In short
Two hosts unpack the psychological “shadow” behind power and influence revealed in the Epstein Files, arguing that public personas (including spiritual gurus and medical authorities) can mask darker private behavior. They connect this to health misinformation, algorithmic “confident” messaging, reduced empathy under success, and the “halo effect”/just-world thinking that leads people to excuse ethical missteps. They also discuss how women can add their voices without cynicism, using discernment (gap between teaching and real-life behavior, how people treat those with no power, and listening to gut/heart signals).
Guest background
Dr Gemma Newman is a lifestyle medicine expert and best-selling author. She focuses on mind-body connections and self-compassion in health, and promotes her book Healthy Shouldn’t Be This Hard (new book mentioned; pre-order May 28).
Key claims
Power can enlarge one’s shadow; success can reduce empathy; hypocrisy is especially striking in spiritual gurus; misinformation thrives when people feel permission to stop thinking; accountability is often lacking; “non-attachment” teachings can become harmful if they undermine responsibilities.
Notable examples
Deepak Chopra’s emails to Epstein; Prince Andrew; Martin Luther King (mentioned with conflicting claims about alleged private behavior); “What the Health” documentary (criticized for cherry-picking).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOExploring Power and Influence
0:45 to 1:30
Discussion on how power can affect individuals and their behaviors.
“And can two truths be held at the same time?”
Understanding the Shadow Self
1:30 to 2:16
Insight into the concept of the 'shadow self' and its implications on success.
“For the last two years, I have kept a secret from you.”
Contradictions of Spiritual Gurus
2:16 to 3:45
The hypocrisy of well-known gurus contrasted with their public personas.
“So if you need a helping hand, if you want a new way to live and be well, then buy my new book, Healthy Shouldn't Be This Hard, out on May the 28th, but you can pre-order it now.”
The Dilemma of Confidence in Health Advice
3:45 to 4:05
Debate on confidence versus expertise in health advice today.
Critique of Health Narratives
4:05 to 6:40
How health narratives can be shaped by misinformation and confidence.
“I have to try to understand the evidence base and what research we have so far and what research could actually counteract that research and which is the most reliable.”
Psychology of Success and Empathy
6:40 to 8:35
Exploration of how success can disconnect empathy and moral judgment.
“What fears you the most right now in the landscape where health is today?”
Narcissism and Empathy in Success
9:35 to 14:05
Discussion on narcissism and its relation to increased power and decreased empathy.
“So initially we could be thinking, wow, we're doing great things for the world, for the planet, for other people.”
Understanding Narcissism and Power Dynamics
14:05 to 16:21
Explore how power can influence empathy and promote narcissistic traits.
“that is essentially part of someone's personality whereas this idea of the increasing um power causing reduced empathy is actually, it's not necessarily an intrinsic personality trait.”
The Concept of the Shadow in Psychology
16:21 to 19:17
Learn about Carl Jung's concept of the shadow and its implications on behavior.
“And so for what it's worth, I'm not really sure how you pronounce Carl Jung.”
Hero Worship and Its Psychological Roots
19:17 to 22:20
Discusses the phenomenon of hero worship and the shadows of admired figures.
“I think this was a big thing that ignited us to want to have this conversation.”
Show all 32 chapters
Navigating Vulnerability in Health Professionals
24:27 to 26:44
Examine the psychological impact of trust and vulnerability in health settings.
“Some people are more power hungry than others.”
Accountability and the Epstein Files
26:44 to 28:00
Discuss the need for accountability in the context of the Epstein files.
“even in kind of the aftermath of the Epstein files.”
The Complexity of Emotional Reactions
28:00 to 29:10
Explore the mixed emotions surrounding public figures' downfalls.
“We saw him get arrested, which I have to admit did give me a sense of pleasure.”
Women's Voices in Health Conversations
29:11 to 30:53
Discuss the importance of amplifying women's perspectives in health discussions.
“And I feel that the woman's voice gets diluted a lot in these conversations.”
Navigating Trust and Disappointment
30:54 to 33:10
Learn how to discern authenticity in public figures and healers.
“But in a way, actually, I think anger that has been well considered and thoughtful is not necessarily harmful.”
Personal Integrity vs. Popularity
33:11 to 35:29
Understand the struggle of maintaining integrity when facing influential personalities.
“And it completely conflicted everything I thought this person was teaching.”
The Importance of Self-Trust
35:30 to 37:38
Examine the significance of trusting one's instincts in personal and professional spaces.
“and so jarred by the whole thing that I didn't want to do a disservice to my audience.”
Responses to the Epstein Files
37:39 to 40:06
Discover the reactions to discussions around the Epstein files and their implications.
“I mean, it's not necessarily an ironclad indicator, but if someone's constantly name dropping and constantly kind of interested in their legacy over anything else, that kind of gives you a clue.”
Reflections on Personal Experience and Knowledge
40:07 to 42:04
Reflect on how personal experiences shape understanding of complex issues.
“People who I didn't even know read my substack, contacted me.”
Understanding Instincts and Overwhelm
42:04 to 43:31
Explore the importance of trusting your instincts amidst conflicting information.
“And that's why, you know, in our conversation today, I'm talking about at least understanding what does your gut, heart and brain tell you.”
The Influence of Strong Narratives
43:31 to 45:59
Discuss how strong opinions can create paralysis and influence our decision-making.
“Being discerning, recognizing your own shortfalls as best you can, but also recognizing your own strengths and not downplaying them.”
Spirituality, Non-attachment, and Accountability
45:59 to 49:26
Investigate the risks of spiritual teachings that promote non-attachment without accountability.
“And anyway, the guy who's run it now has gone to prison and he's got life imprisonment.”
The Dangers of Abandoning Responsibilities
49:26 to 51:23
Analyze the consequences of spiritual practices that neglect personal responsibilities.
“So yeah, I think matriarchal ways of embracing spirituality would emphasize loving connections and community and nature as well as ideas of non-attachment.”
Public Persona vs. Private Actions
51:23 to 54:22
Delve into the disparity between public personas and private behaviors of influential figures.
“well, it's interesting because you can have people that have great influence and do great things in the world.”
Conscious Integration and Discernment
54:22 to 56:00
Learn about the importance of integrating personal truths for authentic living.
“I think values are spoken about and virtues are spoken about quite flippantly in relationships.”
Exploring the Ethical Dilemma of Billionaires in Health
56:00 to 57:40
The discussion delves into the complexities of billionaire influence on global health, particularly focusing on Bill Gates' role.
“So yes, it can feel quite complicated, but really what it comes down to is conscious discernment and integration.”
Accountability and Power Structures in Health
57:40 to 1:00:00
The speakers emphasize the need for accountability in health systems and how power dynamics can impact public welfare.
“But I do believe that accountability structures are vital in this world that we live in because we are human.”
Self-Discerning Practices for Better Health Decisions
1:00:00 to 1:02:20
Discussion on the importance of self-awareness and discernment in making healthy choices and understanding influences.
“And that needs to be done on a global scale, but we have to start with ourselves.”
Navigating the Landscape of Cancel Culture
1:02:20 to 1:04:40
The conversation addresses the challenges of cancel culture and the complexity of calling out individuals while considering intent.
“And I hope that conversations like this will help people to do that too, actually.”
Trust, Kindness, and the Importance of Discernment
1:04:40 to 1:09:20
The speakers highlight the significance of trust, kindness, and discernment in personal interactions and public discourse.
“Is there a gap between what they're actually saying to you and how they treat people without power?”
The Importance of Kindness in Conflict Resolution
1:10:04 to 1:11:09
Learn how kindness influences our interactions and decision-making.
Gratitude and Vulnerability in Conversations
1:11:09 to 1:11:39
Explore the value of gratitude and vulnerability in discussions.
“And yeah, I'm just really grateful that you have spoken out in a kind of compassionate way.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00So we're two women unpacking the Epstein Files. Scary stuff, eh? Are you ready? I'm ready. Bring it on. Dr Gemma Newman, lifestyle medicine expert, best-selling author. So what do the Epstein Files reveal about the experts we gave power to? Does power go to our heads?
0:18Dr Gemma Newman:I think power can very easily go to our heads, if left unchecked. Is this unpacking or revealing their shadow selves? I think sometimes the more success we have, the larger our shadow can become. So what's the shadow? The shadow is that part of ourselves that we try to deny or repress, that we feel a little bit ashamed of. When we have a public persona that we polish, it's really hard for us to see darkness that can then filter through underneath that we try to deny. And can two truths be held at the same time? It's very true that that can be the case. and we've seen how the Epstein Files shows us this psychological map of power and influence and how it can change us actually.
1:01Were you shocked at who came out in the Epstein Files?
1:03Dr Gemma Newman:I wasn't shocked and that's the interesting thing. I think because I have a very deep understanding that we are all human and we all have bits of ourselves that we'd rather avoid. But what did surprise me was the hypocrisy of the spiritual gurus that proclaim one thing and are so obviously doing another. I just had a really heavy, dark feeling. Your gut and you. What fears you the most? The idea that we are naturally inclined to. For the last two years, I have kept a secret from you. And it's this. It's my new book, Healthy Shouldn't Be This Hard. And I think it is a problem that we are all feeling.
1:42And I was feeling it so much that I wrote a book on it. Now, if you've been a guest of this podcast for a while, you know that I am all about kindness, self-compassion. But when I dug into the research of this, my mind exploded. The connection between the mind and body is so integral, but we completely miss out on all the conversations on health, on how we speak to ourselves. And that is such a driving factor on how our food responds to what we eat to, the choices that we make. And we are so overwhelmed right now in the$8.5 trillion industry that is the wellness industry, which is predicted to be by 2027.
2:19So if you need a helping hand, if you want a new way to live and be well, then buy my new book, Healthy Shouldn't Be This Hard, out on May the 28th, but you can pre-order it now. I'll pop the link below in the show notes and I would love if you could support me on this and I honestly think it will support you too. Yama, welcome back to Live Well, Be Well. Thank you, Sarah. I'm delighted. excited oh I'm excited about today me too are you ready I'm ready here we go okay I've been thinking about this a lot and I know you have too do you think we're living in a time where confidence in health advice is outperforming expertise it's a great question it's a leading question and I'd say absolutely yes and I feel that that's led by lots of different things but
3:14Dr Gemma Newman:But the number one thing that I think plays into it the most is probably algorithmic success. Things that are punchy, things that are controversial, things that are outliers, things that blow people's minds. Other things that people click on, watch, scroll, repeat. And so if someone says something confidently enough, everybody listens. Why do you think that confident voices travel so much further online than nuanced ones? because I think that's the big thing that I've just heard from you there yeah I think there's a part of ourselves that almost likes to um almost likes to put um less less pressure on ourselves to think when we see somebody else so confident it almost gives us permission to switch off and just think yeah okay um it's more comfortable I think for us to not have to use our own um I don't want to say intuition but at least our own ideas of um how we critically analyze something how do we how do we look at the pros and cons how do we establish the research base and it also takes so much more effort to look at something more critically especially for someone like me who, you know, obviously I have to do that as a doctor.
4:40Dr Gemma Newman:I have to try to understand the evidence base and what research we have so far and what research could actually counteract that research and which is the most reliable. And when it takes so much more effort to counteract a false claim than it does just to say whatever you want and say, well, study shows this, study shows that, or I really feel this, and this is my reason. And then you could kind of come up with 10 different things and the other person can just kind of go what and get bamboozled and get confused and just think okay well you know what they're confident yeah I'll go with it absolutely well I think what that preys on is vulnerability in other people and I mean I know that podcasts are one of the prime places today of misinformation and social media but even if we go back to like Netflix shows and documentaries and you know there was a really interesting one I don't know if you remember called What the Health?
5:33Dr Gemma Newman:Yes, I do remember that one. Yeah. And I actually renamed it What the Fuck. That's the first time I've ever sworn on Live Well Be Well in five years. Oh, so privileged. Which is the first time. Thank you for that. Because I watched that and the cherry picking of evidence was so outrageous that it led the story narrative into what the producers wanted the outcome to be. And I think I was always told from the beginning of when I started studying nutritional science that a really good scientist will always try and disprove their hypothesis wrong so they will try and look at all the surrounding evidence to say is this really true now what I see and I'm sure you agree is the flip side people have a hypothesis and they want to do everything they can to make that right and will outline all the other evidence that kind of weighs up the for and against yeah I definitely see that online more than anywhere else but I think it's also a facet of human nature we want to feel right and we want to be able to trust ourselves and our point of view and we also it is very hard for us to accept when we're wrong and I think the ego can play into that for everybody but yes I think that's one of the core facets of science in general is the understanding that you almost you almost welcome a bit of critique because it allows you to see the things that you would otherwise miss and I think that's an important quality that we should take into the rest of our lives as well and it's something that's very hard I find it very hard actually but necessary so I feel as though sometimes the more success people have both in terms of what maybe in scientific world but in life in general the harder it is to receive feedback that's genuine honest and can actually um help us to see our own blind spots um so yeah i think that's really important in in the scientific process and in life and a lot of the people that we see in not just on social media but in celebrity world as well like they they've got a skewed sense sometimes of objective reality and there's probably not that many people around them telling them that what they might be doing is wrong or what they might be saying is incorrect and then if they do get called out then the natural instinct is to double down, the natural instinct is to deflect, natural instinct is to deny and I think it's really important for us to recognize that in ourselves and in other people.
8:11What fears you the most right now in the landscape where health is today? it fears me the most well in the context of today's discussion I think
8:24Dr Gemma Newman:the idea that we are naturally inclined to equate success with goodness um and I think that tendency can lead us down the wrong path sometimes and it's so interesting when we look at the psychology of it, right? Because you see someone that's good looking, you see someone that's successful, you see someone that is well connected or wealthy, and there's this subconscious tendency to put that positive impression onto their moral value as well. And I think when we do that, we can sometimes really slip up. How do we navigate that? Awareness, I think, is really important. I mean, yeah, I was researching a little bit about the psychology of this in the wake of the Epstein files and all the information that's come out about people and the unexpected things that have come out about it and the shocks that people have had.
9:31Dr Gemma Newman:and I think that being aware of these patterns is really important so there's something you know like I mentioned earlier we sort of give we equate these positive things to people's moral value and we also have this understanding about you know the halo effect if somebody is good at one thing then they're automatically going to be potentially good at other things or highly moral people and that's just simply not the case and because we like someone or like something that they're put out we also have this tendency to um assume that any kind of ethical misstep is a mistake will underplay in our minds and we do that in relationships as well right we do that we can sometimes do that um in our personal relationships um and i think that that is human nature we want to connect with people on that very real level but we can definitely sort of fall foul of that instinct and um i was looking at this as well with regards to the way that we act around people and i think it's fascinating because i was reading that um a lot of us have this uh understanding of the world where um things that are just are right and that that people will receive their comeuppance in the end like the just world like karma karma yeah and you know I think sometimes that way of thinking can also lead us to be more vulnerable to not only um being misled but also into being dishonest ourselves because it was so interesting I I've had some really interesting research Dasha Keltner did around this, where essentially when we have a feeling that we are more powerful or that we are more successful, some of the empathy regions of our brain kind of switch off.
11:30Dr Gemma Newman:So initially we could be thinking, wow, we're doing great things for the world, for the planet, for other people. And then the more power and success that we feel, he was doing interesting studies around sort of functional MRI scans that show that those kind of mirror neuronal pathways that show you know that we laugh when other people laugh or that we feel tense when other people feel tense they kind of get switched off a little bit and I think again that's a really important thing to be aware of have an understanding of so that we can look at these patterns in ourselves and in other people wow yeah I want to talk about something important to you guys.
12:06People today are lonelier than ever. Most long-term relationships aren't happy ones and a third of people under 30 haven't had sex in the past year. Sexual issues among young people have surged over 3 ,000 percent but what most people miss the vast majority of relationships and intimacy struggles aren't physical problems they're psychological and yet most people never get traditional therapy because it feels awkward expensive or just impossible to access. So much about Live Well Be Well's mission is aimed to reduce stigma around health and help us understand ourselves better. And that is exactly why I wanted to tell you about Mojo, an app for dating, sex and relationships that I am genuinely excited to tell you about.
12:54They have partnered with the world's leading experts in sexology, including some that you're actually here on this podcast to create expert-led courses. Now, their AI personalizes everything to your specific situation so you can work through it privately, at home, and on your own time. Suffering in silence doesn't help anyone. And I don't say this lightly because I've believed in Mojo so much that I've personally invested in the company. Now, if any of this resonates, go to mymojo.com forward slash livewellbewell and use the code livewell15 for 15 % off. Our sexual well-being matters and everyone deserves support.
13:39That's so interesting because I guess to me and I could be completely wrong here and I have to be really careful of using this word. I've only used it once on the show before but they seem to inherit from what I'm listening to certain traits like like narcissism right where you become more inflated and less connected to the kind of
13:59Dr Gemma Newman:empathy of other people yes I think I think sometimes yeah you're right so I think with the idea around narcissism I think it's considered to be sort of an early years trait or something that is essentially part of someone's personality whereas this idea of the increasing um power causing reduced empathy is actually, it's not necessarily an intrinsic personality trait. This kind of hubris is more something that can come out later as a result of these circumstances if it's not unchecked. So I think sometimes we bandy around words like, oh, they're narcissistic. And actually it's not necessarily that.
14:39Dr Gemma Newman:And also they can also fundamentally believe a lot of people that they are doing things correctly and right. And, you know, this idea about the just world hypothesis, again, this is another psychological understanding of, you know, even if I do something that's a bit wrong, I know that on balance, it's going to be the right thing because I believe it's the right thing to do. And so you can, you can convince yourself that you're doing the right thing sometimes when you're causing harm. Yeah. So it's not that somebody is narcissistic and power doesn't always necessarily equate to narcissism. It's that the more power you get and the less feedback you get about the things that you're doing that might harm other people, then the more you believe that you're doing the right thing and the less you feel the unconscious need to want to connect with other people on an empathic level because you feel more right.
15:35I guess you feel like you're more on a pedestal at that point, right?
15:38Dr Gemma Newman:Yes, well, exactly. And it's like you believe your own kind of power, you believe your own persona. And the more polished that persona becomes, I think the harder it is to see through it, even yourself. and that's one of the things that I think oh sorry getting so excited bashing the microphone I think that's one of the things that I've really taken away from seeing stuff that Deepak Chopra wrote in his emails to Epstein and the irony is he wrote an entire book about the shadow you know and he's doing all of the things that you would do to escape the shadow in the wake of these revelations it's it's so interesting to me talk to me about the shadow because carl young carl young i never say it saying properly talks about the shadow self a lot and people who are interested in psychology would know his work yeah others that don't and you just mentioned that deep effort a whole kind of book on the shadow so this feels quite a resemblance of parts of themselves that they're kind of bringing up to the surface yeah Yeah, yes, it does.
16:50Dr Gemma Newman:And so for what it's worth, I'm not really sure how you pronounce Carl Jung. I say Jung. I feel like it seems more appropriate somehow. Carl Jung. Oliver Berkman says it perfectly, I'm sure, when he comes on. Yeah, but I mean, his work, obviously, phenomenal. The idea that, so what is a shadow then? Shadow is really anything that we suppress or repress because we feel like it's unacceptable. and interestingly it doesn't always have to be something objectively bad even traditionally you'd think of it as something bad carnal instincts or negative thoughts or things that you would want to do to someone malicious things but it doesn't have to be that sometimes it could be something that's actually objectively good for you and others that you repress unconsciously as well maybe some creative outlets um instincts natural instincts that you might have about things circumstances people and these shadows form early in our lives and usually um based on the research around this it's from you know childhood patterns parents people that were around in our formative years doesn't have to be parents but obviously that's what you would probably associate with it most and the more harsh the attitudes that you come across when you express these parts of yourself the more negativity you then hold towards these things especially when they are um seen in other people got you and you almost it's like you sort of ignore those parts of yourself and then you get more angry with others for showing those parts because those are the parts that you are most ashamed of in yourself and I think it's fascinating and there's something called the golden shadow which is again what I've just alluded to the idea that you repress sometimes things that are actually objectively really useful or important or creative or um things that uh you uh you know would do really good in the world if you were to actually bring out of yourself and I think that is one of the things that actually brings about this idea of hero worship it's like things about yourself that you've denied or not even aware of compassion exactly yeah so things that you've denied in yourself or that you're not really consciously aware of yourself you put on that other person say wow they're so amazing and you put them on this massive pedestal uh whilst also denying those things about yourself well so how How do you think, so you mentioned Deepak Chakra though, we kind of touched on the Epstein Files.
19:34I think this was a big thing that ignited us to want to have this conversation. Yes.
19:39Dr Gemma Newman:Yes, it did. And he wrote a whole book on the shadow. So kind of looking at him from, I guess, like a psychological lens, what do you think kind of played out there in his behavior? I think I come back to instinctively the idea that the more polished we are in our persona, the darker the shadows become. I think that the shadows get larger with success. I think that sometimes you can have a sincere self-delusion around your own shadow as well. I don't know what Deepak Chopra's understanding is of his behaviors, but there's a clear disparity between the private emails that he sends and the public persona that he brings.
20:36And I think that it's really hard for so many people who have essentially hero worshipped him to really kind of understand this or reconcile it in their minds. But essentially we are all human and we are all flawed and we all have parts of ourselves that we don't really like and that we would rather other people didn't see.
21:02Dr Gemma Newman:Yeah. And that's true for every single one of us. So I think when it comes to figures that have massively disappointed us because, you know, you expect almost bad behavior from. I don't know. Do you expect bad behavior from billionaire businessmen? And I do. Maybe that's something I need to unpack. But we don't expect it from spiritual gurus or doctors. Yeah. You know, we trust them. We are vulnerable with them. And I feel this really keenly. I know the privilege that it is that people come to me with their biggest fears, their health concerns, their vulnerability, their lowest ebb. They come to people like me and they have to be able to trust that.
21:49Dr Gemma Newman:And so when you see doctors talking in this way and behaving in this way, it's so jarring for that reason. And, yeah, I think I think it's important for us to really understand that, you know, we are all human and that sometimes the people with the biggest success, the biggest protocols, the biggest platforms also have dark shadows that they have to deal with. And sometimes they don't. And just an awareness of that, at least, I think is important. And sometimes you can have an instinct on that. But even if you don't necessarily have an instinct on that, at least know they are human. You know, they have bodily functions.
22:37Dr Gemma Newman:They have desires. they have weak spots just like everybody else. As someone who has spent a long time studying the mind-body connection I am constantly asked what do I use to track my health. Since April you've probably seen if you're watching this show me wearing a piece of tech on my arm and that is no watch because I genuinely believe it has been one of the most thoughtful and mind-aware pieces of tech that you can wear. Unlike most wearables that focus just on your steps or your sleep Know what is a bit different and gives you real-time insights into your nervous system. The invisible engine that calibrates everything from your stress to your sleep to your recovery, your rest and ultimately your health.
23:21With its stress recovery metric it doesn't just show you how long you were stressed for but also how long you recovered. It shows you your homeostatus and that to me is where real health begins and I think it's all something that we're craving. And most importantly it does this without dragging you back to your phone because that motion just depletes you. It delivers meaningful health insights to you only when something genuinely matters. Using AI to turn complex signals into clarity that you can understand. And in just five days, it calibrates to your body and creates your personalised health fingerprint.
23:54You can try it for 30 days completely free. And if you're curious, now's the time because they're giving you guys 15 % off with my code LWBW15 if you head to knowwhat.com. And you guys know as listeners of live well and this whole community that understanding yourself in the most mindful way is one of the most powerful things that you can do for your health and this little gadget helps you on your journey completely i think that's the thing i think it's not blaming or shaming it's a discussion around i think it's just an interesting discussion around what we are seeing as health professionals in this sector kind of unfold and unravel in front of our eyes and I am not religious so this isn't meant to be a religious comment but I found this really interesting just because of what you were saying there's a passage passage in the bible and I don't want this to feel like I'm making a religious statement here at all but I thought it was really interesting where I said be aware of false prophets who come to you in sheep's clothing but inwardly
24:59Dr Gemma Newman:are ravenous wolves oh so powerful so powerful oh that's given me goosebumps right and it's it's i think that one of the things that makes us so vulnerable to this is that we think other people think the way we do yeah and some people don't some people actually don't think the same way we do. Some people are more power hungry than others. Some people are less attuned to other people's emotional worlds than we are. And so we also naturally blame ourselves if we, if something goes wrong or if something happens where we've been exploited or we've been taken advantage of, we think, oh, what's wrong with me?
25:44Dr Gemma Newman:Yeah, we self-blame. Yes. But there are actually people in the world that have less scruples than you do or maybe even you know less scruples than they used to have um and i think it's so difficult to navigate that and i think you know with regards to the epstein files in a way there's a part of me that does feel we need to call it out yeah um and we need to ask people to be accountable at least at the very least ask them to accept that there is a level of behavior that is wrong. And that accountability, I think, has been lacking. You know, the Epstein files and the whole kind of thing, I mean, we could talk for hours about the Epstein files, but I think it's a map.
26:31Dr Gemma Newman:It's a map of how power works, how psychology works, how proximity to influence works, how it can silence people, and how vulnerable people are often just left by the wayside. And that really bothers me. Well, I think that's what we're saying. even in kind of the aftermath of the Epstein files. People are speaking up. I think people in our sector are speaking up online about it. We've, you know, really tried to navigate this conversation beforehand to think about like, you know, how deep are we going to go? Where are we going to go? What are we going to speak about? How do we formulate this type of open conversation in a way that's, you know, not judgmental, but informative for people?
27:13And it can also feel quite terrifying. Yeah. coming up and two women taking on essentially the Epstein files yes yes well I mean I wrote
27:26Dr Gemma Newman:an article about all this in preparation really for this chat because I wanted to have I wanted to have my thoughts in a way that felt coherent because you know it is it is a challenging area And I think there are so many things that feed into why this happened and why it probably still happens in various ways. And even now, like you say, I don't think there's been a massive amount of consequences, certainly in the US. We saw Prince Andrew. He's not a prince anymore, is he? No. We saw him get arrested, which I have to admit did give me a sense of pleasure. I felt so pleased. And then I felt bad for feeling pleased.
28:14Dr Gemma Newman:How crazy is that? Oh, such misfortune. See, there's a car even unwrap that psychology. I know. That is madness. So this is the thing is I think just to be aware sometimes of how we feel about things and where that comes from and the parts of ourselves that we feel embarrassed by or ashamed by, and the parts of ourselves that we need to actually begin to love in order to be able to be a functional human being. Yeah. And I think that's true for every single one of us, even spiritual gurus like Deepak Chopra. Yeah. Well, I think the thing with this landscape is, and I don't want to kind of make this against men because there's so amazing men out there that also support women's rights and equality in the voice and they're very balanced and they want to kind of, you know, bring this conversation and support women.
29:07But I guess a lot of the stuff that we're seeing in the science sector and the health sector is involving more conversations from men and less from women. And I feel that the woman's voice gets diluted a lot in these conversations. What's your perspective of this? Kind of like looking at the landscape in the last kind of 10 years. Because I think the reason why this has all started is because of who's coming out in the Epstein files and the shock and the horror and the fear of seeing these names and what they're attached to. And as you said, they also hold an authoritative view in the fact that they are treating people's health.
29:39You know, they're taking in really personal parts of people's lives. And you wouldn't do that knowing that they were associated with this type of behavior. So already you feel a lot of fear and discerning yourself of second guessing yourself of maybe even self blame on, wow, I really believe that person was all for this doing good, but potentially not. Yeah. How do we kind of navigate this to help bring the women's voices more into this conversation without the fear of being cancelled? Yeah. How do we do that, Sarah?
30:13Dr Gemma Newman:How do we do that? You tell me. I'm trying to do that right now. Yeah, I think we have to. So I think discernment is really important. And we have to try to avoid cynicism. I think actually, you know, for women, it's very easy to become cynical, isn't it? We've all had experiences where we have felt our boundaries have been crossed and that we had to be polite and that we had to be professional and that we had to be grateful. And that's how we are. That's how we are wired from a very young age. And. Being aware of that is important without being angry about that. Trying to let go of that. But in a way, actually, I think anger that has been well considered and thoughtful is not necessarily harmful.
31:04Dr Gemma Newman:It can fuel us. The worst anger is that suppressed. Exactly. Yeah. And so discernment over cynicism, perhaps, understanding that we can take a step back and we can analyze behaviors and we can maybe think about, you know, what we know in our brains to be true about a situation, what we feel in our hearts. based on our experience and what we feel in our gut, which is difficult to sometimes even sort of understand if you haven't been used to feeling into that. But I do believe that a lot of the bodily sensations that we have can be clues that it's important for us not to ignore. It doesn't always mean that somebody in front of us is a bad person, but it means that we are picking up on something either in ourselves or in them that we need to be aware of.
31:53Dr Gemma Newman:and I suppose if you wanted to try to look at it just purely from a logical point of view there are a few things I think people can do to protect themselves from being I guess taken advantage of by people that you would trust and that have let you down especially when it comes to spiritual gurus or big important doctors or people online that have got a big following and I think it's important to look at the gap actually between the teaching and the real life Like if you have the opportunity to actually meet the person, are they polite to the people around them? Do they give you an idea through their small behaviors that they are open to critique, that they can tolerate being challenged, that they are kind to someone that has no power?
Read the full transcript
32:42Dr Gemma Newman:um you know how do they treat people and that you can see the difference sometimes between somebody who you think oh my gosh they're so amazing and then you meet them and it's just a massive disappointment I know that because I sent you a voice note after I interviewed somebody you did and that person ended up being in the Epstein files yes and we never aired it yes and that was the hardest moment of my of my be well actually because I recorded and I just had a really heavy dark feeling but I was also I think they say it's really sad because they say never meet your heroes right and there's been a lot of heroes I've met on this show that have made me love them even more yeah and you can feel their energy and I've had them back on the show and they've inspired me and actually they've become my mentors which to me is completely wild because you never think you meet someone and you're heroes and then they become your mentor and that's a whole life-changing experience but obviously we've interviewed so many people on here now and you can't always get everyone to be how you hope them to be and there was that one experience when I voice noted because I knew you were a fan of them too yeah and I voice noted you about the excitement that I was going to have them on and I felt so let down and it was a really hard decision to not put that episode out because everything in me kind of started to question myself was I doing something wrong like was I not prepared enough um but actually I was too compassionate in my in my viewpoint actually like my boundaries kind of did go more so in that because I was trying to move around this person so much and actually there was just pure rudeness.
34:31Yeah. And it completely conflicted everything I thought this person was teaching. And so I made a decision to not put that out.
34:41Dr Gemma Newman:Well, that's a brave decision in and of itself, especially if you want your podcast to grow and you know that that person has a massive following. What made you stick with your gut on that? I think it was odd I think I messaged you first about a voice note um which made it feel that it was real because I think I have a tendency in the past to not actually speak up about how I feel in that moment to not actually even if that person disagrees or agrees with what I'm saying who I'm sharing that with I think the tendency for me naturally was to be like it must be me because I see myself lower than that person who's on.
35:22So that's my fault. But actually it was so obvious that that wasn't the case in this situation. But I think I felt so disappointed and so jarred by the whole thing that I didn't want to do a disservice to my audience. And the whole reason I started this show was to translate ethical health advice and important conversations. And that felt to me really unethical and how that person was treating. like the value set of what they had I can always account someone's having a bad day and I think we all have them I have them I'm sure I've turned up on podcasts and they're like she's a nightmare but 90 % of the time except when you're asking for your granola but 90 % of the time I think I always try and do my actions by my values yeah and there was it was you can see the difference of someone having a bad day and somebody not living authentically to who they persona to be yeah and so something within me just knew that the the advice that I was delivering to my audience wasn't authentic and actually going to be helpful yeah so I just made but it was hard it was hard to cut someone who I knew would give me leverage on the show because again the only way you survive as a podcast is by having people that listen and engage and want to listen to the person that's on your show so it's like a double-edged sword yeah yeah
36:45Dr Gemma Newman:Yeah, it is. And the fact that you decided not to air it is very powerful. And it must have felt very validating to find out later. You sent it to me. Yes. I wanted you to feel validated. You have to trust yourself. You have to trust yourself. Yeah. And that's something, again, I think I feel so passionately about because I have so often not trusted myself as well. You know, wanting to see the best in somebody, wanting to think, OK, it's it's me, not them. And objectively speaking, that's actually just as likely to be them, if not more likely in some cases. Yeah. Yeah. So that's a good piece of advice that people can take is to actually watch out for the difference between the public persona and how they treat people with no power.
37:31Dr Gemma Newman:If you have the ability to do that, you don't always. I think another thing is think about who they surround themselves with. I mean, it's not necessarily an ironclad indicator, but if someone's constantly name dropping and constantly kind of interested in their legacy over anything else, that kind of gives you a clue. So I think real wisdom is often a bit more humble as it has a bit more humility about it. And so that's something to be aware of in ourselves and in others. Yeah. Trusting your gut, like you said, just trusting yourself, actually, a bit more. Something that we are conditioned not to do.
38:16Dr Gemma Newman:And I think that's why the whole Me Too movement back in 2027 felt so powerful for so many women. It's because they began to realize, oh, my experience is not the same as the men around me that I love. Or my children or my parents, my sons, my father. My experience of the world and how I navigate it and how I move through it is entirely different from theirs. And they have no clue what goes on. Good men have no clue how bad men treat women because they are not doing it themselves. And that was mind-blowing for so many people. You know, I started to open up conversations around that, as many women did.
39:00And the good men in my life were just completely flummoxed by it, confused.
39:05Dr Gemma Newman:because that's something that obviously they would never experience. So I think having conversations about it is important, and that's why the whole Me Too movement, I think, became so cathartic for so many women, is because you're just so used to just keeping it to yourself or thinking, okay, maybe it's me, and assuming that everybody has that same worldview. What was your response to the Substack article that you put out on the Epstein files with spiritual gurus and doctors? It was overall very positive. And I did have this, I had this sense as I was writing it, because I said to you just now, I wrote it to gather my thoughts for today.
39:42Dr Gemma Newman:And I felt it was a very cathartic piece. I was like, yes, this feels great to write. And then I pressed publish. And then I had this sense of anxiety falling over me thinking, oh my gosh, is that, how is this going to land? Are people going to be judgmental in some way? I couldn't sleep. Wow. Being that vulnerable because I speak on podcasts mostly about wellness nutrition I like to speak a bit about spirituality because I am a spiritual person but I never really have to talk about stuff that's happened to me or things that I've experienced because often I send to my patients so for me it was like oh this is a bit scary but I'm glad I wrote it and there was a lot of positive feedback and people contacted me who I haven't heard from in years.
40:31Dr Gemma Newman:Wow. People who I didn't even know read my substack, contacted me. So many supportive people. And it just made me feel really nice, actually. Did any of them agree? Did any of them say, like, I've experienced this too? Oh, definitely. Yeah. And I had other doctors reach out to me and say, this happened to me as well. This conference or in that situation and it feels horrible and I'm really glad you've talked about it. And I've had, I had one man message me angry on my behalf because he'd had a bad experience with somebody that I had written about saying they treated me really badly. They, you know, they, because he didn't have any power, right?
41:14Dr Gemma Newman:Yeah. It wasn't somebody that could be particularly influential or important. So they treated them badly. And so obviously that's not necessarily for women. I think we experienced that perhaps more in a sexual way because we are women. And so if you have someone who's a powerful man and a heterosexual, then that perhaps is the way that it comes across. But if you're a man without influence or power, then it's probably purely more just disrespect or putting them to one side, casting them aside. But yeah, it was a very powerful, It felt powerful in the sense that I do think it helped people because I also wanted to offer people the takeaways, the important things to trust.
42:04Dr Gemma Newman:And that's why, you know, in our conversation today, I'm talking about at least understanding what does your gut, heart and brain tell you. Don't necessarily always have to act on everything that you feel, know and experience, but have an awareness of it, trust it, listen to it, reflect on it. And don't immediately discount your experience as being something that's your problem. I think, and I don't know if you agree with this, obviously I mentioned that I've become better at trusting my own instinct. But I felt completely lost in that for 10 years because of the conflicting advice that was online.
42:37And maybe I felt like I was falling behind. I felt like I think also when you start studying you realize how much you don't know yes and that also overwhelmed me so I was like wow people are so strong in their opinions but I feel like I've opened a can of worms and now I kind of doubt everything well that's a sign that you've got
42:57Dr Gemma Newman:more knowledge than them that's the irony the whole Dunning-Kruger effect you know somebody's so sure of themselves and their position that they will not be moved is a sign that they probably haven't read enough research or they probably haven't actually reflected on it enough but i think like until i studied science that was completely oblivious to me because these people were so strong and now we have such big camps in different sectors and strong narratives on each one and so to then try and trust your instinct in your gut on what feels right becomes complete overwhelmed because you're having people stand so firmly with a spear and say this is correct and so you end up becoming maybe unconsciously more influenced by this kind of fear that we find ourselves in that's true you kind of almost become paralyzed by it don't you yeah it's but that's that's a tactic as well used in in all sorts of situations that you put out in fact in a way i read about this online there's an attorney that in america was talking about even the way that the Department of Justice released the Epstein files was a almost like a chaos tactic you release three billion pieces of information everybody's like oh what do I do with this yeah because you're gonna have to go through all of them and no one has that time exactly you just you so you're paralyzed into indecision and inaction and I think it's important for us to take a step back and to be aware that that is something that is that we're all prone to to experiencing and to actually again just sit in quietness as much as you can in those quiet moments feel into what feels right and in terms of the science actually that can itself sometimes backfire because your instincts on something could be wrong so it's important for you to actually take in other viewpoints and look at what study evidence is showing you so yeah it's discernment again it comes back to discernment, doesn't it?
44:53Dr Gemma Newman:Being discerning, recognizing your own shortfalls as best you can, but also recognizing your own strengths and not downplaying them. And I think when it comes to science and spirituality, they can intersect. And I like to try to bring those two things together in my life but I think in a way our instincts can sometimes um still lead us astray and when you've got someone like Chopra or other gurus talking about the things like non-attachment we can find ourselves lost in a quagmire of non-feeling or non-trusting ourselves and our own experiences. And I think if your guru or your teacher is very persuasive and there's no accountability around them, it would be so easy for ideas around oneness and how we're all connected to mean, oh, well, I won't speak up about that or I won't take action about that.
45:59Dr Gemma Newman:That's quite culty. Yeah. Yeah. And that's, again, something that we are very susceptible to, especially if we're religious people or we're spiritual people you know we can become very easily swayed by that kind of thing yeah well this is how cults start forming very quickly people sometimes even realize they're in a cult no until it's too late um i'm trying to think if there was an hbo documentary on the very famous cult that was out of la and i'm trying to think of what it's called now um and it was a very kind of a spiritual movement and people ended up and it was huge famous celebrities in there that were giving away their money and their lives and kind of just kind of transcending into this cult.
46:42And anyway, the guy who's run it now has gone to prison and he's got life imprisonment. But it was a huge movement. It was a big kind of series on HBO just about how quickly this all kind of transpired. And they call him a full-blown narcissist. And one of the guys who ended up taking him down, who I know is releasing a documentary all about the fears of narcissism in powerful places.
47:04Dr Gemma Newman:Oh, it's so interesting. I think we have to come back to teachers that center our own development and well-being above them being right. Yeah. um and i think it's important to trust that if somebody if there is no sense of accountability then that's that's a bit of a red flag isn't it and it i think i think that feminist ways of being spiritual are actually sometimes a bit different let me explain what i mean i think when you have teachers and gurus that talk about are the importance of non-attachment it can almost and if you're really making an effort to sort of not be attached to outcomes it can also lead you to not being attached to people people or responsibilities you know and by non-attachment do you mean more like a stoic way of thinking stoic ways of thinking yeah like i will love but i will not form an attachment to an outcome that non-attachment aim that the aim of a lot of spiritual um teachers to to be you know to have complete equanimity when it comes to um outcomes nothing being right nothing being wrong uh it just being um which it gives us a lot of comfort this idea that we can um be in a state of pure love that we do not expect of others in the way that we would if we were just forming relationships in terms of attachments like you will do this for me and I will do this for you and you will not leave me and my identity is around this relationship or this thing that's kind of an attached way of living and a lot of these spiritual philosophies are advising us to let go of all of that and to live in love and to live without judgment um which is which is helpful and is important but it's not necessarily how power structures work in the world yeah and if we are making huge efforts to live this way against our natural instincts sometimes then it can also lead us to make decisions that are actually not in the best interest of community family loving actions We abandon our responsibilities.
49:33Dr Gemma Newman:So yeah, I think matriarchal ways of embracing spirituality would emphasize loving connections and community and nature as well as ideas of non-attachment. because I think sometimes if you are so caught up in not feeling things because you're above all that it's not actually truth and reality as we live it in this world on this planet no that doesn't feel like we're living in 2026 at all no you can live this aesthetic lifestyle and go and live in a cave and be all spiritual but what if you've got a wife and kids at home that you've basically just left to fend for themselves. I mean, that's not great either.
50:25Dr Gemma Newman:No. And that's something. Oh, I mean, I don't want to offend anybody, but I do believe, I think, I think the modern day Buddha did that. I think it, you know, really, yeah, I think he had a family and then he just went off and found Nirvana under the Bodhi tree. I might, might need to check, fact check that. But, um, I do find it interesting that a lot of these esoteric practices, useful though they are uh if not integrated in terms of these ideas of shadow can lead to harm sometimes it's interesting isn't it um i probably should fact check this we need to do some fact checks don't we we need to do some fact checks but as i was talking about this today you know i was really trying to get to the intention of what this conversation is going to be about i was really trying to distill it in my brain of like what is going to be the takeaway for the listener what conversation are we opening up?
51:18What are we trying to create here in our narrative of discussion? And as I was kind of like talking through it in my mind and with my team, one of my team said, well, it's interesting because you can have people that have great influence and do great things in the world. But behind closed doors, they're a very different person. For instance, and this is where the fact check comes in because I didn't fact check this, Martin Luther King. Incredible what he did in this world incredible for what he stood for but apparently before he died he punched his girlfriend in the face right okay yeah how do we break that down like how it's a
51:59Dr Gemma Newman:do you see the concept that i'm trying to yes yes like how are we consistent in our behaviors in private and in public yeah i do believe that is shadow integration work it has to be we need to be aware of our impulses, of our emotions, of how events shape us and our behaviors in order to moderate those behaviors and bring them into sync. So I don't think we should abandon our darkest part. We have to integrate it. We have to accept and love it. And that is the crux of your message. Of course it is, Sarah, the whole idea of it. But it's hard to put into practice because these are the things that we try to escape from from the moment that we're born right it does say here martin lutherkin engaged in a verbal dispute with his girlfriend there is some saying that he did there is some saying that that is absolutely not true so i have to just just wanted to put that yeah well it's good to fact check some are saying it hasn't happened and some are saying such claims are widely considered to be rumors and allegations some of which are spread by the fbi in an effort to discredit him so I will just say we don't know the truth on that no but as in my but my point around that is not to do with him it's to do with the context of yes the persona versus the truth behind how their actions are at home yeah and you know we I think it's the it's the integration of our deepest desires that we if we can do that then we can be a lot more coherent as a person our public persona won't actually be too different i mean obviously we have to be discerning again with what we share you know i'm not going to come on a public podcast and talk about all the things that i have ever done that i feel oh i wish i hadn't done this or said that because i don't think that's a very healthy thing to do you know there are situations in which you can be vulnerable and there's situations in which we have to protect ourselves and our image of ourselves.
54:05Dr Gemma Newman:But it's important for us to do this work, especially in our closest relationships and with our friendships, in order for us to actually be consistent with our value set when we're out and about and in the world. And I think that is the most important thing. Yeah, I agree. I think values are spoken about and virtues are spoken about quite flippantly in relationships. And then you have culture settings within companies that have like different cultures and do you fit into that culture? But interesting when you kind of look at people of power, they're not as represented. Some are, amazingly. I think Obama did a really incredible job at doing that and creating his value set at home as well as when he was in office.
54:50But why do you think that's maybe not more shown? with certain people but we still respect them why do i think it's not shown why do i think that
54:59Dr Gemma Newman:people are able to get away with being different well because people don't always see people's private lives and it's easier to ignore these things and it's hard for us to see our own blind spots yeah um i think it's true that our personal relationships our parents and our children are probably our biggest mirrors to the way we need to do work yeah and um that's where we can start in our own lives so that we can also have a logical heart-centered gut-centered approach when we are seeing other people and how they go about their lives doing that work for ourselves and that's where i suppose non-judgment comes in because we have to we have to integrate our own blind spots, our own bits that we wish we could get rid of.
55:49Dr Gemma Newman:We all have them. Exactly. We all have that. And it's not always the same thing. But I think the things that probably trigger us the most are the things that we need to work on as well. So yes, it can feel quite complicated, but really what it comes down to is conscious discernment and integration. okay so we mentioned earlier at the very beginning you know billionaires and we we sweeped over that quite quickly but it made me think about bill gates again he's obviously been in the epstein files as well so it feels quite relevant to bring him up he has probably saved millions of lives through global health funding like he has funded a lot of different things and he's actually now stepped in to the who since trump has pulled all the funding.
56:39Bill Gates is now becoming the primary funder of the World Health Organization. But I say that with a but, because at the same time, people feel deeply uncomfortable about the influence of an unelected billionaire having so much influence over medicine. So I feel like there's like two truths, sir. At one point, he's kind of helping. But at the other time, And there's a huge amount of influence from one individual. So how do you kind of look at that landscape as a health professional?
57:11Dr Gemma Newman:I find it really challenging because I think that nobody should be that rich and nobody should be that powerful. Because I do believe it warps our sense of self and reality. And I'm glad that who is getting funded. And yes, it's wonderful when powerful people do good things. And that goodness can extend far beyond what we could imagine. And that's great. So I am all for that. But I do believe that accountability structures are vital in this world that we live in because we are human. We are fallible. And our decisions are not always based on the public interest. They're sometimes based on our own interests and the things that we think are important, which is sometimes different from what other people think are important.
58:00Dr Gemma Newman:So I think accountability in public office, in power structures is vital. And actually, now I think about it, that's actually a very matriarchal way of looking at the world. Having power that is kind of stretched out among more than one person, having accountability, having sort of structures that center more than one opinion, I think is vital. And that's important for all the organizations, I think, that provide medical assistance, guidelines and dietary guidelines. I mean, we've talked for ages. Oh, gosh, I haven't even got into dietary guidelines. But you need to have different voices, different expert voices and accountability.
58:54Dr Gemma Newman:Yeah. It's really important. it's hard because i do feel and maybe it's because i'm this is the field that i'm in that i see a lot more you know we just gasp at dietary guidelines some people might not even realize why we just gasp at dietary guidelines you know there's been a big controversy about the american food pyramid this year and it being flipped upside down and there's a lot of political interests and connections to the meat industry and so on and so forth um and it's caused a lot of controversy and I guess this is my worry with health but I guess this is with anything that has money in it is it for the best interests of the people or is it for the best interests of money and that's a debate that I think is forever going to be going on yeah and I think when people in power don't show any kind of humility or accountability then that shows the rest of the world that they can do what they want without consequence and I think that's very wrong um and that plays out in our own lives and on you know on the on the world stage um I don't really have any solutions for that uh sadly I wish that we lived in a different kind of material world than we currently do but I do believe the work starts at home yeah I believe that if we can be discerning with ourselves and with other people, be self-compassionate, integrate the things that we don't like about ourselves, that it will help us to show up in the world in a much more healthy way and bring people into our lives who have healthier patterns of being.
1:00:32Dr Gemma Newman:And that needs to be done on a global scale, but we have to start with ourselves. Yeah. We have to start with what's right here, right now, in our homes, in our lives, the people that we surround ourselves with and the things that we hold most important. Yeah I agree and I think the reason why that is so critical is because the moments where I was more swayed by influence and power dynamics and people I would listen to or follow it's because I didn't have that in myself. Yeah. So for me it was like oh these people must be trustworthy and so you naturally have that poor dynamic of wanting to follow because you want to be like that person.
1:01:10Dr Gemma Newman:Yeah. Right. As opposed to actually believing it within yourself. And I do think that's like a self-development kind of process you go through. But when I think you do become quite sure of yourself and that's kind of maybe the more work that you've done or the more research that you've kind of gone into your area and go, no, actually, I kind of do disagree with that. and I can hold my opinion and that can also be true is a really important stage to get to. I think the fear that I have is that a lot of this preys on vulnerable people who aren't aware that they're being influenced. Yeah, you're right.
1:01:43Dr Gemma Newman:It does. So I guess what can we do about that? What do we do? We have to put out voices that are a bit more measured, a bit more nuanced. we have to put different um sources of information out there for people to to be able to look at and hopefully evaluate for themselves but i think the important thing is to actually bring people again back to back to themselves we can lose ourselves in looking to other people um and i don't know whether that's always from this so-called golden shadow of things that we've repressed or we just don't trust ourselves or it's easier to to trust someone who seems confident but we have to come back to what's important to us and um what we feel when we're around somebody just as much as the discernment that we use our brains for when we understand why do we feel this way yeah um so you know when it comes to stuff like the epstein files it's a complete as i said to you earlier it's a complete map of psychology and power structures as they currently exist and I think that that needs to change and do you think it will I hope it will I remain hopeful um I mean the way the world's looking right now it's literally like chaos um unleashed yeah so I like to think that the arc of change is overall going to be positive and that good people will stand up and speak the truth.
1:03:19Dr Gemma Newman:And I hope that conversations like this will help people to do that too, actually. Yeah, me too. Good on us. Well, we try, don't we? We try. I'm so interested to see the comments on this, actually. Yeah. To see what resonates, to see, you know, because I haven't wanted to. I am a big believer in the Epstein files are such a big thing. I am a big believer in also giving people the benefit, the doubt in certain situations. And I also am going to spin the pendulum the other way. And I am also worried about people that get called out maybe rather that haven't been as kind of, you know, heavily disregarded in the same respect as these guys have been.
1:04:03You know, these have done very wrongdoings in everyone's eyes. but you know sometimes with health information if someone's maybe got something a bit wrong or they're a bit confused or whatever but the intent isn't bad I also fear that there's platforms that are literally just trying to take people down yeah and that also fit worries me yeah because it's kind of like you can normally I can try and normally see if there's a good intent behind certain people and sometimes I feel like others are just out to get people yeah and that I also
1:04:32Dr Gemma Newman:feel was unhealthy i agree with you it's that whole cancel culture isn't it um so i don't like to indulge in that because i feel like it brings out the worst parts of ourselves to do that same um and i think i can see why people do it um and why people feel like they're doing it for the right reasons so they have this whole kind of moral high horse about it you know i'm saving people i'm helping people and they and they are um but i do value i value discernment when it comes to um how you go about it agree um and i value kindness but i also as i say i think it's important to i think it shows more integrity to um you know reach out to somebody um message them directly yeah if you can um but again it's hard for us to know other people's intentions because we project our intentions onto them yes that's true so much projection happening so much projection we just project everything what am i doing who am i um but if you believe if you believe that in general people are good and in general they are wanting to do the right thing then it is consistent with that to reach out to them and say oh by the way did you know or i thought you'd be interested to see this rather than automatically assuming the worst and i think a lot of the time when you're doing this calling out you're automatically assuming the worst yeah and i think that's where it makes people feel uncomfortable um so yes yeah so to leave people with and maybe hope yes a little bit of hope a little bit of discernment i think bottom line when it comes to situations in your own life what you can do um to feel that you're on the right track with somebody um or with a situation at work or at home or online is to think to yourself you You know, who is surrounding this person?
1:06:40Dr Gemma Newman:Is there a gap between what they're actually saying to you and how they treat people without power? Trust your gut. It's information. Don't necessarily always immediately have to act on it. But at least trust that something is coming to you from that, a signal that you need to explore. And just be aware that success doesn't always equal integrity. You know, be aware of the halo effect. be aware of this tendency that we have to equate success with goodness or attractiveness with goodness because that's just not always the case so understanding those pitfalls is really helpful and awareness of ourselves integrating the bits of ourselves that we don't like that's that's the big piece that's the hard piece exactly yeah that's the hard piece yeah but it's important because it allows us to be consistent with our values whatever situation we're in we can be consistent with our values and feel good about it even when you know we um there's a part of us that kind of wants to put that on someone else yeah it's an easier job isn't it yeah exactly way easier job yeah way harder to take it in it is it's humility at the end of the day yeah so i I hope that this was helpful.
1:07:57This feels very different for a live well, be well conversation.
1:08:00Dr Gemma Newman:I know. It's a different thing for me to talk about, but I've really enjoyed it. Yeah, me too. I feel as though it's helpful to talk about. Yeah, I agree. And I also think it's helpful to talk about without trying to retake people down. Because there's another fear that I fear that, you know, sometimes you can go online and it feels that people just want to take people down. And I think it's important, as you said, to have. Oh, now I'm doing it. To have that more open view on situations and just awareness, because we can either bury our head and just ignore it, or we can become aware and we can talk about it.
1:08:37And ultimately, whatever you feel comfortable with is the right thing. And so if it feels uncomfortable unfollowing somebody or feeling like you don't connect to their view or their opinion, then actually that's where the truth should be held. Yeah. Yeah.
1:08:55Dr Gemma Newman:I'll come back to discernment because um sometimes as I say our instinct is oh I'm just going to get rid of that thing I don't agree with that and then we we lose we lose the ability to have a conversation yeah um but yeah ultimately I think trust in ourselves is is the is the ultimate is the ultimate aim yeah discernment not reaction yeah and again that's what we leave it with well that's my final question and I should have gone back and seen what you've said the last time you were on here but Gemma what does live well be well mean to you oh well in light of today's conversation right now in the world what does this mean oh not living in a war zone that would be a really helpful thing yeah you can't live well and be well if you're being attacked yeah uh yeah what does it mean to me I think it means it means self-compassion but also uh getting perspective on not just our own hubris but trying to remain humble um I think is very important yeah very humbling and yeah I think you know we all have we all want we all want to be right i think a lot of us you know we feel psychology exactly um but i think sometimes connecting with other people requires um requires a little bit more discernment about our instincts and um kindness it comes down to kindness again doesn't it 100 i mean you know that's my favorite thing it's your favorite thing there's a reason why it's your favorite thing you know being kind to yourself and other people allows you it allows you to be discerning it allows you to stand up in the face of oppression it allows you to um be more measured in how you approach a situation of conflict um and it allows you to know yourself a little bit better absolutely well i'm going to link if you're happy with that the sub-site article in the show notes sure so people can go and have a source after this to go and read everything that we spoke about I think it's a great article.
1:11:11Thank you for writing it.
1:11:12Dr Gemma Newman:Thank you. Very vulnerable. And yeah, I'm just really grateful that you have spoken out in a kind of compassionate way. Thank you, Sarah. I'm grateful for you. Oh, I am. I think you're great. Thank you. You're welcome.
1:11:38Thank you.
From the publisher
Why is it that the loudest voices in health are often the ones we trust the most — even when they’re not the most qualified? In a world where confidence travels faster than evidence, it can feel almost impossible to know who to believe.
This week on Live Well Be Well, I’m joined again by the brilliant Dr. Gemma Newman. Gemma is a GP, author, and deeply thoughtful voice in the wellness space, known for her ability to bridge science, psychology, and compassion. In this conversation, we explore the uncomfortable truths behind power, influence, and the psychology that shapes who we trust. From the Epstein files to spiritual gurus, we unpack how easily admiration can turn into blind faith — and what it really takes to stay grounded in your own truth. This is a conversation about discernment, integrity, and learning to trust yourself in a world full of noise.
Here’s what we explore together:
Why confident health advice often outperforms true expertise — and how algorithms amplify this. The psychology behind why we trust powerful, successful, or attractive people more easily. How the “halo effect” can blind us to red flags in health, wellness, and beyond. What the shadow self really is — and why ignoring it can lead to harmful behaviour.
How spiritual teachings like non-attachment can sometimes be misused or misunderstood.
The dangers of hero worship — and why “never meet your heroes” can sometimes ring true.
How to spot misalignment between someone’s public persona and private behaviour.
Why women’s voices can feel diluted in health conversations — and how to reclaim them.
The impact of movements like MeToo in helping women reconnect with their instincts.
How overwhelm, misinformation, and “chaos tactics” can keep us stuck and disconnected.
The ethical tension between doing good and holding too much power (from
gurus to billionaires).
Why accountability, humility, and multiple perspectives are essential in health leadership.
How cancel culture can sometimes do more harm than good — and what to do instead.
A practical framework for discernment: using your brain, heart, and gut together.
Why the most important work always starts with integrating your own shadow.
Love, Sarah Ann 💛
👉 Practical beats perfect.
Here’s a free 5-recipe PDF I use to support energy and stress during busy weeks.
https://open.substack.com/pub/sarahma...
This episode is sponsored by:
Further Reading & Resources:
Let’s be friends!
📷 Instagram: / sarahannmacklin
📹 Subscribe: / @livewellbewellsarah
🐦 Twitter: https://x.com/SarahAnnMacklin
📱 TikTok: / livewellbewellpodcast
💌 Newsletter: https://sarahmacklin.substack.com/
If You Enjoyed This Episode, You Might Also Like:
Sign up to Sarah’s Compassionate Cure newsletter:
Science Simplified, Health Humanised.
Join thousands in exploring actionable insights that prioritise compassion, clarity,
and real-life impact.
https://sarahmacklin.substack.com/
Highlights
00:00 Epstein Files Opener
00:08 Power and the Shadow
00:51 Spiritual Guru Hypocrisy
01:30 Book Announcement Break
02:50 Confidence Beats Expertise
24:22 Spotting False Prophets
37:37 Humility Signals Wisdom
38:06 Trusting Gut After MeToo
39:24 Publishing Vulnerable Substack
42:22 Overwhelm and Chaos Tactics
45:22 Gurus, Cults and Non-Attachment
51:03 Shadow Integration and Values
56:10 Billionaire Power and Accountability
58:53 Health Guidelines and Money
01:00:45 Building Inner Trust
01:03:34 Cancel Culture and Kindness
01:06:22 Practical Discernment Checklist
01:09:24 Live Well Be Well Closing Love what you’re hearing?
My small ask is to please rate and review Live Well Be Well. This helps the show
expand and allows me to keep producing these with the best quality guests. It means a huge amount to me, so thank you.



