AI has changed SEO forever (SEO vs GEO)

0:02So Google rankings versus AI citation from that diggity here. So Chachie CBD pulled in 55.2 billion visits by June 2025. That's an 80 % jump in a single year via your favorite site, Search Engine Land. Sure, Search Engine still get 34 times more traffic, but that gap is closing fast, which means one thing, your content has to work for both Google rankings and AI citations. So here's the split and then we can talk about this. Google takes shots, short queries like car insurance UK or best shoes, best red shoes or whatever, and runs them through dozens of ranking factors such as backlinks, relevance, authority, technical SEO.

0:35So for AI, AI deals with long conversational prompts. It doesn't filter as deeply. It leans more on co-citations than traditional links. So he's basically saying, look, many old tactics still work for AI system, but here's what works for both. So for you and I both know this already, but writing an FAQ section, what is, how to questions, right? That's going to help. Add two to three sentence summaries at the top of every article explaining the main point. Include your business name, address, phone number. So NAP, back in the day, guys, NAP. and then break complex topics into one, two sentence factual statements that AI can easily extract and then cover five to seven related subtopics within each main article instead of creating separate pages.

1:14So these are the baseline things that you can do to do well in both. Yeah. An interesting thing that we're seeing AI pull from when people ask questions about like the best X, the best Y, whatever it may be, like best credit card, best credit for college students, best electric car, dude, they're just pulling from we've seen a huge trend on ChatGPT where they just pull from random sites. Forget authority. It could be written by like JoeThePlumber.com. There's nothing wrong with plumbers. They're your millionaire next door. Amazing businesses, by the way. And ChatGPT will pull it and index it. And I don't think they're looking as much as context, like eat.

1:54And I do believe that's going to change in the future. Probably within the next 12 months, to be honest. Because we've seen some players in different verticals because we scrape a lot of the different queries on OpenAI through their API. And no joke, they're just pulling from random websites that just do list-based articles, ranking products or services or sites. And the people who just guest posted a ton are doing really well. But Google went through this. They eventually realized that not all websites are equal and they filtered out the junk. Yeah, eventually, like people are trying to game it right now.

2:28They'll figure it out. And then it's always like a cat and mouse game. That's what it is. And Google's always been ahead. By the way, you actually tweeted this one. I want to give you the shout out for this one. But 98 % of people aren't getting an ROI from AI due to this. And you basically did a quick study on MCPs. So most people you're saying do not get an ROI from AI, but people who use MCPs do. So you can go on it. People who use, I have a tweet somewhere on there, but people who end up using MCPs. So think of it as like an AI for, or API for AI. and what it allows you to do is connect different platforms together or software solutions together so that way the AI can actually do stuff to help you get ROI.

3:11It's honestly still like an API to me. Yeah, it really is. At least that's the way I look at it. I know technically it's not, but I really do view it as an API. And the numbers were not using MCPs. Think of it as like an API for AI, as Eric mentioned as well. 96 % are not getting ROI for the ones who are using it which is a much smaller sample size roughly 2 % are you got 4 % each here using MCPs not seeing ROI oh yeah 4 % using of the 4 % 61 % are seeing ROI and 2 % are not which is kind of crazy to think about and then when you look at oh yeah this is for reversed yes reversed so look I think Neil's main point here is if you're using an MCP, like most people aren't seeing an ROI from AI.

4:02But if you're using MCP, you're far likelier to see 61%. You're likely to see an ROI. Those 2%, I'm sorry, guys, you probably just need to do some training on it. You'll probably see an ROI. Yep. Yep. It's kind of crazy to think about. And it's just like people are using AI and they believe using ChatGPT or NanoBanana is going to get you ROI. why if you're using the wrong strategy, it's just AI is cool and it doesn't do anything for you from a financial aspect. Here's the problem with most marketing agencies. They don't understand what is happening with the world of AI. With my agency, Single Grain, we think about agentic workflows.

4:42We think about creating agents for the future. When we think about SEO, we think about creating different products such as internal linking products or content consolidation products. And on the other side of things, we think about building products that just care. We just think about making marketing easier overall. If you want to stay at the cutting edge of marketing and at the same time leverage the power of AI, go to singlegrain.com and we'll see you on the other side. You know what's interesting? So Alex Lieberman, one of the co-founders of Morning Brew tweeted this too. So if you're to go to Fortune 500 executives right now, and I'm sure you and I have talked to some, but the AI bar for Fortune 500 executives, if you're talking to an executive, if they see they're seeing an ROI from AI right now, most of what he's seeing at least is the leverage they're gaining from AI right now is only AI meeting recordings in some ways.

5:25So the bar is extremely low right now. And interestingly enough, and I think you've seen this too, you and I, like, I know I'm speaking to like an older group of CEOs next month. And the guy I was talking to is like, dude, this group has no idea what to do and you need to whip them into shape or whatever. And I'm sure you've already done this for organizations too this year too. What are you seeing?

5:47What we're seeing is, we're seeing the same thing. It doesn't matter if it's run by older people or younger people or who the executives are. It's all very similar. And corporations, big or small, they all claim that they use AI, but they don't understand what is a good bar, what is a bad bar, how to actually use it to get an ROI. Is it actually creating time savings or people just spinning their wheels? the biggest thing we see when we talk to large organizations like fortune 500 global 10 000 whatever you want to end up calling it they're actually seeing an increase in expense due to ai they're buying all this stuff for ai and they haven't figured out how it's going to help them save money or make money yep but they're reading how it's going to solve all these problems and they can't figure that part out yet.

6:43I saw Mark Cuban on the TBPN podcast. I think it's Tech Bros Podcast Network, TBPN. And he was just like, dude, in my 20s, I was trying to get everyone to get a PC. And they're like, no, I have my assistant. I have this. He's like, the gold rush right now, if you're in your teens, is to get people on, to help businesses get on the AI train. But my question for you is, what age did you start using the internet at? Because I remember for me, I stole my mom's credit card when I was about eight years old. And I signed up for MSN. when did you start using it? I don't know what age, but it was really maybe like...

7:16If you've ever built a website, you know how tough it can be to keep a strong design while ensuring site performance is fast. That's where Framer comes in, and it totally changes the game. Framer is the design-first, no-code website builder that lets anyone ship a production-ready site in minutes. I recently built a custom landing page in just a few hours. Animations, fast load times, responsive layouts, all without writing a single line of code. It was easy to use and the end result was polished enough to look like a developer spent days on it. One of my favorite things is that Framer's AI handles translations with a single click.

7:48So your site can be up and running in multiple languages almost instantly. And with real-time collaboration, your whole team can jump in and work together. No issues with versions or miscommunication. Whether you're starting from scratch or using one of their templates, Framer lets you focus on design while handling the technical side for you. Animations, responsive layouts, search optimization, and all the things that matter. Ready to build a site that looks hand-coded without hiring a developer? Launch your site for free at Framer.com and use code MS to get your first month of pro on the house.

8:19That's Framer.com, promo code MS. Framer.com, promo code MS. Rules and restrictions may apply. When I first started my business, the overwhelm was real. I didn't have the tools to help me scale. If only I had Shopify from the start to handle all the behind-the-scenes work. Shopify is the platform behind millions of businesses globally from huge names like Mattel and Gymshark to the smallest brands just getting started. The best part about it, it has everything you could need. Say you're ready to launch your own design studio. Shopify has hundreds of templates to create a beautiful store that matches your brand style.

8:51Or if you need help with content creation, Shopify has got AI tools that write your product descriptions, craft page headlines, and even enhance your product photos. Shopify lets you easily create email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they are, whether they're scrolling or strolling. If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify. Turn your big business idea into with Shopify on your side. Sign up for your$1 per month trial and start selling today at shopify.com slash marketing school. Go to shopify.com slash marketing school, shopify.com slash marketing school.

9:27somewhere between nine and 12 years old if i had a guess so probably before 12 but i would say 9 10 or 11 roughly around the same age right and so it was a dial-up modem yeah that's what i had people couldn't use the phone when i was on the internet yeah same for me and so i did i i didn't buy an extension so i had to i waited for my mom to leave and i would move because my my computer desk had wheels on it so i move it over to the phone thing plug it in and once she got home i'd like unplug it and then move it back. That's what I did for the longest time. But my point is, most people don't know what to do with this right now.

9:59And especially if you're younger right now, this is your opportunity. If you really try to understand one business and then try to optimize that business for AI, you saw Sierra, they raised a bunch of money and they're just building agents for companies. I think there's another company. I didn't actually see that. They raised a lot. Yeah, hundreds of millions. There's another company I just started recently with Kushner, Josh Kushner. They're almost like an AI services company too. So they're an AI services company, and they raised like$200, I think, just like this week. Yeah, Josh is well-connected.

10:27He's done well with Thrive. Yeah, he's a killer. Anyway, all that to say, go ahead. Yeah, but I look at AI as similar to any business tool that you have available at your toolkit. I'm not saying you shouldn't use it. I genuinely do believe it's here to stay. I think businesses just focus on the wrong thing, and they look at, they have shiny object syndrome instead of just focusing on what's going to drive ROI. You know, dude, like the other day, someone asked me about this podcast. They're like, you record a podcast with Eric. They're like, yeah. They're like, how many years have you been doing it?

11:04And I was like, I don't know, maybe five to 10 years, somewhere around that range. Nine years. Nine years? Yeah. Okay, so it's a long time. I knew it was more than five, but I knew we didn't hit 10 yet or we would have celebrated on the podcast. I don't think we would have celebrated. I think I'm likely just forget it. You wouldn't even know. And I thought we would have been like, we hit 10 years and then there's, okay, we like a thousand episodes, 2000 episodes, 3000. We just keep going. Yeah. But I was telling them, they're just like, you know, they're like, okay. They're like, what's your ROI from the podcast?

11:33I'm like, honestly, I think it's negative. Like genuinely speaking, I actually think the ROI. On pure dollars. On pure dollars, which is all that matters. Right. At the end of the day, for me, the way my brain works. Continue, continue. Right. and they're saying why do you do it and i was like i don't know i enjoyed my time with eric and now noah too and you know they're just like uh you know we're talking about business and i'm like yeah sometimes people do things that have no roi but potentially could and people spend a lot of time on wasted stuff within an organization and they focus on either what we see is shiny object syndrome they see something that's cool they want to do it or the second thing is is they listened to a podcast, watched a video or read a book and heard on how someone did something amazing and grew and they're like, we're going to stop this.

12:24This is the new thing. This is what we're going to do. And this is like, cool. How about you go do the fundamentals that have proven to work for 90 plus percent of businesses that you still haven't accomplished yet? Yeah. So two parts of this and I'll address the podcast or my philosophy on the podcast piece. But I think one, it's not just a shiny object. People should be thinking about, yes, what drives the highest leverage. It's not even just ROI things. It's what's going to drive the highest leverage ROI. That's how people should prioritize. And I think if you're going to be serious about the AI stuff, you as an executive, you should have a coach or somebody helping you understand this.

12:58I don't care how old you are. That's on the AI side. Now, on the podcast piece, interestingly enough, someone came up to me at HubSpot and was like, he's like, dude, actually in the past week, I've talked to a handful of people. When I get on a call with them, I was like, dude, we cut our teeth learning through you guys. I'm like, how long have you been listening for? Seven years. He's like, one guy that we just started working with, he's like, I started listening at 19 years old. There's a lot of people that learn marketing through us that I'm just, I'm kind of shocked by that. But the other thing is the guy I met at Inbound was like, the good thing about your podcast is it forces you and Neil to kind of sharpen your brain, right?

13:32To understand kind of what's going on with trends. And you and I study our own things around business and all that, like the business we operate. But this does, it forces us to engage in discourse. and whatever discourse we're having here, it stays in our mind, right? Yeah. I will say we did make some money too for those good three years that we had with We Love You Dream Host. Yeah, that's true. Dream Host paid us really well. We're ROI positive, I think. No, but I was looking at more like a time perspective, right? I would say the podcast is really useful for me as an individual. You know, I don't know about your business, but for me, when we're going after SMBs, the podcast hasn't been useful as we've been over the years as we moved upstream.

14:11I would say mid-market, sometimes enterprise, they're listeners. And I would say a lot of times if they're super fans, like especially if the CEO listening, they wanna do everything that we're talking about, right? So I would say, I think it's a helpful, like for example, you have your blog as a touch point, you have your YouTube as a touch point. We have this podcast. To me, it's not the rule of seven anymore. It's the rule of 21. You need more touch points. This is just another touch point. And you know what? This is interesting. We just hired a new social guy because I'm so angry about how we're doing social right now.

14:39I'm like guys look at our marketing school channel 10 ,000 subscribers nothing right and this guy came up with all these ideas Like dude with all the clips that we do for you and neil because sometimes you have really good clips Sometimes I have really good clips, right? Right. Why don't you guys just like add as collab on on the the instagram i'm like Oh, yeah, duh So there's a lot of things like we don't pay enough attention to this stuff. No, yeah I think it's just to me. It's just another touch point is is how I see it. Yeah, and the way I look at podcasting is this. I'm in the marketing business.

15:08Marketing is very different from enterprise than most businesses. If you're at Accenture, you can generate a lot of business, not just from RFPs, but from relationships, knowing the executives going to Harvard Business School with them. In marketing, even if you know the right person or they listen to your podcast, marketing for enterprise contracts is a pure RFP game. It is not who you know. If you look at all the RFPs for most of the enterprise, not just brands, but dollar amounts, they go to the holding companies not because they know some are there. It's just a default that you just go to the large agencies and it's a RFP process.

15:44I was at a conference somewhere in Europe, I think later last year. And I learned this from a person who worked at one of the big holding companies. They wrote a book and they started becoming consultants to agencies. And he told me something that was interesting. I can tell you about this, yeah. Yeah, the guy's retirement at this point. And he's like, when I was in the agency world, it was old school, madman relationship style. And he's like, the marketing industry compared to most spaces has really moved to RFP game and they don't really give a crap about relationships as much. That's the difference.

16:19And what we found is we just get RFPs for not YouTube videos, not creating blog content. It's more so requirements that you have X amount of people in these regions. We don't want to work with five agencies. We just want to work with one. So you are one of the ones that we included in this pitch. Yeah. And that was it. And that's the game. I think the way I look at this, and we can move on to the next topic, but the way I look at this is there's an ROI in many different areas. Now, is it the best ROI money-wise in terms of time? No, right? But in a lot of other intangible areas, we talk about the relational wealth standpoint.

16:52I think keeping our mind sharp, I think that does dictate how we have conversations and how we make decisions too. And so I think it's a net positive in my mind. Otherwise, I wouldn't be doing it. And I'm assuming you would be stupid to keep doing something that's not a net positive. It's not that. Some of it's friendships. But before, I know we only have time for one or two topics. I want to cover the Peter Thiel one. I'm building a monopoly. I'm assuming this is zero to one from his book or is this from something else? Yeah. So here, I'll open this up and we should pull this up on the clip. So Peter Thiel, I'm building a monopoly.

17:24So there's three steps to building monopoly. Before you go, is this a new thing or is this old? This is just a combination of, I think, his writings from the past. So this is posted this week. So you see up here. So Peter Thiel, obviously, he was involved in Palantir. Palantir is crushing right now. PayPal, right? And then Founders Fund. And so three steps to building a monopoly. Number one, you start small and you monopolize. What does he mean by that? Every startup begins small and every monopoly dominates a market. Focus on a very small, specific niche first. It is easier to dominate a tiny market than a large one.

17:59So we'll just focus on this one. Here's the example. Let's talk about it. Example, PayPal initially targeted Palm Pilot users, though that early attempt failed due to a poorly defined market. So those that don't know, Palm Pilot was like the iPad before the iPad became a thing. I used to always want one, but it turns out it was a failure. It was too early for its time. Yeah. Yeah. So start small and monopoly. She just basically means niche down initially. Uh-huh. Yep. It's like do marketing for only D2C e-commerce shops and then expand into CPG and then more and more markets and more services.

18:28Number two is to scale gradually. Once you dominate a niche, expand deliberately into adjacent markets. Example, Amazon began with books, then expanded to CDs, videos, software, and eventually all retail. eBay started with Beanie Baby collectors, then grew to a broader online auction marketplace. Sequencing matters. Expanding too quickly or into unrelated markets can fail. So let's use you as an example. So maybe you started more SMB initially and then you expanded to mid-market enterprise. What was the title for number two? Scale Gradually. Got it. Yeah. Yeah. I would say that's right. We started SMB and then we scaled slowly into mid-market and then we slowly scaled into enterprise.

19:03And while we're doing enterprise, we scaled globally, which was very expensive, but that helped us get more enterprise. And the last one over here is don't Disrupt. So people talk about Silicon Valley. Disrupt. I'm disrupting this industry, this and that, right? Avoid framing your startup as a direct competitor to incumbents. True creation is not about attacking existing companies, but offering something new. Disruption can attract attention, but also unnecessary conflict. Remember, we used to use Napster back in middle school. Everyone used Napster, they got shut down, right? Too much attention, right?

19:33Negative attention. PayPal grew. They're also breaking law. Well, yeah, that's a big one, right? But PayPal grew the overall market for payments rather than trying to directly destroy Visa. So I remember back in the day, we were teenagers at the time. I was trying to use PayPal. PayPal had problems all the time. And they're such a niche player. And I knew everybody, we know now everyone was trying to kill them. And they didn't say they were trying to destroy Visa. They wanted to partner with Visa. So when we look at Carrot right now, we're like, oh no, we're not trying to disrupt anyone in the personalization space.

20:01We want to partner with you. And so right now we're working with all these companies to partner with them. And the last one, Bonus insight. This one's counterintuitive. The last mover advantage. So people like to say the first mover advantage. So Coke used to be the first mover, right? People talk about first mover advantage. Being first is tactical, not strategic. Aim to be the last mover in the market. Make the final great development and enjoy lasting monopoly profits. So Google wasn't the first search engine. They came later and they're very much a monopoly, right? Strategy, dominate a small niche, then scale carefully toward the long-term vision cool yeah so guys that's how you start a monopoly and peter teal's whole whole thing with monopolies is you should strive to be a monopoly so you don't have as many competitors you can get really big my favorite thing on one of his speeches when he talks about monopolies like one thing that they all have in common they have a really like strong brand and then he goes in to say i don't understand how you how they build a strong brand but it's a requirement yeah because like his brain just doesn't process things that way when he's like a machine yeah i think all right yeah brilliant guy yeah i don't know him but brilliant guy so that's it for today guys please don't forget to rate me and subscribe i will see you tomorrow