Vance vs. Rubio 2028

0:00Astead Herndon:In Donald Trump's second term, there's basically only like five guys who really matter. Steve Wyckoff, Scott Besson, Stephen Miller, Marco Rubio and JD Vance. And those last two, they really matter, considering they're the ones who best represent Trump's beliefs. And they're basically the only Republicans who are floated for president in 2028. Vance is out with a new book recently, and he's walked back that cat lady comment, making it pretty clear that he's planning to run for president come next year. But considering how much of Trump's second term has Marco Rubio's fingerprints all over it, who's really the heir apparent to the throne of Donald Trump?

0:46Astead Herndon:And what does that version of MAGA look like? That's coming up on Today Explained from Vox.

0:59Support for this show today comes from Anthropic, the team behind Claude. Claude is the AI for minds that don't stop at good enough. It's the collaborator that actually understands your entire workflow and thinks with you. Whether you're debugging code at midnight or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. With deep research, Claude's research capabilities go way deeper than basic web search. comprehensive, reliable analysis with proper citations, turning hours of research into minutes. For problems worth solving, you can get started with Claude at Claude.ai slash Today Explained.

1:35That's Claude.ai slash Today Explained. Support for Today Explained comes from Fetch. Fetch is pet insurance, if you hadn't figured it out. Do you have a pet? According to a study from a pet insurance company from a few years ago, every six seconds, a pet owner in the U.S. gets hit with a vet bill over$1 ,000, and it almost never comes at a convenient time. So check out Fetch. You get paid up to 90 % of vet bills. You can use Fetch for any vet in the U.S. and Canada. Every vet is in network. Go to FetchPet.com slash save right now for your free quote. That's FetchPet.com slash save.

2:18Astead Herndon:This way, if it works out, I'm going to take the credit. If it doesn't work out, I'm blaming. Today Explained. Yeah, I like that idea. I think it's a good idea. Thank you very much, everybody. Thank you. I'm Estet Herndon, filling in on Today Explained. When you talk about the inner workings of Trump world, there are few better than Maggie Haberman. Maggie is a New York Times reporter and recently co-authored the book Regime Change with Jonathan Swant. It's a bestseller, and it digs in to everything Trump-related, including the question of his 2028 endorsement and how he feels about people like Vance and Rubio.

2:53Astead Herndon:So I started by asking her about this incredible scene in the book where Rupert Murdoch is at the White House with Donald Trump and Trump essentially turns to him and ask him, Vance 2028 or Rubio 2028? So it's October of last year. And by this point, Trump is suing Rupert Murdoch over the Wall Street Journal's Jeffrey Epstein reporting, and specifically about that birthday card that Trump insists he didn't write that has a very Trumpy-looking signature on a female body. It's not my signature, and it's not the way I speak. And anybody that's covered me for a long time, no, that's not my language.

3:32It's nonsense. And Murdoch comes to dinner with a bunch of news corps executives from his U.K. holdings and from the U.S. And so there's New York Post folks there. And it's in the Blue Room at the White House, very formal dinner. Also there is J.D. Vance and Usha Vance and Marco Rubio. And Trump is very solicitous of Murdoch. I mean, you would think that nothing has happened. But in the course of this conversation, he says, you know, what do you think of J.D.? And Murdoch says, well, J.D. has the potential to be great. And Vance, who knows full well that Murdoch had tried very hard to keep Trump from picking Vance, Murdoch does not like Vance's worldview.

4:15I mean, you know, Vance, he does not believe in the intervention skepticism. So Vance says, you know, thanks a lot, Rupert. Thanks a lot. And then Trump says, well, what about Marco? And Murdoch says just very flatly, Marco was brilliant. And it was uncomfortable at this table, according to all of our reporting. I also want to make clear that we have no reporting that Marco Rubio is running. Right. In fact, quite the opposite. Now, he could obviously scale up very quickly. He has run for president before. But everything we know of right now is that Rubio is going to support Vance, and it would take some tremendously, you know, unforeseen circumstance to change that.

4:59Astead Herndon:Yeah, I mean, that's partly what made it so interesting. You know, Rubio, Donald Trump Jr., the turning points groups have all made very clear that they feel like they're lining up behind Vance as Trump's successor. It would seem as if it would take something extraordinary to knock off that path. And yet you have Trump there seemingly dangling his whispered competition in front of him. Is that just sport for the president? Like, how does he view his own succession? Well, look, I mean, as you know, he because you've watched him a long time, too. He loves pitting people against each other. Yeah.

5:33Astead Herndon:He does it at the State of the Union, you know. You should be ashamed of yourself not standing up. You should be ashamed of yourself. Yes, well, and he did this in 2016 when he was debating between Newt Gingrich, Chris Christie, and Mike Pence for VP. You know, he would poll people at fundraisers. Who do you like? But there is something a little different going on here, which is, number one, and we write about this in the book, Trump just has a better personal chemistry with Rubio for whatever reason, which is shocking if you think about 2016. Yeah. And what that looked like. Little Marco. Little Marco.

6:08Astead Herndon:Little Marco. It was so insulting. It was kind of personal. It felt as if sometimes he was stepping on them, even after Rubio kind of deferred. There were dick jokes on, you know, on stage. And you know what they say about men with small hands?

6:26You can't trust them. You can't trust them. But for whatever reason, they do better together. Trump likes being around Rubio. He likes talking to Rubio. I think he'll go down as the greatest secretary of state in the history of our country. I really believe that Marco, or I wouldn't say it.

6:39Astead Herndon:Marco Rubio, I wouldn't say it. Maybe I would. He also is a pretty calm presence around Trump. The age gap between Vance and Trump is a real thing. I mean, that has come up repeatedly. Just like different generations? Or it's just a harder vibe to make work? I think it's just a harder vibe to make work. I also think that, you know, as much as we think of Donald Trump as extremely online, he's extremely online in a specific way. Vance really is extremely online in sort of a generational way. And everyone around him would acknowledge that. But Trump, you said the successor thing. Trump doesn't want to see the stage to anybody.

7:14I mean, the second that he anoints somebody or backs somebody or whatever, the clock starts ticking on his own relevance, even though he's never going to allow himself to be irrelevant. And it's really hard to think of a world where that happens. But there is nothing in his history that suggests that he's just going to go off and do paintings like George W. Bush.

7:35Astead Herndon:Yeah, I wanted to ask about this specific scene I think is most memorable with Vance, which I think is that Oval Office kind of ambush of Zelensky in 2025. You're gambling with the lives of millions of people. You're gambling with World War III. Which read to me as just such a set play performance for the president. How was that received by Trump? So it's interesting. Our reporting was that it was not actually an ambush. It wasn't a setup, but it did flow pretty naturally. Trump dislikes Zelensky enormously. Vance dislikes Zelensky immensely. Have you said thank you once? That a lot of times. No, in this entire meeting, have you said thank you?

8:17Astead Herndon:Given today. And so Vance certainly saw an opportunity, but it was not, there's nothing in our reporting that suggested this was a pre-planned, you know, tennis match between Trump and Vance. It just flows from their natural kind of shared dislike of the guy. Correct. And then, but what also flows naturally is Trump saying at the very end, This is going to be great television, I will say that. because everything is sort of through the lens of the box and the performance and the attention economy. It is one of many things that we would not have seen in Trump term one. It is one of the many ways this term is so radically unrecognizable to term one.

8:54Astead Herndon:You know, the book lays out areas of daylight between Trump and Vance that are also super important. These are the fault lines that come up in our reporting also. Epstein files, the Iran war, and both. Vance ends up on the different side than the president. I guess since Donald Trump still went through with said decisions, how significant were these disagreements and how much did it shift their relationship? It's a good question. I don't know that I could say shift the relationship. I can certainly say that there have been irritation points over a number of issues, including the ones that you just described.

9:29But there's nothing more consequential that a president does than take a country to war. And so we got very deep inside situation room meetings about what that was going to look like. There was nobody in Trump's orbit who thought that going—the closest would be Hexeth—but that thought that this regime change potential effort was wise. John Radcliffe, the CIA director, Marco Rubio, Dan Cain, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Hegseth was in the room, as I just said. You know, Susie Wiles, J.D. Vance. Vance was the only one who really argued forcefully with the president in those rooms against it.

10:01And it cost him with Trump. Trump got very irritated. And there was some lingering irritation over that. In terms of Epstein, he just did not want to talk about it. Kept calling it a Democratic hoax. However, there were members of the administration, including Vance, who had been talking about the need for transparency for many years. Remember when we learned that our wealthiest and most powerful people were connected to a guy who ran a literal child sex trafficking rink? And then that guy died mysteriously in a jail? And now we just don't talk about it? Vance argued for releasing everything, including uncorroborated information, including uncorroborated information about Donald Trump.

10:42And there's this incredible meeting in mid-August of last year where they're having this conversation about a planned website, like a public-facing, DOJ-created, Jeffrey Epstein files. Here it all is. Here it all is. But an aide had looked up Trump's name in this beta version of this website prior to this meeting. And the first thing that came up was this secondhand uncorroborated and, by the way, already public, unsealed a year and a half earlier in a civil case, the allegation that Trump had abused some woman's nipples. and, you know, this person in the meeting raises this and says this is out there.

11:23And Vance argues for releasing it and says that, you know, he doesn't think the president would mind. He's been accused of worse. And the White House chief of staff very quickly says, no, actually, he would mind. And there were other aspects of this discussion, but the website thing goes away. So it doesn't help a case that Vance is especially powerful with Trump, that on these two issues, he was on the other side of him and was not listened to. Right.

11:46Astead Herndon:In some ways, it feels like one vision of the world has won a policy battle, while Vance has set him up for the kind of political battle to come. But I guess I just wanted to ask the question more clearly, like, how has Vance navigated his America First position in a White House that increasingly feels non-America First? Like, is there a risk? Do we think that that drags him down with him? I don't think it's totally black and white. I think that there's a nuance there. Rubio really has had a foreign policy conversion over many years. He has really pulled back from his far more interventionist view, far more hawkish view.

12:26In terms of Vance, there were moments during the 12-day war where Trump was not happy that Vance didn't say obliterated. We obliterated the nuclear sites. And so that was an example where, you know, Vance was sort of walking this line where he then went back out on TV and was much clearer. We feel very confident that the Fordow nuclear site was substantially set back and that was our goal. He's also aware that he is the vice president. Yeah. And the president sets the policy. And so Vance was against this war is quite well known, you know. And so to be the person who was trying to negotiate an end to a war that you didn't believe in in the first place, I don't think that's personally a bad political position for Vance to be in.

13:13And people around Vance are very dismissive of the idea that this is somehow bad for Vance. And I think they have a compelling argument as to why that is. I hear that. It's a no lose for Vance on that one.

13:23Astead Herndon:I guess my last question will be kind of the brass tacks one. Like, Vance has spent the whole term working to stay and kind of walking in this line, as we talked about. When his 2028 campaign launches, do you think he can count on a Trump endorsement? I think anybody who is counting on Donald Trump's anything often ends up pretty disappointed. But I also think that Vance is the presumptive frontrunner right now, and it's hard for me to see who else that could be. And so while I don't think that Trump wants to anoint anyone, and I think he's going to torture Vance and make it very difficult for him, as we lay out in the book, if Vance is the likely nominee, it's also hard for me to see Trump being the person who undermines that completely because it's still something he can take credit for.

14:22Astead Herndon:Maggie Haberman of The New York Times. The book is Regime Change. Coming up, Marco Rubio hasn't said he's running for president in 2028, but could he? And would he beat Vance in a nomination if he wanted it?

14:55Support for the show today comes from AG1. When we go on vacation, we need to put some of our healthy habits on pause, but AG1 doesn't have to be one of them. AG1 is a daily health drink with multivitamin pre and probiotics, superfoods, and antioxidants. It's a simple habit you can add to your morning. Just mix a scoop into eight ounces of water and enjoy, kind of like baby formula. It's made to help maintain energy, support gut health, and support immune health. Plus, AG1 is clinically shown to support gut health and fill in common nutrient gaps. Claire White tried AG1. Drinking athletic greens is totally a part of my routine.

15:39It feels like something I look forward to in the mornings just to get myself going, get myself awake, and to ensure that I'm really nourishing my body with the proper nutrients. Before the day even gets started. Visit drinkag1.com slash explained to get a free AG1 travel case with seven free AG1 travel packs in your welcome kit with your first AG1 subscription. Order while supplies last. That's drinkag1.com slash explained.

16:12Support for the show today comes from Anthropic. In case you were wondering who's behind Claude, that's Anthropic. Claude is the AI for minds that don't stop at good enough. Is that you? It's the collaborator that actually understands your entire workflow and thinks with you. Have you been looking for that? Whether you're debugging code at midnight or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter with deep research. Claude's research capabilities go way deeper than basic web search. Comprehensive, reliable analysis with proper citations, turning hours of research into minutes.

16:46We love a proper citation, don't we? Plus, you can connect Claude to your professional tools like GitHub, Jira, HubSpot, Notion, Google Workspace, and watch it become your command center with context from all your work. That means Claude has context from your calendar, emails, and all of your go-to tools. For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at claude.ai slash todayexplained. That's claude.ai slash todayexplained.

17:19Support for the show today comes from Grow Therapy. As I recall, they want to grow you. Too often, people treat sunny summer days like they owe you happiness. But if you ever find yourself with a case of the blues this season, just know that you're not alone. These few months are actually one of the busiest stretches of the year for people starting therapy. Help is within reach in the form of Grow Therapy. Grow connects you with thousands of high-quality licensed therapists across the U.S. offering both virtual and in-person sessions, nights and weekends. And you can search by what matters to you, like insurance, specialty, identity, or availability.

17:56And you can get started in as little as two days. There are no subscriptions, no long-term commitments. You just pay per session. Grow helps you find therapy on your time. The therapist you want takes your insurance on Grow. Grow accepts over 125 insurance plans. Sessions average$21 with insurance and some pay as little$0 depending on your plan. Visit growtherapy.com slash explain today to get started. That's growtherapy.com slash explain. Growtherapy.com slash explain. Availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.

18:28And you know what they say about today explained. You can't trust them. You can't trust them. All right.

18:35Astead Herndon:Matt Lewis is a conservative columnist at Notice, but also has been someone who's been following changes on the right for the last decade and plus. And I would say particularly since 2016, a lot of the changes that Donald Trump has introduced. Matt, thanks for joining us. Well, thank you for having me. We spent the first half of the show talking about J.D. Vance, and we were focusing on him because all the stars have aligned for a Republican Party that seems set to coronate him after Donald Trump leaves office in 2027, 2028. And there's not necessarily any factual reporting that Marco Rubio's interested in running or that he's making plans to run.

19:14Astead Herndon:But we also seem like we're somewhat in a Rubio moment. He seems to be growing some power in the White House. And there are folks who are increasingly calling for him to reemerge as maybe a Republican Party voice for the post-Trump era. I wanted to know, are you one of those folks? Sort of. I've had a long love-hate relationship with Marco Rubio. I went from being a fanboy to being very disenchanted with him more recently. And now that we are facing the possibility that he could emerge as the Republican standard bearer, I'm Marco curious again. Well, let's start at the beginning. When you said you were a Marco fanboy, where does that begin?

19:58So Marco Rubio runs for Senate in 2010, and I was working at the now defunct AOL Politics Daily at the time. Charlie Crist was the sitting governor of Florida. He was wildly popular, believe it or not. And Rubio was going to run against him in the Republican Senate primary. And Rubio just couldn't get any traction. So his team decided instead of trying to get media attention in Florida, we will go national and we will force the local media to cover us. And it really worked. But I was one of the beneficiaries of that as a as a youngish conservative blogger and columnist. I had a lot of access all of a sudden with this young, charismatic, up-and-coming politician, Marco Rubio.

20:43Of course, he goes on to win that race. Thank you. I'm glad you didn't say polo. That would have thrown us all off. And I may have been the first person to write one of those really wildly naive and premature Marco Rubio for president pieces way back in, maybe even 2010, possibly 2011. But I also thought Rubio was maybe just a once-in-a-generation talent. His ability was incredibly eloquent. He gave a great, probably the best pro-life speech I've ever heard in my life. I think it was in 2012 at the Susan B. Anthony List gala. All life in a planet where life is increasingly not valued, in a planet where people are summarily discarded, all life is worthy of protection, and all life enjoys God's love.

21:33He was young, kind of Kennedy-esque, boyish, you know, charm, good looks. My brand of optimistic, Reaganite conservatism. And the fact that he was also fluid in Spanish, I thought could possibly open some doors to communicating the conservative message to a broader audience than we had done up until that point.

21:53Astead Herndon:And I think that was certainly the Rubio logic. Well, you know, obviously this runs up against the buzzsaw that is Donald Trump. as a Rubio fan boy, or at least self-described, at least initially. Self-described, yeah. I mean, how did your feelings change about him in that first term of Trump? I think that Rubio very early on realized, I think that he was shocked that he, not only that he lost the primary for president, the 2016 primary, but that Trump went on to win. A lot of us were. So I think it really created a almost an identity crisis for a lot of us. And it chastened us. Maybe we don't quite understand this party.

22:40Maybe we don't quite understand this country. And that led to a lot of soul searching. I mean, think of it this way. The Republican primary electorate had a golden opportunity to nominate a young, optimistic, eloquent, inspiring Hispanic. And instead, they chose a thrice married casino magnate reality show star. I mean, that that that tells you all that there is about it. And so I think Rubio kind of went back and reverse engineered some parts of his, not just the way he communicates, but his philosophy. He's become more populist. He's become, you know, more nationalist.