deal. And they played that kind of music.
47:27That was odd. And we were there for Christmas. And I wish I had kept it. Maybe I have it somewhere. he sent out a Christmas card that he had done with pencil.
47:37Scott Feinberg: This is Cameron? No, no, no. It was one of the guys that was in the orchestra. Or I don't know what you call it, the quintet. And so he said of him looking down in a bowl of soup with the Titanic going. You know, because at that time, none of us knew that it was going to be this magnificent, you know, but there were moments. I mean, you go out and suddenly you walk through a daughter and it's 1912. And the intricacy with which Jim did that, and he's been down there. I mean, he deserves all the kudos. You know, I know it was a difficult shoot for everybody. Nerves were frayed. Let's just say that.
48:17Scott Feinberg: Sure, sure. And I know that you've said there were, as is always going to be the case, things get cut. but it was a bit of a bummer that some of the more meaty scenes that your character would have had that explain, kind of illustrated who she was, they did not make the three-hour runtime or whatever. Oh, yeah. There was one scene where she's sitting there and she wants ice in her drink, and you see the iceberg going by, which might have really been jumping in the shark. All right, so the year after that is the project that brings you Oscar nomination number two. This is primary colors. You're playing fiercely loyal aid to a Bill Clinton-like candidate who's a true believer in what he's selling, which comes with tragic consequences.
49:02Scott Feinberg: But based, I think I've heard, on one of the real aid to him when he was a governor, Betsy Wright, who I guess this is their words, not mine, but she was in charge of, quote unquote, bimbo eruptions at the time, like, where dealing with people who came forward to accuse. Anyway, that was that person. I guess I didn't do that kind of in-depth. No, well, hey, it doesn't. It was great. Oscar nomination without it. Vince, what was his name? I heard that it was a combination of those people. Killed himself or did he? That's their big thing. But anyway, being directed by Mike Nichols, whenever I've had somebody on this podcast who was, I have asked them about that because I've gathered that there was something about the way he worked with actors, maybe because it was from theater and live performing himself or what.
49:57Scott Feinberg: But did you find him to be a particularly effective director? I don't know. He just, oh God, yeah. He was Mike. Did you say you talked to him? I've never talked to him, but a number of people who worked with him, I just got the sense, I've got to ask you about this. He's just, he's an actor's director, brilliant. There would be no words in the English language that I could use to describe what it feels like to be in his presence. And in your case, it's with a script from Elaine May. Oh my gosh. So the two of them. And it was so funny because they did so much improv, but you could not get a word wrong with Elaine or a comma.
50:37Oh, really? With their script? Yeah, and it was a brilliant script. Right. But there was just something about it. You know what? And plus you had John Travolta and you had Emma Thompson and you had all these amazing actors and Billy Bob and Carolyn Aaron. I mean, I could go on and on and on. and um he just it just for me it was being in an a team production which was rare for me and being around mike and hearing all of his stories from over the years he was a great raconteur and uh he just raises the game because it's mike yeah fucking nickels you know and you want to be great for mike you know and ann roth the costume designer who i met and i mean it was just, it was magnificent.
51:27I mean, it's, when I go back and think about it, I can remember every single thing about it.
51:32Scott Feinberg: Now, if anyone, not that anyone does this, but if anyone ever wanted to question your range, you go from 1998 primary colors to 1999, the water boy as Mama Boucher, mother of Adam Sadler's Arrested Development guy there. And I understand that as somebody might expect your initial reaction to hearing that you've been sent to Adam Saylor's script is, this is not what I do? Well, it's the one script that was on my bedside table and it got tipped into the trash. I read the first 12 pages. I went, what? This is a stupid football movie. What the heck is this? You know, and I just tossed it in the trash.
52:12And my niece, Linda, who, God bless her for her patience with me, has worked with me for years and years and years and years. I think we had our 32nd anniversary. She came up. She said, what is this? And I said, ah, it's some stupid football movie. I don't know what it is. And she picked it up and she said, Adam Sandler? You don't know the Hanukkah song? You don't know Adam Sandler? She said, you have to do this. You have to do this. So I think I did that for Linda. And I remember after the movie aired, when it opened, the opening weekend was$34 million. And back then, it was a lot.
52:47Scott Feinberg: Even for someone who's been in Titanic, you could still appreciate it. Yeah, I mean, and I remember Adam calling and said, we made$34 million. I can't believe it. You know, we had so much fun. I'm glad I did it because, you know, Henry Winkler. And I mean, he's divine. And it was just, it was a lovely experience. Okay, so Roberta Herzl, about Schmidt, hippie-ish mother of the guy who is in a relationship with the girl whose father is Warren Schmidt, played by Jack Nicholson. This is Alexander Payne directing. There's another person who, when you talk to actors as an interviewer, it just seems like there's something about the way he writes and directs that brings out the best in the people he works with.
53:34Scott Feinberg: you guys didn't know each other before this right and now you get a script that describes this woman and of course in particular her most memorable uh scene with uh with Jack in the hot tub and I just what did you immediately say all right I could do something with this or did you have to be convinced a little bit well I I loved the part it was Jack I mean I remember going to a memorial memorial service. Jack was there and there was sort of this buzz that, you know, we were going to do this together. And then when I read it, I thought, oh, dear God. And Alexander wanted me to be completely nude.
54:13And then what about a murk? And I said, what the fuck is that? And so when I found out, I went, I don't think so. And then we did the scene, you know, I had a couple of cosmopolitans and jack was talking about you know winston churchill during world war ii and all this stuff was just so bizarre so i i just and then when we did the junket at some point alexander came in and he plopped down he said everybody just wants to talk about the hot tub scene nobody wants to talk about the cows
54:54now and i said you're surprised yeah now you're surprised i know their tits and then their tits
55:03Scott Feinberg: i wonder if a part of you might have enjoyed that scene as a almost a middle finger because i mean i'd like to think society and the industry have evolved over the course of your career thanks to me but no but not i'm i'm even i'm even being serious that like you know no i am you've talked about you've said that you you heard and were subjected to a lot of shit in the early years yeah and some of that was with those theater projects that you got denied the chance to do as a film and all of that and here i am in a hot tub with jack nicholson there's there's that and all of that but i mean like people people i think intentionally or unintentionally i don't know if it makes a difference can be assholes and you didn't uh i'm sure it's driven a lot of people out of this business who might have the talent to be i don't want to say to be at your level but but could be great too why not because you learn as you go along so see if you stop yeah you arrest it's arrested development as they say you're arresting plus i know people who always wanted to do it and even at my age now regret it because they didn't try because they had to drop out and look there as you know the numbers of people in our union who don't work far far exceed the numbers of the people who are lucky enough to do it yeah i'm grateful that i had kind of a it was a crazy number of really different parts which was wonderful because it was an ability to But to just sort of, I don't know, play all these things because that's the most fun is to play all these different characters.
56:49And I certainly wouldn't have gotten the part in Misery if I looked like Michelle Pfeiffer.
56:55Scott Feinberg: Well, I just think that people should not underestimate or overlook. In addition to being great, you've also had to be tough. Well, yes. Well, you do. You have to be tough, but I also think that I always felt that the work speaks for itself. You make it impossible for them not to hire you. That's, yeah. You know, and look at the women that are oversized, that have come along, who've made amazing, indelible marks on our industry. And it's what I was saying the other day to someone. You know, when you go to the theater, you go to a film, and it's the beauty of the performance. It's not necessarily the beauty of the person.
57:49Because when you experience the beauty of that performance, that stays with you always.
57:56Scott Feinberg: And it seems like what people crave more than anything these days is reality, authenticity, whatever. Most people do not look like Michelle Pfeiffer. I think a lot more people don't. And so I feel like it just took the industry a while to come around to understanding or to, somehow we've arrived at a point where it's like, the remarkable thing is not that everyone doesn't look like Michelle Pfeiffer on screen, but that, you know, this makes more sense in a way. that people listen I don't even know how to put it but I yeah let me go you in better than that because I worked with Michelle yeah there there's a there was a line in a play years and years and years ago when I thought about was described a woman pretty enough to just stand still and indeed she is but they want her to stand still they don't want her to move they don't want her to act and be all these you know and the wonderful things that you've seen her do where she's broken that mold she's not chopped chicken liver no you know and so it that beauty can be a trap you know and like charlie's theron is it theron or theron theron charlie's theron has proved that you know she's every actor worth their salt wants to completely embody another human being.
59:27I mean, look what Colin did on the Penguin. You know, I mean, you look at these amazing performances and you think, where did they come from? Where did that inspiration come from?
59:37Scott Feinberg: But I guess the other thing is that if that is what you are first and foremost associated with, your appearance, and this doesn't apply to any of the people we've been talking about, but it certainly does to others, you don't have a career that goes on for decades like yours has. And I I bet you in the grand scheme of things, they would like to trade places. Well, it would be wonderful to start out that way and then end up doing this. And I think some have. My friend Jessica Lange, she was incredible, incredible beauty when she started out. She was a model and all of this dancer. And she just kept on keeping on, and she still is.
1:00:22Scott Feinberg: you know in the last movie that we did together worked together in 1990 same year as misery i believe was men don't leave was the first we did that one yeah and then we just did one um called uh the um was it the oh god i can't remember names of anything anymore well jillian hall oh yeah yeah oh the lillian the great lillian hall yeah that's brilliant but in between a lot of ryan murphy projects. Well, see, once again, you know, we have that variety of characters. In your case here, this is a 19th century socialite who's unearthed in American Horror Story Coven. Then there's a bearded lady, American Horror Story Freak Show.
1:01:05Scott Feinberg: Then there's a hotel manager, mother of a vampire in American Story Hotel. There's Butcher in American Horror Story Roanoke, Joan Blondel, not as horrifying a character as some of those others. I don't know my wig. Feud, Betty and Joan, and American Horror Story Apocalypse, Miriam Mead. I guess, though, you've said that it was through Jessica that you sort of sought out this being part of American Horror Story. I did. It was watching her in a performance, because after I had breast cancer and I really thought, okay, what now? Yeah. And then I happened to see her and I thought, whoa, they can do that on TV?
1:01:44Scott Feinberg: It's true. You know, sign me up. Yeah. And I mean, you'd certainly, again, dip to toe in TV as it was getting better with Six Feet Under, with The Office, with TV movies like Warm Springs. I think that was your Emmy nomination for that. You know, not to the exclusion of movies, because in that same period of the first decade into the second decade of this century, we've got Revolutionary Road, where you're back with Kate and Leo. I love working with them on that. And Michael Shannon was on that. That's right, Michael. That was his breakout in film. Two movies nominated for the Best Picture Oscar, The Blind Side and Midnight in Paris as Gertrude Stein in Midnight in Paris.
1:02:25Scott Feinberg: So, I mean, you were working a lot, but it sounds like pre-Ryan Murphy, and by the way, also, excuse me for overlooking, comedy won an Emmy for an episode as the ghost of Charlie on Two and a Half Men. There were a bunch of stuff with Melissa McCarthy, The episodes of Mike and Molly, the films Tammy and the boss. Oh, she's lovely. I've loved working with her. Also comedy as the mother of Billy Bob Thornton's character in Bad Santa 2. But I guess... The grand guignol. Exactly. But I mean, so there's... You've never... It doesn't seem to me, lack for work. But it was not... It was... It seems like by the time you got up to...
1:03:09Scott Feinberg: Through the... Up until the Ryan Murphy stuff. and then maybe even a little bit beyond Up when there seems like a turning point with Harry's Law, which is the first time you were playing a lawyer who's kind of starting over. This was for David E. Kelly. This was a show on NBC, 34 episodes, lasted two seasons. But really a part written for you, or excuse me, written for a man initially. Yeah, I think Louis Black was, they were interested in Louis. comes out with you huge really uh very respectable ratings then a change of leadership at nbc and and the plug got pulled so i think it and then it was right after that in the same year that that ended in 2012 is when you got this second cancer diagnosis and it just seems like from what i've been able to gather that that moment post harry's law in the midst of dealing with cancer just before that 2013 first project with Ryan Murphy that sparked all the, you know, a number of years with him, understandably, you weren't in a happy place.
1:04:17Scott Feinberg: Is that fair to say? Oh, my gosh. I never expected this in a million years. I never did. I mean, I, the word, I just keep, just, it's like a beacon in my brain. It's like a neon sign going on, grateful, grateful, grateful, grateful, grateful. Not just the role, not just the depth of the character, not just the fact that it has substance, that it's dealing with, that there still is an opioid epidemic. 100 ,000 people, they estimate, a year die from that. When I had my breast cancer, I wanted more and more and more and more medication. And my doctors kept saying, no, no, no. And I didn't realize until now, why?
1:05:06Grateful for Jenny Ehrman, who really creates an ecosystem that, I mean, you're not supposed to say, oh, this is my favorite. This is my favorite. But damn it to hell, I'm 77. after 55 years in this business, you know, at the moment that I'm at right now, I never have headlined a show like this, that every single person around, I mean, I just was working with Erica LeBlanc, who's my wonderful assistant, who's now going to start becoming a producer on the show and learning to do that. It's inclusive, it's supportive. I'm getting to be an executive producer on the show. I'm not just taking the credit.
1:05:49I'm, you know, looking at, you know, scripts and giving my two cents because it's from an actor's point of view, which is different. For a while, it was like, I don't know. I was, you know, I'm not sure if I'm supposed to do this. And she said, no, no, I want to hear what you have to say. And so I get to look at the cuts before they're locked. And I'll, you know, write down the numbers. And I'll say, you know, let's look at a different take because sometimes I'll be on a set with an actor and I'll see a take that I think is fantastic and for some reason it didn't end up in the cut and I'll say wait wait go back go back go back you know so all of that is so stimulating and so exciting and having to memorize lines and keep my brain fresh and I'm in great shape physically it's so different from Harry's law when I weighed 245 pounds and I could barely get across the floor and had to sit down every second because I couldn't breathe.
1:06:43And it was, it was just, um, I was not.
1:06:46Scott Feinberg: People in their twenties say that doing a show for a broadcast network, even, you know, maybe gone are the days of whatever, 28 episodes. 18 is a lot of work when you look at what's on Netflix sometimes, or, you know, four or eight episodes or whatever. You guys are working hard and you are in every scene. It seems like you don't, you know, if we go back to just before this crossed your radar, Matlock, you were halfway out the door to France and out of the business, right? Yeah, I felt that, you know, I was doing roles that, you know, like working with Jessica was great because we're old friends and we could really illuminate those relationship and that was exciting to me but by and large other roles that I played although I loved working with Nicole Kidman she's oh she's a delight but they were roles that were not as challenging for me and that's what made me think you know do I really do I want to go off and you know do some of the things that I've always wanted to do even that's cockamamie to think you know I could be a painter or an author or this or that but you know I keep thinking well you know I've got some time left who knows how long and then all of a sudden this came across the transom and I and I read it and and I I think you know I've said I started reading and I thought you know and then I got to where it was about opioids it was about something and I I thought, okay, now we're talking.
1:08:22The twist. Yep, now we're talking. And the preparation for it that was really deep and hard to, you have to create, I had to create a character that just comes full bore into that room. So it's not that I can come in working off of other actors. So that preparation took a long time. And I don't know if they knew what I was going to do, you know, if they were really, okay, what is this going to be?
1:08:49Scott Feinberg: Were you confident that you could do a network show at this point? Well, I wasn't thinking about that. I was thinking about, can I do this pilot? Right, just the pilot, right. Can I create this character? Who is she going to be? Right, right. You know, and I have this wonderful friend I've known for 42 years, my friend Billy DeMichel, and he's my consigliere. And he knows me so well, and he really helped me develop that opening monologue that just launched the whole thing for me. Should we say for people who haven't yet checked it out, because we want them to after listening to this, your character is this woman, Madeline Maddie Matlock, ostensibly, who BS is her way or connives her way into the into a law firm, top high end law firm and pitches herself on becoming wanting to be an employee, but settles initially for I don't know what they call it, like a temporary attempt position.
1:09:47Well, they give her a period of, what is it they use? Probation. Probationary. She's on a probationary. Well, what she does is she shames them into using ageism. She said, I don't know. I've been sending my resume in here, and I don't know why I haven't heard back from anybody. So she's like really cleverly saying, I'm going to stick it to you, you know. And then they said, okay. And Bo's character's great. He said, okay, well, we'll give you, you know, because I said, are you going to hire me now? And he said, no, not right away.
1:10:15Scott Feinberg: And then there's that big twist late in the episode where you see that she is not who she is advertising herself as. I love that so much. And that's where the multi-layers, again, of basically multiple characters that you're playing. Well, and Kat Koiro, who is our amazing director, producer, and she did most of the episodes. And she really helped me create Kat character as we were moving along. And I think it must have been, I don't know if it was Jenny's idea or Kat's idea. They're like little chipmunks, the two of them. They're so cute together. I love that they had her pull out her diamond ring in the back of the car.
1:10:50Scott Feinberg: Yes, with her kids with the driver. Now, obviously, in hindsight, it was a brilliant thing to go to you and ask you to do this. But has anyone ever told you what made them initially think of you for this character? I don't know. You'd have to ask Jenny. You know, in all the publicity we've done, she's always thought was, well, wouldn't it be great if? If, yeah. You know, and what cinched the deal for me, Scott? was that it was a great pilot, but you never know who you're going to meet. You never know who's on it. And so when I went in and sat down with her, and I mean I had a list of questions I wanted to ask her, and I said, don't change anything.
1:11:32Don't rewrite anything. Just talk to me about this character. It's great. I want to do it. Let's talk about these things I want to know, all these questions. I'm like that. No, that's great. I just, anyway. So, and just the working off of each other during that meeting, I thought, yeah, this is going to be good. And people should not make the mistake that I made going into this, which is assuming this is just a reboot for a new era of the Andy Griffith Matlock that I grew up on and that a lot of people know.
1:12:04Scott Feinberg: There's a name that's in common, but there, and the character is, it's all directly referenced in the show. I guess thematically there are some similar, you know, law and all of that, but this is its own beast. And it also does something that I don't recall the original ever doing, which is really speaking about age and obviously something you couldn't do with Andy Griffith and what it is to be aging as a woman. And you directly say in the pilot about the invisibility of that and how you can actually get away with things because nobody's even paying attention after a certain age for women. And I just think it's not something we often see on screens, big or small.
1:12:49Scott Feinberg: The last thing I can think of that was really making that point was, I remember Meryl Streep talking about it with the Iron Lady, how we don't see her when she's in power. We see her on the subway when she's just another lady that nobody's paying attention to. And in your case, it's built into the character that, again, nobody's even giving her two thoughts. Yeah. Well, yeah, it's true. I mean, I think biologically, men were anatomically, psychologically, biologically created to procreate, I believe, well into their 70s. And women go through menopause. And I think that there's something in that.
1:13:39I'm not condoning it, but a lot of times a man will take a younger wife or whatever. I wonder, I'll ask the question, I wonder if there's something biological about that. That women do reach an age where either they let themselves go or whatever. Although, you know, my sister Mary, Linda's mom, she's nine years older than I am. She was married for 50 years to the most wonderful man in the world. And they still took each other at me. He would take her out on their little front porch and watch the full moon. Or I remember taking them, inviting them to a screening, and he'd have his hand up behind her neck and kind of stroking her on her shoulder.
1:14:23and he was extraordinary. So you see those relationships. So I'm not saying that it's a blanket thing that that's going to happen. And a lot of women live older than their husbands, don't they? And I just, or we've got the Karens now, which isn't helping. Although I have to think they need to behave. They're giving old women a bad reputation.
1:14:53Scott Feinberg: Don't hold Karens against all older women. No, no, no. So, and I don't want to put Karens down because maybe some of them are my fans. You know, you never know. We'll take them all. But, you know, I think, and or even, you know, people do disappear. It's not just old women. And I think maybe that speaks to a lot of people. One of the things I hear about with our show is that three different generations are watching it. I'm watching it with my mom and my son and that's just great it's old fashioned TV in a lot of ways what's different I think from the Andy Griffith show is that the characters in our show were so interesting and so compelling and the cast is so exciting I think you really get involved and invested in each one of these people like what are they going to do next you know or that you know Bo is going to convince her to take an edible you know i've read that what yeah this woman is against opioids her daughter she's going to get on edibles now oh my god so um but you know it's kind of bonkers brilliant with with the last two minutes if i if i may i just want to first just i want to close with a few quick things but the first one's going to be the longest wind up this show matlock season one has had great reviews it's 100 % on Rotten Tomatoes.
1:16:20Scott Feinberg: Unbelievable ratings. It's the number one most watched news series and the number two most watched series overall on television behind only CBS's Tracker. And in fact, according to one thing I read, it's the most watched new broadcast series in its first season ever, ever for a first season. That's unbelievable. With an average of 17 million viewers across broadcast and streaming, on the streaming on Paramount Plus, the broadcast on CBS. Then there's awards. You've already won the Best Actress in a Drama Series Critics' Choice Award. And it seems like we're certainly headed towards some cool Emmy time, which you've already won two Emmys.
1:17:01Scott Feinberg: And I think they could use a sibling. I need a balance. Three is always a good number. So just, I guess, the first of these lists, rapid fire that we'll close with here. The others will actually be rapid fire. But just with that, I mean, did you expect this huge of a response? No. I remember driving into New York and talking to the guy at CAA who works on the numbers, and he said, this is just new territory. He said, this doesn't happen. He said, I can't tell you how big this is. And, of course, I'm always the Debbie Downer in a way because everybody was really excited on the show. And I said, we all have to calm down.
1:17:42we have to get back to the work because the work is without us here and everybody was like can't we celebrate just can't we have a few minutes to celebrate on this so no it wasn't all i didn't and the first time i expected it was when we got emails from from amy reisenbach and david staff and and and george cheek saying this is incredible it's the best pilot we've had in years and years
1:18:05Scott Feinberg: and years well it should make you feel really good that because people there's the brand matlock and there's the brand Kathy Bates and the two go well together, apparently. Okay. It's been renewed for season two, obviously. How long would you like to keep doing it? I don't know that I could have Swarovski do a, you know, a jewel encrusted Walker for me. Okay. So that's, you know, I just would love to be healthy enough to really do it well. Sure. Sure. And then in that case, I'd stay on. Where do you keep your Oscar? I'm looking around. I see some Emmys. I see some, Oh, okay, they moved it. There was one, they moved it for my Vanity Fair shoe.
1:18:43I think it's gone back into hiding.
1:18:45Scott Feinberg: It's back into hiding, okay. I don't know why it's silly I should put it out, but I think, you know, if something happens to it, they don't give you another one. No, they will now. Maybe in the old days they were, no, but they actually, of course, and in fact, like, there were some, recently they've been doing some cool things, like Haley Mills had been given one as a child. A little bitty one. A little one, and they replaced it with a proper one. Although I think the little one's cool. Then there were some people who lost theirs in the fires recently. Oh, yes. Well, of course. But there are things where somebody, it's been stolen or whatever.
1:19:18Scott Feinberg: They've been good. So I wouldn't show. Maybe I should just be out and proud. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And then finally, you have said, and I can't believe this is true, that of all these great parts that you've played, many of which we've talked about, who is the most like you? Well, recently I said Annie Wilkes. I love the character in Primary Colors. I think she's very much like me. Alexander's very conceptual, you know, so God love him. So I think those two characters, there's bits and pieces in all of them, you know, I think. Yeah, they're all just part of me, I guess. Sure. They're just, yeah, they're all alter egos in there rolling around, Mama Boucher dancing around on the football.
1:20:08I mean, think about what you do with yourself in your life, the crazy stuff. And I've had a chance to just put it all out there, especially now.
1:20:17Scott Feinberg: It's been so fun watching it and I can't thank you enough for doing this. Thank you, Kathy. Scott, it's been really fun to talk to you. Thank you so much. Absolutely.
1:20:34Scott Feinberg: Thanks for listening to Awards Chatter. We really appreciate it and would really appreciate you taking just a minute more to subscribe to the podcast and to leave us a rating and review on your podcast app. and to follow us on Twitter and Instagram, where our handle is at Awards Chatter. On those platforms, we announce upcoming guests and provide details about special live recordings of the podcast that you can attend. Until next time, thanks again for tuning in. Coca-Cola. For the big. For the small. The short. And the tall. Peacemakers. Risk-takers. For the optimists. Pessimists. For long-distance love.
1:21:16For introverts and extroverts. The thinkers and the doers. For old friends and new. Coca-Cola. For everyone. Pick up some Coca-Cola at a store near you. This episode is brought to you by Netflix's new series, East of Eden. A bold reimagining of John Steinbeck's masterpiece following generations of the Trask family. through love, betrayal, and the choices that shape humanity. Starring Mike Feist and Christopher Abbott as the Trask brothers and Florence Pugh as Kathy Ames, the complex anti-heroine determined to build the life she wants, no matter the cost. Watch East of Eden now, only on Netflix.
The Oscar and two-time Emmy winner reflects on the bumpy road to her breakthrough in 'Misery,' why she didn't enjoy working on 'Titanic,' how she was convinced to do a nude scene in 'About Schmidt' and why, after nearly quitting the business, her creativity and passion have been reawakened by her hit new CBS drama series.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices