


Celine Song discusses love as an “art” and an act of attention (not something to “take” or “fall into”), and how modern culture turns dating and marriage into self-commodification and asset-acquisition. She connects these ideas to her film Materialist and to themes in the four books she recommends.
Celine Song (filmmaker; director/writer of Past Lives and Materialist). Interviewer is not named in the transcript.
Song studied psychology and philosophy; she’s known for character-driven, intimate storytelling about relationships, desire, and identity.
Love requires knowing the real person, not an image; marriage is institutionalized via benefits and “value police” internalized through culture/Instagram; erotic desire is about pursuit/knowledge, not exclusivity-as-ownership; romantic love remains uncertain and “makes fools of all of us,” yet it’s the most practical choice.
Eric Fromm’s view that love is standing in love; marriage as a business partner arrangement; dating apps commodifying people into “coordinates”; Materialist’s portrayal of transactional intimacy and self-objectification; The Razor’s Edge’s Larry choosing a life others deem unserious; How Should a Person Be?’s honesty about desire and power; Pride and Prejudice’s family steering contrasted with Materialist’s internalized values.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Celine discusses her love for the book 'The Art of Loving' by Eric Fromm.
“Thank you so much for doing this you've chosen four incredible books I actually I was saying uh before you got here I think they're my four favorite books that anyone's ever recommended.”
A deep dive into the nature of love and its various forms as described by Fromm.
Discussion about marriage's societal implications and materialism.
“game to preserve our prestige and feelings of superiority and merit in terms of getting married which I think feels like a theme in your new movie Materialist as well.”
Exploration of how love and relationships change as we age.
“So something that has been very helpful is to be like, when somebody says, when there is a question of, does this person love this other person?”
Celine reflects on the bravery required to seek love and its societal implications.
“But I think that's really hard to explain to somebody who's not been loved very well.”
Discussion on the enigmatic nature of love and its impact on human intellect.
“And I think that makes it so much easier to be like, I wish I could tell you that.”
Exploring the challenges and societal perceptions of love and relationships.
Discussing the significance of exclusivity in romantic relationships and personal growth.
“And then, of course, I feel like it's also interesting because, of course, for such a long time, marriage was a domain of women.”
Analyzing the loneliness epidemic and the effectiveness of dating apps in fostering genuine connections.
“Even if you try to devote your whole life to that.”
Examining the impact of capitalism on self-worth and the commodification of individuals.
“You can use dating apps beautifully, but I feel like often it is being used as a way to commodify and objectify each other.”
Understanding the essence of love beyond societal expectations and materialism.
“You're sort of like, even when you think about something as what, I mean, it sounds like you had a great university experience where you're actually like expanding your mind.”
Discussing the insights from W. Somerset Maugham's 'The Razor's Edge' regarding life's choices.
“I know you need to be a motivational speaker for young women.”
Exploring the intertwining of character and destiny in making life choices.
“You know, so I think it's always like when somebody's making a choice like that, my thing is always to believe them.”
Exploration of character motivations and the heartbreak in love choices.
“Because my thing is, it's like, well, she could always have the character in Somerset Mom could have always made the decision.”
Discussion on the influence of societal norms and self-perception in character decisions.
“Well, I think that like it is possible to live without romantic love for all of your life.”
How self-objectification affects personal identity and relationships.
“Well, because I feel like the truth is that we have already installed the value police inside of us, right?”
Insights on collaboration with actors and their understanding of self-objectification.
“She launched her book club, and I interviewed her about Beautyland and about the book club.”
Discussing the themes of Sheila Hetty's book and its reflection on womanhood.
“And before the interview, I was looking through my phone because I always tape photos of pages that I like and I just had so many photos.”
The importance of revealing darkness in stories for authenticity.
Learn how characters can embody both beauty and darkness in storytelling.
“about yourself can work and can exist in the world and for the audience.”
Discover the nuances of physical intimacy and its implications in relationships.
“And the thing is, like, to believe that it is what it is means that, like, well, are you actually willing to go out there and meet the human beings that you're supposed to grow old with?”
Examine the intersection of practicality and romance in classic literature.
“But if you think about what the story is, we were just talking about the first line of the book.”
Reflect on how perspectives on literary characters shift with age and experience.
Discussing the complexities of happiness, societal expectations for women, and the nature of love.
The discussion delves into the deep connections and rituals of dating, connecting modern practices to ancient traditions.
“And then like some of it is about the kind of like this ancient like dating ritual that has always existed on some level.”
The speaker shares personal insights from their brief matchmaker experience and societal pressures on dating standards.
“But Taylor Hanson's making my day way better with these new soft and swirly King's Hawaiian cinnamon bites.”
The conversation shifts to the importance of discussing financial realities and societal numbers openly.
The need for candid discussions about personal expectations and societal definitions in relationships is emphasized.
The hosts express appreciation for Celine's work and encourage listeners to see her play Materialist.
“And then, of course, the clients will talk around it, but Lucy and her colleagues, right, yeah, she can interpret what they really mean.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On One Nightstand, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Propel Fitness Water with Gatorade electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade electrolytes. Fall never arrives all at once. First the air, then the light, and slowly the things you love begin to find each other. A jacket meets a dress, a hoodie slips beneath a blazer. An old cap finds a new scarf. Because you don't simply step into the season. You create it layer by layer until it finally feels like fall. Find fall your way at Ross.
0:44Celine Song: This big scene that Mr. Darcy shows up to, he literally goes like, you are so poor and so in debt, but I feel something for you. It's very confusing. And then she's like, fuck. Fuck, I love that. She says, fuck off. I know it's so good. Well Celine Song welcome to One Night Stand. Thank you so much for doing this you've chosen four incredible books I actually I was saying uh before you got here I think they're my four favorite books that anyone's ever recommended. I'm so happy perfect it is just I those they're my favorite books and I'm just so happy that we get to talk about them. Yay okay well let's start with The Art of Loving by Eric Fromm.
1:23I assume that's how you say I should say
1:25Celine Song: tell me what you love about this book i feel like this book is kind of like i think of it as a very much a textbook in the art of loving there are by the way just a caveat as it has some things in it that are like very old ideas about queerness and gender that i think is like just a caveat for people reading it but um it's a book that was written by i mean the first book that i read by eric from is a book called escape from freedom and it's this amazing book he's a marxist and he was somebody who said in Escape from Freedom that like all of us we say that we want freedom but actually all we want to do is to be rid of it.
2:02Yeah. And it talks about a modern condition when it comes to that so I that was such an important book and and then I was reading everything that he had and one of the books that came about is This Art of Loving which is a pretty short book and I was just I found it to be it was something that really unlocked something in me when it comes to what love is because I think that love is one of the great mysteries of life and when I was in college I was trying to understand what it is as a psychological problem an emotional problem but also like an existential problem and when I read that book the way that it like delineates different kinds of love yeah but then to talk about something that unifies all of it which is that it is not a gift to give it's not a thing to take but it's a thing that uh we do yeah you stand in love he says rather than fall into it exactly and then you stand in love and then you also uh every moment you live you can always choose to be doing it yeah right yeah and and just because and it also is something that was really beautiful is that um romantic love erotic love love for family love for friends it's the way that it is there's no uh there's no inequality in those things as in like just because you have love for your friend um it does it's such a unique thing but it doesn't have to be uh of higher value or lower value so basically to uh get rid of the notion that love is a value yeah that it is an act and it's what an amazing act that we get to do in our life totally you know and it but it also kind of really gets at the complicated ways like i think he's sort of making the case that we've fallen a bit from how we should think about love some of the time right and he talks about um i wrote down this one he talks about the psychoanalyst sullivan who says we play according to the rules of the game to preserve our prestige and feelings of superiority and merit in terms of getting married which I think feels like a theme in your new movie Materialist as well.
4:08Tell me about how you do you agree with that? Do you think that's accurate? I think so. I think that the thing is like marriage is something that ends up in the historical record. We get a little piece of paper. And then, of course, it comes with a lot of like benefits that the government and the right. Yeah. And everybody decided as like, well, yeah, these are you're going to have tax benefits. You're going to have health care benefits. like there's gonna be all these like benefits to getting married to someone yeah that's not the place in the uk you don't i don't think this town thinks so well as in there's obviously like yeah if there's two of you paying for a house instead of one but you don't you have tax returns in the same way really yeah you just pay it based on your individual income in the u.s definitely i know and it's crazy when i got here i was like damn but i think it's like so there are just like an amazing way that has become completely an institution institutionalized thing yeah and then you're when you're thinking about your partner in that way, someone to marry, you start to think about them as who will be my business partner.
5:07Yes, literally. Right? Yeah. But then you have to realize, well, what is the business of a marriage anyway? Right? And the thing is, well, the business of marriages, and of course there's a huge industry built around treating marriage and weddings as a business. yeah right and so to me it's like well materialist is about acknowledging materialist as a film is about acknowledging that as a reality modern reality that we live in yeah but to also ask
5:34Celine Song: the question yes but like what was it all for it's like what's the ancient thing that we were doing um and what is it for and I think that there is another side of materialism and love where I think that it is about like how um you know uh sometimes it's about like the watching your partner grow older their body yeah as a material age right or to um decide what to eat together yeah right so i think about that and i think that's really what was so uh to me that book uh meant a lot to me in college and it of course it still serves as that and when somebody asked me like oh i want to know more about love I want to think more about love more deeply yeah it's usually a book that I gift oh yeah I mean I love that you got so into that at college were you always a big reader growing up and yeah yeah of course yeah and then you just during your studies that was love and that sort of topic was something you were just curious about from that sort of age yeah I mean I was a psychology major so I feel like I kind of knew about Eric Fromm yeah I feel like I knew philosophy and so he was kind of like in one of the one of the authors but i remember meeting this book and then being it's like oh like now i understand love a lot better and uh because it's an art and that's what's called the art of loving and you have to think about it the same way you think about uh writing something or making a movie yeah and it's a it's an it's an act right And it's something that we, and so much of it has to be about understanding and acceptance, which is what our loving is.
7:16So something that has been very helpful is to be like, when somebody says, when there is a question of, does this person love this other person? There's a very simple answer. It's like, well, does this person know the other person? Or is this just an image that they have of the other person? Oh my gosh. Right. Very real. We've all been there. We all know. It's like, well, is this somebody that you made up in your head or is this the person that you met and you know and you're connecting with? That's a hard one. And we get it wrong all the time. People are too focused on being loved and giving love.
7:47But I think that's because we feel a lot of scarcity.
7:51Celine Song: Yes. Yes. Right. We feel so starved of it because, and I think it's a cultural thing. I think it's a matter of a problem of the civilization yeah where I think that we are um often in environments or we feel like there is a kind of a way that we've been robbed of feeling generously yeah love right because in our survival and everything like there's a bit of it where it's like we are constantly in need of it because we don't have enough of it totally right but the truth is that it's you have endless supply of it yeah right it just has to do with you Yeah. If you're able to give it endlessly, then you're going to have it endlessly.
8:31Yeah. But I think that's really hard to explain to somebody who's not been loved very well. No, that's so true. And that's unfortunately, I think, most of the world.
8:39Celine Song: Yeah. Right. So I think like everybody, you can ask them, well, who was the first person that really showed you love? Yeah. Right. And then some people will have struggle naming somebody and some people will say that one person. Yeah. But the truth is, wouldn't it be amazing if we were all able to give it? What that means is it's going to inspire love in the other person. Totally. And there'll be more. I think one of the great cruelties is that I feel like in some ways it gets harder as you get older to learn that. Me and I, I'm single and 36, and I talk to a lot of my friends that are also single.
9:14And I feel like in many ways it does get sort of harder as you get older, because I feel like you're a little bit set in your ways. like and we see that in your movie materialists as well where the characters who are older get more like i've hung in here for this long and i'm gonna get what i want and what i came for yeah whereas i do feel like when i think back to when i was a teenager i was more like i think malleable and sort of open to stuff and it does but yeah it's sort of a cruelty because that's as you get older you sort of need it more in a way because like life i feel like gets you know it gets harder and there's bigger challenges and stuff but yeah i don't know i feel like we increasingly are told that uh we don't need it and we shouldn't need it yeah to need it is a weakness and desperation 100 right and when you're younger i think that there is less demand of that so i feel like there's a lot of like self-denial of love but in fact it's like well it is very brave to say to somebody like what i need is love yes right but it's so hard to do that that's why it's so brave yeah right and i think it's like increasingly as you get older it is harder to be brave like women because i think it's simply that i think it's like when you're 19 yes you kind of whatever you you don't know now you don't know that you're gonna look embarrassing what in love oh so much like you watch like a tv show or a film and then you it's normal for you to be like obsessed with right love right and then i think that as you grow older they're like are you a child exactly right are you a little girl yeah right two men of course they're like this girl you know just being like such a girl yeah right so there is a kind of a constant demeaning in people's desire for uh love and romance right and then because uh it is very brave that's why it's very brave to be like well i may be rejected but i will still ask i love that would you love me and yeah i love you would you love me back yeah right and i think that to me is like what is the hardest thing it'd be so much easier i think to say like what i want is money right totally i mean and that's what a lot of these people who go to these matchmakers say because it's sort of like well they're like they're like what i want is these material things actually because that's so much easier than to say like i want this yeah thing that i used to when i was a teenager this old very ancient thing all right every song is about right every book is about 100 and i want that yeah the bravery of that i think is really um it's to me that's what's so heroic right have is your like capacity for that bravery changed as you've got older do you or do you feel like you've sort of always been able to sit in that kind of strength to be able to do it i actually feel like um part of the reason why i make the movies that i do is because it's like uh it is in a way to keep myself from uh not being brave yeah you know like it's like
12:09Celine Song: it's just i'm really trying to keep my bravery up always right i love that yeah and it's like But what's great is also that like some of it has to do with the fact that like I have been loved and I am loved. And I think that makes it so much easier to be like, I wish I could tell you that. I wish I could tell people who are like, well, how can I believe it? It's so hard. It feels impossible. I don't feel brave enough for it. It's very hard to tell them. It's like, yes, but when you have it. Yeah, it's all worth it. it's worth all the risk is worth it but it's a lot of risk to put up front it's a lot of risk right and it's a lot of pain yes exactly and of course it's like and to want it is so embarrassing yeah that's that that's the part i think is so where i sometimes feel i i look i think we're born like a month apart because i looked this online when i was researching so we grew up in the same sort of generation i sometimes feel like i got done a little bit dirty by some of the way that things were positioned when we were younger because I feel like people were were rebounding justifiably against the kind of like marriage as their own as the sort of goal and it was like no you have multiple goals but I almost I feel like sometimes in I was like pushed to think of love as like really just like man whatever like kind of thing and and I it's what I love I love about your work is that I feel like it pushes it forward and is like no you can want money and you can want career and you can want job and you can want all of those things but well it's interesting because I feel like uh love is a mystery that we were never going to be able to solve no right so as the world advances as the technology advances as all of us start to like discover and explore and find everything and have answers and certainties about everything what's the one thing that is completely uncertain yeah and I think about this because I'm like well you talk to the smartest most interesting uh most brilliant people on earth and you talk to them and they tell you about what everything from quantum physics to politics to like history everything and then you ask them well uh how's your love life going yeah are you in love what's happening and then they will say of course like i don't know yeah it makes me feel like an idiot yeah right and the thing is like love makes fools of all of us right that's the cliche yeah so i think in that way it's like it's always going to be yeah like a thing that uh if you want to seem smart you're going to shy away from that i think that's exactly how i felt that's exactly what i felt about when i was younger when it was sort of like well you're like you're a bright child you're gonna do well you're gonna like ascend your starting point in life so you don't worry about that don't worry about love like love is not something that because you're not gonna get an answer for it no you're gonna you can't get an A plus.
14:55Yes, exactly. Right? Everything else you can get A plus. I know. You can't get A plus. So don't even bother. And then, of course, I feel like it's also interesting because, of course, for such a long time, marriage was a domain of women. Yes. Right? Women are the ones supposed to want and desire it, which, of course, makes sense because of how much power that it gave somebody to be married. Right? It's one of the few ways that a woman could get power. Yeah. So another part of this is that like, well, there's a bit of a dismissal of it being it's like, well, love, marriage, relationships. That's the domain of women.
15:29Yes. Which, right? Yeah.
15:31Celine Song: Which should feel like, well, that means it's a very powerful domain. Yeah. But in fact, they just were like, well, because of that, it's frivolous. Exactly. Right. Because of that, you should want to ascend beyond that. Yeah. And it's like, and it's like, it's not serious. No, exactly. Right. Yes. a lot of the stuff that I'm just like god why did I swallow that hole it feels because of lish but it's like yeah and also you're being told that you're really smart and you have answers to everything exactly of course and then and then they're like yeah but then love there's no answer to that so so uh oh you're just a girl yeah just the you know just a girl who's into like love yeah boys and then you're kind of like uh no no no I like I like serious things right and then you're like oh yeah but then why what makes us believe that love is not a serious thing yeah and also that's the reason why we don't have enough of it no quite right you're so right yeah um i also there was a bit in the eric framework where they talk about erotic love and the exclusiveness that comes from that and i've wrote one quote down that um it's about two people who identify themselves with each other and who solve the problem of separateness by enlarging the single individual into two and the sort of like idea of exclusivity and I feel like he is sort of making the case that we shouldn't be so obsessed with that exclusivity did you I don't maybe I read it incorrectly but how do you feel about that sort of dynamic well I think that it is really about knowing the other person yeah in such a deep way and then to really it's kind of like once you are obsessed with the topic yeah it's like when you're obsessed with the topic of your lover and then you can kind of uh you're kind of digging into that lover right as as deeper deeper you dig into that lover you get to learn the universe that exists in another person in a way that if you just casually know someone you may know some parts of their universe but maybe not necessarily the deepest most intimate so it's really just the pursuit of knowledge of the other person i think that's really what that really is about as for I think the exclusivity it's like well it's more like um you might be like well right right now I'm into specific genre of jazz music from this time right and then maybe you're sick enough one day say like actually now I'm interested in a different right depends on the person I think I think some people can be like no I'm into that piece of jazz music for the rest of my life yeah some people might be like oh I moved on from the jazz music I'm like I'm moving to something else.
18:07But I think it's like, but the truth is, I think what Eric Fromm is also talking about is inside one person is endless abyss of meaning and the way of seeing the world that it actually, you're not going to get to know that person in their entirety. Even if you try to devote your whole life to that. So that's sort of what I believe. I just fully believe that it's like, well, it's I think it's a unconditional lifetime thing because I know that it's it is something that like won't stop. I will never stop learning about the people I love. Right. I love that. I thought it was sort of fascinating. It gave me plenty to think about that book, especially as we think about the sort of like loneliness epidemic that's hitting young people.
18:56Yeah.
18:57Celine Song: No, I just feel like the loneliness epidemic, I feel like we talk about it as a whole epidemic. I'm like, well, the loneliness has always existed, right? Yeah. And a solution to that has always been love. But then I'm like, well, is there any attempt that we're making to make it possible for us to love, right? And you're like, well, I don't think that dating apps are necessarily what's achieving that. Definitely not. Because it's about dating apps. You can use dating apps beautifully, but I feel like often it is being used as a way to commodify and objectify each other. Yeah, 100%. And themselves.
19:36Yes. And you sort of itemize yourself in this way of like, these are my five coordinates. Exactly. And where are your coordinates? And then you try to do this and you try to improve yourself. Like think about it. Exactly.
19:48Celine Song: Like there's a lot of self-improvement language. I know. Like there's a dating coaching. like there's a lot of ways that you're trying to improve your worth as a product i totally i mean and even just this idea i saw um uh i can't it was um oh god i'm thinking of the actress who plays leslie nop in parks and recreation uh amy paula yeah in her podcast she was talking about how she's like i think women have done enough improving she's like yeah done and i think that as well because i'm like part of this constant culture of self-improvement i'm supposed to want to improve like the length of my hair the quality of my hair the texture of it and then move on down I'm meant to include the quality of my forehead the texture of my skin it's just like endless bullshit I'm like so over it yeah well I mean that's the reason why I think that so Eric Fromm is a fundamentally he's a Marxist yeah um political scientist is probably what he would identify him and the thing about him is that part of Marxism is has always been that like well no you you're a human being you're not a commodity right and so it's about how capitalism is something that where it turns human beings and their life and of course their labor and their mind and everything into a commodity and as a part of a factory yes right so that's always been the thing that marxists are talking about they're like well human beings are the human beings right and they're they are whether they're valuable just because of the way that they're just living, breathing animals, not because of the things that it can contribute to the market.
21:23Exactly. But that's right. You're sort of like, even when you think about something as what, I mean, it sounds like you had a great university experience where you're actually like expanding your mind. But when I was at university, the way a lot of people were thinking about it was very much like, I'm going to maximize my value in the market that's ahead of me. And so I'm going to acquire these specific skills or whatever. Well, not even skills, like this specific like branding almost. Yeah. It's fascinating. But I just don't know where love can show up for that.
21:49Celine Song: No. And you're like, well, is it, are you loving all the assets and all the way that, right? Like, are you, and then of course, then it becomes like, is dating an acquisition of an asset? Yes. When the highest asset possible. Yeah. Right. And you're like, well, unfortunately, love is so simple. It is two people looking at each other and being like, I could do this forever. Oh. Right. And if that's what it is, it's not going to have anything to do with how much you improve height, weight, income. Oh, my God. You know, but then that's how, that's the only way. And by the way, I understand it because the whole world works that way.
22:25So why wouldn't love? So why wouldn't love? I know you need to be a motivational speaker for young women.
22:33One of the other books that you recommended is The Razor's Edge by W. Somerset Maugham, which I loved. I was telling you before I was up till midnight reading this on Sunday. And I think this also has a lot of interesting ideas about capitalism. And capitalism is an opposite to curiosity in a way, which I thought was really interesting. But tell me what you love about this book.
22:52Celine Song: Well, I feel like I love that all these different characters were dealing with the kind of like incoming modernity, trying to make their way. And then in a way, they all end up in exactly the way that they want. But it's all very, very different. And I think that the central character, Larry, is somebody who is in pursuit of something that the world does not want him to be pursuing. And doesn't understand. Doesn't understand. And can't even understand it. No. And it's like a really interesting thing because it's like, well, he seems like he is completely out of his mind because he refuses to live the way that someone like him, quote unquote, should be living.
23:34Exactly. He's a man of leisure. Yeah. Right. He doesn't do anything. I just want to loaf. I just want to loaf. That's what I was always saying. I'm just going to loaf. Exactly. And then you're like, and there was an amazing thing where it's like, yeah, and everybody's looking at him.
23:45Celine Song: And so much of the book is about everybody looking at him and being like, how can you be happy this way? And he's like, I'm the happiest person here. And he's right. And he's right. He absolutely is. It's fascinating. And at the heart of the book is, well, the first sort of half is Isabel's choice between Larry and Grey. and she ends up with Grey. And do you think she makes the right choice for her? Well, I think that... I really believe that every choice somebody makes is the right choice for them. Yeah. Because they made the choice. They made it, yeah. You know, so I think it's always like when somebody's making a choice like that, my thing is always to believe them.
24:24Yes.
24:24Celine Song: Right? Well, you're making that choice because you know that that's the kind of life that you want to live. Yes. You don't want to live the way that Larry lives. No. Right. So you're choosing a life. Yeah. right now is she gonna have regrets later maybe totally right and she also like can't quite get over the love she has for larry and like she can't she can't turn her back on that and when she sees him it's still there it's still there and my thing is like it's that uh erotic desire for a different life yeah right and you're like oh she's just longing for this other life that she could have had larry yeah and you're like well completely but the truth is that you make the decision that you did because of who you are yeah right and that speaks volumes about who that person is totally i also there's also such interesting ideas about gender in this book one of the lines i wrote down was that um when larry was talking about how he didn't want to get a job he was like i've got three thousand a year i can live off that and she goes that's the way hysterical highbrow women talk when he was talking about the things that he was searching for in his life and i was like whoa what an interesting kind of oh yeah characterization of the different gender roles in that book.
25:30Of course. I mean, I feel like at that time where there was an amazing incoming of modern ideas, right? I think that this, they were trying, it was very messy. And you can see that this time period that the book is set is a pretty messy time for how we're going to handle gender and how we're going to handle romance and marriage. And I love the chaos of that. And she's saying like, it's like, how can you be so unserious? Yes. And he's like, no, I'm the most serious person here. Yeah, totally. I also think it's quite funny. And she talks later on when she basically implies that she should have just like booked it out of her system with him.
26:05She's like, I should have just gone away with him for a few months and then I would have been able to move on. I'm like, I'm not sure how that works. I don't know how it works because I don't think you can make decisions in that way because we just don't.
26:17Celine Song: Exactly. And the thing is, like, when you're when you feel that, when you're feeling like this totally like this pull, this like longing. towards this person and you're like and when you have denied that person uh you are going to live with the consequence of that for the rest of your life totally you know i do think that it's sort of hard because you look at her options and you sort of think neither of them are ever going to completely satisfy you because neither like neither gray nor larry because larry she will always feel like something's missing and she was the same with gray it's difficult they used to choose the life that you want exactly and i think that to me in materialist the thing that i think about what the main characters were describing always as a choice yeah i'm like well there's a very uh an amazing um uh wisdom from the ancient greeks where they he go they go um uh character's destiny yeah and what it is about how who you are is going to uh result in the fate of your life like as in like who you are is the destiny right it's there's no destiny that the heavens give you the gods give you there's no destiny that you're fighting for like no no the destiny is the one that you are reflects who yes well I love this line I wrote this one down where it says uh when the mom's character that sort of narrator is goes can anything in the world be more practical than to learn how to love to best advantage and I just thought that is that's that feels like the kind of thesis of materialism in many ways though exactly I think that that that's exactly the sentiment that I was trying to catch her.
27:50Yeah. Right? Wouldn't it be amazing? Right? Wouldn't it be amazing to have the practical and the romantic? Yeah. Right? But the truth is, it's like, but when push comes to shove, the most practical thing is the romantic. Yeah. Totally. Because my thing is, it's like, well, she could always have the character in Somerset Mom could have always made the decision. Yeah. Right? To choose love. Totally. It depends on what you want. Yeah. What you value. Exactly. And where she is in that moment.
28:18Celine Song: Yeah. Right. And it's like, and it's heartbreaking her story because of that. But the truth is, like, Larry was going to always be the person who Larry was going to be. Yeah, exactly. And what she imagines is like this person that she is in love with. Yeah. Will change. And also that she could kind of like trap him and then he would have to be there in her house. Oh. Being him, but in her house kind of thing. It was like going to work. I know. Right. And it's like, well, unfortunately, we're all people. And that this is connected to like how all of us are people with capable of our own choices.
28:49Celine Song: Yes. Right. It's like, well, when you're questioning the choices of my character, Lucy, my lead character in materials, Lucy, you're like, well, why would she make a decision like this? And you're like, well, just because that's the character she has. Exactly. And that's the change she's going through. Yes. This is her life. Yeah. And maybe you won't make this decision. No. And also this idea that like character can just be what it is. It doesn't have to be self-optimized. It's like this idea of optimization constant in our culture now. I'm like, maybe that's just who I am. And, you know, as a result, that's just what I'm going to choose.
29:21Celine Song: And also, why are you making a decision value judgment about what is the most ideal life? Yes. And I'm like, where did that come from? Could it be Instagram? Yeah. Oh, my God. Like, truly. I'm like, where did you get these value systems? And could it be from, you know, everything that has nothing to do with your life? Totally. Right. And you're like, well, you could just kind of think about you have one life. Yeah. Right. Are you going to try to find something that is not real for you that you saw one time on the Internet? Yeah. Right. Or are you going to accept the life that you have? Yeah. Right.
29:53Celine Song: And then you're going to live the one that you have to the best of your ability. And to me, it's like Somerset Mohamed is so I really think he's like a poet of life. Right. And in this book, he is so I love him generally, but this is my favorite book of his. right because it's like he's able to sort of reflect it's like no everybody's basically living the consequence of their decisions right and because it's a consequence of their decisions uh it is a happy ending whether they like it or not yes oh i love that that's so interesting i also think i mean at the heart of that book is elliot temple turn as well who is the sort of the sort of benevolent depending on if you think he's stood in the right direction uncle like he's given her money and such forth but his life in the book is a kind of unromantic one right he's sort of he doesn't have a partner I mean I think there's a way and you could you could definitely read him as a queer character who isn't sort of how do you read that character because it's so I would read him as a queer character yeah for sure yeah um but do you think that that character off the page is probably having romantic liaisons and romantic life or do you think he was I think maybe not no I think so too it's just because that's and then that's why He's maybe so obsessed with this sort of this snobbishness, the value of things in other ways.
31:07Well, I think that like it is possible to live without romantic love for all of your life. It is possible. People have done it.
31:13Celine Song: Yeah. Historically, people have done it. People have done it a thousand years ago. Right. And the thing is, it's like and when romantic love visits you. Yeah. Right. It's so it's always a question of like, well, are you going to follow it to India? Yeah. In the case of sorts and all. Or are you going to live the life that you have? It's also a matter of like, it's beyond anything. It's a willingness to change, right? I think about that in terms of love, but love will change your life. So are you willing to let love change you? Yeah. Right. And I think when it comes to Elliot, he's like, well, I'm going to actually let the world change me.
31:50Celine Song: I'm going to let something else change me. Yeah. And I'm going to, it's not necessarily going to be the way that I live through my life. Because I think he is somebody who, even though he may not have specifically romantic liaisons, he has a very fulfilling and happy journey. For sure. Yeah. And I think that's the... Although there's no one coming to visit him when he's dying. I know. That's very sad. That's just sad. For romantic comedy, I think the characters say, die alone. Yeah. Like five times. Yeah. It's a constantly a feeling. It's like, well, what is it for? Yeah. Right. One thing I was struck by in Materialist, so in both The Razor's Edge and in Pride and Prejudice, which is one of your other books, we'll get on to a second, it's family members who are so often steering people away from romantic matches towards more like strategic matches.
32:43And I was struck by the fact that Lucy and the sort of world that she's in, there aren't family members steering her. Was that a conscious decision on your part to keep it pretty contained? And why did you make that decision?
32:55Celine Song: Well, because I feel like the truth is that we have already installed the value police inside of us, right? Like, I'm like, well, I think that maybe it used to be that in the Victorian days, it was the minders and the parents and the aunts and uncles who were like, you must marry this person, right? But the truth is, I feel like the self-commodification and self-objectification has become so internalized that now it's like now we're fully speaking the language of the oppressor. Yeah, you feel like now we're fully speaking in a way where I'm like, well, I don't need to look at the societal norms because I am the societal norm.
33:37Yeah, you don't need it on in her head. So it's in her head.
33:39Celine Song: No, she's the one who's being like, no, I should make a practical match because of my material reality and the safety and the comfort and what I need. Yeah. And you're like, where did you get these? Where did you get this? She didn't need an aunt or anything. Right. No. I think that all you needed was a little phone with Instagram. Yeah. Right. Gosh, I felt like you're not. So you're not an Instagram fan. I have on Instagram, but I post about my movie. Yeah. But, you know, so I think it is something where I'm like. the way that we are so visible to each other right because that's i think that's what i mean by instagram it's more about how visible we are and how visible we are to ourselves like we're sort of forced to think about our own identity through this little grid yes and what it says about us and of course you know which i think is a strange and also our photos we can photoshop you know you can work on it you can do makeup like you can do things where you can kind of uh see the most improved version yeah of yourself and then that is something that is going to be I know the way that you're seen and I find the pressure I don't know if you feel this with your job but like this pressure to be online in this very visible way forces you to think about your identity in this kind of where culture happens you have to be there but I know but I think something that I think is very real is that in through this self-objectification and by the way Lucy the main character in my movie is an expert yeah right she's so good at it yeah she understands exactly what her value is yeah as a result there's going to be an inherent uh there's a self-hatred and the self-disappointment that's going to be built into all the ways that we feel uh when we try to objectify ourselves right it's like and you're like no but we're a person right that's what sophie says in that scene she goes i'm a person yeah right and the thing is like when we are trying to um work through uh what kind of love life and things like that it's like yeah there's one thing which is love and there's a whole other area which is just just dating yeah where it's about again what we're saying about acquisition of assets right it's like totally and you're like and i think that the kind of a push and pull around that is always the um at the center of like what my movie is but also what is kind of a part of these books that we're talking about totally yeah tell me about the experience being on set with dakota and chris and pedro and like their perspective did they bring any sort of like ideas as well to that in collaborating with you on the process of how this dynamic was going to come to lie well i think that the truth is that like if anybody understands self-objectification and self-commodification it's actors actors are so true so of course they're movie stars because they're they're are their body their face the way they move through space the way their their humanity yeah their emotions their intimate connection yeah all of those things are turned into their work yeah right so they understood the script and the movie instantly yeah right so in a way like we had an amazing shorthand because I could always look and say like well this is about how um the how you see yourself as an object and they're like got it it is just such a big part of like what they have to do is their work and they're so good at it and it's their calling but still is something that they have to contend with yeah every day right like they're like you know they just get photographed everywhere they go so in the way it's like uh it was such a direct like everything we're talking about here in these books these were things that were um on the forefront of every single thing that we were talking about totally right like we were so connected because they understand it so intimately the pain of being objectified.
37:20Yes, for sure. Right. Yeah. Dakota's a big reader as well. I interviewed her a year ago. She has a book club. She launched her book club, and I interviewed her about Beautyland and about the book club. Have you read that book? Yes, yes. I loved it. I loved it. And I feel like I love what she did with it. I feel like what her book club does is so cool. It's so cool. Yeah, because it gives us all the context even beyond. Well, that's the thing. She made such a great tool of Instagram because it actually pushes you deeper and it pushes you, and it's also, I love that it's a kind of like choose your own adventure.
37:52Here are lots of materials for you to learn more. Decide what you think. Yeah, exactly. Which is so rare these days where you're actually forced to come. It's why I love going to the theatre as well. I never read about the play before I go. Yeah. And I like to just come out and be like, what did I think of that? And then I go read all the reviews and I'm sort of like, I'm testing my comprehension almost. Yeah, I think that's, I think that's how we should be. Right. Yeah, you can sort of, and we can also decide how you how you text yes exactly but so it's so hard to do now because before like you go everything's everywhere of course but yeah I love she was she's such a great reader and I think the books that they recommend in the tea time book girl are so good they're so good they're very special and they're treated as such special books which they are and I just feel like um I don't know I just I love books yeah well let's move on to your third book which is how should a person be by Sheila Hetty which I also loved.
38:42And before the interview, I was looking through my phone because I always tape photos of pages that I like and I just had so many photos. I was like, I don't even know where to start. But tell me about your love for this book.
38:52Celine Song: Well, I think that this is, again, a book that I think that when one of my friends is going through something, I usually gift this book, right? Because the thing about this book is that it's like, I mean, the title I think about a lot, because how should a person be, is a thing that we need we need to be and we are asking every day of our lives yes and every day we go without thinking about how should a person be yeah i think that is a life unlived yeah right so i think there's something so uh so ready immediately i'm like i'm in love with the title but of course the rest of the book is so connected to that it's so good it's like an existential book and it's uh it's like um I don't know I feel like I haven't read a book for me that reflects my womanhood as well and as deeply as this particular book I don't totally know why yeah but there's something about uh its relationship to erotic desire its relationship to uh being a girl desire the the the ambition and then the greed yeah that's the greed of yeah like wanting to be desired or like the wanting to be wanted and wanting to have power and control like there's something in it that i always feel like i feel very connected to it's like oh this really is so honest and and the strange way it manifests itself in female friendship as well as like the romantic relationships all those things of course because i mean like those uh margo and a Sheila's character they are uh uh they're in love yes but it's right and they're in love in a way where it's like well but it's not necessarily in a way where they want to like hook up kind of but it is in a way where they're like no but we're in love and as just like true animals yes they almost like I almost want to sort of possess each other yeah like it's sort of they want to be each other possess each other they want to kill each other right they want to just like be one yeah like there's something that's like and the yellow dress the one night oh god it's like it's like and you there's something about it that just understands so deeply the most like it's like the id yes it understands the id yeah right and i always feel so seen in this book yeah and i think it's like that to me is like um something that i really look up to yeah i was making i was looking up to it when i was making material is that because i was like well she is so unbelievably honest Because I feel like more than like literal biography or like people like, you know, writing deeply about their like sexual escapade or something.
41:30There's something about this book that made me go like, oh, no, you're going to be real about that.
41:35Celine Song: Right. You're going to be real about that. And it's and it's the problem with I feel like sometimes sometimes the autofiction is there's a problem with autofiction. And of course, my first movie, Past Lives, was an autofiction of some kind. And the thing is, like, I was thinking about this book when I was working on that movie, too, because it was so about the only reason why how a book about yourself or a movie about yourself can work and can exist in the world and for the audience. and it's not just a diary, is if it is simply unafraid to reveal the darkest, ugliest, toughest shit about yourself.
42:21Celine Song: Totally. Right? And that's how I feel about how should a person be? Because it's like you get to meet this character and this character, you get to meet just how dark it goes. Yes, totally. And just how bad it is. Yeah. And just how awful of a person she is and just how completely beautiful. exactly right i mean there's a lot of sort of sex in that book as well like you say about a lot of erotic was it a conscious decision with materialists not to have sort of sex scenes in the sort of traditional sense well i feel like uh the the when it comes to the sex scenes of it it's like um it has to do with like what is uh what kind of part of the story that it tells yeah i feel like it's more like a decision made on it's like do we need to show like sex in it because of the um story yeah and the problem is it's like the well no actually it's so much more about erotic desire yeah erotic desire is not about you know like actually yeah watching somebody do it no but you got some really good kisses in there the kisses are really like intimate that's so good I think the kiss can imply more erotic desire than literally seeing them butt naked and hopping on the thing.
43:38Which I'm like, we all know what it is.
43:41Celine Song: Or if you don't know, you will know one day. So I think there is something about that. I didn't necessarily feel like that was the best way to reflect this erotic desire. And the erotic desire is also connected to what the whole movie is about. Yes, totally. it's like like lucy's aspiring to live a different way yeah right she's aspiring to be a different kind of a woman and then of course she realizes no she can only be the woman that she is exactly but it's also it is kind of powerful the dynamic between um her character and harry lucy and harry like the fact that they're they're like their sort of physical intimacy is different like you can feel the difference it does feel a little bit like yeah not flat but sort of like I know what you mean it's technical yes transaction transactional and I think that was something that of course uh Dakota Pedro and I are talking about we're like well how do we do this um some of these like intimate scenes and it should be funny yeah right and it should be sexy but how do we make it so that it feels like exactly what it is which is a business deal like a hundred percent and it does feel as a result it feels like you say transactional and kind of um like colder as a result in a way like uh it's a different it's a different kind of high that they're getting from it i guess and by the way it's a very powerful high well great i mean most people marry based on it yes of course i'm like it's like well if you have an apartment like that who cares exactly right who cares like how he's looking at you yeah right but then but then if you think about like in john's apartment yeah i didn't tell your mat he better be looking at you like because there's nowhere else to look no and also he better kiss you like the way he kisses that character exactly yeah but um no the interiors were so well done as this like brilliant manifestation of these two scenarios like well but i think the the the production design and the locations it's like well they have to reflect the character because it is about um how they live and the way they live it's materialist so it's kind of like you can't watch or read a Howard's End and then the house has to be so the house that a property has to be so specific it's a character in the in the it's a character in the story yeah right because yeah are you worried that any people will be like oh I didn't share and end up with the guy with the money I'm sure I'm sure they will but I think that the truth is that in the in the heart part of it is that like do we all dream of the one thing that is completely invaluable yeah and the only thing that makes us rich which is uh love that makes you say oh don't worry about that yeah oh fuck that totally so i think that it might be that in this moment um it's hard to imagine love like that for so and then you're like well i can't imagine that i don't right now have the uh willingness to imagine love that could make me say who cares no totally right yeah and something that I can always say is like yeah but yeah but like I I you should date somebody rich yeah right and you're like yeah but then of course but then at the end of the day like wouldn't it be amazing if everything you believed about what kind of a guy you want to meet uh goes out the window because this person you actually meet well quite well you kind of like turn the unicorn into a horse you're like yeah exactly this isn't like um you know this isn't what you think it's what you think is because it's never what you think it is.
47:05No. It's never what it is. No.
47:07Celine Song: And the thing is, like, to believe that it is what it is means that, like, well, are you actually willing to go out there and meet the human beings that you're supposed to grow old with? Yeah, totally. Because when you actually meet the person, you realize that it's not actually a bunch of assets. No, quite. They're very complicated. I like this conversation between Sheila and Jali's character where they talk about the French expression for the love life being the sentimental life. Which I thought was so beautifully kind of poetic about the sort of difference. So how different cultures can approach it.
47:43Of course.
47:43Celine Song: And I think it's like, and when you think about what matters in your life, right? I think that it is hard to be like, again, in a world where it feels like there's a scarcity of love. when although I fully believe that well in each of us just like how someone may say in each of us is a buddha yeah like in each of us is just an endless spring of love in there yeah but I think that if you haven't been given enough of it or feel like there's not enough of it yeah you might feel like I have nothing yeah man and I just I just have to hoard it and no one can go near it you know there's a kind of a funny thing where it's like you become a pauper by choice when it comes to um the love you have yeah right you're like i have very little love to give yeah right and you're like well unfortunately actually the thing is like just like how buddha is in all of us and like all of us are holy like we all have this thing we all have this amazing ancient thing where it's an endless spring of love that's possible and it's a matter of just discovering it yes right oh i loved that distinction that they make in the book between when they're talking they talk about whether you're a craftsperson or an artist and the sort of difference and I think that that almost like plays out to your approach the approach to dating it's like are you like a skill focused sort of like I'm gonna adhere to the system that's been handed to me and I'm gonna try and make a most beautiful version of this thing or like an artist someone who's like I don't know I mean how do you think about that distinction well I feel like it's really about um the what are you in love with yeah in the art right and I think that I don't think there is like a better way or a worse way yeah right the thing is it's like and I didn't this disconnect to when it comes to love the art of loving right as in like well do you feel like an artist of love where it is a this holistic thing or is it a craft right and I think that like I don't think it's one thing or the other as long as you're doing it yes right like I don't necessarily have a judgment about how you want to do it except that you should be doing it at all yeah and Lucy in materialist in the beginning of the film she is somebody who is um doing so much work that makes maybe you might think is uh expertise in love and she corrects she corrects harry she says no i'm an expert in dating yes right and dating is about the market and it's about pursuit it's about acquisition acquisition exactly but love she says it's easy i have no idea right do you think she stays in the job after or does she quit i mean oh so i mean that's one of the first conversations dakota in a hat and i think that like we think she keeps the job she has to right like how's you gonna pay rent at her place um with her uh yeah her broke fiance yeah the broke boy who kisses well yeah exactly he was in love with you but i kind of liked it because i kind of felt like it when and our next book uh pride and prejudice really has this where like the the future she gets it really like she gets the money and the love and to some extent I thought that was you maybe offering a branch of being like you're gonna because she when the when they put the um her former boss is like ask for whatever money you want or it was the idea of like you get the guy that loves you and kisses you properly and you're also going to be rich and it's going to be your own money it's going to be your own money and I think it's like well unlike the characters in Pride and Prejudice it's like well you're actually your income and then your material reality is much more in your control because we as women can work totally we work a lot yeah right it's like you know we work yeah I work and I feel like we uh we have power in the material world and then there's so much um that shifted since Pride and Prejudice so in that way you're like well if you can do it if you have control if you know if you believe in it for yourself then it's like yeah then you then you have more options yeah right totally and I think that I mean to talk about Pride and prejudice i think of course the fantasy of that book is that the practical reality um sort of the solution to your practical problems yeah is also the love of your life yeah what an incredible fantasy it truly is i mean it's intoxicating when you read it as a i read it possibly as a teenager we have my very tea stained old copy here but you're so cute but i mean we're talking about uh We're talking about how this book clearly probably meant so much to young women at the time that it was published.
52:04And I think it still does. Totally. We still are obsessed with this story. We are. But if you think about what the story is, we were just talking about the first line of the book.
52:14Celine Song: Like any time that there was a, because something that I know I was contending with when I was working on materialists is a balance and the contradiction between the practical and the romantic. Yeah. Right. So it's a question of like, well, how practical is this movie and how romantic? And the truth is that it has to be both for you to reflect the way that love works in the modern world ever. Yeah. And every time there would be a question about like, well, are we getting too, like, is it too much math? And I'm like, yes. Is there too much romance? Yes. Right. Yeah. And every time I would run into that question, I would always think about this first line in Pride and Prejudice, which is, it is a truth universally acknowledged that a single man in possession of a good fortune must be in one type of life.
52:59And Pride and Prejudice is one of the great love stories in probably in literature. Yeah. Right. And I think it was it would definitely be the top three, if not number one.
53:09Celine Song: Yeah, right. So given that, the first line of it literally has the word of good fortune. I know. Right? So the practical reality is something that I think that has always been a part of love stories and romance. And it's still remains so. Totally. And I think it's also because the practical reality is something that, and it's connected to love, marriage, everything, is something that has been a woman's domain for such a long time historically. Because, of course, like the poverty for a long time, poverty in one gender and the other gender, it meant very different things in terms of their entire existence.
53:53So I think that in that way, that's why this book is like such a direct way of talking about the practical reality that is going to run up against this very ancient feeling. Yes. This great mystery, love. Propel Fitness Water. With Gatorade electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade electrolytes. Finding a doctor is hard enough. Finding the right doctor, even harder. Someone who takes your insurance, has an available appointment when you need one, and feels like someone you can actually open up to.
54:37That's where ZocDoc comes in. Download the ZocDoc app to search and compare doctors by specialty, insurance, and availability. Read real patient reviews, find the right fit for you, and book instantly. Because getting seen by the right doctor matters. ZocDoc. Ready to be seen? Download the ZocDoc app today. Totally. And the book does such a good job of showing the wisdom of crowds and the stupidity of crowds. And Austin's voice is so good at poking fun at that in a clever way. But reading it again, now I'm older, I feel like Mrs. Bennet is such an interesting litmus test for your feelings about her.
55:13When I was younger, I was like, oh, she's the worst. and now I'm older I'm like I have no kind of more empathy for her as like a mother of five daughters who's like I'm gonna be booted out my house when my husband dies and we all need somewhere to live and so I don't know the sort of it's interesting the way that you read this book changes over time well the thing is like I have no uh endless empathy and sympathy for uh women who are trying
55:40Celine Song: to survive yes quite right and care for their children yeah right so the thing is like I'm not are i feel like you're so right when i was younger i was like there she goes again she goes again being that annoying old lady yeah but then i think it's like of course as you you know as we were older and we just actually start to pair our own bills quite right like we're starting to be like wait um she's just talking about a very uh it's about a reality exactly right and she has to and it's because and i feel like i i read somewhere it's like well poverty has something that robs you of happiness yeah right and you have one life yeah you need to pursue there's a pursuit of happiness pursuing happiness so in that way it's like you have to at all times understand somebody who is just asking all of us to be happy yeah quite I have nothing there's like I would not roll my eyes at that person no and we can't no we can't that's what miss Bennett is saying she's saying like we have to be happy yeah quite well that's why it's alive Sharla is also another character who I feel differently about you know she obviously makes the kind of non-romantic but like yeah it's like actually I feel like in some levels she finds some romance in the situation of what her life is able to become I don't know I think so I think that it's like uh especially at that time where to have stability as a woman yeah especially we don't have means of your own oh exactly being 27 and being told you're on the shelf it's like oh of course and then the thing is it's like well why can't you uh accept uh having a life yeah right over like going out there and trying to look for somebody who who's you're gonna fall in love with yeah right and the thing is like well we don't um I don't think we can fault any of those characters that way it's just such a classic because you walk away feeling like it is just a complete picture of what are some of the options yeah uh in life was yeah for women at that time yeah and the thing is it's like uh what I really love about the book is that um you know the the big scene that mr darcy shows up to uh liz and goes like you know like the big scene everybody's like i love you ardently and i'm like guys you guys are forgetting about every other word that is around that he literally goes like you are so poor and so in debt it's like your family are awful your mom's awful i never wanted to come for Christmas.
58:01I hate you or family. I hate your economic status. Yes, I hate everything. But I feel something for you.
58:10Celine Song: It's very confusing. Yeah. And then she's like, fuck, fuck, I love that. She says it. She does. I know, it's so good. And I think that's the thing that I'm always running into. I'm just like, well, it's like you were all talking like, oh, yeah, if it's a rich guy, he can do anything he wants to meet. And you're like, absolutely not. Absolutely not. Absolutely not. because you have uh it's not a decision that you're making for the uh one transaction no this is a this is a partnership that you're gonna have to do forever exactly all right like think about that it's like you share a toilet yeah i think about this with like um you know my husband i'm like will you share a toilet yeah travel together right it's like when we're gonna watch each other grow old and eventually you know we'll like probably go end up in the same like nursing home we'll probably change each other's diapers like you know there's so many things that we have to accept as that so what do you mean um he can do whatever he wants he can treat you however he wants no it's like no actually yeah this has to be something that you know is love yeah just for longevity yeah right it's like I mean like I need to I know so it's about it has to be unconditional because it can't be like well if you gain weight uh I don't love you anymore and I mean it's like If it's like that, then how can you actually, and this thing too, it's like, well, let's say you're looking for someone who's over six feet tall.
59:32Celine Song: It doesn't matter. When you're 90, we're all going to be 5 '6". I loved that you did that in the movie. You have to. Because I think it's sort of like we do, I mean, obviously very intimate with the ways that women are taught to self-optimize for the dating market. But I loved that you approached it from the men's side as well. Of course. Because, I mean, like, to me, it's like it's really interesting. I mean, there was a moment in the film where the John's character, he goes like, well, it's just dating. Yeah. It's not that serious. Right. And she's like, yeah, you think it's just girl shit. Right.
1:00:02Celine Song: And the thing is, it's like, that's how I feel about it. It's like, well, why is this not a genre for men as well? Yeah. Because it should be. Because the thing is, it's not like men don't do it. Men do it as well. Men have to love as well. Yeah. And they have to receive love. They have to give love. They have to be in it. and the thing is it's like why is it that it's relegated to something that is not for them yes it should be absolutely for that loneliness epidemic i'm like no it should the thing is like it begins where you are willing to accept that you are a part of the world that has to love right yes and i think that that's how i sort of feel about it i'm like well how does this dating market there's so many ways that we're seeing the way that the the dating modern dating is destroying women in the film but this thing that i was like well we actually have to address how it destroys a man too i completely right it's like of course like it is i think in street dating it is maybe uh i think men are still in positions of power so totally so in some ways you're like well you know like he's they're not maybe not the primary uh people who are being destroyed foreign group of people are being destroyed but at the end of the day i'm like no no this is destroying your soul as well This is destroying your body.
1:01:14Yeah, it is. But I think the way that he talks about when he has the surgery and, you know, he finds it, you can tell he finds it hard to talk about it. But he talks about how those six inches didn't just change his romantic life. It changed his work life. It changed the way he was able to hold into rooms. His value. His whole value.
1:01:30Celine Song: And of course, when he lowers himself to get to his height before the surgery, you understand it. It doesn't matter how not materialistic we are. I don't, you know, even if we don't necessarily mind somebody who's shorter, we can't help but notice this person's value drop. A hundred percent. And the thing about height is like, well, it's like it was a constantly a thing that was being talked about for what they want from a man. Yeah. And I'm like, what about the, you know, like you're telling me about a certain height. Average male height in the United States is 5 '8". Yeah. 5 '8", 5 '9". And everyone wants the house at 6 '4".
1:02:08It's crazy. And you're kind of like, well, what that means is a lot of men are shorter than that.
1:02:12Celine Song: Yes. Right? That's average. So the thing is, like, well, so if that's where you're at, where you're saying, like, all I want is somebody who's above six feet tall, which, by the way, again, presumably this person and you love each other and you stay married forever and then you grow together and then this person's going to be five, six. Yeah. Don't worry about it. Like, you're all going to shrink. Totally. So, but yes, of course. So if you want somebody six feet tall, you're like, well, right now that's something, it is genuinely something that is like constantly talked about. And the surgery, which is a real surgery, is one of the fastest growing plastic surgeries, right?
1:02:47Celine Song: Because, and then how can you blame men? It's just like, I know. And of course, how can you blame the men? I know. Because you're like, well, if it is true that the minimum height that women are quoting is over six feet tall, then how can you blame them for trying to not self-optimize? Yeah, self-optimize for the market. Invest, right, so that they reach it. Exactly. So the thing is, it feels like this dating market is like, it seems like the pains and then the way that it's destructive is a domain of women. but actually no no it's it's for men 100 because men are in it too yeah so that's how i feel about uh my movie materialist it's like of course it's the rom-com is a genre that was that has always been uh being a genre that it's made for uh women yeah and audiences of women but i know that it's very welcoming to men because it also has like um two i think very delicate uh beautiful men in it being performed by two incredible actors who are creating such sensitive pictures of what it's like to be a modern man.
1:04:01Yeah, totally. Talk to me about the trailer, about the voiceover,
1:04:05Celine Song: because everyone loved it so much. It is so cool. I love it so much. I feel like it's like, to me, it's like, of course, the references for what kind of a film this is are things that were of a certain time, right? which is like the whether James Brooks or like Nora Ephron or like even like as old as like Billy Wilder so there's a kind of like an older feeling when it comes to look at what kind of a movie it is as in like well it's a movie where it's going to have a beautiful way you're going to get to enter which is that you're walking into a story about love which like who doesn't want to just you know like live in New York City for two hours and the shots of New York are so beautiful as well you get to enjoy how beautiful like New York is and then uh in those two hours we're going to talk about we're going to talk about love yeah so what an amazing um in to me it's an invitation to hey come over come to New York City watch uh sit sit with me and these characters for two hours yeah and we can you know uh talk about love together I know and I loved that I also thought the voice over was such a good like metaphor for the fact that dating now involves us all having these little like quiet voices and I had been like that's so true I mean I was thinking about that but that's that's true but I feel like that's the thing but I think something that I know is true is that like yes of course it is pulling from this uh this place of like yeah it's I wanted to be a romantic comedy where we get to talk about something yeah totally something real and I get to be as honest as I can yeah because I mean that's what I was talking about Sheila Hedy's book I'm like I every time there would be a question of like what should this be it would always be like yeah yeah Yeah, but it has to be honest, right?
1:05:50I have to just be really honest about what I really believe. Yeah. What I personally believe about love, right? Yeah. Right. And what that means, though, is that it has to be still a movie that is for 2025. Yeah. Right. And for the audience who live and breathe now. Totally. Right. So it can't be, so maybe the way we're making it is connected to Billy Wilder, Jim Brooks, and of course, Mike Lee sometimes. like even if it's connected to that kind of filmmaking um the topic the things that we're talking about the conversation in the film is going to be what concerns us today yeah concerns us now i loved that scene when they when um uh lucy and john's character come together and they're standing on the steps outside um the uh the lady's house and when they start to kiss and the leaves and the way they're like rustling and twinkling in the background it almost felt like it was sort of it almost felt like not animated at that moment but it felt like it was sort of like a blurring out of reality in a way that I was like I thought it was such a lovely metaphor for the way that like you can have all these difficult moments but like actually love will give you these when you have it or give you these flickering moments so that feel like almost
1:07:06Celine Song: supernatural of course and I think it's like that's uh that's the only like piece of miracle that we perform in our life. Yeah. Right. We have a little piece of magic that we can all do even if we're not magicians. Yes. Which is that like, oh, we're capable of having this right. Exactly. And it felt magical that moment. So magical. And so magical and totally miraculous. Yes. Exactly. And totally mysterious and just beautiful. Yeah. And you just get to be like, well, I get to have this beautiful moment in my life. Yeah. You know what a way to live. Right. And you topped and tailed it with these other scenes.
1:07:39Tell me about that decision. Well, I think that to me, it is about the kind of connecting it to this ancient feeling. Right.
1:07:45Celine Song: Because it's like love is an ancient feeling. It's an ancient mystery. Yeah. Why these two people fall in love? I wish that there was an answer. Like, I think if you ask two people who are in love, why do you guys love each other? None of them will say, height, weight, invite. No, no, no. Right. They'll say like, once, once he brought me just a bucket of chicken. That's right. Or like they'll be like, one day I was like walking down and then like he like just picked this thing up from the ground and like made a joke about it. And now I'm in love. Right. So it's like you realize it's unclear what makes us fall in love.
1:08:21Celine Song: Yeah. Right. And the story of love, I think it really was about like how we have records of which people being married historically. It has a name on the ledger, right, of like the historical record of who married who and who had children, all that, right? And then, of course, there is also, even before that, we know that these set of tools passed over to another side of the land and was traded there. So we have records of that. But the thing that we don't have a record of is the feelings that passed between those people. So it was kind of like, we know that there was love in the ancient times, but we don't know who loved who and how or what, right?
1:09:06Celine Song: And I think about this, of course, and it comes to like a queer love, a queer partnership. So like, well, there's no record of that almost whatsoever, except for maybe some photographs. But there's no record of it in the city hall, right? But the thing is, it doesn't mean that those relationships, that those love stories meant less, right? Or the feelings that passed between them was less or didn't exist. So in that way, it was about kind of like the things that are material, right? The things that are immaterial. So that's why I wanted it to be bookended by this ancient love, right? I love that.
1:09:41Celine Song: Because the flower, of course, is going to become dust. Yeah. It already has, right? But what was passed, the sentiment that was passed in it still is here. It may not be made of like big rock. Yeah. you know like the one that harris trying to propose with the beautiful diamond ring i'm like it may not have the the material tangible thing but the ring that john passes her is right it doesn't mean that the feeling in it is uh less no it is still uh something that is being uh passed between them yeah and it is as uh great a deep as the one that was passed between the cave people yes yeah so i think that's why i really wanted it and also of course like i feel So like it's a lot of the score too.
1:10:25And then like some of it is about the kind of like this ancient like dating ritual that has always existed on some level. So it's also that too. It's like kind of like there's a bit of a survivalist part of it. Like these clients are like, if you listen to the songs like plays, the music that plays during their client meetings, it's meant to sound a little bit tribal. Propel Fitness Water with Gatorade electrolytes, zero sugar, and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade electrolytes.
1:11:03Ugh, I hate Mondays. King's Hawaiian cinnamon swirl bite? Uh, Taylor Hansen? Sure, I'll try one. Mmm. Bites, ba-du-ba-da-ba. Hey, let's get back to work, please. But Taylor Hanson's making my day way better with these new soft and swirly King's Hawaiian cinnamon bites. Taylor Hanson? Nice. Try one. Mmm.
1:11:26King's Hawaiian cinnamon bites. There's nothing like it.
1:11:33Yes. Yeah, well, those kind of meetings are so funny. Yeah, they're so good. You know, listen, like, they're just, you know, they're just being so honest. Yeah, and was that based on your own experiences and that's right?
1:11:43Celine Song: I mean, the thing is, like, I worked as a matchmaker for six months. Yeah. And I think that it's like, but of course, it's not really specific because this is the things that everybody wants. Totally. Yeah. Everybody wants this. Everybody wants this one particular kind of a thing. There's no variety because the whole world has basically trained us to want one thing. Yeah. 100%. dominant beauty standards right dominant the right age to marry like everything has been decided by everything we watch everything we see and then it's again it's become a part of our it's become a police officer inside us exactly right it's like we don't need the we don't need miss bennett because miss bennett is us yeah she's in us she's in us and she's there being like um yep don't make a impractical choice like she's out there just doing this yeah right so i think that to me is really what yeah what that is it's like that's why it's all the same you really want someone who's taller than six feet tall not a single person says i want someone who's 5 '4 and and this not thing being the sort of like yeah well and everything do you know what 20 bmi it's just like a little bit over having you know yes it's like one bmi over underweight yeah it's models are 20 bmi right like i mean models are 18 bmi but it's like but you basically have model weight it's all these like euphemisms aren't they all of those terms and like the they all just are like sort of more acceptable ways of saying uncomfortable things i'm like well what's comfortable in new york quite very i mean i learned that um i think i read somewhere i feel like i did this research which was that um the average income in the u.s is 35 000 yeah right and then you're like well but that means there's a lot of people in the u.s make less than that yeah that's what that means all right and the thing is it's like when we're talking about like money i mean that was very important for me in making materialists where we actually talk about numbers yes you know i like that i like that she said her salary her salary and we hear about what how much the apartment is we know how much john's rent is yeah so every single thing every time we say the numbers what's so funny to me is that um the the numbers we have such a powerful reaction to right because we think about it in the context of our own lives yes yeah right it's like if i am uh five eight uh and someone says six feet tall right then you can't help but compare five eight to six feet tall right your salary is thirty five thousand dollars to lucy's which is 80 right so this it's an amazing thing where we get to something that felt really important is like let's be very real about some of these numbers yes because right because i'm like the euphemisms around it oh yeah right the euphemisms around it like you're i'm well i just want somebody who's comfortable i know and you're like what does that mean yeah could be 80 yeah it'd be 250 it's hard to be alien and then like good family and what that means and you're like what does that mean yeah not divorced yeah or lost yeah like what does you actually mean by any of these things right so it was just important that is being constantly talked about as i love that as openly as we can.
1:14:55Right. And then, of course, the clients will talk around it, but Lucy and her colleagues, right, yeah, she can interpret what they really mean. Oh, yeah. She'll just say like, yeah, that's how old she is. Yeah. Right. Oh, my gosh. It's fascinating. Well, thank you so much, Celine. This was such a wonderful conversation. I love talking about these books. Me too. And everyone should go and see Materialist. I loved it so much. Everybody see Materialist. Yeah.
1:15:20Finding a doctor is hard enough. Finding the right doctor even harder. Someone who takes your insurance, has an available appointment when you need one, and feels like someone you can actually open up to. That's where ZocDoc comes in. Download the ZocDoc app to search and compare doctors by specialty, insurance, and availability. Read real patient reviews, find the right fit for you, and book instantly. Because getting seen by the right doctor matters. ZocDoc. Ready to be seen? Download the ZocDoc app today. Fall has never looked or tasted this good. Sweetgreen's fall harvest menu is back with seasonal favorites dressed to impress and made to be devoured.
1:16:01Warm roasted sweet potatoes, crisp apples, maple glazed Brussels, and crave worthy flavors in the autumn harvest bowl, maple glazed salmon plate, and roasted bacon Brussels side. The season's most desirable menu has returned to Sweetgreen, featuring fall's best dressed. Make your move. Order on the Sweetgreen app.
In One Nightstand, celebrity readers and writers join us at The Blond in 11 Howard to discuss their favorite books. ‘Past Lives’ director and Oscar-nominee Celine Song discusses the books that helped shape her life and work, including new A24 romantic comedy, Materialists.
Materialists starring Dakota Johnson, Chris Evans, and Pedro Pascal is out now.
Credits
Director/Director of Photography: Marshall Stief
Assistant Camera: Konstantin Yelisevich
Post Supervisor: Delia Kelly
Post Production Manager: Mateo Delgadillo
Editor: Matt Hoffman
Producer: Aubree Lennon