1. Podcasts
  2. Page 94: The Private Eye Podcast
  3. 195: Branded
Page 94: The Private Eye Podcast

10 Nov 2026 · 40m · 17 chapters

In short

The episode “Branded” (Page 94) uses Russell Brand’s sentencing as a springboard to discuss media, legal strategy, and sexual-abuse reporting; it then pivots to Samaritans’ volunteer “future-proofing” plans and ends with UK climate policy at COP31.

Guests (backgrounds)

Andrew Hunter-Murray (host, Private Eye). Ian Hislop (editor, Private Eye; long-time investigative journalist). Justine Smith (journalist/Private Eye writer; has covered sexual-abuse cases). Adam McQueen (journalist/Private Eye writer; discusses politics and media).

Key claims

Brand’s defence lawyer Ian Winter tried to attack journalism as contempt/abuse of process; victims and investigative reporting were crucial to prosecution. BBC investigated Brand after 2023 complaints; broader political/media support helped Brand’s public image. Samaritans’ central plan to close local offices and shift listening to hubs/home threatens volunteer safety and capacity. UK COP messaging is undermined by rollbacks on electrification targets and approvals for new fossil projects.

Notable examples

Brand sentenced to 10 years 6 months for rape/sexual assault; Winter’s prior sexual-case and Shipman representation; BBC LA toilet exposure incident; Samaritans founded 1953; 134 million calls; volunteers in Omar (1998 bombing) upset by closures; Samaritans Wales informal survey: 90% wouldn’t do home listening; COP31 “35 by 35” and possible EV target cuts (80%→50% by 2030); Jackdaw/Rosebank approvals.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Contextualizing Brand's Sentencing

Discussion on the current state of news surrounding Russell Brand.

“I was going to say, Rosamund Irwin, don't you mean the journalist who disgracefully ensured that some of these women came forward with their stories about what had happened to them?”
1:45

Journalism's Role in the Investigation

Acknowledgment of the journalists' efforts in reporting on Russell Brand's case.

“Charlie Elphick, the Tory MP, you might remember, was found guilty of sexual assaults on two women.”
2:56

Defensive Tactics in Court

Analysis of Ian Winter's defense strategies and reactions.

“There have been a lot of people throwing blame around, not simply at Brand, but saying, well, Brand was actually, you know, he was the darling of the BBC.”
5:06

Media and Public Perception of Brand

Exploration of how media portrayal has influenced public opinion on Brand.

“Yes, the left, during the brief period he was left, made him a huge star and fawned on him.”
7:00

The Impact of Past Allegations

Discussion on how previous allegations against Brand affected his career.

“He said, I suspect you are trying to obtain money from him, which was not what she was after at all.”
9:22

Victim Stories and Legal Challenges

Insight into victims' experiences and the difficulties they face in legal systems.

“Justine, you've written about some of them.”
11:24

Reflecting on Systemic Issues in Sexual Assault Cases

Examination of systemic problems in handling sexual assault cases.

“The judge has sentenced Russell Brand to 10 years and six months in prison for rape and sexual assault.”
14:00

Media Representation and Accountability

Explores the role of media in shaping perceptions of criminal cases and the implications for victims.

“I mean, denying the role that the jury and the CPS and the police play and the victims in all of this.”
18:04

Historical Context of Russell Brand in Media

Examines Russell Brand's controversial relationship with various media outlets and their portrayals of him.

“Just a big banner headline after the guilty verdict that just said rapist.”
18:50

Challenges Facing the Samaritans Organization

Discusses recent changes and challenges within the Samaritans and the impact on their volunteer network.

“I don't know about you, I hate the word for future proofing.”
Show all 17 chapters
23:50

Response to Future-Proofing Initiatives

Details the reactions from volunteers regarding the future-proofing plans and their implications.

“Which doesn't sound like a terrible argument if you've got...”
26:55

COP Conference Reflections

Reflects on the current state of climate initiatives in relation to the COP conference.

“So, Andy, the COP26 summit begins on the day we're recording in Turkey, I believe.”
28:00

Electric Vehicle Targets and Industry Response

Explore the changing landscape of electric vehicle sales targets in the UK and industry reactions.

“lowering emissions by turning things electric, the UK is in the middle of this extraordinary series of steps backwards on electrification and cleaning things up.”
29:00

Political Dynamics and Environmental Policies

Discuss the internal conflicts within the Labour Party regarding environmental initiatives and industry pressures.

“And the headlines today are suggesting that the government are going to be making a big change on that.”
30:49

COP Conference and Climate Commitments

Delve into the implications of the COP conference and the UK's commitment to climate targets under a Labour government.

“I mean, he spent a chunk of his summer objecting to the idea of a new solar field in his constituency.”
33:20

Challenges of Global Climate Negotiations

Examine the complexities of international climate negotiations and the role of major nations like the US and China.

“And then, I mean, the UK has never missed one of its climate commitments.”
34:48

The Pragmatic Approach to Climate Goals

Analyze the practical implications of adopting a pragmatic approach towards climate goals and its potential consequences.

“Didn't the Saudis host it one year or something?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Page 94: The Private Eye Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Page 94, the Private Eye podcast. Hello and welcome to another episode of Page 94. My name's Andrew Hunter-Murray and I'm here in the iStudio with Ian Hislop, Justine Smith and Adam McQueen. We're here in a, can we say a bumper fortnight for news? There certainly seems to be a lot more than usual happening. Some stuff going on, isn't there? Some stuff going on. So we are recording this episode in the middle of the judge's sentencing of Russell Brand. So we thought we'd start off with a brand story this week. And Adam, I think before we get into the details of it, you wanted to point out a couple of congratulations.

0:36Yeah, I do. So I will be keeping my phone open on the desk in front of me. It's not because I'm checking my TikToks. It's genuinely that we've got the judge in court at the moment starting the sentencing. So I'm keeping an eye on that. Yeah, no, I just wanted to start and say an amazing achievement for not only all of the women who turned up in court, one of them today in the sentencing remarks that she turned up to read her victim impact statement in person, which is a hell of a trauma to undertake on top of an awful lot of other trauma. So to all of the victims but also to the women who led this investigation so particularly Rosamund Irwin on the Sunday Times and Charlotte Waste on the Times did some absolutely incredible work on this over literally years it took to get this story kind of nailed down and then take it through all the way to a criminal prosecution.

1:17Lots of other journalists on the Times as well and Channel 4 dispatches came in on it as well so it's one of those cases where you just kind of go, unlike the prosecution lawyer in the case Well done to some journalists for doing some good work. I was going to say, Rosamund Irwin, don't you mean the journalist who disgracefully ensured that some of these women came forward with their stories about what had happened to them? Yeah, one of the most extraordinary things that's come out since the end of the trial last week. You should explain the whole thing because it's mind-blowing. Yeah, is that Ian Winter, who was Russell Brown's lawyer, who's actually a specialist in fraud and financial crime, so a very odd one.

1:49He has done a few sexual cases before. Charlie Elphick, the Tory MP, you might remember, was found guilty of sexual assaults on two women. And he also represented Harold Shipman early on as well, Ian Winter. So that's quite the CV. So if you're picking your defence lawyer, you know where to go. Well, I mean, he tried something absolutely extraordinary, which I've not heard of before. In a pretrial hearing, which we're now free to report, he actually tried to bring an abuse of process hearing and said that the journalism that had been done on this case by the Sunday Times and the Times and Channel 4's dispatches was not only perverting the course of justice, it was also in contempt of court and therefore unlawful and criminal, which is, I mean, as the judge pointed out to him, complete and utter nonsense, because at that point there weren't any active criminal proceedings against Rosabrand.

2:34He's got a cart before the horse there with that one. There wouldn't have been caught without the journalism. No, there absolutely wouldn't. He tried to turn the whole thing into an assault on journalism. He absolutely did, yeah. For those of us watching, we thought, you're accusing journalists of contempt of court, Yet your client is doing a round-up of what's been happening in court on his own blog. Yeah, yeah. Is that not contempt? I don't know. I'm not a KC. There have been a lot of people throwing blame around, not simply at Brand, but saying, well, Brand was actually, you know, he was the darling of the BBC.

3:08That was reported in the Telegraph, wasn't it? The Telegraph said, BBC enabled rapist Brand. That was their first one. The mail said, downfall of the swaggering sex predator fawned over by the left. And actually, in a way, because Russell Brand has had such a long and a weird career, there is sort of quite a lot of blame to go round. I mean, papers as ever, sort of selective in where they put it. I mean, the BBC, to be fair to them, launched a full investigation headed up by the boss of their editorial complaints unit in 2023 when the first stories broke about Russell Brand's behaviour into complaints that had been made by staff about him during the very short period of his career that he was actually working at the BBC.

3:43It was only from 2006 to 2008 when he was a presenter on Radio 6 Music and then slightly staggering, you know, Radio 2. I mean, if you think of anyone who's less Radio 2-ish as a presenter, it would be Russell Brand, I would think. Not to mention comic relief. Yes, yeah, yeah. Well, that was his last appearance, wasn't it? I think it was 2017 he held comic relief for the BBC, yeah. And they barred him from their LA offices, though, for the exposure in the toilet. Yes, yeah, yeah. So there was certain action taken. Yes, he exposed himself to a woman in the toilets at the LA studio at that point.

4:16But that's where the action stopped. Yes. No further action. It seems to have done, yeah. Yeah, the BBC did a bit of sort of maya culpa over it in 2023. No doubt there's going to be some more going on now. I mean, for the male to say fawned over by the left, well, yes, OK. There was a period post the sort of BBC period where Russell Brand suddenly became this great revolutionary guru, quite inexplicably and started sort of, The Trues was his video podcast that he was doing at that point, wasn't it, which was The True News. See what he's done with that? And there was an interview with Ed Miliband.

4:50Ed Miliband went round to his kitchen on the eve of the 2015 election. Yeah. To kind of beg him to endorse Labour at that point because he was thought to be such a big force in getting out the youth vote. Yeah, and he rather unhelpfully said that his advice was for everyone not to vote, which isn't hugely helpful. Yeah, yeah. Even when you're on the left. Yes, the left, during the brief period he was left, made him a huge star and fawned on him. But in recent memory, it's entirely the right. It absolutely is. It's Trump, it's the MAGA brigade, it's American lunatics online and some British lunatics.

5:31Being unpatriotic in case anyone accuses me of this. They championed him. And are still doing so and saying he's not guilty. It's a conspiracy. Well, the difference, I think, I mean, one of the other rather brilliant defence tactics, which Ian Wintercasey tried, was to say that poor Mr Brown, no one would touch him with a barge pole after these allegations came out. But actually, quite a lot of people had quite large barge poles they were touching him with. I mean, I could list a few. We've got Tucker Carlson, Alex Jones, Donald Trump Jr., Elon Musk, Jordan Peterson, RFK Jr. and on our own side, as you say, Ian, GB News presenter and barnpot-in-chief, Bev Turner, who still last week was still standing by her view that he is the victim of a witch hunt and vested interests pulling strings and that was the reason behind this belated justice being served.

6:19During the period where he was huge, I mean, the kind of 2006 to 2015-ish period, were these complaints known about? I mean, there seemed to have been lots of people in the comedy world who knew and famously Catherine Ryan had a good go at him on air during a recording of something. Do we know if there were other people talking about this outside that world? Well, it's like all of these cases that suddenly it seems to be one of these things that's been an open secret forever, but certainly nothing came out. Now, part of that was down to extremely judicious use of lawyers by Mr Brand. So in several cases, he was protected not only by a couple of his agents who called lawyers in, Hannah Chambers, who was his comedy agent and ang harrod wood who was his literary agent uh both at certain points allegations were made to them uh in in hannah shames's case it was it was another comedian a male comedian in that case who was who was talking about russell brand uh in in terms of sex offenses in his act and she um she accused him of slander ang harrod wood uh called uh lawyers in uh when when allegations were made um and i was just looking through the list we we listed them back in 2023 uh in a piece i wrote for for the eye uh we had thompson heath associates had represented him at that point, BCL solicitors, Archerfield partners, shillings almost inevitably, perhaps most strikingly, Philip Barden of Devonshire's, who in 2020 wrote what was described as a very aggressive letter personally to one woman who was claiming sexual assault by Russell Brand.

7:42He said, I suspect you are trying to obtain money from him, which was not what she was after at all. She was after an apology and some retribution. But on Brand's part, after decades of talking about the importance of his own freedom of speech and how he should be allowed to say anything at any point at any time to anyone, even in the middle of a court case against him. When it comes to other people saying anything at all, he immediately reverts to lawyers. He doesn't say, no, I didn't do it. This isn't true. He just tries to shut down free speech, which is interesting for both his left wing and his right wing fans and also for his Christian fans.

8:20I would like to say that not only did he think the left would be good cover, then the right would be good cover, he thought faith would be a good cover. He was a Hindu briefly, if you remember his marriage. Then he became more of a sort of wealth is great Christian. And they're all being remarkably slow to come forward and indicate that they now disapprove. Baptised famously in the Thames by Bear Grylls. Yes. Adding to the level of shit floating in. One of the things that this whole case has revealed is how actually trying sexual cases, cases of rape and sexual assault, it has come on in some ways.

9:02In court, those were discussed and there was an attempt to defang those myths in court, like the idea that victims, if they're not screaming and running away, then actually everything's fine, this kind of thing. But another thing that's revealed is how actually things haven't moved on. And I know that around this table there is plenty of experience of writing about these stories. Justine, you've written about some of them. I have indeed, yeah. I mean, going back to Jimmy Savile, I was told by a woman that she'd been attacked by him many years earlier. It had destroyed her life and she described in very minute detail what happened.

9:38So I said to her, I can't write about this. I'm not allowed to report on it. Am I without any kind of evidence or police involvement? So I suggested she go to the police anyway, because I said, well, if he's done this to you. And I had had another report when I was on a newspaper many years ago from another victim who was unable to go to the police at that time. And I said, you need to go to the police. She went to the police. The police turned up and said, Jimmy Savile is going to employ the best barristers in the country. They're going to tear you to shreds in court. I suggest you don't go ahead with this.

10:07It's going to do you more damage than good. So I went to the police press office and it was a guy I used to work with years ago. and I said to him, this is absolutely outrageous. This is a victim of a sexual crime. She needs to be treated as such. It doesn't matter who she's accusing of this. You need to treat her claims very seriously. And I was accused of making it up for a story. It was unbelievable. Luckily, I kept my transcript. When was this? This was in about 2010. Okay. So Seville was alive at the time. Seville was alive. He could have faced justice. Right. Yeah, so the police refused to accept it and she was put off completely.

10:42She didn't do anything. He went on, you know, to die lauded. And she said it was horrific seeing, like all of his victims, just imagine seeing he's dying. And everyone's saying, what a great guy who is, how much money is raised for charity. And we all know he's been a mass abuser. And it was very well known, wasn't it? So, yeah, so I kept the transcript and gave it to the inquiry. And they ended up looking into it very closely. The police force got, you know, admonished, as they should have done. And she ended up getting quite a lot of compensation because it had destroyed her life. Every time she saw him on TV, which is exactly what Russell Brand's victims say today, it re-traumatises.

11:17You see this person walking free, being lauded, celebrated. We've literally, as we're speaking, we've got a sentence. It's just come through. The judge has sentenced Russell Brand to 10 years and six months in prison for rape and sexual assault. So how long of that will he serve? It will be around two thirds. So sentences obviously are being cut a lot at the moment because of the prison overcrowding. but serious sexual offences still get a more substantial of the sentence served actually in custody in prison. Right. So Katy Perry said he should be in prison, her verdict on their marriage, and she was right.

11:51Yep. But I think, I mean, what you talk about, and it comes back to Ros and Charlotte and the incredible work they did, these cases, there are a lot of these cases where afterwards everyone will say, well, everyone knew about it. But getting things to a point where you can safely, legally bring these accusations, publish these allegations, is incredibly difficult. And it involves enormous bravery, not from the journalists particularly, although there's a lot of lawyers and things that they have to face down, but that's fine, that's part of our job, but from the victims in the cases who generally have to come through and put their names to things.

12:23Ian, you had some experience with this early on in your journalistic career as well, haven't you? I did. I mean, one of the first stories I ever wrote for the Eye, which was about a senior figure in the BBC who was indulging in this sort of sexual predatory behaviour. I mean, this is in the early 80s. Can you imagine? The climate was somewhat different. And the women who came forward, I mean, there were only three TV channels. They knew pretty much that this was going to end their careers. And they were incredibly brave. But I have to say, I mean, the early 80s, this was before Laddery. I still can't believe I lived through a period of nuts and loaded and zoo and old fuddy-duddy old boring private eye bunch of, you know, moralistic public school twats.

13:08What we noticed was that this bunch were pretty grubby. And having all the channels devoted to, you know, chat shows about anal sex and football was not necessarily a huge development in the history of feminism or human rights. So I'm saying this has been going on an awful long time. And I couldn't believe how old fashioned the defence was. I think the judge couldn't either, could he, in this case? It was outrageous. He kept leaping in and saying, you can't say this or no, that isn't right. I thought the days of that were past, you know, crucifying the witnesses, trying to make them look unreliable, suggesting that their actions meant that they couldn't have possibly been raped or attacked in any way.

13:50I mean, it was a real throwback, wasn't it? I think, you know, and the way he behaved afterwards, which was targeting one of the journalists. Which one was it? You went in there? Yeah, yeah. I mean, that was Ian Winter. Q said, this is all down to you. I mean, denying the role that the jury and the CPS and the police play and the victims in all of this. After the confrontation with Roswell Irwin from the Sunday Times, Ian Winter did report himself to the Bar Standards Board. But also the way he put that even was, having seen the ways matters have been characterised in today's press, he said he was going to do that.

14:22Just leave it at this point. Come on. It's not about bad journalism. It's about your behaviour. And he didn't stop there. When he was speaking just before the sentencing, he said to the judge, do not sentence him, his client, as the monster portrayed outside this courtroom. No, no, he was portrayed as a monster inside the courtroom. Yet again, this man, Winter, incapable of not turning anything he said into an attack on the media. That's it. There's this other element for the complainants, the damned if you do and damned if you don't thing. You know, if there's only one complaint, then the story is, well, there's only one complaint and that can't possibly be real.

15:00In this case, there was the initial rash of stories in the Sunday Times. But the complainants in this case were completely separate to the complainants who'd come forward to journalists. You know, they had seen the journalism and been inspired to actually finally speak out about it. and then that was attacked by Ian Winter saying, well, actually they've been forced to reimagine what happened to them which was all perfectly fine at the time and now they think it can't possibly have been fine because they've seen journalism about it. It's exactly the same thing. It's extraordinary. You should say as well there are two more cases that police are pursuing, one of which does come out directly out of the Sunday Times reporting.

15:37Right. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. There are more to come. And there's an important role to be played by the media in that as well in sort of, you know, breaking the dam and making other victims realise that they can come forward. And of course that's something you have to be really, really careful with because you always stand the possibility of ending up with someone like Carl Beach who comes forward with completely false allegations. There are two men out at the moment that can't be named. One of the most recent proceedings and then one from several months back. Both of them, there are injunctions on reporting anything.

16:07Both of them, multiple, multiple victims. Both of them in the public eye. I mean I've spoken to one of the alleged victims in one of them she's prepared to speak publicly and be named but we still can't publish that he's managed to get an injunction very heavily slapped anyone who dares say anything about it so we know this man is out there potentially abusing other people and there's nothing we can do to report it we should say actually I mean again the events may have moved on by the time that people are listening to this but the injunction which we talked about in the last episode Yes. The injunction was removed, but the celebrity in question was given leave to appeal, which runs out currently at 4.30 this afternoon as we're recording.

16:48So things may have moved on a little by the time that this podcast comes out. We've given a kicking to almost everyone who I think deserved kicking. There's just room to fit in the Sun newspaper here, Adam. Well, we should put in a word for The Guardian as well. I mean, there was no bigger fan sheet for Russell Brand in the early noughties than The Guardian, which seems bizarre. As you say, it was the era of zoo and nuts. But no, The Guardian were right in there. They serialised his bookie-wook. George Monbiot, famously called his hero of 2014. Also, I should say, the bookie-wook, full of very, very long sentences.

17:19So, Bran does have experience of this. Thank you. Yes. Thank you very much. To their credit, someone on The Guardian felt a bit differently. Polly Toynbee, Suzanne Moore, Hadley Freeman were all, at the time of The Guardian, hero-worshipping him, kind of saying, yeah, no, actually, maybe not. And Suzanne, more famously, it was another person he threatened legal action against on the grounds that she'd said he might have ghostwritten the bookie book. And he threatened, he didn't just want a correction. He sent a lawyer's letter saying, no, this is extremely, extremely deeply libelous. And he guest edited The New Statesman in September 2013.

17:50There is an extraordinary photo, which the magazine posted at the time, in which they recreated The Last Supper with Russell Brand as Jesus. and I have to say our own of this parish, Helen Lewis, who was then Deputy Editor of the New Statesman, does appear in that as well. But The Sun, yes, yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, they've gone big on it. I'm absolutely shocked on Friday. Just a big banner headline after the guilty verdict that just said rapist. 2006, 2007 and 2008, they crowned him their shagger of the year for their bizarre column, their showbiz column. And in 2009, which is actually the year when Russell Brand committed the rape that he has been convicted for, in addition to the sexual assaults.

18:29They renamed it, and effectively retired it, the Russell Brand Shagger of the Year Award, to which he gleefully said, I've now become the global authority on shagging and the arbiter. So there you go. It was the sun what won it. Well, that Russell Brand chap was thoroughly depressing in various ways, so let's move on to something nice and cheerful now. Justine, the Samaritans. Samaritans. so antithesis hopefully of all of the grub we've been speaking about these are heroes every single one of them all of these volunteers that the peak i think they had 23 000 of them turning up all day and night to listen to people in their very very darkest hour um set up in 1953 by a reverend with a single black phone in his vestry of his church and that phone's still there apparently since then since 1953 they've taken 134 million calls and I don't think you could even begin to calculate how many lives they must have either saved or improved however I'm sorry to say it's not another happy story today that's why we're here Dusty that's why we're here I know I'm sorry so there's trouble at Samaritans it's been going on a while now so the headquarters has announced a future Proofing scheme.

19:44I don't know about you, I hate the word for future proofing. Future proofing against what? Well, it sounds like future proofing against being able to have a presence in every community and have volunteers who can go into offices and work together and support one another, you know, make their presence known. So we should say how it works at the moment, which is there are about 200 branches all over the UK and people go into, you know, small local operations and they it's often like it's often night shifts isn't it because that's when people are feeling you know at the lowest and most desperate and all of that so yeah and it's minimum two two people on a shift minimum two people on a shift yeah now um what the center is saying is that 10 years ago they got rid of all of the localized numbers and had a central number and it now runs through a system where if you rang you might speak to someone in northern scotland or northern ireland it doesn't you know so what they need is more bums on seats at those difficult times in the night when they can't get people in.

20:40So they're saying that the model of having all of these different buildings and running these different buildings doesn't work anymore. Charities are struggling. Income is lower. Lots of charities are struggling at the moment, aren't they? But what the local branches are saying is that actually most of us run our own. Something like 140 of them are called affiliates. They have their own budgets. They run their own money. They raise their own money they talk to the media they recruit they train most of all they look after one another through these difficult hours when they're taking these calls they've run three pathfinders so one in scotland one in humberside new york show one in the southeast sorry is that trials trials pathfinder trials yeah try out this new regionalized system where they want to build these bigger hubs yeah and where you can have more people in them and you remove all the smaller offices So they've tried these out and they said, you know, these will be tried between 25 and 2028.

21:38But suddenly last month, lots of volunteers in a number of offices, about nine, were called in and told they'd be closed down, some by the end of November, by the end of this month, some in January. And they would be given two options. One is go to the nearest hub. And the second would be eventually, because this hasn't been set up yet, answer calls from home. Yeah, I know. so working from home so on your own without the support yeah dealing with the most traumatic phone calls you can possibly imagine so number one terrible idea number one some people would have to drive two and a half hours each way for a three-hour shift potentially in the middle of the night otherwise the option is listen to this trauma from home allow this trauma to come out in your home it assumes you've got a spare room with confidentiality you haven't got children running around you haven't got people who can overhear and imagine you're sitting for three hours and you're talking to someone in their darkest moment and obviously if you're talking to someone sometimes those calls are going to run on because you might be keeping people alive in that very moment and then you have to put the phone down and you're on your own with your thoughts in your house and you have nobody to talk to nobody to turn to and in fact they did a an informal survey in Wales and asked people if they would do this 90 % of them said they wouldn't do it right what organization apart from perhaps Mountain Rescue and RNLI has this willing army of volunteers who are willing to do so much for their community I can't think of any other any other that is the asset that they've got and that's the asset they want to strip.

23:05And in your story about it, Justin, which we should say is in the latest edition of The Eye, you mentioned that the Samaritans, the central organisation, has set up its own helpline for volunteers. Yeah. That sounds like a really black joke. Really. Yeah. So they are so distressed. I mean, the ones I've spoken to a lot, they are so distressed. Some in Omar, for example. Omar's not part of this cost cutting, sorry not future-proofing. Omar the volunteers there took one of three calls when the when there was the bombing in 1998. Some of them have been there since helping their community to deal with that enormous trauma biggest single atrocity in the troubles.

23:45They were told they were closed down their office has been closed down. Now they they own their own building it was gifted to them as a legacy okay these people have worked through terrible trauma they're being told that their office is going to be closed down all of the assets will be stripped and sent back to the centre now the centre now accounts for something like 18 million pounds of the 23 million raised lots of it most of it in legacies and donations that used to go straight into you know straight into the services now staff costs are something like 18 million pounds in an organisation that we all associate with volunteering don't we as you can understand there's a lot of upset a lot of sadness people are in we're in tears when they were told the biggest worry for them is who will be there for people in their darkest hour you know there's a lot of these people who would be until their dying day and it's just not going to be an option for them so i imagine you put all of this to the semantics what was their response when the home listening service is set up because it hasn't even been set up yet um there will be they'll be being monitored that creates safety for callers but not necessarily for the listeners and only one in ten will actually be watched by the centre so nine out of ten calls will not even be being monitored by anyone else so their response to this is a terrible idea was but we can make it less terrible well they're yeah they're saying that um the hubs are more likely to attract more volunteers and then in those hubs some of them have got 60 seats, they can ensure that the difficult times in the middle of the night are better covered.

25:27Which doesn't sound like a terrible argument if you've got... Because, I mean, I read through their response to you and they were saying, well, if there are two people on a shift and then one of them doesn't turn up, then the other one can't do it. And so you do lose a bit of capacity during that time. But why are there two people on a shift? I mean, to protect one another, to look after one another, to protect anyone else, anyone, you know, to protect callers. Maybe you have someone, a third person, say, who's on call. Right. In case one of the others does. I mean, far be it from me to do logistics for them.

26:00But you don't need 60 people in a hub to preserve the fact that if some person is ill and doesn't turn out for the job, you don't just close down the office. The thing is they're spending millions on building these hubs as well. One person who's been a supporter of the Samaritans for very many years wrote to Private Eye and said, I've changed my will and I've told them I'm changing my will. I was going to leave my entire legacy to Samaritans worth£100 ,000 and now I'm not. Now, what I'm worried about, I do not want this reporting to make people think, A, they can't call Samaritans because that line is still active, it's still going, it's still there, the people are there, or to think that they shouldn't give money to it anymore because it's a really important service.

26:42But we do want the centre to listen to its volunteers, the people who have run it for all these years, who've made it what it is. And that's all that they're asking. They're saying, you know, we're the listening service. Listen to us. We know what we're doing here. And I think that's what's not happening perhaps at the moment. So, Andy, the COP26 summit begins on the day we're recording in Turkey, I believe. COP31 begins, actually. COP26 was five years ago, yeah. Well, that's just confusing, isn't it? Five years plus a pandemic ago. COP31 in 2026 kicks off. One question. Good COP, bad COP? Lovely.

27:18Dirty COP, I think, is what we're coming to the conclusion of. Yeah, yeah. COP means Conference of the Parties, and it is the annual global conference trying to do something about climate and energy. And it is all the nations of the world attending, bar one. Can you guess? It's the USA. Quite a big one. But not the whole game in town. And so what's interesting is we're recording this on day one of COP. The UK has always been an enthusiastic partner in and in some ways leader of the process, has made an enormous amount of progress itself on emissions, something the UK can be quite proud of. And yet day one of this conference, which is all about electrification, efficiency, lowering emissions by turning things electric, the UK is in the middle of this extraordinary series of steps backwards on electrification and cleaning things up.

28:10It's really weird. I mean, there are announcements that are being made all the time right now that are completely contrary to the presiding spirit of this big global conference that's happening right now. So we've had Jackdaw, the big gas field, being approved, haven't we? I think today I saw headlines about electric vehicles, the targets being rode back on those as well. Yes, this is one of those things which is extremely heavily briefed in both directions by people who are sticking their oar in but don't want to admit they're sticking their oar in. And this target has changed so much. I mean, it's absolutely exhausting.

28:43This will be the third big change in three years to this target. And at the moment, the car industry, they're either screaming out for just some certainty, or they're screaming out saying, can you cancel all these electric targets because they're fractionally harder to achieve than we thought. yes the idea has been for a long time for about a year that by by 2030 80 percent of new car sales which is a small proportion of overall sales most people buy their car secondhand 80 percent of new car sales be electric and the rest can be hybrids and there has been intense screaming from the car industry mostly the bits of it which haven't managed to get their ducks in a row people like jaguar land rover that kind of thing uh saying this is impossible it won't work you've got to lower that 80 % to 70 or 60 or 50.

29:29And the headlines today are suggesting that the government are going to be making a big change on that. And that is one of the main policies they've got for lowering emissions and making cars more efficient. And they're briefing it'll go as low as 50 % of new cars to be electric by 2030, which would be a huge collapse in ambition. Like 80 is a lot. Like the trajectory at the moment, 80 will be pretty hard to achieve. There was a lot of tolerance even in the you know the woke eco lewds among us saying well 80 is going to be quite hard maybe 70 is more realistic but to cut it down all the way down to 50 given all these extra flexibilities in there it just feels like a total collapse in the batting order and this is a target so are there fines if if they don't there are fines if you don't meet your target no one has ever had to pay a fine every manufacturer has met their target every single year because there are flexibilities and if you clean up your fleet a bit here you can sort of get fresh credits over here no one has ever had to pay a fine yet is this because the greens are so popular labor are desperately rowing back it's because of a few different reasons we think of labor as being you know relatively strong on environmental stuff there are big uh undercurrents within labor that frankly don't really give a toss about it and uh we've got a new chancellor john healy who has a long record of going slow on stuff like this.

30:52I mean, he spent a chunk of his summer objecting to the idea of a new solar field in his constituency. And then you've also got donors. You know, there are institutional donors like the unions, the GMB, where the B stands for Boilermakers. And you've got individual... That's a clue. It's a bit of a clue. And you've got individual donors like Dale Vince, who doesn't like various solutions like heat pumps and thinks, you know, that his solution of biomethane biomethane will work instead, which it won't. You can read about this in the eye under the very, very disguising moniker of Sonny Jim. He's good.

31:25I like his stuff. Or her.

31:30So, obviously, as a journalist, I can only perceive in things in terms of Westminster whispers and who's up and down. I mean, Ed Miliband being moved over to Foreign Secretary sounds like a remotion. Is it just to get him out of the way of the green stuff? Presumably not, because we're also told that the new environment secretary, Miata Van Bulla, is a protégé of his. That's how she's always described. She is, definitely. I think Miliband was such a bet noire for the places like the Telegraph and the Mail that people want to, you know, stories got even more clicks when it was Miliband's woke eco-lunacy rather than Van Bulla's woke eco-lunacy.

32:03She's not as recognisable a name. But I think in general, remember this name now, Keir Starmer, was stronger on green stuff than Burnham has been so far. And that's despite Burnham talking a very good game. There is a series of actions approving Jackdaw, maybe approving Rosebank, which is a much bigger oil field. Jackdaw you can kind of make a case for. Rosebank would trash a lot of climate commitments. But Rosebank's figures were amusingly put into the budget as though it was going to happen. And even the dimmest of financial journalists thought, hello. Yes. It looks like this is already done.

32:40John Healy has been saying well of course it's all Miata's decision and I wouldn't dream of interfering with this process but wouldn't it be nice to get away this tax revenue. So isn't she opposed to it though? Has she been publicly? She has not publicly said she's been quite careful to go to Aberdeen and say we do support this industry and we quite like to keep some seats in Scotland. But there is a debate over whether or not Burnham and Healy will together say no we're having it and intervene with that process. But And all of this is happening in week one of COP, which is meant to be trying to resolve some of these issues.

33:13And it was cross-party, this UK initiative and involvement. I mean, really, it's a Tory thing. It was Theresa May, wasn't it? Theresa May signed it into law. Yeah, yeah. And then, I mean, the UK has never missed one of its climate commitments. I think if some of these steps go ahead, for the first time under a Labour government, the UK will miss its targets, which are legally binding. Not that that makes too much of a difference to what actually happens on the ground. Will Boris Johnson intervene? I mean, I don't quite know where his politics are, but he used to be quite green. He was very hot on this stuff.

33:45He was terrific at announcing big targets and then jollying people along, which probably did a fair bit of good. I mean, on the green stuff, as with Ukraine, he certainly talked a good game, even if the results on the ground weren't actually quite as fast as he hoped. I mean, he brought forward the target to 2030 for electrifying new car sales. But Kimmy Bay not very much the other way, isn't she? She doesn't approve any of that stuff. No, she recycles, though, and good for her. That's all she says in interviews when asked about it. Yeah, the Conservatives and Reformer, you know, scrap all targets, scrap all of this.

34:15We'll get there somehow anyway, but they don't say how. Do you think they will? No, no, no, no. All of this comes with a big background of do the COP conferences do anything? You can't get nations of all these different sizes, different wealth, all of it, to agree on anything. The petro-states are always going to try and gum the thing up anyway. So there is a big question over whether it's a worthwhile process to engage in. Didn't last year they agree not to mention fossil fuels? I may be exaggerating slightly, but the wording was rather... I mean, basically... Where was it hosted last year? I remember this wrong, wasn't it?

34:49Didn't the Saudis host it one year or something? It has been hosted in the UAE. It's been hosted in all sorts of nations which have all sorts of variable records. But if you only want to host it in perfect nations, then you're only ever going to host it in small island states or in Denmark or places like that. So you sort of… I mean, a small island state that's getting smaller by the day might be quite a good bit. It would focus people's minds a bit, wouldn't it? Yeah, yeah, yeah. But no, that's the thing. They don't mention fossil fuels. And the target this year is quite snappily named 35 by 35, which is the idea that by 2035, 35 % of final energy, so not the energy that's put into the system the actual useful energy services should be electric right now the reason people say that is because there's this massive thing about primary energy where people say well fossil fuels provide most primary energy that goes into the system and what that means basically is that the energy that goes in is fossil about three quarters of it is lost is wasted during the process of getting stuff out of it basically if you've got two postman and one of them delivers 100 parcels but throws 75 into a hedge that is actually not a better postman than someone who's delivering 30 parcels can i put it that way yeah yeah yeah so it's a great metaphor so that the target of 35 by 35 is is going to be haggled over for the next couple of weeks but as you say and no one's mentioning fossil fuels there's this awful embarrassing uncle in the corner of the room and everyone's just saying well let's just let's just try and move around the uncle.

36:16Couldn't we do more though by helping the global south with its targets than giving a bit of money towards heat pumps in this country? There's definitely a case to be made about what is the most effective thing to do and where the responsibility lies for action. You know, should nations contribute to forests overseas and keeping them? But then that becomes a bit of a hostage to fortune of nations overseas saying, well, we'll trot them down if you don't pony up. So yeah, I mean, it's described as a multiplayer problem with a multiplayer solution. You know, it is a bit of everything. Because there was an 83 billion pledge to help other countries who are...

36:49Yeah, the rich nations are very slow on delivering and signing up. And even the things that are agreed are mysteriously slow to appear. I'm getting the impression that targets is the name of the game here, isn't it? Rather than actually doing anything. Goals. Setting targets. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And this is why this one, the organisers, Turkey, who are kind of co-hosting with Australia, don't ask about the footprints of travelling around. Everyone's flown in. Never mind that. They have said they want this to be the cop of implementation. The cop of implementation. That's not the bad cop that's going, hi, I'm the cop of implementation.

37:21Good cop, bad cop, and implementation cop. You do think maybe 30 years ago could we have focused on implementation, but we are where we are. Probably a bit late now. Yeah. And the fact is that by getting the Paris Agreement over the line 11 years ago, that has made a huge difference to the overall trajectory of global emissions, which is extraordinary. You know, it's just that it hasn't gone far enough or fast enough yet. And isn't the US just withdrawing from it all anyway? The US likes to play hokey-cokey with these negotiations. I think we've had out, in, out, and then we'll wait for two years from now to see if they're going to be back in again.

37:53But the conversation's kind of moved past whether America's involved, really. It's much more about China these days. China and India. And it's all a bit up for grabs. What's going to happen in America now after the midterms and losing control of both houses? Yes, there are loads of Democrats just making their own freelance trips over to the COP conference, saying, well, we're going to sort this out. you know which is very interesting well you've been very very positive andy i didn't mean to be i meant to alarm everyone um but no it's just we'll see what happens with this sort of mad uk rollback because it really is it's sending all the wrong signals basically is it the lebe party saying we can do the pragmatic thing even if lots of people hate it because we're fit for government now i think it is and i think there is a question over this word pragmatic because i don't think when we get to two degrees in 20 years time or whatever it is everyone will be saying well thank god we were so pragmatic 20 years ago i think that will not be on anyone's lips and we have forgotten the summer already haven't we yeah it was quite warm it's really cold now the hottest hottest october on record haven't we in this country and it's going to be the hottest year on record they've just announced in the last couple of days haven't they that this will be the hottest year surpassing 2024 well that's something dangerously radical dusty and i think we need to cut these electric car targets just in case.

39:06That's it for this episode of Page 94. Thank you so much for listening. Hope you've enjoyed it. Thank you to Ian, Justine and Adam. We will be back in two weeks with another episode of this show. But until then, if you find yourself needing more stories, there is a magazine out there that I can recommend to you. It's called Private Eye. And if you go to private-eye.co.uk, subscriptions are available. Failing that, just go to your nearest newsagent, assuming you still have one in your local area, and get a copy of the magazine. Thanks also to Matt Hill of Rethink Audio for producing. Bye for now.

From the publisher

The team (with Justine Smith) discuss the long, long failure in the media to notice Russell Brand telling the world who he was; with extra reports on the calls for help from Samaritans volunteers and the ‘Dirty COP’ climate conference happening in Turkey.

For more on Russell Brand, including Helen’s encounter with him at the New Statesman, try Episode 88, Brand Management.

The Samaritans can be contacted on 116 123.

More from Page 94: The Private Eye Podcast

All episodes