Why Your Body Needs Gravity

13 Sep 2026 · 43 min · 15 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The episode explains gravity’s role in human physiology using Einstein’s twin paradox, then the real “twin study” of Scott and Mark Kelly on the ISS, showing that microgravity affects aging, eyes, bones, blood, circadian rhythms, and gene expression. It also discusses telomeres: they lengthen in space (via ALT) but shorten after return, implying deep biological aging despite less visible aging.

Guests (people mentioned)

No co-host guests; the hosts are Hannah Fry (host) and Michael Stevens (host/guest in-studio). Astronauts discussed: Scott Kelly (ISS astronaut, twin) and Mark Kelly (Earth-based twin; also a U.S. senator). Also mentioned: astronaut Don Pettit.

Key claims

ISS time dilation is tiny (milliseconds over ~340 days) but microgravity causes major bodily changes; astronauts can develop vision impairment (e.g., John Phillips); bone loss is severe and can persist; circadian rhythm drifts without cues; gene expression changes largely reverse but ~10% linger, possibly due to radiation; telomeres lengthen in extreme environments (ISS/Everest) via ALT, then collapse after return.

Notable examples

2015 “vomit comet” study on intracranial pressure; 2022 study showing shin bones look ~a decade older a year after; John Phillips vision dropping from 20/20 to 20/100; Everest twin telomere elongation; mouse sperm freeze-dried in space remaining viable.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

The Twin Paradox Setup

0:25 to 1:07

Discussing the story of two twin astronauts and the concept of time dilation.

“Okay, Michael, for today's episode, I want to tell you a story about two men.”

The Kelly Twins Experiment

3:06 to 7:37

Exploring the lives and experiments of Scott and Mark Kelly regarding space travel and aging.

“this is a real story oh i'm talking about the bald twins huh are they bald do you know what i I should know what they're like.”

Einstein's Twin Paradox Explained

7:37 to 14:00

Detailed explanation of the twin paradox and calculations involved in the experiment.

“All right, so let's kick off with what Einstein said about twins.”

Time Dilation and Twin Paradox

14:00 to 15:35

Explore the fascinating concept of time dilation and its effects on twins.

“Rather than it being a factor of two, which is what it was in the example I can view, they're aging twice as fast as you.”

Lorentz Factor and Speed of Light

17:58 to 19:29

Understand the Lorentz factor and how speed affects time experience.

“So is this graph of like time dilation, it's not linear.”

Effects of Space on the Human Body

19:38 to 23:01

Learn about the various physical and mental changes experienced by astronauts.

“Like no G-force on your body for a year.”

Challenges of Living in Space

23:02 to 26:53

Discover the challenges astronauts face regarding temperature and circadian rhythms.

“Your eyeball is harmed by this cerebrospinal fluid stuff because the optic nerve goes right into the brain.”

Psychological Effects of Time Isolation

26:53 to 28:00

Explore how isolation affects perception of time and psychological health.

“One that I really like was in the 60s, a 23 year old geologist got put into a cave and then just sort of left there.”

Isolation and Perception of Time

28:00 to 31:23

Learn about the psychological effects of isolation on time perception through personal anecdotes.

“Would you like to guess how long he thought he'd been down for?”

The Impact of Gravity on Bones

31:24 to 33:00

Discover how gravity affects bone density and astronaut health in space.

“Your set of time anchored to the planet.”
Show all 15 chapters

Blood Cell Decay in Microgravity

33:01 to 34:29

Understand how living in space affects blood cells and potential health risks.

“You can tell because every time a red blood cell dies, it releases one molecule of carbon monoxide.”

Gene Expression Changes in Space

34:30 to 36:15

Explore how gene expression is altered during space travel and its implications.

“So while your DNA is, it's like a recipe of how to make the whole of you as a human, the way that those genes are expressed changes in your whole body, changes all of the time, right?”

Telomeres: Lengthening and Aging

36:16 to 37:46

Learn about telomeres, their role in aging, and how space travel affects them.

“And that brings us then to the biggest change of all.”

The Dilemma of Space Aging

37:47 to 42:04

Delve into the paradox of aging in space versus on Earth and the implications for future space travel.

“You had me ready to buy my ticket to the moon.”

The Necessity of Reproduction in Space

42:04 to 43:17

Exploration of the need for reproductive methods in space to ensure human survival.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Welcome to The Rest is Science. I'm Hannah Fry. And her hair is ginger. Yes, it is. I haven't mentioned it. It doesn't really come up. I hadn't noticed, honestly. I'm very colorblind, you know, in that way. We're all people. What if you were colorblind and you just... I don't really know what the big deal is.

0:16Michael Stevens:I just don't even know. You're just a human to me. Just another human. Anyway, my name is Michael Stevens and this is The Rest is Science.

0:25Hannah Fry:Okay, Michael, for today's episode, I want to tell you a story about two men. They had the same face. They were twins. That's not that much of a mystery. One of them gets onto a rocket ship in Kazakhstan. The other one drives home to Arizona. Now, I know what you're thinking. Einstein talks about this. He said, take two twins, put one in the rocket ship, send them away from the earth. They'll come back. They'll be different ages. I want to talk to you, Michael, today about what actually happened when people actually tried it for real.

1:07Michael Stevens:This episode is brought to you by Cancer Research UK.

1:10Hannah Fry:As if they weren't cool enough already, some astronauts have now added cancer scientists to their CV. They are making use of microgravity conditions in space to carry out experiments. That's because the same thing

1:21Michael Stevens:that lets astronauts experience weightlessness also affects how cancer cells grow, behave and respond to drugs.

1:29Hannah Fry:And back down on Earth, Cancer Research UK is working with astronomers to explore tumors with technologies that are typically used to map the Milky Way, which I think gives you an idea of just how complex this disease is.

1:43Michael Stevens:That's right. There are over 200 different types of cancer, but by pushing boundaries and embracing the latest technologies, Cancer Research UK has helped double cancer survival in the UK over the past 50 years.

1:54Hannah Fry:And today it is continuing to save and improve lives around the world. For more information about Cancer Research UK, their research and breakthroughs, and how you can support them, visit cancerresearchuk.org. Queen Carvania stood haloed by the morning sun. An army hung on her every word. My champions, I have sold my chariot on Carvana. T 'was a lovely SUV, an inexplicably queenly offer. They're even coming to the castle to collect it. Tonight, we feast. An offer you can feast on. Sell your car today on Carvana. Pick up fees may apply. Sierra has all the best active and outdoor brands for the super athletic stuff.

2:40Like running gear for cruising up the trail. Woo! And the super athletic-ish stuff. Like fishing gear for chilling by the creek. Nice cast. Fitness apparel to push for higher reps. You got this. and golf balls priced so you can afford to lose one or a few head to sierra or sierra.com for the brands you want at the prices that let you do it all from athletic to athletic sierra's got it

3:05Hannah Fry:rest is science

3:14this is a real story oh i'm talking about the bald twins huh are they bald do you know what i I should know what they're like. I'm pretty sure they are. I know every bald man. They are bald. Aren't they lovely men? I can't remember their names. Kelly? Yeah, Scott and Mark Kelly, yeah.

3:33Michael Stevens:One of them is like a senator.

3:35Hannah Fry:Oh my God, that's Mark Kelly. Yeah, yeah. I cannot believe I've been researching this for like two days and I didn't put two and two together. Wait, were they both astronauts or just one of them? They were both astronauts.

3:49Michael Stevens:Mark was a retired astronaut. Mark has done a wonderful job of literally finding a way to be known for something besides the fact that you're an astronaut. Right. He comes up in the news all the time. And I'm like, he's an astronaut. I can't even mention that at this point. Can you imagine having a life like that where you're like, oh, yeah, I've been to space. But that's not even what they say about me most of the time.

4:11Hannah Fry:Not even the most interesting thing about me. I know. Wild. I cannot believe I didn't put two and two together because I follow American politics all the time. Like all the time. know all about Mark Kelly, genuinely was so interested in what happened in this experiment, it never even occurred to me to think that that name might ring a bell. Have you met any astronauts, by the way?

4:31Michael Stevens:Yeah, I have. Which one have you met? Don Pettit. Right. And I met him like twice. So technically two. Two.

4:39Hannah Fry:Because he's made up different atoms the second time I met him. I completely agree. You know, no man standing in a river is the same man. Different river, different man, right? Yeah, different astronaut. Different you as well. It was a different me. Have I even met anyone? This collection of atoms has not. Here's the thing. I think astronauts, they're as close to a superhuman species as we have. You know, I think if you filtered off just the astronauts, did an astronaut breeding program, you know, I think quite quickly they would diverge from the rest of us. They are so special, so smart. They're like the smartest people, incredibly fit, unbelievably brave, and also just really, really kind and decent.

5:24Michael Stevens:And there's a demeanor to them that I don't know if they always have that and they self-select for astronauthood or if they become that way as they become closer to astronauthood.

5:37Hannah Fry:I also wonder whether having to face your own mortality, which I think you have to do if you are going to do something that is really as, you know, I mean, you're taking your life and you're strapping yourself to what is essentially a bomb and blasting yourself out of the atmosphere of our planet.

5:57Michael Stevens:But not for the thrill of it. The guys who do that with Red Bull are very different. An astronaut has this sort of humility, this kind of service oriented personality. I'm here to serve this agency, the American people or the people of my country. It's very, it's very cool.

6:18Hannah Fry:It's really, really, really cool. And I think that this experiment of Scott and Mark Kelly demonstrates just how willing they are to give themselves over in the pursuit of knowledge and science. for all of humanity, not for just themselves. And astronauts are not perfect, by the way. Sure.

6:39Michael Stevens:I just want to say that because you can read some of their biographies and you'll be like, oh. But in terms of public persona, they are like a kind of person I've only met a few of in my life. Right. I find them so much more impressive than actors, than musicians. Than podcasters. Can you imagine looking up to us?

7:02Hannah Fry:I find them so much more impressive than basically anything else. Athletes can be really impressive. The sort of single minded pursuit of a goal, of an ambition, of like pushing the boundaries of what's humanly possible.

7:14Michael Stevens:And the natural talent to do what they do. And it's like, I will never do that. I will never win an Olympic gold medal. No, agree. I will also never go to the moon. No. I mean, I might be able to, but I will choose not to. So that what I just said will stay true. I mean, frankly, absolutely the same.

7:34Hannah Fry:Okay, shall I tell you about this experiment? Because it's genuinely fascinating. All right, so let's kick off with what Einstein said about twins. Okay. The twin paradox, is it? Classic. So he proposed this as a thought experiment in 1905. And what he said is, okay, so you've got two twins born on the same day on Earth. You pop one on a spaceship, send them off on a journey 10 light years away from Earth. But they're traveling at, this wasn't Einstein's numbers, but let's say 86.6 % of the speed of light. I thought it was a specific percent. It was specific, wasn't it? Yeah. Now, the reason why I chose that number is because at that speed.

8:09Michael Stevens:88.6 % the speed of light. 86.6. 86.6. Got it. Okay.

8:13Hannah Fry:Yeah. Okay. I can see you're going to do the calculations in your head, Michael.

8:16Michael Stevens:No, I'm not. I just want to remember because there's a cool fact about it you're about to tell me. There is. I don't want to forget it. Okay. You ready? 86.6 % the speed of light is special because? It's special because it means that time on Earth will travel faster than the speed on the spaceship by a factor of two. Double. Okay, perfect. All right. So at that speed, I'm traveling at that speed. My stationary twin on Earth is going to be aging twice as fast.

8:46Hannah Fry:Correct. Right. So if you go off your pop, right, accelerate away, 10 light years away, turn around, come back. By the time you come back, it's going to have taken you 11 and a half years. They're twice as old as me now, even though we were born on the same day.

9:01Michael Stevens:And it took me 11 and a half years to go 10 light years. Correct. But then I have to come back. Yeah. Why did it only take me 11 and a half years? Shouldn't it take me 10 years to go at light speed? So in total, the distance that you've traveled is 20 light years. OK, yeah, because you went 10 light years away and back.

9:20Hannah Fry:Correct. However, you're going at 86.6 % the speed of light. So that's where you get the 23 from. That's how long it took, according to your twin on Earth. Yeah, your twin on Earth is like, right, off you go. Distance and time, it's very simple. Speed is distance over time. I know your speed, 86.6 % the speed of light. I know the distance, 10 light years. I'll see you in 23 years. See you in 23 years. But for you, who's traveling so quickly,

9:46Michael Stevens:how long has elapsed according to your watch? 11 and a half years. Just half as long. Half the time.

9:53Hannah Fry:Wow. And you come back and you're like looking in your twin's face and you're seeing your future, essentially. You are seeing what lies ahead of you in your body. Eleven and a half years from now. Exactly. You say, I will look like that.

10:06Michael Stevens:Right. Bummer. Bummer. And your old twin is like, oh. Or maybe great. Or maybe great. Probably great. Probably great. With the way twins are, you know. Yeah. and your earthbound uh twin is looking at you going oh 11 and a half years ago i had that appearance so fresh-faced more or less i mean things can happen maybe maybe you you know decided to grow a beard and your twin didn't i don't know there could be some differences but the point is maybe your twin on earth really took up smoking and drinking heavily can i ask you another question go ahead so okay you're on the ship and the whole trip the 20 light year round trip only took 11 and a half years for you.

10:48Michael Stevens:Yes. Is it confusing to be like, wait a second, I just traveled 10 light years from Earth. I wasn't even going at light speed 100%. Right. But I still I got there in like, what, five and three quarters of a year. If you asked a photon who just traveled 100 light years, how long did that take? They'd be like, it was instant.

11:08Hannah Fry:Yes.

11:09Michael Stevens:So it's fine. This must not be a problem.

11:11Hannah Fry:Yes, because the distance itself is effectively length contracted, isn't it?

11:15Michael Stevens:Oh, that's it. Yeah. Like the photon, when it leaves a star and it lands in your eye a billion years later to the photon, your eye was right next to the sun. It just comes out into your eye. Hi. If it was conscious, that's what it experienced.

Read the full transcript

11:29Hannah Fry:Yeah, because this is the whole point about space time, right? That space time is only according to your particular perspective. So that whole like speed is distance over time calculation only works when you're standing on Earth and it's like, all right. It's a good approximation.

11:44Michael Stevens:Okay, not to be the Newton flag bearer guy, but like most of the time I can go ahead and assume that the universe has depth. Yes. And it works. And it works. I'm able to sink my baskets. Yeah. Because I'm really good at basketball. Yeah. It's just a humble bragging. You can reach out for a handshake and expect the person's hand to be where you thought it would be. It is where I want it to be. And it's not like, whoa, my hand moved so quickly. My hand is like so much younger than me now. Suddenly the distances and the time.

12:10Hannah Fry:Anyway, anyway. Right. Here's the point about the Einstein thing. It's like once you get up to really fast speeds, once you're traveling long distances close to the speed of light, everything goes a bit woo-woo. Right. Everything goes a bit strange. All is dilated. It's all problematic. Your twin on earth is older than you. That's the key point I want you to remember. It's bizarre. OK, so NASA being NASA, we're like, guys, we can sort of try this. Why don't we just give this a go? We've got Mark and Scott Kelly. Let's just pop one of them in a spaceship, see what happens. Tiny problem, small, is that unfortunately getting a spaceship up to towards the speed of light and traveling 10 light years away.

12:53It's just it's just beyond their capabilities. Right.

12:56Michael Stevens:An appreciable amount of the speed of light not going to be reached anytime soon by any space agency.

13:02Hannah Fry:So they went for the next best thing, which is they put Scott on the ISS for a year almost. OK. All right.

13:10Michael Stevens:And how fast does the ISS go as a percentage of the speed of light?

13:14Hannah Fry:OK, so it orbits as well, it orbits at about 7.66 kilometers a second. I mean, that's fast. That's fast. That's fast. That's not light speed. fast it's not like speed fast it's about 0.00256 percent of the speed flight that's fewer knots

13:30Michael Stevens:than i expected yeah just two zero zero two wow okay so i mean that's small but i was expecting

13:41Hannah Fry:like 12 zeros right okay but the iss is fast look seven kilometers a second are you kidding me that's super fast you blink your eyes and you're traveled across london wow you're not quite half of london All right. Blink your eyes slowly. So NASA did this twin experiment in real life. They did. Here's the thing about it. Rather than it being a factor of two, which is what it was in the example I can view, they're aging twice as fast as you. Instead, one twin will be aging 1.0000000000003275 times faster than the other. There's all the zeros I was expecting. it's about 3.3 parts per 10 billion basically that's um that's how much faster okay say that

14:26Michael Stevens:again three parts per 10 billion yeah okay so for every 10 billion seconds yeah your twin on earth lives you only live 9 billion 999 997 exactly that's exactly that's still pretty cool it's

14:46Hannah Fry:pretty cool once you put it all in once you do all your calculations over 340 days which is how long scott kelly was was in the iss for in total one twin is between five and eight milliseconds older than his brother five milliseconds what can even happen in five milliseconds i mean not much not much if you want to pump it up there you can if you if you went up there for like three years Right. If you wanted to get a second on your brother, you just need to do a simple 110 years in orbit. Aye yi yi. We got to get those numbers up, NASA. You know what, Dave? You would come back and be like, wow, that's what I'm going to look like when I started this sentence.

15:29Hannah Fry:Yeah, right. My gosh. I'll tell you what, let's have a break and I'll do more when we come back. Excellent.

15:48Hannah Fry:This episode is brought to you by Cancer Research UK.

15:50Michael Stevens:Think of some things that glow. Okay, fireflies, glow sticks, the northern lights. They're very cool. But what if we could replicate that glow inside our bodies? And what if doing so could help us save lives? Because Cancer Research UK scientists,

16:06Hannah Fry:they're investigating whether a special fluorescent dye that sticks to prostate cancer cells could tackle an ongoing challenge in the operating room, removing every single trace of cancer.

16:17Michael Stevens:Because when cancer cells are glowing and easy to spot, surgeons can precisely remove them, leaving healthy cells untouched, meaning there's less chance of the cancer returning and fewer nasty side effects. Cancer Research UK's vision is a world where everybody lives longer, better lives free from the fear of cancer, with breakthroughs like this leading to kinder, more effective treatments.

16:41Hannah Fry:For more information about Cancer Research UK, their research and breakthroughs and how you can support them, visit cancerresearchuk.org slash rest is science. Sierra has all the best active and outdoor brands for the super athletic stuff, like running gear for cruising up the trail. Woo! And the super athletic-ish stuff, like fishing gear for chilling by the creek. Nice cast. Fitness apparel to push for higher reps. You got this. and golf balls priced so you can afford to lose one. Or a few. Head to Sierra or Sierra.com for the brands you want at the prices that let you do it all. From athletic to athletic-ish, Sierra's got it.

17:21When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications, and more. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. That's indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

17:58Michael Stevens:All right, we're back. So is this graph of like time dilation, it's not linear. Correct. So if you go half the speed of light, you're not halfway to not experiencing time at all. Correct. It's probably the graph's probably like that or something. Yeah, it's called the Lorentz factor. The Lorentz factor. That graph is probably shaped where it's like, oh, if you're going 0.002 % the speed of light, basically no change. But once you get up to like 80 % or beyond, then it's just like, whoa, now you're going to notice it.

18:30Hannah Fry:And then it flattens off as you go further on. Yes, you're basically at one, you're a factor of one, essentially, up until about half the speed of light, that's when it starts picking up.

18:42Michael Stevens:Really?

18:43Hannah Fry:Once you get up to 0.8, 0.9, that's when you're doubling, right? Right. So you traveling that fast are aging half as quickly as someone who's stationary. Correct. That's when your factor is two. But, you know, you get really close to the speed of light. You can have 10, a factor of 10. I mean, you can have any number you like. you get super duper duper close yeah you could you could be like 100 if you want right i just i just spend just a year up there and i'll come back and be like oh no everyone you love would be dead dead yeah yeah maybe don't do that but that's the theory anyway that's like einstein's theory of how one would age compared to the other but nasa aren't stupid right they sort of knew that they wouldn't be able to go fast enough yeah actually measure the difference of five milliseconds But what they did do, and the reason why they did this twin study, was to look at the impact of physically being in space.

19:38Hannah Fry:Not just because of general relativity.

19:40Michael Stevens:But all the other things. All of the other things. That have much bigger effects. Right. Like no G-force on your body for a year. Right. Between the two brothers. Probably more radiation. Right.

19:51Hannah Fry:And let me tell you, Michael, the effects of being in space are mental. Right. completely insane all right tell me what happened okay so one of the big things um one of the astronauts i got to meet he is not allowed to be in space anymore because being in space has changed the physical shape of his eye because of the way that the pressure changes so on the iss they have to have loads of spare pairs of glasses oh up there floating around your prescription changes

20:25Michael Stevens:Why do your eyeballs change? Because surely the air pressure inside can be made similar to Earth's.

20:33Hannah Fry:Right. It's not just about pressure, though. I mean, so your optic nerve swells. You get all these folds that appear. You get it's sort of like wet wallpaper, basically.

20:43Michael Stevens:Yes, because there wouldn't be gravity keeping the blood away from your eyes. The blood just is like, I'm going to be here. So, I mean, the whole shape of it changes.

20:52Hannah Fry:Yeah. And then and permanently so in some cases. There are some astronauts. There's one guy called John Phillips who went up, had 20-20 vision when he went up. And then when he came back, it was 20 out of 100. I don't know loads about how those numbers work, but I think that's not good.

21:06Michael Stevens:That means that what a person with normal vision can see from 100 feet away. Right. He'd have to be 20 feet away to see. OK. Yeah. Which is, I would say, bad. Which is worse than 20-20.

21:18Hannah Fry:So there were all these theories about why, what is it, what's going on? And I mean, something's definitely increasing the pressure on astronauts' eyes. But what is it? Is it to do with lymphatic fluid that's moving around in microgravity? And NASA calculated that the equivalent of two large plastic bottles of Coke shifts from your legs when you're in space towards your head. Wow. You've got a lot of fluid. I mean, that's sort of why they look a little bit like they're being choked.

21:49Michael Stevens:That's one of the main reasons I wouldn't want to go up. I think that if my face got all puffy and it was all congested, I would just feel so grumpy. They wouldn't invite me back anyway.

21:59Hannah Fry:No, I mean, you wouldn't do 340 days up there, would you? The thing is, is that they did a study into this in 2015. And they were looking specifically at people on the Vomit Comet to work out how much pressure was in their heads in that moment. And they were actually surprised to find out that intracranial pressure, right, intracranial, so inside, actually dropped during the periods of lower gravity. Okay. so the the current theory about why is all of the stuff going on in your eye so even though your face is getting puffy and your lymph is up in your face it's inside your head you're actually okay okay so the current theory is that it's your uh cerebrospinal fluid oh that is floating around this is the stuff that helps to cushion your brain yeah by the way and when you are not in in an upright position when you don't have gravity assisting you, that pressure is like all over the place and your eye ends up changing as a direct result of it.

23:00Hannah Fry:Jeez. Not good, is it? Why does your face change? Because of the lymph. Because of the lymphatic fluid.

23:07Michael Stevens:Your eyeball is harmed by this cerebrospinal fluid stuff because the optic nerve goes right into the brain. Exactly. So you're like, wow. Yeah, not good.

23:16Hannah Fry:there's more you're going to tell oh there's oh there's more not everybody is affected in the same way with their eyes it affects some people worse than others but we're talking we're talking the whole of the body is essentially like really not happy when it goes into space i can see that this

23:31Michael Stevens:would be a big challenge for long space flights very definitely we've got to come up with some artificial gravity yes maybe some more stuff you tell me what else goes wrong because this is the

23:41Hannah Fry:thing you just don't expect that gravity would make that much of a difference but it turns out that that the earth is the reason why our bodies function in the way that we do we are we are of

23:53Michael Stevens:this planet right we really are we really are this is our womb and our crib and our world and our grave and we think oh it would be so cool to have no gravity around and then our bodies tell us actually this is what i was built for what are you doing okay so let me give you some

24:13Hannah Fry:examples about the ways in which our body is built for this body temperature is so much harder to control when you're in space is it really than it is when you're on earth because if you're on earth right you lose most of your your body heat through through convection you've got air that's moving around you you've got cooler air you've got that sort of movement turning on a fan on a hot day all of that kind of thing. But on the ISS, there's no convection. Right. Because there's no buoyancy.

24:41Michael Stevens:Warm air doesn't rise. Warm air stays kind of around as an envelope around your body.

24:47Hannah Fry:So sweat sticks to your skin as well. And astronauts' temperatures when they're up in space rises by about one degree C. You're constantly hot and puffy. Yeah. And you can't see. Hot and puffy. A fan would help. A fan would help. agree because then you're mechanically moving the air humans have sort of outsourced a lot of our thermoregulation to the planet which i think is a kind of crazy idea there's also our circadian rhythm our sense of time our sort of concept of days and nights just goes completely all over the place when you're up in space because because that again is tied to the orbit of our planet around the sun right and the rotation of our planet um on its own axis so there have been lots of studies

25:35Michael Stevens:into this okay in the iss they can control their lights but they've got what 17 sunrises and sunsets a day so you have to just rely on the artificial lighting in the iss for night and day you do i want to write this down or a couple of things down because i i'm obsessed with the ways in which we offload our mind to calendars and computers and notifications and alarms. But you're right. Even before technology, our bodies were offloading functions to physics in general. Right. I need to dump heat. Luckily, convection exists. Thank you very much. I need to not have my eyeballs get all fricked up.

26:20Michael Stevens:Luckily, gravity will keep those fluids at bay that's the closest i've ever heard you get to swearing i can't believe that if my mom hears that i said fricked i said it again i'm gonna have to go to space

26:36Hannah Fry:just to get away but also this idea of like when to rest you know our bodies automatically know when to rest and that is something else that we have completely outsourced to the planet we have in the form of our circadian rhythms and daylight being the the primary driver of it There have been much longer, older studies into this about how messed up we get about the passage of time when we don't have those cues. One that I really like was in the 60s, a 23 year old geologist got put into a cave and then just sort of left there. This is in the Ligurian Alps, about 130 metres down. I would say not a nice place to spend some time.

27:19Hannah Fry:So it's like it depends on how introverted you are.

27:24Michael Stevens:Not really. No, it depends on how much you treasure your sanity. Yeah. Yeah.

27:28Hannah Fry:It sends you completely wild. So there's a one way phone line. He could call up and the team would not call down, but they were instructed to never mention the time or the date whenever he called them. And every time he woke or he ate or he prepared to sleep, he would ring them so they could log it. So they had a little clock that he wasn't allowed to see. And he just had the freedom to eat when he was hungry and sleep when he was tired and so on. Anyway, when he eventually came out, he had been down for 63 days. Would you like to guess how long he thought he'd been down for?

28:05Michael Stevens:Yeah. Hold on. My guess is that he thought he'd been down for, gosh, I don't even know, longer or shorter. i i'm gonna say he thought he'd been down for 90 days right which would have been my guess as well

28:19Hannah Fry:i would have i would have assumed that it was torture and that it just felt like time had stretched in the sense of psychologically actually he thought he'd only been down for 35 days whoa right half as long yes i mean it's the factor of two again it's the same as if you send your twin in a spaceship but except you haven't actually aged for real which i think is wild But basically what happened is his circadian rhythm stretched a little bit day by day by day by day. Right. Until he was living not 24 hour days, but sort of 30, 40 hour days and just not even realizing that that was what was happening.

28:55Hannah Fry:Wow. But the same thing, if you're not careful, without the like cues, without sort of the sense of time and like cues, you just cannot keep track of time. I mean, I think clocks sort of help this as well. As you say, you sort of outsource this to a clock.

29:09Michael Stevens:Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So if we lived in like this room with no natural light, but we had a clock, we could still say, oh, I think it's bedtime now. But I spent three days in an isolation room with no clocks. And the lights were on, weren't they? And the lights would never go off. Oh, and no meals were delivered because I didn't want to ever get any clue. So all the food was there with me. and I didn't ring anyone up because I was afraid that even if I rang up to be like, oh, hey, I've decided to go to sleep, that I could tell what time it was based on how groggy the person sounded. If it was like the main producer answering, it's the middle of the day.

29:43Michael Stevens:If it was some younger production assistant, I'd be like, it's the middle of the night, okay. And I had them surround the whole chamber with loud fans because I didn't want to be able to hear, that sounds like someone who's doing some maintenance work that wouldn't be happening at night. It's not night. So but I got immediately confused by the next day. I thought it had been two days or something. But that was only a three day isolation. So you thought it was longer? Yes. I thought, OK, it's definitely Sunday by now. And then down on screen, they're like, it's Friday at 11 p.m. Like I was just way off.

30:21Michael Stevens:I would take little naps and wake up and think, oh, man, it's been a whole night. But I couldn't turn the lights out. Did you have an eye mask? No, no. But I used like the pillows and the bedding. And I had a little there were cameras in there the whole time, too. So I had like a kind of a private ish toilet. But I just meditated. I didn't have I started playing with my sock. And I said, no, this is about nothing coming into my brain. And it felt like it whizzed by looking back. At the time, though? At the time, it felt like, is this ever going to end? Are they going to leave me in here? But I have no memories from it because nothing happened.

31:05Hannah Fry:Yeah. Oh, my gosh. I can't. I would worry that I would permanently psychologically damage myself in that situation. You are much braver. I hoped I would.

31:13Michael Stevens:The opposite of worry. But I'm fine, as it turns out.

31:18Hannah Fry:As it turns out, we think. Still too early to tell.

31:23Michael Stevens:Is it? Is it? All right. So circadian rhythms. Yeah. Your set of time anchored to the planet.

31:29Hannah Fry:Your bones also, by the way, another thing, extremely anchored to gravity. And what's happening is astronauts, they're losing bone at this unbelievable rate. They just don't need it. They just don't need it because you shouldn't think of your bones as though there's this storage unit. You should instead think of it as almost like a bank, right? Sort of like making deposits and withdrawals all the time. And when you stop requiring these withdrawals, it just sort of decays away, right? Just stops like remaking itself. The thing is, is that the way that your skeleton exits your body, do you know this?

32:06Michael Stevens:No.

32:06Hannah Fry:You essentially urinate it out. Oh, really? So it's put into the liquid waste. Yes, you're pissing out your own bones.

32:16Michael Stevens:That sounds kind of fun, actually. Not going to lie.

32:20Hannah Fry:But kidney stones are a really big problem in space because that's essentially one of the things, right? As you are urinating your bones away, they collect in the kidneys. Exactly, they're crystallizing in your kidneys. And the thing is, once you get back to Earth, you're still in trouble from all of this. So there was one study in 2022 which looked at astronauts a year after they'd been in space. And if they had been for six month missions, they still hadn't recovered a year after. Essentially their shin bones looked a decade older than they would have been had they stayed on Earth. We need that gravity.

32:59Hannah Fry:We need that gravity. Blood also, by the way, you are breathing out your dead blood cells as you're in space. You can tell because every time a red blood cell dies, it releases one molecule of carbon monoxide. Oh. And so you can tell how much blood is decaying in somebody by giving them a breathalyzer, essentially, by testing. More CO2 in their breath. Right. More blood cells die. And space anemia is a really well-documented thing that people are losing blood cells in space at a rate of one and a half times what you would be getting on Earth. Wow. One and a half times. Right. It's a lot. isn't it?

33:36Hannah Fry:So you're urinating out your skeleton, you're breathing out your blood, you can't see anything unless you've got the glasses that they've got on the ISS. You can't really sleep. You can't really sleep. You're hot. It's hot and you're sweaty, but your sweat's not going anywhere and your face is all puffy. I mean, this is like, frankly, doesn't sound that great, does it?

33:56Michael Stevens:No.

33:56Hannah Fry:One good thing is your DNA is all right. You're okay. Your DNA is okay. And we know this because there was an experiment where they took some mouse sperm, freeze dried it, popped it up to the ISS, left it there, you know, just sitting in storage for a little while, brought it back down to earth. Thawed it. Thawed it, used it for IVF, put it in a mouse. Absolutely, totally fine. Happy mouse babies. Congratulations. Grandchildren, mouse babies. Absolutely fine. Your DNA, fine. If it's in a sperm cell, no big deal. Happy. Okay. In your body, however, slightly different story. So while your DNA is, it's like a recipe of how to make the whole of you as a human, the way that those genes are expressed changes in your whole body, changes all of the time, right?

34:45Hannah Fry:When you sort of, I don't know, do a lot of exercise or even going back to the bone thing, right? When you're under gravity, there'll be certain expressions that are dominant over others. When they did the testing during the twin study, when they were testing Scott's genes in space and then Mark's genes on Earth, so they described it as like a set of fireworks going off in Scott's body. Scott was the one in the ISS. You would definitely expect to see some of these changes if you take a human and you put them in a really stressful situation. There's like lots of changes that the body is adapting to.

35:20Hannah Fry:But what was really interesting was just the sort of the scale of the magnitude and the speed of this. But also that when he was brought back down to Earth, about 90 % of these changes reversed, but 10 % of them lingered. They didn't go back. They didn't go back. The suggestion for why this might be the case is that he's exposed to so much more radiation than his brother was. and this matters because these systems are things that are involved with immune function with dna repair with like you know inflammation with oxidative stress with like bone formation all

35:57Michael Stevens:of this stuff and this was primarily they think because of radiation damage potentially right

36:03Hannah Fry:because the thing is is that mark kelly who was on earth his gene expression has changed too but because he'd lived a year sure so he also had this giant atmosphere uh protecting him right Right. From radiation. Right. Which is brother up in space, more exposed, much more exposed. And that brings us then to the biggest change of all. Oh, everything is like, OK, yeah, sure. You put your face is puffy or whatever. Your bones are pissing out your bones. Big deal. Big deal. Who cares? I call that Tuesday. But this one is like really dramatic. Do you know what a telomere is? Yeah, it's like the end of the DNA.

36:42Exactly.

36:43Hannah Fry:It's sort of, it's best described as the cap on the end of a shoelace. Okay, yeah. That protects it. When DNA is replicating itself, you know, when cells are dividing and replicating themselves, this thing gets shorter and shorter and shorter over time. And it's actually a really good way to assess how old somebody is. So their epigenetic age, as it were, as opposed to their chronological age. Right. You want long telomeres. Got it, yeah. You want nice and long. It means you're nice and young. You've got plenty more replications to go before you lose more and more of that shoelace. When Scott Kelly was in orbit, his telomeres got longer.

37:18Michael Stevens:Right? I was just going to ask, what can I do to lengthen my telomeres? Are there any like snake oil salesmen selling, you know, telomere lengthening cream? Yeah. NASA. Go to space and it's NASA. Whoa. NASA. So, okay. Do we have any ideas why?

37:36Hannah Fry:Why that's going on? Wow. Okay. I should also add, it sounds really good while you're in space. You've got nice long telomeres. Isn't that lovely? Kind of makes up for all of the other horrible stuff. When he came back down to Earth, the length of his telomeres collapsed and were then shorter than they would have been before.

37:54Michael Stevens:What a rug pull. What a rug pull. You had me ready to buy my ticket to the moon. Because this is it.

38:00Hannah Fry:Then it's like Einstein was right. You live longer when you go into space. As long as you don't come home. Oh. Ooh, I like that. I should say, it wasn't like all of them were suddenly way short, but he had an increased number of critically short two minutes. It sounds painful. It sounds critical, frankly. It does sound critical. It sounds bad. It sounds bad. Okay, so the question as to why this might be the case, there's another twin study where they took two pairs of twins and they took them to Everest. Two of the twins, right, from different families, went up the mountain. their brothers stayed down the bottom of the mountain and they did the same thing they were like doing all of this testing on them they had to like draw blood from them while they're at the top of the mountain which i think was apparently quite dramatic i bet yeah um anyway they saw the same thing that the telomeres elongated when they were at the top of the mountain the same thing as you get if you're on board the iss which is like a really strange thing but once again once they came down it didn't end well right so the suggestion as to why this might be the case There's only two ways that the human body can lengthen their telomeres.

39:09Hannah Fry:One, when you're born, there's this thing called telomerase. It's an enzyme that you find in embryos. You also find it in stem cells. I mean, it does exist, but just not in the normal run of things in the adult body. The other way that you can lengthen your telomeres is something called ALT, which is alternative lengthening of telomeres. And this isn't rebuilding. It's more that it's using a sort of DNA trick. It's like copying the sequence from another chromosome. it's extremely rare and you really only see it in certain types of cancer cells oh so why would that be happening to people in space and at the top of everest like who honestly who knows sort of seems as though what is happening is this ability for your cells to lengthen their telomeres is switched off but kind of remained dormant unless you push that human into a really extreme environment.

40:06At which point your body sort of starts acting like it's cancer cells. Or it starts acting like it's being born again.

40:14Hannah Fry:Like it's being, well, although it's a different, it's a different mechanism. It's a different mechanism.

40:18Michael Stevens:It's alt, not telomerase.

40:19Hannah Fry:That's a really important point. In both the Everest and the twin study when they were in Scott and Mark Kelly, it was the alt mechanism, not the young, cute little baby one that you get in embryos.

40:33Michael Stevens:Bummer for them.

40:34Hannah Fry:Bummer for them. This raises this really interesting question, because it means that we know that humans can lengthen their own telomeres. And this is like a very important thing if you're talking about lengthening people's lives. It's been demonstrated that you can force people into a situation where their telomeres lengthen. You also then, everybody ended up worse off, right? As soon as they had this happen to them, they ended up worse off. But going back to Einstein's idea of who ends up being older, the one on the spaceship or the one on Earth, this telomene thing, while you're in space, you maybe have a longer lifespan, but get back.

41:11Hannah Fry:The one who went to space is worse off. It's the opposite way around to what Einstein said. So to them, less time has passed.

41:20Michael Stevens:They may have aged visibly on the surface less. but deep in their dna they might actually be older might actually be older right if you actually put them on the rocket ship that went away from 10 yeah so who would you rather be the twin on earth or the twin in space on earth thank you very much much rather stay on it you mentioned earlier

41:43Hannah Fry:how are we going to get people long distance space travel if all of this stuff is going on yeah maybe they just need to be born in space yep maybe they just need to not have the history of

41:55Michael Stevens:of gravity in their midst okay all right so right if we start delivering babies in space they will be prepared for it yeah i mean there has been a bit of delivering babies in space just not human not human yeah they've done like rat babies i think fish as well oh fish or in the case of the telomeres we maybe maybe the change we kind of like but coming back we don't i mean yeah i think the only solution to this is that we we do some pregnancy we've got to do a lot more reproduction

42:28Hannah Fry:in space we need we need a maternity ward in space yeah get on it guys um and we started this episode by saying that astronauts are willing to uh to give themselves over for the study of science i think a newborn astronaut let's not be on the realms of what humans can achieve the newborn can't consent to being an astronaut it's all right they're doing it for humanity

42:48Michael Stevens:we can thank them later we can thank them later we'll find a way to lengthen their telomeres back yeah it's okay so those of us on earth have a lot to be very very grateful for and we have a lot to be grateful for to those who go out into space for us because they're living through time differently and they're changing their DNA for us.

43:15Hannah Fry:Thank you, astronauts. And thank you, listeners.

43:18Michael Stevens:Yeah. Whereas we do this show for you. And we love doing it. So thanks for being with us today. Be sure to subscribe to us on YouTube or follow us on whatever platform you're using to watch or listen.

43:33Hannah Fry:And field notes later in the week. We'll see you then. Bye-bye. Bye.

44:07We'll see you next time.

44:18I didn't like what you said, Odin pauses, about the future.

44:24Michael Stevens:This is the love story of real hinge couple Odin and Edward, written and read by me, Curtis Garner. Listen to the free audiobook now.

From the publisher

Does space travel make astronauts younger?

Professor Hannah Fry and Michael Stevens explore Einstein’s twin paradox, time dilation and NASA’s famous Twins Study with astronauts Scott and Mark Kelly.

After Scott Kelly spent 340 days aboard the International Space Station, he returned milliseconds younger than his identical twin. But microgravity had also affected his eyesight, bones, blood, gut microbiome, body temperature, genes and telomeres.

So what exactly happens to the human body in space, and which changes remain after astronauts return to Earth?

In this episode, Hannah and Michael discover how deeply the human body depends on gravity. Along the way, they uncover why your head ages faster than your feet, what a 63 day cave experiment reveals about our sense of time, and whether future humans could ever truly adapt to life beyond Earth.

-------------------

For more information about Cancer Research UK, their research, breakthroughs and how you can support them, visit ⁠https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/our-research/rest-is-science

Cancer Research UK is a registered charity in England and Wales (1089464), Scotland (SC041666), the Isle of Man (1103) and Jersey (247). A company limited by guarantee. Registered company in England and Wales (4325234) and the Isle of Man (5713F). Registered address: 2 Redman Place, London, E20 1JQ.

-------------------

Find The Rest Is Science all over the internet by ⁠⁠clicking here.⁠⁠

-------------------

Video Producer: Teo Ayodeji-Ansell 

Animator: Sam Benson

Video & Social: Bex Tyrrell

Assistant Producer: Lucy Lipscombe

Producer: Simona Rata

Senior Producer: Lauren Armstrong-Carter

Chief Digital Officer: Samuel Oakley

Exec Producer: Neil Fearn
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Rest Is Science

All 92 episodes
Why Your Body Needs GravityThe Rest Is Science · 43 min
Listen in VO