Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Notes: Broken Record - Episode with Tinashe

Overview Podcast Title: Broken Record Episode Title: Tinashe Hosts: Rick Rubin, Malcolm Gladwell, Bruce Headlam, Justin Richmond Release Date: [Insert Date] Description: In this episode, Justin Richmond interviews Tinashe, an artist redefining success in pop music. She discusses her career journey, her recent music releases, and her experiences in the industry.

---

Key Themes and Discussions

  1. Redefining Success in Pop Music
  2. Emergence: Tinashe rose to prominence with her hit "2 On" in 2014.
  3. Fanbase: Despite subsequent projects not charting, she cultivated a dedicated fanbase.
  4. Independence: In 2019, Tinashe left her major label, opting for an independent route, which has proven successful.
  1. New Music Releases
  2. "Nasty":
  3. Described as a potential "song of the summer."
  4. Part of her album *Quantum Baby*, which is the second part of a trilogy.
  5. Creative Process: Tinashe discusses the process of breaking her work into parts, allowing fans to digest and appreciate each release.
  1. Creative Independence
  2. Decision to Go Independent:
  3. Tinashe emphasizes the importance of creative control and the challenges of financial planning outside of a major label.
  4. Enjoyment and empowerment were key factors in her decision to go independent.
  1. The Role of Feedback and Collaboration
  2. Collaboration with Producers:
  3. Tinashe works closely with producers like Ricky Reed, creating a comfortable yet challenging environment.
  4. She favors starting songs from scratch or making adjustments to existing ideas.
  1. Artistic Identity and Challenges
  2. Genre Fluidity: Tinashe resists being boxed into one genre, allowing her music to draw from various influences.
  3. Release Strategy: She keeps her circle small for feedback, emphasizing her instinct and artistic vision over external opinions.
  1. Personal Reflections on Music and Life
  2. Freestyling: Tinashe discusses her writing process, often starting with freestyle sessions that capture raw emotion and instinct.
  3. Emotional Resonance in Music: Themes of love, disappointment, and self-acceptance permeate her songs, often with a bittersweet quality.
  1. Insights into the Music Industry
  2. Impact of Social Media: Tinashe acknowledges the influence of online platforms on her career and fan engagement.
  3. R&B's Place in Pop Culture: She reflects on R&B’s often overlooked status in mainstream music, advocating for its recognition and relevance.

---

Key Takeaways

  • Artist Empowerment: Tinashe's journey exemplifies the evolving landscape of the music industry, where independence and fan loyalty play crucial roles.
  • Creative Authenticity: Emphasizing personal expression over market-driven formulas leads to more genuine art.
  • Cultural Commentary: The conversation touches on larger themes of representation in the music industry and the need to celebrate diverse musical genres.

---

Additional Resources

  • Playlist of Tinashe's Songs: [Listen Here](https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3S63wKRJBXA2dZApSj7nqL?si=c257db1f5cbe4f02)
  • Follow Broken Record: [YouTube Channel](https://www.youtube.com/c/brokenrecordpodcast)

---

Conclusion This episode provides a deep dive into Tinashe's artistic journey, her approach to music-making, and her insights into being an independent artist in today's music landscape. The discussion is a testament to the evolving nature of success and expression within the pop genre.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:06Pushkin. This is an iHeart Podcast. In today's super competitive business environment, the edge goes to those who push harder, move faster, and level up every tool in their arsenal. T-Mobile knows all about that. They're now the best network, according to the experts at Ooclas Speedtest. And they're using that network to launch Supermobile, the first and only business plan to combine intelligent performance, built-in security, and seamless satellite coverage. That's your business, Supercharged. Learn more at supermobile.com. Seamless coverage with compatible devices in most outdoor areas in the U.S.

0:48where you can see the sky. Best network based on analysis by Ukla of Speedtest Intelligence Data 1H 2025. Every great music conversation goes beyond the surface. The influence that shaped an artist's sound. The moment that changed their creative direction. The story behind the story that fans never hear. Claude helps you discover those deeper connections. Upload interviews, liner notes, or music journalism, and Claude reveals patterns across an artist's entire journey, showing how influences become innovations. Whether you're a music journalist, passionate fan, or someone who loves understanding creative processes, Claude matches your curiosity about what really drives great artists.

1:29Try Claude for free at Claude.ai slash brokenrecord. Lexus is a company that believes in the importance of setting a standard, which I can appreciate as someone who holds themselves to lofty if not ridiculous standards, especially with the car I drive. The standard Lexus has set for themselves is to experience amazing. Lexus measures success by the feeling and emotions evoked in a driver, like exhilaration and joy. Amazing can only be achieved by knowing people on a deeper level. The standard of amazing results in a feeling in drivers that their car was built in anticipation of them. Machines that make you feel more human.

2:06Because a car that doesn't make you feel something is a car that stops short of amazing. Experience amazing at your Lexus dealer. Tina Shea's changing what a pop music career can look like. Back in 2014, her song Two On featuring Schoolboy Q became a huge hit. It was her very first single from her very first album and seemed like a clear indication that she was poised for more chart success. Instead, something maybe more interesting happened. Instead of dominating the pop market, she released projects that missed the Billboard chart, but gained her an incredibly strong and loyal fan base. She even left her label in 2019 to go independent and brought her fans along with her.

2:48And now, 10 years later, has her second Billboard hit with the viral sensation, Nasty. Nasty comes from her new album, Quantum Baby, the second part in a trilogy of albums that, to my ears, sounds like her best work yet. I spoke to Tina Shea from Amazon Studio 126 about these trio of albums, including her big summer hit, and the time she spent weeks filming The Polar Express with Tom Hanks. This is Broken Record, liner notes for the digital age. I'm Justin Richman. Here's my conversation with Tina Shea. Yo, congratulations on everything, I guess. This is crazy. I know. I'm so excited. We kind of set this up a while ago, I want to say, before I knew the song was going to do what it did.

3:40And it's like, you've been doing incredible work for so long. Thank you. It's incredible to see the payoff. Yeah. It feels good. I'm having fun. Yeah. Yeah. What was, maybe we can just start with Nasty. Yeah, sure. i guess or maybe we'll just start with the new part two in general like how were you part one and part two yeah of uh baby angel baby angel i didn't want to mispronounce it baby angel baby angel uh baby angel like how did you kind of make both at the same time yeah yeah well i initially went in with the intention of making a full-length project but breaking it up into parts to give people enough time to really chew on each piece of material.

4:28I think, you know, we live in this day and age that's very quick to consume. And I think as an artist, you know, you spend so much time working on the songs and curating them so perfectly and listening to them over and over and over again. There's something kind of sad every time you release like a full length project and you're like, well, what about this track and this track and this track? You know, like people get caught up. Obviously the singles get their light, they get their shine, they get their little focus track moment or a music video or something but there's usually so many other songs on a record that you want to like celebrate or you know let them have their flowers so i thought it would be smart to break it up into three different parts seven songs each so i initially started working on just like a huge batch yeah so you wanted people to be able to digest yeah something yeah just each individual batch yeah chunk so then how many how many songs did you wind up recording um a lot every project i end up recording a lot of material usually so i don't know there's not really like a set number but i would say it was getting into like the i would say 50 i would say 50 50 records maybe wow but those aren't all like fully fleshed out ideas they're usually like i'll start a song make a verse hook call that a song you know yeah decide if I'm fucking with it, if I want to change it.

5:51Well, take me to the inception of stuff. So like, how do you work with it? Like there's some great producers on here. Obviously, Nasty's Ricky Reed, but you got no such thing. Yeah, he's amazing. He has some incredible cuts on part two. Yeah, and he produced Talks to Me Nice on part one. So I feel like that's like a great connection and also kind of shows how the cohesion between the first project, the second project, and also the evolution from the first project to the second project, you know, because they're both the same but you know they're different they have their own personalities they have their own feels for sure so how do you um how do you like lock in with the producer and kind of like tell me the process of like kind of who starts like are you are you going to listen through listen for some for tracks listen for yeah and then i mean it kind of depends on who i'm working with or kind of the mood of the day um a lot of times we'll start from scratch depending on the producer if they're more comfortable with like playing beats that they've kind of made then And like, that's cool, too, because I will definitely take an idea, start something and then kind of go back in and like make tweaks and make edits that way.

6:55But I also love starting from scratch if people are down for that. So, you know, just kind of starting usually with like a BPM, a tempo, something that feels inspiring, something I want to dance to, something that feels different and unique as well. That's always something in that moment feels. Yeah. Yeah. It feels right. It feels inspiring. Is there something off part two that started that way? it's kind of like it was a la carte to you um yeah I mean I feel like every record was honestly thinking back on it Nasty definitely Red Flags yeah so many all of them okay Getting No Sleep he didn't cook that one in the room though that was more like we had a session the first day I told him what I wanted he said I'll come back with something tomorrow so it was still like it was still special you know specially made tailored right for you Yeah, Taylor made for you.

7:47Yeah, exactly. But just spend a lot more time on it. Given you have so many great deep cuts on an album, and that was kind of the impetus for maybe breaking these up a bit. How do you go about deciding once you have a set of songs what the single is going to be? Yeah. The single, I may actually get some feedback on the single because I do want to hear what other people are into, but not necessarily the songs on the album itself. Like I'll definitely refer to which ones I'm looking back on and constantly playing to see which songs are like the keepers. But sometimes the singles is just like playing it for a few people and you can tell.

8:29Sometimes it's the one that sparks the idea for a music video. I'm like, oh, I could do this really cool concept. I'd love to give this a moment. Sometimes it's just highlighting a record that I feel like would otherwise be just lost in the shuffle. there's not like a huge rhyme or reason behind it. But there are some songs at the end of the day you'll set aside as being like, maybe you have a hunch, these could or would be interesting too. Yeah, just because people are usually excited about it. People in the studio. Yeah. Or hearing you play things in your life or whatnot. Anything you can point to as to why you feel like Nasty's doing what it's doing?

9:08I mean, I think a lot of things, probably. I think the fact that the song is very catchy. It's easy to get in your head. You can hear it one time, you kind of remember it, or you kind of know what it's about. I think the simplicity of it lends itself to being a hit song. I think it doesn't really sound like too much other stuff on the radio right now, or in the universe right now. I think it has its own vibe with the minor chord section going into like the major chord hook so i think that stands out in a way i think it's memeable you know it's got these like funny funny lines that are like is somebody gonna match my freak or i have a nasty girl you know that people are just finding these little memeable moments and i also just think like time and place like you know just sometimes the universe is just like the perfect storm of everything coming together yeah everything else that's out right now where i'm at in my career the fact that it's summer you know i think there's just so many things that go into it the um the the lines part about the meme of a line even like you deliver it is really like your delivery on that yeah it's so interesting even like um um i need somebody with a good technique it's just it makes you it makes you feel something different you know i mean like you're like oh it's just like there's a you could tell that there was really um almost sounds like uh i mean in a way it's almost like maybe the way like an actor reads lines like you kind of treated them i don't know that you did that but yeah as a listener yeah it's like wow you really no there was definitely a purposefulness of the approach to the verse like how i said it i really wanted it to be in like a conversational part of my voice and so it felt very in your face and really like I was just talking to you and not like I was trying too hard to like perform it or sing it or do it in my singing voice or any particular voice because sometimes it's easy to do that too you know like perform it in like a sexier tone or like you can do so many different ways to make it interesting if you will but I really wanted it to be like in a talky conversational kind of tone is that like an intention you'll set out in the studio and then like I guess how do you get vocal feedback yeah i also don't really get vocal feedback i usually it's just me and my engineer recording everything and yeah just doing whatever feels right i actually don't like vocal feedback every time there's like a vocal producer in the room i'm like this is so annoying let me sing it how i want to sing it the initial reason was because i'd recorded it as a freestyle and i had that tone so listening back to the freestyle that I'd recorded I was like that sounds good I tried to mimic it and it didn't come across that same way so I was very specific in trying to like mimic it the way that I just was saying it when I was messing around wait so what part of it exactly was the freestyle the whole I've been a nasty girl nasty and is somebody gonna match my freak is somebody gonna match my freak is somebody gonna match my nasty The whole thing.

12:22The uh, uh, uh, uh, uh. The whole thing. I have it in my computer on photo booth. Wait, is that what you... It wasn't like a voicemail? You hopped on photo booth. Yeah, because I was driving in my car and the music was playing off my phone. So I had to record myself. So I had my laptop and the passenger seat, I like open it up. Very safe. Record. I wasn't filming myself. It was just filming the audio. And then, yeah. how much is that a part of your your process freestyling yeah i feel like that gives me the best product so i always try to be very purposeful about following my instinct and making sure that i record my initial instinct on a beat that's really important too um because a lot of times i just think that that's your best idea for some reason just is so you recording things going back to hear what the initial like yeah what really spoke to you initially yeah and then yeah not exaggerating but but building on yeah yeah and a lot of times either there will be words already like with nasty there were actual words tangible words but sometimes it's just melodies sometimes it's gibberish sometimes it's a word here and there mumbo jumbo and you kind of have to like excavate the lyrics but yeah i think that's usually how i write um nearly every song wow that's really cool yeah you just kind of felt like yeah well i really love that like west coast kind of chilled but still makes you want to dance it's that pocket that like everyone wants to bob their head yeah everyone could kind of catch that beat it's not too up it's not too slow um yeah and i've been djing a lot lately and there's always like a lot of songs in that like 99 100 bpm that i love to play i don't know because i grew up on the west coast but it's like sweet spot what are the what are those tracks i don't know like anything like tie dollar sign or like yg you know like that it's giving that laid back effortless bop energy and wanting to kind of start with that pocket okay dope um when did you officially move to california like how old were you seven you were seven yeah did it feel um how was coming out here like like music because you're obviously from a young age plugged into the arts plugged into music digesting things that you're taking in how did how did moving here change the way you you listened to things and felt things and what you wanted to do.

14:48I feel like the West Coast has such a specific style of just culture and sound, whether it be like how the culture of creating music, you know, being in that culture from a really young age, being in the studios, you know, seeing how songs were made, you know, how producers worked, you know, just the culture of chilling in LA and the laid backness of it all. And I think that has a lot to do with like approach, subject matter, BPM, style, just different things that I tend to like, you know, growing up here has a very clear vibe, in my opinion. Yeah, it's hard to explain, I think, to people that don't grow up here, too.

15:32It's like and there is a certain cadence and a swing or rhythm, I guess, a rhythm to life here. that I guess is maybe like you could explain to New Yorker because they also have a rhythm that they're plugged into for sure that they feel very much and feel as superior maybe sometimes but I do think like you know obviously the legacy of kind of like that west coast swing that goes into like a YG my crazy life and all these other cuts like I love and now that you're saying that I can kind of hear that because you do have a unique style yeah thank you and it feels like because uh two on was your first single yeah turned out to be a big yeah definitely and it feels like you kind of came fully formed yeah well it had that pocket too so i feel like that's another reference point always like going back to being like how do we you know that there was some magic in that what was that you know what set that song apart.

16:32And I think that part of it is that identity, having that kind of its own identity, its own vibe, its own cadence. And yeah, I don't know. I just remember like growing up and going to dances, you know, just being around at the house parties and stuff like that. I think it's just very visceral and you want to be a part of it and you want to just like have that energy. So going into my entire career, I kind of always had in the back of my head, like every project has a couple of those little tracks sprinkled in from back to my first mixtape. I have a record on there called Chainless. That's the super West Coast, just like we shot it on Fairfax, shot the music video.

17:08It's just kind of funny to see how everything comes very full circle. Yeah, yeah. You've stayed based here your whole career too, right? Yeah, yeah. How do you... I'm just thinking you shot your very first video from your mixtape on Fairfax. Yeah. You're at a very different stage in your career and life at this point today. Yeah, I was just driving down. Where you're just driving down. Yeah. In traffic in the exact same location where I shot that video. Like, wow. I'm just tripping about how you must experience the city so differently. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. It's amazing. I think the evolution and the journey is all these little moments along the way really make it so much more meaningful and impactful to be where I am now and to kind of see firsthand.

17:52You can compare very easily like the then and now. And I think that that makes it really sweet. Yeah, absolutely. We'll be right back with more from a conversation with Tina Shea.

18:25an only business plan to combine intelligent performance, built-in security, and seamless satellite coverage. With Supermobile, your performance, security, and coverage are supercharged. With a network that adapts in real time, your business stays operating at peak capacity, even in times of high demand. With built-in security on the first nationwide 5G advanced network, you keep private data private for you, your team, your clients. And with seamless coverage from the world's largest satellite to mobile constellation, your whole team can text and stay updated even when they're off the grid. That's your business, Supercharged.

19:06Learn more at supermobile.com. Seamless coverage with compatible devices in most outdoor areas in the U.S. where you can see the sky. Best network based on analysis by Ukla of Speedtest Intelligence Data 1H 2025. The greatest music stories aren't always in the songs themselves. They're in the late night studio sessions, the chance encounters, and the cultural moments that shaped entire movements. For music lovers who find themselves going down rabbit holes about their favorite artists, Claude, an AI thinking partner, helps you explore those deeper questions. Whether you're wondering about the connections between different scenes, trying to understand what drove a particular creative period, or exploring how social movements influenced sound, Claude works through these complex cultural puzzles with you.

19:54It's built for people who know that understanding music means understanding the human stories behind it. Claude doesn't just compile facts. It helps you see patterns across decades of music history, ask the kinds of follow-up questions that reveal deeper truths, and works through the nuanced relationships between artists, movements, and moments. Whether you're a music journalist, industry professional, or someone who just lives for understanding the stories behind the sounds, Claude matches your level of curiosity about what really drives great art. Try Claude for free at Claude.ai slash brokenrecord and see why the world's best problem solvers choose Claude as their thinking partner.

20:32This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. One of the things I think is universal to nearly everyone is that warm feeling you get when you find someone you feel comfortable sharing parts of your life with that otherwise you might just keep to yourself. Often it's a friend, sometimes it's a loved one, But in those moments, you really take a load off. That's one of the things I've enjoyed most about therapy. That there's someone regularly in my life that I'm able to talk to about things I'd probably keep to myself for longer than I really needed to. And they're clinically trained and licensed to help.

21:03Plus, if you regularly see them, they have most, if not all, the context they need to really understand how this item you're sharing might be affecting you or those around you. That's where BetterHelp comes in. They've been helping people find their therapy match for over a decade. Because of their quality therapists that work according to a strict code of conduct, they have a 4.9 rating out of 1.7 million client session reviews. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Find the one with BetterHelp.

21:33Our listeners get 10 % off their first month at BetterHelp.com slash broken. That's BetterHelp.com slash broken. We're back with Tina Shea. I want to talk a bit about your journey to being like an independent artist. Yeah. Or your journey since becoming an independent artist. It's interesting that you seem to kind of be ahead of the curve a bit on that. I don't know. I don't know. It's the Aquarius in me. Like we're always trying to move ahead of the curve, I guess. Always trying to see around corners and see what's going to happen. Yeah, I was just trying to make your own path, you know. carve your own way because it's like you left your label in 2019 yeah and so uh five years later it seems to be like like i just saw today neo is going independent really yeah wow like it this is a real um sort of time a real pivotal like kind of like a boiling point in music where artists are realizing what they can do for themselves and you you got like a five-year yeah head start on it super cool can you take me through the decision to go independent yeah i think for me it the thing about the independent route that i you know try to emphasize or keep in mind is that i do think i wouldn't necessarily write out the gate be like everyone should be independent i think it's like a very case-by-case basis i feel like i had a very lucky perfect storm of like having the experience with the major label that kind of sowed a lot of seeds for me and then like you know establishing a fan base that was very dedicated and like super loyal so that when I was able to make that step they were able to go with me and follow me and still continue to support me because I do think the independent grind is super difficult and so I I think it's it's more what what's really important is being able to tailor your career specifically for like what works for you because the reason I went into bed personally was because I just like mentally was not enjoying being in the place where I couldn't make all of the creative financial you know timing decisions when it came to my music and I think it works for some people you know um you know it's a complicated relationship sure yeah but I mean like it must have been because you know like there's a world it must not have even been label specific or you could tell me if it was because it's like, I'm sure you could have just like found a different relationship that worked.

24:14You mean like a different record label? Different record label. Yeah. Yeah. I wasn't interested in that at that point because I really wanted to, I guess, prove to myself that my decisions were still the right decisions. And I was very wary of adding more cooks to the kitchen, if you will. I think, you know, like when you're working with a bigger team, a bigger machine you start making little compromises here and there it's not necessarily like it's in your face and it's very cut and dry like i'm making the wrong decision it's you know you start listening to so many different opinions and there's a lot of outside noise and i think i really wanted to just eliminate all of that go back to my roots go back to making music in my house in my home and being the sole decider of like this is the one this is what i'm to do this what i want to put out and so yeah it was just really important for me at the time to make that decision to like fully embrace being by myself you know on a creative front yeah um you you had mentioned that it's like you know when you go independent there's not like some you know i mean there's kind of there's not some like predetermined path like you kind of have to tailor it to who you are as an artist and your taste.

25:30So what were some of those early conversations you were having amongst, you know, your team at that point about what, how you could position yourself to be successful independently? I mean, the biggest question mark is always like, how are we going to fund this? So it's, there's big ideas, but without, you know, a major label budget, you're constantly thinking about how how are we going to find the funds, get the funds, or, you know, like, make the funds, you know, like, you just have to figure it out, get very super smart about how you spread out your financial decisions, where you spend the money, how you spend the money, looking for like the tiniest ways to be able to cut corners to maximize the art itself.

26:12And I think for a couple years, that was definitely something that was a big focus was just trying to figure out how do we just keep it going, keep the art coming, keep the music videos coming with the budget that we've got. And did you feel like you had to almost step up the output in a sense? Of course, because you always have to continue to step up the output. I think just competing in this environment and also as the type of artist that I am, like I'm not brand new. So So I'm constantly trying to raise the bar creatively and with my own work. So, I mean, a lot of times when you have like crazier and crazier ideas, you know, it costs more and more money.

26:51So you're it's just something that you're constantly trying to figure out where how to negotiate that, like within your own mind, you know, as an artist. Obviously, you never want to compromise your art and you can't, but you have to figure out how to be crafty sometimes. Right. How did that then impact the art? Yeah, I think I enjoyed it because it was empowering in a sense. I mean, it was difficult, but it was empowering to know that all of the output was because of hard work and great relationships and, you know, just the strength, if you will. um so yeah i think everything that we did after going independent really led up to these moments that i'm having now it really paved the way because i was able to re-establish um i think how like my perception within the industry i think people respected the fact that i was making it on my own and that kind of changed i think how people perceived me yeah i could see that because you know like obviously when your first single is two on and it does what it does i mean i'm sure there must have been some sort of temptation to just sort of slot you into the machinery yeah but very clearly like you are a different kind of artist yeah well i i don't like being put in a specific box very much i tend to break and push against that so i i feel that initially there were a lot of labels whether it was just simple things like genre like i was very opposed to being labeled as like a particular genre and still to this day i don't feel that pressure as much anymore because i feel like people have an understanding of like the fact that i do genre hop and use a lot of inspiration from different things but i definitely feel like at the beginning just a very visceral reaction to be like no do not put me in that box right you know and they're trying to just sell you to a certain market yeah like it's so much more nuanced and complicated and layered and colorful than that yeah yeah um one of one of the things i noticed about like and it was so it's listening to um i haven't spent the last almost year with part one and now getting the chance to um preview part two um it's refreshing that there's no features yeah like it's nice just to hear you yeah thanks like straight up you like you know what i mean like And I feel like that's something that is, I don't know, it's not, we don't get a lot of these days.

29:35And I love that you're able to make decisions like that. Like it's just going to be you going to work on a song with the producer. And we're only going to hear from you because you, I mean, you have a real distinct point of view. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. I mean, I love just having the work speak for itself. And I think that that's what these projects do, which I really love, is that they're simple. And the fact that it's all me, there's not as many like side quests and different things added to like add flavor or spice. You know, it's just it's simple and it's all me. So that's great. That's amazing.

30:12Do what kind of how do you so if you're coming from a system where there is it's more team. Yeah. Or there's this kind of larger decision making body. Yeah. And you kind of scale this way down. Yeah. When you record, say, 50 something songs. And you're thinking about, well, I like these. I want to make this into something. Who are you talking with to sort of figure out what the vibe is? What the move is. Yeah, like, are these good and how do you want to put them out, etc. I mean, I do have like a team that I trust, like people that are close to me that I trust, but I keep my circle super small.

30:52So I would say it's not that many people. And even within that team, I don't know, I think it's important to really not even ask that many people's opinions. Like, really not at all, like truly not at all, because I think that that just messes with your instinct. And I think a lot of the times at the end of the day, you know what you want to do. If you don't, you can ask, which is great. But you don't always have to ask. I don't know. It's not that many people. You got to keep it tight. Do you have any other artists that are kind of in your circle, people that you could hit up to be like on a creative decision level?

31:26Not really. Honestly, no. Really? No. Really? Yeah, no, not really. Oh, that's shocking. I mean, maybe I'm sure I could, but I haven't. that's really impressive because i mean the output's really good but i'm also very precious with my music like i don't really like the experience of sharing like i don't like sharing it with people i like sharing it with people i don't want to be a part of it once i've shared it with you like i i want to it's almost like i i don't want to hear your feedback i don't want to i don't want to consider what you thought of it or how you took it like the art speaks it is what it is the art was made for the purpose of expressing a certain feeling how you interpret it is your business in a sense and that goes for like my family friends like i don't like to watch people listen to my music or hear people hear it for the first time like i'd rather be totally separate from them be like here it is literally it's like yeah like enjoy it hate it whatever you do with it but at that point it's really not my business yeah yeah yeah i don't know That's a strong way to handle that.

32:37I've heard you say too in interviews that you don't even, when you're making music, consider like, whoa, this could be a hit. That's not an expectation that you put on your art. Yeah, because I feel like I did for a certain amount of time and it was detrimental to my creative process. I feel like it just changed how I would approach things. it's too formulaic in what way like it's too formulaic like it's too gameplayy it limits you in how you just like think about things like you're trying to make it fit a certain amount of bars or you know sound like we got to get to the hook first or you know we have to it has to be this certain you have to say the hook you have to say the word four times you know like there's all these like fake rules that people make up of like how to make a hit song and i think it's very limiting in terms of just like how you approach it i think that a better decision is to just make it however you want to make it and then if you want to edit it to something that feels more consumable or more hit like or whatever that's different or even just more to your liking or more to your liking which is what i tend to focus on like i just don't even bother trying to like make a hit i think that's fickle and also i consider like every song i make could be potentially a hit so i don't like to you know put that like hierarchy on them you know it's just so funny like i i'm just so bugged out because um i mean i was talking to someone before you got here like um needs to me yeah needs a great song sounds like just like like i'm thinking about i'm like um as great as nasty as i'm like it's good like why wasn't these as big i mean you never know you never it really goes to it really just illustrates the point you really never do You never know.

34:23You never know. So much is out of everyone's control. Yeah, so just make what you want to make and then let it happen. Does having nasty, which is kind of shaped me up to be a song of the summer, you know what I mean? It's going well. Does that impact the way you feel about your music or the way that you're thinking about your sort of career now that you are more in control of things? I mean, you have the thoughts. The thoughts creep in where you're like, now what? Where do we go next? What if? The what ifs. What happens next? What does this mean? Thoughts of like, does this mean that everything else I've ever done is not as valuable as this?

35:14There's so many different ways you can look at it. But at the end of the day, not really. I feel like I'm more focused on the fact that I'm just enjoying what's going on and like living in the moment, trying not to like let those intrusive thoughts in or really focus on any of that. I think that's where you mess up. Yeah. So, yeah, I'm not really trying to change anything about the process in terms of the art or what I would do next. Have you had what are the conversations you've had with with Ricky Reed who produced it? Yeah. Around it. we're just happy like it's it's fun every day just seeing all the way people are sharing it and all the different milestones that we're hitting it's just like a celebration yeah yeah it's gotta be huge i mean it's yeah it's like and i feel like for your fans too it's funny the your fans are super dedicated yeah and it almost seemed as if when you went independent they went into like overdrive like super like protective super um and like so for a while it was like the narrative was like that you were like underrated.

36:17Oh yeah, for sure. I was like, your fans were always in things. Like people would be like, oh, the best R &B vocalist of the 2010s. And they'd be like, why isn't Tinashe in this list? Why? Yeah. They mean well. No, of course they do. And it's like, dude, what a blessing to have like fans like that, that it got your back like that. And, but it's like, it's so, I don't know, just as a, as a, I'm a huge R &B fan. I feel like R &B doesn't get, and not to put you in a box, but I feel like R &B doesn't always get its due. No, it doesn't. I think that's why I had such an aversion to being in that box.

36:53It wasn't because I don't love R &B. It was because I know how push to the side R &B always gets. Yeah. It always feels like a side category or something that's like, yeah, R &B's cool. Yeah. It gets no... In terms of when you think about it, hip hop before that rock and roll. take up all the oxygen in the room. But every time that R &B has had its main moment, they just consider it pop. And I think that was my issue when I first got in the game because I'd be like, yeah, I make R &B. But to me, that's pop. I don't know. I grew up in the early 2000s. All of the pop songs were R &B songs. Yeah.

37:32That is a great point that every time R &B has a moment, it just gets called pop. Like Michael Jackson's... Or hip hop. It falls into other categories. so you know people just the borders are so loose in certain regards like what is it what is rmb at the end of the day really exactly but there's music that we call that i guess just for shorthand but the funny thing about it is like i feel like more than any other music it's always been relevant to our lives as people like totally everyone like has you know remembers their first dance or like their wedding song or like whatever whatever there's all these like landmark moments and our lives are kind of soundtracked.

38:11Totally. Bar and B. And it's always there. It's like, it's always selling. There's always these popular artists, but no one really is like, no one talks about it. Give R &B her flowers. It needs it. It needs it, you know? Yeah. After one more quick break, we'll be back with the rest of T-Nashe.

38:30In today's super competitive business environment, the edge goes to those who push harder, move faster, and level up every tool in their arsenal. T-Mobile knows all about that. They're now the best network, according to the experts at Ooclas Speed Test, and they're using that network to launch Supermobile, the first and only business plan to combine intelligent performance, built-in security, and seamless satellite coverage. With Supermobile, your performance, security, and coverage are supercharged. With a network that adapts in real time, your business stays operating at peak capacity, even in times of high demand.

Read the full transcript

39:08With built-in security on the first nationwide 5G advanced network, you keep private data private for you, your team, your clients. And with seamless coverage from the world's largest satellite-to-mobile constellation, your whole team can text and stay updated even when they're off the grid. That's your business, Supercharged. Learn more at supermobile.com. Seamless coverage with compatible devices in most outdoor areas in the U.S. where you can see the sky. Best Network Based on Analysis by Ukla of Speedtest Intelligence Data 1H 2025.

40:08trying to understand what drove a particular creative period, or exploring how social movements influenced sound, Claude works through these complex cultural puzzles with you. It's built for people who know that understanding music means understanding the human stories behind it. Claude doesn't just compile facts. It helps you see patterns across decades of music history, ask the kinds of follow-up questions that reveal deeper truths, and works through the nuanced relationships between artists, movements, and moments. Whether you're a music journalist, industry professional, or someone who just lives for understanding the stories behind the sounds, Claude matches your level of curiosity about what really drives great art.

40:47Try Claude for free at claude.ai slash broken record and see why the world's best problem solvers choose Claude as their thinking partner. Lexus is a company that believes in the importance of setting a standard, which I can appreciate as someone who holds themselves to lofty if not ridiculous standards, especially with the car I drive. The standard Lexus has set for themselves is to experience amazing. Lexus measures success by the feeling and emotions evoked in a driver, like exhilaration and joy. Amazing can only be achieved by knowing people on a deeper level. The standard of amazing results in a feeling in drivers that their car was built in anticipation of them.

41:25Machines that make you feel more human. because a car that doesn't make you feel something is a car that stops short of amazing. Experience amazing at your Lexus dealer. We're back with the rest of my conversation with Tina Shea. How does DJing, you mentioned that you're DJing a lot. How does DJing impact your sort of, your palate? I think it's just, again, like that awareness of like BPM and how I want to approach mixing certain songs where I see them in a set kind of affects like how I approach it in the studio just considering the different tempos and the different energies that I want to convey but at the same time also flipping the script in that way like if I have a bpm that's super fast approaching it like in a half time speed or vice versa right I think that that yeah like if we have like a 70 bpm kind of approaching it how i would uh 114 140 max 140 you know 140 yeah exactly um do you do you spin your own music as well yeah of course you do okay yeah that's the fun part how like how is it like you just sneak a song in or yeah like yeah yeah i'm not shy about it like whatever I want to play my songs I like them I made them I'm putting them in the set list will you play new stuff have you played stuff that you haven't even put out totally unreleased I've played unreleased remixes and things like that but I've never played a fully unreleased song in a set wow yeah that's probably a good idea I told you I don't like watching people listen to my music for my first time so in a DJ set it's my worst nightmare it's kind of like a really organic way till I just sort of see how people are vibing.

43:18You're right, but in my mind, I would though. In my mind, I'd be like, they're all dancing because they hate it and they're trying to act like they like it. They're trying to dance because they... That's a really convoluted line of thinking. I'd be like, wow, these people are dark. How did you connect with the... How did you connect with the producers across these various projects? Yeah. um this one was a lot of people that i knew through my management rock nation and then also just people that i'd worked with on my last project kind of carrying over um not not baby angel part one but um yeah like the three three three two baby angel era on probably within the last i'd say five years people that i've worked with or like one of the producers on this project like my brother's friend and like was my brother's roommate who's that his name is troy okay yeah he's produced he produced um he also produced a song on 333 so i'm like i'll find beats or i'll work with whoever honestly kind of if your shit's hot i'm into it i'm interested wow that's i enjoy the process of getting new vibes from different creatives and having new people in the room and fresh energy i guess i'm not really the type of artist that like works the same producer for like a really long period of time yeah if i do work with someone for a long period of time or multiple times like i really we really have a good vibe like an especially good vibe so so it's like the producers like no such thing i'm like has been across yeah part one and two yeah that's i imagine this producer you got like a pretty strong we've got a great vibe for sure he's a super creative guy, just super down to earth.

45:06And I think I enjoy the fact that he is like an ultra creative. Some people I feel don't push me as much and others do like his stuff is so it's so out of the box sometimes that I feel pushed creatively to try to meet him at that level. And I think that that's really inspiring for me rather than, you know, beats that I feel, oh, this is easy. I'm coming up with ideas right away. Sometimes I like a challenge to get in the studio, be like, I have no idea what i would sing on this how to approach this i have no idea how to approach this that's more exciting wow um what how how much do you um how many different like iterations of what will like songs go through like yeah especially a particular like i just talked about this project in particular um it kind of depends on the song i would say usually there's an initial draft of the song where i decide that i like really like it or i don't like it and then i'll kind of go in and make little individual tweaks and that can be adding backgrounds that can be changing the beat that can be changing lyrics on a verse that could be re-singing sections and that can either be like one session or like 10 sessions you know like just kind of depends on how many things i end up wanting to add or change but initially to come up with with the like main meat of the song it's usually like one main session nice yeah um what what i want to talk about no sleep yeah um that's a song that sounds almost like uh i like i guess it doesn't could sound disparaging but almost sounds like a demo to me yeah in the sense that it sounds like effortless yeah i like that it sounded like you like you guys put like like you just like like a michael jordan game or something like you just came out with the flu and you put up some shots and you like yeah i i like that feedback because i feel like there was a certain there were some decisions made and how I approached that song that I wanted it to feel very effortless, not singing, not like I was trying to overly perform, whether it's the fact that a lot of that song is like a single vocal, there's not a lot of stacks.

47:21It feels very kind of like a freestyle, like it all just kind of spilled out. The fact that the structure of the song is different from the first hook being shorter, the second hook adding like a whole nother, you know, refrain of that with different lyrics. So yeah, I think that was one of the things that made that song interesting. And also when he brought that beat back after, you know, he kind of took it overnight and brought that beat back. It already had these really interesting like progressions to it. He would add like this kind of garage sounding kick over the regular kick only like twice.

47:56I'd be like, well, that part was really cool. Let's make that the post or whatever. Trying to just go with the flow of how the beat moves of how it all evolves I think that that's how the lyrics kind of match it in that sense like they all just kind of evolve together yeah yeah what about Enough? I like Enough too both of these are Nostarge Thing pre-songs both of those Enough was too? yeah I love the pre I guess it's maybe like a pre-chorus on that that was one of the moments on the album where I'm like like the maybe it's not meant to be yeah you like it's like why damn you're really singing on that yeah thank you vocal really came through yeah i love that song because i feel like it has this really interesting contradictory energy like i love songs that feel really happy and jovial but then like talk about something sad i feel like that song it's not that it's sad but there's like a bittersweet energy to enough which i love i love bittersweet songs like i don't know it's like the artist in me the romantic in me loves like a bittersweet moment yeah so i am i love that it's about feeling maybe like you you gave it your all but it wasn't enough like just knowing that you know it's not quite good enough and feeling that like sense of disappointment but then at the end of the day coming to the conclusion that you have everything that you need and being thankful and having gratitude i think that that's that what that song is but it sounds really happy so like I love that.

49:29I feel like When I Get You Alone is a little bittersweet too. And it's kind of like a love song. And then it's like at the end though, it's kind of like, well, it's a little amorphous, but it kind of sounds like maybe things weren't so perfect. You know what I'm saying? I mean, is love ever perfect? It hasn't been for me, but maybe for someone else. We can only speak for ourselves. Yeah, absolutely. How much do you put your own personal, I mean, romantic love life into your music? I feel like it's always the core of the inspiration. Like, I would never sing something that, like, I totally couldn't relate to.

50:12But definitely I can exaggerate on certain feelings, thoughts, emotions. I can kind of pinpoint maybe how I feel on a particular day and kind of go with that. I think emotions are also always changing and always evolving. So I think it's important to speak to them as they come up and make a song that represents them and then move through it, go on to the next. But I'd say the core of it is always pretty real or something that I relate to, at least. The idea of exaggerating is pretty interesting. I've never heard anyone reference that. I mean, it's just kind of taking the feeling and going deeper with it and expanding upon it.

51:02Yeah, and sometimes you want to tell a story and you want to make it even more real for the listener. And I think that that's where little exaggeration comes into play. Yeah. Have you ever found yourself having to explain things that you've written to partners or things like that? Because it got you in trouble. um in like cheeky ways but not in like real ways if yeah not real not not in real ways not in like a real okay not yeah no one's ever been like very upset but people have definitely been like oh my god are you gonna write a song about me like maybe and maybe you really are or maybe you already have right um do you you were uh you mentioned three three three kind of like keeping the same more or less cast of collaborators yeah three three three and baby angel they kind of sound like um extensions of one another like in like a real major ways um what was that a a conscious decision when you started making these sets of songs that you felt like you liked what you did on 333 and you wanted to extend it?

52:18I think they're all kind of of an era. I started making 333 in the pandemic, like 2020, and I just think my energy shifted since then and it's just kind of been evolving. To me, 333 feels like Baby Angel and Quantum Baby, but it also doesn't feel as confident and as resolved as these songs do. So I feel like this is, again, it's not that it's, they're different, but it feels like an evolution to me. God, no, no, no, it makes sense. There's some, I love that album though, 333. Thank you. That song like Angels, for instance, is like out of control. Thank you. Want to let you go, but I have this random question I want to ask.

53:06I want to ask randomly about Tom Hanks. I know you did the motion capture for Polar Express. Yeah. But I was always curious. I couldn't find an answer. Was he there? Was he there when you were doing that? Yeah. We acted the whole... Yes. He was there for, I think it was like six weeks, eight weeks. It wasn't someone else. It was right here. I was saying this on the Paramount lot. Literally here. Really? Yes. We acted the entire movie, but they'd built the entire set out of wires. So we all had these weird suits. It was all in a soundstage with wires and they dubbed over the whole audio. but we had to do the entire movie.

53:44Filmed it. Someone's got that, like someone's got the file of the real footage of us with the funny suits. It's probably like on the DVD extras or something. It's deep somewhere in the vault. In the vault. What was working? I mean, you were young. I was in fourth grade. I was nine. Younger even. Yeah, I was nine. It came out, I think, when I was 12 because it was very early technology. It took them a long time to come to do the animation. That's funny to think about. I remember when I was nine being like, It's not going to come out until 2005. So far away. What was working with Tom Hanks like?

54:17It was really cool. He was a professional, which was very cool to see from early days. I feel like just witnessing professionals on set gives you a lot of motivation, like how they would treat the PAs. And he bought lotto tickets for everyone. I remember thinking that was really impressive. I was like, whoa, everyone? A lot of people. Yeah, it was a really fun experience. I was young, though. I loved it though I really enjoyed being on sets and doing all the things how much do you still how much is that because you did a good amount of acting when you were younger like how much does that still feel like a part of you like something you wanted I feel like I use all the skills that I gained when I was young entertaining and acting for what I do whether it's entertaining whether it's how to be a professional whether it's just you know how to turn it on how to turn it off I think there's so many ways that I'm still incorporating like my acting skills or you know whatever now but music's definitely my number one focus and I want to return to acting as something that I focus on probably later so it's still that kind of acting bug is still yeah I mean I love it I just love being in front of a camera I love putting on a show I love performing so I would definitely do it in your mind who's the greatest performer who's like your inspiration dang well music wise I would always say janet jackson she's like up there but then like i don't know probably my biggest inspiration is like my dad when it comes to being a performer he's like a he's a theater guy he loves the theater he loves stage acting um kind of you know initially was the person who like brought me to all my auditions and things like that so he's an inspiration we went to a play last night did you yeah what'd you go see what was it called uh something a strange loop don't know it i saw driving down the street i saw all these posters for it it's like you don't ever notice something until you see it and then you're like it's everywhere oh my god it's like when you get a car and then you see that same car everywhere yeah what um just to follow up on that we can we can wrap up but like would your dad being that he's like a teacher and like would he was he always kind of showing you, pointing things out to you about performances or about films or plays?

56:32You know what? Yes, but I was really, I didn't like it. Like every time he would try to help me with my lines or like give me feedback or whatever, I would, I didn't want to take it. So that's very true of like who I still am today. Like I just don't do well. Well, I could see, that's a great point. I could see how growing up with two teachers, by the way. I was like, no. Would make you like. Stop telling me how to read the lines. Do you feel like it's in there somewhere? What? Whatever he passed over to you? Oh, of course. You're always listening secretly. I just don't like being told what to do.

57:12Makes sense. It's very Janet of you. Yeah, I don't know. Cool. Well, hey, thanks for doing this. Yeah, thank you. It's incredible. Thanks so much. incredible to uh see like you know that uh the success that the singles having and that like i hope people listen to the rest of the project because it's like there's some incredible songs on both part one and part two so thanks for doing this thanks for having me cool thanks to tina shay for talking about her career and her new album quantum baby with me and also for indulging my question about tom hanks if you want to hear a playlist of her favorite tina shay songs, check out our playlist at brokenrecordpodcast.com or in the episode notes.

57:57Subscribe to our YouTube channel at youtube.com slash brokenrecordpodcast where you can find all of our new episodes. You can follow us on Twitter at Broken Record. Broken Record is produced and edited by Leah Rose with marketing help from Eric Sandler and Jordan McMillan. Our engineer is Ben Tallade. Broken Record is a production of Pushkin Industries. If you love this show and others from Pushkin, consider subscribing to Pushkin Plus. Pushkin Plus is a podcast subscription that offers bonus content and ad-free listening for$4.99 a month. Look for Pushkin Plus on Apple Podcast subscriptions. And if you like this show, please remember to share, rate, and review us on your podcast app.

58:40Our theme music's by Kenny Beats. I'm Justin Richman.

58:46The more you learn about your favorite artists, the more you want to know. Claude helps you keep digging, finding new threads and rabbit holes to explore. Whether it's discovering deeper meaning behind a detail in an interview or figuring out the influence behind an artist's particular era, Claude thinks with you to find the next clue. If you can't get enough of the stories behind your favorite music and artists, Claude will help you discover new layers you didn't know existed. Try Claude for free at claude.ai slash brokenrecord. This is an ad by BetterHelp. We've all had that epic rideshare experience.

59:20halfway through your best friends, and they know your aspirations to go find yourself in Portugal. It's human. We're all looking for someone to listen. But not everyone is equipped to help. With over a decade of experience, BetterHelp matches you with the right therapist. See why they have a 4.9 rating out of 1.7 million client session reviews. Visit BetterHelp.com for 10 % off your first month. This episode of Broken Record is brought to you by Chase Sapphire Reserve. Traveling is one of life's greatest joys. Honestly, can anything be more exhilarating? Well, actually, yeah, with Chase Sapphire Reserve.

59:58It's your gateway to the world's most captivating destinations. First, you will earn eight times points on all purchases through Chase Travel. And the card gets you into Sapphire Lounge by the club at select airports nationwide and access to one-of-a-kind experiences. Whether you are booking a once-in-a-lifetime trip or your next weekend escape, Discover more with Chase Sapphire Reserve at chase.com slash sapphire reserve. Cards issued by JPMorgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval. Terms apply. This is an iHeart Podcast.

From the publisher

Tinashe’s changing what success in pop music can look like. Back in 2014 her song "2 On" featuring Schoolboy Q hit big on Billboard. With major success looming, Tinashe released projects that missed the charts but gained her a strong, loyal fanbase. In 2019 she left her major label to go independent. And judging from her massive online following today, her fans have stuck behind her.

In April, she dropped the highly meme-able track "Nasty" that many are calling the song of the summer. “Nasty” comes from her album Quantum Baby, the second part in a trilogy of new albums.

Justin Richmond spoke to Tinashe from Amazon Studio 126 about her new albums and what it took to go independent. They also talk about her role in The Polar Express and working with Tom Hanks.

You can hear a playlist of some of our favorite Tinashe songs HERE.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from Broken Record with Rick Rubin, Malcolm Gladwell, Bruce Headlam and Justin Richmond

All 196 episodes
TinasheBroken Record with Rick Rubin, Malcolm Gladwell, Bruce Headlam and Justin Richmond · 50 min
Listen in VO