In short
Podcast Notes: This Is TASTE - Episode 627: An Epic NYC Pizza Tour with Maurizio Leo. Plus, Anthony Falco’s Italian Pizza Adventures.
Episode Overview
- Hosts: Matt Rodbard & Aliza Abarbanel
- Guests: Maurizio Leo and Anthony Falco
- Main Themes: NYC pizza exploration, pizza styles, and culinary culture
Episode Description Matt invites Maurizio Leo, author of *The Perfect Loaf*, for a pizza tour across New York City. Together with producer Clayton Gumbert, they taste slices from seven renowned pizzerias: Joe's, L’industrie, Mama’s TOO!, Lucia, Upside, Scarr’s, and F&F. The episode also features a discussion with Anthony Falco, a global pizza consultant who shares insights from his recent trip to Italy and highlights contemporary trends in both pizza and trattoria culture.
---
Key Takeaways
Pizza Tour Insights
Pizzerias Visited
- Joe's Pizza
- Known for its classic New York slice.
- Discussed the balance of cheese and sauce, as well as the importance of crust texture.
- L’industrie
- Notable for their unique offerings, including a variety of toppings.
- Comparison of crust textures and flavors with Joe's.
- Mama’s TOO!
- Renowned for creative takes on pizza alongside traditional offerings.
- Heavy slices with a focus on texture.
- Lucia
- A newer establishment with a significant emphasis on dough flavor.
- The pizza was described as dense yet crispy.
- Upside
- Highlighted for its innovative toppings, including a corn and poblano pizza that resonated with both hosts.
- Discussed fermentation techniques and the flavor profile of the dough.
- Scarr’s
- Emphasis on using high-quality, milled flour.
- Discussion around the importance of dough quality in pizza making.
- F&F
- Praised for its Sicilian-style pizza, embodying a “less is more” philosophy.
- A focus on flavor development in crust and toppings.
Guest Insights
Anthony Falco
- Italian Pizza Trends: Falco shares insights from his trip to Italy, discussing various pizza styles and the cultural significance of trattorias and gelato.
- Art & Culinary Connection: Falco touches on the intersection of culinary arts and traditional Italian culture, including a recent focus on quality ingredients and craftsmanship.
Culinary Themes
- Quality of Ingredients: Importance of sourcing local and high-quality ingredients in both NYC and Italy.
- Culinary Heritage: Discussion on the preservation of traditional cooking methods and recipes in Italian cuisine.
- Pizza Culture: Reflections on the evolution of pizza in both America and Italy, highlighting the community and cultural significance of pizza as a global food.
---
Observations & Reflections
- Dough as a Foundation: A recurring theme is the significance of dough quality across various pizzerias, indicating that a well-made base is key to an excellent pizza.
- Cultural Influence: The episode delves into how pizza reflects local culture and traditions, with both hosts emphasizing experiences shared over food.
- Personal Experiences: The hosts share personal anecdotes about their pizza preferences, illustrating the emotional connections people often have with food.
---
Closing Thoughts The episode encapsulates a vibrant exploration of pizza, merging culinary expertise with cultural appreciation. Through lively discussions and firsthand tasting experiences, listeners gain insight into both the craftsmanship behind pizza-making and the rich tapestry of culinary culture it represents.
For more, visit [This Is TASTE](https://tastecooking.com) and check out previous episodes including *Pizza Week with Anthony Falco*.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:28This episode is brought to you by Resi and American Express. I'd have to look at the statistics, but I'd say if there's like one food that is present in every country on the planet. I mean, I've made pizza in Mongolia, so I mean, it's all over. It's pizza. This is Taste. I'm your host, Matt Rothbard.
0:58I was so excited to invite my friend Mauricio Leo to New York City to walk the steamy streets and eat a lot of pizza. Mauricio is the author of The Perfect Loaf, an incredible cookbook and online community dedicated to all things sourdough. Mauricio and I visited seven pizzerias along with lead producer Clayton Gumbert and tasted our way through some of the city's best and maybe not best slices. So what do we think about Joe's, Industry, Mama's 2, Lucia, Upside, Scars, and F &F? Well, you're going to have to tune in. Also on the episode, I catch up with Anthony Falco. Falco is a global pizza consultant and a true pioneer in the pizza game.
1:40He just returned from a three-week trip to Italy, and we talk about all the pizza styles and trends he's spotted there. We also move beyond pizza to discuss the modern trattoria scene, good and great gelato, and how Anthony's appreciation for art dovetails with his interest in the culinary world. This is a pizza-packed episode, and I hope you enjoy it.
2:06We're sitting at Joe's. We just ordered three slices. It's a limited menu. I mean you can definitely go fresh ma's, you can definitely go or soft ma's or you can go pepperoni It doesn't it's not that crowded where it's 11 15 a.m. It's really it's early early in the day What's your impression is looking at it? One of the things I've been trying to figure out is how to get the right melt for the cheese So I've been ordering because in New Mexico It's not a huge fresh cheese selection or even age so I've been ordering like grande mozzarella online And that's been the best that I've used. And so I'm looking at the webbing that this kind of creates, and the oil and the cooling.
2:47So some cheeses I've used, there's just too much oil coming out. It pulls up. For me, this is just right on the cheese. I mean, at this volume at Joe's, and they do hundreds and hundreds of supplies a day, they clearly got this thing down. Dialed in. I mean, my impression is this slice has always, to me, been about the thickness, which is, it's not. For a New York slice, it's incredibly light. If you pick it up, it's one of the lightest single slices you're gonna get. Let's taste it. Let's dive in.
3:30The cheese, man. I love it. I love that cheese. So simple. Yeah. There's no aromatics getting in the way. It's very cheese heavy. We have to acknowledge that this is our first pizza of the day, which kind of ultimately makes it the best pizza of the day when you had that first bite of pizza. And we're going to have to acknowledge on our last stop that our palates will be in a unique place. It'll be different. It's going to evolve through the day. But I also like the bottom crust, like a uniform color. No, one thing that gets me is pizza one. It's too white. It's just not good for that. Especially the outer rim.
4:13Like, I don't know. I want a nice brownness on the outside. And it folds without snapping, which I think is key. For New York Slice. It's key, right? Very good point, Mauricio. And we're all kind of doing Clayton as well. We're all doing the fold method. which is something that I never knew about. It's just part of life here probably for you. Mm-hmm. Eventually. But growing up in Michigan, Domino's, Little Caesars, I was going in like landing on an aircraft carrier, like a plane. There's no folding that guy. Right. I like the sauce a lot here. Again, it doesn't really have aromatics at all. It's definitely sweet.
4:57What is sweet? Which to me is what I grew up on, moving to New York it was profound sweetness of the guests up in pizzerias here is just I think at like 2 a.m. you need you need that yeah it can't be subtle right I think it goes well with the crust and the cheese and like you said I think it's a probably a food memory for most people here yeah yeah good call well let's I think we should head on to the next spot what do you think let's do it all right so we're in line of industry 11 people in front of us it's 15 minutes before opening so I feel pretty good about this yeah we'll get in quick so in the research for your book and just in general you've never been to industry what do you know about it what are you thinking I've just you know I've I've done a deep dive on New York style so whatever you can find online right and like asking people searching online trying to find information on the style of pizza that they're doing how it's different from a typical New York style and just trying to take tips from you know the dough kind of the dough program or how they're mixing fermentation times the difference for me is that all my doughs are sourdough 100 % so I'm pretty sure there's are yeasted.
6:16Almost every pizzeria is yeasted. I think it's maybe changing a little bit now. Like a lot of pizzerias are doing 100 % sourdough, which is harder. Very, very hard to do and more rare. It's more rare and, you know, the reason is you, when you have a pizzeria, like my dad's pizzeria, you need predictability. You don't want to have a batch of dough that just doesn't turn out. You know, it's like extra hot the next day or whatever. And so yeast provides that comfort zone. Yeah. But you also don't want sourdough pizza that's sour in any way. So there's extra steps you have to go to... To like tamping down.
6:53I mean, that's the Pisaolos who are anti-sourdough. And I've come across them. We'll get to that later today. I have a thought on that when we make a very specific visit. We'll be visiting a Pisaola who doesn't quite agree with the sourdough method. But it's really important to obviously balance it because you don't want it to taste sour. I think we all can agree on that. Yeah. Yeah, it's not like bread. where when I make sourdough bread, I'm not looking for super sour, but I want enough so that your mouth starts to water. So it's kind of a different way to build it up. You don't want a lot of sourness in pizza.
7:28So what do you know about this place? Because I know you had checked it out online early on. It reminded you of something. Yeah, it kind of reminds me of my dad's, the way my dad started. Like he came over from Italy. He didn't really have a plan. You know, he was like, should I start a restaurant? Should I work in construction or whatever? He was a trained chef, but he just made it up as he went. Like, there were no, like nowadays, I think there's kind of a path you can follow for restaurants. Like, okay, you can get these ovens and whatever. But, you know, 45 years ago, there was no, he was using like a baker, like a bakery oven to make pizzas.
8:06And I think that's kind of the New York style. The baker's prides are in most of these places. Yeah, and that kind of oven makes a certain type of pizza. So anyways, I think the owner of Lendistry is, reminds me of like a younger, my dad, right? He's like scrappy, just figuring it out as he went. Yeah. I love that. I love it too. Well, I can't wait to check this out. Yeah, so Mauricio, industry, industry. I call it industry, you call it industry. What thoughts? What are you thinking? I mean, it's amazing to see the line. Yeah. It's something, but I thought the pizza was great. The texture was good.
8:43Yeah. I like that it was different. There wasn't that sweetness that you're getting in some of these other New York pies. And I love the texture, the texture of the crust. I thought it was really good. I didn't taste a lot of depth of flavor in the crust. In the dough. Yeah, yeah, me too. In the dough itself. But I think they're going for a good quality sauce. The cheese was good. melt was good and then I mean it's it was a great a great slice yeah I do not like the burrata slice I I'm fully opposed to that being on my pizza I am with those who are in the against camp and that's my only notes on the negative side about about industry I think what they're doing is is a show we like great music and their things are popping and like clearly a very exceptional pie and slice I did like the range of the menu they had like spicy salami they had a brada slice they had regular they had we tried the the fig marscarpone a little bit of bacon I like that it was good yeah I mean it was totally a one direction one note idea on top of this very nice crust that has great structure less flavor I agree the flavor development of the crust is not as there or aggressive and then maybe intentional for them.
10:07Yeah yeah I think but I think it balanced out with the sauce and the cheese that they're using and you're right and the toppings I mean there were more I don't know intense toppings exactly flavor wise but I agree with you on the burrata I'm not a huge fan mostly because it's not easy to to eat through and you if you're using a fork and knife which sure I think on a New York slice you're not going to be doing and so it doesn't it doesn't quite fit for me yeah I'm more of a less is more me too typically we'll hit some spots later we're on our only our second visit I think we'll see some more maximalist slices that maybe we'll bring you over to that side I just think it's a clear reason to eat a lot of burrata which is why I brought it as well as a side it's like you're eating this incredible cheese with a high cream content it's a lot is literally cheese and cream together yeah yeah and you know on the bread side having a piece on bread is amazing because bread is meant to absorb yes the ingredients right so if you're topping with olive oil like that fits perfectly for a pizza it's thin so how can you support a large ball of cheese I know it's so strange I mean it was smart it was like a viral idea I go line check we started at 11 I think when we when they opened the doors there was over 75 in line now like 20 minutes 30 minutes after opening the line seems to be consistent 45-50.
11:24Yeah I mean that for me to see that is insane. It's shocking. It's funny. But the the model works for them like yeah you walk up you grab a slice and you walk off and so you know it's perfect you can service these people they're not gonna be waiting too long. No. And they're just constantly firing off those pies in there so. In and out within an hour I would say to be honest like pizza you can eat fast you know. Alright let's go to the next spot. So, Mauricio, we are at the new-ish location of Mama's 2. And when they moved downtown from, like, I would call it, like, near Columbia uptown on Broadway, it's kind of a big deal because up until that point, you had to go way uptown to have this pizza.
12:05And a lot of people did. I remember the first time I heard about this pizza was actually from Phil Rosenthal. He and I were catching up, and he told me that he was going to Mama's 2. This was several years ago, and he was like, I love that place. And I was like, Phil Rosenthal knows his shit. So I was like, let's go, Phil. And I've been up subsequently several times to the Upper West Side version or way uptown version. I've been here once to this West Village location. And we're here on a Friday as this whole day is unfolding. The lines are apparent. We're just hopping from line to line. We're hopping from line to line.
12:40I love it. And, you know, we'll talk about our thoughts about this pizza when we get in and try it. But I think that they have been known for their creative takes on pizza. That's what I would say. They also do a lot of sandwiches. A guy is literally doing a TikTok in front of us while we're eating in line. So we also have the same microphones. Like we're using the same labs. So we're like all like fam here. Does it look like a meatball sub? Yeah, he's doing meatball sub. So it kind of reminded me. They're known for their subs and their sandwiches too. So Mamasu is everything. So for me, I'm like really excited to introduce you to this pizza.
13:44and will help us continue to make the best show possible. That's the This Is Taste listener survey, link in our show notes. From February 20th to March 7th, dive into Canada's biggest culinary festival, Montreal en Lumière, an exclusive partnership with the McCord Stewart Museum and its exhibition, On the Menu Montreal, a restaurant story. The 2026 festival invites food lovers on a flavorful journey through time. Montreal's top restaurateurs will reimagine 65 years of the city's iconic astronomy, crafting inventive, nostalgia-inspired dishes with a modern twist. Prepare your palate. World-renowned chefs, including several Michelin-starred talents, will team up with over 80 of Montreal's finest local chefs to create unforgettable, one-of-a-kind menus.
14:34The full program is available at MontrealOnLumiere.com, presented by Lotto Quebec in collaboration with National Bank. These slices are not fucking around. They're very heavy. What do you think? I agree. They're heavy, but at the same time, not as much as I thought it was going to be. Okay, fair, yeah. Because it's so thick, I think the actual crust is super light. There's a lot of fermentation in there. It wasn't like a dense piece of pizza. Fair. Well said. I mean, there's flavor development, too, in the crust. I tasted some of that, too, in the dough. And nice and crispy on the bottom, like ultra crispy.
15:10Yeah. I love, I think the crispness on the bottom contrasted with that soft, like fluffy top and middle part. I think that's what does it for me. It's that contrast that's so good. And because the crust is so light, you can get away with the cacio e pepe, which is a little bit heavier. But still, it's like one slice max and I'm done. But it was good. Okay, well, we're just warming up. That was number three of seven. Let's go to the next spot. Let's do it. So we are down on West Broadway and Canal at Lucia's Soho location. Now they have locations, they originated way out in Brooklyn and have, I think this is their third location, I believe.
15:52But a real institution, right? And the expansion is cool to see. I wish LMB, LMB I think tried to do it and put up a spot in Brooklyn and Dumbo maybe. But, you know, I'd be curious. I haven't been here. This is like the one place I haven't been on our tour. So I don't know what we're going to have. It looks, I mean, I'm kind of peeking in the window here. I see a really nice tall crust on the edge. Huge pies as usual, but I'm excited. Yeah, I'm excited. Let's go inside. That pizza was really good. It was cool to have it in this kind of pocket on Canal and West Broadway because the vibe was like there was cops there was like young cool kids and then like random people like ourselves so I think the pie in my estimates was I read it very high and maybe one of my favorites that we've had so far and I really liked to me the flavor in the dough was noteworthy I really got great flavor development there what do you think yeah I think there it wasn't just textural thing the texture was nice but there was actually flavor contribution there like it levels of flavor right you get the cheese the tomato and then the crust itself has brings something to the table i liked it we tried the the the the nona slice the grandma slice and i feel like that was as close to nona that i know than we had so far yeah it was it's probably half the thickness half the thickness of mama's two and i would say more a little bit more dense but it still had a nice crispiness on the bottom and i think to me the biggest difference was there was just a lot more oiliness to mama's too oh yeah and it might have been the cheese or the toppings well of course that you know that's going to contribute to it but um this was just a little bit more of a cleaner slice yeah and i think for me it was the texture like the thickness was a little bit more dense, in a good way.
17:55Like, I really liked it. Let's head to the next spot. Okay, Mauricio, we've walked over now. We've headed east, and we're at Upside, at the corner of Mulberry and Spring. I've really enjoyed coming here and watching the evolution of the brand. I know Anthony Falco was on the ground level when this pizzeria was launched, and I just think the world of what they're doing and I love the way they expand and each of their shops has a real vibe they pick cool real estate and I enjoy the pizza so I mean it looks super cool really busy corner like you said the vibes here very different from where we were let's do it great so we've had the slices at upside this is a highlight for me this is easily at the top ranks for me this was amazing especially the corn pie yeah tell me what What do you like about the corn?
18:49I think it's a non-traditional topping. Yeah, corn and poblano. Yeah. A white pie. It has a little bit of hometown vibes for me with the peppers. Green chili in New Mexico, yeah. Green chili's everywhere. A little bit spicier than the poblano, but I love the pairing. The sweet and spicy together, I think it's amazing. Yeah, and what I like about their corner slice, which you know you'd call like Sicilian more than Nona right probably because of the pan and the frico and it looks like it's gonna be a bomb and like we got that bomb at Mama's too we got that bomb and it's good and some people really want that bomb and and but it's a magic trick because you tear into it and it's light as air super light yeah it's deceptive it looks like you're gonna half a slice and you wouldn't be able to eat anymore but I think you know you I could eat a whole slice and that wouldn't be a full meal.
19:44Like I could eat one and I'd still feel good afterwards. I know. And guess what? I've been there. I've had one as like a snack and it's a beautiful snack. But let's talk mostly about the flavor in the dough because what I think we both remarked when we were tasting it and you're a sourdough expert. You think about flavor development deeply. What they're doing with the dough here, I mean, it's not a full sourdough, but it's getting into those realm, which to me is very exciting. Yeah, it's, I mean, it's harder to do, but I think the levels of flavor that you're getting from this kind of a crust is just way more than you would with just a standard yeasted dough.
20:25And, you know, you can tell they're really pushing fermentation in this. Like, it's super light, super airy, which makes the dough, you know, arguably a little harder to handle. I mean, it sounds like, from what I remember, they're over 48 hours in, you know, program. It's like maybe 72 hours of rotation. So that's a three-day fermentation. For a place that operates at scale, they've got five, six locations now in New York alone. That's hard. I'm just waiting for them to get to 300. I mean, I could see this idea, this vibe, this energy, and of course this exceptional pizza, you know, doing well all over the country.
21:02Well, it's impressive. Really, really good job upside. Really good job. Let's head to the next stop. So we're here at SCARS. This is stop number six of seven. Back to my burrata comment from industry. Industry is obviously a fan of burrata. SCARS, their point of view is like no burrata. They're like not about it. Anti-burrata. Yeah, because on social media they just posted a photo of the staff wearing no burrata shirts. So they clearly have a point of view. Now, I had Scar Pimentel on the show recently to talk about his cookbook and his process. The guy really cares about wheat, about grains. He's really about, he mills all of his own flour.
21:48And really, he makes the clear claim that he's not selling the pie for the price that it really costs. He really is trying to keep the prices at an affordable level while using the highest quality of products. That's what we're getting into here. I, you know, from my perspective as a bread baker and somebody who mills my own flour pretty much every time I bake, I love that. Especially in pizza. Like, I don't feel like you don't see that often. And that instead of treating the flour and the grain as just another commodity ingredient, to me it's like going deeper, you know, like another level. Well, let's go inside.
22:29Let's check it out and see how the pizza is. So we've had the pies. I mean Mauricio, you are pulling apart the crust, you're smelling it, you're kind of quiet, which I think is a good sign. I mean you're really, what do you think about the, let's talk about dough first because I know we know Scar is so into milling and you're yourself as a bread baker, care so deeply about it so you have that shared value there. I think, you know, for me, you can't have a good pizza if the dough and the crust isn't good. Like, that's where it all begins. Like, you can put whatever toppings you want, you can mask it however you want, but if you don't have a good dough or a good base, then it's not going to be a good pizza.
23:11But I think this is really amazing. I'm looking at the color. Like, there's, you know, a yellow kind of goldenness to the interior, super light and fluffy. I love how it's cooked pretty boldly on the bottom. Yes. It's not like leoparding. It's like black cat. Yeah. But it's the right level of char. You know what I mean? It's not acrid. No. We're not tasting burn. You're right. And yeah, to me, I almost always eat a pizza. I almost want to eat from the crust in. Oh, I've witnessed it. That is definitely how you eat. Yeah, that's what I've been doing. Because to me, that's where it all begins. And this is really nice.
23:48The flavor and texture is great. I'm glad you like it. To me, I always just order the slice. The hot boy, we tried the hot boy as well. I like it. I just don't like honey on pizza, personally. That's my take. I think that the cheese he's using and the way you had noted, Mauricio, about the bubbling and the crown of the cheese was different.
24:18It's different. more thought that goes into, maybe not thought, because all the places we're going to think about their pies, but there's just something about the flavor of the cheese alone that makes me keep coming back for the slice. Yeah, I think, and I mean, we've only tried two here, but I think if I came here, if I lived here, I would probably just go, you know, cheese every time, which to me is like the essence of pizza. I mean, aside from just tomato, the cheese for me is the next step, where it seems like it should be a simple thing, but you can actually, if you have good cheese, if you have good tomato, and you have good dough, it punches way above some that have fancy toppings, let's say.
24:59Part of my chewing, I literally just shoved more cheese pizza into my mouth while you were explaining. We typically were just talking, but I just saw the cheese and I had to eat some more of it. I'll just close and just say, I haven't been back here in about six months, and try to come here every six months, and this is one of the better slices I've had at SCARS ever. And I'm really happy to report that back because there was a time when I came here when they first opened the pizzeria, I had a pretty mediocre experience and it wasn't in my mind, but the last two times I hit slices, really, really good.
25:32And I agree with you, the flavor in the dough shines. Well, let's head to our final stop. You feel like eating some more pizza? You feel like pizza today? Let's do it. Just a little more. A little more pizza. We'll do that. All right. Well Mauricio, our final stop was something, a place I needed to take us. I've talked about so many times on the show but we're actually on location on Court Street outside F &F which to me is, it's on the podium for Best Slices in New York. For me it's always L &B Spamoni Garden, that's for another trip when you visit, and then F &F. And I'm just excited to show you the way the Franks articulate their pizza vision.
26:14They definitely use a less is more approach. I've always, always, always been here for the Sicilian slices. I've had Sicilians that have been lightly dressed. They're almost like focaccias. The one we're going to try today, I believe, has green olives. So I'm just thrilled to be here to take you into FNF. All right, so we've finished the consumption part of this tour. I'm feeling great. I'm just absolutely loving being out. Loving hanging out with you. It's amazing. It's been really fun, Mauricio. It's amazing to be in the city. Great to be with Clayton as well. We've enjoyed some great pizzas.
26:50Let's just talk about F &F. I mean, to me, I said what I said in the opening. This is on my podium. What do you think, Mauricio? I think this is definitely some of the best pizza out of all of them. I really like the, I don't know if they called it the Sicilian, but it's, I mean, to me, it feels like a focaccia that I would make. I mean, these are just semantics. Yeah. It's a green olive, and you can tell they just kind of hand-crush the whole peeled tomatoes on top. But it's minimal. There isn't a lot of, you know, not a ton of oil. There's not, you know, it's not packed with tomatoes. It's, like, really balanced.
27:27Fermentation is spot on. Super light and fluffy crust. and a pretty crispy and crunchy rim. I mean, I think this is one of my favorite of them all. And I was coming into this expecting triangular slices were going to be the king, but that was pretty strong. It's kind of their secret weapon is their Sicilian, which I agree. I think the flavor of the dough has always been something that has drawn me here. Before I even thought about what sourdough was, and once I met you, we talked a lot about sourdoughs, I always called this more of a sour pizza dough, even though it's not technically a sourdough.
28:00So there was a lot of flavor there. And the way, I agree with you, the way they're topping these pies, it's not maximalist. It's just well-curated, positioned, selected toppings in an even way. Yeah, on a flavorful dough, which is, in my opinion, the most important thing out of the whole pizza. They get extra points for just the pizzeria itself. It's like, I just love coming out here. to this, they have a courtyard, they're having a private event tonight, so we're out on the street. And there's nothing just better than hanging out at either Frankie's or FNF. Just love being here. Everybody is friendly inside.
28:40Oh, yeah. You can tell when you go to a place and, you know, the workers inside are in a good mood, everybody's, you know, happy to talk about dough or schedule or whatever. I felt that here. Yeah, they were cool here. They've always had good stuff at FNF. Yeah, I've talked about so much on the show, and now we're here reporting from here. All right, so we're done with this tour. Seven pizzerias. We started at 11.15. It's now almost four. How are you feeling? I'm feeling good. A lot of the pizza's thin. They're light and airy, and we didn't eat full pies either. So yeah, but I think I have my full, my fill of pizza.
29:22Okay, so we started at Joe's, really with the classic. We went to industry. We headed to Mama's 2. And then we headed over to Lucia. We walked around Soho a bit. And then we headed over... Upside? Upside Pizza. Down to Scars. Popped over on the F train to Carroll Gardens, up at F &F. We've hit many on the New York Times list, not that they're the benchmark. We've hit many names that we've talked about on the show. Mauricio, what are your highlights? Well, you know, I think the reoccurring theme here for me is that it's really the dough that I'm most impressed by. I think at Upside I thought was phenomenal.
30:06I think the dough there was super flavorful. And FNF Sicilian was pretty phenomenal. I liked Lindestreet. I thought it was a really nice slice. I think the flavor at Upside and F &F was a little bit more complex. There's more layers there, which I appreciate and I like that. But I also, you know, I like the slices at Mama's. I thought they were in a different way, you know, like a different kind of pizza. Especially for me, where I didn't really grow up eating that style of pizza. So it's different, but it was good. I like those thoughts. I'll just add, I think that for me, in terms of the actual favorite bite, I'm still going to go back to Scar's cheese.
Read the full transcript
30:55Just everything came together today. They were having a good day. I think that F &F is having a great day today with their focaccia. We also tried the sausage and Rob iconic slice that is just straight as an arrow, always there. I think that we progressed in terms of dough styles, in terms of the fermentation. and Upside really took it for me. I think that what they're doing there with the flavor in the dough was just exceptional. I think FNF also has with this focaccia just such a flavor profile that shows time and maturity. Going back to industry, I think that that was like the most, even though it was like right at the beginning, that was like the most fun space.
31:36Yeah, it was fun. It was like booming and I love the way it's designed and I love that it had a beautiful pastry case filled with desserts. I love the energy there. I think Mama's struggled for me a bit today. I just thought the pies felt overly done and heavy. And I've been, this is now like my fourth time. I'm not sure if I'm going to run back. There's like many other slices I want to try. I want to go to Ciri's just to have pizza. So I don't think I'm going to run back to Mama's too, but I'm definitely going to head out, head back to all the other places whenever I can. Yeah, it was fun. I mean, you really can't go wrong.
32:13It's almost like, what mood am I in today? You know, which place do I feel like the most? And if I lived here, it'd be hard. Hard picking every day. Hard picking. It's just such a beautiful thing to have, to be able to have a meal for under$20, and that includes like a nice drink and gratuity and a couple slices and maybe a quick salad or something. I mean, just such an affordable luxury, say that a lot on the show, to have pizza so beautifully done with such care at such a low price point. We're lucky in New York City. I mean, you're definitely lucky, and you have to think, you know, a lot of these doughs are two, three-day fermentation schedule, and so it's not something they're whipping together right there in the moment.
32:58So there's, I mean, there's a lot of thought, a lot of planning, and a lot of, you know, systems that have to be in place to serve this kind of pizza at this scale. So I love hanging out with you. Let's close and tell us about what you can tell us now about the book. Okay, yeah. My book is all about pizza, focaccia, a few special bread recipes thrown in there. It's all sourdough. So there's different kinds of schedules that you can go on for making these doughs. I think that's one of the hardest things for people at home is, you know, these pizzerias are making, they're on this cadence. You know, every two, three days they have doughs, but at home you may not, you know, you may not want to have dough prep during the week while you're busy working and then have pizza on the weekend.
33:43So part of the book is about scheduling and making pizza, like amazing pizza at home a reality for anybody. And a great companion for your first book, The Perfect Loaf, to have like a great bread program and then transition all that energy to pizza and with a bunch of good recipes. Yeah, and I think they're related, right? Oh, yeah. A lot of people think bread and pizza are two completely different things, but like I say in the book every few pages, if your dough is good, then your pizza is going to be good. Let's leave it at that, Mauricio. It's been fun hanging out. Likewise. Thank you so much for hanging out too, and thanks for joining, buddy.
34:21Thanks for having me.
34:25This episode is brought to you by Aura Frames. If you're one of those last-minute shoppers, you might know the feeling. Ideas are running low and the clock is ticking. Here's a fun idea. Aura Frames. Aura Frames is the solution with a GIF that feels personal, a little curated, and sent with love. And a GIF that can be purchased in no time with a few clicks of the mouse. Aura Frames are great. They sent me one to check out and it was really cool and dumb simple to set up. I loaded photos using the app and it was displaying them instantly. There are no limits to the amount of photos you can load, and you can customize messages with each photo.
35:03And here's the deal. You can preload an Aura frame with photos and have it directly sent to that special person in your life, gift-wrapped and all. There will be no price tag, and you can include a personalized message. Think about it. All those photos from this past summer's family reunion delivered in a digital frame. That is pretty cool. For a limited time, save on the perfect gift by visiting AuraFrames.com to get$35 off Aura's best-selling Carver Matte Frames, named number one by Wirecutter, by using promo code TASTE at checkout. That's A-U-R-A frames dot com, promo code TASTE. The deal is exclusive to listeners and frames sell out fast, so order yours now to get it in time for the holidays.
35:49Support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply. Today's episode is brought to you by ButcherBox. As a food writer, I can be a little skeptical about subscription cooking boxes you hear about on podcasts. There's big talk about cooking simplicity, but you're usually left with disappointment after smashing that promo code. Now, Clayton, have you ever tried one of those subscription boxes? Yeah, Matt, my friend gave me a code for that one that has all the chopped vegetables in little baggies. I felt like a drug dealer trying to cook dinner. Yeah, man, I have so been there.
36:20ButcherBox is a true exception. I was sent a box of premium beef and pork and was blown away by the quality and variety. There was 100 % grass-fed pasteurized ribeye, tri-tip, and ground sirloin for my favorite at-home smash burger recipe. George Motes, you better watch your back. For pork, they sent me a beautiful center-cut pork loin for slow roasting. I was super impressed, and I haven't even talked about the ribs, which I cooked in my Instant Pot. There was a rub of salt, white pepper, and togarashi, and I pressure cooked with water and apple cider vinegar. It was incredible. These ButcherBox ribs are amazing.
36:59For nearly a decade, ButcherBox has led the industry with meat and seafood that's antibiotic-free. As an exclusive offer, our listeners can get free protein in every box for a year, plus$20 off your first box when you go to butcherbox.com slash taste. Visit butcherbox.com slash taste to get this limited time offer and free shipping always. That's butcherbox.com slash taste. Don't forget to use our link so they know we sent you. Anthony Falco, welcome back to This Is Taste. How are you? I'm great. Thanks for having me back. I'm so glad to be back in New York and be back here talking with you. Well, you just returned from three weeks in Italy, and you were on the road with your family, the four of you.
37:45And I was observing it from afar, from social media and some messaging in between. And what a great trip. It was amazing. And I mean, I travel for my work like nonstop. And, you know, if there's between school and the feasibility of the location, if I can have my family with me, it's great. But the reality is I am out there by myself a lot. So, you know, summer comes and the kids are out of school. We all took the opportunity to go there. And Roman had never, my youngest son had never been to Italy. Frank had been when he was six months old, so he didn't remember it at all. Oh, I didn't realize that.
38:25I thought this was almost like a regular thing you do. So this is like the first time the whole fam was together in Italy. Yeah. Well, sorry. That was the first time. We did go to Rome like a couple years ago. I forgot about that. But it was the first time that that Roman had been to Milan. Milan. And so Frank had been to Milan when he was six months, which is really funny. But, yeah, I mean, I want to make it a regular thing. I think it's great for the kids. And, you know, if we can make it happen, I want to try to go as much as possible. But, yeah, I go by my I go without them more often. It's great to show them your spots.
39:04Okay, before we get to the trip and all the pizza you had and all the other great things you enjoyed, tell me about what's up with your consulting business. You've got so many projects. You've opened over 60 restaurants through your consulting. And I'm going to link in the show notes to an earlier episode that talks a little bit about your history and where you came from and starting Roberta's and really being a leader in pizza. But I want to hear right now what's good in the consulting world. Yeah. I just so right before Italy, I had like only one night home from a trip to Costa Rica where I was working on a project called Fachi.
39:39Great, great clients. My client, Juan Damiani, just a really, you know, he was very inspired to switch careers, which are some of my favorite clients, is when someone has like a corporate job, but they make pizza on the side or they do pop-ups and they want to, you know, open, like commit to it full time and follow their dream. You know, because I think that's the best reason to open a restaurant is to is because you not from a logical left brain perspective, but because you want to follow your dream and you just you like cooking as opposed to, you know, working spreadsheets. You have to love it.
40:16I mean, the pizza business, my sister-in-law owns a pizzeria in North Jersey. It's like extremely, extremely physical and mentally taxing. It's like you're not just running a restaurant or any pizzeria and you're just like running around all the time and lugging stuff and working with a customer that maybe doesn't appreciate your product as much as it should. Do you agree with that? Yeah. I mean, you know, like it's nobody really can. There's a lot of people who have never worked in a restaurant. And I think that you just you really cannot understand like the amount of work it takes. Being on your feet for, you know, 12, 13 hours at minimum, like, you know, that is something that a lot of people just, I mean, they won't understand.
41:05And so they, everyone thinks they're an expert on restaurants because they've all eaten at a lot of them. But yeah, it's, you can't think about, I try not to think about the customer too much. I mean, I think my philosophy, and I tell this to all my clients, is you have to make what you want, make what you want to eat, make what you're inspired by, and people will come to that and they will respond to that. You know, block out the negativity, focus on the positivity, and just, you know, it's you against the product. It's not you against the clients or the guest or the other competition. It's you against the product.
41:45And it's a it's a long term battle of like looking for perfection, but knowing there will never be perfection. And that's like a noble pursuit in life, I think. It really is. And you also just have to think about a very price sensitive customer because everyone has their opinion about what a slice should cost and what a pie should cost. And it seems like it's so it's always hot button. I mean, I'm talking about pizza on the show all the time and people are always saying it's too expensive. It's too expensive. Yeah. I mean, it's also very geographically sensitive. Sure. You know, it's cheaper to make a pizza in New York than it is in Costa Rica, for sure.
42:23Yeah. You know, and you think, well, okay, that's like, it should be a cheaper country, right? Things should be cheaper there. People have perceptions things should be cheaper in Thailand or other places. But, you know, if you're not in the northern hemisphere or parts of the southern hemisphere, you're not like necessarily in a great place for dairy production or for tomatoes or for flour. So you have to import those things. And so, you know, that ends up being more expensive than, say, like what the local cuisine is. So it's a lot of times pizza is a specialty. Even though it is found everywhere in the world, I mean, I'd have to look at the statistics, but I'd say if there's like one food that is present in every country on the planet.
43:09I mean, I've made pizza in Mongolia. So, I mean, it's all over. It's pizza. But it's, yeah, it can be a struggle sometimes. So, you know, Italy, it's very affordable, you know. But even they are price sensitive as prices are going up. You know, and they are very sensitive to that because wages are very low there. So, I mean, I think if you're a restaurant and you're charging something, I think that it's probably – you probably know what you're doing because if you're open. Yeah, yeah. You know, so if you get it wrong, you're going to be closed pretty quickly. Yeah, it's true. That spreadsheet was a couple points wrong.
43:52Yeah. In your projections, you're not staying open. Yeah. It's a very small margin business. I want to ground it in New York a bit and talk about Upside because early in this episode, Mauricio and I were on our pizza crawl and we just love Upside. It was Mauricio's first time there. I've been many times in what Noam has built there and what you have helped build on the culinary side. Really one of my favorite slices around. I want to talk to you about this summer slice I tried. Okay. So good, man. Yeah. So it was fun to get back in the kitchen with Noam. And, I mean, they're just, you know, great clients.
44:30I started working with them, like, I forget, what, six, seven, eight years ago? Before they even opened, I bet. Yeah, I mean, no, from the very beginning, the first store. And Noam actually came to Seattle with me to do, like, it was like a Breville event. And he's like, you know, I want to shadow you and really learn the pizza. And I was like, okay, well, I'm just doing this all naturally fermented. Like, when I make pizza for myself, I do it all sourdough. And he's like, I want to do that in the shop. And I'm like, no, people don't. You don't do that in shop. We'll do a hybrid. We'll do some yeast and we'll do some sourdough for flavor.
45:02He's like, no, I want to do. He really insists. He was the first client of mine to insist on all naturally leaven. And I was like, all right, let's do it. And, you know, he was unbelievably dedicated in the beginning, like going in, checking on the dough at like three in the morning. And putting the thermometers in. Yeah, exactly. And, you know, I mean, from the 8th Avenue original location, what they built is incredible. I think they had seven. Seven, I think. Yeah. And then Norm's, which I also worked on with them, which is three or four. Up on Court Street. I remember going there, right? Yeah.
45:37That was the one. I love that one. And they have great branding and the signage and stuff is super cool what they do. And, yeah, I mean, they're one of my favorite clients. And Norm is also just a really good friend and just, you know, he's a great guy. He hustles really hard. And I think it's great pizza. I mean, I think it's some of the best New York slice there is. And I have, you know, people tell me that sometimes who don't know I was involved in it. And that always feels really good. That's nice. But, yeah, so the summer slice, you know, I went in to check on like kind of, you know, once you get to like seven stores, things, you know, it's you're making dough at every location.
46:16The temperature is a little different. Everything's, you know, it's, it can be complex. So, you know, just dial some things in. We did a rework on the Sicilian right before you went, which is cool. The feedback you gave us was great. But, yeah, the summer, it's corn. I grew up in Texas, and one of my favorite things ever was something called sopa elote, which is a corn soup that I used to have at this restaurant called Fonda San Miguel. and it was one of my favorite things when I was a kid and it was corn, sweet onions, milk, and poblanos, rajas. So roasted poblanos cut into strips and they would put corn.
46:59Chips on top, tortilla strips, yeah. So good. Sounds delicious. So this was kind of inspired by that, because all those things come in season at the same time, the corn, the peppers, and the onions. And so we did a cream base, the white wine lemon cream, which is the same recipe that's on the base of the mushroom pizza. Okay, cool. Yeah, so we cross-utilized that. Yeah, yeah. And then some just raw corn that we just tossed with salt and olive oil and roasted poblano strips and some mozzarella and pecorino. And then when it came out and some yellow onions. Yeah, the onions are, I think, really cool element.
47:43They're raw, right? Yeah. Yeah, the raw onions. Yeah, we wanted to keep it simple. I mean, I think there's a lot of ways where you could make it more complex, but I think I always want to start more simple, and if it works, then we're going with that. And then we finished it with just a little togarashi, which is kind of a reference to street corn when they put the tagine on there. But yeah, the togarashi is a cool element. I could see the tagine working as well. but I think it has buzz to it. I think people want to eat togarashi on things that aren't ramen in Japanese and it's a clever use of a now well-known product as a little spice, as umami, of course.
48:25A little citrus. Citrus too from the Yuzu. Yeah, it's beautiful. Yeah. Great slice, great slice. Thank you, yeah. We're proud of that one. I think it's a great summer slice and everyone should go to Upside Pizza. Yeah, and the corners, I mean, getting that Sicilian and just like the texture and just like the, it all comes together in such a cool way. Yeah, they've been great to work with. And, you know, now I'm back. I'll go check on them again. Yeah, you'll probably do a little, like, do you just like pop in? Yeah. Even if you don't know the guys, are you just trying to do a little QC? Sometimes if I'm walking by, I'll pop in.
48:57And, I mean, I know a lot of the guys now because I've worked with them. Yeah. And they have some really talented pizza makers there. Definitely. And they've got, you know, new locations. and so if I see it, I've tried to go to every location. But yeah, I mean, I need a little break from pizza at the moment right now. I can imagine. We'll get to your trip to Italy. One more question. Where do you land on burrata on the slice? Because I had some pretty strong opinions about it that I shared. Love to get your take. Yeah. I mean, why not? I mean, first of all, it's, I mean, I had it in Italy. They've been doing it in Puglia forever.
49:36Yeah. I mean, why would you like, I don't know why anyone would get worked up about something like that. Unless they had like a specific beef with like a specific pizzeria that's doing it. I mean, Lindustria has become known for the Burrata Slice. It's their calling card. They're the home of the Burrata Slice. I love those guys so much. Nick and Mossimo are the best in the business. I think it's the best, you know, when they get rated number one slice in the world, I don't think it's wrong. Transparency, are they a client? No, not at all. Good. Just friends and neighbors. Actually, Nick's my next-door neighbor.
50:14Oh, cool. I mean, yeah, I mean, my opinion, I think I was just having a little fun. I mean, that's the fun thing about pizza. I know it is your career, and, like, any shade towards your work is personal and shitty. I just think we have fun with it as writers about judging and rating and stacking the order. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I'm generally pretty open. And all the things that I said I would never do, I've done. I love that. That's so cool. Like no chicken on pizza. Well, I was in India and there's a lot of dietary restrictions. Chicken was one thing everybody who eats meat can agree on. Yeah.
50:52And so I did it and it was great. You know, we were just in, when we were in Italy, one of the best restaurants that I went to was Aie Due Platini. And Giuseppe from Stella Pizza in Milan made the reservation for me. It was like, it's an impossible to get reservation. He hooked it up. So the pizza dudes looking out for pizza dudes. And they had a chicken pasta that was awesome. And people are like, oh, chicken pasta doesn't exist in Italy. Yeah. It's there. It's there. It's real. It was one of the best restaurants in the country, you know? Yeah. So I think if you do anything you want, man, like I'm not a – I don't tell people.
51:40I'm not trying to like – Rules are for writers. I feel like we just need like structure and we need to like actually like sell papers. Where do you land on the burrata? Oh, my earlier comments is that I was extremely negative on it. And I feel like I just didn't see the need for it. Yeah. And I really, I hope it came through in the piece that we really liked industry. And we really like it as an operation, as a vibe. I love the pastry counter. Just what they serve at the counter is amazing. They're awesome. Yeah, it's a really important restaurant. So I just didn't see the need for it. And I think I would rather go to other places than like wait in line for a burrata slice.
52:18That's where I landed on it. Okay. Yeah. I mean, there was definitely a over-barata moment. I think Tammy wrote about it. And I don't think she was wrong in what she was saying that it just, it is everywhere. Yeah. And it's not something that I have done a lot, although I just announced today that we're doing an homage to it in Brazil. Amazing. At my pizzeria in Sao Paulo, Braza Electrica. we're doing a Brooklyn special and it's inspired by Nick and Mossimo. And I mean, I imagine Brazil has some nice burrata too. Great local burrata. Local burrata. Local buffalo burrata. I've been to the, in Jau, to the factory and made burrata with the ladies who do it every day and they laughed at my poor technique.
53:06Yeah, at least you're trying. They do great stuff there. I mean, the product is amazing in Brazil. That's cool. Well, let's talk about the trip. I mean, how do you go into a big trip like this with your family and tell us where you actually went over these three weeks, like the path you took? Yeah, I mean, I'm pretty I'm pretty plan oriented kind of guy. So I create an itinerary day by day with links to everything and, you know, try to make a lot of reservations. I think if anyone's planning a trip to Italy, it's important to make as many reservations as you can. go ahead and leave yourself some open, you know, spots for panini and pizza and things like that.
53:46But Trattorias, Osterias, you're going to need a reservation at the best places because they just, I mean, sometimes you make the reservation and then you go in and there's really not that many people there. And you're like, what? Why did I do this? Why did I make that phone call? Yeah, but it's a lot of it is because they are planning, you know, it may not look full, but they're not just waiting. They're not just going to prep a lot of food and like hope a bunch of people come in. They want to plan their service. You know, so I think it's important for them and for you to make the reservations.
54:19So we started in Milan and we were there for like, there was like this best pizza awards thing. And I'm a voter and I have some friends and clients on the list. And so, you know, they invited me and I was like, yeah, it's a good excuse to go to Italy. and I got to see a lot of my friends from around the world there, which was super cool. Probably pick up some new clients maybe? Maybe. We'll see. I mean, I'm really, you know, one of the biggest, like, eye-opening things is this idea that I've had for a long time is that New York pizza is about to hit big in Italy. So I'm waiting for that call from an Italian operator to do New York Slice in Italy because, you know, it's happening.
55:05now like one of the people that i met there was the uh giuseppe from uh stella pizza in milan and it's from the guys uh who own uh bar paradiso which is like one of the best natural wine bars in milan and they're doing it's like a full-on new york slice place like uh ninja turtle stuff on the wall okay they're they're camping it up a little bit yeah they had to they had to have like they had to smuggle in the wood peels and stuff i mean it's like baker's pride it's a morety horny which is a great deck oven electric um but yeah no there's uh there's there's still a lot that that they won't i don't see a baker's pride showed up in italy yeah someone might i mean just as like nostalgia for some american i mean if you really wanted to do the full like look yeah the look yeah but the performance of the electric ovens is important and it was busy i mean it was like all the cool kids were there and it was it was awesome so we started milan um we also went to Confine, which is Francesco's pizzeria.
56:07He's originally from Salerno in the south, but he opened a pizzeria in Milan, number two in Italy, number four in the world from one of these lists. We did the tasting menu. The kids just had like a margarita pizza and they loved it. But he does this like fried pizza. He did like this calzone with like a gemberry rosso in it. Like, I mean, it was really a little fancy for me, but the core pizza was just great. Hard to argue with. And Francesca was amazing, gave me a tour of his kitchen, super state-of-the-art kitchen. My friend Henry made me the reservation from, this is an Instagram, I don't know if you know, Al Dente Life.
56:52I don't know, I'll follow. He's from Taiwan. Good name. Some restaurants, but he studied and worked in Italy for a while. So he knows his Italy recommendations. And he does kind of like on the street interviews with chefs in Taipei. Cool. And Henry's an amazing guy. Yeah. So he made the reservation. That was great. We tried to not eat much pizza in the north. Yeah. Save that for Rome. Yeah. And then after Milan, we took, oh, Ravella da Chotto. Okay. Was incredible. That's in Milan. That's one of my favorite restaurants I went to in Italy. The pasta is incredible. Highly recommend that restaurant.
57:36And then you get Cotoletta Milanese. Oh, yeah. You got to eat local, I think, personally. And then we rented a car and we went to Parma, Modena, and Bologna. And it was a real whirlwind Amelia Romagna food tour, like constantly Trattorias, Tortellini Ambrotto. Lombarusca, Tortellini Ambrotto, all the hits. Gnocco Fritto. Gnocco Fritto. Yeah, Culatello. Yeah. I mean, it was, my family was begging for mercy after, because it was hot. Oh, Italy is hot for like five months a year. It's crazy. It was extra hot. I mean, it was like making the news hot. Oh, that's right. It was making the news. You're literally.
58:20Yeah. It was like 100 degrees, which is like, okay. You're from Texas, though. Yeah. And I was not complaining. You're good. But my family, on the other hand. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. And the north is, it's very hot because basically that whole valley is situated, it's a giant flat plain situated between the Alps and the Apennine Mountains. and it's just so the air just kind of like hangs in there and the humidity is very strong. I mean, I feel like it even was, Rome was better, even though it's further south, the humidity was not as, I mean, it was very muggy. I had never been to Parma and I had never been to Modena, so it was great to do that with all of us together for the first time.
59:10The gelato was exceptional. Oh, in Modena In Parma, Modena, and Bologna Wow I mean, it was every place There was, like, show-stopping gelato So my friend Gabriele, who owns Love in Rome Which is a specialty coffee place So they do, like, proper third-wave coffee And then they do proper, like, French-style pastries Which, like, you know, laminated croissants and things Not the Cornetto And his stuff is world, world class. So he was giving me all the recommendations. Choco in Parma, outstanding. Oh, I love that. Bloom in Modena was so, so, so good. And then Cavour in Bologna was just like on another level entirely from all of them.
1:00:01Anthony, tell me about where you land on Gelato. I think you gave me the best rec in Naples, the gay olden rec was we went back twice. What do you look for in a really good gelato? So my friend Grace, who was going to school in Bologna, and then she was working in Milan. So we had dinner with her. She's originally from Mexico. We worked together in San Francisco. But she was studying gelato, studying pastry in Italy. And she was like, one of the first things you need to look for, okay, is when the gelato is in the case and it's piled up super high, red flag. You know, probably just walk out. Super smart observation.
1:00:48Makes perfect sense. Now, if it's level in the containers but uncovered, still not what you want. What you want is the metal lid. They're in the round containers and there's a lid on the gelato. You cannot see the gelato. Yes. Until they open the lid. Yes, and Gay Olden is exactly that. And you have to, like, kind of guess sometimes what the flavor is because you can't see it. Yeah, and some of those places don't even let you do tastes either. So you just got to roll with it. It's not America. Customer's not always right. Yeah. Sometimes you just have to be like, okay. Take a shot. Yeah, exactly.
1:01:23But that's what we're looking for. And then there's all these places, at least Chaco and Bloom are very big in this, like, it's like, whatever, new school, old school. like where they're basically like, they're no preservatives, none of these binders, none of the chemicals, things like that. And then really trying to source, you know, seasonal ingredients and things like that, local ingredients. One of the things I found out is that they are, they have been growing mango in Sicily now. And so they're, they're able to, some of these tropical fruit like sorbetos and things, they're able to source even locally.
1:02:00That's very cool. What's your first flavor and your second flavor when you're judging a gelato shop? I pretty much order the same thing everywhere. I'll taste like when I was with them, you know, my wife is like, she's always trying new things. My youngest son's trying new things. But for me, I'm pretty locked in to either chocolate and Fiori Latte or chocolate and crema. Crema, yeah. Definitely always grab crema myself. And I like to add a little panamontata on there, the whipped cream. If you can get that, please do. No pistachio though. Yeah. And no, I mean, like, I guess I'll try a lot of different things.
1:02:37But, okay. I'm projecting. That's my, I go chocolate, fiori latte, and then pistachio. Those are my three. Sure. I mean, and I love pistachio. And, you know, I think that, like, if they're sourcing from Sicily, especially too, I mean, it's like, I think that's a great thing. But, again, locally, crema is really, in Emilia Romagna, I feel like that's a signature flavor for them. And there they do it so simply. Like there's not vanilla even or like lemon zest sometimes you'll find in Rome, crema with those in there. It's really just eggs and cream and sugar. And that's it. And great products. Yeah.
1:03:25So you leave Emilia-Romagna, do you head down to Rome then? Yeah. So we did all of the, you know, I mean, Osteria is like Mirasole, which was like number one. Yeah. You know, I mean, it was literally named number one Osteria in Italy. And it was an incredible experience. But we dropped off the car in Bologna and then we took the train to Rome. And it was like full on pizza from like for five days. I think we ate at 11 pizza places. Oh, cool. You know, starting in the airport at like 6.30 a.m. with Aliche, which is like a chain Alice pizza. I don't know if it's called Alice or Aliche, but it's a chain everywhere.
1:04:08Not very good. No offense to whoever's behind that. But, you know, still it was in the airport. You were dropping off the – yeah, you were taking the train to the airport and you just said that's where you're going. Yeah, we had got up super early and we arrived and we needed something to eat before we went on the, you know, the Airbnb check-in like adventure. Because then we had to change from Termini to the subway to go down to Stachio. But some went to some of my favorite places. So for Tonda, which is the round, thin and crispy style, we went to Arota. Oh, my God. It looked amazing. Your videos, everything.
1:04:47Oh, my gosh. It's very, very good. It's part of this new school wave of people doing—like, Tonda is generally old school. The way it was done was not a ton of care in its production. It's a high volume. It was a value proposition. Yes. Cheap pizza, yeah. Yeah, and also late, open late. You know, I remember when I first, you know, went to Rome 25 years ago, I was like, oh, there are restaurants in Europe that stay open past 11 at 11 p.m. And it's always the like Roman style pizzerias. They're open super late. And they're just like cranking them out. But Tonda, each one is like perfectly presented and beautiful at Arrota and great ingredients and just a lovely place.
1:05:36I mean, just great, great pizza. And then went to some old school places that I'd never been before, Pizzeria Ostienza, which was awesome. Just fun. High, high energy. Frenetic. Hectic. No one spoke English. You know, had to fumble my way through the whole order in Italian, but they were super cool about it. And we loved the pizza. and then normally I'll go to 180 Gramey because I think it's so responsible for this revolution That's a reservation place, right? Yes. Mauricio and I were in Rome last fall and we couldn't book there. They have a takeout and delivery at the original location in Cintocelli so if you want to just try it and you don't have a reservation that's the move but it's also Cintocelli it's out there Which a lot of the best food is a little bit out of the ways in Rome.
1:06:34We then, for the Talio places, we did Fratelli Trecca, which is amazing. It's the guys from Pantera. Yeah, which is closed recently, I saw. Yeah, but then it reopened in Milan. Oh, okay. But I didn't get a chance to go there because it was like the day we were leaving. Okay. Good to know. But Fratelli Trecca is incredible. and it was everyone's favorite. We also went to Roover, which I think is like maybe only a year old. And so Alessandro Roover, he was a like worked under Banchi for a very long time and he's just a wizard. I mean, I had a rabbit ragu slice from there. Oh, beautiful. It was probably one of the best bites of food that I had in all of the whole trip of Italy.
1:07:25It was, the flavor was insane. And I was kind of like, he like gave it to me because I was ordering pretty basic because for the kids, it was like mortadella and margarita and like, you know, and he's like, you got to try the rabbit. And I was like, okay. You're like wild choice here for a topping. Yeah. Okay. But it was awesome. What's the acidity on that? There's got to be something. Exactly. Yeah. It was, it had this beautiful, bright acidity. It was with peppers. So kind of the way they do polo and pepperoni. like the classic Roman braise. Yeah. But it was with rabbit and it was like there was this really nice bright acidity and then the fruitiness flavor from the peppers from the sweet peppers and the tomato sauce that it was in.
1:08:11It was just fantastic. What's the cheese element? None. If any, there's none, right? No. It was just the ragu on top. Yeah, ragu on top. Yeah. That Roover was great. We ended up going there twice. So cool. Roover. Yeah. He followed his bosses is just name the spot after your name. Yep. Just do it. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I mean, and Roover is a memorable name amongst Italians. Same as Falco. I'm just like, you know, possibly Pizzeria in your future. Yeah, it would be a good name for a pizzeria. We'll see what happens. We'll see what happens. And then we went to Frumentario, which was just named number one slice pizza in Italy by the top 50 pizza list.
1:08:57And it was amazing. And my cousin, who is a doctor, and she lives in Rome from the Falcos who stayed in Sicily, she met us there. And, you know, we just, we all loved it. It was great. And, yeah, she was giving us all our advice on how to survive with the electrolytes. It was hot. It was very hot. We had an outdoor dinner at Piatta Romano, which is a great classic Roman trattoria. And for when we first got there for my son's birthday and it was just like we were dying and like we wanted to sit inside. And so then the next restaurant, we were like, OK, we'll sit inside. And then we went and sit inside and we were dying because the air conditioner was so weak.
1:09:42And it was like we couldn't win. So but that's why the slices are nice. You can just grab a slice and keep moving. Keep the breeze going. Keep the air going. Yeah. Yeah, so we also checked out a new slice place called Nonare in Garbatella, and it was from the split of Pantera. So Pantera closed. Oh, one of those things. Yeah, that's the pizza world, man. That pizza was great. Marisa and I loved our slice there. Yeah. And I'm trying to stay neutral because they're all very nice guys to me. But they split up. And so, you know, one group is now Nonare and Garbatella, and then Fratelli Trecca is the other group.
1:10:24And I think they're going to reopen, and they also are the ones who kept Pantera. Like the lease of that location. Yeah. And so we'll see what happens if Pantera reopens in Rome. But in the meantime, Fratelli Trecca is amazing. And then for the Pizza Paula, we went to Campo di Fiore. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Which is great. The pizzetta actually is the move there. For sure, yeah. So good. Yeah, so good. And then Roscioli, of course, is kind of a must stop. You just go one, two, four and oh to Roscioli. It's there, right. And then with the Pantheon in between. Right there, close, yeah. Which I always go to the Pantheon because it's just, to me, the most amazing building on planet Earth.
1:11:05And I can't go to Rome without it. And I don't want to bury the lead, too. It's like you went to some amazing spots with your family. I don't want you to come off as like a psycho. Like you went to like historical sites and went to. Yeah. Like you were at the embassy I saw on social media. Yeah, we got a private tour of the U.S. embassy, which was super cool. So cool. I think that was from the cookbook. The guy who works there was a fan of the cookbook and went to some of my pizza places clients. So that was great. I mean, what a nice guy. And it's in this like palazzo that has all this history.
1:11:38Oh, yeah. We went to museums in Parma, Modena. Yeah. Bologna, Rome. We went to multiple museums. We went to the Caravaggio exhibit. Oh, cool. Which they re-released tickets, so we got up at 8 in the morning to get on this crappy website and try to get on them. The museum that we went to in Bologna, Palazzo Poggi, highly recommend. One of the craziest museums in Italy. It's from the medical school of Bologna, which is the oldest university in the world. It started in 1088. And they have all these like skeletons and, you know, things in formaldehyde and wax like recreations of deformed, you know, creatures and things.
1:12:23And very cool, very goth kind of cool museum to go to. The Estense in Modena was incredible. The Estée family was super powerful. And so they collected antiques from Rome and from all over and they commissioned, like there was a Velasquez in there. It was just like, okay, we're literally the only people in this museum. And you've got these incredible pieces in there. So, yeah, culture is a big part of it. Obviously, you have a mind for detail and appreciation of art, which is pizza and other things too. So I love that. Yeah, for, you know, like, I mean, art was the idea, you know, but ended up in the pizza world.
1:13:10But, yeah, I mean, I still do illustrations for some of my clients and I did a few drawings for Upside and other clients around the world. I had no idea you did some of those drawings for Upside. Yeah, yeah, I do. I've done a lot of, I mean, I used to do a lot of art at Roberta's. Yeah, I know that. I mean, of course, I know your history. I mean, you created this identity that was iconic and influential, but you're also doing design consulting, too. I didn't quite grasp that. That's neat. Yeah. Anything else from your trip to Italy that you want to want to? You're dropping so much great stuff here.
1:13:47I just think it's really helpful and very cool. I mean, I just I love Italy so much and it's starting to become kind of like an obsession of, you know, needing to go and explore all the different areas. But I think that something like a takeaway for for people who are listening in our planning trips is like, you know, get off the beaten path. Like, yeah, Modena was amazing and there was like no tourists there. Yeah. You know, we went to a water park that was on the outskirts of Modena, you know, like just signed up, bought tickets. And it was like, like just Italian families, you know, dealing with the heat, you know, like I want to go to like all these like Trentino and like, I mean, there's so many different like off the beaten path.
1:14:44It's not just Rome and Puglia and Tuscany. There's so much in Italy. I want to go to Umbria. That's one on my list I've heard. Yes. Tuscany on a budget in the best possible way. Yeah. From locals, they told me that. Last summer, we drove to Umbria from Tuscany for just one day. We were like, why did we not spend more time there? Yeah. I definitely want to go back there. Yeah, definitely. Yeah. Do you ever do tours of Italy? Have you ever been booked to? Yes. Or like with like listeners of our show? Have you ever? Yes, I have. I've done private tours and I would love to do more of those. I did a pizza tour of Rome.
1:15:28It was, you know, I promised as a pizza tour, but I, as maybe have caught on, it turns into like a Roman history tour as well. Yeah. Just because I'm, I mean, I'm really like obsessed about just Italian, not just Roman. Italian history is so incredible. It's had so many waves of interesting things. Going to the North, really, you realize, too, like how much interesting stuff was happening in the Middle Ages there and then leading into the Renaissance. But, yeah, I'd love to do that. And, you know, more than just pizza, I'm really interested in kind of all of the cuisine and going to producers.
1:16:13and that's always really great going to like, you know, I've taken people to wineries and to flour mills and things like that. So, you know, it's, I don't know if that would ever be like a full-time thing for me. There's a lot of really talented people in that space, but I think maybe it's like, you know, I'm a chef. So like that's a little bit of a something, like I'm a working chef. So I think that that kind of gets you, I mean a lot of the best things that I was able to organize in this trip and previous trips is because of my colleagues in the industry. Yeah, you can make those connections.
1:16:50Well, we do taste travels. I'm just saying. So maybe we could talk about something. Get some of the books for 26. I feel like it might – maybe in the future. I think you've really outlined why Italy is so important to you and your deep connections to industry, not just with pizza but throughout the cuisine of Italy. It's so impressive. I'm very surprised that you care so deeply about this. Not surprised, but I respect your interest in it and your deep knowledge, not just of pizza. Yeah, I mean, I think that, you know, one of the things that's so important about Italy is this, and it goes so far back.
1:17:33But this thing that they do where they like they are controlling the quality of the food. Yeah. And it's not just about money. And yes, there are some, you know, volume produced things, but they are there is. And I guess if you are like a, you know, real like diehard, like kind of libertarian American or whatever, it might look like it's like overregulation or and maybe it harms their GDP or whatever. things like this but like it's hard to argue with the end result of like you know like uh like the the slow food movement you know and um the the like the you get snack foods like one of our favorite things to do is just go to grocery store and get junk food for the kids like snacks to have at the house but i mean even those you look at the ingredients and it's like this is not bad really it's not that bad you know i mean there was like these like pastries that we were getting and it was like they're sourdough you know like they're like have a long they have a natural 11 fermentation fermentation yeah i mean and and it's like there's no glyphosate are illegal bromine flour is legal bleach flour is illegal like they've they've they're protecting their heritage and food is an important part of their heritage along with art and culture and literature and music and they are, they guard it, you know?
1:18:58I mean, and yeah, they're very good at making money, but they're tempering that with this guarding of the quality of what they, of their life and, you know, of things that they make. And maybe it's more inefficient, but, you know, like - Bless them for that. We don't need efficiency. It's all about efficiency. It's not. Yeah. we'll wrap and just like let's return to New York. We talked about upside just in general. What's exciting you on the pizza scene right now? Like new openings or even established places. I know it's a broad question, but always want to get your take. Yeah. I mean, I haven't been back since the, the, the boys got their like groundbreaking review by the person.
1:19:45But Cheris is like, I went when it was still, I went like three times when they were still doing slices. Yeah. Spend some time with them and like, it's great. I mean, I love what they're doing. I love the use of the high quality Italian products and then high quality American products. I did a project in Pennsylvania recently in Littitz called Cavalo. And I used the Caputo Brothers mozzarella for the first time and I loved it. And they're using that mozzarella and that's, I love to see that. It's awesome. It's a really, it is a different mozzarella. It's very special, naturally fermented. It's really deep in flavor.
1:20:22It's very good.
1:20:26I'm excited to, you know, I would like to see, and I've had some people talking to me about like Roman style, like Tonda pizza happening. So I see some stuff maybe coming down the pipeline in that area. It's been launched a few times over the past 15 years. Yeah, like Marta. Marta, yeah, I think of Marta a lot. I think it's got to be done the right way, which is it's got to be just a box and cheap and volume. And you got to tell people, look, don't get this pizza delivered. Don't take it to go. Sit down. That's a lot of rules for a New Yorker. I know. I know. It just might not work in the city, unfortunately.
1:21:09Yeah. I got to give a shout out to Upside alum who worked at Upside and Norm's Rosario. And he just opened a place called Alvo's. Oh, okay. And on, I think it's Court Street or Smith Street. I think it's on Smith Street. And he's doing some really interesting stuff. It's like, you know, it's kind of like in the vein of Diamond Slice, if you've been there. It's also great. It's in Greenpoint. it's in the vein of kind of like hey like this is like you know old school New York pizza we're gonna have salad pizza we're gonna have buffalo chicken pizza it's gonna have too much cheese on it it's gonna be like you know like what's a direct fermentation like whatever man like they're just doing you know like kind of reviving that kind of 80s like more is more New York pizza yeah I mean the salad slice and salad pie out on Long Island you think about the popularity of that, bringing that and channeling that in Brooklyn would be cool.
1:22:11It's new to me. Yeah. It's my old neighborhood. I love that. Yeah. Yeah. Check that out. Alvo's. And it's a cool space. And Rosario's just a great operator and a great guy. He deserves a lot of credit. He's worked really hard in the business. He worked at Badia when I first met him. He was there. The guy's been a student. Made the rounds. He worked at Best Pizza. He's a student of the game. Best Pizza. He finally got his, yeah, I mean, Best Pizza is always amazing. Yeah. You know, anything Frank's doing, I want to be, you know, I want to be there eating it. The F &F series is great, like what they're doing.
1:22:47So I look forward to going to another one of those. Yeah, those are fun. Yeah. I mean, I'm sure there's some, someone's plotting something right now. Well, probably the time we run this, there'll be a few more openings. I'm just going to wrap it there, Anthony. It was such a great catch up. Yeah. Thank you so much for joining the show. Thanks for having me. It was a pleasure. I appreciate it.
1:23:12This is Taste is hosted and produced by Eliza Abarbanal and me, Matt Rodbar. The show is edited by lead producer Clayton Gumbert and supervised by Pat Stango, director of media production and development at Penguin Random House. Thanks to Shalia Harris and the production team at Penguin Random House. Theme music by Steve Rydell Logo and guest illustrations by Ellie Skrzat Visit Taste Online at tastecooking.com And make sure to subscribe to our newsletter To keep updated on all cool things in the world of taste
From the publisher
Matt was so excited to invite his friend Maurizio Leo to New York City to walk the streets and eat a lot of pizza. Maurizio is the author of The Perfect Loaf, an incredible cookbook and online community dedicated to all things sourdough. Matt and Maurizio visited seven pizzerias and, along with lead producer Clayton Gumbert, tasted their way through the city’s best (and maybe not best) slices. So what did they think of Joe’s, L’industrie, Mama’s TOO!, Lucia, Upside, Scarr’s, and F&F? Tune in!
Also on the episode, Matt catches up with Anthony Falco. Falco is a global pizza consultant and a true pioneer in the pizza world. He just returned from a three-week trip to Italy, and we talk about all the pizza styles and trends he spotted there. We also move beyond pizza to discuss the modern trattoria scene, good and great gelato, and how Anthony’s appreciation for art dovetails with his interest in the culinary world.
For more, listen to This Is TASTE 344: Pizza Week with Anthony Falco.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices




