In short
Podcast Summary: Episode with Philip Calder on Omega-3 Deficiency
Episode Information
- Podcast Title: Live Well Be Well with Sarah Ann Macklin
- Episode Title: 76% of People Don’t Get Enough Omega-3 - And It Affects Your Brain
- Guest: Professor Philip Calder, Expert in Nutritional Immunology
- Main Topic: The global deficit of Omega-3 intake and its implications for health, particularly cognitive health.
Key Points Discussed
- The Global Omega-3 Deficit
- Statistics: 76% of the world fails to meet Omega-3 intake requirements.
- Implications: This deficit contributes to various health issues, including cognitive decline and inflammatory diseases such as arthritis.
- Importance of Omega-3 Fatty Acids
- Main Types: EPA (Eicosapentaenoic Acid) and DHA (Docosahexaenoic Acid).
- Sources: Primarily obtained from fatty fish (e.g., salmon, mackerel, sardines).
- Current Consumption: In the UK, only 25% of the population consumes adequate amounts of fatty fish.
- Recommended Intake
- Government Guidelines: UK recommendation is a minimum of 450 mg of EPA and DHA per day.
- Personal Recommendation by Calder: Suggests at least 1g per day based on health benefits.
- Understanding Inflammation
- Analogy of Fire Brigade vs. Firewall:
- Omega-3s help "put out the fire" of inflammation rather than merely masking symptoms.
- Chronic inflammation can lead to diseases like heart disease and Alzheimer’s.
- Cognitive Health and Alzheimer's
- Connection: Omega-3s are linked to lower risks of cognitive decline and Alzheimer's disease.
- Silent Inflammation: Low-grade inflammation can occur without noticeable symptoms but is harmful over time.
- The Dimmer Switch Effect
- Omega-3s help regulate inflammation within the body, acting as mediators to resolve inflammation.
- Muscle Health and Omega-3
- Muscle Protein Synthesis: Higher omega-3 intake can enhance muscle protein synthesis, crucial for those engaged in resistance training.
- Omega-3 Supplements
- Types of Supplements: Many are labeled as Omega-3-6-9, but Calder recommends focusing solely on Omega-3.
- Concentration Matters: Check EPA and DHA content on labels to avoid supplements with high bulking agents.
- Dietary Concerns and Fish Consumption
- Farmed vs. Wild Fish:
- Farmed fish may contain less EPA and DHA compared to wild fish due to changes in farming practices.
- Concerns over contaminants like mercury and microplastics are noted, particularly in high-chain fish.
- Practical Recommendations
- Eating Fish: Aim for one to two portions of oily fish each week while being mindful of the type of fish and its source.
- Home Cooking: Encouraged as a form of self-care and to ensure nutrient-rich meals.
- Conclusion
- Importance of Omega-3s: The discussion highlighted how crucial Omega-3 fatty acids are for overall health, influencing not just cognitive function but also inflammation and muscle health.
- Action Item: Listeners are encouraged to increase their intake of Omega-3s, particularly through dietary sources such as oily fish.
Additional Resources
- Follow Sarah Ann Macklin:
- Instagram: [@sarahannmacklin](https://www.instagram.com/sarahannmacklin)
- Newsletter: [Sarah's Substack](https://substack.com/@sarahannmacklin)
- Website: [sarahannmacklin.com](https://sarahannmacklin.com)
---
This summary captures the essential discussions and insights from the podcast episode on Omega-3 fatty acids, their significance in human health, and practical steps listeners can take to improve their intake.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOUnderstanding Omega-3 Deficiency
0:45 to 2:30
Discussion on omega-3 deficiency and its prevalence worldwide.
“If you have a higher omega-3 intake, your muscle protein synthesis is increased in response to a meal.”
Omega-3 Sources and Recommendations
2:30 to 5:00
Explores sources of omega-3 and dietary recommendations for intake.
“So that's actually the easy answer to your question.”
Inflammation and Omega-3: The Connection
5:00 to 7:30
Examines the role of omega-3 in managing inflammation and health.
“Yeah, the effects of omega-3s, EPA and DHA on inflammation are one of the central mechanisms by which they maintain health.”
The Mechanism of Inflammation
7:30 to 10:00
Delves into how inflammation functions and its role in various diseases.
“So that's where the inflammation is destroying the person's joints.”
Resolving Inflammation with Omega-3
10:00 to 12:30
Discusses how omega-3s help resolve inflammation and their health benefits.
“So what's happening here is inflammation is happening, but when it shouldn't be happening, so we've lost the ability to resolve.”
Broader Implications of Omega-3
12:30 to 14:00
Explores the links between omega-3 and various health conditions.
“We all know when we feel a bit inflamed.”
The Role of Omega-3s in Inflammation and Brain Health
14:03 to 16:22
Discover how omega-3 fatty acids influence inflammation and cognitive health, particularly in ADHD.
“But the connection actually is they all involve inflammation.”
Nutrition: A Debated Landscape
18:14 to 20:17
Explore the complexities of nutrition recommendations and the importance of individualized approaches.
“I think nutrition is probably one of the most debated topics online.”
The Challenge of Implementing Healthy Eating
20:18 to 22:04
Understand the barriers people face in following healthy eating guidelines and the role of psychology in food choices.
“I mean, the amount of time I think I spend sometimes in sessions with people just trying to undo what they've seen or read online without any understanding.”
Understanding Omega-3 Supplementation
24:24 to 28:00
Gain insights into the importance of omega-3 supplementation and how to choose the right product.
“supplements out there, and people can feel so overwhelmed when even looking at what to buy.”
Show all 28 chapters
Understanding Omega-3 Concentration in Supplements
28:00 to 29:50
Learn how the concentration of EPA and DHA in supplements affects their efficacy.
“But in other words, the more you're taking in, the greater the effect is.”
The Importance of DHA During Life Stages
29:50 to 31:20
Discover why DHA is crucial during pregnancy, infancy, and beyond.
“Now, the algal oils are around about, typically they're about 45%.”
Maternal DHA Transfer to Fetus
31:20 to 34:05
Explore how DHA is transferred from mother to fetus and its significance.
“about pregnancy and someone's wanting to have a supplement, we could talk a bit more about that as well, you know, a DHA-rich supplement might be really important there.”
Concerns About Fish Consumption: Wild vs. Farmed
34:29 to 35:38
Understand the health implications of consuming wild versus farmed fish.
“So is there a difference when it comes to just health, we aren't talking about anything else, with farm fish versus wild organic fish?”
Contaminants in Fish and Health Guidelines
35:38 to 39:45
Learn about the risks of contaminants in fish and dietary guidelines regarding consumption.
“And, you know, it's fundamentally important, obviously.”
Evolution of Fish Farming and Nutritional Quality
39:45 to 42:00
Explore how changes in fish farming practices affect the nutritional quality of seafood.
“What's the minimum amount of fish oil that salmon needs when it's being farmed?”
Nutrient Depletion in Modern Food
42:00 to 43:53
Explore how nutrient levels in food have declined over the years and its implications.
“So of course in the farming industry, I mean we're mainly talking about commodities and I mean you know farm fish is a commodity even though it's not something that everyone is using.”
Farmed vs. Wild Fish: A Nutritional Debate
43:53 to 46:00
Understanding the differences in nutrient content between farmed and wild fish.
“So when the guidelines, the UK recommendations were made, which was 2004, microplastics weren't on.”
The Risk-Benefit Analysis of Fish Consumption
46:00 to 46:32
Benefits of omega-3s often outweigh the risks of contaminants in fish.
“And so when people got a little bit concerned about mercury, for example, in fish, some researchers did like a risk-benefit analysis.”
The Nutritional Value of Fish
46:32 to 47:48
Discussing the broad nutritional benefits of consuming both oily and lean fish.
“Yeah, I think there's another, just to mention that, of course, fish, particularly, you know, oily fish, fatty fish, isn't just about omega-3s.”
The Impact of GLP-1 on Nutrient Intake
47:48 to 51:38
Examining how GLP-1 medications affect eating habits and nutrient deficiencies.
“So one thing that's not balanced, but also kind of a real revolution, and it's a real zeitgeist, this conversation.”
Omega-3s and Muscle Protein Synthesis
51:38 to 56:00
Linking omega-3 intake with increased muscle protein synthesis and overall health.
“So your second question is about the relationship between muscle and omega-3s.”
Understanding Omega-3's Role in Muscle Health
56:00 to 56:30
Explore how omega-3s complement amino acids in muscle building.
“And I'm not saying that's not important to talk about it is.”
The Importance of Omega-3 Awareness
56:30 to 57:14
Learn why many people are unaware of their omega-3 deficiency and its impacts.
“I just think it's fascinating because we started off this conversation by saying 76 % of people are in a deficit.”
Holistic Approach to Nutrition
57:14 to 57:47
Understand the interconnectedness of various nutrients for overall health.
“look at this is I'm not saying this is what you should do, but let's say you think, okay, I'm not actually so interested in heart disease.”
Nutritional Considerations Across Life Stages
57:47 to 58:20
Discuss how nutritional needs change throughout different life stages.
“Because, again, all those things are interconnected.”
Personal Insights on Living Well
58:20 to 59:41
Hear Philip's thoughts on what it means to live well and be well.
“nutrients, multiple organs across the life course.”
The Value of Home Cooking
59:41 to 1:00:28
Discover the importance of cooking from scratch for health and connection.
“And I think something I touched on, which is important, I think, is where you can, you should prepare your own meals from scratch at home using fresh ingredients.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Sarah Ann Macklin:76 % of people are in a deficit and I don't think people know that.
0:03Philip Calder:This is one of the most amazing things that's happened in omega-3 research. Today we're joined by omega-3 expert, Professor Philip Calder. Omega-3s are associated with a lower risk of Alzheimer's disease. We mention IBDs, we mention arthritis and so on. The connection actually is they all involve inflammation. The main source of those is fish, especially fatty fish. In the UK, only 25 % of people are eating these types of fish. Fish oil is used in aquaculture. Aquaculture uses 80 % of the world's fish oil. Farmed salmon in 2026 has less EPA and DHA than farmed salmon in 2005. The food composition tables are probably not accurate.
0:44Philip Calder:Your second question is about the relationship between muscle and omega-3s. And this is really fascinating. If you have a higher omega-3 intake, your muscle protein synthesis is increased in response to a meal. Let's say you think I'm not actually so interested in heart disease. What I'm interested in is the muscles and my performance. So omega-3s are for you as well.
1:06Sarah Ann Macklin:If people are really working hard on their resistance training, really working hard now on their protein intake, this could be just one thing that can also help increase all the things that they're doing already. Hey guys, I am very bad at asking for this, but I wanted to stop for just one minute and ask a huge favour. If you want to hear more diverse conversations from female voices such as myself, I would love if you could hit subscribe. We work so hard on this show to bring you some of the best guests in the world. And having a female voice sometimes gives a different perspective. And I really want to elevate more of that on this channel.
1:43Sarah Ann Macklin:So please hit subscribe if that's important to you, as it is to me. We're in a 76 deficit crisis of omega-3 intake. Now, Philip Cadler, you co-authored a global review that showed that up to 76 % of the world is failing to meet even the minimum intake of omega-3. And this isn't just a developing world problem. So what's happening right now?
2:07Philip Calder:Yeah, so the issue is that the omega-3s we're talking about, the ones we call EPA and DHA, these are the ones that are really important to human health. The main source of those is fish, especially fatty fish. So that's things like salmon, mackerel, herring, sardines and so on. So if people aren't eating those fatty fish, they're not getting enough EPA and DHA. So that's actually the easy answer to your question. So in the UK, only 25 % of people are eating these types of fish. And that means 75 % of people are certainly not getting enough of EPA and DHA.
2:45Sarah Ann Macklin:How much should people be getting to try and reduce that burden?
2:50Philip Calder:Yeah, so you referred to an article that I was recently one of the authors on. And in that article, we tried to gather together all of the different recommendations that have been made around the world for EPA and DHA intake. So here in the UK, the government recommendation is at least 450 milligrams of EPA and DHA per day. that would be equivalent to having one of these fatty fish meals at least once a week, preferably twice, I think. So that's the UK recommendation, at least 450 milligrams per day. But when we looked at the recommendations that have been made in different countries around the world, different countries and regions, they're quite variable.
3:31Philip Calder:So the lowest recommendations that have been made are 200 milligrams per day. Where's that? Well, in fact, the WHO and the European recommendations are 200 or 250 milligrams per day. So the UK recommendation is higher than that. But in some places, there are actually higher recommendations. So for example, in Australasia, the recommendation is up to 610 milligrams per day. So we're talking about recommendations between 200 and 600 milligrams per day, let's say. Now we know, again, from UK data, but also other data, most people are consuming less than 200 milligrams per day, even less than 100 milligrams per day.
4:15Philip Calder:So people are falling well short of the UK recommendation and even short of these lower recommendations. So irrespective of what the recommendation is, most people are not meeting it. And that, I come back to my earlier point, that's because most people are not eating these fatty fish that are the really good sources of EPA and DHA.
4:36Sarah Ann Macklin:The UK guidelines are one portion of oily fish a week. What would you say?
4:41Philip Calder:The UK guidance of at least 450 milligrams per day is good. But my own view is people need more than that, maybe at least a gram a day.
4:53Sarah Ann Macklin:Well, I'm going to now come on to inflammation. inflammation but we've weaved our way into one of the most important topics of omega-3 which is the inflammation conversation and I found this quite genius for how you describe it so people can really understand because I do think I'm hoping people have stuck with us um on you know all the different terms but it can be quite confusing if you've never really heard of this area before sometimes these words can feel quite overwhelming but you mentioned a really amazing analogy that I read which I thought explains it so well when it comes to inflammation and you talk about the fire brigade versus the firewall and looking at omega-3s as kind of an active recovery tool and helping kind of put out that fire as opposed to the ibuprofens and the anti-inflammatories and things that kind of just help you know I would say like put a plaster on it or just put some water over the fire but doesn't fully let the fire out so can you just explain why it's like a firewall and helps block the inflammation and why omega-3s are such an important part here in this conversation.
5:56Philip Calder:Yeah, the effects of omega-3s, EPA and DHA on inflammation are one of the central mechanisms by which they maintain health. Now, I need to say just a little bit about inflammation to start with. So again, inflammation is a physiological process. We need inflammation, It's actually part of the way we defend ourselves, and it's part of the way we heal and repair ourselves. So inflammation is really important to us, to our normal functioning. So inflammation, actually, the way it helps us defend ourselves is to create a toxic environment for bacteria and viruses. So that toxic environment, of course, is within us.
6:44Philip Calder:So it's actually also toxic to ourselves. Now, we're happy to live with that whilst we are infected or damaged in some way, but not in the long term. So the idea of inflammation, it's really the starting point of our immune defense, is to help us to all the really sophisticated immune cells come along and deal with those things. And then our inflammation should go away. So it should be there when it's needed and then go away. That going away is called resolution. resolution of inflammation and resolution biology has become quite a big thing how does our inflammation resolve itself how does it turn itself off what's the dimmer switch so um now unfortunately in some circumstances inflammation doesn't resolve and can become pathological okay and the really good examples of this are actually what we call inflammatory diseases, like rheumatoid arthritis, for example.
7:48Philip Calder:So that's where the inflammation is destroying the person's joints. And you have all the characteristic signs of inflammation, which are redness, swelling, heat, pain, and loss of function. So anyone with arthritis will be saying, okay, I'm familiar with all five of those things. So they're the classic signs of inflammation. So arthritis is an example of a chronic inflammatory condition, inflammatory bowel diseases, active asthma. These are all inflammatory diseases, and people will treat those with anti-inflammatory drugs. And essentially what those anti-inflammatory drugs are doing is controlling the symptoms.
8:30Philip Calder:So it's not actually making the inflammation go away. It's just allowing us to live with the symptoms. Now, it turns out there are some other diseases which are very common, which also involve inflammation. But I call these silent inflammation because the person may not actually be aware. And a good example of this is heart disease, where actually you can have inflammation of the blood vessels. Okay. Another example that we now know is cognitive decline, where you have what's called neuroinflammation, inflammation in the brain. Obesity, you have inflammation of the outipose tissue. So these are a little bit different from, let's say, arthritis, because in arthritis that person has pain.
9:16Philip Calder:They have something, you know, they can't move their hands. They have the loss of function. So with these silent inflammatory diseases, this is a much lower level of inflammation. It's called low-grade inflammation, and the person doesn't really know it's happening, but it's part of the pathology. So what this means is we have high-grade inflammatory diseases. we have low-grade inflammatory diseases, but inflammation is at the core. So one of the really important, I think, realizations of the last 20 years is that inflammation is core to many more diseases than we thought before. Some people say it's actually the root of all diseases.
9:54Philip Calder:I think that's maybe a bit extreme, but certainly it's involved in many diseases, okay? Now, so that's the first thing. So what's happening here is inflammation is happening, but when it shouldn't be happening, so we've lost the ability to resolve. We're not having the resolution. We're not turning down the dimmer switch, okay? So I've talked about that like a fire. You've got a fire burning. So in arthritis, the fire is burning in your joint, metaphorically. in heart disease the fire is burning in your vessel walls in cognitive decline the fire is burning in your brain and you need to put the fire out and that's what resolution is so it turns out i mean this is one of the most amazing things that's happened in omega-3 research in well ever but it's happened in the last 20 years it's relatively recent so there are chemicals that are produced because everything in the body involves messengers and chemicals and hormones of course.
10:55Philip Calder:So there are chemicals that are produced from both EPA and DHA that are central to the resolution of inflammation. So I've talked about this, I mean I'm using dimmer switch as a metaphor now, but I've talked about it as the fire brigade putting out the fire of inflammation. So omega-3s are the substrates to produce the chemicals that are the fire brigade. These are called specialized pro-resolving mediators, and that's because they are specialized to resolve inflammation. So EPA and DHA are responsible, ultimately, for resolution of inflammation. So one of the things that happens when we consume more EPA and DHA, either from fish or supplements, is our cells have more EPA and DHA in them.
11:45Philip Calder:Talked about that early on. And that means we're in a better place to produce these pro-resolving chemicals when we need them. And this actually explains many of the effects of omega-3s that were described in the 1980s, the 1990s, the 2000s. The fact that they can produce these firemen, the fire brigade of the inflammatory system, the dimmer switch of the inflammatory system.
12:12Sarah Ann Macklin:I just think it's absolutely fascinating that such a small little thing can have such a profound effect on our bodies. You know, I think, you know, from all that we've spoken about, if this doesn't want to make you eat oily fish at the end of the day, I'm not quite sure what's going to, because I think none of us want it. We all know when we feel a bit inflamed. And especially if there's people with inflammatory bowel disease, you know, dementia is one of the biggest killers now in the UK. It's, I mean, sadly, I mean, hopefully, we'd never want any disease to be the main killer, but cardiovascular disease is the biggest killer in America, and dementia now is the biggest one here, I think.
12:50Sarah Ann Macklin:You know, and that's personally one that I feared the most. I saw my grandmother suffer with Alzheimer's, and it was one of the saddest things I ever saw. And I think just in having a thought about omega-3s in this conversation, the EPA and the DHA, the ones that you were speaking about, It's just so interesting to think that this could be something that could be preventative and help in that journey.
13:11Philip Calder:And I think this mechanism helps a lot understand the manifold actions of omega-3. So, of course, the effects on heart disease are the most well described. But we now know, mainly through epidemiology, that omega-3s are also associated with a lower risk of cognitive impairment, cognitive decline, Alzheimer's disease. they're associated with lots of other things as well we mentioned IBDs we mentioned arthritis and so on so they're helping with a lot of things so how can that be people struggle with that but actually if you have a central mechanism that inflammation is involved in all of these things and omega-3s are just helping the body control inflammation you can understand why they're so important in all these apparently unconnected conditions.
14:03Philip Calder:But the connection actually is they all involve inflammation. And that's the way omega-3s are working. So I think it helps explain a lot that's known about these fatty acids and a lot that's been known going right back to the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s that wasn't really well understood. And I think some of the emerging areas that you've mentioned probably also have an inflammatory component so things like adhd for example inflammation where um some of the um chemical link-ups that should be happening in the cognitive system are just not working so well so it could explain you know effects of omega-3s in these i'll call them emerging areas these less well researched areas yeah i
14:48Sarah Ann Macklin:I think that is also such an exploding topic. I mean, personally, that's what I became fascinated in. It was just for my own personal understanding that I was just newly diagnosed with neurodiversity and then had a lecture on omega-3s and kind of this emerging research that was coming out. And I found it fascinating. I always think if something isn't detrimental or extreme, you should always try and give it a go to see if it can help you. And you can kind of monitor yourself. And I've never looked back. I mean I'm someone who eats three to four portions of oily fish a week from someone who didn't you didn't eat fish at all you know I did a whole 180 and I didn't used to like fish I mean I mentioned to you before you sat down I used to only eat fish fingers when I was younger and I used to struggle to eat that and so I think you know it's not saying that everyone has to go and eat fish but understanding if it can really help you know ADHD can be so disruptive for so many people and thinking if oily fish could be any type of beneficial help, I think it's worth always exploring it.
15:48Philip Calder:So I think if we go back to how we started, all or most governments and other agencies recommend that people have EPA and DHA. And you know, we talked about the different recommendations. But the reason for that is the literature showing that they are important in maintaining health, whether that's in early life, later life, we've discussed. So it makes sense that people consider ways to get these fatty acids. We've talked about some of that. And it also makes sense that if people are not getting enough, they're just not getting the benefits and their health will probably suffer one way or another eventually.
16:34Philip Calder:But again, of course, they're just part of the whole dietary mix. So there's lots of other important things in there. and you know maybe the effects of omega-3s also depend i mean we talked about omega-6 relationship which is an obvious one but maybe they depend on other aspects of the diet other aspects of lifestyle as well um so i think you know personally i think everyone should be getting should be trying to get enough um because of the you know the health promoting benefit
17:02Sarah Ann Macklin:i attended ted earlier this year and i found myself in conversations with the founders of no watch. You've probably seen me wear something on my wrist and lots of you have messaged me asking me what this is. It looks like a classic watch but it's actually quietly tracking something much more meaningful, your autonomic nervous system. This is the system that governs everything from how you respond, from excitement to anxiety, calm to overwhelm. Most wearables just give you a score but if you're anything like me that score can sometimes make you feel worse, like you're already behind before your day even begins.
17:38Sarah Ann Macklin:No watch works differently. There is no judgment and there is no dopamine chasing dashboard. It simply reflects what your body is already experiencing and also helps you notice what it might be missing. It gives you minute by minute timeline of your stress responses and your recovery. The recovery is the most important part and it's the part that no one talks about and it is often the most revealing marker of our long-term health. In just five days, it calibrates to your body and it builds your personal health fingerprint. You can try for free now for 30 days. And if you use the code LWBW, you can also get 15 % off.
18:13Sarah Ann Macklin:If you want to understand your body, not just through performance, but through self-awareness, then this is where I'd begin.
18:22Sarah Ann Macklin:I think nutrition is probably one of the most debated topics online. Everyone has an opinion. everyone has something to say. The American Food Pyramid that obviously just came out a couple of weeks ago caused one of the biggest kind of online discussions, which I think is great, because people are actually talking about this and everyone has an opinion. And I am much of a belief that there isn't one-size-fits-all. There is such an individual scope here.
18:46Philip Calder:That's right. So I think, you know, that's recognized in the UK in the recommendations that are made that there isn't a one-size-fits-all. And, you know, in the UK we have very, I mean, you can debate the details, but we have very clear sex and life course related recommendations, mainly for micronutrients. Maybe we could do a bit more on that with regard to macronutrients, but certainly the micronutrients, you know, are very well defined by sex and stage of the life course and age and so on. It's not a one size fits all because, you know, different things are happening at different stages of the life course and lots of other things are different.
19:31Philip Calder:But I think everyone has to eat. So nutrition is important to everyone, but that makes everyone have some level of expertise. But unfortunately, there are a lot of people who are not well informed that are happy to share their opinions. and that's not always healthy. I think we should be looking for, I mean, I don't know if expert is the right word, but informed guidance around all matters of lifestyle. In fact, not just diet, but other things as well. Otherwise, I mean, there is a potential for harmful things to happen.
20:16Sarah Ann Macklin:Absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, the amount of time I think I spend sometimes in sessions with people just trying to undo what they've seen or read online without any understanding. And I don't want this to sound like heavy or sad, because I think ultimately everyone is just really trying to do their best. But sometimes if you're a very good marketer, that can steer you away from the evidence-based practices.
20:46Yeah, sure. into those areas of interpreting health information
20:50Sarah Ann Macklin:because it sounds so much more engaging and fun. There is a big thing with people coming in and medications stop working because of certain supplements or, you know, lots of things. And it is, you know, it is really important.
21:03Philip Calder:So I think, I mean, in general, we have quite good healthy eating advice. Unfortunately, not everyone is following that. And I mean, that includes advice around omega-3s and their sources. But, you know, I'm talking more broadly in terms of fiber sources, fruit and veg, stuff like that. So I think you don't have to be a genius to be aware of general healthy eating advice. It's where the people are able to follow and implement that in their own setting, their own situation.
21:36Sarah Ann Macklin:Their own day-to-day.
21:37Philip Calder:And I think that's where maybe... I'm mainly a lab-based researcher. You know, I do laboratory work, I do human trials and so on. But the real gap is around food choices, consumer science and things like that. That is a big gap. You know, getting people to be more able to follow the existing advice. And then the other one is something we touched on, which is the nature of foods that are available to consumers, which have some properties which are less desired, let's say.
Read the full transcript
22:16Sarah Ann Macklin:Yeah, absolutely. I mean, psychology plays a huge role in our food decisions and choices.
22:21Philip Calder:Yeah, the psychology of food choices, that's a big and complex area. But actually, that's something where maybe more resource should be placed. because we have a public health challenge, not just with over consumption of calories, but under consumption of essential nutrients, which I include EPA and DHA in there.
22:48Sarah Ann Macklin:I want to talk about something important to you guys. People today are lonelier than ever. Most long term relationships aren't happy ones. And a third of people under 30 haven't had sex in the past year. Sexual issues among young people have surged over 3 ,000 percent but what most people miss the vast majority of relationships and intimacy struggles aren't physical problems they're psychological and yet most people never get traditional therapy because it feels awkward expensive or just impossible to access. So much about Live Well Be Well's mission is aimed to reduce stigma around health and help us understand ourselves better and that is exactly why I wanted to tell you about Mojo, an app for dating, sex and relationships that I am genuinely excited to tell you about.
23:38Sarah Ann Macklin:They have partnered with the world's leading experts in sexology, including some that you're actually here on this podcast to create expert-led courses. Now, their AI personalizes everything to your specific situation, so you can work through it privately, at home and on your own time. Suffering in silence doesn't help anyone and I don't say this lightly because I've believed in Mojo so much that I've personally invested in the company. Now if any of this resonates go to mymojo.com forward slash livewellbewell and use the code livewell15 for 15 % off. Our sexual well-being matters and everyone deserves support.
24:23Sarah Ann Macklin:There's so many supplements out there, and people can feel so overwhelmed when even looking at what to buy. And it's interesting thinking about that, you know, there's a lot of supplements that are labelled omega-3, 6 and 9. Yes, there are. And I feel like from hearing what you said, this is from my own personal understanding as well, is that we really should just be trying to have more of the omega-3 supplements than opposed to adding the 6 onto it as well.
24:50Philip Calder:I couldn't agree more. So 369, to me, doesn't make a lot of sense. And let's deal with the nine first. So the omega-9 in those supplements is probably oleic acid. Oleic acid is the most prevalent fatty acid in our diets. So we get it a lot from plants. We also get it from animal foods. Not only that, we can make it ourselves. It's not an essential. the amount you will get in a supplement is negligible compared i mean most people are eating like 30 grams of oleic acid a day yeah right so if you've got a supplement that's got
25:29Sarah Ann Macklin:a teeny tiny bit of oleic acid in it that's like useless yeah you can use that word um
25:36Philip Calder:so the nine is not relevant most people are eating enough omega-6 some people would argue they're eating too much. We've talked a bit about that, but they're certainly eating enough. Okay. So we're way above the threshold, for example, to prevent essential fatty acid deficiency. That actually hardly exists. Yeah. Okay. So we're way beyond that. We're talking about, you know, amounts related to long-term health now, not an acute deficiency disease. But we're eating way beyond that. I mean, most, I think in the UK, the average man is eating about 11 grams of linoleic acid a day in a woman, I think about eight or nine grams per day.
26:19Philip Calder:So again, in a capsule, if you're getting a little bit of omega-6, it's not making any difference. The difference is the omega-3 because most people are eating very low amounts of omega-3s. I mean, even alpha-linolenic acid, you might be eating one gram a day. Okay, so linoleic, I said 11 grams. Oleic, I said 30 grams. So we're talking about, you know, an order of magnitude less. So we've got low intake of alpha-linolenic acid, unless people are consuming a lot of flaxseed, flaxseed oil, stuff like that. And we've got very low intakes of EPA and DHA, unless people are eating a lot of oily fish.
26:59Philip Calder:So we're talking tiny amounts. So a capsule, a supplement, can make a big difference to omega-3 intake. It makes no difference to omega-6 and omega-9 intake.
27:09Sarah Ann Macklin:I just think it's so important to clarify that because I can imagine so many listeners will walk in trying to find the right supplement and seeing the omega-3, 6 and 9s. I mean, I remember before I started studying this and thinking that I was doing really good for my health and had no idea of these ratios. So I think, yeah, go in, look for a supplement, but it is just omega-3. And I'd also say, not sure if you agree this, but looking at the back and just seeing what the differences is between EPA and DHA and how much is also bulking agents? Because some supplements are like 30 % of just that supplement and the rest is bulking agents.
27:45Sarah Ann Macklin:And others are like full of 90%. So that's also really important.
27:49Philip Calder:Yeah, so this is super, super important. So all of the effects of EPA and DHA that I've been talking about are related to dose, if you like. They're related to intake. Now that could be intake from fish, could be intake from a supplement. But in other words, the more you're taking in, the greater the effect is. That's really clear, dose-dependent, okay? Now, I think it's really important to distinguish between the oil and the omega-3s, okay? So a standard fish oil, whether that is a fish oil or a liver oil like cod liver oil, a standard fish oil is about 30 % EPA and DHA, okay? So if someone is having a one-gram capsule, that's got 300 milligrams of EPA and DHA, and it's got 700 milligrams of other fatty acids.
28:39Philip Calder:They're naturally present in the fish oil. So let's agree on that. They're not watering the omega-3s down. That's actually how the fish have made it. So it's about a one-third EPA and DHA. So that's why people should look at the label, how much EPA and DHA is in the supplement. Now, it's possible in industry to concentrate the EPA and DHA. So a lot of supplements will be concentrates. So they might have 45 % EPA and DHA. They might have 60 % EPA and DHA. They may even have 90 % of EPA and DHA. So in other words, in a one gram capsule, you could get 450 milligrams, 600 milligrams, 900 milligrams.
29:25Philip Calder:So you're getting less of the other stuff that you don't need. Of course, a concentrate is more expensive. And in general, the more concentrated it is, the more expensive it is. So you can sort of work out the price per 100 milligrams of EPA and DHA, if you like. And, you know, you make your choice. Yeah. Do I want to spend less and get a less concentrated form? Do I want to spend more and get more for that money that I'm putting out? Now, the algal oils are around about, typically they're about 45%. So they're more concentrated than the standard fish oil. But I agree people should look at the label.
30:02Philip Calder:How much EPA and DHA is in here? Now, sometimes the label will have total omega-3s. Total omega-3s doesn't necessarily have to be EPA and DHA. So it's really handy if the label has EPA and DHA on it. About EPA and DHA content. So that's a really interesting question. And so the question is, does it matter if there's twice as much EPA than DHA or twice as much DHA than EPA? So I think that depends on the answer. It depends on who the consumer is. So there's a lot of DHA in the brain and in the eye. So as our brain is developing and as our eye is developing, DHA is really, really important. okay it's not to say that epa isn't important for other parts of the body but dha is vital so and when you think okay when was my brain built some of it was built before you were born and the rest of it was built in the first few years of your life so during pregnancy during lactation and mom and during infancy in the baby dha is really important okay so if you're thinking about pregnancy and someone's wanting to have a supplement, we could talk a bit more about that as well, you know, a DHA-rich supplement might be really important there.
31:31Philip Calder:In infancy, if supplementation is what you want, you know, I would look for a DHA-rich supplement. And later on, both EPA and DHA are important. So in adults, in adolescents, in adults and older people, you know, to me, it doesn't really matter too much whether it's got more EPA or more DHA so long as you're getting enough of those things but it's a life course consideration I think that's really important
31:57Sarah Ann Macklin:the pregnant woman is one of the most important ones to highlight there as well because the third trimester is when the baby's brain is formed and so obviously the mother's needs are increasing during that and that's actually when it's a really important time to make sure so so I mean that's a
32:11Philip Calder:physiologically interesting stage of the life course. So the mother is transferring DHA and also arachidonic acid actually, and other fatty acids as well. But the most interest is DHA because of its role in the eye and the brain. The mother is transferring DHA across the placenta to the fetus. And in fact, the fetus is concentrating DHA. So the fetal blood has a higher concentration than the mother's blood. And of course, things usually go from high to low concentration. But across the placenta, the baby's actually concentrating DHA out of the mother. So where is that DHA coming from? So some of it will come, obviously, if the mother's eating DHA, so dietary DHA, but also DHA stored in adipose tissue, for example.
33:05Philip Calder:And some people have even argued that the mother's brain gives up DHA for the growing fetal brain. Wow, I didn't know that. Yeah, so this has been, so I think the evidence for that is very weak, if existent, but it has been a hypothesis. And some people have used this as a rationale for some of the cognitive and mental changes that can happen in pregnancy and soon after pregnancy, that the mother's brain is losing some of its DHA. So I think it's an interesting thing to think about. But certainly the mother's physiology is set up to provide DHA to the fetus. And then afterwards, of course, breast milk is important.
33:53Philip Calder:Breast milk contains DHA. You know, in Europe, infant formula has to contain a certain amount of DHA actually to mimic the average DHA content of breast milk. So that's a very important stage of the life course.
34:07Sarah Ann Macklin:I'm interrupting for one moment to ask one small favor. Please subscribe to the show. This helps it grow more than you know. And I'm so bad at asking this from you. I'm so bad of thinking about this but you know my goal is a hundred thousand to get to on YouTube and I really want to bring you more content and bigger episodes and we can only do that with your help together so please do hit subscribe thank you when I think about how mums can increase this the one thing that I think comes under fire and it's not just mum there's anyone trying to increase their fish horses right because I can just imagine them going how she not asked this question yet but I don't know if you ever saw see spiricy that documentary that absolutely terrified people of eating fish.
34:51Sarah Ann Macklin:There was a lot of scaremongering in that as there is with so many health documentaries and I think now so many people are worried about whether the fish contains adequate amounts of these of these EPA and DHAs or they're also laced with other like microplastics and chemicals and dyes and so now we find ourselves in this position where people are worried sometimes to choose the farm fish. Environmental conditions I can also understand, but when we're just physically just talking about the health kind of outset of this, people have now watched so many different things on media that it's made them quite fearful.
35:28Sarah Ann Macklin:So is there a difference when it comes to just health, we aren't talking about anything else, with farm fish versus wild organic fish?
35:36Philip Calder:Yeah. So, I mean, this is a brilliant question and, And, you know, it's fundamentally important, obviously. So let's think about wild fish first. So there is a risk of... So the sort of fish we're talking about, omega-3 rich fish, EPA and DHA rich fish, there is a risk in some species particularly, particularly the ones right up the high end of the food chain, because a lot of the things in the sea are passed through the food chain, of course, for those fish to contain contaminants. be that mercury or other types of contaminants, like flame retardants, for example. Now, because of this, going right back to where we started when I talked about the UK government recommendations, so if anyone chose to look at the book that contains the UK government recommendations, which most people don't, most people just say 450 milligrams per day.
36:35Philip Calder:I pointed out it's at least 450 milligrams per day. and what they say in the recommendations almost nobody talks about and that is that men, boys and women not of childbearing age could consider consuming one to four portions of oily fish a week but women of childbearing age should limit to one or two and the reason for that is the point I'm making the concern about contamination being present if people ate, if pregnant women ate, or women of childbearing age in general, ate more than two portions of oily fish a week. So that's actually in the UK recommendations, although almost nobody says that.
37:23Philip Calder:So that's a recognition of the potential for this. Now, having said that, personally I'm not aware of anyone actually being reported as being poisoned. by eating too much oily fish. Now, of course, there's also, in the same recommendations, there's a statement that people, particularly women of childbearing age, should be wary of swordfish, shark. Tuna. I think it's bluefin tuna, and there's one other. There's four fish that are named because they are the highest in the food chain and the most likely to be contaminated. So that's wild fish being discussed. Your question is about farm fish. So we're mainly thinking about salmon here, I think, although there are other farm fish.
38:13Philip Calder:And some trout. So in the wild, salmon are carnivorous. So they eat other fish. And they have a high requirement for EPA and DHA. Okay. So when you farm salmon, you have to give them EPA and DHA, otherwise they don't grow well and also they get sick. Okay. Fish oil is used in aquaculture, fish farming, as a source of EPA and DHA. In fact, aquaculture, fish farming, uses 80 % of the world's fish oil. And humans use most of the other 20%. Wow. Actually, some is used in pet food, which is a growing area. We love our pets. People love their pets, yeah. So both cats and dogs. So the amount being used, so there's sort of a fixed amount of fish oil.
39:11Philip Calder:Yeah. And, you know, that's because it's a natural product that comes from fish that are harvested. There's a sort of a fixed amount. So as these other uses go up, there's going to be less for humans. And we're talking about wanting more so far. So I think that's an important consideration. Fish oil is also expensive compared to vegetable oils. So if you're using it in fish farming, it's an expensive part of the farming industry. So the fish farming industry got very interested in sort of how low could they go. What's the minimum amount of fish oil that salmon needs when it's being farmed? And can we make up the rest with plant oils?
39:58Philip Calder:so if you go back let's say 20 years in salmon farming fish oil was the sole oil that was used okay if you go and look now they use mix mixes of fish oil and the common plant oils that we've been talking about and maybe the fish oil has gone down to about 50 percent so if you go below that threshold, the salmon are not growing well, they're sick, and so on. But if you go above that threshold, the salmon grow fine, they're healthy. The consequence of that for human nutrition is the salmon, although it still contains EPA and DHA, contains less than it would if they were using 100 % fish oil. So in other words, farm salmon in 2026 has less EPA and DHA than farm salmon in, let's say, 2000, 2005.
41:00Wow.
41:01Philip Calder:So that has some consequences. So that means actually the UK government recommendation was made in 2004. And it was based on how much EPA and DHA was in salmon at that stage. If it has less salmon, instead of at least one oily fish per day, maybe we need at least one oily fish per week, maybe we need at least two to get the same amount of EPA and DHA. It also means the food composition tables are probably not accurate. So we can't work out so well how much EPA and DHA people are consuming.
41:35Sarah Ann Macklin:Wow. So you're saying that because we've changed how the aqua farming is distributing the fish oil now to the fish farms in 2026 the fish that we're eating has probably less epa and dha in it than
41:50Philip Calder:it did 10 years ago so i think the first caveat just before people panic too much is that that salmon is still a good source of epa and dha yeah okay so it still has a lot of epa and dha it's just it doesn't have as much as it would have had had it been produced 20 years ago it's
42:06Sarah Ann Macklin:so interesting because when i look about this even and you know like in in farm culture with you know the minerals that's in our soil we know that they've been depleted over the last 50 years dramatically and so how much when we think when we look at you know a bowl of salad that's got you know your spinach and in your tomatoes how much more you might have to eat to compensate what you did 50 years ago precisely is massive the same with meat and how cows obviously eat the grass and similarly now to fish yeah so actually we need more of an abundance in more concentrated forms than ever before.
42:41Philip Calder:So some of this is about cost. So of course in the farming industry, I mean we're mainly talking about commodities and I mean you know farm fish is a commodity even though it's not something that everyone is using. You know there's a desire to keep the price lower. So if you have an expensive product like fish oil, you know the industry will look for an alternative to keep the price of the fish, in this case, lower. I'm sort of guessing, although I haven't had this conversation, that if people were willing to pay more, it wouldn't be such a pressure. But I mean, we're actually talking about the need for more people to be eating these fish.
43:23Philip Calder:So I think having them more expensive is not going to help with that. So maybe it's a good alternative for more people to be eating fish with less EPA and DHA than for fewer people to be eating fish with more epa and dha you're sort of spreading the epa and dha over more people in
43:42Sarah Ann Macklin:a way yeah i just think it's such a sad state of affairs that as we kind of develop more into a world that's meant to become more efficient and better we have more knowledge than ever we're actually more deprived of the nutrients that's in our food because i always say you know supplements to supplement your diet but as it as everything starts dropping it's i'm you know starting to feel like over time in another 50 years, is it going to be an essential? So when we're looking at the verdict on the farm versus the wild fish, the guidelines are one to four for men and women, apart from childbearing and pregnant women, to have one to two because of the microplastics and all the things that are in the, because they're top of the food chain, basically.
44:29Philip Calder:So when the guidelines, the UK recommendations were made, which was 2004, microplastics weren't on. I don't think they'd been discovered. I don't know. But they weren't on the agenda anyway. So the concern then was mercury and other contaminants like flame retardants, for example, which are fat soluble. Okay. So, I mean, but the concern was contamination.
44:55Sarah Ann Macklin:Yeah. And so what I'm saying now is if people were to go into a supermarket and they're going, OK, I've just listened to this podcast. I've heard what the guidelines are, but I also know what the farm fish kind of landscape is. Is there a real difference between which one should choose versus the health benefits? They're going to have higher EPA and DHA on the wild, I feel, and maybe lower on the farm.
45:17Philip Calder:Yeah, they may do. Yeah, yeah.
45:19Sarah Ann Macklin:Will the other things change, like the microplastics and chemicals or not?
45:23Philip Calder:I think it's hard to answer that question because I don't actually know the level of undesirable ingredients, more ingredients isn't the right word, chemicals, in farm fish versus wild fish. I think I'll come back to the point I made earlier. I'm not really aware of people suffering adverse consequences due to contaminants in either farmed or wild fish as something that's happening at all. I'm not saying it has never happened. Yeah. And so when people got a little bit concerned about mercury, for example, in fish, some researchers did like a risk-benefit analysis. So if you've got risks from the contaminants, but you've got benefits from the omega-3s, and they're both together, how does that weigh up?
46:21Philip Calder:So again, this was in the early 2000s when these issues first came up. and those studies almost always came to the conclusion that the benefits outweigh the risks in other words the benefits of having more omega-3s outweighs the risk of the possibility
46:37Sarah Ann Macklin:of low levels of contaminants i think that's really interesting people to hear yeah right knowing that actually yeah there is things that maybe aren't the best for you in there but actually the benefit of getting these ep and dhas kind of yeah makes it worthwhile making sure you're including them.
46:53Philip Calder:Yeah, I think there's another, just to mention that, of course, fish, particularly, you know, oily fish, fatty fish, isn't just about omega-3s. You know, you've got good quality protein in fish, you've got fat-soluble vitamins, and you've got a lot of some of the trace elements, for example, selenium, iodine, things like that.
47:17Sarah Ann Macklin:And iodine's so important because we're also seeing an iodine deficiency right now from the reduction of dairy in our diets.
47:22Philip Calder:Yeah. So, I mean, fish is a very good nutritional package. And actually, you know, white fish, lean fish is also a good nutritional package. Just doesn't have so much of the EPA and DHA. So I think, you know, being more holistic about fish as a food, lean fish, oily fish, you know, it's not just the omega-3s, although they are important. There's lots of other things in there as well.
47:47Sarah Ann Macklin:It's all about balance, Phil. You know, it's all about balance. It's all about balance.
47:51Philip Calder:Everything's about balance.
47:52Sarah Ann Macklin:So one thing that's not balanced, but also kind of a real revolution, and it's a real zeitgeist, this conversation. I mean, it's one of the most interesting things that's happened in the pharmaceutical world in decades, and it's GLP ones. There's so much discussion around this. But something that I find really interesting, just from a nutritionist perspective, is like seeing how important that people who do go on these drugs actually look at the micro macro intake on their diet because obviously it blunts your appetite which means that you're eating less and we know that when people do that they're more at risk of a nutrient deficiency and there's so much buzz around protein right now that we kind can't get away from it and it is really important but there's so many other also parts of the diet that are also important to talk about and I saw this week that Marks and Spencers has actually released a line of food that is specific towards people on GLP-1.
48:47Sarah Ann Macklin:So these meals are smaller, but they're more nutrient dense. They've got a higher quality of amino acids for your protein, they've got rich omega-3s in. And what they're trying to do is saying, well, obviously you can't eat large amounts. So what we'll do is we'll make these more smaller and more specified to you to making sure that you're maintaining a good micronutrient baseline. I think that's really important. The one thing that I found really important when looking at this and kind of looking at today's conversation was how omega-3 also plays a really important role within this guideline, but also within the connection to muscles.
49:24Sarah Ann Macklin:Because I think protein is so widely spoken right now, but we forget that omega-3 is also really important in helping our muscles as well. So can you tell me why that's so important that we shouldn't be forgetting this?
49:36Philip Calder:So I think GLP-1 receptor agonists obviously are increasingly used, and it's clear they work very well. They manage to get people to lose weight quite quickly. Yeah. And this is mainly fat that they're losing. There's also some discussion about loss of lean mass, which probably is mainly protein, but it might be other things as well. And, you know, these are working by suppressing appetite. So people obviously are eating less. Now, this could be problematic because if people are eating a low essential nutrient diet already, and that could include EPA and DHA, I'm including that along with the vitamins and minerals and so on, and they reduce intake of their diet, they're going to be getting even less of these important nutrients.
50:24Philip Calder:And I think one of the issues which relates a bit to the last topic we were talking about, or the one before that, is many people have moved to energy-rich, essential nutrient-poor diets. So if that's a diet that people are choosing to eat, but now they want to eat it in a much lower amount, okay, they're cutting down their energy intake, but they're also cutting down their essential nutrient intake. So this could be quite an adverse thing. So it's very interesting that this trend that you mentioned has happened, where I think people are wanting more protein, but there's definitely a need for more protein.
51:12Philip Calder:But packing into that more vitamins, more minerals, more omega-3s, and so on. So people will actually not only be reducing their caloric intake, but they will be increasing the intake of essential nutrients. So I think that's a good thing. And although maybe this is a focus for people who are receiving GLP-1 receptor agonists, this is actually the sort of diet that everyone should be eating, right? So this is actually maybe an innovation that will improve health more widely than the intended target group. So your second question is about the relationship between muscle and omega-3s. And this is really fascinating.
51:51Philip Calder:So I mentioned before that when people consume more omega-3s, they get into lots of tissues in the body. That includes skeletal muscle. That's been very well described. There's some time course and dose response studies looking at people's skeletal muscle. This has mainly actually been done in young people interested in physical activity, partly because of the interest in muscle and exercise performance. It would be good if some of this research was done maybe in older people who are at risk of loss of lean mass. That hasn't happened quite so much yet. So throughout the day, people are breaking down muscle to release amino acids for use elsewhere in the body and then they're rebuilding muscle so there's a turnover of muscle protein okay and what happens is when you eat a meal you build up your muscle and then after a period of time you start breaking it down then you have another meal you build it up again so if you're in a steady state over the course of a day you're not really using muscle you've just been turning it over of course if you're growing, like in childhood and adolescence or bodybuilding, you're making more protein over the course of the day.
53:00Philip Calder:But you've got this turnover. So you can study the breakdown and the synthesis of muscle protein experimentally. So it's very well defined, this rhythm that people have. So some researchers here in the UK, but also in North America, have done studies to see if omega-3s somehow are playing a role in regulating this muscle protein turnover. So one of the things that drives muscle protein breakdown is inflammation. So the thinking was, if omega-3s are anti-inflammatory, they could slow the breakdown. Now, when people did these studies, they actually found that omega-3s increase synthesis of protein.
53:48Philip Calder:They increase muscle protein synthesis. They might also decrease breakdown, but they seem to primarily promote synthesis. So it's not really understood how that happens, the mechanism, but it turns out if you have a higher omega-3 intake, your muscle protein synthesis is increased in response to a
54:11Sarah Ann Macklin:And for people that don't know what muscle protein synthesis is, just explain.
54:16Philip Calder:So that's making muscle protein. So your muscle is mainly composed of protein, right? That's how your muscles work, because it contains proteins that drive contraction. And when you have the contraction increase and decrease in contraction, that's how you're actually moving. So that's promoting your mobility for skeletal muscle. You have to be muscle protein synthesis is making new muscle proteins. And as I've said, that's happening all the time in real time, but it happens in response to a meal because you've got amino acids in your meal that you can use to support the muscle protein synthesis because proteins are made of amino acids.
54:55So this process is increased by omega-3 fatty acids.
55:01Philip Calder:Okay. So this effect is called an anabolic effect. So anabolism is making things. catabolism is breaking things down. So the main drivers of increasing muscle protein synthesis are insulin. And of course, after you have a meal, insulin levels go up. And also the presence of particular amino acids called branched chain amino acids. And omega-3 seem to increase the response to insulin and branched chain amino acids. So it could be if you want to make protein, having a higher omega-3 intake could really increase this.
55:34Sarah Ann Macklin:Wow. Well, I'm just thinking, you know, resistance training has been on the forefront now of the conversation for so long, especially for women, especially when they're going through pre and post-menopausal. But, you know, we do say on the show that everybody should be doing some type of resistance training. You know, 10 years ago, people spoke a lot more about cardio, but now we're really understanding the importance of our muscles for our health. And I just don't think this has been spoken about as much. You know, we talk about how important it is with protein timing and protein quality. And I'm not saying that's not important to talk about it is.
56:03Sarah Ann Macklin:But it's interesting that omega-3 hasn't come into the picture of the mention of this conversation.
56:08Philip Calder:So this is an emerging area. I mean, obviously, the overriding effect is having the amino acids there to build the muscle. OK, so omega-3s can't replace amino acids, right? You need amino acids to build muscle. So I don't want people to get the wrong idea. But what I'm saying is you just get an increment if the omega-3s are there. That process is working just a bit more efficiently, I suppose, as a way to think of it.
56:30Sarah Ann Macklin:I just think it's fascinating because we started off this conversation by saying 76 % of people are in a deficit. And I don't think people know that. I don't think people maybe are aware that they might be in a deficit. And if people are really working hard on their resistance training, really working hard now on their protein intake, this could be just one thing that can also help increase all the things that they're doing already. You know, a lot of people who listen to the show are very much into preventative health. You know, they want to learn, they want to figure out like, what is the science-based evidence right now that I can do to put myself in the best position.
57:04Sarah Ann Macklin:And it's just interesting. This is such an interesting area that this one small tweak, if they are deficient and they start consuming more fish, could be a massive game for them.
57:13Philip Calder:Yeah, sure. So I think, you know, a way to look at this is I'm not saying this is what you should do, but let's say you think, okay, I'm not actually so interested in heart disease. What I'm interested in is my muscles and my performance. So omega-3s are for you as well. So I think a way to look at this is it's a bit more holistic. Yeah. So you shouldn't really think about one organ system. So don't only think about the brain or the heart or the muscle, because they're all interconnected and they're all in the same body. And don't only think about omega-3s. Think about your protein. Think about your micronutrients.
57:53Philip Calder:Think about your total energy intake. Because, again, all those things are interconnected. did. So I think we have to think in a much broader sense. And, you know, there aren't actually magic bullets. We're just trying to get our physiology to a more optimal state. OK. And that is physiology across the whole body, across the whole life course. And we've touched on some things around pregnancy and so on. Mentioned older people at one stage. And, you know, we're thinking multiple nutrients, multiple organs across the life course.
58:24Sarah Ann Macklin:So Philip, I guess I always leave with one lasting question, which I ask the same to every guest, which basically is a similar formula for health. Everyone has their own opinion of what that means for them. So Philip, what does live well, be well mean to you?
58:39Philip Calder:Living well and being well is complex. So I think for me, primarily a good quality diet is part of that, by which I mean plenty of fruit and veg and other plant-sourced foods. Eating oily fish is certainly part of it. I think trying to get enough fibre is important. And, you know, maintaining calorie intake, trying to maintain weight, you know, that can be a struggle of course. Physical activity is the other side of the coin but other things like you know getting enough sleep is really important those sorts of things. Social interactions of course are important. I think the things you do in your spare time are also important to your health and well-being but it is complicated and it's different for different people and you know it can be hard to follow when people have busy lives, which could be busy professionally, but they could be busy domestically as well.
59:41Philip Calder:And I think something I touched on, which is important, I think, is where you can, you should prepare your own meals from scratch at home using fresh ingredients. I don't mean never go out and eat. Of course, that's brilliant. And that's part of having a good life as well. But I think, you know, the mainstay is good old-fashioned home cooking, I think.
1:00:03Sarah Ann Macklin:Yeah, I love that. I mean, I feel like that's massively declined, but I think it's one of the most things that you... I think it's the biggest form of self-care that you can give yourself is cooking for yourself and cooking for people you love. It's definitely a love language. It's definitely one of my love languages. So we all want to get people back in the kitchen. Philip, thank you so much for coming on to Live Well, Be Well and divulging us for such a plethora and amazing evidence on Omega-3.
1:00:27Philip Calder:Well, thanks for having me. It's been great.
1:00:29Sarah Ann Macklin:I hope you all now go and eat one to two portions of oily fish a week.
From the publisher
Exciting news - pre-order my debut book
Did you know that 76% of the world is failing to meet even the minimum intake of Omega-3?. It’s a staggering number that honestly stopped me in my tracks. We often hear about "healthy fats" in a vague way, but when you realize we are living in a global deficit crisis, it changes how you look at your dinner plate. This isn't just a "nutrition fact", it is a fundamental building block of our health that most of us are simply missing.
I’m joined by Professor Philip Calder, a world-leading expert in nutritional immunology. He has spent decades researching how what we eat literally communicates with our immune system, and today, he’s breaking down the science of Omega-3 in a way that is so practical and easy to understand.
Here’s What We Dive Into:
- The Global Omega-3 Deficit: Why 76% of the world is failing to meet basic requirements and what that means for our long-term health.
- Fire Brigade vs. Firewall: A genius analogy to help you understand how Omega-3s actually "put out the fire" of inflammation rather than just masking the symptoms.
- The Truth About Intake: Why the government recommendation of 450mg might not be enough, and why Philip suggests aiming for at least 1g a day.
- Silent Inflammation: Understanding the "low-grade" inflammation that could be happening in your blood vessels or brain without you even knowing it.
- Cognitive Health & Alzheimer’s: The deeply personal connection between fatty acids and protecting our brains as we age.
- The "Dimmer Switch" Effect: How Omega-3 acts as a specialized mediator to resolve inflammation and return your body to balance.
Love,
Sarah Ann 💛
***
This episode is sponsored by:
NOWATCH: The compassionate health tracker
Connecting body and mind with unique stress recovery insights so you can live fully today
15% off with code LWBW15 at https://nowatch.com/
Mojo: the app for expert-led courses in better sex.
Learn from world-class sex therapists and relationship experts with courses tailored to your needs.
15% off with code LiveWell15 at mymojo.com/livewellbewell
***
The Great British Veg Out
How to support your gut, energy, and hormones by eating more — not less.
👉 https://sarahmacklin.substack.com/p/the-great-british-veg-out
Reset Your Health
If your body feels off after stress, travel, or burnout — this is where to start.
👉 https://sarahmacklin.substack.com/s/reset-your-health-in-30-days
👉 Practical beats perfect.
Here’s a free 5-recipe PDF I use to support energy and stress during busy weeks.
https://open.substack.com/pub/sarahmacklin/p/download-your-free-5-recipes-to-relieve
👉 If this resonates, you can join the thousands who read
The Compassionate Cure each week. https://sarahmacklin.substack.com/
***
If You Enjoyed This Episode, You Might Also Like:
Dr. Zach Bush on Glyphosate, the Microbiome & What Modern Medicine Gets Wrong
***
Sign up to Sarah’s Compassionate Cure newsletter:
Science Simplified, Health Humanised.
Join thousands in exploring actionable insights that prioritise compassion, clarity, and real-life impact.
https://sarahmacklin.substack.com/
***
Highlights
Highlights
Intro (00:00:00)
How Much Omega-3 Do You Actually Need Every Day? (00:01:47)
How Fatty Acids Put Out Internal Fires (00:09:40)
Omega-3, Brain Health, and Alzheimer’s (00:12:22)
How to Spot Misinformation Online (00:18:22)
Why You Should Avoid Omega 3-6-9 Supplements (00:24:23)
EPA vs. DHA Ratios: Which One Should You Prioritise? (00:30:19)
How Feed Affects Nutritional Value (00:38:14)
Balancing Risk vs. Nutritional Reward (00:43:43)
GLP-1 (Ozempic) Concerns (00:47:52)
Can Healthy Fats Prevent Muscle Loss? (00:51:44)
Why Home Cooking is the Ultimate Act of Self-Care (00:57:05)



