Dangers of AI Content, The Death of Agencies, Best-kept SEO Secret, and The North Face's Genius Marketing Move (Reactions Dec 2023 Week 2)

0:00All right. So we're going to start on the reactions for this week. And Neil, you actually get to go first. Or would you like me to go first? It's up to you. You get the shit. Okay. So there's actually Ross Hudgens, who's a guy that we both know. He had a post here on Twitter. This is one that we get. We're basically going to react to a lot of this news. And so actually, this one relates to the AI piece that I was just trying to get to. So scaled AI content carries real reputation risk for big brands. So this is Ross Hudgens. The juice here is really worth the squeeze. So Sports Illustrated said on November 27th, today an article was published alleging that Sports Illustrated published AI-generated articles.

0:40According to our initial investigation, that is not accurate. Articles were product reviews and were licensed content from external third-party company, and then they're just trying to offload the blame, right? So I think this is a good place for us to start. And we kind of touched upon it a little bit in the last episode around AI-assisted content. But I just think that too many people are just saying – I talked to a guy. I remember there's an entrepreneur. He's like, yeah, I was paying$15 ,000 to a content marketing agency, and I decided to fire them. And you know what? I'm just paying$50 to an AI-21.

1:10It's just cranking out articles for me. Now, on the other side, this sucks for the content marketing agency because I have a content marketing agency friend. They're in trouble right now. Like they're losing a ton of clients left and right, and they don't know what to do because everyone's switching over to this, right? I think there's a happy medium here. Obviously, both Neil and I have agencies, but it's at the end of the day, like we just want to say, hey, the right thing to do here is to have a human in the loop at the end of the day. If you don't have a human in the loop, the content is also not as good.

1:39And I think everyone forgets this, no matter how smart AI is, if you look at chat, GPT, their index, at least of this recording is from September 2021. So anything that it outputs is going to be, you know, scraping the web and scraping a lot of old stuff, like when you're asking it just general questions. And it's just old, people want fresh, new information. BART is more up-to-date, but even still then, people want fresh, new stuff that hasn't been talked about. If you look at all the content that does well, it's typically new stuff. It's not old, regurgitated information. I think the way to do this, Neil, is, okay, let's say you have a ton of data.

2:16I think companies that have a ton of data, right? Like, let's say we collect a bunch of data from clients. It's like, you can now use Gemini or BART or ChatGPT to upload the data that you have and then use it to come up with insights. And then you can take those insights, that data, and then you can craft a nice LinkedIn post, a nice Twitter post around it. And so that to me is still very AI assisted. And I think it's going to do a good job because I'm just like tangentially related here. Like I don't like it when I have to go to my finance team and be like, hey, can you give me the blended LTV over the last three months?

2:45And then this channel over here, that channel. And like, it takes forever to get the answers, but to be able to ask immediately and get those answers, I can move a lot faster. You can. What's funny is what you're talking about doing with AI, that only works if you have data. I think a lot of companies don't have data, so they're just relying on other people's information on the web. But one thing that we're doing with our businesses, we're moving from AWS to Google Cloud. Plus, they offered us amazing. Oh, why? Oh, there you go. Let's just say financially, we saved a lot of money. But in combination, we believe Gemini, Bard, whatever you want to end up calling their solutions, depending on the names they're starting to use, it's just going to be a better place for them to dissect our data and give us insights versus AWS plus AWS costs more.

3:34And when I say discount, I'm not talking about like 10, 20%. I'm talking about something substantial. Yep. All right, Neil, you're next. Pick one. All right. So let's talk about the agency model is dead. You're supposed to pick one of yours, but that's okay. We can go with that. So we're getting used to this format still. So this is interesting. So Neil, I listened to this podcast. This is Perpetual Traffic. And it's a pretty – shout out to them. It's a pretty good marketing podcast. And what I would say is I agree with a lot of stuff that they're saying. And some of the stuff like it's – both Neil and I have agency, so we're incentivized to just understand our incentives at the end of the day.

4:13But a lot of stuff is changing where Google, for example, what used to matter a lot was the way you Google ads is how you structured your campaign, how you bid on, how you eliminated, how you had negative keywords and a lot of that stuff. Right. And now it's more so it's starting to trend towards this performance max. It's not all the way in that direction right now, but more and more people are just saying, hey, I'm just going to run performance max and just leave it there in the next five, 10 years. Who knows what happens? Right. Here, let me finish my thought first. The other thing is... Let me talk about Performance Max, right?

4:46Okay, go, go, go, go, go, go, go, go. Right, so I haven't listened to this podcast episode. Did you see that, was it Adweek that wrote an article on Merkle and Performance Max? No, go. No, go. Okay, so Merkle is a big agency. It's owned by Dentsu, the big conglomerate based out of Japan, but they're global. I think they say their headquarters are technically London. But either way, they have like 60 or 100 ,000 employees. It's something large like that. and the last time I checked their market cap it was around$9 billion so it's a big corporation Are they part of a holding company? Merkle is just an agency they own just by itself they're switching all the names to more like Dentsu X, Dentsu Performance, whatever it may be so they're trying to consolidate the brands but it is an ad agency when you look at what Dentsu what Merkle did is with a lot of their clients they ended up running Performance Max campaigns and they just let Google do their thing.

5:41Guess what happened to the performance for most of their clients? I'm guessing it went down. On the flip side, we ran performance max for our clients. Guess what happened with our performance? It went down. It went up. Oh, it went up. Okay. Yes. That disproves your point. No, but what we see with performance max is a lot of time, it ends up driving junk leads and then it's fine tuning its model based on also the junk data or the junk quality traffic that it's driving. so what we did on our end is we disqualified the junk we send the junk to a different landing page versus the real good stuff the performance max is then being fine-tuned off of the good stuff and then we were able to outperform versus just letting performance max do it on its own like what merkel decided to do we didn't want to take that risk hence we had human intervention the point i'm getting at is you know in the future it may be able to figure all this out on their own But right now it isn't.

6:36So having a human go in there and tweak it, we're finding to produce better results than not having a human go in there. You're seeing a theme here, everyone. So the theme here is you want to have a human in a loop because we're not quite there yet where it can do everything. Like it's this stuff. I mean, ChatGPT is barely a year old right now, right? Like this stuff is just getting started. So it's highly recommended you have a human in a loop. Same thing for us. When we run performance access, it's the same thing as you, Neil. Like you need to fine tune it. And fine tuning just means that you're helping them iterate on data and you're helping guide the model, right?

7:05At the end of the day. The other thing too, Neil, I'm not sure if you're seeing this, but I'm definitely seeing this on our side as at SingleGrain. It's, there's becoming, there's more and more pushback going against the percentage of spend. I don't think that's going to evaporate like overnight, but I'm seeing it more than I have before. What have you seen? Wait, can you repeat the question again? Yeah, the question, okay. So here's what we've seen, right? Right. So we've seen there start to be a gradual rise in pushback against the management fees, right? So that the percentage of spend, which is what's typical in the ad world, right?

7:40But what these two guys said on the podcast, and they both have advertising agencies too, is they're saying they think the model is going to go away. I'm not sure it's going to go away overnight, but I think we're going to start to see a bigger rise in pushback. No, I would say my agencies at scale, maybe others would disagree, but we're not seeing any pushback on management fees. We know a lot of the executives that run the bigger ad agencies, They're not seeing pushbacks either. Yeah. So I can only speak anecdotally and listen to what these guys are saying too. So Neil's not seeing it. Obviously, different sizes for different agencies too, right?

8:12The common theme with fees and everything like that, what people care more about the fees is performance. Dude, we've taken accounts, Fortune 100 companies, not 5 ,000 or 500. I'm talking about really big companies that make tens of billions in profit per year. Not every once in a while or a billion a year in profit. I'm talking about eight plus figures. I'm not eight, nine, ten. Over ten plus figures in profit per year, right? So not actually ten. Nine would be$100 million. Eleven figures, whatever it is. I'm bad at math this early in the morning. But we've charged them more management fees than what they were paying before.

8:55They don't care necessarily about the management fees. What they really care is in total, including your management fees, this is how much we spend. What's our ROI? And if you can drive a better ROI, people usually don't care. Yeah, I think here's how I would position this. It's at the end of the day, if people aren't willing to pay and they complain about price, it means value hasn't been conveyed. And so it really is a matter of how well you're able to figure out what their goals are and what the value is of meeting those metrics. And then guiding and saying, hey, like, okay, you want to hit these metrics.

9:23Here's what's good. Like it's going to take resource on our end. But if we can hit these metrics, is it worth it to pay us this? And they'll say yes. Right. And if they say it out of their own mouth, usually they're more much more receptive versus having sticker shock. Yep. All right. Next up. Here's something interesting. You know, what percentage of search traffic, SEO traffic, do you actually think that companies over a billion dollars generate from outside of their brand name? I don't know. The way you asked, that makes me think a low percentage, like 10%. Yeah. So, you know, I had this post on Twitter.

10:04We took a lot of data and we're, you know, analyzing it. And I pretty much bring down a little SEO secret that no one talks about. So we look at the brand queries. What percentage of organic search traffic are coming to websites based on the revenue size? So companies from 1 to 9 million, typically around 12.5 % of the traffic is coming from people Googling variations of their brand names. From 10 to 99 million, we're seeing it 22.4 % of their search traffic, organic search traffic, coming again from people Googling variations of their brand name. And for 100 million to 999 million a year, we're seeing brand queries make up roughly 41.9 % of their organic search traffic.

10:46And for a billion plus, it's 68.2%. It's ridiculous on how much branded traffic actually drives for big corporations. But should it be shocking, the last time I was looking at SEMrush, they had this report of the top 10 most popular search queries. Seven out of the 10 of them were brands like Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, WhatsApp, Amazon, et cetera. Dude, as a side note, I feel like you should be getting a lot more play on this one. Maybe this has to be repackaged. Did you put this on LinkedIn too? I don't know if I got put on LinkedIn. This for sure would do well on LinkedIn. But anyway. But yeah, I also think with some of this stuff, a lot of it doesn't do as well because people can't relate to it.

11:29How many of us actually have a billion plus dollar revenue a year company? Yeah. Well, I mean, look, I think on LinkedIn, that's why I think it'll do well on LinkedIn. But that's interesting. So what is our key takeaway for this one? You know, a lot of people are worried about like SEO, is it coming or is it going away? It's going to affect all these big corporations. What people tend to forget is a lot of these big corporations get the majority of their organic search traffic from their brand, not from random search queries. On top of that, you know, brands tend to rank really well because search engines know that they're less likely to create fake news.

12:05Facebook, too. Eric Schmidt and Matt Cutts used to have different sayings about brands. I won't repeat them. But the Matt Cutts one is the easiest in which you would be like, look, we know that New York Times and IRS is on this side and a lot of other sites that don't have that reputation on the other side. And what SEOs really need to take away from this, build a brand. Use a rule of seven. Use omni-channel marketing. Get it out there. Use all the channels. This is how you're going to win in the long run. When I first started my business, the overwhelm was real. I didn't have the tools to help me scale.

12:37If only I had Shopify from the start to handle all the behind-the-scenes work. Shopify is the platform behind millions of businesses globally from huge names like Mattel and Gymshark to the smallest brands just getting started. The best part about it, it has everything you could need. Say you're ready to launch your own design studio. Shopify has hundreds of templates to create a beautiful store that matches your brand style. Or if you need help with content creation, Shopify has got AI tools that write your product descriptions, craft page headlines, and even enhance your product photos. Shopify lets you easily create email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they are, whether they're scrolling or strolling.

13:13If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify. Turn your big business idea into with Shopify on your side. Sign up for your$1 per month trial and start selling today at shopify.com slash marketing school. Go to shopify.com slash marketing school, shopify.com slash marketing school. If you've ever built a website, you know how tough it can be to keep a strong design while ensuring site performance is fast. That's where Framer comes in and it totally changes the game. Framer is the design first no code website builder that lets anyone ship a production ready site in minutes. I recently built a custom landing page in just a few hours, animations, fast load times, responsive layouts, all without writing a single line of code.

13:57It was easy to use and the end result was polished enough to look like a developer spent days on it. One of my favorite things is that Framer's AI handles translations with a single click. So your site can be up and running in multiple languages almost instantly. And with real-time collaboration, your whole team can jump in and work together. No issues with versions or miscommunication, whether you're starting from scratch or using one of their templates. Framer lets you focus on design while handling the technical side for you. Animations, responsive layouts, search optimization, and all the things that matter.

14:26Ready to build a site that looks hand-coded without hiring a developer? Launch your site for free at framer.com and use code MS to get your first month of pro on the house. That's framer.com promo code MS, framer.com promo code MS rules and restrictions may apply. You know what I used to hate Neil? And I think we talked about this before. I used to hate it when people called me the SEO guy. And I think you didn't really like it as much either. But as we get older, I'm just like, it's okay to be doing as a guy for something. Yeah. Yes. I actually, I still hate it today when people are like, you're the SEO guy.

14:57And then I'm like, you know, it's funny. I probably spent 90 % of my time on business and business strategy than even on SEO. But it's okay because being known as a guy who's good at SEO has made me a lot of my income in this world. So I'm not going to hate on it too much. Yeah. All right. So we're going to cap it off with this one over here. So can you hear the audio, Neil? Yeah. Oh, not on the video yet. You hear it now? A couple of days ago, the tag in the advertising said that it was waterproof, as a rain jacket would be. Well, listen, I'm 100 % sure that it's raining outside and I'm soaking wet.

15:39Oh, look. Listen, I don't want to reach that. I want you to redesign this green coat and make it waterproof and express delivery it up to the Walker Valley Lake in New Zealand, where I will be. All right. So the key takeaway here for those of you that can't see it is this gal, she got about 10.3 million views on her TikTok. And she was complaining about her North Face rain jacket not being waterproof because it said it was waterproof. Now, here's the interesting thing. Now, this next video, we can talk about whether it's staged or not. But here's the thing. North Face reacted to it.

16:21You got a helicopter? Yep.

16:36same person same person so the first one i believe was not staged it's the second video let me explain what happened in the second video we can react to it so the second video north face makes a video i think it gets like three four million views or so they take a jacket a red jacket and they get in a helicopter and they fly to the spot where she's supposed to be waiting, right? She shows up in the video. She looks like she's very clean and all that. So this video looks like it's staged. But the point is North Face had a chance here to really siphon off of one video that was talking about them that got 10 million views.

17:06And then they got even more views from it. Yeah, that's really cool. I think that was smart of them too. I've had North Face jackets in the past. Maybe the one she was wearing wasn't rainproof. But when I lived in Seattle, So North Face was one of the key go-tos because they do make products that are rainproof and they keep you warm and aren't too thick. But it's really good on how they ended up reacting like that. Yeah. We can call it social listening or just being on top of it. But I think this is just one of those things that stands out. And that's how you get people's attention, right? That's marketing 101.

17:38So don't forget to rate, review, and subscribe. It helps us grow. Check out this next video over here. And that being said, we'll see you tomorrow. And I'll see you next time.