The Epstein fallout

0:00Jonquilyn Hill:The Department of Justice has released more than 3 million documents related to the Jeffrey Epstein investigation. And honestly, they're kind of a mess. It's not just 3 million documents. It's 3 million documents that have no rhyme or reason, right? There's no context. They're messy. They're full of typos. They're duplicates. But they also shed new light on how some of the world's richest and most powerful people use that power. Epstein, in an exchange with Elon Musk, discusses sending his helicopter to take him to his island. In these messages from 2013, the convicted sex offender connecting New York Giants co-owner Steve Tisch with various women.

0:39Emails also show Trump Cabinet Secretary Howard Lutnick coordinating a visit in the Caribbean in 2012. It's not clear if the meetings happened.

0:48Jonquilyn Hill:So, will there be any actual fallout? That's coming up on Today Explained from Vox.

0:59Support for this show comes from the Working Forest Initiative. The working forest industry is committed to planting more trees than they harvest. More than 1 billion seedlings are planted in U.S. working forests every year. From biologists to GIS analysts, hiring managers, accountants, and more, Working Forest professionals have dedicated their focus towards sustainability, using their expertise to help ensure a healthy future for America's forests. You can learn more about Working Forest initiatives at WorkingForestInitiatives.com. WorkingForestInitiatives.com.

1:38Until now, mobile phone companies have worked very hard to ensure their phones do not start fires. But we found one company that dared to go in a different direction. and make a phone with fire starting as a feature. On The Verge Cast, we talk about all the greatest and weirdest phone concepts from Mobile World Congress in Barcelona. Plus, after years of legal battles, Google and Epic are now best buddies, contractually obligated to not say mean things about their app stores anymore. That's this week on The Verge Cast, wherever you get your podcasts.

2:12This is Today Explained. Hi, I'm Madeline Berg. I am a correspondent at Business Insider covering wealth and power. Okay, Maddie, broadly, what have we learned from this latest document dump? Right. I think that so far, I guess, the overarching thing I've really taken away is it's a really rare look about how rich and powerful mainly men communicate. how the network works, how they do favors for each other, how, you know, oh, can you help my daughter get into college? How can you connect me to this person? How that network is so tight and that world is so small. People know each other. People do favors.

2:56And people talk about women in a way that is really scary. That's kind of the overarching theme I've taken away and is how permissive this rich and powerful class has been, or was, to Epstein. Additionally, there have been revelations about figures. Some of them, like Elon Musk, have really said openly, I have cut ties with Epstein. I didn't know him. I never went to the island. But we're seeing in this, he was emailing Epstein asking for an invite to the island to go to a wild party. You've got mail. What day slash night will be the wildest party on your island? You've got mail. We'll be in the BVI slash St.

3:34Bart's area over the holidays. Is there a good time to visit? We're seeing Howard Lutnick. He said he cut ties with Epstein in 2005, but there are emails which indicate he was planning a trip and seemingly went to Epstein's island in 2012. My wife and I decided that I will never be in the room with that disgusting person ever again. So I was never in the room with him socially, for business or even philanthropy. If that guy was there, I wasn't going because he's gross. And so we're seeing a lot of these rich and powerful people have more connections with Epstein than we thought. And we're already seeing the fallout for that.

4:16In real time, we're seeing Brad Karp, the chairman of Paul Weiss, the law firm, step down overnight as chairman. He's still working as a lawyer there. He was revealed to have emailed Epstein many, many times. He seemed to give him confidential information about a client. He asked him for a favor to help his son intern with Woody Allen. We're seeing— Oh, yikes. There's a lot of Woody Allen-Epstein overlap in this, just going through some of his scheduling. It's like, oh, dinner with Woody tonight, lunch with Woody, coffee with Woody. He actually helped Woody Allen's daughter, one of them, get into Bard, it seems like.

4:54So again, there's so much overlap in terms of who you think of as kind of creepy men.

5:02Jonquilyn Hill:In addition to American businessmen, we've seen more powerful elites from around the world be named in these files. Can you share some of them and how they're connected with Epstein? Yeah. So Prince Andrew, we've known he's connected to Epstein or former Prince. The artist formerly known as Prince Andrew has been connected to Epstein for years. He had the most extraordinary ability to bring extraordinary people together. And that's the bit that I remember is going to the dinner parties where you would meet academics, politicians, people from the United Nations. I mean, it was a cosmopolitan group of what I would describe as U.S.

5:50eminence. There is in these emails evidence of seeming, it seems like sex trafficking. It seems like him asking Epstein to be set up with women. Additionally, we're seeing Sarah Ferguson, Prince Andrew's ex-wife, speaking to Epstein in a very friendly way. Same with the crown princess of Norway. And this is all, by the way, after 2008 when he was convicted of prostitution with a minor. So it's after that. And same with most of these communications, for what it's worth. We're also seeing Peter Mendelsohn. He was a former British ambassador to the U.S. He resigned from his position in the House of Lords, and we're seeing fallout for that.

6:33Keir Starmer, the prime minister of the U.K., is under fire at the moment because apparently he knew about some of Peter Mendelssohn's ties to Epstein when he was named ambassador. I want to say this. I am sorry. Sorry for what was done to you. Sorry that so many people with power failed you. Sorry for having believed Mendelssohn's lies and appointed him. So we're going to continue to see this fallout around the world. Yeah. How is this being received in the UK? Do you know? Yeah. The Labour Party there is really not happy with Keir Starmer. I think that they're, you know, I think the Prince Andrew thing was so disgusting to a lot of people in the UK.

7:22And I think that reverberated for a really long time. And we're now seeing Starmer under a lot of heat. And I mean, there are calls for him to resign. I don't know if that will happen, but it's definitely not going away over there.

7:36Jonquilyn Hill:We've seen more repercussions to foreign leaders than to Americans. Why do you think that is? You know, I think that a lot of the leaders in America that were really the names that are jumping out to us are business leaders in the private sector. And in that, I mean, they're going to be, we're kind of going to see how that plays out, right? We saw with Brad Karp. We're seeing the NFL is investigating, not formally, but it's looking into Steve Tisch, the owner of the Giants. We're going to really kind of see how the pieces fall as we learn more and more. I also think that the repercussions-wise, the whole point of the document dump is not to find new evidence for people to go under fire.

8:22It's for the Department of Justice to prove everything it did, that we did not leave any stone unturned. We looked into everybody. We thought about prosecuting these people. We, you know, went down those rabbit holes. We couldn't find enough to criminally prosecute them. So other than other than Ghislaine Maxwell and Epstein. So, you know, I think that this is the DOJ saying we did everything we could. We couldn't find enough criminal. There might it might be creepy. It might be sleazy. It might be unethical, but there wasn't enough criminal goods in this to prosecute.

8:57Jonquilyn Hill:I wonder, you know, it's it's it feels like holding these two things as once like not enough to prosecute a crime, but it is very creepy and bad. I guess what do consequences look like if they're not charging them? Does that mean they're not guilty? Like, where do we go from here? Yeah, I think it's kind of a lot of it is up to the public, right? I feel like now it's up to the public to if we're not OK with something that we read in this, whether it's from a politician or a business leader, to really to push back and to say this is not OK. We want this leader out. We want out of government, out of their business, whatever it is.

9:33It's kind of up to the court of public opinion now. That said, we are going to see some of these people testifying in front of Congress later this month. The Clintons are going to testify. Les Wexner, who was, you know, was listed in a draft document by the DOJ as a co-conspirator, a potential co-conspirator of Epstein's. So we are going to see these people questioned by the government. We might get more answers and we might then, it won't be criminal charges necessarily, but we might get repercussions from the public and there might be more consequences in that way. you have to remember these documents are such a mess that a lot of them are really hard to understand um there's so many just everyday emails mixed in with really incriminating emails so we kind of we need that explanation and i and i think that everybody hopes that these when these people testify we're going to get more of an understanding of what actually happened there are also files that the DOJ didn't release.

10:31There are 200 ,000 documents that the government said it will not release. We don't know what's in those. We may never know what's in those, but there could be things in there that eventually do get revealed. And there also, I don't think any news organization has been able to go through all three million documents, no matter how much manpower they've devoted to this. So, you know, we're going to continue to get revelation after revelation.

10:57Jonquilyn Hill:What should the public take away from all of this, this whole thing? Yeah, I mean, I think it's important to understand how the very, very, very wealthy, the very, very powerful interact with each other, how they speak about women, how they use each other. People are using Epstein. Epstein's using other people. And also how many people can't be taken at their word, right? So many people denied having a connection to Epstein or visiting his island or talking to him after the after his conviction in 2008. But they were lying. And I think it's really important that we hold people to account and we don't take their word at face value.

11:39And and also, I mean, one thing that really I found interesting is how much these people put into writing. It was almost like they believe they were above the law or above repercussion. And not everybody, obviously, but some very rich and powerful people think they're immune to consequences. And it's really up to the public now that this is out there, what consequences they face.

12:10Jonquilyn Hill:Madeline Berg is a correspondent at Business Insider. She covers wealth and power. Up next, how a journalist who's covered Epstein from the start is reading these files.

12:30Support for the show comes from Built Rewards. I don't think anyone's a fan of paying rent, but earning something back on that payment might make it feel a little better. With Built, they say that every rent payment can earn you points that can be used to wear flights, hotels, lift rides, Amazon.com purchases, exclusive benefits in your neighborhood, and so much more. And starting this month, Build says that for first-time members, you can now earn points on mortgage payments. That means you can get rewarded wherever you live. Plus, Build says that you can unlock exclusive benefits with more than 45 ,000 restaurants, fitness studios, pharmacies, and other neighborhood partners.

13:09and you can redeem built rewards for built home delivery services, gift cards at over 120 brands. And they say that you can use those points even on your student loan balances. You can join the loyalty program for renters at joinbuilt.com slash explained. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash explained. And make sure you use our URL so they know we sent you.

13:40Support for Today Explained comes from Quince. Quince makes elevated essentials feel effortless, says Quince. They say their clothes are designed for layering and mixing, helping you build a timeless wardrobe made to last. Timeless how? How about a trench coat, a classic pair of jeans, or one of those super soft Mongolian cashmere sweaters? According to Quince, each Quince piece is made to last with premium materials in ethical, trusted factories, then priced far below what other luxury brands charge. Our colleague Claire White has gotten into some quints. I recently picked up a few more pieces of the Mongolian cashmere collection from quints, the fisherman sweater and a cardigan.

14:21I love both of these pieces, not only because the quality is amazing, but because the price point is truly unbeatable. I know these will last in my closet for seasons to come, and they've kept me so warm and so fashionable. since I received them. Refresh your wardrobe with Quince. Go to quince.com slash explain for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada, too. That's quince.com slash explain to get free shipping and 365-day returns. Quince.com slash explain.

14:59Support for Today Explained comes from Vanta. Business owners know, says Vanta, that the landscape is changing. Risk and regulation are rising. Customers expect proof of security before they even consider signing. Earning trust is critical to closing deals, but it's also costly, complex, and time-consuming, says Vanta. Vanta says it's their job to make it easy. Vanta says they can automate your process to bring compliance, risk, and customer trust together on one AI-powered platform. They say they automate the process of achieving and maintaining compliance with over 35 security and privacy frameworks, including that SOC 2, that ISO 27001, and HIPAA.

15:38This helps companies get compliant, remain compliant, opening doors to next-level growth opportunities, freeing up time instead of getting buried in audits and spreadsheets. Vanta says Vanta gives you a system that runs behind the scenes, minimizing risk and powering your growth with confidence. You can get started at vanta.com slash explained. That's V-A-N-T-A dot com slash explained. Vanta dot com slash explained.

16:08This is Today Explained.

16:12Jonquilyn Hill:Vicki Ward is a best-selling author and investigative reporter. She first encountered Jeffrey Epstein in the early 2000s. She was a reporter for Vanity Fair and was writing a piece about how this man got all this money when she stumbled upon some even more disturbing information. Now, 20 years later, her name has popped up in the Epstein files. but kind of in a good way? Well, you mean because he's trashing me. He's trashing me. He sends my boss at the time, Graydon Carter, then the editor of Vanity Fair, a note trashing me and my reporting. And he says it's defamatory. And he writes me a long, long fax, which I remember receiving, telling me what a dreadful journalist I am.

17:05And both of these missives are on the topic of Annie and Maria Farmer, two sisters who I'd spoken to back then on the record and who had told me about the abuse they had suffered at the hands. in Maria's case at the hands of both Jeffrey and Ghislaine Maxwell. Annie Farmer was more focused on Ghislaine Maxwell at the time, but she also had a horrible experience with Jeffrey. Annie had been underage at the time of the abuse. And they were very brave. They were on the record. I didn't find any other girls, women at the time. They were the only two. And I didn't back then have a sense of the scale of this operation that we now know to be horrendously enormous.

18:12But I did have them. And yet Epstein's threats to my boss, compounded by the fact he visited the Vanity Fair offices at the time behind my back, were enough to get the pharmacist's cut from the article, which was a truly terrible, terrible, terrible thing to happen. because what it meant was that I had inadvertently exposed them to Geoffrey and Ghislaine. I think Ghislaine then went on to make Maria Farmer's life horrendous, terrified, threatened her. And we hadn't provided the protection that printing their allegations would have given them. it also meant that it wasn't until well over a year later that the FBI phoned me because somebody must have told them that I'd, you know, spoken to the farmers.

19:24And as we know, the FBI investigation took a long time, but ultimately in 2008 it did wind up with the ridiculously cushy plea deal and the non-prosecution agreement that Jeffrey Epstein struck in Florida. But meanwhile, hundreds of other girls, children, went on to be abused and trafficked by Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. So what happened back in 2000, that was the fall of 2002, when I was reporting this piece, unfortunately is a really tragic, tragic mistake.

20:20Jonquilyn Hill:I wonder what it's like for you as a person who started reporting this, you know, back in 2002, to see this story become so huge, for it to be like a household name and for people to wonder what's in the files. What has that evolution been like for you to see? Well, mixed, to be honest. I'm not an Epstein victim, but he did make my life hell.

20:54And, you know, in the first few years, to be honest, I was glad. I never really wanted to hear his name again. I had a complicated pregnancy when I was dealing with him and the irony is that you know I'd been assigned to actually profile him because my boss thought he it would be easy um for me he lived in New York I lived in New York I wouldn't have to get on a plane I'd done some financial journalism before this you know I know how to sort of I know I understand money and wealth management and things like that and so nobody expected that this man would would would turn on me and start threatening me um and threatening my unborn children and tell me that he knew where i'd be giving birth and telling me he'd get my husband fired you know some of the the threats were stupid but some of them were really horrible.

21:52And I did end up going into labor much too soon. And I did then have my two babies who, you know, weighed two pounds and two and a half pounds, you know, in the hospital, we had to ask for security for them for two months, because I really was terrified that Jeffrey Epstein would be coming to harm them. And so after all of that, to be honest, I wanted to forget about Jeffrey Epstein. I wanted to sort of normalize the whole thing in my mind. But then the years ticked on and I began to realize that it wasn't just the farmers, that the scale of this thing was potentially enormous. and I did feel, to be honest, that the idea of Jeffrey Epstein walking into the office of my boss, Graydon Carter, behind my back, it was during the fact-checking process, I'd by that time been put on bed rest and for me to have been cut out of the loop of the decision-making on the piece, I did feel this smacked of the good old boys club, boys protecting boys.

23:12Graydon Carter was a bachelor at the time you know he was running around dating all sorts of people and I the whole thing made me sick to my stomach and angry frankly really really angry and and I think you know now what do I feel I feel that it's very important that these victim survivors get justice. But even so, even so, what's happened is botched. The survivors, I know Annie Farmer's, you know, spoken out. All the documents are still not out there.

23:58Jonquilyn Hill:You know, some of the people mentioned in the files come across worse than others. Yeah. What does it mean just for your name to pop up in the Epstein files? Nothing. I mean, you know, particularly in the way that my name comes up, I'm thrilled. I'm absolutely thrilled. I think Julie Brown's pretty thrilled that, you know, he sends emails around viewing her as a problem. and he clearly viewed John Connolly, who was a friend of mine, another great investigative journalist who co-authored a book with my co-author, James Patterson, clearly viewed him as a problem too. So that's, you know, I think that's not a problem.

24:40I think that it's absurd. Some of the redactions make no sense. There's a woman, Melanie Walker, who's a person of great global influence, who was an Epstein protege. He paid for her to go through college. She became a neuroscientist and she ended up going out with Prince Andrew and she ended up being the partner of Steve Sinoski, who was Bill Gates's number two at Microsoft. And she ended up on the board of the World Bank. She's a pretty influential person who is intensely loyal to Jeffrey Epstein. and I noticed that her names have been redacted and it seems absurd to me as to why that would be.

25:28What questions do you still have about the case? Well, I still want to understand the money. I'm not sure I'm ever going to get an answer to that because without the money, there would have been no sex crimes. There's no evidence that Jeffrey Epstein went around abusing teenagers before he had hundreds of millions of dollars and before he was able to hide, essentially, behind the walls of his enormous mansion and on his private island.