

Chris Ashton, owner/managing director of the International Wine Challenge (IWC), explains how the IWC “sake” judging works and why it’s been brought to Japan (including the 20th IWC in Hiroshima). He also discusses sake education, palate differences between Japan and the West, and new/expanded categories like aged sake (chilled/frozen storage), koshu, and fruit/floral sake (ume, yuzu, tea, hops).
Chris Ashton is a UK-based wine/sake logistics business owner (CA Wine Logistics), a “sake samurai,” and a Cool Japan ambassador. He entered sake via alcohol magazine publishing (database/circulation work for IWC starting in 1999), later learning sake deeply after Sake joined IWC in 2007, with mentor Toshi/Sora-san Koichi Sora (Urakasumi, Sendai).
IWC’s goal is not another sake competition but internationalizing sake using a 50/50 Japanese-vs-Western palate judging mix. Judges are trained to reward style-typicality and taste quality, using a two-round triage system and reflighting to compare like-with-like. Education and international exposure increased sake sales and judge capacity.
Hiroshima tours in Saijo (sake birthplace); post-2011 tsunami IWC efforts in Tokyo; a cheese-warehouse bottling story; aged sake example from 1985 (clear, “as clear as water”); sparkling sake’s rise from “pariah” to Michelin-star relevance; rice-field community lunches in Hyogo; “warm sake” not included due to equipment/logistics; Japan’s Coming of Age Day should officially feature sake to reverse domestic decline.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Learn about the origins and focus of the Sake On Air podcast.
“The people of sake actually brought me into sake.”
Hear about the significance of the International Wine Challenge in Hiroshima.
“But so I believe that you've been doing a bit of traveling and that you might actually be in Hiroshima right now or you were in Hiroshima.”
Learn about the special guest Chris Ashton and his current activities.
“Chris, thank you so much for making time for us.”
Discover how Chris Ashton got started in the wine and sake industry.
“So, it doesn't do very much with my waistline, I'm afraid, though.”
Explore the evolution and expansion of the sake competition in the International Wine Challenge.
“So we had Wine International, Wine and Spirit, Drinks International, you know, lots of different wine or wine related drinks products.”
Learn about the efforts to promote sake on an international scale.
“And he was, and that's for anybody who doesn't know, it's for the young guys, anyone under 45 in the sake industry.”
Understand how different palates influence sake preferences worldwide.
“which we were pushing for and working with them on it.”
Listen to Chris Ashton share the impact of the 2011 tsunami on the sake industry.
“And the tsunami, we did it, you know, it all changed for me.”
Discover the challenges and experiences during the trip to Japan post-tsunami.
“I think, you know, Saki needed help then because it was going to have a really tough time.”
Learn about the humorous challenges of processing sake in a cheese warehouse.
Explore the evolution of sake competitions and their significance in Japan.
“And then we put our heads together with Toshi and everyone.”
Understand the cultural significance of rice planting for both judges and locals.
“After the judging, the guys had a couple of days where they went on Tamil trips, you know, went out.”
Gain insight into the judging criteria and process used at the IWC for sake.
Discover how the IWC focuses on positive attributes in sake rather than faults.
“So you can tell one is different to the other and stands out.”
Learn about the structure of judging panels and how judges are promoted in the IWC.
“And it's a little bit more difficult with sake.”
Learn about the structure and balance of judging panels for sake competitions.
Understand the process and criteria judges use to evaluate sake in the first round.
Discover how sake is organized into flights and the tasting process involved.
“to have people, the judges go through all of those in the first round, just to get rid of the ones that are not so good.”
Explore the second round of judging where medals are awarded for quality sake.
“So we do half of it in day one and half in day two, in the morning of the second day.”
Learn about the careful discussions and scoring process judges engage in during tastings.
“so we're now down to about 1 ,200, something like that.”
Find out about the introduction of new aged sake categories and their significance.
“What do you think the global wine world still misunderstands about sake?”
Learn about the evolving definitions and classifications in aged sake, and the industry’s innovations.
“So as usual, the sake brewers are playing around with everything.”
Discover the journey of sparkling sake from pariah to prestigious in the sake industry.
“And I must admit, I did push that because I said to them, look, people in the West love bubbles.”
Understand how the classifications of futsushu are changing and the implications for quality.
“But here in Japan, if anything, they are polishing less, not more.”
Explore the logistical challenges of creating a warm sake category in competitions.
“But I think you might see this in the next couple of years coming out.”
Learn about initiatives to connect the younger generation in Japan with sake culture.
“We did a documentary last year about sake and on Adults Day in Japan, which we don't have it in the UK, is when somebody turns 20, they become an adult and it's their first time they can legally drink alcohol.”
Discover how the International Wine Challenge is adapting its approach to sake competitions worldwide.
“The domestic consumption here is really, really on its last legs in many respects, you know.”
Explore the evolving drinking habits and cultural shifts in the UK over generations.
“And my eldest son does drink, but not very much.”
Chris Ashton encourages listeners to diversify their sake experiences by trying new options.

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Sake On Air, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:02The people of sake actually brought me into sake. Back in 1988 this place was actually in Ginza on the main drag. At first it was kind of soy sauce, it was miso. To the point where it actually changed my life. New Year's Day 1989.
0:15Chris Ashton: Not just sake as a beverage but all the culture and history. Thank you for tuning in to another episode of Sake On Air, the world's first podcast dedicated to expanding the dialogue surrounding Japan's iconic beverages, sake, shochu, and of course, awamori. I am one of your regular hosts on the show, Chris Shoes, and I'm joined today by one of your other regular hosts, Cindy Bissig. Cindy, how are you doing? I'm doing great, Chris. Hello, good morning. Yeah, good morning. It seems like an ages since we've actually done one of these together, But we obviously have quite busy lives and we don't meet each other perhaps as often as we should and we could.
1:00Chris Ashton: But so I believe that you've been doing a bit of traveling and that you might actually be in Hiroshima right now or you were in Hiroshima. I was in Hiroshima for a little bit. And I think so have you. Yes. So we were both involved in some way with a rather important, quite special, sake competition, which has made a rather rare appearance in Japan. I'm, of course, talking about the International Wine Challenge, which is normally held in London, but it has been held in Japan in the past two or three times. and this year for the 20th International Wine Challenge it was held in Hiroshima and as part of the competition there were a few days of tours as well and I was very lucky honoured and privileged to be able to join that as a judge and I believe Cindy you were there representing the media.
2:00Yeah I've joined a IWC tour in Higashi Hiroshima organised by the area to introduce some of the judges to local businesses breweries do tastings overnight stays because i think that's one of the objectives of competition is not just judging the sake but also help with some of the regional branding and hopefully economic development of the region through the competition and you guys
2:26Chris Ashton: obviously joining from all around the world well i i don't know about you i had a great time so the actual venue for the hosts of the competition, well, it was Higashi Hiroshima, East Hiroshima, in particular, Saijo, which is one of the birthplaces of sake, one of the places in Japan, which has a very rich, deep-rooted history in sake. And I had a great time. I learned a lot. It was great to network with people from around the world in the sake industry. And I could tell you a lot about the competition but rather than do that we are very very lucky to have with us today a very very special guest who's probably the best person in the world I think to tell us about this competition yeah so without further ado let me introduce this episode's special guest we've been wanting to get him on the show for a while now but he's a very busy guy traveling around the world, none other than the owner and managing director of the International Wine Challenge, Chris Ashton.
3:33Chris Ashton: Chris, thank you so much for making time for us. It's an honour to have you on. I believe you're in Macau at the moment? Yeah, it's Macau. I've just been doing – oh, hello, by the way. Just been doing a marquee event here in Macau with Wind Palace. We've got a series that we do here, and it coincided with my trip to Hiroshima, so I've popped down here for a few days. You know, life could be worse. It's very pleasant here. So, yes, we had two huge Wagyu dinners paired with some sake, which was unbelievable. Very nice. Unbelievable. I'm very lucky. I get to go to things like this, and it's just fabulous.
4:14So, it doesn't do very much with my waistline, I'm afraid, though. That's why.
4:21That's the one problem. Yeah.
4:24Chris Ashton: That sounds amazing. And so as well as the International Wine Challenge, you also have your own wine and sake logistics business in the UK, CA Wine Logistics. You're also a sake samurai and a Cool Japan ambassador. So if I can take you back in time a bit, how did you actually get involved with the competition? And what is your sake discovery story so far? Tell us a bit more about yourself. Well, I was in publishing and back in 99, I joined a company called Wilmington and they had a portfolio of magazines and I looked after the circulation. I was a circulation director. We had loads of alcohol magazines.
5:08So we had Wine International, Wine and Spirit, Drinks International, you know, lots of different wine or wine related drinks products. and I was asked to help build a database for the International Wine Challenge because I'm a customer acquisition database kind of guy at that time anyway. And so I helped build a database for the International Wine Challenge to run the competition because it was getting bigger and bigger and bigger. This is 1999, so it's a long time ago. And so I built the database and then I ran the International Wine Challenge for a while and really started my wine journey, really.
5:46and we had a little bit of sake in there but not very much and as time progressed the business was sold I remained with my I was a publishing director so that's what I did and then we associated with the wine challenge for about six years before it was sold so we we got to the nuts and bolts of everything and then I joined the business I got made redundant then I joined that business looking after the International Wine Challenge in full. And at that stage, this was 2009, and Sake had just joined, joined in 2007.
6:19Chris Ashton: Right, yes. So that was with Toshi and Sora-san and Sam Harrop, who was a co-chair of the International Wine Challenge at the time. And when I went back, there was this whole section called Sake, which I knew absolutely nothing about. so we had to go on a very steep learning curve and luckily Toshi was very helpful and my friend Rii Yoshitake in London was very helpful and I had a crash course in sake before any courses existed and I had to learn about sake, I had to learn about how we judge it and I needed to learn about how we could put it together in a competition it had been running for a couple of years and I think the first entry was about 240 sake, something like that, and there's about four categories, I believe.
7:12And over the years, what we have done is increase the number of categories and obviously increase the number of sake joining. But it joined the International Wine Challenge for one simple reason, Sorasan, Koichi Sora up in Sendai. Yeah.
7:27Chris Ashton: The CEO of Urakasumi in Yagi Preview. Yeah, so he's my mentor in sake, really. And I owe a great debt to him. He's a very generous man. Yes. And he's a lovely guy, and I really enjoy his company. And we've become longtime friends. And he was the first president of the newly formed Sake Samurai Association. Yes. And he was, and that's for anybody who doesn't know, it's for the young guys, anyone under 45 in the sake industry. So it was really designed to get the sons and the next generation involved in sake, but actually do something physically different than the owners and the Sake Brewers Association.
8:14So they could, you know, the young books, you know, the energy for the future. And Sorosan was charged with expanding the footprint of sake worldwide. So by bringing Sake International Wine Challenge, we could internationalize it. We could make it exist on an international scale because of our, you know, we were one of the biggest wine, we were the biggest wine competition in the world then. And, you know, we were doing 15 ,000 wines at the time, I think, something like that. It was huge. And so what we did, we used our platform, the international management platform, to promote sake. And the more we did it each year, international sake sales started to increase, you know, and the national tax agency started doing reports.
8:58All of a sudden the graph was just going like this. The more we worked on sake, you know, in our small way, the more impetus sake got. And then more people around the world started to get involved in sake. And then the WSET launched their course, which we were pushing for and working with them on it. And Toshi did lots of work there as well. And then all of a sudden the education started. And that's when it really took off because people started to learn more in depth about sake. And it meant that I could have more judges because at the beginning it was really tough. I wasn't involved in the initial selection, but I know they found Bo Timken in the US.
9:43They found R.K. Norgren in Sweden.
9:46Chris Ashton: Yes, yeah. He is an expert, yeah. And I think Simon was involved in it as well. Simon Hofstra was involved, yeah. yeah uh so that was the that was and ken ohashi obviously yes and um and that was the bare bones of the of the team and i i think the first judging the first judging was about 20 people or something like that might even you know a couple of hundred sake yeah but they were the world experts we could find you know and uh we needed to try and we had some people flying from japan and we had some global people because one of the whole points is the whole thing about the iwc is not to be another another sake competition like the Japanese ones because they've already got them what we were trying to do was internationalize sake so so we needed western palettes and and what we did was you know really hard and we still do it to this day 50 percent of the of the judges must have Japanese palettes yeah and uh and the other one should be western now western is means basically anybody outside Japan so they could be from Asia from Singapore China whatever We classify those as not Japanese palates.
10:55So we have to have a 50-50 mix. But that's palates, not people. So, for example, John Gortner is American, lived in Japan for how many years? 40 years, as he said. He's got a Japanese palate. Similarly, Japanese people that have lived in the UK for 30, 40 years are now tasting more like Westerners, inverted commas.
11:19Chris Ashton: Yeah. Pallets change around the world. You know, the people, people's palates, people's diets, people's wines are different, you know, in every part of the world. So, for example, if you've got an international brand of wine, just an example, it will be sweeter in the US. It will be drier in Europe. It will be slightly sweeter in Asia just to suit the palates. okay so and similarly with palates uh with sake they want different things you know westerners prefer because they've been educated for this with wine it's more flavor more originality more complexity uh and where whereas the japanese parrots potentially want more purity and more subtlety so it's a different side so and this is where the big ginjos came in so we have a we learnt about the yeast involves and the toji involves and things like that.
12:14The high ethyl producing yeast, the ginjo yeast, juice more flavours than the original old style yeast. We identify those within the entry process, so we know whether they're together. So we put all those ones together and all the original style ones together. And it's really interesting because we have probably slightly more sake entered into the sake competition now that from original yeast but i think it's it's all about education it's all about educating palates yes you know and and i think the more the longer we go on we've been doing it 20 years now you know the longer we go on and the more people we educate it it will be sustainable as a product you know and it brings people's eyes to the originality and the original styles of sake which are inverted commas as you said maybe coming back into fashion a little bit so people are looking for different flavor profiles internationally as well you know
13:10Chris Ashton: which is really interesting so you mentioned that this was you were 20 years so one of the big things about the IWC that you just held in Hiroshima in Japan was the 20th IWC the anniversary the 20th tasting yes so we the first was done in 2017 so this is the 20th one we did so and we we didn't even through COVID, you know, we managed. Um, yes. Yeah. And the tsunami, we did it, you know, it all changed for me. You said about my sake journey, it all changed for me 2012, 2011, 2012. So I got my understanding of sake then, but when the tsunami hit, um, I know in 2011, it sort of changed everything because in Europe we could, they couldn't export sake to Europe.
13:57It was banned. And more than anything, I think, you know, Saki needed help then because it was going to have a really tough time. So we went to Tokyo. So I spoke to Sora-san, who was still president. And I said, look, if you can't come to us, we'll have to come to you. So we're coming to Tokyo. And it was a bit of a struggle because we did it in the old Saki Samurai offices, in the Saki Brewers offices, you know. And we did it on the fifth floor, I think it was. It was still quite small, you know, and even then, you know, I think, I can't remember, I think we did about 500 or 600 sake at the time, something like that.
14:32It opened my eyes to Japan, really, that trip. Yeah. Because of the resilience of the people and the generosity of people, more than I noticed.
14:43Chris Ashton: Had you ever been before to Japan? Sorry to interrupt. Had you ever been before? That was your first trip? No, I was planning to go. Yeah. I planned to go in 2011. Right. But then couldn't because of the tsunami. it just wasn't right to go but that's when we we because we went out there um i went out there once before the before the trip just have a look around and see things it wasn't there very long but and then and then we put it all together quite quickly but no we worked with really close to the saki samurai association then and we made it happen and the generosity of people then under such extreme harsh conditions after the tsunami was unbelievable we threw everybody in you know all the judges turned up and we did our best you know we did our best with what we could do but that's what that's when my real engagement with japan happened right that became you know before it was work and then it turned into passion i'll tell you a funny story we turned up and we had to do it in a warehouse near uh nigata so all the sake was there right in the offices in tokyo there wasn't space so um so no uh no it was near the airport you know you got to airport we're in a warehouse and it was a cheese warehouse okay of course it was yeah it's really cool yeah i put cheese yeah i absolutely detest cheese i hate i oh really as a as a wine uh you know professional that's quite surprising to hear i i i detest i hate cheese i hate the smell of it i hate everything about cheese anyway so I had to do we had to do the bottling or the processing of the sake in a fridge about 2 degrees and there's this intense smell of cheese for about 10 days while we processed all the sake it wasn't my favourite moment in Japan but looking back at it it was very funny but very funny and very cold the whole point is we try and do our best for the sake so we try and keep it cold even in London it's cold you know so we work in a cold environment in Hiroshima we had fridges for the for the Nama and things like that but we couldn't refrigerate everything so yeah this is what it is um is that the reason why you decided to bring IWC over to Japan regularly yeah because because it happened so much so much and then oh when we did it in 2012 and then you know we had this crazy idea that maybe we should do it more often in Japan because it was such a different judging type really and you know to be to be fair on the on the sake brewers where we did it there it was quite tight and there we were lucky because there's a spare floor that we managed to or some rooms on another floor that we managed to borrow to do the competition you know so we're very lucky so it wasn't it's not designed that place wasn't designed to run a sake competition so then we decided to try and see whether we could do it properly in another place.
17:44And then we put our heads together with Toshi and everyone. And then we put the competition together, did it in Yamagata. It was a different animal then because I think Japan was back on its feet and then they wanted to promote their recent, what do they call it, the designation.
18:06Chris Ashton: Oh, the geographical identification. G.I. G.I. G.I., yeah. Sorry, that was Yamagata. In Hyogo, which was the first one we did, we were celebrating the 80th anniversary Yamanadishiki rice. Oh, right. Oh, Hyogo was the first one, wasn't it? Yeah, sorry. Yeah, it was. Hyogo was first, so we did the celebration there, and all the judges learned so much about Yamanadishiki. It was unbelievable. So we did a really intense... We had professors doing lectures on it. It was really interesting, you know, because they were getting the real science behind the rice and the longevity. And it was amazing that our judges soaked that up.
18:48Chris Ashton: And you actually grew some Yaminenishki, didn't you? I remember the photographs. It was very symbolic. After the judging, the guys had a couple of days where they went on Tamil trips, you know, went out. So one of the ideas was we went into northern Hyogo and planted rice. Just to give you some context, as a Westerner, I'd never seen rice growing. I'd never seen rice growing in a field. Well, you would be surprised how many people I meet who think there's a difference between brown and white rice, that they're two different varieties. Yeah. So I'd never seen it before. So for the judges, I didn't do it because I was working, doing the trophies that day, but a lot of the judges had never been in a rice field.
19:27Yeah. And the overriding thing about that chip was not the uniqueness of planting rice, but the people. People who are all the rice growers, all the women cooked food for everyone. So if you didn't go to a restaurant, all the people, all the people associated with the rice growing made food in their homes and brought it out for everybody to have lunch. And people spoke more about that, you know, how people made them so part of what they were doing. They felt part of the whole process. yeah and it's incredible how the communities you can communicate with them without actually speaking Japanese as well right yeah yeah so I went back later to harvest it so there was a we I came over for the uh Saki Samurai um inauguration in Kyoto so we went went there to harvest as well and and that was fascinating that was really interesting again everybody came out and we and all the Saki Samurai team went down there and we harvested the rice it was wonderful and I think wherever we've been people have welcomed us which is really lovely and that's something that I will always cherish you know it's just and it's part of
20:44Chris Ashton: the IWC ethos isn't it that's sort of you know helping to put these communities these local regions back on the map. Well that's the whole point about the IWC and the way we judge we don't what we have to do is give everyone a chance every single target gets the same opportunity so we remove information so we don't tell the judges what prefecture is from or for a start you know right what rice it is but you can yes you can get rice so you know you know what the rice is and you know what the blend ratios are but that's it on the alcohol and but that's it you know you don't know any other information you know we have non-japanese sake in the competition you know so but we don't do that we don't identify and it's not like with grapes where you can figure out the region from the rice variety because because brewers use rice varieties from all over japan yeah it's impossible you know yeah so all and it's all mixed up and we we we flight it so that's flighting is putting the sake together in in one one group so you can judge it and so so we put those together that are very similar so the same blend ratio same rice same blend ratios um and and same alcohol content so they're very similar product and then they're divided into category aren't they so you've got put them into categories first and then yeah and then and then we we sort them by similar backgrounds what i'm trying to do is to make your your journey as a judge easier so um soccer judges don't judge all the time you know there's that many competitions you can do this at and especially an international one like us there's there's one you know so so i I have to be gentle with you all, really.
22:27I can't keep your hard time. It takes a little bit of time to get going. So what I try and do is to make it easier for you. So I put sakes that are the same together. Yeah. So, you know, as I said before, same rice, same blend, all the rest of it. So you can then spot the nuances between the difference between each one of them. Yeah. So you can tell one is different to the other and stands out. You know, that's what we try and do. but obviously I don't know that because I haven't tested them so all I'm going on is how they're made and then it's down to you guys as judges to say this one's good, this one's good, this one's good, that's why we do the triage system so in round one we just do quick judging, good, is it good, is it worthy of a second look is it worthy of a medal, yes, bang let's have a look at it in round two is it good you know, we'll be very happy to drink it but it's not medal worthy, that's a commended or it's out because there's a problem or an issue or it's just not good but remember in many ways we are different from other competitions because especially japanese competitions japanese competitions generally run on negativity so they're looking for to to knock it all the time say this is bad this is off this is off this is off and the best the
23:43Chris Ashton: one with the least faults wins right okay exactly yeah yeah well we're looking at the other way around what's positive about it does it taste good is it a definition of the style is it supposed to is it saying telling to you what it is if it's a honjo does it taste like honjo you know we'll come on to polishing rates on that again because that's that was a big thing this year so it but we what we want to do is to say to somebody who has um they're going to a shop in in any country in the world and they see sake on the shelf and it's got an idc sticker on it be that gold, silver or bronze, and it says, this is Jun Mai.
24:20We want that sake to taste like a Jun Mai. It's got to be typical. With wine, we want wines to have a sense of place, where they're from. And it's a little bit more difficult with sake. So I want it to be a definition of the style, as in, you know, make sure that when somebody goes in and they go, and I have that sake, oh, I like Jun Mai. I'll buy Jun Mai again. all right that's a really nice one if that's what you might taste like i want that so that's what we go for in all those things so in round one what you're doing is getting rid of the things that are not as good as the others okay so they then being put through and then the co-chairs recheck all of those so all of those that you push out so the first day day and a half all they're all they're doing is drink is tasting not so good sake right yeah i noticed that but
25:12Chris Ashton: That was a lot of fun in itself as well. That was a nice kind of warming up exercise, to be honest with you. It gets you into it. It's quite an intense day. You're tasting 100 sake. Yeah, it was. Yeah, throwing the deep end. But it was the best way to do it, I think. Well, not many people in the sake world will taste 100 sake in a day. No, no, no. But the whole point of round one is to get you up to speed, get your palates working, and then deal with round two separately because then you're on form, then you're flying. Yeah, I felt much more confident. Exactly. So we've got rid of the ones that we think are not too good.
25:51The co-chairs have checked them. They've put some back in to give them another go.
25:54Chris Ashton: Yeah. And especially at the end of the day, people were getting tired. Yeah, yeah. And so the co-chairs came into more action in the afternoon, just catching things before people made a mistake. because mistakes are made. People's palates have been, you know, after about 80 sake, they're getting a bit jaded. So that's why we have the check system. So the co-chairs who are not doing the same kind of volume because there's five of them and they're all breaking it down, they can just see where and put it back in and give it another go. Put it back in. And co-chairs are judges who have worked their way up the competition hierarchy being praised or recommended to be kind of promoted by other judges over time and you've at some point you've thought this person is kind of ready to to be a uh a co-chair is that a correct understanding yes yeah because you know we we get them in at the beginning so they have to come through the process to come in through me to get into it and then how they get promoted i don't get i don't get involved with the judges promotions until they go to co-chair right okay so they're they are promoted by their peers so that so this is why we ask you to do all those forms every day um because we want your feedback and the panel chairs give feedback on you yeah we had these questions just to tell our listeners we had these uh each judge was issued a questionnaire to fill in um at the end of each day um because another thing that just to make clear we were all divided into groups into panels so each judge would be with another three or four judges and the panel that you were on would be different for each day of the three days of the competition and we were asked to evaluate the performance of the other judges that were on the same panel and then basically one of the things that you can do in the questionnaire is you can actually maybe recommend someone to be promoted to uh the next level of judging whether that's senior judge or um possibly even uh panel uh chair or then co-chair so we take all that feedback we analyze it um and then so you go who will submit you go well then look at all of that and then recommend promotions or demotions you know you can go down as well and up and one of the things i just had on the judging panels before we'll leave that you may have noticed the judging panels are uh configured in such a way to give balance yes i definitely felt that yeah yeah so what you've got is you if you've got a japanese head or panel chair you will have a western senior judge and then you have you'll have two western judges and one Japanese so you'll have your so if you're the head you you could be technically outvoted and so you can't be dominant this is why we say that the panel chair must always go last to give their scores we're not ever allowed to go first because if you are the lead and the most senior one people may be in deference and then just copy what you do they influence definitely you could influence what your the lower judges think and some people may end up changing their we don't want that, I want to see what they're like the whole point as I say to everyone, put your score down don't change it burn from it if you put a commende and everybody else has put gold, you go, why have I done that?
29:28For anybody who's maybe listening and doesn't know how the judging goes, if you could just maybe give us a quick explanation of like what the group are judging and how fast they're going through each sake and maybe just a really quick um how the whole system works well i live into the judges really so i don't i don't i don't think as a competition organizer you should be telling judges how to judge no no but i what i meant to say is like you're going through so we established that we have groups of five to six people we have a head judge senior judge and some fellow judges how many saccades per rounds will they judge how much time do they have um is there open discussions do they all score by themselves there's a final score i'll just go through the process yeah we have five people on it five people on a panel okay and in day one so or round one they judge about 100 100 sake okay so those are flights and they can be broken down into flights of three or about eight we don't go really any more than eight okay but they're all going to be similar in the round one to consider which of those starts okay are worthy of a medal i either they're a good definition of the style they're well made they're well balanced you know the alcohol is is is in line with the flavors and it tastes good does it taste good that's what you want all right i'm not interested in whether that was two degrees higher in the fermentation process i don't care because people don't know that people who are drinking that don't care about that stuff like that they care about does this taste good is my money being well invested in this this is delicious that's what i want them to go and say not this was maybe two degrees too high it doesn't work you know anyway so so what we want to do is to have people, the judges go through all of those in the first round, just to get rid of the ones that are not so good.
31:33Okay? Put them out, in, out, in, out, in, out. There's no in-depth notes taken. If there's something faulty or there's a problem, the panel chair will write down and tell me what the problem is. And then the co-chairs will double-check that to make sure that it's done. So I don't know how many flights that would be during the day, but probably somewhere in the region of about 12, 13, 14. Some of them are small some of them big it just depends so for so for example uh we'll we'll start off with futsushu and you'll probably have three or four in your flight okay three or four sake i've got 13 tables so there's three or four going out in every flight and then we'll have a honjozo there's probably two or three in each flight then a junmai that's a big category so we're now going into probably sixes or eights so if you consider that you've just had two relatively easy flights of Futsusu Honjozo.
32:24You know, your palate's now active. You've probably had 10, 12 sake. You're getting into it. Then you hit Junmai. Junmai then comes in, and it's a big category, and there's lots of diversity within Junmai, so your palate's up and down. And this is one of the reasons why we put everything together. And then you will move on to Ginjo, then Dai Ginjo, two smallish categories. Ginjo's small. Dai Ginjo's a bit bigger. And then you've got Junmai Ginjo, which is a huge category. and this is I think the most difficult one to do because it's all full of ginjos, full of flavour there's a lot of activity there so you've got to be on your game but now that you're in mid-afternoon first day you're flying, you've just had lunch you're having a good time so you're into Jumai Ginjos and then the big one Jumai Dai Ginjo comes and bites you now what we do with Jumai Dai Ginjo because it's so huge, we had over 550 sake and if I gave that to all these judges in day one, they'd all be dead.
33:22They'd all be wiped out. So I split it into two. So we do half of it in day one and half in day two, in the morning of the second day. And we'll finish off then with either an aged sake or a koshu or I think this year we did fist, so fruit-infused sake. That's right, yeah. So there's a new category for this year and I've been pushing to do that for a while. so we brought in basically omeshus and yuzu yuzu sake and anything that's flavoured with it but it has to be sake based not shochu based which was really interesting this year because we had some beautiful omeshus, some really lovely yuzu sake and then some tea sake and some hops that was my group we got hops
34:12Chris Ashton: yeah Yeah. As usual, we had some pretty zany stuff within that category, I think. Yeah. Which we'll develop. You know, we'll develop that as time goes on. You know, we just did the first one. We'll learn from it. We'll look at the results, look at what people did, and then we'll do it. So that's the end of your first day. And then in round two, the numbers are lower. So we've probably taken out about 40 % of the stockings. All right. So we're now down to, you know, we've gone from 1 ,700, so we're now down to about 1 ,200, something like that. We're now judging for medals. So potentially all of these sockets have been put through to round two are potentially medal-worthy.
34:55However, I put some back in. So I put some... Just need some in, right? ...that have been chucked out from round one just to keep everybody honest. Because it would be very easy to go, well, these have all been given a medal so far this year. we'll give them all a medal no no no no it doesn't work like that so what what i want to do and this is again another test is to make sure that those wine those sake put back in come back out again and most do and most do um occasionally one goes through and we have a look at it with the co-chairs you know and just said what do you think and it was no this is worthy metal you know this is good so there might be a difference between that and the first bottle or the first bottle was you know So most are commended.
35:36And so occasionally one squeaks through, which is nice to try and catch one. But then they're looking at the gold, silver, bronze. So when you're judging then, now, again, I've reflighted these, and these, again, are all similar. So now we're looking at those nuances between the two. So it could be a commended. There's five solutions for round two. Gold, silver, bronze, commended, or out. They're your five ones. You've got to be on your toes. So what happens is that the co-chair, you all judge them one by one, and then you mark your scores yourselves. And then you have a communication with each other.
36:15Panel chair will go, okay, round one, sake one. Chris, what did you think? And he would then go and say, oh, I thought this was a bronze medal. And then the next one would go bronze, and then bronze or commended, and then somebody might go gold. So, okay, we'll follow those down. Now you discuss. But where did everybody score? I assume you're judging one sake by one sake and you move on, but you're actually scoring and then you communicate over the group of sake.
36:42Chris Ashton: We taste all the sake. This might vary by panel, but in all the panels I was part of, we tasted all the sake quietly, I might add. So there's no talking, no discussion. You do it quietly. You can concentrate. Then once everyone's ready, the panel chair will go, are we ready to discuss now? And then basically for each one, one by one, they will go through, each person will say, you know, we did it by letter. So it was B, S, G. And then the panel chair will say, right, okay, for the ones that didn't agree with the other ones, you know, sell this to us. Like, why do you think this should be a gold?
37:23Chris Ashton: Why do you think this should be a silver? Then we'd have another discussion. and then it was a question of whether we would end up going with that person or we would come to a sort of a balancing point well we've got one gold but we've got a lot of bronzes here one silver why don't we meet in the middle and we come to a silver but we'd all we'd all agree on why that should be a silver and you have to write tasting notes in round two so you have to actually be able to describe the sake as well you're supposed to work as a team the whole point Well, we've taken a lot of your time, Chris. What I'd like to do is just, we've got some quick fire questions.
38:02Chris Ashton: Let's see. Cindy, you've asked some as well. Yes, I do. Well, you go first then. What do you think the global wine world still misunderstands about sake? I think that what has happened is that people have come to the realisation about the complexity of sake and how it fits within the wine world. you know and they see that it's not it's not a competitor in the real term but it is a competitor in now in many terms but it also offers the diversity that wine can give you but with a similar product you know um and it gives a difference i always think that if you get wine choice wrong with with with food you could be in big trouble sometimes the wine fights the food and I haven't come across any sake yet that fights the food.
38:55It blends in beautifully.
38:57Chris Ashton: Tell us about this new aged sake category and the koshu category that was added to the competition. Yeah, we put that in a few years ago. It's a long story, so I'll try and be brief on it. Basically, I was at Duzekakura when he won his second with Nakano-san and when he won his second champion. And he said he'd been clearing out his fridge and he found some sake that his father made. And it was a Jun Mai and it was 25 years old. And he had six bottles of it. And he said, oh, should we try one? I went, yeah, cool, go on, this will be lovely. And we drank, we opened this bottle and it was wonderful.
39:38And he, you know, I remember it just, because it had that extra level, it's pure, clean and clear, no oxidization, nothing, because it had been, basically put in minus five. He just kept six bottles. And we drank it. The level of remod was off the scale. It was just something different. And I remember saying to him, how much have you got of this? I can't understand. And he went, oh, six bottles. Oh, my God.
40:06But then when I started digging, people had more. So all of a sudden, I started to push people and say, right, this is, you know, I've got a vision for this. Nobody knows what to do with it Because it's all sake It's been at the back of the freezer For decades Nobody knows what to do with it But I envisage a Tokyo businessman Having dinner And ordering a 30 year old Sake And willing to pay for it And so I said How can we build this I spoke to the guys I spoke to Kazoo you know, sake said my association went right, I want to do this category and so we decided to put this in the distinction was that sake that was aged but chill freeze as in low storage temperature other than the stuff that's been left in a tank and oxidise and it was getting really difficult to judge Koshu because there was such diversity from young koshu which is two years old which is technically still koshu but still clear and then koshu that was 30 years old and it was dark brown and luscious and very different and honeyed and all that and you know so you've got two products almost like a bottle of water and a cup of coffee in the same flight you know you just this is crazy so we split the two and what we've now found is that more and more people have got more of this stuff and and And the Age Sake Trophy this year is one from 1985.
41:49Chris Ashton: Yes, it's incredible. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's as clear as this bottle of water. It's stunning. I don't know how much it is, but it was stunning. Born, right? It was born, wasn't it? Born, born, wasn't it? Yeah. We're still developing this category. It's only the third year we've done it. So as usual, the sake brewers are playing around with everything. And so we've got to strengthen our definition. So next year, aged sake is only going to be clear sake. So if it's got any color in it whatsoever, we're going to push that over to the koshu section. Right, right. Because even a light one, it's got all the koshu flavors coming through.
42:28You know, the honey, you know, all the oscaritas. So even with a light color, it's there. So that's going to go into koshu. And what I'll do with koshu is subdivide that by color now as well.
42:40Chris Ashton: Oh, right. Interesting. I'll do that next year. But I have to now I can't fly that until I see it So it's a bit difficult Everything else, low temperature Has to be clear Because that's what we want for aged sake So I, you know Stuff that's been stored at minus 5 For 30 years, that's the one Stuff I want to see in aged sake It's a new category It's not a category within Sake officially at the moment But this is one of the beauties of of the IWC, we can, we can do what we want really not bound by tradition. Um, we can, we can try things out, you know, and if it doesn't work, it doesn't really, it's fine, you know?
43:22And, and say, because we did this with sparkling sake 10 years ago, you know, and at the time sparkling sake was viewed as a, and not a real sake, it was just something.
43:31Chris Ashton: Pariah, pariah in the sake industry. Yeah. Yeah. And, you know, and Ishinokura had one, he was first that did it. So it's, I think his first one was 30 years ago. He did one. So within 10 years of us introducing the sparkling category, within 10 years, you've now got sake brewers producing secondary fermentation sake like champagne. And one of the brewers is now supplying Alan Ducasse in his restaurants. Ah, Shichiken. Yeah. Yeah. Three Michelin star restaurants. Yeah. In 10 years. And they were your champion last year. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, but he got it for this Jumai Dai Ginjo, not the sparkling.
44:11Chris Ashton: Not the sparkling, no, that's a good point. But he won a gold with that as well. But the whole thing is that in 10 years from being something that was viewed as, as you said, a little pariah, something not too serious, to being something which is world-class now in three Michelin star restaurants, whoa, what a journey, 10 years. That's why the Awasaki Association was built. And good on them. It's fantastic. And I must admit, I did push that because I said to them, look, people in the West love bubbles. Bubbles. Yeah. They have a little bit more sweetness. So because we use it as a celebratory drink.
44:50So why not push this? And I'm pleased I did push it because now we've got something that's...
44:57Chris Ashton: Have you ever considered like, or maybe this is a consideration for the future, but you were talking about typicity. And one challenge that we have in the sake industry right now is that typicity is disappearing. The differences between the different grades, the premium grades of sake, is blurring quite a lot. Do you foresee in the future that maybe the IDBC will have to get rid of the Tokute Meisho shoe-based flighting and maybe start to sort of categorize sake by style and not how they were made? Yeah, we've had a discussion about this already. Oh, right. I'm sitting on the fence at the moment.
45:40Okay, yeah. But if you notice futsusu this year, the definition of futsusu, it can be anything you want. It can be anything.
45:47Chris Ashton: Yeah, literally anything. Anything. And it was always really, really, really low polish rates, as in it was like 10 % or 20 % was normal. Yeah. We're having 60%, 65 % million rates now on rice in futsusu. we had 10 gold medals in futsushu we've never had that we usually get the futsushu were amazing like i was blown away by the one from takara chochikubai like this this it was so silky and soft and smooth and this lovely pear kind of flavor going through i mean there's no in a million years i would have guessed that was futsushu not in a million years but you know i think that's really where it's interesting right because it's not the premium socket that only gets the medals there's so much great socket that is not high-end premium anymore and people don't always recognize this overseas they think it has to cost a lot of money and be highly polished but then you have all this amazing Futsushu or similar in the landscape of sake now here so I thought it was great to see that there were so many medals to be honest you know Ken Ohashi pushes for as well he believes in the Futsushu and Honjo category so there is this blurring of the lines especially with Millin now and I think that at some stage I think we need to look at it i i i it's too early at the moment to consider changing more yeah i i don't think any knee-jerk reaction is needed but let's just see how it goes maybe in the future it might be a fad it might be yeah you know to be fair with the price of rice at the moment i don't know what they can do it for but i mean um you know it's it's interesting to see that the million rates are increasing so when when you say high high polishing rates i just want to make it clear for our listeners you mean the high polishing uh the lower polishing ratios right like 65 50 40 yeah so you're milling away you're milling away more yeah more and more and more so you're just getting down to the proteins you know but if one scale you've got uh you know absolute zero which is which is you know what 0.8 uh yeah yeah the one by knees our knees hours yeah zero which you know um and then uh you've got the stuff that just just removes 20 you know so you know so there's a huge diversity within but there is a trend in this year's competition to higher milling rates as in getting rid of more of the more of the rice husk you know that that's interesting chris because in japan we are seeing the opposite uh trend brewers are actually um it It may be that they did that for the competition, possibly all for competitions in general.
48:27Chris Ashton: But here in Japan, if anything, they are polishing less, not more. I would just – the sake they enter here has got to be commercially available, so it's not competition sake. Sure, sure, sure, sure. Sure, sure. Yeah, yeah. But I think you might see this in the next couple of years coming out. That's possible. Yeah, that's true. Yeah, yeah. So we do this with wine. we tend to see stuff coming into the wine competition before it hits the shelves. Yeah. They use it as a, as a, as a test to see, you know, a benchmark exercise. So it might be that they produce some of this product, seeing how it goes and, you know, it's a really good way to test your product.
49:11Chris Ashton: Yeah. That's what I meant by sake for the competition, not like competition sake, but yeah, for testing things out. Yeah. The proviso is, you know, This stuff has got to be available for sale. Because if you win a medal, people will want to buy it. Because you are a consumer-focused competition at the end of the day. Absolutely. We don't consider the brewer or the winemaker. We consider the buyer of a product. Yeah. So on that note, let me ask you a rather challenging question, maybe. I'll put you on the spot. You have, in interviews on TV or in other media, you've made it very clear that you are a big proponent of warm sake.
49:53Chris Ashton: You love warm sake. Yeah. Why isn't there a warm sake category in the IWC? The really simple answer in that is getting the equipment to make it. Yeah, of course. Of course. Of course. Logistically, it would be a nightmare, wouldn't it? I've tried. We have done tests. the difficulty is you've got a very short window of time to get it right for you guys yeah of course yeah so i would need hundreds if not huge baths yeah six degrees to to make it happen it's something we've have got down there on the back burner that we need to consider how we do um you know but the simple answer to the question is um we haven't got the equipment to be able to do it properly and if I'm going to do it, I have to do it properly.
50:40But I will say this before we end this. We did a documentary last year about sake and on Adults Day in Japan, which we don't have it in the UK, is when somebody turns 20, they become an adult and it's their first time they can legally drink alcohol. Is that right?
51:01Chris Ashton: Yeah, that's correct. so why don't doesn't japan get into the process of the first official sip of alcohol a japanese person drinks is a glass of sake yeah yeah not beer not wine not cocktail a glass of sake it could be sparkling sake it could It could be a mission. It could be anything. Yeah. But to maintain that connection between the youth of Japan and sake is important because it's been lost. So why can't we say, and I've spoken to a few politicians about this, and I took the opportunity to speak to the governor when I was in Saito and a few other politicians there, saying, I think we need to push this.
51:54So next Adults Day, which will be next February, I think it is. Is it February? I think it's February. I think it's actually called Coming of Age Day, right? It's Coming of Age Day. That's it. Now, I'm not so naive to think that that's going to be the first time they ever drink alcohol. All right. But their official Coming of Age Day drink should be a glass of sake. okay because what we need to do throughout all of this throughout all of the the 20 years of the iwc the world has woken up to sake and more people are buying sake around the world than ever before but in japan it's not it's not it's declining so we need to stop that decline and we need to get the youth of japan engaged with sake to understand what they've got because when it's gone just to
52:44Chris Ashton: give some context it's it's declined by a third in the last uh 10 years so so we need to engage the japanese people with sake again it's not an old man's drink because i think that's what it's been yeah well that yeah that's the that's the reputation that it kind of developed for itself but it's not it's just wonderful beverage and and sometimes you don't miss something until it's gone You know, our direction for the last 20 years has been about increasing exports. Yeah. And we'll continue to do that. We'll continue to do that. But I've now got a personal mission that I wanted to start developing this in Japan and get people more engaged with sake in Japan, especially the younger element.
53:37Kenji's brilliant. He's a lovely guy. He's a really lovely man. And I think him, with his fame, is a great ambassador for Sarkit. And I think what we need to do is to use that as best we can to engage more
53:55Chris Ashton: and get the politicians involved because, you know, I think that's what we need. That's great. That's what we need without a doubt. The domestic consumption here is really, really on its last legs in many respects, you know. So we definitely need that. Does that mean that IWC in Japan is going to be going to try to make that a regular fixture? Well, I'm hoping to do it every two years. Yeah. We've changed our model to be able to do it. And we've changed the, you know, if we can do it once in London or wherever it may be, we may travel more. I'm changing the IWC as well. Fine. We're not just doing that in London anymore.
54:38We're going around the world with it. So the IWC for the first time in its 42 years, we're going to be holding one in the Americas. So for North and South America, that's going to be in Mendoza in November. And then we're doing one for Asia Pacific, which is Australia, New Zealand, South Africa as well, put them in, China and Japan. So that's all in one. And that's going to be in December of this year. That's going to be in Adelaide. And then we're going to do IWC Europe, that's going to be Montpellier because it's very close to Italy and Spain yeah and then we're going to do one in the UK and then Sake will be in the UK again next year but by doing that we are taking the competition to those places because the cost of shipping stuff around the world now is just absolutely crazy it's not going to get any cheaper for a long time and if we can push domestic market sales it's better for the wineries it's better for the breweries because export's expensive exporting products are expensive there's taxes and duties and all this stuff to pay on it goes on to the you know the cost of sake in the UK is probably more than double what it is in Japan because of all the extra costs right but sadly the brewer doesn't see one penny of that no it's all brought up in it's all taken up in cost so if the sake brewer does a really simple process if the sake brewer could sell more domestically he'll make more money that doesn't negate the international market which is important for every product especially sake and we'll continue to push that but I think if we can get them selling more internally to a new market of everybody under 30 for example it's going to be hard it's not a 5 minute job You know, I've got two sons, they're 25 and 23.
56:38And my eldest son does drink, but not very much. He prefers to go to the gym, you know, and my youngest son doesn't drink every day. You know, he drinks on the weekend. He goes out and has parties. You know, he's in Melbourne at the moment. And so he works all week, doesn't drink at all during the week, goes to the gym, plays golf. But that's the usual stuff today. Why I'll be in the pub every night.
57:03Chris Ashton: Well, more healthy in many ways, isn't it? More healthy, looking after themselves better than we did, maybe. Yeah, yeah. But, I mean, you know, I used to be, well, I played rugby when I was a kid. So, you know, we were in the pub for like four days a week, five days a week, you know, just after training, beers, you know, after rubbing beers, you know. Always, you know, drinking was part of the culture. My grandfather's culture and our grandfather's culture was when you went to work, you went to the pub after work. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. you'd take four or five pints before you went home the doors crowd and that's gone so it's just really just the experiences of the UK because we've lost so much craft product in the UK over the last 50 years it's been unbelievable and losing that we can see now you can see you've lost whole generations of of craftspeople that are no longer there are gone they're absolutely gone and that's a loss to us that's lost to our heritage and and um uh hopefully we can pass on we can pass that on to on to japan before it's too late absolutely right you've given a lot of a lot of your time chris we really appreciate it cannot stress that enough is there one last sort of message that you have for our listeners um about anything all i would all i would say to everyone is try something new try something new today you know go down to your local sake brewer and buy something you haven't bought before and try it you know and if you're outside japan you know go to your local sake importer or your shop and buy a bottle of something you haven't tried before just diversify try something different spend a little bit more money, try something different that you haven't had.
58:59It will enhance your life.
59:01Chris Ashton: There you go. Sage advice from Chris Ashton, managing director and owner of the International Wine Challenge. Thank you so much for coming on to the show and speaking to us, Chris. Really appreciate it. And we'll be following the journey of the International Wine Challenge for another 20 and many more years to come. It's been great talking to you. And Cindy, thank you for helping me on with this interview as well. Yeah, chipping in a little bit. And we'll let you get off and do your packing, Chris. It's not going to pack itself. Cheers, guys. Thank you for talking to me. It's about like 10 minutes, so thank you.
59:42Thank you. Good luck. Speak to you soon.
59:44Chris Ashton: Have a safe journey back to the UK. Will do. Cheers, guys. Thank you. Thank you. Bye-bye. Bye. I'll send you a picture. Bye-bye. Bye. What an amazing interview that was. We've been wanting to get Chris on for a while now, and he didn't disappoint. As always, when we get guests like Chris on, we learn so much. And as always, thank you so much for listening until the end. It's you, the listeners, that make Sekyone Air what it is. We wouldn't exist without you. So thank you very much for listening to the show. we'll be back with more Saki On Air very soon until the next time Kampai!
As sake continues to expand beyond its home borders and evolve into a global beverage, the rules of evaluation are being rewritten. While Japan’s competitions are mainly concerned with technical purity, competitions overseas are flipping the script with a more consumer-focused approach. One of the biggest of these is the International Wine Challenge held in London. Having already built up a solid reputation as one of the world’s foremost, influential wine competitions, in 2007 a sake category was added.
In this episode, we sit down with Chris Ashton, the owner and managing director behind this massive UK-based competition. As well as exploring Chris’s personal story with sake, we learn more about how the competition judges sake in this new era, what a consumer-focused lens reveals about modern sake trends, and how an event thousands of miles from Japan is helping shape the future of the industry.
This year’s competition was particularly special, as it marked the 20th anniversary and was held in Hiroshima, Japan. As well as Rebekah, who is a regular judge, Chris and Cindy were both very lucky to take part, either as judges or in the media.
As always, if you have questions or comments, please do share them with us at [email protected] or send us a message on our Instagram, Facebook, or Substack!
We’ll be back very soon with plenty more Sake On Air.
Until then, kampai!
Sake On Air is made possible with the generous support of the Japan Sake & Shochu Makers Association and is broadcast from the Japan Sake & Shochu Information Center in Tokyo. Sake on Air was created by Potts K Productions and is produced by Export Japan. Our theme, “Younger Today Than Tomorrow,” was composed by forSomethingNew for Sake On Air.