In short
Choosing investment funds—what funds are, how they work (OIC vs investment trust vs ETF), key terms (accumulation vs income), and how to compare funds (intent, time horizon, risk, fees, and active vs passive).
Guests
No external guests; hosts are Kate and her dad Pete (“Bank of Dad” podcast).
Guest backgrounds
Pete is a mortgage/house-buying participant and business owner paid via dividends (dividend/company/tax-year complexity mentioned); Kate is the co-host and asks questions to clarify fund mechanics.
Key claims
Start with investment intent and time horizon before picking funds; if you need money soon, consider not investing. Benchmarks can be gamed by fund managers. Passive/index investing generally beats most active managers because it avoids manager-selection risk and is cheaper. Fees matter materially over long periods.
Notable examples
Section 106 “affordable house” mortgage rules (buying at 81% market value, valuation by chartered surveyor, no estate-agent valuation, no outbidding) and “Nancy” vs “Simone” fund-manager change illustrating lagging past performance.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VORecent Reading and House Purchase Update
0:45 to 4:36
Discussion on recent books read and updates on the house purchase process.
“7 and a half gosh actually I really enjoyed I read a lot of sort of non-fiction I really enjoyed the first two in what is a trilogy by Leigh Bardugo really really love Six of Crows she's famous for Grishaverse series.”
Choosing Funds and Investment Basics
4:36 to 9:48
Overview of investment funds and the importance of understanding funds before investing.
“but it's important that mum knows, you know, from somebody other than me, I think.”
Determining Investment Intent and Goals
9:48 to 13:15
Exploration of how to determine investment goals and the importance of intent.
“indeed so there are obviously thousands of funds to choose from where do you even go about I will take the piss where do you even go about oh we're carrying on yeah Yeah.”
Assessing Risk and Investment Timing
13:15 to 14:01
Discussion on risk tolerance, investment timing, and the necessity of assessing financial situations before investing.
“So if you need the money in the foreseeable future, say the next two, three, four years, the question has to be, should you be investing at all?”
Understanding Risk Tolerance in Investing
14:01 to 16:09
Learn how to navigate your risk tolerance and investment strategies based on timescales.
“Because otherwise you would have missed out on it.”
The Mechanics of Open-Ended Investment Companies
16:09 to 18:18
Discover how open-ended investment companies operate and how shares are managed within them.
“And I have a question here that says, what do I need to know about how funds work?”
Investment Trusts and Their Characteristics
18:18 to 21:18
Explore the characteristics of investment trusts and how they differ from open-ended funds.
“I really wouldn't lose any sleepover again.”
Exchange Traded Funds and Market Behavior
21:18 to 23:28
Understand the behavior of exchange-traded funds and how they differ from traditional funds.
“The other one that everybody that's even looked at this briefly will have heard of is an ETF.”
Active vs. Passive Investment Strategies
23:28 to 28:00
Learn the differences between active and passive investment strategies and their implications.
“The fourth bullet point on here, which I think people need to understand, is that there is a difference between accumulation and income or distribution.”
Active vs. Passive Investing: The Core Debate
28:00 to 31:26
Explore the differences between active and passive investing, their pros and cons.
“So the whole point of paying a fund manager is to beat the market that they are investing in.”
Show all 15 chapters
The Importance of Fees and Performance
31:26 to 37:08
Understand how fees impact investment returns and the relevance of past performance.
“I may get some flack for this, but honestly, I don't know why anybody would invest in an active fund.”
Understanding Fund Types: Accumulation vs. Income
37:08 to 42:00
Learn the differences between accumulation and income funds and their implications.
“The last question, which we kind of, maybe I got a bit sidetracked is, you know, what do people look for when comparing funds?”
Understanding Bonds and Funds
42:00 to 42:43
Learn about the complexities of bond funds and their management.
“And bonds are just another thing you buy.”
Engaging with the Audience
42:43 to 43:36
Discover how the hosts encourage audience interaction and feedback.
“But we are going to continue this discussion on another, the next episode we'll be continuing this because otherwise it'll be like a two hour long episode and nobody wants that.”
Closing Remarks and Resources
43:36 to 44:14
Get insights on upcoming episodes and where to find additional resources.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00I haven't even checked my hair. I'm sure my hair is just gorgeous as always. Well, that, it's amazing how that was the word I was going to go for. Gorgeous. Yes, uh-huh. It's, yeah. Okay. Hi and welcome to the Bank of Dad podcast. I'm Kate and this is my dad Pete. Hello. And we're here to teach you the money lessons we were never taught at school. There's no judgment, no jargon, just real talk about how to handle your money. Not bad, it's been a while since you've done this. Yeah, it took me a minute. Nice tan, by the way. thanks you too it was the sole mission for 10 days it was read books 10 up it was lovely wasn't it yep really really good do you have a favourite book of the ones that you read because you read 6?
0:467 and a half gosh actually I really enjoyed I read a lot of sort of non-fiction I really enjoyed the first two in what is a trilogy by Leigh Bardugo really really love Six of Crows she's famous for Grishaverse series. So this, the first one, it's called Ninth House and the second one is Hellbent. So it's a trilogy, totally different from the other stuff. Yeah. Really enjoyed them. Read those one per day. They were that good. Yeah. I read five and a half, but the half of the book that I read was 800 pages. Sarah J Maas. So it's six books, right? Like that's, the half was 400 pages. It's not a competition.
1:25That's a book. But if it was, I'd beat you. Yeah. Because you read nonfiction, it's fluffy. Yeah, well, you reckon. I'm joking did you see how angry he got then yeah yeah finding meaning in the second half of life yeah it was quite funny you were chatting to me in the pool after reading it going sorry if I've messed you up what the hell are you reading Jungian psychology I was reading it was quite good but yeah anyway far more interest how is the house purchase going so actually I was about to say pretty stagnant but for the viewers and listeners there has been a development major development I got my mortgage offer finally four months it's been an ordeal hasn't it but for two specific reasons yeah which we've alluded to before but essentially having a house buying a house that is considered an affordable house under the section considered it's still 193 grand or whatever yeah so it's under something called the section 106 scheme which I actually believe is a Cornwall only oh really yeah because Gary was like what the hell is this oh okay Yeah.
2:28Gary is mortgage advisor Gary King. We love him. Extraordinaire. Yeah, we love him. So that means I buy the house for 81 % of its market value, which is great. I'm buying a lot more house than I'm paying for. But the deal is I sell it for whatever its value is at 81 % of whatever the value is. Yeah, but what's cool is you can't get it valued by an estate agent. It's got to be valued by a surveyor, a charter surveyor. Yes. And you can't be outbid. You can't bid more than the asking price. Yes. So for example, there was an offer on the house when I looked at it. Which was less than the asking price.
3:02Which was less than the asking price. So I went asking price. And I got it. And you can't be beaten. All I could do was be equaled. Yes. And they pick who they prefer. Yeah. But thankfully we didn't have to go down that route. So that's the first reason why it's been tricky. The second reason being because it's really hard to buy in Cornwall, okay? It's a lot of money. We are doing a joint borrower sole proprietor JBSP mortgage, which means that mum and dad are on the mortgage. But don't own the house. But don't own the house. So it's bitship for them, really. Shafted either way you look at it.
3:32But actually, it's a means to an end. But the point is, the banks can then look at that and go, oh, if she can't, they can. Yes, they factor in our income, don't they? So that they can lend more. They also factor in our age, though. So it means that you can't necessarily get as long a mortgage as you might otherwise have been able to get. Yes. But those two things combined have meant that it's been a ball ache, to get it on, get it ready. I mean, despite Gary's tireless efforts, it's been a hassle and part of it is because of the way I'm paid and stuff you know I'm a business owner and it's dividends and company years and tax years and all that sort of stuff the amount of stuff two different accountants it's just been a bit of a faff but anyway we've got the mortgage offer now I messaged I emailed my solicitor this last week and she said that she is awaiting responses from the seller's solicitors regarding some things from the searches and also awaiting some documents from Barclays my lenders yeah anyone got some independent legal advice which is happening tomorrow.
4:26Just to make sure I'm not swindling you, I guess. To make sure we know what we're getting into. Yeah, like... I asked if I could waive it. I mean, you know, I know what I'm getting into, but it's important that mum knows, you know, from somebody other than me, I think. But, although she'd be like... Couldn't get less. Yeah. But I did ask if I could waive the right to legal advice, but the answer was no. So I've got to do that and pay for that. So anyway. Sorry. No, no. It's all good. What are we talking about this week? this week we are kind of it's in a similar vein to last week which honestly feels like a very long time that we recorded it yeah so um yeah so i'm sure it is on the similar vein we just don't remember what we're on about then um in that we're talking about choosing funds last week we were talking about asset allocation so it's all about kind of making the most of your investments isn't it yeah yeah getting the investments in place getting them right hopefully from day one yeah And sent things off on the right foot.
5:21So choosing funds this week. But before we get into that, it is time for Wanky Word of the Week.
5:32Yep. And what is this week's Wanky Word of the Week? Benchmark. Benchmark. A meaningless word. Yeah. I mean, and we know the meaning of it. Yeah. Something, a standard against which you are measured, isn't it? is there a specific meaning for this? Well, no, because fund managers, to some degree, can choose what benchmark they are measured against, which kind of makes a mockery of the whole thing. Yeah, I was just about to say, well, what's the point in that then? Well, because you pick a benchmark which makes you look good. Yeah, thus, then they're not comparable to other. Well, it's like I'm thinner than the people on my 600-pound life, but that doesn't make me in good shape, does it?
6:14No, exactly. so it depends on you we had a real phase of watching that didn't we we did so you know if you can set your own benchmark it seems a bit daft we'll come back to benchmarks later but it's basically when you are choosing fun they will say you know compared to this benchmark we have achieved an out performance of X or an under performance of Y whatever oh it's sounding suitably wanky yeah well it's just a bit of a stupid word how did that word come about anyway do you know what I mean it's probably something like in the victorian times where they would put a bench up sideways and that was like how they measured you like in height like you're that part on the benchmark like do you know what i mean it probably is it's probably something like that okay you want to do it you want to google it out yeah well i want to see how close i am because i feel like that's actually not bad benchmark etymology let's have a look origins and 19th century land surveying so now you're not far off with victoria but you're probably all right where surveyors cut a horizontal mark horizontal mark into a stone wall or building to insert a metal bracket called a bench that securely held a measuring rod in place.
7:20Hang on, let's just review the things I got right there. Along the wall, Victorian, along the wall, and a measuring thing. Well done, Kate. God, I'm a genius. Or lucky, but either way. It was an educated guess. It was educated and it started out well. So choosing funds. So let's start with the basics. What is a fund? Yeah, good place to start. A fund is a, we call them collective investments. So what it means is you, me, and however many other people want to invest in this fund, we essentially pool our money together. You think, well, that sounds a bit dodged. How am I keeping track of that? Well, obviously there are mechanisms for who owns how many shares in the fund.
8:05Yeah, if I put 300 grand in and you put 20 quid in, it's probably not fair that we have the same volume of ownership. No, you wouldn't have the same number of shares, would you? Yeah. You'd have proportionally the right number of shares based on how much you put in. And what's important is that by pooling your money, it gives you pretty much two things. Firstly, potentially at least, economies of scale. So, you know, more people invested more money. You can buy more stuff. and also if the fund manager is going to buy like 10 million quid of a particular stock they're going to get a deal on trading fees and stuff like that they've got institutional rights yeah and there's not many individuals who can buy that much of no and the thing about owning because mostly these are shares also bonds so the underlying assets that we talked about last time you know as an individual investor if you own shares in say 10 companies i swear to god the paperwork these days even if it's virtual into your email inbox It's intense.
9:02Really? And so if you own 100 stocks, it would just be unmanageable. Whereas by investing in a fund, you could be potentially accessing 5 ,000 underlying stocks. So you're spreading your money more widely. So not only economies of scale in terms of… You also diversify. Yes, exactly. It's not just in terms of cost, but also reducing risk by diversification. You can buy more stuff, access to more stuff as well through a fund. But it comes at a price. There are costs involved in investing in a fund. so a fund is simply a collective investment you pool your money with other investors it gets me more stuff and yeah and different stuff we've defined that before but I think it's just good to reiterate that especially beginning an episode all about it it would be yeah it would be remiss of us because if somebody hadn't listened to the previous one so yeah indeed so there are obviously thousands of funds to choose from where do you even go about I will take the piss where do you even go about oh we're carrying on yeah Yeah.
10:00Okay. You're going to piss about it. It's getting on the edit. Okay. There are thousands of funds to choose from. No, it's fine. So look, I always think choosing a fund, I actually done a video on Meaningful Money YouTube channel on this very recently. People sort of start with what fund should I buy? It's like, hang on, that's like decision number six, right? It's way down the list. It's important, but it's a long way down the list of what's really important. So if you're going to invest at all, you should always say, right, what's the intent? What do I want my money to do for me? here you've got to then work from there so you know from there comes on you know uh the kind of risk you might take um the time scale stuff like that so these are the questions you should be asking yourself jumping ahead a little bit but if you start with intent the rest kind of gets easier whereas if you start with like 20 000 funds on a sourcing website somewhere and you're just like how do I start with this?
10:56Does there have to be a set? Can the goal be just as simple as I want my money to grow? Yes, it can. Or does it have to be, this is for the house, this fund will be for this, this fund? You can over compartmentalise for sure. Most of us want our money to grow. Otherwise, why would we do it? But you should always really, I think, try to answer the question, to what end? Even if that's a really vague answer. Can it just be like security? Yes. I want a bigger number. I want a bigger number. Eventually, if that's always your answer, then you'll never be happy and you'll never be satisfied and you'll work your entire life.
11:35I will feel comfortable at X. Yes, totally. By such and such a time and date. That is legit, yeah. Most people will be like, well, I'd like to retire one day. So if you're talking about pension money, but not so much. In my eyes, I'm trying to think. This age, it's to build it. It's to get money. You've got stocks and shares at ISA. I do. You've had lifetime ISA. I haven't put much in my stocks and shares recently. Well, you're about to buy a house, so that's fine. And really, to this point, that's kind of been the target. Yeah. With that out of the way, it's going to be like, okay, we might want to size up one day.
12:16It might just be getting a bigger buffer between you and whatever the world throws at you. Emergency fund, obviously, is a start. but once that's done, you're like, well, actually, we're building financial freedom one day. And at your age, you never put a number on that. You never put a timescale on it because it's just, it's a big number and it's a long way in the future. And so to grow the money is a legitimate goal, no doubt. As long as that's not your goal. You know what I'm trying to... Yes, as long as that's not your only thing. It's like, I want as much money as possible. It's like, you'll never be happy.
12:47Go outside and smell the flowers. There's other things going on. Take your shoes off and walk on the grass. Yeah, exactly. Get in touch with nature. Before choosing a fund, what questions should you ask yourself? So a really important one, again, should you be investing at all? Because if it's like in your case, you've disinvested now, haven't you? Because the house purchase is imminent. Yeah, I didn't want my deposit to go to less than what I said I have. Yeah, right. Last thing you wanted is market crash before, you know, and suddenly instead of X, you've got X minus five grand. That would be great.
13:17That would be shit. So if you need the money in the foreseeable future, say the next two, three, four years, the question has to be, should you be investing at all? Or should you keep the money safe in the bank on deposit? All right. So the first question is, should you be investing at all? I think, obviously, yes, timescale matters, but it depends on the function. So for example, the next kind of big purchase I'll have to do is I'm going to need to size up my car. Yeah. But saving through an ice is not a bad way of doing that. No, for sure. But that's not like a life or death purchase that if it goes down, it's going to kill you.
13:48No, exactly. That's an important point. and you probably haven't got a rock solid timescale on it. And so in the absence of that, you just want, yeah, I want the money to work. Yeah. Because if it's five years, you'll wish you had invested. Yeah. Because otherwise you would have missed out on it. If it's two, it's like, well, I didn't very much, but hey, at least it didn't do nothing. Yes, exactly. So timescale is important. Risk, we've done previous episodes on risk. And, you know, it's such a kind of fluffy, difficult to pin down thing. risk so we generally start with people's kind of innate risk tolerance which is hard to measure and different to capacity yes well done but it's hard if you've never invested before to know that stuff you can answer the questions but it's like well okay i'm answering this stuff with no frame of reference so is it quite not quite a good idea because that sounds like advice but is it you know, to start investing, to work out your tolerance, to sort of go fairly run of the mill, maybe on the more cautious side.
14:52I'd go the other side of run of the mill if I was starting out. On the slightly more volatile side and then go, oh, I'm constantly checking it, not so good with that, dial it back, or actually I'm totally fine, I can even afford to go up a bit more in terms of risk. Yeah, you can't learn this stuff in the abstract, unfortunately. you can learn about it. And plenty of people will say, well, you need to sort of go on a thought experiment. You know, if it went from 10 ,000 quid down to eight, how would you feel? And the answer is you don't know. And I think risk tolerance, we have a kind of baseline for risk tolerance and you kind of learn that by doing.
15:25But also I'm a big proponent of kind of flexing risk up and down based on timescale. So some of your age investing for retirement should be like a full out 100 % equities. It doesn't matter what the market does because you've got 30 years before you can touch it, 35 years. So just let the markets do their thing because you know over those timescales, you will multiple times your money. No doubt about that. But a big holiday in five years' time, you wouldn't take maybe quite that level of risk because you might want to just dive back the volatility a little bit. So risk is both innate, but it's really hard to know what that is except for by doing, and it's also linked to timescale, I think.
16:06So these are the things you need to be asking yourself. Okay. The next section is called understanding the mechanics. And I have a question here that says, what do I need to know about how funds work? And you've written four bullet points here, none of which are words. No, they're triggers for me. All of them are acronyms. Pretty much. So let's dial up the wankiness. Here we go. Bullet point one. It's written O-E-I-C. Is that what you all call OICs? We call them OICs. So there are a few different kinds of funds, right? People don't need to lose sleep over this, but it's pretty important, I think, that they at least have a broad handle on it.
16:42Right. So most funds by far are OICs. It stands for Open-Ended Investment Company, but that doesn't matter. What makes an OIC an OIC is that the fund company, if somebody new wants to invest, they simply create more shares in the fund. So the number of shares available at any one time is open-ended. So if you want to put some money in, they'll make some shares just for you, Kate. Aww. Right? And when you sell your money, they'll destroy them. Yeah. When you sell out the shares, they'll just destroy them, right? Destroy them or give them to someone else when they buy them? A bit of both, potentially.
17:15What does it mean by destroy them? Just cancel them. They stop existing. And therefore, everybody else's that they own in that company go up slightly. Well, this is the point of an open-ended, right? And it's as opposed to, which we'll get to, investment trusts in a minute, which are closed-ended. If you're a company that people can invest into through OICs, can the fund manager just break up the company into as many shares as they want? No, no. It's not the company shares that are increased. It's the fund. So, you know, if you've got, say, you've got 10 investors, right, and they've got 100 grand each in.
17:50There's a million quid invested in that fund. And then you have somebody else who wants to invest another 100 grand. We've now got 11 investors. But the same amount of... Well, on a closed-ended fund, one of the existing investors would have to want to sell. Yes, because they needed to stay at the 10. Yes, but on an open-ended fund, they would just create more shares for the new investor. But we're not diluting anybody else's shares. So how do they do that? They press some keys on a keyboard. It's all digital. Just more appear? Yeah. From where? I really wouldn't lose any sleepover again. Right.
18:29But I'm like, where did... Okay, right. This is the clarification I need then. How is it not shares in a company? So the fund buys shares in the company. So you buy shares in a fund. The fund is essentially, it's an entity. All you own is shares in the company. Your money goes in... Sorry, shares in the fund. Your money goes into the fund and the fund manager says, I'm going to take that money and buy shares in Vodafone and Tesla and Apple, right? But they don't control how many shares Apple have in issue. They just buy any that are available. But the fund is what you own. You indirectly own the companies.
19:07So it's the fund is the mechanism. So what happens if the company goes bust? Company? Company goes bust. Well, then the value of the fund will fall because it owns the company. Right. I think I'm with you. Yeah, it is. I'm looking forward to Has Kate got it later on. Shit, I forgot about that. I could almost hesitate to say this and now I'm questioning my life choices. But the great thing about open-ended funds is that they're super flexible and they're super liquid. And that means you can get in and out really easily. Okay. You can sell your shares really easily and get your cash back. Because you don't have to wait for a buyer.
19:45With a closed-ended fund, like an investment trust, IT, it's the third bullet point here, right? An investment trust is closed-ended. So if I want to buy some shares in an investment trust, there has to be somebody willing to sell. And that's what a market is for, to match buyers and sellers. And so if you wanted to sell, you have to wait. But there was no buyer, then you can't sell. You're stuck in that fund. Gotcha. Right? So we've got Oikes. Open-ended investment company. Pigs. What? Oik. Oh, Oik. Yeah. Okay. And ITs, investment trusts. Which are closed. they're closed ended yeah um kikes no no investment trust just call them my teeth closed ended kicks yeah yeah look they're closed ended so everything we've said yeah you know if you're going to buy there has to be a seller if you want to sell there has to be a buyer um that structure is also as it happens an investment trust can borrow to invest so not only can they take your money as an investor they can borrow from a bank and double down on their investments that adds an element of risk because it can go in both ways because if the investment goes wrong not only do they owe you the investor they also owe the bank so it's just wouldn't want to be them well not if it goes badly but that's what they're paid for to get that stuff right okay they don't always but that's what they're paid for so to be honest not that many people So investment trusts are kind of advanced level, right?
21:18OICs are by far the most available. The other one that everybody that's even looked at this briefly will have heard of is an ETF. Yes. Exchange Traded Fund. OICs are priced once a day. So if you want to buy a fund, right, and you've got 100 quid, right, and they're a pound a share, you'll have 100 shares. But if they're two pounds a share, you'll only get 50 shares. Sure. So the fund share price moves, but it only moves once a day. Right. Don't ask why. Forward pricing, it's called. And basically, the fund sets its price once a day. Whereas, if you want to buy shares in a company, let's say Apple or Vodafone or whatever, their share price moves throughout the day.
22:01You've seen the charts, right? They go up and down throughout the day. Markets continually moving. What is that, like hourly updates or? By the millisecond. it's continual you know from whenever the market opens 8.30 till 4.30 literally by the millisecond in fact traders have moved their data centres like 500km closer to New York because it saves them 3ms on trading time I kid you not is this the whole like when people are yelling each other waving papers around on the phone it used to be like that now it's bots now it's algorithmic trading it's all electronic but it used to be the yelling in the thing yeah and people were like holding three phones to their ears and waving bits of paper and chucking paper airplanes at each other I don't know how they didn't all have like aneurysms well quite a lot of them did I think a lot of them died young, stressful yeah so now it's mostly digital and because of that less aneurysms well three millisecond could make you a million quid because the price will move in those three milliseconds but honestly for people listening to this you don't worry about that that's the big finance stuff Oh, right, so you pick a good time, but actually, if it's to the millisecond, you're never going to know.
23:11Oikes are traded once a day, you get the price in one day. ETFs behave like shares, their price moves throughout the day. Don't matter why, they just do. So ETFs behave a little bit more like shares, but they essentially do the same thing. All these are pooled investments, like we talked about right at the beginning. Just different mechanisms. The fourth bullet point on here, which I think people need to understand, is that there is a difference between accumulation and income or distribution. So very often on a fund, you'll see ACK, A-C-C at the end, or INC or DIS. And INC and DIS are the same thing.
23:45Income or distribution. Distribution is another word for income. So a fund owns shares in companies. Companies do well. They make a profit. They issue a dividend. It's an income to their shareholder investors, right? Well, if you own shares through a fund, it's the fund that gets the dividend, right? but surely they've got to give that to their yes exactly so an accumulation fund what happens is the when a dividend comes in it increases the price of each share just bear with me right so let's say well that makes sense because it's gone up in value it's well there's more money in the fund now yes exactly because they've had the dividend Yes, so...
24:34Thus, the share is worth more. Yes, so the good job, right? An income fund, instead of the share being worth more, it creates more units. So the price stays the same, but now you hold slightly more of them. Same net result. And that's in an income one? In an income slash distribution, yeah. Let me guess, accumulation one, the value of your share goes up? Yes. Gotcha. So, yeah, right? God, I'm working hard here. I think my brain is looking like it's got a six-pack. Yeah. Yeah, we have Nurofen for when we finish recording. Not sponsored. Other brands of... Other painkillers are available. I'll take any of them.
25:11Yeah, anyway. So, you know, these are just mechanics, but I feel like you're going to come across these terms and these are the sort of things that can make people just go, oh, I don't know what that means, I'm not going to do anything. To be honest, OIC or ETF is fine. Either is fine, it doesn't really matter. And when people are picking them, they might have ACC or INC. While you're building wealth, for the most part, Certainly if it's a pension, certainly if it's an ISO, go for ACK. It just makes life easier. Don't worry too much about why. But we know why, what they mean. Okay, so sometimes you see when you're picking them, the phrase is actively managed and passively managed, and I've heard that in Jackson's too.
25:44What does it mean? What are the differences? A favourite topic of mine. We're quite a way in already, so. Yeah, well, yes, we are. We're nearly 30 minutes in. We've gone a long way to go. This might become two episodes. Well, in fairness, it's because I've asked loads of questions off script, but I needed to to understand. That's why I'm here. So I'm assuming that the audience, I am the vessel of the audience. You are, exactly. So, yes, active versus passive, favourite subject. Yeah. One of my favourite subjects. So, we talked about when you're investing in a fund, you're pulling your money with other people.
26:18There is a fund manager involved, right? Their job is to run the fund. They're the name of the fund, I guess. Well, usually it's a human. So you might choose, for example, the Fidelity XYZ fund, right? Fidelity, let's say UK income fund. And there will be a manager, a name, a person, right? Usually extremely well paid. And their job is to buy and sell stuff according to the intent of the fund. So in that case, Fidelity is the company. It's a UK income fund. So the whole point of that fund is to invest in UK stocks that produce a good income. Their job is to find which stocks to buy. Now, let's just say we're going to invest in the XYZ FTSE 100 fund.
27:05Which? That's an index of the 100 biggest companies registered in the UK. Yes. Let's just say you want to invest in the FTSE 100. So we've got the XYZ FTSE 100 fund, and that is an active fund. The manager of that fund will look at the 100 available companies that they can invest in. and say, which of these do I think are going to win? Which do I think of these are going to go up? Which do I think are not in a good place and are probably going to go down? Let's just say they identify 30 out of the 100 possible companies in the FTSE 100. They split your money in whatever weight they want against those top 30.
27:45They have made an active choice as to which shares to buy. The whole point of that is for them to outperform the FTSE 100 as a whole, the index. Okay. And the index is the collection of those hundred companies and the sort of combined value of them all. So the whole point of paying a fund manager is to beat the market that they are investing in. Otherwise, that's the point. Well, the point is the alternative is passive investing, sometimes called index investing or focus investing. and a passive investor will buy all 100 companies in the FTSE 100, irrespective of which they think are going to go up or down.
28:29So the pros of that would be that it probably averages out. The cons of that is you could be putting more money in the successful ones, but it's harder to predict what the successful ones are going to be. Ding, ding, ding, ding. Exactly right. it's really hard. In fact, it's impossible to predict which ones are going to do well. And the stats on this are ridiculous. So the active investing, while seems logical, pay the clever person with knowledge and experience to guess which will be best. But the stats are that only about one in ten of those do it consistently. So you've got a 90 % chance of choosing the wrong manager.
Read the full transcript
29:06In which case, averaging it out by just picking them all and having less across them, but at least all your bases are covered. Yes, it removes the risk of the manager making bad decisions. That's why we call it passive. There's not a lot of decision-making going on. That's what Jackson's does, isn't it? Yes. Yeah. So we believe in, I think I said focus investing earlier on, index investing is what I meant to say. Oh, did I? Yeah, index investing. So we just think that makes sense, and the vast majority of the evidence shows that. There are a few debates in financial services that get people riled up because we like to get excited about sort of stuff that doesn't really matter.
29:41but active versus passive investing is something that really riles people up um in what way well very often people have got an agenda you know needless to say active fund managers have got plenty of really good arguments against passive investing and vice versa sure but all the in i don't say all that's an oversimplification the vast majority of independent research shows that for most ordinary investors passive investing wins hands down you know just because it removes, to me, it removes the risk of choosing the wrong fund manager. If you wanted to invest in the 40-100, there might be 50 or 100 different fund managers trying to do that.
30:21And surely some of them will have their own biases and their own... Yeah, yeah. And that's okay. That's what you're paying them for. But are they right or not? But is there such a thing as right before it happens? Well, right is outperformance, I guess, isn't it? Yeah. So they might have their own biases and convictions, but if they buy stuff which goes down, you know, Whereas the index itself goes up, it doesn't matter how convicted they are about it. It's a bit of a fail, really. Okay. So I am unequivocal on this. For most of us, index investing is the way to go. And one of the reasons why is those fund managers are really, really well paid.
30:58And so an active fund might cost you anywhere from three to ten times the annual cost. Because they need to be paying the fund managers. Because those people are going to be paid. They get big bonuses. All right? Whereas a passive fund... Big bonuses for a 10 % success rate. Yes, essentially. I'm in the wrong career. Yeah, it's not fair. Educated guesswork, and I get thousands of pounds for it. Yeah, they're not even doing most of it. They've got teams of analysts. I may get some flack for this, but honestly, I don't know why anybody would invest in an active fund. Well, there you go. We personally would pick passive, so do Jackson's, but you do your own research.
31:39Yeah, nicely. so what should people look for when comparing funds is there like i mean we've obviously said buzzwords you know look for the acc and if you want passive or active is there anything that's like oh golden like ticket oh look for that that's good no so damn it yeah i'm not surprised your important words were uh when comparing funds so let's say you're right i'm investing money that I don't need for at least 10 years. So I can push it pretty hard and I can largely forget about it, get it invested, add to it every month and just let it go. So now I've kind of decided that and let's just say you decide I'm going to invest globally, global equities, right, global shares.
32:25Well, I mean, it's probably like, I don't know, 1 ,500 global equity funds, if not more than that. So where do you start then? Yeah. And so the biggest, the first thing people look for is performance, right? And every comparison site, my favorite is pickafund.com. Brilliant. It's free. Really good. We'll put that in the show notes. Definitely. Pickafund.com, superb. I know the guys who are building that. They're doing great work. So, pickafund. So, you know, comparison sites and also the investment providers themselves, they'll say, here's our performance over three months, six months, a year, three years, five years, ten years, since inception.
33:08Every one of those figures, firstly in the abstract, it's meaningless because it's like compared with what? Remember, benchmarks, they're irrelevant because you can pick whatever benchmark you want. So that right at the start. But comparing with their peers is a bit more interesting. Yeah, you can see, okay, yeah, they're all growing, but that one's growing at a much higher, more consistent rate. Yeah, so if it's an active fund, has the fund manager made a lot of better decisions than the fund that's underperformed? You've got to think probably yes. Here's a question. Okay. You're with an active fund.
33:41There is a fund manager. Yes. Let's call her Nancy. Okay. Nancy, the fund manager. She's very well paid. Yeah. I wanted to make her a woman because she's a lot of women in finance, and that's great, but I do hate her a little bit. So she's doing a wonderful job, and I've decided to invest in that fund because I've seen that over the last six years she's done brilliant stuff, and she's trailblazing, and it's doing really, really well. Nancy goes on mat leave, or Nancy buggers off. Yes, goes to another fund manager for a bigger bonus. And Simone comes in. Am I, as someone who's gone into that fund, told that the fund manager's changed?
34:20And am I given the option to leave? You've always got the option to leave, and you would be told, but it's whether you'd read the fan-out email, which is just one of many in your interest. Because what if Simone is rubbish? What if Simone is great? Well, it'll take you a while to find that out, won't it? Probably. Yeah, true. Because it'll take a while for Simone to get her feet under the table and really get going with the rubbish decisions. So it'll take a while. And the problem is all performance figures are lagging. They're in the past. And on every single piece of investment literature you'll ever read is the same line.
34:54Worst to the effect of, past performance is no guide to future performance. Which is obviously true. Yeah, but that is, I guess, the risk you're taking, especially if you go into an actively managed fund having looked at, wow, this person's on it. Look, history is littered with star fund managers, in inverted commas, where people just chuck money at these people, right? Who go, at best, go off the boil. So they've been brilliant performers and then suddenly they're not. Suddenly their particular method of investing doesn't do well in current market conditions. Market conditions don't give a shit about you or the investment managers, right?
35:30They, it will do what it does. Yeah, right? So maybe Nancy goes off the boil. Maybe she leaves, you know, Maybe she decides to rear chickens in Pembrokeshire or something. She's probably got the money for it. Well, exactly. She's made enough before she's 35. Probably she can do that. But what happens then? Your money is in there. You've always got the option to move. But my experience is that most people are not so hands-on with their money that they're going to be on top of stuff like that. So they're three years later and they're still in that fund and they're wondering why it's not done so well.
36:02so that is another reason to my mind in favor of passive investing because it doesn't really matter who's in charge it's you know because mostly it's algorithm it's the computer doing it i've come into some flack for in the past for saying that but you know it's not like the whole thing turns on one person's decisions it's much more consensus and it's much more pattern and algorithmic based yes it's based on one person when you average out yeah so it doesn't really matter who's in charge, that person can go to Pembrokeshire and raise chickens because somebody else because the fund will continue as it was.
36:38That makes sense. And like you say, for people who are less active it's a poor choice of word in this sense. Less involved in their finances which I'd probably say the most of us are. And should be. Honestly, it's a bit sad if you're watching this stuff every day and really excited about it. Some people will be, but I know I'm not. I'm the world's laziest investor. so I think I would rather just pick something that I can for the most part fire and forget just let it get on and that's what I love about passive investing so I think you're right I do think we need to wrap this up so we'll make this a two-parter yeah I think so 40 minutes in but clearly I've needed to ask you lots of extra questions off the cuff to get an understanding there is one more on this section though and thus I was getting there let's get to the last question of the section that was basically what I was going to do fees yeah yeah now they get talked about a lot do they really matter?
37:31Fees is one of the comparables. The last question, which we kind of, maybe I got a bit sidetracked is, you know, what do people look for when comparing funds? Most people look at performance, that's in the past. And there's a million reasons why performance can be good or bad. All right. Fees is another one. Yeah. And it is important. So if you are paying, let's say, three quarters of a percent of your investment per year to a fund manager that's going to add up as opposed to 0.1 percent say right a passive funds often cheaper oh yes significantly right an active fund can be anywhere from three to ten times the annual cost of a passive fund it's material so you know fees are important because every pound you pay to your fund manager is a that you can't spend yourself and can't compound for your future.
38:24So costs are really important. But it is possible to, like everything, overanalyze and get buried in and you spend, like, weeks trying to save 0.01%. Yeah. To be honest, that doesn't matter. But 0.02 versus 0.75, drastic. 0.02 versus 0.0198. Yeah, no, exactly. Totally not worth worrying about. It's like people who continually move in savings accounts to get another 0.2 % interest. It's like, do it if you want. but I it's too much fat for me so fees are important they definitely matter the longer you're investing over because you've got longer to compound and work against you in this case so I think fees are important next week I think we'll talk about avoiding mistakes and we'll talk about putting it into practice next week I think honestly this has been understanding it more yeah really important covered a lot of ground actually I thought I knew what funds were but we ended up you know Kate had to do some learning then yeah and I wonder whether we defer whether you've got it to next week because this is going to be we can if you want what do I do difference between ACK and Inc this is a hard question okay now I can do this when the company earns a profit one of the ways it can deal with that money is to pay its shareholders dividends yes when the fund if the fund is the share owner they get the dividend correct an accumulation fund means that the money that they've that the fund has received through the dividend the shares value individual value increases yes exactly right what's the other word ink income income one that means the shares value stays the same but the quantity of shares increases perfect well done that's quite a distinction can you remember what Ike stands for?
40:22open ended investment companies yep good effort can you feel I feel like the mic will be picking up the ticking the vein in your head pulsing no Ben does talk about my stress vein is it out is it on full show no no no no it's not visible anyway makeup's got a lot no makeup can't this protrudes wow No, definitely not protruding. Which actually should be concerning if Ben spotted it. Maybe he's the one causing the stress. Whereas here you're nicely relaxed, I think. Just a quick distinction between active and passive. Okay.
41:01Actively managed funds have a person whose sole job is to look at the shares that they're going to buy and that would fit the goal of the fund and predict which might do best and thus only focus on those. Yes. A passive one will take all the options. There's no set person. Not really. Okay. A passive one will take all the options and spread it across all of them so that averages it out. Yeah, basically. Which one is successful, which one. With active investing, the manager's looking for the individual investments to outperform. With passive investing, you're essentially buying... Averages. Sectors.
41:44Yeah. So you might be saying, I'm buying global equities, like every company in the world, or UK equities, or EU, or Japan, or whatever. What am I? Or I'm buying, you're a global equities. I'm global, aren't I? Yeah, you were actually, you were 80%. I'm 80 % equities, 20 % bonds, right? Yes. Yeah. I think. Right. And bonds are just another thing you buy. So an active bond fund, the manager is looking for the best bonds. Yeah, but we're going to do a bond episode because they started to confuse me. Yeah, they confuse most people, so. Okay, that makes me feel a bit better. So we've covered a lot of mechanics there.
42:14Hold on, Andy, you've got it. That's definitely a ding, ding, ding. Do you know what? I'm quite proud of myself. You should be. Because it's quite... It's late afternoon on a Monday. Mm-hmm. We only came... This is my third day back at work, and it has been all systems go with Jackson stuff, hasn't it? So I'm actually really quite proud of myself. Yeah, good job. If I say so myself. But thank you so much for watching. Hopefully, you started to gain a bit more of a wider understanding of funds. I know I have. Because she's got it. because I've got it and all the various letters and acronyms that it entails.
42:46But we are going to continue this discussion on another, the next episode we'll be continuing this because otherwise it'll be like a two hour long episode and nobody wants that. Nobody wants that. So stick around for next week when we carry that on. Whilst you're here, please like and subscribe if you're watching on YouTube and if you're listening to us on whatever podcast app you use, feel free if you want to drop us a rating leave us any comments both constructive criticism or positive feedback we take it all on board definitely do if you've got any questions questions are really starting to come in now we've already probably got enough from the Q &A so send us some easy ways on email so hello at bankofdad.show and just put the subject line podcast question because we love those Q &A episodes they're a lot of fun and it's the stuff that's important to you so send us any questions hello at bankofdad.show and use the subject line podcast question yes that's it isn't it we have mentioned a couple links oh yeah a meaningful money video the pick a fund so we will put all of those in these show notes which you can find at bankofdad.show forward slash episode 34 and yeah you can find all the sort of recommended reading on that little section there but for now I think that's everything and we will see you in the next one cheers
44:12Thank you.
From the publisher
This week, we're getting to grips with investment funds: what they are, how they work and what's actually going on when you put your money into one. We'll break down the basics, cut through some of the jargon and look at the mechanics you need to understand before you even think about choosing a fund.




