1. Podcasts
  2. Today, Explained
  3. America’s death penalty problem
Today, Explained

12 Oct 2026 · 26m · 11 chapters

Episode artwork

America’s death penalty problem

In short

America’s death penalty “assembly line,” focusing on declining public support but rising executions, botched lethal-injection attempts, wrongful convictions, and how Florida accelerates executions.

Guest

Pamela Koloff, writer for New York Times Magazine and ProPublica; has covered criminal justice for decades; author of Catch the Devil.

Key claims

Lethal injection is not reliably humane or error-free (Krista Pike survived two doses in Tennessee; governor suspended executions). DNA and wrongful-conviction problems persist (Florida has 30 death-row exonerations). Florida is the biggest outlier: Governor Ron DeSantis sets execution dates non-chronologically, creating “Death Watch” about 30 feet from the execution chamber with ~30 days’ confinement and rapid turnover.

Notable examples

Krista Pike (Tennessee, 1995 case); Florida’s rapid scheduling (including DNA testing granted 5 days before execution); Texas exoneration case involving a victim’s family struggling to accept innocence.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

Introduction to Krista Pike's Case

Explore the shocking details of Krista Pike's botched execution and its implications.

“In 1995, 18-year-old Krista Pike, along with her boyfriend and a friend, tortured and killed a classmate.”
1:42

Introducing Pamela Koloff

Meet Pamela Koloff, an expert on criminal justice and author discussing the death penalty.

“On this week's episode, I'm joined by Nathan Lane.”
2:32

Decline in Death Penalty Support

Examine the declining popularity of the death penalty and recent botched executions.

“We began our conversation about the death penalty by talking about its declining popularity.”
4:00

Botched Executions and Wrongful Convictions

Discuss the implications of botched executions and the rise of wrongful convictions.

“Whereas in May, it was an issue with accessing veins, which can be an issue with lethal injection.”
6:32

Florida's Unique Death Penalty Process

Explore the peculiarities of Florida's death penalty administration under Ron DeSantis.

“As you know, Texas used to be the leader in putting people to death.”
7:50

The Experience of Death Watch

Hear about the chilling conditions and mental toll of being on death watch in Florida.

“And so I went back and looked at what were the patterns here?”
8:52

Implications of Execution Delays

Delve into the psychological effects of delays in executions for those on death row.

“You know, you wrote about the Florida death row turning from something like a purgatory where people stay for a long time into something closer to an assembly line, right?”
16:34

Florida's Unique Death Penalty Policy

Exploring Florida's policy allowing the governor to control death penalty decisions.

“So I would just want to add one thing that goes to your question but is slightly different.”
18:19

Political Implications of Executions

Discussing Governor DeSantis' push for expedited executions and its political motivations.

“Your reporting kind of suggests or ask the question of whether this might be in part to boost his political standing.”
20:03

Victims' Families Perspectives

Diverse opinions from victims' families regarding the death penalty and its aftermath.

“And you can see in Florida, the laws have been expanded so that child sexual assault cases, for example, can now result in a death sentence.”
Show all 11 chapters
22:41

Future of the Death Penalty

Examining whether a fair and safe death penalty system can exist in America.

“Does any particular person you've spoken to come to mind?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Today, Explained, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00In 1995, 18-year-old Krista Pike, along with her boyfriend and a friend, tortured and killed a classmate. Pike was tried, convicted, and sentenced to death for her part in the crimes. Last month, officials in Tennessee, where the murder took place, tried to execute her. Around 7.30 at night, officials gave Pike pentobarbital at a dose high enough that it should cause someone to stop breathing and die. But she didn't. She's breathing, moaning, snoring. So the state gave her another dose, but that didn't work either. Around 9 p.m., the ambulances arrive. Six days later, Pike woke up and started talking.

0:38I think she is angry and confused about everything right now. The case is shining a spotlight on America's problems with administering the death penalty. Support for the policy has been declining for decades, but the number of executions is going up. Today on Today Explained from Vox, inside America's death penalty assembly line. Support for the show comes from Fisher-Price. Every baby is unique. And from the first wobbles to the confident cruising, Fisher-Price has the walker for that. Take the musical penguin walker, where each step activates music and sounds that encourage your baby to keep moving.

1:17Or their turtle walker, where baby-powered motion turns every step into action your baby can see, keeping little ones motivated and engaged. However your baby moves, it's time to celebrate it. And for your baby, discovering the world one step at a time, there's Fisher-Price, your go-to for a reason.

1:41I'm Ina Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite new and old friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. On this week's episode, I'm joined by Nathan Lane. We talk about his critically acclaimed run in Death of a Salesman, taking his dog to therapy, and winning an Emmy for Only Murders in the Building. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers!

2:20This is Today Explained. Pamela Koloff is a writer for the New York Times Magazine and ProPublica. She's been covering criminal justice for decades, and she has a new book out called Catch the Devil. We began our conversation about the death penalty by talking about its declining popularity. In 1994, 80 % of Americans told Gallup they supported putting murderers to death. In 2024, that number was just 53%. And while executions have started rising again in the last couple of years, there are still way fewer of them taking place now than there were in the 1990s.

3:01How much of the decline in the use of the death penalty has to do with, in your estimation, people feeling like there's no way to do it that's humane, that's constitutional? Like, we're taping shortly after news came out that a woman in Tennessee who was on the death row, authorities attempted to put her to death. They gave her two doses of lethal injection medication, and she survived. And then the governor there suspended the use of the death penalty indefinitely. I mean, you read about something like that, and you think, like, God, like, is there a way to do this? Right. And this is the second botched execution in Tennessee this year, just to give you a sense of things.

3:43So this is more common there than in other states. They've changed their drug protocols. And what we don't know a lot about what went wrong with Krista Pike. She's still alive, as far as we know. As of this recording. As of this recording, right. Whereas in May, it was an issue with accessing veins, which can be an issue with lethal injection. I think it's also important for people to remember, you know, we had the electric chair as the method of execution through the 80s into the 90s in some places. And so while this is considered a far more humane, quote unquote, way to do this, we can see that nothing is perfect.

4:33I will say while the issues of botched executions, I think are very important, and I think there's some other ones coming up to be concerned about, which I can speak about, I am more interested in how it is that other errors are made, that other people end up with the ultimate punishment. when that perhaps was not the right punishment for what occurred. Yeah, and I want to get to how that process plays out. But while we stay on the topic of sort of how the death penalty has been used nationwide over the last couple of decades, the big picture, maybe some of its decline is due to difficulties in finding a way to do this in a way that people agree is humane.

5:19You've also written that it's just expensive, right? And on top of that, you know, DNA evidence has made it clear that many of the people who were being convicted were not guilty or there wasn't strong enough evidence to convict them. Like, how do you think about that mix of factors? Yeah, well, I was really struck. So Florida, which I've spent a lot of time writing about, Florida is the leading place in America by a mile in terms of the number of executions and has a very large death row. So Florida is also the leader in wrongful death row convictions. So just to give you a sense of things, Florida holds the distinction of 30 death row exonerations.

6:00So what that means is in the modern era, we have had in the past roughly 50 years, there have been 30 men who were given dates of execution who now walk free. And for anyone who pays any attention to how the criminal justice system works and how incredibly difficult it is to overturn a wrongful conviction, if we have 30 people in Florida who have that distinction, we know that there are many more. Yeah, let's talk about Florida. As you know, Texas used to be the leader in putting people to death. Florida has taken that place. What's going on in Florida? When did you realize that something was different there?

6:46So it really ramped up last year. So last year, Florida executed 40 % of the people who were executed in the U.S. Jeez. In last calendar year. In this year, there have been 16 men who've been executed in Florida so far. Just to give you a comparison, Texas is the next state with the highest number of executions, and they have executed six men in that time. So, we already have outlier states, primarily southern states, and then we have Florida being the ultimate outlier. And there's so many things that make the administration of the death penalty interesting and unique in Florida. The thing that fascinated me the most is among active death penalty states right now, Florida is unique in that one person determines who it is from the hundreds of men on death row who will receive an execution date and what that execution date is.

7:49Who is it? And it's Ron DeSantis. The governor. Governor Ron DeSantis. And so I went back and looked at what were the patterns here? What were the things guiding Governor DeSantis' thinking in setting these dates? And was fascinated to see and very troubled to see. There are a number of men who've been there so long. They've been there since the 1970s. These are men who were convicted when Gerald Ford was president just to make this real to people. But the dates are not being set among the men who are what are called death eligible, meaning that they've gone through all their appeals. They aren't being done chronologically.

8:34There's no rhyme or reason to the process. And so there's this speculation game among victims' families, prisoners, their advocates about who will be next. and men can sit there on death row for decades with that hanging over them. And that is a Florida phenomenon. Yeah, I found that really striking and surprising reading your work and learning that people commit crimes decades and decades ago, are sentenced decades ago and are facing their fate, facing execution by the state for so long, like this sort of purgatory drags on and on. You know, you wrote about the Florida death row turning from something like a purgatory where people stay for a long time into something closer to an assembly line, right?

9:25Like I think you used a factory metaphor. Yes, exactly. Why did you do that? So I was so struck by the fact that in Florida, in order to have this pace of executions, there were people who were receiving their dates as little as 30 days, sometimes less, sometimes fewer, out from their execution dates. And just to give people a sense of why that is unusual, there are so many things that kick into gear when a death warrant is written. There are numerous legal maneuvers and next steps that happen in the courts. Just to give you a quick example, there was one defendant in Florida this spring who five days before he was scheduled to be executed was finally granted the ability to test DNA evidence in his case that had gone untested.

10:17So he had great lawyers who didn't sleep to make that happen, but that it came as close as five days to his execution date, I think should give us all pause about how fast this is moving. So you have multiple people sort of in the queue at the same time. There's a place at Florida's, well, it's in a different unit than Florida's death row that you're taken to once you get your date called Death Watch. Tell me about Death Watch. Like, what does it look like and what does it feel like in there? Death Watch is roughly 30 feet from the execution chamber. There are three cells that are there. when you receive your date, you are taken from death row to death watch where you're put, I don't want to say solitary because if there are other men who are held there, there are one or two other men, but you're in a far different situation than you would be on death row where there are people walking, you know, guards and other people, you know.

11:20So from that point forward, there are roughly 30 days where you are held, again, within steps of where this will take place. And to me, it was chilling when I was doing my reporting in the spring on the story that I published this summer that all three cells were filled. And as soon as one person was executed, the pattern was that often the next day, a new death warrant would be signed and there would be a new person in place. Really dark in this sort of like assembly line leading to execution is really striking. Why do they do that? I mean, why do they put these people next to the place where they'll die?

12:03I mean, I think that's one of the many questions I had about that. You know, we talk about not wanting to have cruel and unusual punishment about it. You know, our constitution does not uphold that, but it's such a unique kind of mental torture, I think, to be 30 feet from where you'll be put to death. The other thing I was struck by was the waiting aspect. So, if you're on death row, again, you always have this hanging over you. So I talked about the way in which when you're in that kind of sensory deprivation, you become highly attuned to sounds and smells and things like that. and I interviewed someone who's not on death row anymore whose sentence was commuted who talked to me about recognizing that jangle of keys and the steps that this group of people who comes to deliver the death warrant takes and knowing that someone is about to be served with a death warrant but not knowing is it me is it the guy next to me is it someone down the hall and I just want to say I understand that, you know, there's a counter argument to all of this, which is these are people who most often committed terrible crimes.

13:24Their victims did not know when they're, you know, when they were going to be killed. I do think, however, as, you know, a state that administers this thing, there has to be a rhyme or reason to this. Otherwise, you have total chaos, including for victims' families who never know. Are they going to wait one month? Are they going to wait 15 years? They don't know.

14:11cruising. Fisher-Price has the walker for that. Take the musical penguin walker, where each step activates music and sounds that encourage your baby to keep moving. Or their turtle walker, where baby-powered motion turns every step into action your baby can see, keeping little ones motivated and engaged. However your baby moves, it's time to celebrate it. And for your baby, discovering the world one step at a time, there's Fisher-Price, your go-to for a reason.

14:44Hi, everyone. I'm Kara Swisher. And I'm Sky Galloway. Twice a week, we get together on Pivot to sort through the biggest stories in tech, business, and politics. And we're taking the show back on the road for a live tour in November. So we'll bring hot takes. I'll bring the insight and the dick jokes. And Kara will try. Keyword is try to keep me in check. You'll get to see her hit me in person live. I'll do it. If someone has to do it. We'll cover AI, whatever chaos Washington has cooked up that week, and every billionaire misbehaving. That's all of them. And you'll also get to participate in audience Q &A, so bring your best questions.

15:20Scott will probably answer ones you didn't ask. We also have secret special guests, which you'll enjoy for every city. Get tickets at PivotTour.com. That's PivotTour.com. We are selling out, so don't wait. And we look forward to seeing you.

15:38What if we told you there was one thing you could eat to reduce your risk of death by about a quarter? Interested? And what if we added that this magical substance can dramatically lower your cholesterol, improve your mood, and keep your weight stable? No, it's not protein. It's actually fiber, the least sexy, most overlooked nutrient of all. But what is fiber? How could one nutrient do all those amazing things? And how can you get enough? Is a powder you stir into some water going to do it for you? All that plus the strange tale of the gorilla poop obsessed father of cornflakes in the latest episode of Gastropod.

16:15Find Gastropod and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.

16:21This is Today Explained. Let's talk a little bit about, you know, this situation in Florida. Florida is a unique policy that allows the governor to be the only one making a decision about when men on death row are put to death. Do you know why it has that system? So I would just want to add one thing that goes to your question but is slightly different. I think it's really important to note that Governor Lee in Tennessee, seeing what happened last night, we're speaking on October 1st, what happened with Krista Pike's botched execution, and again, this is the second botched execution of the year.

17:02He put a pause on executions for this year. He is having a third party come in and look at protocols. And this is someone who's pro-death penalty. And I think those things can work together. You can be pro-death penalty and want this system to work as well as it possibly can. So what's interesting to me is that Governor Lee has put a pause on things while Governor DeSantis seems to be going more than full steam ahead. And again, DeSantis is doing that with this backdrop of all these wrongful convictions. And we can see from what I was just talking about with the five-day window, you know, where this defendant got DNA testing with five days to spare, when you're moving too quickly, mistakes can happen.

17:53Mistakes can happen both legally with a case like that, or they can happen in the execution chamber, which takes a great toll on everyone, including prison staff. Let me ask about Governor DeSantis in Florida, which is who is, you know, going his own way. You report on how he has initiated and enthusiastically pushed for this dramatic acceleration in death row inmates being put to death. Your reporting kind of suggests or ask the question of whether this might be in part to boost his political standing. Like he's not going to be the governor for much longer. The election to replace him is in November.

18:34Maybe he's looking for a job in the Trump administration. Maybe he'll run for president again. Do you think that's true? So I will tell you that I tried so hard to figure that out. And I spoke to so many different people in Tallahassee and elsewhere trying to understand what was in the governor's mind. And I can't say that I know. I can say that in the past, the playbook, and I think this has changed, but in the past, the playbook, particularly in Florida, was if you are strong, quote unquote, on the death penalty, if you're executing people with some regularity, that helps your poll numbers. We saw this in the 80s on forward, literally when people's poll numbers were dropping, this would be a solution to getting voter support.

19:25I do think the calculation of that has changed a bit as Americans' opinions of the death penalty have shifted. So all I can speculate to is I think sort of within MAGA world, you know, obviously being tough on crime, and I want to revisit that term in a moment, but the perception of being tough on crime is something that holds a lot of power. But something important is, you know, Trump, when Trump came into office the second time, the day of his inauguration, he signed an executive order that was basically doubling down on the death penalty. Now, he really only has purview, you know, to some degree over the federal death penalty, which had, you know, fallen by the wayside, basically, and then under his watch, this tremendous number of people in his first term were executed, and then he came in in his second term and really encouraged, and I can't say directed district attorneys because they don't answer to him, but highly encouraged prosecutors across the country to use the death penalty as much as possible.

20:42And you can see in Florida, the laws have been expanded so that child sexual assault cases, for example, can now result in a death sentence. Things like non-unanimous juries can render a death sentence or recommend. I should say in Florida, they recommend it to a judge. So in Florida now, Now, and this is a recent change, you need just eight jurors to sign off on the death penalty. Eight out of 12. So that's so different. We don't see that anywhere else in the country. So I think we can see the ways in which this sort of ties into, you know, you think about things like alligator Alcatraz and this very performative aspect to law and order.

21:37I think what I've tried to do with my work is show that being tough on crime is not necessarily the things that we see politicians saying are being tough on crime. When you talk to victims, families, people who are on the other end of these death penalty cases, what do you hear from them? A whole range of opinions, and I think every family is different, but it is not uncommon. There have been many studies done in which victims have felt a sense of disappointment, that maybe this thing that they'd been, again, think of the buildup to some of these. We're talking so many years that it didn't deliver what was promised.

22:22And then you at the same time have what I consider to be a new victim's family. You have parents and siblings and children who've lost a child, who've lost a parent because they've been executed. So there's just so much pain around so much of the way this is administered. Does any particular person you've spoken to come to mind? Anything you want to share? You don't have to use their name if you don't want to. I am thinking in particular of one member of a victim's family. This was in a death penalty case in Texas that ended in an exoneration. and I spent a lot of time reporting on that and that reporting helped to lead in part to that happening and when I spoke to a member of the victim's family afterward you know he there were so many emotions but that family had been told a certain set of facts by by prosecutors for so many years and of course they believed that why would they not and he was explaining, even though all the evidence of this person's innocence is there right before me, it's very hard for, you know, my mind understands, but my heart isn't feeling it yet.

23:50This is someone who we spent 18 years in court looking at, thinking about, and imagining him committing this crime against our family. And so, you can see that's a wrongful conviction, but you can see in which the ways that victims' families, again, in this sort of tough-on-crime mindset, are often not served, that they have to go through a whole other ordeal. Like, a trial is in and of itself just shattering, right? And that's kind of just the beginning of what victims' families go through in these cases. So I want to close the conversation by bringing us back to the death penalty and its future.

24:31You've spent many, many years reporting on the death penalty in ways that that system has broken or has failed. Can you imagine an America where the death penalty exists and is used, but is fair? Can it be safe? But it exists and is used and is fair. I cannot, knowing everything that I know, because it's a human system. So to be clear, nothing is perfect, of course, right? So we know that if we get on an interstate and the speed limit is 65 or 70, there are going to be casualties at some point. Nothing can be perfect, but we accept those risks. I would say that when we're dealing with something like the death penalty, where it's the state putting someone to death, and knowing all the ways in which it can go wrong, it's very hard for me to imagine what it looks like getting that right.

25:42That's Pamela Koloff. You can read her work at ProPublica and the New York Times Magazine. Today's episode is a cut-down version of a longer conversation I had with Pamela for the Vox podcast, The Gray Area. If you would like to hear the full interview, you can search The Gray Area wherever you get your podcasts. And if you want to watch the interview, you can find us on YouTube. Today's show is produced by Thor Newrider and Beth Morrissey with help from Amina Alsadi, engineered by Shannon Mahoney and David Tadashore. Fact check by Melissa Hirsch. Our executive producer is Miranda Kennedy.

26:23Thank you.

26:53Price has the walker for that. Take the musical penguin walker, where each step activates music and sounds that encourage your baby to keep moving. Or their turtle walker, where baby-powered motion turns every step into action your baby can see, keeping little ones motivated and engaged. However your baby moves, it's time to celebrate it. And for your baby, discovering the world one step at a time, there's Fisher-Price, your go-to for a reason.

From the publisher

Support for the death penalty has dropped dramatically in the US, but in some places there's still a "death penalty assembly line" as this episode of The Gray Area explores.

This episode was produced by Thor Neureiter and Beth Morrissey, with help from Miranda Kennedy and Amina Al-Sadi, engineered by Shannon Mahoney and David Tatasciore, fact checked by Melissa Hirsch, and hosted by Miles Bryan.

Walls Unit in Huntsville prison is where lethal injections are carried out on inmates. Photo by Jerry Cabluck/Sygma via Getty Images.

Listen to Today, Explained ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: vox.com/members. New Vox members get $20 off their membership right now. Transcript at ⁠⁠vox.com/today-explained-podcast⁠.⁠
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Today, Explained

All episodes