In short
Podcast Summary: Broken Record - Episode "Chicago"
Podcast Overview Hosts: Rick Rubin, Malcolm Gladwell, Bruce Headlam, Justin Richmond Description: Deep dives into the lives and inspirations of musicians, featuring candid discussions about their craft interspersed with music. Episode: Chicago Air Date: [Insert air date here]
---
Episode Description In this episode, the hosts celebrate the 50th anniversary of Chicago's landmark album "Chicago IX: Chicago's Greatest Hits." They explore the band's unique blend of brass, jazz, and rock, their early albums, and the innovative idea of including a horn section as a fundamental part of rock music. Bruce Headlam interviews Chicago members Lee Loughnane and Jimmy Pankow, discussing their creative process, experiences on the road, and the band's enduring legacy.
---
Key Points
Introduction to Chicago
- Debut Album: Released in 1969, Chicago combined brass elements with rock, differentiating them from other bands.
- Success: By 1975, Chicago IX became one of the best-selling albums of the decade, solidifying their legacy.
Interview Highlights
- Guests: Lee Loughnane and Jimmy Pankow share their insights on the band's formation and the role of the horn section.
- Formation of Chicago: Discusses how the band was formed at DePaul University with a democratic approach to decision-making.
- Innovative Sound:
- The band aimed to use horns not just as background instruments, but as a lead voice in their music.
- Early influences included the Beatles, jazz, and the R&B scene of the time.
Recording Experiences
- Recording Process:
- They described their early recording sessions in New York, often working late night shifts after Simon and Garfunkel.
- The challenges of isolating instruments in a studio with limited technology shaped their sound.
- Unique recording techniques included using a church for natural reverb.
The 50th Anniversary of Chicago IX
- Expanded Edition: Celebrating the release with additional tracks that showcase their musical evolution.
- Live Performances: Pankow and Loughnane reflect on their decades of touring, emphasizing the joy of performing for multiple generations of fans.
Musical Composition
- Songwriting Process:
- Members would bring in demos, and the collaborative effort would shape the final product.
- The discussion about "Make Me Smile" highlights its complex structure with key changes and intricate arrangements.
Legacy and Reflection
- Impact of Songs: The band acknowledges the timeless nature of their songs and their connection to fans.
- Personal Stories: Loughnane and Pankow share anecdotes about their lives and the music scene during their rise to fame, including encounters with iconic musicians like Jimi Hendrix and Janis Joplin.
---
Key Takeaways
- Musical Innovation: Chicago revolutionized the role of brass in rock music, making it a central element rather than just an accent.
- Collaboration: The band's success is attributed to their democratic approach and the blending of various musical influences.
- Enduring Legacy: The continued popularity of their music showcases how it resonates across generations, making Chicago an iconic name in rock history.
---
Closing Notes
- Listening Recommendations: The episode includes a link to a playlist of Chicago's songs and the newly released 50th-anniversary edition of their greatest hits.
- Future Engagement: Fans are encouraged to follow the podcast and connect on social media platforms for more musical insights.
For more information, visit the [Broken Record Podcast](https://www.brokenrecordpodcast.com).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:06Pushkin.
0:10When Chicago released their debut album in 1969, they, along with bands like Blood, Sweat and Tears, Sly and the Family Stone, and James Brown and James Brown and James Brown and the J. became one of the most commercially successful acts in American music history with a string of hits that remain staples of classic rock radio even today. By 1975, when Chicago 9, Chicago's Greatest Hits, arrived, the band had already amassed an extraordinary catalog of songs that captured both the experimental spirit of the late 60s with the pop sensibility of the 70s. That compilation became one of the best-selling albums of the decade.
0:54Now Chicago is celebrating the 50th anniversary of that landmark release with an expanded edition that offers fans a deeper look at this pivotal moment in the band's history. On today's episode, Bruce Hedlum talks to Lee Lachnane and Jimmy Panko of Chicago about recording their early albums. They also discuss what inspired them to incorporate a horn section into a rock band. And they explain why after decades of being on the road since the late 70s, they don't even bother to unpack their suitcases anymore. This is Broken Record. Real musicians, real conversations.
1:31This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. When you own your own business, you own every decision. Now own the card that rewards you for it. Chase Sapphire Reserve for Business is a pay-in-full card that elevates your travel experience and offers premium benefits that will take your business to the next level. Sapphire Reserve for Business offers 8x points on all purchases through Chase Travel, 3x points on social media and search engine advertising, airport lounge access, and more. With over$2 ,500 in annual value, it's the card that gives back all you put in. Learn more at chase.com forward slash reserve business.
2:11Chase for Business, make more of what's yours. Accounts subject to credit approval. Restrictions and limitations apply. Cards are issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank, and a member FDIC. You want your master's degree? You know you can earn it. But life gets busy. The packed schedule, the late nights, and then there's the unexpected. American Public University was built for all of it. With monthly starts and no set login times, APUs, 40-plus flexible online master's programs are designed to move at the speed of life. Start your master's journey today at apu.apus.edu. You want it? Come get it at APU. When it comes to the holidays, I believe you fall into one of two camps.
2:53Someone who loves holiday music or someone who won't admit they love holiday music. There's something about a voice you love singing a familiar opening phrase, maybe it's Donny Hathaway, maybe it's Mariah Carey, that just flips a switch and you instantly back into that warm and cozy headspace only the holidays can bring. For me, that feeling pairs perfectly with a cup of Starbucks Caramel Brulee Latte. That's their signature espresso with steamed milk and a rich Caramel Brulee flavor topped with whipped cream and a crunchy Caramel Brulee topping. It's like the sound of the season, but in drink form.
3:25And that's really what this season's about. Because this season and every season together is the best place to be. Come together over your favorite holiday favorites at Starbucks. Here's Bruce Hedlum with Lee Lachnane and Jimmy Panko of Chicago. We have Lee Lachnane. Yes. And Jimmy Panko. Hello, everybody. Two of the original members of the great band Chicago, two composers, arrangers, but I think most importantly, two members of the brass section. Because that is what really drove so much of that. The rock and roll band with the horns. With the horns. He actually hid one of the greatest guitar players away from being top ten.
4:09Recognized as a great guitar player? I think people recognize him. Well, they recognize him, but it was really, he came in second to the brass when we were really up there, popularity-wise. And I do want to mention the third member of the original brass. Yes, Walter. Oh, Walt Perzader. I feel he's here in spirit. Yes. so we can talk about all these great songs. We miss him. He was a big part of this. He actually came up with the idea that wound up becoming Chicago. We were students at DePaul University and Walt and Danny Serafin and Terry Kath were members of a club act that were working in Chicago, which were kind of on the way out.
4:55And Walt knew Lee and I at DePaul University and he approached us with this, hey, you guys, what do you think about this idea? Because we used to go to the Pussycat and sit in with them. They were called the Missing Links. And Lee and I would show up every now and then. I played a few gigs with them. Yeah. What kind of music would they play? Top 40. Yeah. Yeah. Everybody that played, we played Top 40 when we were a club act before we left to go to California to make records. But he approached us with this idea, What do you guys think about a rock and roll group with a horn section that's like a main character?
5:35How can we do that? We were thinking of going to Vegas and playing those side clubs rather than the big rooms. And somebody told me that he got that idea from a Beatles song, Got to Get You Into My Life. Is that true? I don't know. I don't know. We did a cover of Got to Get You Into My Life in the clubs, as well as Magical Mystery Tour, Little Help From My Friends. He pointed at me because I played bass on Little Help From My Friends. Yes, you did. Boo, boo, boo, boo. Now, is it true he said from the beginning, it'll be a democracy? Yes. Well, we all thought the same thing. We just shook hands and went, let's do this until we can.
6:20Yeah, we met at Walt's apartment and agreed to devote all our energy and time to this idea. And, you know, we committed. We stuck with it. Yeah. And he said you can only leave two ways. You ask out or you die. Is that right? Yeah. Yeah. A little final for me. Yeah, yeah. Well, I'll want a decision by the end of the podcast for both of you guys. That's right. What are you going to do next? Yeah. So you are in New York. You're a Chicago band. You made your bones in L.A. But New York is where you recorded, I think, your first two albums? Yeah. Did you have fond memories of New York? CBS 52nd Street.
6:56Oh, it was the 52nd? What kind of studio was that? It was a multi-story office building, and they had several studios on several floors. And we flew in New York. We had the 12-day shift, and Simon and Garfunkel had the day. Yeah, we were the new guys, so they gave us the graveyard shift. Simon and Garfunkel recorded all day, and then we started recording at midnight and wound up going back to the hotel. The only people on the street were the garbage trucks. Go back to the hotel with a triple-decker sandwich, and you were good to go. Oh, yeah, the stage deli. Oh, yeah. And did you meet with Simon and Garfunkel while you were there?
7:38Did you say hi? No, actually, I never saw them. I met Art in the elevator. Really? Yeah. I was coming to work, and he was leaving. Yeah. Yeah, we just had kind of two ships in the night. But we did. Jimmy Garcia was producing us, and he got close to Roy Halley, who was producing Simon and Garfunkel, and they traded notes. And Roy actually came down and assisted in some of the recording techniques. No kidding. Yeah, he added some of his expertise. He also knew the board at CBS. very well. Well, he knew the board, but he wasn't ready for rookies to come in. He left the project pretty quickly because we were learning how to record.
8:28We knew how to play these songs backwards and forwards because we'd been working with them in the various clubs that we played, but we had to learn how to record, how far to stand away from them, being worried about, oh my god, I can't make a mistake because this microphone, this thing is in my way here. Yeah, it was quite intimidating, you know, and I say this, you know, in performance, knowing that this was gone on tape forever, we better do this right. But you had producers to set up the room. Oh, sure. But still it took a lot of figuring it out. It's just a matter of the actual playing the instrument to that thing and then going into the control room and listening to it back and going, oh, so I have to step back a little bit on this to do a better blend, a natural blend.
9:19I mean, they can do it electronically and with everything inside the control room, but it's better if we control ourselves. We kind of had to mix ourselves in the room to get the right blend in the section. Especially when you do an overdub. Now, when you recorded back then, would you do the rhythm tracks first? Would you do the piano and then add the horns? Well, it was a progressive process. We actually started recording with the whole band in the room. We live tracked. then we realized that we needed to isolate things because if somebody wouldn't say it was audible on every instrument we were doing isolation already we had stuff in between us so it would lessen that problem but we were able to record with the brass because we were going to play the same notes on the song so when we did it on our own the bleed through wasn't going to matter But, you know, interestingly enough, you know, the technology wasn't available in those days.
10:25We recorded on eight tracks, and they only had so much they could do with so little room. So we utilized various rooms. We actually recorded, does anybody really time it as an introduction, in the church. They used a cathedral downtown, I don't know which one, with a high ceiling. and it created a natural room echo that we couldn't get on the board because we didn't have the technology. So we used the church. That's why those cuts on Chicago Transit Authority had that big room sound because of the nature of the room that we recorded in. How many of those tracks did you record at the church? I don't remember.
11:15I know we did those two. We might have done questions there, too. I think we did. Yeah. We did a few scenes. But Simon and Garfunkel, you know, got busy and busy and busier, and we went to a smaller room on the second floor. It was Studio B, and we had to, you know, kind of re-approach everything all over again because it was a different parameter in terms of acoustics. I remember on Make Me Smile, Gershio had me go in the bathroom. They ran a mic cable to the bathroom, and I was whacking the toilet seat with a newspaper to fatten the snare. Oh, yeah. I mean, we used tricks like that. Once you had, yeah.
12:02You can get away with a lot of stuff, and it's just creative. We should do business first before we talk anymore. And the business is? The business is, you put out one of the best-selling greatest hits collections of all time, which was Chicago 9. All right. And if you like, the songs on it are just all these incredible classics. You're re-releasing a new version. Yeah, it's... It's the 50th anniversary. 50th anniversary. Yep. It's a re-release of the greatest hits with 21 tracks. The original was 11, I think. Yeah. Yeah. And we threw a bunch more songs on the re-release, including the first eight albums and then even some cuts from Chicago 10, which follows.
12:50Yeah. Do you listen to the remixes? Do you like what you hear? Sure. You know, the thing is that we've heard them so many times. and when we play them live now, when we go back and listen to, at least when I go back and listen to the original recordings, I realize how much we have developed the songs even further through the years. It's amazing to me that it's not quite exactly the same as what it was when we recorded it. We're doing some different harmonies, we're doing a little different breaks. you know it's just interesting. Is that planned? Did someone say you know something? It was organic.
13:32I also want to mention this is your 58th consecutive year of touring which is staggering. You've toured every year. Every year. Even through COVID. Even through COVID. We worked the first two months of COVID up until we were working in Las Vegas. We were the last band on the strip. Oh really? Yeah. That's right. Rod Stewart was at the Coliseum, and we were at the Venetian. And it was Saturday night, March 16th or 17th. I think it was the 16th, yeah. Yeah. And I got in the car to fly home the next Sunday morning. The driver turned around, looked at me, and he said, good thing you're leaving. Vegas is going down to 5 % occupancy tomorrow.
14:18It's going to be a ghost town. Wow. So we got the heck out of town. but it was pretty wild. It was very weird. And we actually thought we were going to go back to work real quick, that it was going to be two or three weeks, and hey, we're back. Do you remember, was there something odd about that last show? Were people already talking and thinking about COVID? For us, it was business as usual. Yeah, same thing. We just planned a show. That was, yeah, and then next thing you know, we were off the road. Everybody was off the road. It was a complete shutdown. But we were one of the first people to go back.
14:53What, June of 20? We went back. June of 21. We were off for a whole 15 months. Oh, yeah. Right. Okay. So we worked each year. We worked the beginning of the year in 2020, and then the world shut down. And then we came back as soon as we possibly could. We kept trying to go back on the road, but nobody was opening up their buildings. Yeah, but being home that long was strange because we were never home that long. Other than COVID, what is the longest time you took away from the road as manned? Probably six months. Really? Really. It just never gets tired? I stopped unpacking. Yeah. I'm always back.
15:38Yeah, me too. I take the dirty clothes out, clean them, put them back in the bag. Yeah, exactly. And then wait to leave. We're like firemen, you know. We're always ready to go to the next fire. or slide down the pole. That's right. When the Chicago signal goes off in the sky, you guys are... Yeah, exactly. That's it. And they're still coming. We're sold out every night. It's a phenomenon we never, ever expected. You see four generations in the audience, and they're all grooving on their own level. That's amazing. Okay, I'm going to do something that I never do, because you were just mentioning that first album.
16:16To the selfie? I'm not going to. I've never done that. But no, I'm just going to play.
16:32I wanted to play to that last little, becomes a horn fill throughout the whole song. Just because that to me, if you could just play that five seconds to someone, they would just go. That is to me, that's Chicago. I can name that tune. You can name that tune. You can name that band. So now this was not a song you guys wrote. Robert wrote it. Robert Lamb wrote that, yes. And so because you had multiple composers, what was the process for introducing songs to the band? Did you have something formal? Did you all sit down? We just brought songs in. You do a demo, and you sing a rough guide lead into the tape machine with the piano part as you're singing it.
17:23That was the demo. Now it's a record. People are making records for demos. And I remember bringing, I wrote Just You and Me, and I brought it in. We were at Caribou Ranch. and the guys were all there and I brought the song in. Again, it was the cassette with, you are my love and my life, with acoustic piano. And we put it in the machine in the booth and everybody listened to it. I said, is this any good? And Robert looked at me and said, Jimmy, that's a hit song. I went, really? Yeah. And so I didn't know. It was a personal experience at the piano, Just like when Lee writes his songs, we would bring what we had into the room, and everybody kind of voted on it.
18:16And the song really didn't come alive until everybody in the band added their special magic to it individually. Well, this is what I'm interested in this song in particular, because to me it's such a great encapsulation of your music then. You had chord changes, key changes, tempo changes. I mean, everything is constantly moving. For example, the brass stuff, those brass, the stabs off the start, that great riff towards the end. Like, was that part of what Robert brought in? Or was that something you guys added? How did that work? Robert actually arranged his own horns back then. Is that right?
18:58Anybody really like time it is, beginnings, questions. Those are, no, I did questions. But he did beginnings. He did does anybody really like time it is. He did dialogue and quite a few others. And I kept in current, man, Robert, you arranged some great stuff, man. You should keep going with this. When he realized how difficult it was, he had Jimmy stick to him. Yeah, it's just killing me. That's right. Okay, so those were his ideas. That's amazing. Yeah, beginnings too. There were occasions that I had to come in and revoice things because he wasn't particularly adept at voicing because it wasn't his thing.
19:43So he'd write the charts, which are his arrangements, and I'd just revoice them to capture the essence of the section. So tell me what that means, revoicing it, in terms of the brass. You know, typically, you know, I kind of inherited the chair for creating this approach to the horns. And maybe because, you know, I play trombone, what I was hearing was a trombone lead. Shocking, isn't it? Yeah. So, you know, the trombone, because it's a baritone instrument and the trumpet and the sax are above it. If I voiced it by nature of the instrument, the disparity in the voices would not be cool. It wouldn't be—the equanimity of the voicing would not happen.
20:38You know, so I had to— You had to play up an octave, basically. Yeah, so the trombone is— He's the manard of Chicago. Yeah. The trombone is basically in the upper register for a lot of the charts, and the trumpet is in the middle, and then the sax is right there in the middle, between the trumpet and the trombone. So it tightens the voicing. Was the trumpet almost always on top? Well, there are times. Many times. The trumpet, yeah, it leaves upstairs too. Yeah, you know, it isn't always like that. But in terms of just the typical accompaniment with the vocals. Right. Yeah, the section is more tight.
21:19The voicing is tight, so it has more of a punch. You know, and then we overdub and we put the trumpet upstairs on the double and we put the, I do the pedals on the bone. Right. And we might play a wide triad, but then let the rhythm section play the color notes. Mm-hmm. The sevens, nines, thirteenths. The extensions. Yeah. Yeah. That's the conundrum when we're playing live. you have to pick there's only three of us okay and in live performance in the studio we had the luxury of overdubbing of molting so we could we could add all those extensions in the second take or even the third take sometimes we tripled if we wanted really a big sound right uh but live there's only three of us so it's very important to be economically precise you have to pick the just the right three voices to express the nature of the chord.
22:25If it's a seven chord or a nine chord, you're not going to just play the root and the third and the fifth. You need to play those extensions to paint the right colors of that extended chord. And you'd hope that the bass or somebody else was filling in that. Well, yeah, yeah. You leave the guts to the rhythm section. But you're saying sometimes you guys would play chord tones and leave the color notes to the rest of the band. Yeah. To me, that famous riff, Phil, at the end of what I just played, that's got the... Or the trombone? But it's got the... Is that the trumpet on top? Hitting the single note?
23:05Yes. And then there's the trombone and the sax are... Doing the walk. Yeah. Are they playing the same note or are they playing different notes? Different notes. Different notes? Okay. Were they in maybe thirds or something? They're playing thirds. I'm playing the top note. Ba, ba, ba, ba, ba, ba, ba, ba, ba, ba, ba. Yeah. Chord. Wow. Yeah. Wow. But this is the way Robert wanted it. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I got a kick out of his, a lot of his voicing I left alone because it was really great. Yeah. It's just simple to the point. I mean, I have to be honest, you know, beginnings, I mean, the alto trumpet line in beginning, I still, I get chills when I hear it.
23:56I love it. I mean, Robert wrote some great stuff. And then for you guys for playing, I mean, I know different groups, you know, string quartets, people are always looking at each other. There's a lot of body language to signal when you're coming in. And how did you guys learn to play so precisely together? We guessed. And we guessed right a lot. You know what, man? I got to tell you. A lot of times Jimmy would say, okay, this next time we're going to go, blah. We're going to like, we called it the grease. We're going to put the grease on the second note. And I would go, he's not going to put the grease on the second note.
24:33He's going to do it on the third note. So I'd do it on the third. And I would match. He does me too well. and he was I knew he wasn't going to do it how did you know he wasn't going to do it? I didn't for sure I just guessed right but you know the old adage the horn section is like one set of lungs we feel each other by its osmosis or something and you know I'll never forget it when we assembled for the first time in Walt's parents basement in Maywood, Illinois and we were playing James Brown stuff. I heard it. Papa's got a brand new band. Papa's got... I heard it. Immediately, I said, this is magic.
25:18You just knew you three guys were locked in. Yeah, I was, I mean, blown away. It was magic. I said, this is unbelievable. We'll be back with more from Lee Lachnain and Jimmy Panko after the break. This episode of Broken Record is brought to you by Chase Sapphire Reserve. Everybody loves to travel, right? We can get away as a once-in-a-lifetime vacation, all of it. And no matter where you're going, Chase Sapphire Reserve is your gateway to the world's most captivating destinations. Travel is its own reward, you know. You're out there having experiences you can't have any other way, and with your Chase Sapphire Reserve card, you're also being rewarded.
26:00You earn eight times points on all purchases through Chase Travel. So let's say you book a trip to Hawaii, you go surfing at Sunset Beach, you go hiking on a volcano, and you go out to dinner. With the Chase Sapphire Reserve card, you're actually earning points for going on a grand adventure anywhere you go, any trip you take. And that's not even mentioning how the card gets you into the Sapphire Lounge by the club at select airports nationwide and access to one-of-a-kind experiences like music festivals and sports events. Whether you're booking your next big trip or we can escape, Chase Sapphire Reserve makes travel more rewarding.
26:35Discover more with Chase Sapphire Reserve at chase.com slash sapphire reserve. Cards issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval. Terms apply. I firmly believe when it comes to the holidays, you fall into one of two camps. Someone who loves holiday music or someone who won't admit they love holiday music. There's something about a voice you love singing that familiar opening phrase. Maybe it's Donny Hathaway. Maybe it's Mariah Carey. that just flips a switch, and you're instantly back into that warm and cozy headspace only the holidays can bring. For me, that feeling pairs perfectly with a cup of Starbucks caramel brulee latte.
27:12That's their signature espresso with steamed milk and a rich caramel brulee flavor topped with whipped cream and a crunchy caramel brulee topping. It's like the sound of the season, but in drink form. And that's really what this season's about. Little moments of pairing, little moments of connection, sharing a song, sharing a story, sharing a caramel brulee latte, because this season and every season together is the best place to be. Come together over your holiday favorites at Starbucks.
27:42Every December, we start singing at church, around the fire, in our cars with the radio turned up. But have we ever stopped to ask, where did our favorite Christmas carols come from? And what makes them so magical? I think it's probably one of the most perfect tunes to play and to sing. The voices are converging. They're adding this more complex and chromatic harmony. And it gives us that climactic arrival point. Hark is a podcast about the meaning and the making of Christmas carols. Get into the spirit of the season and listen to Hark, the stories behind our favorite Christmas carols. Available now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at americamagazine.org.
Read the full transcript
28:33I want to take you back just a little bit further. Before you met, what, and I'll start with you, Lee, what were, how did music come into your life? We were playing with different bands. But even before that, you're... I played with a band called Ross and Majestics and the Shannon Show Band. And we played the Irish clubs in Chicago. We played like R &B, well, not R &B, country and Western songs, Irish dances and all kinds of stuff, you know. And was your family musical? Is that how you? My father was a trumpet player. Oh, is that right? Okay. Yeah. He was a band leader and he never actually left the States.
29:15He was a chief warrant officer in the Army Air Force when it was combined at the time. And he'd have all these players come through and then go to the front lines. Right. Did he play with a lot of military bands? I think he had stopped playing by that time. He was just the band leader. And these cats would come through and then he would let them go AWOL on the weekend.
29:44so anyway sorry no absolutely of course I'm the crybaby of the band by the way sentimental Irishman that's right well if you can't be sentimental about your father I don't see what you can't absolutely he was good to them then they'd go over and fight the war and hopefully come back but they were some of the greatest players out of the big bands you know, Tommy Dorsey and Jimmy Dorsey and Glenn Miller, all those bands. When they got drafted, they'd come through his band. Is that right? Mm-hmm. Did he have stories about them? He didn't like to tell the stories. He wanted to get away from it when he came home.
30:24Oh, okay. Yeah. And did you play in school? Did you do school bands? I played in school. I started in grade school. Yeah. 11 years old. Wow. And that was back when, in grade school, they walked you into a big room full of brass and said, Pick an instrument. Yep. There was a lot of that in schools. Well, he had played the trumpet, so that was the first choice. Yeah. And they just checked my teeth to make sure I wasn't going to harm myself. My lips were going to be a bloody mess by the time I got done. And it seemed to work out, so I've never stopped since. And then you went to college for music.
31:02Yes, DePaul University. That's where we met. And were your parents happy about that? Yeah, they weren't too happy when I decided to do this for a living. They were trying to talk me out of doing it. And because, you know, how many people make it? I was one of the lucky ones. We were a couple of the lucky ones. When did they finally accept that you'd made it? I'm not exactly sure, but when they started coming to shows and going, that's pretty good. Any day now? I mean, like when you mentioned, does anybody know what time it is? That was sort of a crossover from the big bands to modern rock and roll.
31:38And then what were your, were you influenced by big bands growing up? Oh, yeah. Yeah, because my dad had all those records. I used to attempt to play along with them. You guys aren't unique. They're Blood, Sweat, and Tears. Other bands would have bigger horn. James Brown, I think, had a trombone. But not a lot of bands had your sound. Sly and the Family Stone had a trumpet. Well, the brass was always a background instrument in all the other bands. We were a lead voice. We became a lead voice. And our approach is melodic. Yeah. Whereas a typical horn section is harmonic and frosting on the cake.
32:20And more percussive. We are a lead voice. We are a melodic horn section that interplays in and around what the lead vocal is doing. so it becomes intrinsic in the song. If you take the brass out, there's empty spaces. Were there models for that that you listened to? No, I just arranged what I heard. I wanted the section to be a lead voice, and that wasn't just bop, bop, bop, bop, bop, not shots. Yeah. Do-do-do-da, ba-ba-da-da, ba-da-do-da-da-da, you are my... Seamless. Right. And that's kind of the approach we do because if you take it away, you know, there's something missing. Maybe subconsciously it was job security.
33:09I don't know. But, you know, we just felt it out. Interesting that you say job security because there are people now who, for whatever reasons, they have decided that they are not going to listen to what is popular. And then 20 years later, they're grown up and they decide to listen to Chicago Transit Authority for the first time and then give a reaction, reaction videos. And they inevitably ask if the horn players are part of the band, you know, thinking that it's too big. Or are they even real horns? Yeah. Well, I mean, they had to have been real horns because there was no electronic instruments to be able to play them back then.
33:56You know, and again, there was no comparative. We invented this. This approach became our signature. It does remind me at times a little bit of, he didn't have a vocalist, but like the Mingus band sometimes. Were you guys influenced at all by? Oh, absolutely. I was a jazz guy, you know, and I brought that to the table. And Lee was in his bands. I had my own quintet. It was modeled after the Crusaders, if you will, Cannonball Adderley. We were doing jazz covers, you know, milestones, jive samba, and our repertoire kind of evolved into jazz rock, funk. I started, you know, experimenting with more contemporary motifs.
34:49So when I became part of our thing, I started there, and then now away, I have a vocal group to work with. I have a rhythm section that is rock and roll to work with. I mean, Terry Kath blew me away. I mean, you know, he was brilliant. And Terry couldn't read music. So he helped me help him and vice versa. I sat with him for hours because introduction, which is the first cut on Chicago Transit Authority, is an incredibly intricate piece. I mean, there's every time signature and key change. I mean, Terry was going for the throat, but he didn't know how to put it on paper. He heard it, but he couldn't write it.
35:39He couldn't read it. It was like Brian Wilson. Yeah. Same image. Yeah, so I had to sit with him, and, okay, this is a B minor. This is an F-sharp major. This is a flatted fifth. I had to create a chord chart. Only then could I arrange the song for the brass because I needed a roadmap. And Terry, in sitting with me, learned eventually how to read charts. And I learned how to embrace rock and roll because I had been a jazz guy. So working with Terry opened my brain up to, you know, guitar, man, you know, rock and roll. This is awesome. I can put horns with this. This is cool. So do you remember meeting Terry for the first time?
36:29Yeah. Walt asked him to come over to school, to DePaul, to talk about their gig or some shit. I don't remember. But yeah, he and Danny came to DePaul, and I met Terry at DePaul. What was your first impression? He was wild. He was wild. He had this kind of kangaroo jacket and long blonde hair. And he was a big guy, big, sturdy Norwegian. And he was gruff, you know. And there is something, you know, very caveman about Terry K. And, you know, I was immediately taken aback by it. You know, it was like, oh, this guy is very interesting. and I heard him play I was like holy shit and he was playing bass he was playing bass I think it was before we were in Walt's basement that I heard him playing guitar somewhere I don't know maybe he was just horsing around it might have been at the apartment he used to sit between custom speakers those were his headphones
37:45and man but then when we first got together at Walt's Parents, I really heard Terry. My jaw dropped. I mean, this guy was like, God, the feel, his feel. I mean, he felt it in every inch of his body. And, you know, you couldn't help but be captured by that. But he's also a great rhythm player, too. Great rhythm player, great soloist. He played rhythm and lead at the same time. And sing a lead vocal. Sing the vocal. Yeah, he did it all. He did it all. I've never seen or heard anybody who can do that. And what was your impression of Robert when you met him? Do you remember meeting him for the first time?
38:30I think Walt actually met Robert first. He went to a club where, was it Bobby Charles? Bobby Charles and the Wanderers. The Wanderers, yes. It was at Sub Dive on the South Side. and Robert was playing acoustic piano and Walt asked him if he played B3 organ because we didn't have a bass player and Walt was interested to save money man maybe we could find an organ player that could play the bass pedals on the organ and we wouldn't have to pay a bass player and Robert said oh yeah man I play organ he had never done it in his life He immediately went out and bought a used M3 organ and started woodshedding at home.
39:21So when we got together, he could at least... I think we did that for about six months or so before we... Before we met Peter. And then you hired Peter. Do you remember meeting... Was he like a hire, like you went looking for a bass player? He was in the process of leaving the exceptions that were like the drinking crowd. They were a top 40 band. Everybody played 45 minutes, 15 off. They would take their 15 minutes off and go backstage and learn another song, another hit song, and then come out and try it on the next set. It's like, how the hell did they get? But they would sound exactly like the record.
40:06It was amazing. Yeah, and they had two amazing vocalists, Jimmy Vincent and Peter, and they were like the thing. You know, they appeared on local TV, and they were probably one of the most popular club acts in the Midwest at that time. At that time, we were beginning to get fired from these clubs because we started discovering our own voice, particularly Robert Lamb who started bringing original material into the band and we'd start trying those songs out at clubs and no sooner did we do that the club owners would come to us and say hey you play that stuff you're out of here I want top 40 that's what my customers want come to hear and so we either had to stick to the top 40 or get fired and we started getting fired Mm-hmm.
41:04Just sort of set a pattern for the rest of your career. Not only that, we set a pattern for the type of stuff that we were doing and the way we were feeling about life and some of the illegal things that we were doing on our 15-minute breaks as opposed to having a drink with the boys. We were going out and yelling and smoking a joint instead. You weren't learning a new song. But we were taking that drinking audience. We weren't learning a new song. And we would take that drinking audience away to come and listen to us. And that's what became interesting for Cetera to come and hear us. Well, here's the deal, man.
41:42No sooner did we start getting fired from these typical nightclubs, a club opened on Rush Street called Barnaby's that actually encouraged new stuff. You know, it was, wow, okay, this is what we've been looking for. and we got a gig at Barnaby's and we could do, they loved it. We could do our thing. We were doing expanded arrangements of hit songs. There was a group called Vanilla Fudge that inspired that as well. They do extended versions with alternate chord changes. So we started doing that And then that evolved into completely original material, which we were able to do at Barnaby's. One engagement at Barnaby's, we were an opening act for the Exceptions.
42:40Peter Cetera and the Exceptions were the headliner. And he heard us doing these Beatle covers. He was a huge Beatles fan. He heard us doing Magical Mystery Tour and Got to Get You in My Land. And it blew him away. And next thing you know, he was in the band. And then how soon after that did you leave for Los Angeles? All of it started in February of 68. 67. 67, I'm sorry. And in June of 68, we headed to California. So a year and a half. And you also, did you tour with Janis Joplin? Do I have that right? Well, yes. We met her at the Fillmore West. and we also we opened for Jimi Hendrix we were at the Whiskey Go-Go and Sunset Strip we were opening for Albert King and we were in the dressing room waiting to go back on and there was a knock on the door and we opened the door and Hendrix is standing there and we're going whoa is that Jimi Hendrix and you knew his stuff oh yeah he was on top of the world We were playing like Jimi Hendrix before we heard Jimi Hendrix.
43:54Yeah, we were, in fact, we were doing his cover. We were in Fox and Lady and Purple Hedge in our set. And Hendrix heard him. And before we went back, I said, he came to the dressing room. He said, you guys have a guitar player that's better than me and a horn section that sounds like one set of lungs. Do you guys want to go on the road? Fuck yeah. And next thing you know, we opened for his summer tour. We were the opening act, and he got it. Unfortunately for him, it was at the end of his career and the end of Janice's, but it was our foot in the door to the business. We never took our foot out of the door.
44:31What was he like to tour with? He was very introspective, very shy, quiet. And it was funny because, you know, we'd travel together. Terry was nervous around him, and he was nervous around Terry. You know, he didn't know how to approach each other. Eventually, they got comfortable, and they started trading ideas. Terry would love to have played with him. He would have joined Jimi Hendrix Band in a flash and left us. See you guys. I got something to do here. Well, there was actually some chatter amongst us about maybe doing a project together with him, with Jimi. And, of course, he left us too early, and then Terry left us too early.
45:17he also and maybe it was Walt who told the story that he was telling you how he felt tremendous pressure to have another hit and that he was finding it very hard probably that sort of goes along with the business itself it's always what have you done lately you just don't think that would apply to Jimi Hendrix it applies to everyone who's ever picked up an instrument I forget which artist it was. I think Joni Mitchell, You're Only As Good As Your Last Hit. How quickly they forget. Almost instantly. That's another reason that this journey of ours is such a phenomenon, because these songs broke that mold.
46:06These songs have become timeless. These songs, we are along for the ride. We're just blessed with this ride that this music has given us. You think it's the songs, those songs? Oh, my gosh, yes. Oh, definitely the songs. Oh, my gosh, yes. I mean, these songs, and we hear it every night, these songs have become fabrics of lives, soundtracks. These people, they're singing louder in the band. It's like it's a communion. Little did we know. I mean, we are so blessed to have this phenomenon occur that never would have occurred to us. But now the music business, as opposed to the fans, you found out at some point you didn't have publishing.
46:50Wasn't that right? You didn't have publishing rights? No, Gershiel took the publishing rights. So, I mean, I'd prefer not to talk about him anymore. Okay, yeah. He? Enough already. So he discovered us. Thank you. Yeah, yeah. But then Columbia dropped you after you made them just a gigantic stack of money. Well, we made them a stack of money, but at the time they dropped us, we were managed by a guy that made a deal that they couldn't refuse. And Walter Yutnikoff, rest in peace, agreed to the deal. And they realized after they went back to New York that they had just screwed themselves because they offered us way more than they thought we were worth.
47:40And they were never going to come up and fulfill their end. So they let us go, and they released everything they had over and over, repackaged, repackaged, with no artwork to recoup. And started saying that we were done. We weren't done. So Irving Azoff picked us up and put us on Full Moon Records. Not a bad guy to pick you up. Another historical thing. Just going back to that first album, how long after you'd been in L.A. did you record your Chicago Transit Authority album? Six months. We got to L.A. in June of 68, and we were in New York in January of 69, beginning the recording of Chicago Transit Authority.
48:22Now, it was your first record deal. Columbia was a little nervous, but you insisted on a double album. I'm fascinated by that. Well, we, as a band, realized that these cuts were longer cuts. If we had done, and Garcia completely agreed and supported our vision here, we couldn't have captured full picture this music with one disc. And he tried to convince Clive Davis of that. And Clive said, you know, our budget doesn't allow that for a new artist. And of course, it was the right decision. And the next two albums were also double albums because Columbia realized that it was necessary. One last break and we'll be back with Lee Lachnane and Jimmy Panko.
49:30is your gateway to the world's most captivating destinations. Travel is its own reward, you know. You're out there having experiences you can't have any other way, and with your Chase Sapphire Reserve card, you're also being rewarded. You earn eight times points on all purchases through Chase Travel. So let's say you book a trip to Hawaii, you go surfing at Sunset Beach, you go hiking on a volcano, and you go out to dinner. With the Chase Sapphire Reserve card, you're actually earning points for going on a grand adventure. anywhere you go, any trip you take. And that's not even mentioning how the card gets you into the Sapphire Lounge by the club at select airports nationwide and access to one-of-a-kind experiences like music festivals and sports events.
50:11Whether you're booking your next big trip or a week in escape, Chase Sapphire Reserve makes travel more rewarding. Discover more with Chase Sapphire Reserve at chase.com slash sapphire reserve. Cards issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval. Terms apply. I firmly believe when it comes to the holidays, you fall into one of two camps. Someone who loves holiday music, or someone who won't admit they love holiday music. There's something about a voice you love singing that familiar opening phrase, maybe it's Donny Hathaway, maybe it's Mariah Carey, that just flips a switch, and you're instantly back into that warm and cozy headspace only the holidays can bring.
50:49For me, that feeling pairs perfectly with a cup of Starbucks caramel brulee latte. That's their signature espresso with steamed milk, and a rich caramel brulee flavor topped with whipped cream and a crunchy caramel brulee topping. It's like the sound of the season, but in drink form. And that's really what this season's about. Little moments of pairing, little moments of connection. Sharing a song, sharing a story, sharing a caramel brulee latte. Because this season and every season, together, is the best place to be. Come together over your holiday favorites at Starbucks.
51:24Every December, we start singing. At church, around the fire, in our cars, with the radio turned up. But have we ever stopped to ask, where did our favorite Christmas carols come from? And what makes them so magical? I think it's probably one of the most perfect tunes to play and to sing. The voices are converging, they're adding this more complex and chromatic harmony, and it gives us that climactic arrival point. Hark is a podcast about the meaning and the making of Christmas carols. Get into the spirit of the season and listen to Hark, the stories behind our favorite Christmas carols. Available now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at americamagazine.org.
52:15My introduction to you was from my brother, David, who was a trumpet player. and he brought home the Carnegie Hall record. Now, I know you don't like the sound of the Carnegie Hall. That was the fourth album. That was the fourth album, yeah. But that was the best they could do at the time and I didn't realize that until 50 years later when I did it. Yeah, Lee did a remaster that is brilliant. Really? Yeah, he and an engineer took it into his studio and gave it the digital... Ten months later, we had it done. But we had to take away all of the noise and electronic sounds and everything just to get down to the instruments.
52:58And then we edited that to get as much of the sound of Carnegie Hall out of it. So we would delete everything up to the whatever horn or voice it was and then fade into that note. let the note play, finish, and then fade out of it. And we did that for each instrument. Every drum, well, actually the drums were easier because you can put gates on those. But also to build up the sound of the drums, Tim Jessup, the engineer, put together a drum sound, probably like 10 tracks of drums. But anyway. Yeah, he built a whole... He built a drum sound. So by the time we finished, we were able to move the music forward as though you were sitting in the audience.
53:57And for me, being the arranger, it was a blessing because my beef with Carnegie Hall, and again, it was lack of technology. It's what we had. Oh, yeah. And the horns, I couldn't listen. The horns sounded like kazoos. It wasn't our sound. It wasn't our big sound. And Lee brought that back. But now most people, Carnegie Hall is considered at the greatest acoustics, at least in the world. What was the issue? Just the way it was mic'd? No, no, no. It was rock and roll. Carnegie Hall is built for acoustic music. That's the difference. And if you put an amplifier, it's just, you can probably still hear some of the notes now if you go towards the building.
54:42I hear Chicago from 1971. That's right. Oh, my God. That was, like, 1971? Yeah. It's still, when I sit in my chair, I squeeze a little of the sound out. But tell me about, it's such an amazing piece of music, the ballet. It's got seven parts. Make Me Smile, I think, has at least two key changes in it. And I'm not going to talk about Make Me Smile because, and I will encourage people listening to go to YouTube to, you know, Rick Beato? Oh, yeah. Yeah, which is great. Did a wonderful breakdown of that song. He's amazing, by the way. He's got the stent. Yeah, no. I try to catch all his breakdowns.
55:26He does a lot of... He's done great ones, but I think yours is one of the best. He's an amazing musicologist. Yeah, yeah, he really is. And he does a fabulous breakdown of Make Me Smile, and you can hear all the parts, and it's just a blast. But then there's so much to say, anxiety's moments, And then there's the West Virginia Fantasies, which features you, Lee, on trumpet. Beautiful, beautiful trumpet line. I never learned any of those names. Okay, okay. You know the part where you're playing the beautiful trumpet part? Yes. That's what it's called. I love that. I mean, I complimented on him the other night because I had a clip for a performance.
56:13And when we're on stage gigging, I can't hear a lot of the nuances because there's so much going on in my ears. And I heard that piece very clearly. And I went, Lee, your tone on that thing is so nice. Because I had never heard it on stage. Practice, practice, practice. Yeah. And then there's the beautiful counterpart where Walter would come in. Was that all written out? Was any of this? Every note. All written out. Every note. Every note was written out. When I wrote the ballet, I just approached it as a multi-movement piece. He was still writing it when we were recording in New York. Chicago, too.
56:48Did you have a classical piece of music you had in mind as a model? No, not necessarily. But I wanted to create, as a peon perhaps to the great classic composers, hey, why can't we do this in rock and roll? So I just wrote an extended piece, and one movement evolved into another, into another, but I didn't have anything titled in movements. That was Garcia's idea. He said, Jimmy, let's title each one of those departures, each one of those segues, so we have actual titles on these movements, and we wind up with almost a mini-symphony kind of approach. Well, also the business, the studios and record companies were allowing unlimited copyrights at that time.
57:47And within a few years after that, they cut it down to just 10 copyrights on a record. And that completely changed writers and the record business because they didn't want to share. Once you had 10 songs on a record, you wrote the 11th song, the writers would have to start sharing their royalties. They didn't want to be doing that. So it completely changed their writing. And I could get nastier, but I'm not going to. I'm a Christian. Hey, more titles, more publishing. Well, that's where I was leading. But so anyway, greed changes everything. Yeah. So we were just playing music and writing music, and that's what we love still to this day.
58:33I had been listening to Bach. I am totally a fan of Johann Bach. I mean, arguably the most perfect voicer in the history of music. I mean, his voicing and his intervals were perfect. He was the template in music theory. Bach was a perfectionist, but Bach also cooked. Bach grooved. So here's this perfectionist that had an amazing feel as well. And I was listening to the Brandenburg Concertos. I got absorbed in, how did he do this? How did he do this? It totally drew me in. Well, that inspired me to sit at a piano and start fooling around with arpeggios. a la Bach. And Color My World was directly inspired by the Brandenburg Concerto.
59:34It's a 12-bar turnaround of major sevens and minor sevens. It's a round. And I put a vocal over it and then a flutso over it. It's just amazing. But the changes in it are very, very interesting. It's not diatonic. They're all relative. There's a note in each major 7 chord that sets up the next major 7 or minor 7 chord. So you're always using common notes to create the... Yeah.
1:00:14I only change the F to an A to make it an A minor 7. From an F major to an A minor. So they're relative. All the chords are relative, but they flow. They flow beautifully. So it's not diatonic. It's not. No. But it has that, you use the common tones to keep it going. Exactly. Well, the whole thing is just amazing. Thank you. But Lee, it took you a little longer to become a writer. Yeah. And these guys were already writers. I came in with Call on me. You want to listen to my song? So I had my little cassette put it in. Had you presented a lot of songs before Call on Me? No, this was my first song that I presented.
1:00:59I have to say, though, you came out with a bang. Came out with a bang, and Sotero decided to sing it and became a hit. It did come out. Still a hit today. It's going to be on this 50th anniversary album, so it's pretty cool. As it should be. And it was on Chicago 7 and then The Greatest Hits, which we initially thought was going to be our last album. Because once you do a Greatest Hits, historically, most bands are history after that. And did you think that was, was that around the time that Terry died? Terry died shortly after that, but it was something that was going on, so it did enter our heads.
1:01:42But we just kept playing music. We just kept playing our shows. So there wasn't a point you thought, ah, it's been a 10-year run. No, because we kept working. We were interested in playing music for audiences. We loved playing for live audiences and still do today. But even after Terry died, was there a moment you felt like, we can't do this? He was such a huge force. Not a matter of can't, but he was the leader at the time. And we had to decide that we are still together. he would want us to keep going so let's do that I'm only halfway through my questions and we're out of time so you're going to come back at some point we're going to keep going there won't be 60 more years though right get us before we're planting you'll be talking to if my brain's in a jar that's what you'll be talking to it's been a huge honor thank you so much what an honor In the episode description, you'll find a link to our favorite Chicago tracks, as well as the 50th anniversary re-release of Chicago 9's Chicago's Greatest Hits.
1:02:53Be sure to check out youtube.com slash brokenrecordpodcast to see all of our video interviews. And be sure to follow us on Instagram at The Broken Record Pod. You can follow us on Twitter at Broken Record. Broken Record is produced and edited by Leah Rose with marketing help from Eric Sandler and Jordan McMillan. Our engineer is Ben Talladay. Broken Record is a production of Pushkin Industries. If you love this show and others from Pushkin, consider subscribing to Pushkin Plus. Pushkin Plus is a podcast subscription that offers bonus content and ad-free listening for$4.99 a month. Look for Pushkin Plus on Apple Podcast subscriptions.
1:03:27And if you like this show, please remember to share, rate, and review us on your podcast app. Our theme music is by Kenny Beats. I'm Justin Richman.
1:03:40This episode of Broken Record is brought to you by Chase Sapphire Reserve. Traveling is one of life's greatest joys. Honestly, can anything be more exhilarating? Well, actually, yeah, with Chase Sapphire Reserve. It's your gateway to the world's most captivating destinations. First, you will earn eight times points on all purchases through Chase Travel. And the card gets you into Sapphire Lounge by the club at select airports nationwide and access to one-of-a-kind experiences. Whether you are booking a once-in-a-lifetime trip or your next weekend escape, Discover more with Chase Sapphire Reserve at chase.com slash sapphire reserve.
1:04:17Cards issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval. Terms apply. Hey, audiobook lovers. I'm Cal Penn. I'm Ed Helms. Ed and I are inviting you to join the best-sounding book club you've ever heard with our new podcast, Earsay, the Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club. Each week, we sit down with your favorite iHeart podcast hosts and some very special guests to discuss the latest and greatest audiobooks from Audible. Listen to Earsay on America's number one podcast network, iHeart. Follow Earsay and start listening on the free iHeartRadio app today. You've probably heard me say this.
1:04:56Connection is one of the biggest keys to happiness. And one of my favorite ways to build that, scruffy hospitality. Inviting people over even when things aren't perfect. because just being together, laughing, chatting, cooking, makes you feel good. That's why I love Bosch. Bosch fridges with VitaFresh technology keep ingredients fresher longer so you're always ready to whip up a meal and share a special moment. Fresh foods show you care and it shows the people you love that they matter. Learn more. Visit BoschHomeUS.com. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
From the publisher
When Chicago released their debut album in 1969, they blended brass, jazz sophistication, and rock power into something completely their own. By 1975, when Chicago IX: Chicago's Greatest Hits arrived, the band had already amassed an extraordinary catalog of songs that captured both the experimental spirit of the late '60s and the pop sensibility of the '70s. That compilation became one of the best-selling albums of the decade, introducing new listeners to the band's range while cementing their legacy.
Now, Chicago is celebrating the 50th anniversary of that landmark release with an expanded edition that offers fans a deeper look at this pivotal moment in the band's history.
On today's episode, Bruce Headlam talks to Lee Loughnane and Jimmy Pankow of Chicago about recording their early albums. They also discuss how they came up with the idea of incorporating a horn section into a rock band. And they explain why after being on the road since the 70’s they don’t even bother to unpack their suitcases anymore.
You can hear a playlist of some of our favorite songs from Chicago HERE.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.




