The Don of Boys and Men: Richard Reeves

28 Oct 2025 · 59 min · 25 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Richard Reeves discusses why boys and young men are struggling in the UK and how to talk about masculinity, education, mental health, fatherhood, and labor participation without framing it as zero-sum or demonizing boys.

Guest backgrounds

Richard Reeves is a writer, scholar, and former policy advisor; president of the American Institute for Boys and Men; chair of the Centre for Policy Research on Boys and Men (UK). Hosts are Elliott Rae and Joeli Brearley (advocacy-focused parenting and gender conversation).

Key claims

Boys fall behind across education, especially lower-income and white working-class boys. A “slow-burn” male mental health crisis exists, with suicide as the biggest killer of British men. Young men are losing ground in the labor market (lower earnings, lower participation). The debate should avoid both “feminist-conditioned” and grievance-based men’s narratives. Sex/misogyny education must be empathetic to avoid radicalizing boys toward online misogyny.

Notable examples

“Third of primary schools” lack a single male teacher; “one size fits all” schooling; Barack Obama’s podcast remarks about investing in boys/men; dad role models and longer paternity leave; oxytocin bonding differences (men via physical play/“throwing them around”).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

The Debate on Boys and Men's Issues

0:46 to 3:06

Exploration of the complexities surrounding boys' issues and societal perceptions.

“His research spans education, fatherhood, mental health, masculinity, and the changing role of men in modern society.”

Challenges Facing Boys and Men

3:06 to 5:00

Discussion on educational disparities, mental health crises, and labor market issues.

“Yes and I've found I'm always very careful to communicate in exactly the way that you've described there and to frame discussions, arguments, debates, information in that way.”

Future of Boys and Young Men

5:00 to 8:05

Insights into the potential future challenges and opportunities for young men.

“Especially for boys from lower income backgrounds.”

Government Approaches to Masculinity Education

8:05 to 12:02

Assessment of government strategies on teaching masculinity and misogyny.

“So we're losing men from the labour market unnecessarily, we're losing them from our classrooms, and then most tragically, sometimes we're losing them altogether from our lives.”

Healthy Conversations on Masculinity

12:02 to 14:00

Suggestions for engaging boys in positive discussions about masculinity.

“So I'm reasonably pleased with the new guidance on sex education that came out from the UK.”

Reevaluating Masculinity and Toxicity

14:00 to 15:10

Discussion on the implications and perceptions surrounding masculinity and the term 'toxic masculinity'.

“It has to be not prescriptive and it has to be not pathologizing.”

Exploring Identity and Gender

15:10 to 17:10

Conversation about the importance of defining personal identity beyond traditional masculinity and femininity.

“And that's the question they start with.”

Feminism's Influence on Masculinity

17:10 to 20:00

Analyzing how the feminist movement has shaped views on femininity and masculinity in modern society.

“But it also didn't feel the need to somehow think we had to get rid of femininity.”

Learning from the Women's Movement

20:00 to 22:40

Discussion on how men's movements can learn from the successes and challenges of the women's movement.

“There's been times in my life where being stoic has really helped me.”

The Importance of Role Models

22:40 to 24:30

Exploring the critical role of male figures and role models in the upbringing of boys and their development.

“And too many people on the right are too critical of non-traditional forms of masculinity, whether that's from people who are trans or just stay-at-home dads or kind of whatever.”
Show all 25 chapters

Fatherhood's Impact on Families

24:30 to 28:00

Discussing how involved fatherhood positively influences children and family dynamics.

“And this connects back a little bit to our skepticism about some of these curricula that are being imposed, which is like, I honestly think the best way to learn how to be in the world is from older people, right?”

The Importance of Paternity Leave

28:00 to 29:40

Dads' involvement in early parenting improves outcomes for mothers, children, and marriages.

“But we also know the benefits for children.”

The Long-Term Nature of Parenting

29:40 to 32:05

Parenting is a two-decade journey that requires shared responsibilities over time.

“But in my case, I was much more that when the kids were like coming into early six, seven, and then I did a bit more again in their teens.”

Boys Falling Behind in Education

32:05 to 33:22

An exploration of the educational challenges boys face compared to girls.

“sour yeah yeah important point which i want to talk to you about education we know that boys are falling behind at every level of the education system.”

The Need for Male Representation in Education

33:22 to 35:49

Male teachers and hands-on learning positively impact boys' educational outcomes.

“And I'm using hands-on very much inverted commas.”

Addressing Gender Differences in Education

35:49 to 38:29

Discussion on how education systems often favor girls and the need for a more flexible approach.

“And I would say would resonate with my kids, actually.”

Natural Differences and Gender Equality

38:29 to 41:52

Understanding natural gender differences can help create a more equitable society.

“What it means is you're just allowing a little bit of room for natural differences.”

Biological Differences in Parenting

41:52 to 42:03

Exploration of how different interactions create bonding experiences for mothers and fathers.

The Biological Differences in Parenting

42:03 to 46:46

Discover how biological differences between mothers and fathers influence parenting styles and bonding with children.

Encouraging Men in Caring Roles

46:46 to 49:39

Explore strategies for attracting more men to caregiving professions and the importance of financial incentives.

“How do you think we go about doing that?”

Advice for Government, Boys, and Parents

49:39 to 54:03

Get actionable advice for government, teenage boys, and parents to improve the lives of boys and men.

“By the way, we have a huge shortage of many of those workers, particularly things like care, which have up until this point very often been filled by migrants.”

The Importance of Tone and Positivity

54:03 to 56:03

Learn about the significance of a positive tone when discussing issues affecting boys and men.

“And let's all just have a bit more of a sense of humor about this.”

Optimism for the Future

56:03 to 56:51

Discussion on the positive shift among younger generations towards happiness.

Aims and Objectives of the New Center

56:51 to 58:18

Richard discusses the objectives and initiatives of his new center focused on boys and men.

“I think the second thing is to keep broadening the permission space for this conversation, right?”

Closing Thoughts with Richard Reeves

58:18 to 58:49

A light-hearted conclusion with gratitude expressed to Richard Reeves.

“And so we need to build some institutions that help keep this conversation going with high quality, non-political research and evidence.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:05Elliott Rae:Welcome back to To Be A Boy podcast with me, Elliott Rae. Joeli Brearley. So today we have the Don of Boys and Men, someone whose work has shaken up the global conversation on this topic. Someone who is not afraid to ask uncomfortable questions. Richard Reeves is a writer, scholar and former policy advisor who has made waves with his bestselling book of Boys and Men. In this seminal book, Richard lays out a clear but challenging case that boys are struggling, often in silence, and we are not paying enough attention. Richard is the president of the American Institute for Boys and Men and chair of the new Centre for Policy Research on Boys and Men here in the UK.

0:46Elliott Rae:His research spans education, fatherhood, mental health, masculinity, and the changing role of men in modern society. His work has been praised across the political spectrum, but it's also sparked intense debate, and that's exactly why we wanted to talk to him. In this episode, we go deep. We ask, why are boys falling behind in school? What's behind the emotional crisis in young men? Has concern for boys become taboo? And what needs to change in our homes, our classrooms, and in our culture? So welcome, Richard, to Be A Boy podcast. Thanks so much for joining us. Wow, what an intro. You need to give me a minute because I'm just telling my comms team to start calling me the Don.

1:26Never had that before. So just give me like that's it. That's it from now on. You're welcome. My job is done.

1:32Elliott Rae:You're welcome. It's well deserved. Seriously, I have recommended this book to pretty much everyone I've ever met in my life. I would go as far to say that the current conversation we're having around boys and men, I think this is really the foundation of it. so first and foremost thank you for writing it has helped me so much in my advocacy in my work thank you and back at you by the way i mean thank you for your advocacy as well around this space i mean i think what we share is something that this whole issue really needed which is to break past this idea that it's somehow zero sum right i mean the way i think about this is that there was almost like two camps before there was the camp that said we should care about boys and men because we care about women we need men to be better allies to be nicer to women etc And so it was kind of like a feminist approach to men, right?

2:18And there's nothing wrong with that, necessarily, but it was like conditioned. It was very much, we care about men because we care about women. And then the other side was much more of the kind of men's rights-y side, which was much more grievance-based, which was like, actually, women are the problem, right? The reason that men are struggling is because women have come too far, we need to go back, etc. And there wasn't that much space, it felt like, between those two. They were quite powerful and very separate bits of the debate and then I think people like you and others have actually successfully tried to do what I also have tried to do which is to say no no no no no we can care about boys and men and notice their problems and continue to care about women and girls and notice their problems as well and although that sounds almost comically simple I think actually it's really quite radical that turns out in terms of moving this debate forward.

3:08Elliott Rae:Yes and I've found I'm always very careful to communicate in exactly the way that you've described there and to frame discussions, arguments, debates, information in that way. And I think when we do, we can cut through. And actually, everyone is interested. Women, men, non-binary people, mums, dads, everybody has some stake in this conversation. So I'm glad we're in this place now where we can have the conversation out loud. And it's okay. And it's safe. And it's welcome. Parenting out loud, not least. Parenting out loud. But it's also interesting because I don't know if you've had a chance yet to look at the latest piece from the Obamas.

3:42So Barack Obama went on his wife, Michelle Obama's podcast. He talks a lot about boys and men in that podcast, very much in our way, if I can put it that way, like it's not zero sum, but he says things like, look, we've been very intentional about investing in women and girls, and that's good, but we haven't been as intentional about investing in boys and men. That has been a mistake. That's from Obama. And the progressives in particular, in our language around this, this is him speaking now, have tended to focus on what's wrong with boys and men rather than what's right with them again this is barack obama and what's interesting is the response to that so of course all the mainstream media just wanted to know is like are they getting divorced what's the state of their marriage which was like three minutes of the podcast right and then and then it went into all those details but it also noticed some people more on the like conservative side of this argument posted clips of him talking about this and noticing that he was a bit halting that he did feel the need to talk about women and girls and they were like eye rolling like even when he does talk about boys and men i'm like for the love of god take a win i mean it's barack obama talking to michelle obama for

4:46Elliott Rae:the love of god give the guy a break and i think you know your book made his reading list last year last year last year yeah it's probably not a coincidence i think he's probably been influenced by by the work you've been doing and and the new narrative yeah it feels like you've got a massive part to play in that um okay let's start with the bigger picture so i'm so interested in your your current thoughts right now around the current state of where we are with boys and men in the uk what do you feel like are the biggest challenges that boys and men are facing yeah so there's probably three buckets that i put them in one is just an education where we just continue to see this very very wide gap pretty much every level of education you see it through you know BCSEs, into A-level, into college, etc.

5:30Especially for boys from lower income backgrounds. As you look at actually like white working class boys from industrial areas, on a lot of these measures are actually kind of performing the worst. There are some other racial groups as well, and I don't in any way want to be misunderstood here as saying, time for the white guys to get the attention. But I do think it's interesting that in the UK there is really this strong class dimension to it, which cuts across race, but is more driven by class. And so in education you see massive gaps in higher education, etc. in the UK now, with just the boys falling quite a long way behind in classrooms.

6:02I think that the decline in male teachers is a problem. I think the fact that a third of our primary schools don't have a single male teacher is a problem. One of my favorite lines in the women's movement is you can't be it if you can't see it. And so if we wanted to send a message to boys that education is a female pursuit, one way to do that is to make sure that all the teachers are women. That's a good start, right? I mean, when all the doctors were men, it was hard to persuade women they should go to medical school or to take that side of things more seriously. So education and mental health, whilst I'm pleased that the suicide rate isn't rising as anything like as quickly as it is in the US, nonetheless, the fact that suicide is the biggest killer of British men, I think is a huge problem.

6:43And one that I'm glad that the men's health strategy is taking seriously, led by Wes Streeting, etc. And so I think this slow burn mental health crisis among boys and men is just as significant, no more significant, but just as significant as the maybe faster burn crisis we've seen among girls and young women, more obviously driven by social media. So I think there's something different going on, overlapping, but different going on. But I do think the mental health crisis among boys and young men is every bit as real. And I really worry about that when you see such huge loss of life from suicide, for example.

7:15And then the third area is in the labor market, where just in terms of work, right, I think that, you know, for very good reason, the world where men, particularly without skills, could just go into the labor market, get a great job, they'd be fine, has largely gone for reasons we could get into, but would probably get quite boring, good and bad. But nonetheless, it is true. I was very struck just recently, the study showing that this is kind of US, but I think some of it's true in the UK too, that just a lot of the unemployment is really being driven by young men. Young men actually earn a little bit less than young women now.

7:45The decline in labor force participation is greater among young men. And if we're serious about these growth targets that the UK government has, the only way to do that, this is work from the Centre for Policy Research on Men and Boys, there's no alternative but to increase labour force participation among men and women, of course. But there's so much more we have to do to kind of get more men back into and engaged in the labour market. So we're losing men from the labour market unnecessarily, we're losing them from our classrooms, and then most tragically, sometimes we're losing them altogether from our lives.

8:12Elliott Rae:And this work is so urgent, because I think about 10 years from now, so 2035, if we don't start addressing the issues that you've laid out and more, where do you think we're going to be in 10 years? What kind of men, young men, do you think we're going to have in society if we don't start to really tackle these issues now, today? Well, of course, the honest answer is I don't know. And what I see is a lot of young men, you know, I've raised three boys myself, they're in their 20s now. I'm not young. I'm not young. but I but I some of my best friends are young people young men um uh and so I I think that honestly think that it's just all up for grabs to some extent I think that we're seeing this huge cultural kaleidoscope that's been shaken and the pieces are still moving it hasn't settled yet and so I think this whole question like what should I be what should I do and again I'll point a bit of blame here I think at some of the mainstream conversation has been very good at pointing out to boys and young men and what they should not do, what they should not be.

9:11Good, mostly, but they haven't done a very good job. We haven't done a very good job of saying what they should do, what they should be. And so there's a lack of a script. There's a lack of a sense of like, what will I be needed for, especially and distinctively because, not despite the fact that I'm a man. And it serves a real vacuum here, but look, it could go a number of different ways. Like I think it's huge. Like we see men doing more work in the home. We see, as you know, Elliot, more work around parenting, huge interest from young men around parenting etc but they don't want to do that at the expense of being a guy if i can put it that way on the other hand i think that there's also a real danger that if we don't pay attention to these problems and work quickly enough that actually those problems turn into grievances and those grievances i think can then really be exploited by folks who say yeah you're hurting and i know why it's because of them it's feminism it's women it's whatever and so i think i think it's really this critical moment now where there's a lot of uncertainty about the path to answer your question.

10:05So my positive moments, I think 2035, we'll be coming through this cultural moment and we'll be finding a way to honour men and women with more gender equality, but without androgyny. And that we've helped boys and young men into this new world. And we haven't pathologised them. We haven't told them that they're the problem. But in my darker moments, I think we don't get our hands around this. It gets darker and young men and young women become convinced that the real enemy is each other. And that's a very dark future. Do you think we've seen the government in the UK try and get a grasp of this after adolescence?

10:37And first they said they were going to play adolescence in schools and now they're saying that they're going to teach misogyny as part of the curriculum. Do you think that that could be a step in the right direction or do you actually think that could cause more harm than good? Well I'm very pleased that they're not showing adolescence as a compulsory part of the curriculum. I think that would have been a very bad move. I'm distressed to see that just as the UK government makes that decision, the French education minister came out a couple of weeks ago and said that she was considering showing adolescence in all French schools.

11:06Maybe they'll play in English as part of a language class. I don't know. But, and the reason I think it's, I think it was, I mean, actually, I think most women's groups agreed and the petition against it seemed to me to be led by as much by feminists as anybody else. Because I think if you're a young man and you're sitting there and you think, okay, I'm watching this. They're making me watch this. Why are they making me watch this? What am I supposed to take away from this? And I think it would play into this sense that we think that you're a monster in waiting. You're a problem that needs fixing.

11:35You're a misogynist in the making, if we're not careful. And that just, to me, flies in the face of the empirical evidence about what's actually happening in the minds of most young men and boys. And also it's counterproductive. I think that if you want to radicalize young men, then the surest way to do that is to wag your finger at them or roll your eyes at them or blame them, because that's exactly what the online misogynists are saying we will do. And so in a weird way, it plays directly into the hands of the reactionaries to do that. So I'm reasonably pleased with the new guidance on sex education that came out from the UK.

12:08It says we should not treat boys as if they're the problem. We should treat them with empathy. We should be very careful about that. So I think even in there, there's some of the messages have landed. And so I think when you're teaching about misogyny, just as when you're teaching about any kind of identity-based hatred, whether that's racism or anti-Semitism, whatever. I think just the question becomes how you do it, right? Is misogyny a problem? Yes. Should we be making every effort to make sure that it's not something that's socially acceptable? Absolutely. Just as the other problems that I've mentioned, but should we be singling it out in a very different way?

12:38We need to just be very careful. I've learned that young men and boys are incredibly discerning about the implications of any approach you make to them. They are very smart. They totally get it. They see what's being said behind what's being said, and you have to be extremely careful about approaching them with empathy and compassion and open mind not with

12:57Elliott Rae:prior judgment yeah yeah i've definitely been quite concerned with the guidance i think in principle the guidance is a good thing like we should be talking to boys about masculinity and masogyny but it's as you say richard it's such a sensitive nuanced topic it has to be approached in the right way and there is such a risk of it backfiring and actually maybe recruiting more boys into the manosphere directing them to toxic online masculinity influences if it's done in the wrong way. So I think we need to really talk to the government about how this lands positively and learn from some of the people that have been doing this work for many years.

13:31Elliott Rae:On the point around masculinity, how do you think we should be approaching boys when we have that conversation about masculinity? So the people who are listening who are either parents or maybe they work in schools, they talk to young boys. What have you seen that really works in regards to opening up healthy conversations about masculinity with young boys? Yeah, again, it's not really my area of expertise. And honestly, I suspect that the two of you will know more about this than me. So I can just offer some observations, which is that what I think works well is, first of all, it has to be really open.

14:04It has to be not prescriptive and it has to be not pathologizing. So you don't start off at the bat as saying masculinity is like a problem needs to be fixed. I think one of the problems with the term toxic masculinity is it became so embedded. Like I've had a friend to me last week that her daughter came home. No, she'd been having a conversation and she mentioned the word masculinity just in the context of something else entirely, just something about masculinity. And her daughter said, oh, toxic masculinity. And she went, no, I'm not. I just said masculinity. And she went, no, toxic masculinity.

14:32And she went, no, no, I'm not using, I'm not adding toxic. And the girl who was like 15 went, you can use masculinity without toxic? I mean, honestly, because she'd only heard the term masculinity with the prefix toxic, right? And I honestly, I don't think that's, I mean, I don't think ordinary people use the term that much without it. I mean, I just, I don't, so I really worry about that. And also I think that to try and start with what kind of person do you want to be? Sure. If you're working with boys and men, what kind of man do you want to be? Great. Nice open question. There's a boy, a men's college in the, in the U S that has the only, I think like gender studies curriculum that only has men in it.

15:11Cause it's only men's college. And that's the question they start with. What kind of man do you want to be? And so you don't talk about masculinity straight away. I'm not sure that's the right term. Just like, and in a way, what kind of person do you want to be? And then bring gender into that, like as you see fit, and then maybe get to what kind of, what does that mean? Do you think that's different for men, for women? Do you think as a man, that's different. Obama in his podcast was talking a lot about the feeling of being a protector. That's really interesting, I think. Like what does protection mean in this kind of modern world?

15:39I don't want to say that that's a terrible instinct. He said to use strength to protect, But you've got to think, yeah, but when does protection become control? When does protection become dominance? But let's have a conversation about that instinct to provide. Provide what? You may not be the same sort of breadwinner, but the idea that you're going to contribute to your family, be it quotes provide. Let's unpack those ideas. And it's just a really, really open way. And so I actually think the term masculinity itself honestly might not be the best way in. We don't talk about femininity, I find.

16:07We don't, you know, we never say, what does it mean to be feminine? but we do say what does it mean to be masculine what is masculinity right and when we talk about masculinity we talk about it in very limiting ways what you can't do whereas when we talk about women it's very wide-ranging you can do these things you can be strong you can be do mathematics you can be a scientist masculinity and boys it's always about it feels to me very negatively the toxic masculinity or it's about what you can't do rather than what you can do why do you think that is why do you think we don't talk about femininity because i think women have been subjected to patriarchy for a very long time and we've been told for a long time about the things that we can't do and so now i think we don't ever want to put women in a box because they've been in a box for so long so we avoid saying anything that would make them feel limited about what they can and they can't do whereas for because we have felt that men have caused a lot of problems historically and they have forced women into these positions we feel that we can tell men what is okay and what isn't okay I think we've kind of switched it on its head if that makes sense yeah I want to try an idea out on both of you but especially you Jolie because one of the things that I think has happened is that the feminist movement the women's movement generally did exactly what you said, which is to have a more expansive vision rather than a narrow one.

17:37But it also didn't feel the need to somehow think we had to get rid of femininity. Now, there was a moment, I think, where that was a real debate within the women's movement, where it's like actually, you know, shoulder pads. Margaret Thatcher had to have voice training to deepen her voice, stand differently, do assertiveness training. In other words, you know, become more like a man in terms of the way you can behave. Yeah, a lot of dads said in the 90s. Yes, exactly. And I think enough women just went, hang on, hang on. I don't want to have to act like a man. I just want to be CEO or have an equal shot at being CEO.

18:09And if I quite like to still wear like a dress and if I want to choose to, like if I want to, or if I want to act in certain more feminine ways, if on average women are a little bit more caring or emotionally kind of connected, et cetera, like don't beat me up for that. Right. I don't have to act like a man to have equality. And I think that was an incredibly positive kind of move, if you like, for the women's movement. Right. I don't think we've done the same yet for masculinity right i don't think we're comfortable enough with the idea that like there are just some ways of being in the world they're a little bit more masculine and that tend to be more attached to men right not all and that's cool that's fine let's let's get over it and so in some ways i find myself a bit frustrated by the fact that we're stuck in such long conversations about masculinity when i think the women's movement showed us how to in a way just default over that i don't quite know where that leads me i mean i think the men's movement has a lot to learn from the women's movement i think we've been through a lot of this and we have a lot of insight into how you overcome these stereotypes about how you should behave but that's not to say that we've overcome them because women still tear chunks out of each other sometimes for you know you can't be a feminist you're wearing makeup or you really do they still really that still happens that still happens and we still judge each other for the way that we parent and work we still will judge another woman for working 60 hour weeks if she has two children and you know men will judge us for that as well but we are our own worst enemy sometimes we will judge each other but at the same time we went from the 90s where you know it was anorexia chic and you have to weigh about four stone in order to be attractive to us now celebrating each other's bodies no matter what they look like and I think that transition took a long time and what it took was women having the courage to publicly go here are my roles here is me in all my glory you may think that's disgusting but I don't care and then a load of other women going yes girl you look great and I've got you back and I think what men are missing is sometimes that public camaraderie around a shift in the way that they behave until they find that community and that way of supporting each other through that, I think you're going to be stuck in these stereotypes.

20:32Elliott Rae:Yeah, I think that's right. I always try to tell when I'm speaking to men and boys, you know, we speak about the man box, you know, and inside the man box around being stoic, providing, breadwinning, being brave, and encouraging men to come out of that man box, but not demonizing that box. There's been times in my life where being stoic has really helped me. Being a provider for my family has really helped me. Like being brave, being angry has really helped me and my family. Like they are not bad things in isolation. If that's all we have, if that's all we can be, that's when the issues start.

21:04Elliott Rae:So I think that that conversation we started off at the beginning when we were talking about the right and the left and the kind of demonization of masculinity, if you like, and a lot of boys and men will talk about a war of masculinity. I think sometimes it starts from that point of you're trying to say that me and some of the things that I live and do and my values are bad and wrong when actually it's more about if we are living in that kind of small narrow definition of masculinity which yes if you're if you're if you're restricted to that but what's interesting I think Jolie your point about women being their own worst enemies is kind of playing out or have is playing out a little bit here too but it's actually men who are very often policing each other's expressions of what it means to be a man and masculinity and I think to some extent because it feels a little bit threatened etc but i would say that one of the issues one of the like i take very seriously this idea about learning from the women's movement one of my most fun conversations i've had is with gloria steinham uh and i'm trying to get her on stage to talk about this but we had quite a long conversation about what can what can we learn from the women's movements a lot of which actually overlaps with what you're saying the way that the man box is used by others not by you elliot is sometimes in a way that does end up making it seem like that's bad, right?

22:13The men who are trapped in the man box are kind of sad and angry and whatever. And rather than saying, we don't want you to be restricted to the man box. And I think what the women's movement successfully did, by and large, I accept it's not completely over, Joel, it by and large said, look, you do you. And actually got less judgy of a woman who chooses to look after her kids or a woman who chooses to pursue her career. And there's a little bit more like you go girl, kind of regardless, right? And I don't think we've got our movement to that point yet. I think too many people on the left are quite critical of traditional forms of masculinity as expressed by Elliot.

22:46And too many people on the right are too critical of non-traditional forms of masculinity, whether that's from people who are trans or just stay-at-home dads or kind of whatever. And so it feels like there's a kind of similar war going on within men. I like the days when I get accused from the one side of being a cut. Well, my favorite one recently was this guy has to ask his wife's boyfriend's permission before going out right this is a huge thing on the online right which is that like we're all being cucked we're a soy or soy boy etc right not real men right so you get that but then on the same day i got someone saying this guy is just a kind of camouflage just sort of has progressive camouflage for a men's rights thing don't be fooled right he's a reactionary in disguise i'm like good day because they are just the fringes right but interestingly both men both men saying that right yeah and that's why through um through

23:39Elliott Rae:parenting out loud what we i think one of the most powerful things things we do is just platform dads talking about how they parent loudly like we've got a video in today with a dad with his 16 week old baby talking about his return back to work and how he's nervous about it and the amount of messages that we get saying i've learned so much just by seeing other dads and these men are men, right? Like firefighters, teachers, nurses, civil servants. They are what you would call manly men, but just existing in a different way. And I think the more we can do that to show, look, you can operate in and out the box.

24:14Elliott Rae:You can be who you want to be. You can take on a variety of different roles. What works for you? And we need to give men flexibility to do that.

24:24Elliott Rae:on the fatherhood topic so you've spoken quite a lot about fathers and the impact of fathers and male role models on boys i'm really interested to hear your your current thinking around the impact of men in boys's lives and where are we without that when when boys don't have men in their lives older men what do you think are the impacts yeah i think to start with i do think that we believe our eyes more than our ears. And this connects back a little bit to our skepticism about some of these curricula that are being imposed, which is like, I honestly think the best way to learn how to be in the world is from older people, right?

25:02Older siblings, parents, teachers, church leaders, community leaders, coaches, whatever. And that then within that, so that's the broad message, right? We, as kids, we're like very social, right? We're trying to figure out how to be in this world, in this culture. How do I succeed in this culture all around me? We are, to use Roy Baumeister's phrase, we are cultural animals. We're actually evolved to be cultural and to take in these cultural signals as to how to be in the world, right? Then within that, I think there is something of a gender angle, right? I think there's that broad, that's the big story, which is how to be a grownup, how to be a good, responsible, kind person.

25:35And you can get that from any older role models, regardless of gender. But then I think we also have a little bit of an eye to how should I be as a father? How should I be as a mother? How should I be as a man or as a woman? And I think if we were just doing a better job of having positive role models, maybe we wouldn't be having this slightly agonizing conversation about how a health studies teacher is going to teach 16-year-old boys about masculinity. It will almost suddenly be a woman doing it, right? That feels quite torturous, right? I just feel like more male teachers, more male coaches, more dads around, et cetera, and especially dad.

26:04There's this tendency to talk about the importance of role models. And I think they are, I will go out on a limb here, I think they are especially important for boys. I think because masculinity is a little bit more socially constructed. The role of dads and role models is even more important. And so that's why I think fathers matter. But I think it's why this broader group of men really matter too. And so I think it's true that it takes a village to raise a child. But I think it's also true that at least some of the villagers have to be men to raise our boys well, especially. And again, it's something that Obama touched on very strongly in his recent interview.

Read the full transcript

26:35And so I can, I can keep hiding behind Obama now. That's the nice thing I can say. It's not me saying, Barack Obama said it be angry with him call him a cuck or a reactionary I don't whichever whatever day whatever day I'll just call you Richard Obama from now on you're basically part of the family no I'm just like I'm just a heat shield for me now it's amazing it's like fantastic like don't get angry with me get angry you know email email Obama but yeah I've come to believe that fatherhood is really really important and precious and that most of what fathers do and I'd be interested to know what you both think of this but most of what fathers and mothers do is interchangeable right it overlaps right there's no there's no feminine mystique to changing a nappy right um but i do think as kids get older especially i think that we do bring some subtly different things to the to the parenting enterprise around risk taking around getting out into the world around getting this balance right equipping i see dads as almost like helping to equip their kids um and so i think that that's a beautiful tension between maternal and paternal instincts if we allow it to be yeah i mean i would agree wholeheartedly i found it really interesting there was a study done recently and they found it interesting they felt they had to do this study to check that men were just as disturbed by babies crying in the night as women were and they found that oh yeah I mean amazing men can also hear it's you know so they don't they don't go deaf for the first two years of a child's life um I am absolutely you know I campaigned for this for 10 years as part of pregnant and screwed for dads to have longer paternity leave and it to be better paid and part of the reason I did that was not just because it closes the motherhood penalty We know that if dads spend more time with their children in the early days, women do better in their careers and they have more income as a result.

28:24But we also know the benefits for children. But also, I think the knock-on impacts are enormous. My dad went straight back to work. He worked very hard. We never saw him. And my parents ended up splitting up because they didn't understand each other. They had entirely different lives. My mom was the omnipresent mother, always there, always doing the caring. My dad was always at work, had no real involvement with the children at all. And they just ended up completely not aligning, not understanding each other's lives and ultimately divorced. And so you can see from the data as well that marriages are more likely to last if dads spend time with their children in those early days.

29:01And yet we're preventing them from doing so. So the impact in terms of men and their testosterone levels, their ability to connect with their children, their ability to feel different emotions, because it literally changes your brain, as we both know, Anna Machen, you know, and the research she's done around the brain changes in men. but it you know the benefits for men themselves the benefits for children the benefits for women in terms of their career their mental and physical health but also the benefits for marriages are so vast and yet we still push men back to work straight away I completely agree with that the only thing I would probably add I think it is an addition is that sometimes I think there's a tendency to focus like only on the early days and years which of course are very important but like it turns out that it takes a long time to raise children um and that actually if it's let's call it a two-decade project right um then actually over the course of those two decades you end up just evolving like who's doing what and when and like sharing and you're trying to keep you know maybe my my wife and i have done sort of tag team parenting or kind of relay parenting a bit more right which is like we kind of realize you can't have two very demanding jobs at the same time and so one of you needs to be kind of on the home front.

30:17But in my case, I was much more that when the kids were like coming into early six, seven, and then I did a bit more again in their teens. My wife took time off in between. It was very, it was, let's be honest, it was chaos. We both were able to kind of keep our careers alive, albeit maybe a little bit more slowly, and do the parenting bit. So I agree with you about that, Jolie, but I also think doing parenting, and Anna's new work actually on adolescence has really affected me. um not not the net you now have to say not the netflix show don't you um but at the period of adolescence and how particularly how important dads are for that and my own brother actually for weird reasons was able to take his parental leave when his kids he has two twin boys when they were 14 and he was thrilled about that because he thought they actually need me now more than at any other time and i think he was right about that and so what i don't want to do is sort of restrict the kind of parenting thing to those early years i agree that they're very important and we both need to be shoulder to shoulder around that but i but i think too many dads feel as if they haven't done their bit in the early years it then gets cemented these gender roles get cemented over time and that i think is what causes the problems like 10 years from now so in my case for example my wife did do more of the stuff like in the very early months and years but then i did a lot more later and we were both working equally hard in different ways throughout and i think in the end that's probably what it comes down to is like are you in this together right is everyone pulling their weight even if you're pulling in a different way at different times so when she was incredibly busy in a very high octane job for a while we barely saw her monday to friday by god i was pulling my weight on the home front but wow was she pulling her weight on the economic front right amazing um and i think we both felt that we were in it together and that seems to me to be the thing that you're getting at with the marriage satisfaction thing which is this sense of like no one's free riding on the labor of another that's when marriages go

32:05Elliott Rae:sour yeah yeah important point which i want to talk to you about education we know that boys are falling behind at every level of the education system. And I think that's one thing your book really helped to hit home. One of the key messages I got from your book was around education. Talk to us about the reasons that this is the case. Why is this? Well, I'm going to start by saying everything I'm about to follow with is based on scant empirical evidence, because there's just not enough research. It's one of the reasons I set up the Institute. It's one of the reasons I'm proud to be chair of the Centre in the UK.

32:38It's like actually doing like really high quality research on male education. It just hasn't been that big a field, scholarly field. But I think what we do know is a few things. One is that having more male teachers is positive. Even there, the evidence is a bit mixed to be candid, but certainly seems to skew in a kind of positive direction. And we need more research on that. And also, I wouldn't restrict that just to the educational outcomes. I think for boys to have more men in their lives is important in and of itself. Even if you can't do a randomized control trial showing the impact on GCSE results.

33:11But more men around, more after school activity, more sports, more opportunities to do physical activity. That seems pretty strongly associated with better outcomes for boys. More hands-on learning styles. And I'm using hands-on very much inverted commas. People think I'm talking here about getting back to the idea of woodworking. I still have the things that I made in my school woodworking class and they're not very good. I don't mean that, right? I just, I mean, I don't know about it. Are yours any good? Did you make good things?

33:40Elliott Rae:I don't think I kept them. I'll go into my parents' house on the weekend and say, Richard told me I should have my woodwork. I did one thing. It won't be there. It was absolutely horrible. This little box, the jewelry box, it's an absolutely horrible thing. And my parents have it like on a shelf in their dining room. And I was playing with it the other day and I dropped it and I broke the corner of it. And obviously I was like, well, this is some piece of absolute crap that I made when I was like 13 or something. And my mother was in tears because she was like, what, you made that? And I said, I made it, but it's terrible.

34:08But she's like, no, no, I've cared. And she cared 40 years or whatever. It's the effort that counts. It's the effort. Anyway, anyway, that's love. But I think that what I mean by that is it looks like boys, I hear I'm drawing a lot on Michael Reichert's work as well, who I think is just an amazing psychologist and he wrote a very good book on How to Raise a Boy. Boys seem to need to know a little bit more why I'm learning this before they care about the what. They just need to know the application. It needs to be more connected to the labor market, more connected to specific skills. They're just not as good at undertaking abstract tasks obediently.

34:36And so that's what I mean by more hands-on learning. It's like, tell me why this is important. Link it to the real world. By the way, that's also good for girls. It's just especially good for boys. And then the last thing is that boys do mature a bit later. I make quite a big deal of this, as you know, which is just absolutely true that like a 15-year-old girl on average is older than a 15-year-old boy. By as much as a year, actually, in certain skills, especially these organizational skills, these executive functioning skills, they're called. just like having your acts together skills, remembering your homework, turning your homework in, taking your homework, all that sort of stuff.

35:09And girls, they just get there a bit, again, not breaking news to anybody who's like ever met a boy or a girl or been a boy or a girl, but it is true. And I think that that's now playing out in the education system and giving girls a real advantage on the average because of their older, which we couldn't see before because we were busy back to Jolie's point, we were holding them back, right? We were actually artificially restricting girls' educational opportunities. And once we stopped doing that, their natural advantages were revealed. So I don't think that's a new natural advantage. I think it's just that girls weren't able to express it before because of the conditions of sexism that previously prevailed.

35:42I've heard you call boys malfunctioning girls before. They're treated like malfunctioning girls in the education system, which really resonated with me. And I would say would resonate with my kids, actually. But I have two boys if I spoke to them. You know, both my boys feel that they are feel sometimes that they are they would say they're victims of sexism that they feel that the girls are treated much better than the boys at school they don't express that in those words but that you know that's what they mean when they talk to me about their experiences at school and um the education system in the uk i don't know about america but very much puts kids in a box it says you must behave like this which is why you have so many kids out of the school system in the uk because children with special educational needs it just doesn't work for them at all i guess my question is how do we change that yeah uh i think you're right i think the way the education system works is it's just it is much more like one size fits all uh and that's true in both the uk and the us and it just turns out that um that size is just a bit more female right and so like it's just going to work that kind of narrow pretty prescriptive like conveyor belt thing right just girls are just a little bit better suited for it partly because i do think there's become a bit of a default, right?

36:57If you treat like how a girl behaves and how a girl learns as the default, then you inadvertently create a culture and a curriculum and a pedagogy that's just a bit more girl-friendly in just the same way that arguably we're doing the opposite 50 years ago. Again, I think largely inadvertently. So how do you fix it? Well, unfortunately, you could do a couple of things. One is I think you can start boys in school a bit later. So one of my proposals is at the very least give them the option to have a little bit more time to just develop those skills. So give them the gift of time is what some scholars call it.

37:28A little bit of that. I mentioned male teachers, but I think one of the reasons is it just changes the climate in the act. Female teachers are a little bit more likely to sanction boys' misbehavior and to label it as such than male teachers are. That's just true. And I think intuitive, understand that. So that's why having more men around is important. I should say that my own son is teaching fifth grade in Baltimore City now, and I just couldn't be prouder of him. He's the only male in his cohort of teachers in the school um and so i do think just having guys around helps the atmosphere a little bit for sure but in the long run of course what we want is an education system it's just a bit more flexible there's a reason why there's more boys in special needs there's a reason why more boys have been diagnosed with add and i think that is the problem is that like yes it's one size fits all and unfortunately that size as i just said skews a bit female

38:14Elliott Rae:we have to change that how we found so i think there's sometimes people hesitate to actually talk about the differences between boys and girls and and men and women and you know us with our earlier conversation talking about coming out the box and you can be anything you want to be at the same time recognizing that we are we are different our makeup is different but that can be sometimes a kind of controversial conversation have you had any pushback or challenge when you're talking about biological differences and just how we are naturally different as genders even though you know there is a social construct around gender as well what's been your response to that and the response from the public i mean you're kind to suggest that the public has a response to my but but i would say yes a little bit so a couple of books niobe way uh's book that i the latest book that i don't particularly like uh ruth whitman's book boy mum that i do like i reviewed them both she's a previous guest so it's good to hear that you do like which one and i got it the right way around thank god roof was a previous guest yeah our first guest actually um but they both actually did say look i think that they accuse me a little bit in different ways of like biological essentialism or sex essentialism by pointing out these differences i find it a little bit frustrating that if you suggest that not all of the differences are the result of socialization maybe just a little bit of it comes is more innate that makes you a biological essentialist It doesn't.

39:41What it means is you're just allowing a little bit of room for natural differences. It's actually the other side of this debate who are the social essentialists, the social determinists, because if you really insist that 100 % of the differences in the behavior, psychology, predilections of men and women are the result of socialization, that we are blank slates, then you are the essentialist. And you shouldn't accuse us of being essentialists for allowing any space for it. So yes, a bit of pushback. But here's the thing. I'll give you a specific example. I was to a researcher recently done some work on the manosphere and you know this group term i don't like now but like just for online influencers because it's defined too broadly and he had this pitched battle with his funder who wanted him to include the belief that there are some natural differences between males and females as a sexist view as a sign of being misogynist and he didn't he refused to but it was a pitch battle and i'm like you mean the view that 97 of people behold right i mean this is this is crazy stuff right the question is what do we do about those differences how big are they in what areas do they matter and how do we channel them right because there are some differences that small they don't really matter there are others that kind of do matter like i think that the potential for aggression and violence in men compared to women i do not believe for a moment that that can only be the result of socialization i think i think it's batshit crazy to believe that honestly and knowing that is incredibly important for the way we raise our boys.

41:05I think to deny that there are some natural differences is actually to make culture less important. Whereas I think it makes culture more important. If we know that, for example, that kind of women are more agreeable than men on average, and that makes it less likely that they're going to go into conflict or demand stuff for themselves, we should know that because then we can help to overcome that a little bit and make sure that we don't inadvertently disadvantage them because they're not asking for a pay rise every five minutes, right? Let's not make sure they're not punished for those. But anyway, I'm going on too long.

41:35But I think the point is that just particularly when it comes to fatherhood, it comes to I think the denial of any natural differences ends up being profoundly regressive, because it means we don't take seriously what we need to do as a society to channel those natural differences in ways that are positive and that support gender equality. Big conversation.

41:53Elliott Rae:I think when I saw my wife give birth, I knew there were differences because there's no way that i could even fathom growing a child and pushing them out same same but here's one here's one more rather beautiful example which is about fatherhood i think you'll like this one which is um sarah blaffer hurley she has a beautiful new book out father time and she oh i have the book actually yeah i've got the book yes great book and what i learned from that uh it turns out it's not a new finding but i learned it from her which is that women mothers get an oxytocin spike this kind of love hormone spike from kind of cuddling physical contact with they also get it from giving birth breastfeeding etc so it's very like this kind of physical thing but did you know that men also get an oxytocin spike from a form of interaction with their kids and do you know what they get it from throwing them around throwing them around uh they get an oxytocin spike and so there you've got i think there's a biological difference in not that we both can get this oxytocin bonding love hormone but how we get it and so i think that has just implications because if you if you think like if you're a dad i don't know how you were elliot but like in those early days and kind of months where you just feel a little bit left out in some ways because there's this whole love hormone love bombing thing going on between a child by the way that has no business really being out out of the womb right it's really technically defined as an we should say extra uterine embryo for the first at least the first three months right it's just incredibly young and so this connection between mom and baby especially those first few months is unbelievably strong and we are not going to feel the same way as dads we're just not going to feel the same way but it's not game over we got plenty more to do we can be very helpful in those months and guess what we get our own we get our own oxytocin high thank you very much just a little bit later from saying something different i find that a beautiful biological difference rather than horrible biological essentialism but also i find it really interesting that the different roles that men and women play in a child's life tend to be women tend to be the person that likes to keep the child close that does the sort of real nurturing role whereas men are more the challenger for children and they more like to give them risk you know they're more risk taking with children so they're the ones that's that give them the the view of the outside world as it were that's sort of the roles we naturally fall into whereas women tend to be you know keep them close give them a cuddle and it's really interesting to me that those chemicals work in that way and exactly that way yeah it's almost like we're evolved to have those differences and it creates this beautiful creative tension I think between mothers and fathers like it's a stereotype like have you seen the meme of a guy throwing the kid in the air and it's like how far it looks to dad how far it looks to the kid and then how far it looks to mom and you just don't see women throwing their kids in the air as much in fact almost never and Jonathan Haidt and I are working a little bit on fatherhood and this risk-taking thing and he had this nice observation the other day where he said this at a mom's first event actually where he said look if there's a parent who's pretending to be a predator who's going to gobble their child up and chasing them around which one is it yeah it's always that right mum can be a tickle monster she can be whatever but actually it turns out that acting the role of a predator who is going to kill and eat your own child is not something that mothers are amazingly good at dads are amazing at it um and so i think it speaks to this sort of difference that we have between mothers and fathers that if we take it seriously it's beautiful what i worry about is if we don't if fathers don't feel enabled to play that role in conversation with the mom hopefully right and to have that kind of it can only be a creative tension if there's tension and obviously we're all generalizing at this point but i think it's fine you know if you don't trust us by this point in the podcast you're never going to trust me um or us but like it's fine for mom to be saying i'm not sure you should do that i think that's i'm worried about that be careful be safe etc for dad to say no i think this is okay we're going to do it right and mom's saying i'm not sure and if mom's thoughtful and sensible she'll be like i get it this is hard for me I probably wouldn't do it but I get this important and dad will take her safety concerns seriously but you do need both and if dads don't feel enabled to be dads you lose that creative tension and if they just defer to mom and say mom's way is the best way that ends up not being great parenting it's not that dad's way is the best way it's that they'll each bring something to it and we have to honor and respect that and put it into creative tension within the relationship and it can be creative yeah so just for just for the single moms because I know there will be single moms listening to this that their brains do adapt actually there's research to show that they become more like dance relationships and single moms they do adapt that part of their brain so that they do do the risk take yes i didn't know i didn't know about the brain bit i'd be very interested to learn more about that but i i have heard of that research i also know that a lot of single moms who are listening and the same-sex couples i know who are women are you so pretty intentional about having other men in their kids lives yeah right uncles godparents you know etc and and so actually i find some of the people who are least offended by the idea that there are some special things that men can bring to the raising of children are single mums and lesbian couples right yeah and there's a usually usually get it there's an amazing organization called um lads need dads it's up in yeah i love them and most of her customers are are single mums who will come and say look I've recognized my boy needs some male male men in in their life and they'll go to her and she has an amazing mentorship program so I think you're right in regards to like recognizing a lot of single mums that I know will recognize the need to bring in men and do that very very well I want to kind of move the conversation onto male caring and caring roles men doing caring roles given everything that we've said you you've spoken quite openly about the need to encourage more men to get into kind of caring roles.

47:59Elliott Rae:How do you think we go about doing that? Bribe them. I think money really counts here. I have more to say, but I think that when you have such hugely gendered occupations, I'm thinking about care professions, nursing professions, education, especially in the early years, social work, therapy, counselling, psychology, that are now just so female skewed that it's just kind of hard to get boys and men to think about them. In just the same way, it was very hard to get women to think about engineering when there were no female engineers. Like it's just really hard to get someone to go into a profession when they just feel like they're going to be the odd one out.

48:31Not just true of gender, it's true of other identities too. And so I think in the meantime, we should take another lesson from the women's movement, which is that actually to get women to those roles into STEM, scholarships, financial incentives to help get over that idea. That's number one. So I have no problem. In fact, I'm very supportive of the idea that like, if we want more men in some of these professions, we should actually be targeting some financial incentives towards them. We should keep doing that for the areas where women are underrepresented. But I think there's a case for a little bit of money here.

48:57Then, of course, there's something around changing the conversation about these roles. And I think in the same way that you've been very successful earlier at changing the conversation about what it means to be a dad, in a very playful way, in a thoughtful way, in an attractive way. And so there are ways in which we could be doing a better job of selling those occupations to boys and men, be very intentional about that. When we wanted to get girls interested in STEM, we didn't wait till they went to college. We went into schools. We had whole sessions on it. We had women engineers and scientists and lawyers, and we're going into schools to talk to girls about being those things.

49:28We have to do exactly the same thing for the caring professions for boys. We need to try and de-gender those professions as much and as hard as we can through money and through kind of shifts in identity. And I would love it if policymakers started taking that more seriously. By the way, we have a huge shortage of many of those workers, particularly things like care, which have up until this point very often been filled by migrants. And I'm not saying there's anything wrong with that, but I'm saying that if the government is serious about not becoming less reliant on immigrants to do those roles, well, you've got this huge labor force sitting right there, which is young men.

49:58So maybe get some of them into those roles as well. You can't fix a labor shortage with half the labor market, or at least you shouldn't try to. So I think a really good self-interested reasons why we should do that. And I'm not saying we're going to get to 50-50 in those professions, right? I reckon this is back to some of these differences but my god we could do better than we currently are now in terms of the share of men in them and really really take away the gender stereotype we've done a really good job of breaking the gender stereotypes around male dominated professions not all of them and not enough but very few people say female lawyer or female doctor anymore right or if they do they're really old right because right because it's 50 50 now right but they do say male nurse they do say male teacher they do say male therapist why because there are so few of them so i want to kind of get

50:40Elliott Rae:your advice and help you to give advice to people. So I've got three pots here. I've got the government, I've got teenage boys, and I have parents as well. So if you're going to give one piece of advice to the government to improve the lives of men and boys, what would that advice be? Build on the amazing advance with the men's health strategy by also having a male education strategy in the Department for Education, which is very intentional, or broaden the remits of all of the gender equality units within government to include boys and men as well as women and girls. I don't know if we need a quotes minister for men.

51:16That's been one of the arguments. I don't think it's a crazy idea. I've supported it in the past. But at the very least, we need to find ways to institutionalize within government the attention to boys and men without taking away from the issues to girls. So do what Wes Streeting has done in the Department of Health in every other government department. For teen boys, I would say, God, you're amazing. And we need you. And we need your energy, we need your spirit, we need your ideas, we need your talents, and we need all of those things that are in you, not despite the fact that some of them are more common in males, but because they are.

51:50We need that energy and those ideas from our teen boys. But don't think that in order to be a successful man, you somehow need to turn against women. That is not a good dating strategy, for one thing. It's not a good life strategy. It's not going to be a great marriage strategy. It's not going to be a good labor market strategy, because there's a lot of women in the labor market so like and by the way i think that's what most team boys want to do i think they want a world where their sisters have equal opportunity to them very few of them want to turn back the clock on women but they want permission to be themselves as well and so just we need you will be by their message to you and like don't don't allow either the kind of pathologization of you that you might hear from some quarters or the call to a divisive finding someone to blame don't either of those calls they are the siren calls that will not help you flourish and we need you to flourish in order for us all to have great futures and to parents some of what i just said about teen boys applies too is like don't make the mistake of accidentally treating your sons like malfunctioning daughters don't say why can't you be more like your sister don't even think why can't you be more like your sister i found myself thinking why can't you be more like your sister when i couldn't get the kids to school or to pack their bags or to like my boys right and to be clear they didn't have a sister i made one up i had an imaginary daughter that i would compare them to i was like why can't you be more like your imaginary sister like because i was like um because i knew that just like how hard it was with these boys just for the love of god just two shoes just one shoe on each foot that's all i asked but don't do that and don't don't treat your boys and young men's interest in perhaps some of these questions they're finding online some of their reactions i think joely said about how her boys feel in school don't discount that Don't dismiss it.

53:34Don't prematurely label it as incipient misogyny. Talk about it. Be open to it. These problems that a lot of boys and men are having, they're not the confections of the reactionaries. They're real. And if they can't talk to us as parents about them without being judged, then who, for the love of God, can they talk to about them? And so as parents, it's incredibly important that we don't fall prey to this inadvertent pathologization of our boys, because they need you. And actually, particularly as they get into teen years, etc., God, they need you. And let's all just have a bit more of a sense of humor about this.

54:05I actually think a lot of the work that you've done, Elliot, that I've really admired, I think is really broken, is that like so much of this work has been so earnest, right? It's been so serious. Yeah, but I love like, let's put baby carriers on statues. Let's go on strike for a day. Let's celebrate. And I do think that there's been such a downer on some of these issues around this. It's just been so gloomy. And so like, it's been deficit framed, negative, et cetera. That just a bit of play, a bit of optimism. And I got to tell you, you're talking to me today. I feel great about this. I think that we're going to do much better by our boys and men over the next 10 years than we have over the last 10 years, because they're beautiful and we need them.

54:47Incredible advice.

54:48Elliott Rae:I have two girls and it's still a nightmare to get them to school as well. So that is definitely a girl thing too. So you should get an imaginary brother then. Maybe I'll make one up. I'm going to make one up. they're going to be freaked out about but question how old are yours how old are your how old are your daughters though nine and two okay well if they're still struggling at 13 get back to me well maybe i need to have a boy i'll talk to my wife about that boy yeah exactly you've just you've got the wrong benchmark trust me like maybe you just got the wrong comparison but but also just i think the work you're doing here on this podcast and kind of more generally both of you it's just like so positive and i think that the the thing i've really learned that i think you've just come naturally maybe to both of you.

55:28I think tone really matters here. I think you can point to real problems without becoming a kind of gloom, everything's apocalyptic. I think we can talk about solutions as we have here. We can have a positive affect. I do think that a lot of young people generally, and this is not just about boys and men, I think they're kind of over the negativity. They're kind of tired of it, honestly. They're tired of being told that everything's going to hell that you know they're they're having a huge problem uh they are the problem etc i think they're just kind of tired of it in the us i've really noticed a bit of a move for like can't we just like be happy uh and have fun and play and not jump on each other all the time and just have a bit of room to breathe and be ourselves and i really think that that mood is coming now and it's making me kind of much more optimistic it's the middle-aged people who are still the doomers and the younger people are like they're demanding the right to be happy in a way that i actually think is going to be quite positive and god bless them for that so richard you've got the new center

56:29Elliott Rae:you're chairing over here just yeah quickly talk to us about the aims and objectives and what you wanted to achieve in the next couple of years yeah so there's a few things one is to continue to raise awareness of these issues i think very often still it isn't anyone's job to sort of just notice the data and lift it up um on many of the issues we've talked about and just get that into the media get that into the conversation so that people know. I think the second thing is to keep broadening the permission space for this conversation, right? I think that just the permission space, that's how I think about, like, is it okay to talk about this stuff without being, you know, dubbed a reactionary?

57:03And I think it's more okay than it was, but we still need to provide spaces where people feel able to talk about this without being judged. And then thirdly, to look at solutions, look at kind of what are the effective interventions in school, some of which you talk that actually work with boys. What could we do about getting more male teachers? How could we change our healthcare system so that we're kind of reaching out to men? What do effective male-friendly suicide prevention programs look like, et cetera? Like what works and bring evidence to bear? And so it's awareness, permission, and evidence.

57:32It's what we're doing over here at the American Institute and it's what the UK Institute is gonna do too. There are only two dedicated think tanks or research organizations focused on boys and men in this way. One is here, one is there. So it's the US and the UK, but there's growing interest from others. And I see that as a really nice complement to the work that a lot of the women's think tanks are doing, because they've done a really good job of continuing to draw attention to where there are challenges facing women and girls. I want them to keep doing that. But we just need other people who basically what we're trying to do is create institutions where it's someone's job to wake up every day and think about what's happening with boys and men.

58:08What does that latest data release tell us? Who needs to hear about this? And what can we do about it? And so that's really the big breakthrough for me is that this is not just an intellectual challenge. It's an institutional challenge. And so we need to build some institutions that help keep this conversation going with high quality, non-political research and evidence.

58:26Elliott Rae:Yes, well needed. And you're literally changing the world with your work. So thank you so much, Don Richard Obama Reeves, which we're going to call you from now on. Love it. Writing it down. Got it. Change the name by deed poll. That's my handle. Next time you'll be Don Richard Obama Reeves. I just need him to adopt me. He just ran that past my own parents. But this was so fun. Thank you. Thank you. This has been brilliant. Thank you so much. We appreciate you so much. Thank you, Richard. We really appreciate you and your work. Well, back at you. Thanks. Thanks, Joey.

59:00Hey, it's Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. Now, I was looking for fun ways to tell you that Mint's offer of unlimited premium wireless for$15 a month is back.

59:09Elliott Rae:so I thought it would be fun if we made$15 bills but it turns out that's very illegal so there goes my big idea for the commercial give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch up front payment of$45 for 3 months $90 for 6 months or$180 for 12 month plan required$15 per month equivalent taxes and fees extra initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy see terms

From the publisher

In this episode of To Be A Boy, Elliott Rae and Joeli Brearley sit down with Richard Reeves—author of Of Boys and Men and chair of the UK’s Centre for Policy Research on Boys and Men—for a candid, compassionate conversation about the challenges facing boys and young men today.

Together, they explore how schools can better support boys, why male role models matter, and how masculinity can be reimagined without shame or stereotype. Whether you're a parent, educator, policymaker, or simply curious about gender equality, this episode offers a refreshing and nuanced take on what it means to grow up male in today’s world.

If he's good enough for Obama, he's good enough for TBAB!

More from To Be A Boy

All 53 episodes
The Don of Boys and Men: Richard ReevesTo Be A Boy · 59 min
Listen in VO