In short
Live conversation with composer Nicholas Britell about how he builds film/TV music—especially his signature blend of classical composition with hip-hop/R&B techniques—plus the making and musical ideas behind Noah Baumbach’s Jay Kelly.
Guests
Nicholas Britell (composer; born/raised on Manhattan’s Upper West Side; Harvard psychology/neuro-musicology; Juilliard pre-college; worked on Wall Street briefly). Host: Scott Feinberg (Hollywood Reporter awards editor; host of Awards Chatter). Also referenced: director Noah Baumbach; filmmakers Barry Jenkins, Adam McKay, Steve McQueen, Damien Chazelle; producers Helen Esselbrook, Jeremy Kleiner; HBO/TV collaborators Jesse Armstrong/Jesse (Succession).
Key claims
Britell’s approach is driven by “tone” and emotional function—music should be subconscious, and sometimes scenes need no score. He often “subverts expectations” by using modern forms (hip-hop sampling, chopped-and-screwed slowdowns) inside classical frameworks. For Succession, he leaned into absurdly serious music to make the dark comedy funnier.
Notable examples
Chariots of Fire (first obsession); Moonlight (chopped-and-screwed orchestra for the “swimming” scene); The Big Short (“sound of dark math” via layered, time-stretched piano sampling); 12 Years a Slave (researching enslaved-era spiritual sound without recordings); Succession title theme (dark classical progression + sampled orchestra + 808 bass).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOIntroducing Nicholas Britell
0:38 to 3:26
Scott Feinberg provides an overview of Nicholas Britell's background and achievements.
“My name is Scott Feinberg, and I'm the executive editor of awards coverage at The Hollywood Reporter, as well as the host of our Awards Chattered podcast, for which tonight's conversation is being recorded.”
Early Musical Influences
3:26 to 6:40
Nicholas Britell discusses his upbringing and early exposure to music.
“I'd like to begin here truly at the beginning.”
First Steps in Music
6:40 to 8:10
Britell recalls his first public concert and experiences with piano.
“This is literally the first thing I think I ever wrote.”
Juilliard and Career Decisions
8:10 to 10:05
Britell shares his time at Juilliard and the decision not to continue in conservatory.
“So with this obvious, I would imagine to some degree, innate gift and then a lot of hard work, you go off to at least spending your weekends, I believe, at Juilliard's pre-college division.”
Exploring Neuro Musicology
10:05 to 12:11
Britell explains his studies at Harvard and interest in music and psychology.
“So I I was always really fascinated by this question of why music does what it does to us.”
Film Scoring Journey
12:11 to 14:03
Nicholas describes how he got into film scoring and the development of his unique style.
“you sort of subvert the expectation of what a certain sound connotes.”
The Fusion of Hip-Hop and Film Scoring
14:03 to 16:14
Learn about Nicholas Britell's journey blending hip-hop and orchestral music.
“But so there's that stuff of the, that side of things where you're, you're getting into hip hop and group performance.”
From Wall Street to Music
16:14 to 18:23
Discover Britell's transition from a Wall Street career to pursuing music full-time.
“And while I know your heart was in music, like most people, You say, all right, I've got to do the responsible thing and get a job, right?”
Investing in Whiplash
18:23 to 22:02
Learn how Britell became involved in the production of 'Whiplash' and his role in its creation.
“I mean, I did so many different things to write music.”
Collaborating on 12 Years a Slave
22:02 to 26:26
Explore Britell's collaboration with Steve McQueen on '12 Years a Slave' and its music challenges.
“And so we made the short that summer of, I think it was 2012 or 2013.”
Show all 36 chapters
The Rise of Nicholas Britell
26:26 to 28:00
Understand Britell's journey through independent films to major projects like 'The Big Short'.
“Now, you had been the full composer of several smaller films yourself.”
Introduction to The Big Short
28:00 to 29:04
Learn about how Nicholas Britell became involved with 'The Big Short' and his initial thoughts on adapting its complex financial themes into music.
“Then, as we say, 12 Years a Slave is 2013.”
Collaboration with Adam McKay
29:04 to 30:39
Discover the evolution of Nicholas Britell's collaboration with Adam McKay and how their unique working relationship developed.
“so I met Adam through Jeremy and Dee Dee.”
Exploring Dark Mathematics in Sound
30:39 to 31:35
Nicholas discusses the concept of 'dark math' and how it influenced the score for 'The Big Short'.
“And just to tease that out in case people would like the dots connected, we're going to come to.”
Transition to Moonlight
31:35 to 33:52
Learn how Nicholas Britell transitioned into composing for 'Moonlight' and the unique aspects of that collaboration.
“So while that's happening, it's actually doing this incredibly complicated kind of like, you know, multiple time scales.”
Meeting Barry Jenkins
33:52 to 35:58
Nicholas shares the story of meeting Barry Jenkins and the unexpected way he was hired for 'Moonlight'.
“The next year was something called Moonlight.”
Chopped and Screwed Explained
35:58 to 37:53
Nicholas explains the Chopped and Screwed technique in music and how it influenced his scoring for 'Moonlight'.
“He's like, we just had a really nice conversation.”
Creative Process for Moonlight's Score
37:53 to 38:56
Explore the creative decisions behind the original score for 'Moonlight' and how it reflects the film's themes.
“I knew of the concept generally in hip-hop, but I was not at all an expert at this whatsoever.”
The Swimming Scene in Moonlight
38:56 to 42:00
Nicholas discusses the iconic swimming scene in 'Moonlight' and how its music was composed to enhance the emotional impact.
“Now there's one of the most beautiful and moving moments in Moonlight in large part because of the music is when Mahershala Ali's character Juan teaches Alex Hibbert's character Little how to swim.”
The Creative Process of Scoring
42:00 to 43:33
Learn how Nicholas Britell conceptualizes and develops scores for films.
“Maybe the, you know, maybe the piece is even pretty, but doesn't mean it's right for the scene.”
The Importance of Music in Film
43:33 to 46:24
Explore the balance between music presence and absence in cinematic scenes.
“You know, it just kept going and going and going.”
The Oscar Mix-up Moment
46:24 to 48:10
Hear about the chaotic circumstances surrounding the Oscar win for Moonlight.
“I think in theory, the music is something that should be like, honestly, like every part of a movie.”
Transitioning to Television: Succession
48:10 to 51:06
Discover how Nicholas Britell approached composing for the series Succession.
“it was so crazy I remember thinking La La Land won and I had been nominated for the score that the year so we were sitting, the composers were all kind of sitting together, I think we were sort of on the left side.”
Crafting the Succession Theme
51:06 to 53:16
Learn how Britell developed the iconic theme for Succession's opening.
“that in hindsight I didn't even fully appreciate at the time, Adam said, well, we're gonna be shooting the pilot in New York and you should come to set and just get a vibe.”
Inspiration and Musical Choices
53:16 to 56:03
Understand the factors influencing the musical choices in Succession's score.
“So it was interesting because like you're saying there's this question of what is the tone of something?”
Crafting the Score for Succession
56:03 to 58:46
Learn how Nicholas Britell developed the score for 'Succession' and its thematic elements.
“when you'd have sort of like a culminating moment in something.”
Seasons as Movements of a Symphony
58:46 to 1:01:46
Discover how each season of 'Succession' was treated as a movement in a symphony.
“this is also omnipresent in the underscore, right?”
Behind the Music of 'Beale Street'
1:01:46 to 1:03:28
Explore the creative process behind the score for 'If Beale Street Could Talk' with Barry Jenkins.
“You might recall the rap L to the OG By oh there look at that we got a jersey That I Believe not only was composed by but it was the initially performed by Yourself is that true?”
The Challenges of Scoring 'Vice'
1:03:28 to 1:10:05
Understand the conceptual framework Nicholas Britell used for the score of 'Vice'.
“So the initial thought that Barry had for Beale Street was, I remember I had read the book and then I read the script and he just said that he was hearing brass and horns.”
Exploring Heroic and Broken Music
1:10:05 to 1:10:50
Learn how music can embody both heroism and dissonance in storytelling.
“the music could be both heroic and totally broken and distorted and, you know, dissonant at the same time, sort of like a broken heroism in a sense.”
The Immense Undertaking of 'The Underground Railroad'
1:10:50 to 1:12:42
Discover the extensive creative process behind the series 'The Underground Railroad'.
“And, you know, we've kind of gathered or discussed that sometimes there are jumping off points with Barry, with Moonlight, I think Oceans were a reference point, with Beale Street, Subways.”
Challenges of Scoring 'Don't Look Up'
1:12:42 to 1:14:29
Understand the unique challenges faced while scoring the film 'Don't Look Up'.
“done with him, what you said is that this one was the toughest assignment.”
Innovating Music for 'Star Wars: Andor'
1:14:29 to 1:16:48
Learn about the creative approach to scoring the 'Star Wars' series 'Andor'.
“And I would imagine that it's a little daunting to have to step into that universe.”
Collaborating with Noah Baumbach on 'Jay Kelly'
1:16:48 to 1:19:18
Explore the collaboration process between Nicholas Britell and Noah Baumbach.
“It's different, and that was, that initially was a fun idea, and then I thought I was crazy, and I was like, why did I do this to myself?”
Musical Techniques in Film Scoring
1:19:18 to 1:24:00
Gain insight into innovative musical techniques used in film scoring.
“George Draculius, our music supervisor, was like, Nick you gotta play some of the themes, you know, we're here, so, and I'll play a couple of the themes, I'll play a little bit just of J.”
Celebrating Nicholas Britell's Musical Impact
1:24:00 to 1:25:02
Learn about the emotional power of music in film and the contributions of Nicholas Britell.
“So thank you to you for coming, and please join me in thanking Nicholas Bertel.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00You have one new message. Translating. Disney and Pixar's Hoppers is now available on Disney+. You could say that again. Critics are calling it Pixar's funniest movie ever and a wildly entertaining ride. Blizzard Potato. It's certified fresh and verified hot. Now we party. This is incredible! Wow, I am clear in the rest of the day. Disney and Pixar's Hoppers now available on Disney+.
0:38Good evening, everyone. My name is Scott Feinberg, and I'm the executive editor of awards coverage at The Hollywood Reporter, as well as the host of our Awards Chattered podcast, for which tonight's conversation is being recorded. I'll say this for those tuning in. We are coming to you live from the Virginia Film Festival program of the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, and I want to thank the fest's artistic director, Ilya Tobis, and executive director, Jody Kielbasa, for hosting us.
1:10It's a privilege and pleasure to be in this great city and commonwealth and to have the opportunity tonight to sit down with one of the great artists of his generation, who also happens to be a class act and lovely guy who I feel lucky to call a friend, Mr. Nicholas Patel, but I don't want him to come out yet because I have a few more things to say. Nick is only 45, but few film and TV composers of any age have a resume that can compare with his. The New York Times has described him as a screen composer at the forefront of his generation, a chameleonic, sensitive creator of distinct sound worlds.
1:49They also argue, quote, more than any other contemporary composer, he appears to have the whole of music history at his command. Known for bringing R &B and hip-hop production techniques to classical music, Nick has been nominated for seven Emmys, winning Best Original Main Title Theme Music in 2019 for his work on HBO Succession. and that piece also brought him a Grammy nomination in the category of Best Score Soundtrack for Visual Media and was selected by Rolling Stone as one of the top 25 TV themes of all time. He has also been nominated three times for the Best Original Score Oscar for 2016's Moonlight, 2018's If Beale Street Could Talk, and 2021's Don't Look Up.
2:33His Moonlight score was described by the New York Times as surprising and perfect and by John Burlingame, a film music historian, as follows, quote, What I found in the past is that people have found it impossible to incorporate such modern musical forms as hip-hop into dramatic underscore for films. When Nick did it in Moonlight, I was frankly stunned. I didn't think it was possible, close quote. Nick currently is garnering raves for his latest score for Noah Baumbach's new movie, Jay Kelly, which the audience here has just seen and which we will be discussing tonight, along with all of the above and more.
3:10And so without further ado, would you please join me in welcoming Nicholas Bertel.
3:26Hello. Thank you so much, Scott. Of course. Thank you. I'd like to begin here truly at the beginning. Can you share with our audience where were you born and raised and what did your folks do for a living? I was born in Manhattan in 1980 on the Upper West Side. I lived in the Upper West Side. My dad was actually a real estate lawyer who, I didn't learn this until a few years ago, actually, but he represented mostly arts projects, which I think is interesting. He represented Lincoln Center and helped with the redevelopment of Juilliard. He represented New York Public Library, a lot of public works like that.
4:07And my mom was a musical comedy actress when she was very young, and then she became a teacher. Not all of us have had a moment we can point to that sort of set us down a specific career path, but you did. What was the first film score that you remember being struck by, and when did you hear it? So when I was five years old, I saw Chariots of Fire and was obsessed with it. And we had a old, it actually was like a player piano at one point from the early 20th century. And then we had somehow gotten it secondhand, sort of broken down upright piano in our apartment. And somehow after watching Chariots of Fire, I just went over to the piano and tried to figure out how you play it.
4:53And it's actually not that hard to play because it's the same repeated note just over and over. I felt like a pianist right away. But I remember asking my mom for piano lessons. I just said, I want to know how to do that. While the rest of us were asking our parents to get out of piano lessons. Now, from there, again, from an early age, you were kind of discovering a wide variety of forms of music. Can you talk about what those were and how you kind of gravitated towards them? Sure. I started out learning classical piano primarily. and for a long time up until really college I wondered whether I would be a classical concert pianist that was something I sort of thought might be my path and for a variety of reasons I decided not to do that but over the years you know when I was very young being exposed to sort of a lot of Broadway American song book through my mom and then a lot of jazz in high school I started learning jazz and I fell in love with hip-hop I think there was something about hearing hip-hop there was something about not just the the fact that it was sort of music about music that it was sampling other music and re reimagining it in so many ways but just as an art form in general I was totally fascinated by it sonically poetically everything and in terms of uh writing your own musical compositions um this goes back very early on too I've heard about the train symphony and uh some other these are some that's some deep research We can, I'll let you elaborate, but also, uh, first.
6:32Yeah, actually I could play the, if we're going to, we're going to try the piano. We're going to test this out. Let's see. Let's see if this works. I'll leave this. This is literally the first thing I think I ever wrote. So I apologize in advance for this. I thought this felt like a train, like the sound of a train. So this was, I was very, I think I was like six or so.
7:08That was the train symphony. Not bad, no.
7:14First public concert at 10, is that right? I was 10, yeah. Okay, where was, what was, so you were already kind of known among your peers, amongst your peers as somebody who was a standout at music? I just loved playing the piano. I used to sort of play anything and everything. Like our school had a Friday morning assembly, and I would play like the Phantom of the Opera every Friday. And everyone was like, Nick's the piano kid who plays Phantom of the Opera on Fridays. But I would play, and then I started getting really into, I learned a Haydn piano concerto, and I played that. So at that concert, which actually, interestingly, was it was October 23rd, 1990.
8:00Wait a minute. Happy anniversary. Exactly. 35 years ago. But that was the first public concert I gave. It was at a place that no longer exists called Berzendorfer Hall that was on 79th Street on the east side. So with this obvious, I would imagine to some degree, innate gift and then a lot of hard work, you go off to at least spending your weekends, I believe, at Juilliard's pre-college division. But you ultimately decided not to continue in sort of the conservatory setting after high school graduation. What was the calculus there? it was a really interesting conversation thought process because I think so many of my friends at the time and all I went to Juilliard pre-college so it's a it's a weekend program every Saturday you go in and you take harmony counterpoint you take a chorus class if you're a pianist you have your lessons master classes etc so it's like a really great full rounding in music and so many of my friends, you know, that I still work with went to Juilliard.
9:06Almost everyone I knew wanted to go to Juilliard or one of the great conservatories, you know, like Eastman or Curtis. I think it was one of those things where I was always asking the question of what did I actually want to do with myself? And like my wife, for example, who's an amazing cellist who, I'm lucky that she performs on so many of the scores. She's one of the cellists in the quintet that you hear in the movie, for example. I don't think there was ever a shadow of a doubt in her mind that she wanted to go to a conservatory for cello. And yet I was asking myself all the time. And I think there's something in life about like, if you're constantly asking yourself, maybe that's not, maybe that's not what you want.
9:44So I went to Harvard and felt totally lost in the very beginning, ended up studying psychology, and was very interested in the way that music and the brain intersect and how the brain understands music. And that became, and then it was at Harvard that I started other things that took me here I guess. Well first though let's let's not gloss over so what you were literally you know researching writing papers on at at Harvard this is an emphasis on psychology but an emphasis on neuro musicology can you just explain what that means? So I I was always really fascinated by this question of why music does what it does to us.
10:32And in the spirit of this evening, I will go back to the piano. Thank you. We're going to keep you on your feet. So, for example, there is a very famous series of lectures that Leonard Bernstein gave at Harvard called The Unanswered Question. and this was many decades ago where he was doing his own sort of theorizing on what is music and one of his main theses was that it was a language, essentially. But one of the questions I was always asking was, why are minor chords sad? And there's lots of theories and the big takeaway is no one really knows. There's a lot of theories. But for example, when you hear this, you know, like why does that feel different than, you know, so you hear that feels a certain way, and then you do this, feels a totally different way, and you know, I was like, why?
11:34And no one really knows, but I think one of the, so neuromusicology, one of the things that there's a lot of studies on infants, for example, and how infants turn their heads and the way infant cognition works. But there's also a question of, I think, as a composer, I think this is the other side of this, which is I think if you're writing music, a lot of the time you're thinking to yourself, well, what moves me and how might I do that? And then what does that all mean? So it's a quick digression. And I know that, keep this in mind, folks, because when we come to something like succession, you sort of subvert the expectation of what a certain sound connotes.
12:18Is that the right word? Yeah, totally. So one of the big things that happened at Harvard was after that period that you go to Harvard, then you say, I'm not sure this is what I want to do. Maybe I want to explore being a solo pianist, right? You took some time off to do that. I did, yeah. And then came back to Harvard. I did, I did. My parents were terrified I wasn't going to go back, But I did go back and I thought on my year off, it was actually one of the best things I ever did because on my year off, I basically was like, I want to start a band. I want to have a band. So I went back to school and actually just by luck, some friends of mine wanted to start a band.
12:54And so we all started a band together. And serendipitously at that exact same time, this was 2001, a very dear friend of mine, Nick Lavelle, who tragically passed away about 10 years ago. he was an amazingly talented director and he wanted to he wanted to make a movie and so he came up to me one day and was like I have I'm making a feature film do you want to score it and you know I said I don't I don't know how to do that really I mean that you know and he said well I don't really know how to make a movie so we'll figure it out and I basically spent you know three years in small closets with like editing equipment and my keyboard and we would just we would just look at scenes that he was shooting and figure out what to do musically and it was an amazing education and that was yeah and it's sort of this dual period of discovery at Harvard where on the one hand this group that you were part of the band that you were part of witness protection program witness protection program this was a kind of hip-hop in infused stuff.
14:03Were you called Dr. ATM? That's my stage name. That was your stage name? But so there's that stuff of the, that side of things where you're, you're getting into hip hop and group performance. And at the same time, going down this path for several years with the film scoring, which would, I know from what, or at least from what I've read, you're, you know, studying the John Williamses of the world who are obviously doing a very different sort of music, but you're processing all this at the same time. And maybe that might explain why some of your, you know, output as a professional in later years has been this unusual blend of both, right?
14:45I, you know, it's interesting. That was the first time in my life that I found myself writing music every day, all day, you know? And I think when I was younger, there's this weight on and all, I think anyone who's trying to be a composer, I think the weight of history is so massive. As a kid at Juilliard, I remember just being like, I mean, there's no way I'm a, even if I write music, I'm not a composer, because that's this thing that there's no way I'm that, because that's like these godlike figures from the past. And I think it takes, once you find yourself writing music all the time, at a certain point, you say to yourself, well, maybe I'm a composer if I just write music all the time.
15:30And it was in the band that I started writing music all the time for the band. So that's totally, you know, astute take on that. That that was, I had this keyboard that I bought because I read that Dr. Dre used it for the Chronic 2001 album. And it's the Korg Triton. And it had this sequencer in it, which is a 16-track sequencer where you could basically layer, you know, create music by layering it. And so I spent three years, you know, just like writing this orchestral music for my friend Nick and then making, you know, hip-hop tracks for my band. And yeah, that was the sort of, you know, crucible where it all formed, yeah.
16:13So you graduate in 2004. And while I know your heart was in music, like most people, You say, all right, I've got to do the responsible thing and get a job, right? Pay the bills. So you wind up, of all places, working on Wall Street at the time of the great financial collapse of 2007 and 8. What led you there and what led you out of there in 2010? So there's some interesting, strange connections that we'll come back to with how, with The Big Short, for example. I had a friend who was working at Bear Stearns, the former bank that no longer exists. Our band was breaking up at the time, and then the movie that I'd worked on for those years, initially it felt like we thought maybe we'd find a way to get it out, and it was very difficult.
17:12We really didn't know how to do any of that at the time. So I wasn't really sure how to get my film music moving forward or my non-film music moving forward. And my friend who worked at Bear Stearns said, you know, come and interview here and there's someone you should meet. And I ended up meeting someone who just by total luck and chance himself was a composer who had gone to Harvard and who was taking evening division classes at Juilliard. and I interviewed with him and he worked at Bear Stearns and he said, you know, you know, we'll find something for you to do here. I was like, okay, great.
17:48And so I ended up learning how to trade currencies and I stayed, you know, I kept, I was scoring short films at night. I was giving concerts. I was, you know, trying to do anything I could in music. And for the first few years, it was really fascinating. It was an amazing education just in the world, you know. but it really was not what I wanted to do and it became very difficult, very emotional just realizing that I wasn't pursuing the thing that I loved. So basically post-financial crisis, I quit that job and was trying to figure out how to do what I loved and I really didn't even know. I mean, I did so many different things to write music.
18:34I wrote telephone hold music. which I love doing. I had a friend who worked at a restaurant, and I think this was like 2009, and he was like, I've got a gig for you. I was like, great, you know, what is it? He's like, we need telephone hold music. And I was like, is there a budget or what have you? And he's like, no, I think they'll buy you a drink or something. And I was like, we're doing this. And I wrote telephone hold music, and my friends were so supportive, they would call the restaurant and be like, could you please put me on hold?
19:17And I was like, you guys are great. Thank you. So meanwhile, even as you are kind of figuring out your plans for life, there are several people who either you knew at Harvard or who had been at Harvard and it kind of came back into play here that did clarify where you would be headed. One of them is a woman named Helen Esselbrook. Oh, yes. Who was a friend from Harvard. can you just explain I guess she decides to connect you with another guy who's into film another Harvard kid I believe was Damien Damien Chazelle yeah Damien Chazelle yeah so this for folks who who uh need a reminder this is the guy probably best known for La La Land years after what we're talking about but before what made La La Land possible was that Damien and Giselle first made a short film called Whiplash and then a feature film version of that neither of which might have been possible without one Nicholas Bertel can you just explain how that happened so Helen Helen and I for many years and Helen's an incredible producer Helen for many years we've been having this conversation of you know how do you actually make a movie like what do you really do like technically you know how do you start the llc like how do you make this thing you know from a to z and um we've been having these conversations and so i remember one day this was early 2010s i forget exactly what year might have been 2011 or 12.
20:56helen reaches out to me with this amazing feature script called whiplash and she says you know you really should read this and i read and i was like this is incredible and his full script was you know was not just the short there's a full feature script and then um she called one day and she was like you know we're actually looking for investors to fund this to get the short going because we have an idea that we want to make a short film and show what what Damien can do and then use that as a proof of concept to hopefully raise financing to make a feature film and you know I said what are you looking for?
21:34And it was a very small amount of money. And I just said, well, I'll do it. I'll give you the money, you know, to start to do the short. But I said, I really want to make sure, I don't want to just support it. I want to learn how to do this with you. And I want to be involved and see how does it all happen. And if we get it into a feature, I'd love to be a part of that too and be a producer as well. And she said, yeah, absolutely. And so we made the short that summer of, I think it was 2012 or 2013. I think it was 2012, actually. And then we went to Sundance with the short in the beginning of the next year.
22:19And we were able to raise the money to turn it into a feature. And then we made Whiplash into a feature. Amazing. And Damien, of course, goes on from there. and not to get too far ahead of ourselves, but the year that Damien was at the Oscars with La La Land, you were at the Oscars with Moonlight. Yes. So it's just amazing how life works sometimes. The other Harvard person that we have to bring up who kind of sets the stage for you getting to run with your desire to be a part of films against all odds here is somebody named Jeremy Kleiner who was at Harvard five years before you. Jeremy runs the production company that along with Dee Dee Gardner and Brad Pitt called Plan B, but you did not seek out Jeremy, right?
23:07How did you and Jeremy find each other? So we had mutual friends in common, but there was one day that there was a party in LA and I was playing, I used to just play the piano at parties a lot, you know, similar, linked to the past, and I was playing the piano one day and he just came up to me and we started talking and I didn't know what he did for a living but we both had a love of music, a love of hip-hop. I started talking about the music I was writing and we just struck up a friendship and over the years we would just connect and then in 2012 he reached out to me because he said you know I have a project I would just love your musical advice on and it was 12 years a slave.
23:58So for 12 years a slave this is director Steve McQueen the film is set in the mid-19th century it opens just to remind folks with slaves on a Louisiana plantation chopping sugar cane while singing a spiritual my lord sunshine later on we meet Solomon Northup a person who really lived, was a slave, and performed violin, later wrote a memoir. The problem is that nobody knew what that music would have sounded like because there was no real documentation of music composed or sung by enslaved people from that time. How did that become sort of a problem for you to solve? Jeremy said if you have any thoughts on the script on how we might start figuring some of this out, just send an email.
24:50So I spent a lot of time thinking about this and I wrote this very extensive email to Jeremy and he forwarded it to Steve McQueen. And Steve called like 24 hours later and just said, you know, I'd love to talk to you about this. I liked what you were thinking. And it began a research process of how do you, you know, what is the sound? I mean, there were so many different things to figure out. Like you were saying there are no recordings from that time in history and we started with what the violin would have sounded like you know what would how would would it have even been tuned um so we started experimenting with that how would the violin have even been held and then we got into the question of songs and dances and what that would have sounded like and um steve and i did this research where we found some of the earliest documented descriptions of spiritual songs for example and what was amazing was you know these were these were descriptions by like white people who went south and would write what was happening and basically they said nothing that we're writing down is even a even a hint of what we're actually hearing you know so that what the notation just did not capture at all the sound that they were and so Steve felt that that was a you know an amazing starting point to figuring out what that actually was so it was an amazing experience for me to work with Steve and just to be a part of like seeing a film from its very earliest stages and thinking about how that would come together.
26:17And, you know, it was obviously through his guidance and vision that that started coming together. And just in case anyone is unaware, that film won the Academy Award for Best Picture and was the beginning of the, Now, you had been the full composer of several smaller films yourself. Independent films. Independent films. Yeah. Such as the directorial debut of another classmate from Harvard named Natalie Portman. Yep. Called Eve. Eve. Well, I wrote, I'm actually in Eve. And should I show the music that I didn't need? Sure. Thank you. I wrote a piece called Forgotten Waltz No. 2. there's a scene in Eve Lauren Bacall is in Eve and Ben Gazzara and I'm the cocktail pianist when they go into a restaurant and I remember Natalie said you know do you know can you play something here and I was like well I'll play something I wrote you know so here we go great just an excerpt of the Forgotten Waltz number two
27:47That's beautiful. Thank you.
27:54I think the first time I heard a composition of yours was another great little indie movie called Gimme the Loot. Gimme the Loot, yes. Which was 2012, I believe. Yep. Then, as we say, 12 Years a Slave is 2013. And then, I guess because now this Plan B film, 12 Years a Slave, had turned out so well, and Jeremy was a friend and admirer of yours at this point, you get introduced to another person who works with Plan B quite a bit, and that was Adam McKay. Yes. Talk about how you find out he's making a film about the financial collapse, the big short. I believe you saw the script fairly early on, And Adam has often laughed about the fact that I guess he sent you the script, you know, for thoughts about music possibilities and got back, unbeknownst to him, a financial experts critique of some of their mistakes about how they were describing the financial situation.
29:03So I got in a little trouble for this because basically, so I met Adam through Jeremy and Dee Dee. They sent me the script for The Big Short, and I remember actually initially saying I actually didn't think that would make a good movie because the financial products in The Big Short are so complicated. I thought it would be boring, you know, and then they sent me the script, and I was like, oh, no, they figured it out. They figured out how to make this both engaging and informative, but also without sacrificing any of the sophistication. So I was like, this is amazing. And I got on the phone with Adam, and we really hit it off.
29:43We had all these amazing conversations about the types of things he was looking for. And then Jeremy called and said, you know, by the way, you know, since you have this financial background, would you like, you know, could you give us some notes, you know, on the script? So I wrote all these notes and he didn't tell Adam that I had done any of this stuff. So Adam calls Jeremy and goes, why the fuck is our composer sending me financial notes? Like this has got to stop. It's not okay. And then he was like, the notes are pretty good. So then Adam was like, do you want to come to set? And so there were some scenes where I helped a little with pronunciation and sort of how things would be spoken of and things like that.
30:32And that was the beginning of this really incredible collaboration that I've had with that and friendship with Adam. I mean, he's a remarkable person. And just to tease that out in case people would like the dots connected, we're going to come to. but other Adam McKay collaborations included Vice, included Succession, included Winning Time, and on and on. But in the meantime, you're given an assignment for the actual thing he was seeking from you on the big short was kind of, it sounds like an unusual prompt in a way, which might go back to your neuromusicology expertise. You wanted to know, what is the sound of dark mathematics?
31:19And that was your assignment to figure out? So you're starting to see a connection between all these projects. There are these fascinating questions, I think, at the heart of each movie. And in a lot of ways, that's the thing that I love most about working on film is that you get asked a question and then you're trying to figure out a way sonically to either express some sort of an idea or play counterpoint to that kind of an idea but you're trying to do it emotionally and so it's this wonderful way of mixing storytelling ideas and emotions and the question that Adam asked was he said that what is the sound of dark math and I was like let me think about that.
Read the full transcript
32:09So I wrote this, I wrote a piece, I can play a little bit of it, it's actually really, it's sort of impossible to play on one piano because it's actually six pianos but there's this sort of motif in the big short where you hear this piano going kind of like
32:29So at this sort of, and then it's like,
32:36it's this sort of like building of layers. And then what happens is, which is impossible to play on the piano, is I took the recording of, this goes back to even like hip hop sampling, I basically took my own recording of the piano, sampled it, and then played it two times as fast and then four times as fast on top of it. So while that's happening, it's actually doing this incredibly complicated kind of like, you know, multiple time scales. And then underneath that, there's another melody comes in, which is this sort of...
33:17So this is all going on...
33:22And there's a sort of, I think this was the beginning of some of the explorations of like dissonance that I did a lot with Adam where I think Vice is probably the furthest we ever went with that. But there's a bit of it in Don't Look Up To. And I think there's a sense of like, what's the farthest you can go with sort of putting in a wrong note somewhere to make a point about something emotionally. Thank you.
33:52So the big short was out in 2015. The next year was something called Moonlight. This was the first of numerous collaborations between you and Barry Jenkins. How did you guys cross paths? And is it true that at the time he hired you for that movie, which again went on to win the Best Picture Academy Award, he had not actually heard any of your music? So this is crazy actually because I didn't know that until we were on our Beale Street press tour. The way that we first met was that Jeremy Kleiner had sent me, actually we were at dinner, this is what it was, we were at dinner and Jeremy started telling me about a movie that they were producing called Moonlight and he said the script was so beautiful and then he started to cry.
34:41It was he was just so moved by it and I said you know Is there any way I could read this script sounds unbelievable? So he sent me the script and I read it and I thought it was the most beautiful thing I'd ever read and I remember saying to him it felt like a poem it just felt like a work of poetry and I said is there any way I could meet Barry, you know, just just for a coffee or something and He said yeah, you know Barry's down to meet up with you and so we met up at the Ace Hotel in downtown LA, and what started as just like, you know, coffee or something turned into like a three-hour, we opened up a bottle of wine, and we talked about just movies and music and life and everything, and we talked about ideas even for the movie for Moonlight there, and that conversation started, and it was just really incredible talking to someone where it felt like we really had this immediate connection in that way.
35:39Fast forward three years or so, I guess, three, four years, and we're on the press tour for Beale Street, and we're doing a podcast, actually, and Barry says, you know, I never had heard any of your music when I hired you. And I was like, how did you hire me? Didn't Jeremy send you any examples of my music or anything? He's like, no. He's like, we just had a really nice conversation. and from from that point on i know you guys would uh you know as you said a lot of conversations i think it's important to note that it seems like part of the reason you chose not to be a concert pianist and chose to do film composition specifically is that it involves at least the way you choose to do it and insist on doing it this direct collaboration between the filmmaker and yourself and in this case I know it involved you know not just conversations but sending him playlists of things that were potentially springing off points for things right how did this conversation on Moonlight evolved to the point where you were talking about specific instruments that you wanted to emphasize on this score and also a specific style which is something that I had never heard of before, but I think it's obviously key to this great score.
36:59It's something called Chopped and Screwed. Can you explain what that is? Yeah, absolutely. So Chopped and Screwed music is a style of hip-hop where you take a recording and you slow it down, basically, and when you slow it down, the pitch goes down. But it doesn't just go down, it actually gets richer, and it's like you're pulling the music, you're making it wider, you know? And so every note is like more. It's an incredible sound when you listen to it. And that concept is present in, you know, in hip hop itself in a lot of ways when you're sampling something. But Chop and Screwed is a very overt version of this, really pioneered, for example, by DJ Screw, you know, really the pioneer of that.
37:44And in the first conversation I had with Barry, he brought up Chop and Screwed and he said, this is what I want to do. This is an idea I have. Were you already familiar with what that was? I knew of the concept generally in hip-hop, but I was not at all an expert at this whatsoever. And Barry was basically like, you know, let's dive into this. So I was, you know, like conceptually, I knew how I could do that. But Barry, Barry is such a fan of Chop and Screw. I remember at the time he was only listening to Chop and Screw. He was listening to music that wasn't Chop and and screwed and chopping and screwing and just listening to that.
38:19So he was, like all his music was like slow and low. And like, it was beautiful. It was actually amazing. He had all these amazing playlists. And in that first conversation, we had this idea, you know, of saying, well, what if I was gonna write you a original score? And he knew from the first moment we met, he said he wanted a classical kind of score from Moonlight. He said specifically, I am imagining like an orchestra for this. So we had that conversation of what if we had an orchestra and what if I recorded my own music for this and then we took those recordings and then we chopped and screwed those recordings and that was the score.
38:55And so that's what we did. Now there's one of the most beautiful and moving moments in Moonlight in large part because of the music is when Mahershala Ali's character Juan teaches Alex Hibbert's character Little how to swim. Can you share how that particular scene which probably for a lot of people is the first scene that comes to mind when they think about Moonlight evolved musically into what is now known as middle of the world. Absolutely. That was, this is actually an amazing story for me in my own career, I guess, because I think there was something about the nature of creative process. I mean, I think every movie you're learning, every artistic project you're learning, you know, it's anytime you think you know what you're doing on this stuff, you are faced with a situation where you realize there's still so much more to learn.
39:48And in that, there was an interesting example. I'll show at the piano a little bit. We'll do a little. Thank you. So basically, that was a scene where there's a, the main theme of the movie is Little's theme. That was a piece that I initially had called a poem because I was inspired by that idea that felt that the script felt like a poem, the movie felt like a poem, and the sort of motif in that piece is this...
40:17that's sort of like the symbolic motif for the character of Little, and the piece was this sort of...
40:43So this motif, I felt was a great starting point for the scene that we're talking about, where this is the moment where little is learning to swim. I felt this was a sort of a beautiful childhood moment that could be something that is distinct from what happens later in the film in a sense, sort of, you know, that last moment of childhood, let's say. So I was doing something where I was going to bring in a full orchestra, and I was going to do it in a different key, and it was going to be with clarinet, for example, and it was going to be sort of in like F major, and I was going to do this sort of
41:26sort of
41:29I was going to do this whole thing, and it was going to rise up, you know, I thought it was very beautiful. I did a big demo with orchestra sounds and everything, and I played it for Barry, and he was just like, no. No, no, no, not at all. I was like, whoa, okay, wow, like, what are we thinking here, you know? And he said, this is, this is a baptism, you know, this is a spiritual baptism. This is, this is not that feeling at all, you know? This is the, so it's almost a totally different way of looking at it. This is like the first day of the rest of his life, you know, and and I and I think it's such a powerful thing because realizing A, that a very logical idea of the theme, you know, is, you know, could be a great idea on paper.
42:17Maybe the, you know, maybe the piece is even pretty, but doesn't mean it's right for the scene. And he said spiritual baptism, so I started thinking, okay, maybe it's in D minor, not F, you know, it's like, so we're here. And, you know, he was sitting on my couch, and I just remember this sort of, I was like, well, what if I took these like arpeggios, and I wanted it to feel almost like, maybe it's almost more of like a storm feeling or something, you know, and you take these arpeggios, and I just started playing I put a violin sound on the keyboard to evoke that kind of violin sound I started doing these arpeggios this sort of like...
43:00So I started just doing this...
43:14And I sort of went on there from this whole...
43:33You know, it just kept going and going and going. And so when I finished, Barry was just like, this is it. Keep going. This is exactly what I'm going to do. It was like doing it in real time. You know, it just all came together in real time. I think it was such an important lesson for me in a sense because so much of this is about, it's not just the piece, it's about the idea, you know, and maybe that links back with what you're bringing up with these sort of conversations. So, you know, there's infinite possible scores for a movie. There's so many different ways that every composer might approach a film, but the sort of beautiful meeting point of a director and a composer talking specifically what they can do, that unique vision, that's the thing that I think we're trying to bring out.
44:24And that's what makes something feel, Barry talked about this very specifically, he would say with Moonlight that, you know, it's the specificity of Moonlight that makes it universal. Wow, thank you.
44:42I think it's also something that not everyone gets, but you certainly got that sometimes it's as important to not have music in a scene as it is to have music accompanying it. That was, I think, in evidence with the final scene in Moonlight, right, where we've got the character Black sits in Kevin's apartment, and you guys did not have any music until the very end of that, right? And then there's music that takes us out and actually interestingly that you bring up that scene because there's that scene connects to the first scene when they're on the beach together and that's an example of another scene where I had initially put a big piece of score and this there's something this is just one of the things that I feel is a recurring theme and being a composer is you can write a piece of music for a particular scene and it can be amazing it can be perfect you can watch the scene and it just feels amazing.
45:40It feels like everything's happening. The director feels it's great. Everything's great. And then you go watch the movie in a run and You're and as you get closer to that scene, you're dreading hearing your music and you know immediately that there should be no music in that scene and It's one of those fascinating things about movies is that they're they're long form, you know Every the micro is its own thing in the macro is its own thing and you really have to you really have to watch movies and run to know if music should be in a particular place. Now you're going to notice it. You're going to notice the music.
46:15You're going to be hypersensitive to it no matter where it is. But I guess the question I have is, should the audience be aware of the score? That's a good question. And I've thought about this a lot. I think in theory, the music is something that should be like, honestly, like every part of a movie. I mean, I think every part of a movie should be subconscious as we're watching it. You know, we should be completely lost in the movie. I think if it's functioning at its optimal level. That being said, I do think for me, some of my favorite movies, and obviously I'm biased and I'm a musician and I'm saying, but some of my favorite movies, the ones when I'm totally clocking the score the whole way.
46:55You know, I mean, I'm a pianist because I noticed the music in Chariots of Fire. But I think that if you think about watching Star Wars, for example, I think you're noticing the music. E.T. I mean, there's so many great examples of the music. So I think it's kind of an and. One last Moonlight-related question. I mentioned that Moonlight won the Best Picture Oscar, as did 12 Years a Slave. The circumstances under which Moonlight won the Best Picture Oscar, people might recall, was one of the craziest moments in the history of live television or award shows, which is something that I cover year-round for a living.
47:32I've never seen it. I don't think I'll ever see anything like it again. They announced accidentally the wrong winner at first and then correct it. Nicholas Bertel was one of the people along all the Moonlight folks. Once Jordan Horowitz corrected the mistake, the Moonlight folks went on stage alongside the La La Land folks, who again now you guys know the history of Nick and and and George the whole I mean Damien Chazelle and Justin Hurwitz and all these guys so there was always a nice rapport between the two films but that's a bit of an awkward situation what do you remember about how that all went down it was so crazy I remember thinking La La Land won and I had been nominated for the score that the year so we were sitting, the composers were all kind of sitting together, I think we were sort of on the left side.
48:25I remember we were all standing for La La Land and there were these sort of TV producers with the cameras in the middle of the floor there, and I just remember one guy was just like waving his hands like this. And I remember thinking, I actually remember thinking to myself, you know, look, they just won Best Picture, let let them speak. Like it's okay, you know? Like that's my gut feel. And then we really didn't clock what was happening at all, but someone was like, you guys won. And I was like, what? And then they were like, no, no, no, you guys won. Moonlight won. And then I sort of started seeing what was happening and I looked at my wife and I was like, do I just go up there?
49:11And so I was like, I'm going up. So I just, you know, they don't tell you what to do. We all just, so we all, I went up and it was incredibly confusing. And actually I think the most, there's some photography of me looking unbelievably confused and out of place. And I think, I just remember thinking to myself that I thought that like, I still didn't believe it. You know, it just, I was sort of like, is this actually correct, you know? But it was, and it was, I mean, that was, it was very, like none of us, none of us could comprehend that for the longest time yeah oh that's crazy okay so 2017 the year after moonlight you had uh battle of the sexes which was a about the billy jean king bobby riggs tennis match and and you approached that in an interesting way you had an upright piano for bobby riggs stuff you had a steinway grand piano for billy jean you also co-wrote an original song which you've done a number of times in this case with Sara Bareilles if I dare but then around this time I believe sort of in that same neighborhood not long after Big Short I believe Adam McKay who we mentioned gives you some indication that he's going to be involved with a television series as well yeah how did you find out about Succession so we were we were finishing Big Short and I I remember Adam said that there was a TV series with HBO that they were working on about sort of like billionaire media mogul family.
50:45And I really didn't know anything about what the show was about, but I'd always, I mean, I'd always loved HBO shows ever since I was a kid. And, you know, and I'd never done any television before. So I was totally into it. And he sent me the pilot script and I thought it was fantastic. And then in one of those sort of wonderful experiences that in hindsight I didn't even fully appreciate at the time, Adam said, well, we're gonna be shooting the pilot in New York and you should come to set and just get a vibe. And so I went to set and it was actually the day they were shooting the scene in the dining room between Logan and Kendall when Logan is basically just intimated to Kendall that he's not going to let him be CEO.
51:36And Logan says to Kendall, you know, do you want to hit me? It was that scene. So I'm just like sitting there watching this happen. And I remember just absorbing that atmosphere. And there's something so special about being able, especially as a composer, to be able to go to set, even if briefly, because I think, like in all these things, we're trying to figure out the feelings of things. That's really what I spend my time doing. And the thing it seems that you picked up on right away was that this was a dark, dark comedy. Yes. And so that, but also coming back maybe to the neuromusicology that we were talking about earlier, playing funny music or music that we associate with funny does not necessarily actually make something more funny.
52:35And so I wonder if you can talk about how this applied to your approach to what I think was the, from what I read, the last thing that you did in terms of composing music for the first season of Succession, and that is the title theme, which is the 90 seconds that opens every episode, the thing that you won an Emmy for, that became a crossover hit that's been covered and all kinds of things. A hundred years from now, when we're all gone, people are still going to be playing. I'd love it if you could share how that came together. So it was interesting because like you're saying there's this question of what is the tone of something?
53:23And I think I think that's probably the main question I ask myself on any project these days is really what what kind of tone are we in? Because like I was saying before with the different possible ways you can score something, you know, you can completely change the feeling of something with the chords you're using and with succession there was this feeling of the seriousness the gravitas which was this question of what's the music that the Roy family would imagine for themselves? That was sort of question number one. But there is this humor and this absurdity to the show and I do agree that almost always funny music, music that sounds funny isn't funny, it actually just makes things sound kind of dorky.
54:08And for me, I felt like if there was a way in, especially with this show, it felt like the music being really serious would make it funnier actually so like fully lean in to like almost absurdly serious music and then I saw the dailies and I saw Jeremy rapping to the Beastie Boys in the back of the Mercedes going to work and I was like oh maybe there's this like oversized hip-hop beat or a huge bass that's like mixed way too loud and you're right The way it all came together really was I had, in that time when we were shooting the pilot, Jesse came over and I showed Jesse, I'll go to the piano on this one.
54:54All right. So we were sitting in my studio and I remember pulling up like a string sound, like a string sample sound, and I started playing these dark chords and Jesse was really into it. And the chords were these chords. It was...
55:20So I was playing those chords and he was like, this feels really good. And I remember there were a few different things that I had put together to show him as ideas. I even had these like weird, there's a scene in the pilot where someone comes into the Waystar Royco office to sage the office. So I was like, maybe there could even be a weird zen bell or something like that. I don't even know. And actually, I think there is some zen bell in the pilot. We stopped using that after the pilot. But basically what happened was these four chords are actually a sort of classical progression that used to be used in many pieces in the classical era when you'd have sort of like a culminating moment in something.
56:06You'd have something, everything would come up and then there would be this sort of, you know don't like you know you know do something and and um i use that as a starting point of thinking okay we're gonna have this dark chordly classical sound and then i actually just started writing the whole score working on episodes i mean um we did the pilot it was later a year later we were working on the episodes and i never had the 90 second sequence and so I'd already recorded score with orchestra, done all these different things, and then finally HBO said, okay, there's this 90-second sequence. And I had this idea of this sort of the windy melody, this sort of...
56:48You know, that sort of... And that was sort of the beginning parts. And then I said, you know, I'd already recorded the orchestra, so I said, well, what if I sample my own orchestra? And so those huge string sounds are actually part of the score that I've been writing in earlier episodes. This sort of, you know, that sort of stuff is in there. And then, but I didn't know what to do after that. Where does it go? And this is why it's so interesting having a window of time when you can really experiment with ideas, is because at the end of episode one, I had written a melody which was like this, this sort of.
57:45Sort of, you know, and I was thinking, well, what if that was the middle of the thing? So this sort of like, so then I took, I started writing this sort of.
57:59That became the sort of middle. And then I put it all together, made the bass huge, and those are 808s in the bass. And I remember sending it in to, there was a huge email chain with Jesse and everyone on it. And I felt very strongly about it. I was like, I really think this is great. And I remember saying to my wife, I was like, you know, if they have notes on this, I'm just not even sure what I'll do, because it just feels really good. And I remember sending it out, and I said, you know, here's my idea, you know. and Jesse was amazing. He just wrote back, reply all, and he said, you know, I think the only thing to say to this is fuck yeah.
58:33That's awesome. Thank you. That's great. That's great. And as succession aficionados will know, as you say, you know, this is also omnipresent in the underscore, right? Throughout the series, it kind of works with each other. And then the other thing I think people need to know is that with Succession, you approach these four seasons as essentially a symphony, right? Can you explain what you meant by that? So this was something that Jesse and I talked about after, I think it might have been during season one, but it was definitely when we were going into season two. I remember thinking to myself that how do you give each season a character?
59:21because I wanted to make sure that each season, even if we were winking back to where we had been, I wanted to make sure that we were always pushing forward because if we just kept using the season one music, it's going to get, it's just not going to be the right thing. It's going to be boring. You're going to feel like you're always in the past. And I said to Jesse, you know, maybe we could think of each season as a movement of a symphony. You know, so for example, like in a classical symphony, the first movement would be like an allegro movement, which is maybe really up-tempo. Season two would be perhaps like an adagio, like a slower movement, where it's more meditative and thoughtful, and at the time that I proposed this, you know, Kendall was going into this very meditative sort of place after the end of season one, really introspective.
1:00:10The season three would be maybe something like a scherzo movement, which would be in three-four time or something like that. It would be more sprightly. And actually, interestingly, scherzo comes from the Italian for joke, so there's something to that, too. And then the fourth movement, there's lots of different ways of doing a fourth movement in a classical symphony, but it could be a presto movement or something really fast. It could be a rondo movement where you're going back to an idea. So that was more of an open question. I didn't know that it was only going to be four seasons and that this metaphor would work perfectly with the show.
1:00:43But that was just an idea that we had, And I think it helped us think with like long lines about like what the whole scope might be. And Jesse and Adam were always so supportive of this idea of like, no, we have to, you know, really, it can be fully written out music for every single episode. And I think people should know, like, you know, they might think that TV, you know, you come in, you write the theme and you leave them a few pieces of music to put where they want. And then you're out of there to go do other things. you have described it as more like 40 or whatever movies. Oh, yeah. This was like doing 39 movies.
1:01:22Yeah, because every single episode, we would approach it like a movie, and it was a monumental amount of work. But, I mean, just incredible. Right down to the end credits are different for, I believe, every episode, playing right into the HBO-themed music. It's just amazing. Amazing and also don't think that other music related things that pop up in the show do not trace back to Nick Bertel because You might recall the rap L to the OG By oh there look at that we got a jersey That I Believe not only was composed by but it was the initially performed by Yourself is that true? Oh my god, okay that I worked with Jeremy early on to try to figure out how to line up the rap with a performance.
1:02:22And I didn't know that we were even doing this in the show. I didn't know that there was going to be a birthday hip-hop show for Kendall. And I was trying to figure out, like, what would the music be? and Will Tracy and McKay wrote amazing lyrics. And, but it was sort of like, how do you actually wrap this up? And I remember talking to Jeremy, you know, he was like, well, how should we do this? And I was like, well, you know, here's the lyrics and we just sort of, you just sort of do it, you know? And he was like, well, could you do it and show me, you know, just to see a way to do it? And I was like, I will do this if no one ever hears this.
1:03:08so that recording has been deleted but all credit to jeremy strong because he he fully owned that and made that work you know i mean that's all that's all jeremy and you know hats off so there are there are a million great nick bertal projects that we could talk about but i think what we'll do just uh given the the hour is i'm going to focus on about five more and go deep with with you on these if that's all right so here we go barry jenkins you're back with on if beale street could talk now this is one of the great another oscar nomination for you by the way just a beautiful beautiful piece of music and it starts with him giving you a few instruments that he has in mind right and then you guys find identify a missing ingredient Can you explain what that was?
1:04:04So the initial thought that Barry had for Beale Street was, I remember I had read the book and then I read the script and he just said that he was hearing brass and horns. He was like, I'm hearing brass and horns. I remember I went off and I started experimenting with brass and horns and I wrote quite a bit of music and showed it to Barry and he really, really was into it. but this is another one of those examples where just because a piece of music works doesn't necessarily mean that it's right for the movie. And what we discovered was I think the sound of brass was very direct and felt very tragic in the movie and for Barry Beale Street is about injustice but it's also about love and the music was missing that feeling of love.
1:05:00And what we figured out was that if I took the music that I'd been writing for brass and started playing it with cellos, immediately it felt right to us. And that's what happened. So I remember there was a day where, I can show the chords, I can play the chords here. There were a few pieces of that score. there was the um there was a motif this sort of that was one of the melodic motifs this that was from a scene in the script where Tish and Fani have been able to rent an apartment for the first time and um there's a scene where it says they were shouting to the sky with joy and so I was I wanted the music to have the shape of this sort of upward motion so that was this and there were many brass chords that I've been doing there was this sort of these sort of taking that melody and I was doing all this with brass and then I started doing these things with cellos and then there were these chords that I had been doing with piano, actually.
1:06:16And the piano wound up in the score, too. But I recorded these chords with cellos. So it's, you know, five...
1:06:48And then the melody goes.
1:06:53So it just fits right on top.
1:07:00And with the cellos, I remember sending Barry these, just solo cellos playing these together. And I think Barry said he was like in a car, and he like pulled over. It was like, and that was the way in for the score. It was that way in, yeah. Before you get up, can I ask you about the number from that movie that I think everybody comments on and particularly loves this bit over the scene in which Tish describes the day I realized Fani was in love with me. This is called Agape. That's Agape. That was that we were. Exactly. So that's Agape. And then what happens is I took these brass. It's mostly flugel horns, but there's some piccolo trumpets.
1:07:38And it's this sort of, you know, this.
1:07:44It's like multiple, you can't play it really that well on the piano, but basically it's all, so that's all happening while underneath there's a flugelhorn playing that melody. That's fantastic. Yeah, thank you.
1:08:05Back with McKay on Vice that same year. let's just say you have if Beale Street could could talk you have Vice and you have Succession all starting or coming out in 2018 and in one of the most insane years ever for anyone um that reminds me of like the fact that Spielberg had Jurassic Park and Schindler's List in the same year this is the composer equivalent of that but with with Vice we'll say that that along with Beale Street were both Oscar shortlisted in the same that doesn't happen somebody having multiple on the shortlist but regardless the thing that I found just the most interesting is Vice is a film about Dick Cheney we know about Dick Cheney's heart problems yes when you guys are sitting down to figure out your reference point for or you know jumping off point for Vice what did you suggest Well, Dick Cheney notoriously has these, famously notoriously has heart problems.
1:09:04That was a literal element and a metaphorical element in the film. One of the ideas that I had early on was I had seen years before Bernstein talking about Mahler's Ninth Symphony, and Mahler had had heart problems at the time. And I don't think he talked about this himself, but Bernstein was theorizing that there's this rhythm in the percussion, the beginning, where his theory about it was that it was Mahler sort of musically signaling his own arrhythmias. And that concept of an arrhythmia, like a malignant heart rhythm, was something that I started talking to Adam about, like how might we incorporate this?
1:09:49And what happened was early on, Adam then, I mean, I think he already thought this was the way to go, but he basically said to me, you know, I want you to write a symphony for this movie. And we had this feeling that, like, the music could be both heroic and totally broken and distorted and, you know, dissonant at the same time, sort of like a broken heroism in a sense. and that was in a sense how we approached the square for vice. That's great. The King was 2019, a very good one. Cruella 2021 during the pandemic at Disney, different kinds of projects. But 2021, you went back with Barry, but for the first time to long-form television, a limited series, The Underground Railroad, something that took 20 months of your life.
1:10:47A lot of work. A lot of work. And, you know, we've kind of gathered or discussed that sometimes there are jumping off points with Barry, with Moonlight, I think Oceans were a reference point, with Beale Street, Subways. With the Underground Railroad, what was it? Well, there were actually so many. There were so many different things. There were times where I went down to Savannah, and we were on set figuring out the sounds of some of the on-camera music. And there was actually sounds of, like, insects in nature that became a part of just the elemental forces of the world. There was this feeling, I think, of elemental forces that went into it.
1:11:33I mean, that project was so immense. I think I'm still kind of like, you know, yeah, yeah, like processing it. And drills, right? Oh, yes, we had drills. There was a sound of a drill that we were in our in a in a production office and we heard a drill outside and we did a voice memo of it. And yeah, the idea of earth, the idea of digging, those were elements of it. There was a lot of sonic exploration. that was another project where every single episode in the story every single episode it's it actually feels like you're going into almost a different planet so that was another huge undertaking of it wasn't like we could say that the sound in episode one was going to be anything like the sound in episode two so in almost every episode we had to say to ourselves well maybe we have to rethink everything we're doing so we're doing your people are picking up I'm sure there's a lot of Jenkins to McKay to Jenkins to McKay.
1:12:34We're back with McKay on Don't Look Up 2021, another Best Picture nominee. And what's interesting is that of all the things you've done with him, what you said is that this one was the toughest assignment. Why was that? Again, what was interesting, and that was, I don't know if this is what you're referring to, but during that project, I had bought a new house. And the movie is obviously about climate change. and while we were scoring that project my my roof leaked and I was inside the movie basically because I was dealing with like it was the most rain that had ever fallen in one hour in the history of Central Park I think it was like nine inches in an hour or something like that and it all went into my house while we were recording remotely during the pandemic in London with an orchestra and I was like guys I gotta give me five I gotta figure something out and I was like I had a tarp up in the and it was like pushing water off it it was it was insane so yeah so that was and we'll note that you also contributed to a uh Oscar shortlisted song on that along with Kid Cudi and Ariana Grande called Just Look Up which is one of the funniest songs you can imagine it's so uh I think you have to kind of uh initially hear it in the context of the film to realize just how cheeky it is, but it's a great song on its own as well.
1:14:02You go from there back with McKay to Winning Time, the drama series 2022. And then the second to last thing I'm going to talk to you about here is Andor, which is from Tony Gilroy stepping into the Star Wars universe. I know Tony's got some background in music, but also Star Wars for a half century has been and associated with John Williams. And I would imagine that it's a little daunting to have to step into that universe. And while the master, thank God, is still with us, you're gonna be, you were gonna be entering that, those big footsteps in a way, but also I know that you kind of figured out that it wasn't quite that.
1:14:48Can you take me into the mindset of and or? Yeah, I mean, John Williams is, I think all of our hero in a way. He's just one of the most inspiring musical figures of the century, of the past century really. And I think I was lucky in the way that I came into the Star Wars universe because in the first conversation I had with Tony Gilroy, he said that he didn't want the music to have anything to do with that sound world. And I think as an initial starting point, that was very helpful because we wanted it to have a feeling of that universe, of that galaxy, let's say, but we didn't want it to have a direct reflection or, you know, referral to it.
1:15:34And so we were able to start with, like all these projects, we were able to start with the feelings and the story and, you know, what's the sound of Ferex and what's the sound of Coruscant and what is the world that's in front of us and and how do we make that sound? And I think that for me, there's a incredible kind of yearning scope and sweep to Star Wars, which is one of the things I think we all love about it. It's just this epic, vast canvas. And so I think I wanted, in my own way, that music to have a feeling that it could get there if it was earned on our part, but the starting point was actually light years from that.
1:16:14it was really like you know I started out with almost like a kind of retro future you know analog synthesizers and uh like I was writing you know this sort of like dark you know club music on Morlana and things like that which ended up recurring as a pop track you know Nyamos that we wrote for for the rest of the for the for the whole you know galaxy that they were all listening to this piece. And it's just unbelievable because I don't know if you were asked to do this or if you took it upon yourself to do this, but the arrangement of the main theme for every one of the 12 episodes is different.
1:16:51It's different, and that was, that initially was a fun idea, and then I thought I was crazy, and I was like, why did I do this to myself? At like episode 11, I'm like, why am I doing this to myself? It actually came out of a conversation that I had, I was trying, you know, to come up with a theme, with a main title theme for for Andor, I had done all these different arrangements of the theme. So for example, I had done a big full orchestra version, and then I did a very small version, and then I did a version with intimate strings, and then I did a ver, you know, there were all the, then I did one with a huge beat under it.
1:17:27And I remember kind of going through these in my studio with Tony, and I was just like, I like all these, like I don't, there isn't one that's the one. And actually, I think there was something about not just using the full orchestra theme as the theme that felt right to us for what we were doing with the show. And so, you know, it might have been Tony who just said, well, what if we just use all of them, you know? And so I had a few ideas. That got me up to like episode five. And I was like, okay. Wow. Yeah. Okay. Jay Kelly, Noah Baumbach, is a filmmaker who you did not know before this. No. and he was an admirer from afar, I guess, and reached out and said what to you?
1:18:11We met up in his office in New York, and I had been a fan of his for, I mean, I guess his whole filmography, really, and it was one of those great conversations where from the very beginning, I think, you know, you can tell when you're with someone who completely loves movies. you just have a different kind of conversation and it was so clear that not only was he good at this but he loved it and I think the longer I get to this the more that really matters he knew right away that he said I want this movie to have a the score that's really a part of the movie you know he wanted it to be something that had a voice and he said that there it could he wanted something that felt like it it harkened to that sort of the you know the way movies used to be made that kind of a feeling, which kind of links to one of the reasons we recorded with analog tape, and how did people used to do these, what's the movies that we grew up loving, you know, and I was very inspired by that first conversation, and from there we started talking about the score, what it might be, and this was about the previous year before he started shooting, and so because we started so early, I wrote a few themes, and he came over to my studio, I played them on the piano, and then they invited me to set so I went to Italy and I'm actually in the scene at the tribute I'm sitting next to Billy Crudup.
1:19:39But I mean and one of the things that you know back in LA a few days ago I was doing a SAG interview with the actors from that movie and they were all saying Clooney and Laura Dern, Billy Crudup and I guess I forget I'm blanking on who else was was with Adam Sandler how do you forget and they were all saying it's such a rare treat to be able to have at least a chunk of the score present what know the score before they perform the scenes because it can inform yes as music did during the silent era when they would play piano or whatever on the set it gives them a sense of what they're a part of exactly it's a different it's a very different thing and I guess now that we've talked about so many of these his you know I'm seeing connections in my own past now that I'm not sure I was fully aware of before this conversation but I think the idea of being on set the idea of being around what the movie is and what it's becoming is something that you absorb and I remember that there was this amazing dinner we all had in this farmhouse in Tuscany and there was a piano there.
1:20:52George Draculius, our music supervisor, was like, Nick you gotta play some of the themes, you know, we're here, so, and I'll play a couple of the themes, I'll play a little bit just of J. Kelly. The themes that I had at that point, I remember I played the chords, these were this sort of, the J. Kelly theme were these chords.
1:21:24And there was this melody that was a...
1:21:57And then it can go into this sort of alternative version, which is this.
1:22:24That's the alt that it sort of goes into, you know, and the other theme I had at that time I remember I played was the cinema theme, we call it the cinema theme, which was this sort of...
1:22:57That was one of the other themes. And so, you know, I was playing all these on set, and just very quickly you start feeling like you're figuring this all out together. And I've never done that before, where I was playing my own score on set during the movie. Yeah, it's unbelievable. Wow, beautiful.
1:23:20And just I think people should know that your creativity, I mean, who would think of this, but in those scenes in the film where Jay Kelly literally walks into his own past, what did you do with the music? So I don't think this would always work, but basically I took the melody and I played it backwards, but I wrote it out backwards, so it's not like the audio is reversed. it's actually the notes themselves and when I reversed the notes it actually sounded really interesting and I started using that as a concept sort of a way into this idea of him going back into his memories. And the just the music there at the tribute at the end it's it you can't I cannot imagine and I know this is a thing you've done with students and people who have come to learn from you that you know you can watch a scene without any music and I'm not saying it wouldn't still be a beautifully made film or whatever but it is impossible to imagine that hugely emotional powerful ending of Jay Kelly or the rest of it for that matter without the beautiful work that you did and so I know that I know that I went long tonight but I did it because it's not, and I thank you for rolling with it, but it's not every night that we get, you know, to hear, and not just hear vocally, but at the piano from a genius and a master and somebody who's going to be doing great work for many, many more years.
1:24:56So thank you to you for coming, and please join me in thanking Nicholas Bertel. Thank you so much, Scott. Thank you, Scott.
1:25:09Thank you.
1:25:39announce upcoming guests and provide details about special live recordings of the podcast that you can attend. Until next time, thanks again for tuning in. Good energy in. Good energy out.
1:25:58Storm, zero sugar, 200 milligrams of caffeine and immunity support. Storm, energy for life.
1:26:07Nicholas Britell:Pandora jewelry brings the sparkle to your summer. Now with even better prices. Enjoy up to 50 % off select styles. From personalized pieces to must-have favorites made for the summer. Timeless designs that shine with you through every moment. Wherever the summer takes you. Shop in-store or online. Now through July 5th. Terms and conditions apply. Visit Pandora.net for details.
From the publisher
In front of an audience at the Virginia Film Festival, and a piano, one of the leading film composers of his generation reflects on how he was shaped by both classical and hip-hop music, how his best known scores for TV (the main title theme for 'Succession') and film (Barry Jenkins' 'Moonlight' and 'If Beale Street Could Talk') came to be, and how his score for Noah Baumbach's new film was composed and employed differently than any of his others.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
