1. Podcasts
  2. Today, Explained
  3. When Dems take the House
Today, Explained

5 Oct 2026 · 26m · 9 chapters

Episode artwork

When Dems take the House

In short

Ahead of the midterms, the episode argues Democrats are likely to flip the U.S. House, with the key question being how large the majority will be. It focuses on Hakeem Jeffries’ path to becoming Speaker (if Democrats win), what priorities he’d push, and how he’s handled conflict as minority leader.

Guests/backgrounds

Jason Zengerle, journalist at The New Yorker, discusses a profile he wrote on Jeffries. Mariana Sotomayor, Capitol Hill correspondent for Puck News, reports on House “vibes,” strategy, and likely early agenda if Democrats take power.

Key claims

Jeffries’ success comes from deliberate, non-ideological positioning (“hotel art”), and from unifying messaging around health care during a shutdown. Democrats’ early planks are affordability, health care, and corruption/investigations; details remain vague pre-election.

Notable examples

Jeffries’ response to Trump’s racist Obama video (recorded Instagram-style, with “fuck” bleeped). The shutdown strategy centered on health care. Discussion of potential subpoenas/impeachment of cabinet officials (e.g., Pete Hegseth).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:30

Interview with Jason Zengerle

Discussion with Jason Zengerle about Hakeem Jeffries and his political journey.

“I invite old and new friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City.”
2:18

Hakeem Jeffries' Response to Trump

Exploration of Jeffries' calm demeanor and his response to Trump's racist video.

“We reached out to Hakeem Jeffries to talk, and he did get back to us and was interested, but like, it still hasn't happened.”
4:12

Jeffries and the Congressional Black Caucus

Analysis of Jeffries' role and aspirations within the Congressional Black Caucus.

“I mean, I thought it captured his – I mean, the dilemma he faces in some ways, just in the sense that he is this very deliberate, you know, calculated in a lot of ways political figure, very conventional.”
6:06

Ideological Positioning of Jeffries

Discussion on Jeffries' political positioning and his avoidance of being pigeonholed.

“And I think a lot of CBC members kind of viewed Jeffries as a potential future speaker and they started to groom him for that.”
8:01

Handling the Government Shutdown

Jeffries' strategic approach during the government shutdown regarding healthcare.

“I mean, we always joke about the Democratic tent being so big, you know, At one point in 2024, it included everyone from AOC to Liz Cheney.”
10:45

Jeffries and Trump: A Political Rivalry

Analysis of the evolving relationship between Jeffries and Trump, focusing on the potential presidential showdown.

“And that was a real victory for Jeffries.”
15:05

Jeffries and Trump: A Political Rivalry

Analysis of the evolving relationship between Jeffries and Trump, focusing on the potential presidential showdown.

“As the holidays approach, on one hand, it might seem like a strange time to jump into an intense new process, like starting a business.”
16:05

Midterms and House Vibes

Discussion on the current political climate and expectations for the midterms.

“okay now we're joined by mariana sotomayor who's the capitol hill correspondent for puck news mariana What are the vibes in the House around these midterms right now?”
21:43

Democratic Strategy and Speaker Prospects

Exploration of the Democratic strategy, key priorities, and potential speakership of Hakeem Jeffries.

“You know, Jason, who we heard from earlier in the show, who profiled Hakeem for The New Yorker, was saying how he's definitely going to be learning a lot on the job.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Today, Explained, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01We're just about one month out from the midterm elections in these United States. And despite all the gerrymandering and voting restrictions, legal challenges and personnel shakeups, it looks like the Democrats are going to flip the House of Representatives. The vibes of U.S. Democrats are incredibly strong. It's mostly Democrats trying to tell each other, like, don't oversell how amazing of a night we're going to have. So on Today Explained from Vox, how are the Democrats going to mess this up? Nah, JK, JK, JK. Let's enjoy it while we can. The question isn't any more like, will Democrats flip the House majority?

0:42It's how big is that majority going to be? And they hear the sound. So on today's Explained from Vox, we're going to talk about the new sheriff in town, if all of this goes as Democrats think it's going to go. Hakeem's house coming up on the show. What we're after. Support for Today Explained comes from Anthropic, the team behind Claude. Anthropic is a public benefit corporation founded on a hard question. That question is, how do we make sure AI goes well for people? They're working on it, publishing what they find, even when it's uncomfortable. There's hope in hard questions. Ask your hard question at claude.ai.

1:22Today Explained. That's C-L-A-U-D-E dot A-I slash Today Explained. I'm Ina Garten, and each week on Happy Hour, I invite old and new friends for a drink and a fun conversation at my kitchen table in New York City. On this week's episode, I'm joined by Andy Baraghani. We talk all about how he started his career as a teenager at Chez Panisse to becoming an internet heartthrob from his cooking videos to opening his first restaurant in New York City this fall. New episodes of Happy Hour are available every Wednesday. You can watch on YouTube or listen wherever you get your podcasts. Cheers.

2:18We reached out to Hakeem Jeffries to talk, and he did get back to us and was interested, but like, it still hasn't happened. Our doors always open, Hakeem. Anyway, he did talk to Jason Zengerle from The New Yorker. So we talked to Jason. And Jason wanted to start with that super racist video Trump posted depicting the Obamas as apes. Jeffries has this reputation for being a very calm, deliberate, not angry person. You know, oftentimes to his detriment. I think a lot of Democratic partisans wish he would be more angry. But the way he told me the story, he was legitimately pissed off. And he realized that he needed to respond in some way.

3:01And he didn't think that a tweet would be sufficient. He wanted to do, you know, an Instagram post. And, you know, he looked into his aide's iPhone and he said, F*** Donald Trump and his vile, racist, and malignant behavior. And as soon as he was done recording the video, I think he started to have second thoughts. And, you know, they sent the video up to Washington for a social media team to edit. And he told them, like, let's bleep out the word fuck. You know, for him, it was a smashing social media success. Well, well, well. Welcome to the party, Hakeem. We've all been here a while, but we saved you a seat.

3:42Hakeem Jeffries has no fucks left to give. I like it.

3:54You spent months writing about Hakeem Jeffries, and you were given access that a lot of people in the media rarely get to this individual. Why did you want to start your profile of him with that story? What does it tell us about who this individual is? I mean, I thought it captured his – I mean, the dilemma he faces in some ways, just in the sense that he is this very deliberate, you know, calculated in a lot of ways political figure, very conventional. And he is operating in a political space these days that doesn't really reward or appreciate that approach. And oftentimes that approach is not successful.

4:44And I think he is, you know, he's he's trying to adapt to the new the new rules of the road. And, you know, he's kind of doing it in fits and starts. And sometimes he's more successful than others. But I still think even when he is successful, he still has some maybe qualms about it. I remember when when former speaker Kevin McCarthy got the gig, it was like this culmination of a lifelong aspiration. How long has Hakeem Jeffries wanted to be speaker of the House? When he got to Congress in 2012, he definitely, I think, you know, wanted to become a player. There's a hip-hop song, Every Day I'm Hustling.

5:24And I kind of feel that way down here in Washington in a positive manner, of course. He wanted to be in leadership, you know, chair a committee, whatever. He was someone who kind of had his eye on that. But at the same time, he kind of had his eye on that. The Congressional Black Caucus, I think, had started to think a little bit differently about what they could achieve in Congress. For a long time, they wanted their members to get chairmanships and things like that or maybe be like majority whip. But by the time Jeffries got there, they started to think that we could actually get a speaker. and his arrival kind of coincided with this realization on the part of the CBC.

6:09And I think a lot of CBC members kind of viewed Jeffries as a potential future speaker and they started to groom him for that. And pretty soon after that, Nancy Pelosi started to think of him as someone who would be a good member of her leadership team. And I think, you know, I think by 2018, that's when it really sort of became apparent that he was he was going to be someone who could potentially be a speaker what does he actually stand for as a leading democrat as the most powerful democrat in the house i think quite intentionally he doesn't stand for anything i think that in some ways has been you know key to his success is that he has managed for the most part to avoid, you know, being kind of pigeonholed or put anywhere on the ideological spectrum.

7:00He is very critical of the far left of the party, especially the DSA. Do Democratic socialists belong in the Democratic Party, Leader Jeffries? Well, what I can say is that I do not support defunding the police. I do not support open borders. I do not support abolishing the Senate. He views the DSA as, and this is particular to Brooklyn. I mean, he views them as college educated, young white people who are coming to Brooklyn and displacing older black working class people. But I was talking to this, you know, former Democratic congressional aide and basically asking this person the question you're asking me, you know, what does he stand for?

7:48And this person was, you know, trying to kind of explain it and finally just was sort of exasperated and just said, and he said, he's intentionally not trying not to stand for anything. He's sort of like hotel art. He just is. And it's satisfactory. He just is. Yeah. I mean, we always joke about the Democratic tent being so big, you know, At one point in 2024, it included everyone from AOC to Liz Cheney. Now it might include everyone from Abdul Al-Sayed to Karl Rove. Yes. Yeah, we don't have a lot of case studies for how he manages his caucus because they haven't been in power. But I think maybe one of the most telling examples was the shutdown because they were, in a way, like the power brokers there.

8:41Tell us how Hakeem Jeffries managed that. That was probably his greatest success as minority leader. When Trump took office for the second time, especially for those first few months, I think all sort of congressional Democrats and Jeffries especially, they were really on their heels. They could not figure out how to deal with this guy and what they're going to do to stop him. And, you know, Jeffries was even complaining that he didn't have any leverage. It was almost sort of like plaintively like saying he didn't have any leverage. I'm trying to figure out what leverage we actually have. What leverage do we have?

9:22Republicans have repeatedly lectured America. They control the House, the Senate and the presidency. It's their government. But then he eventually realized that a shutdown would be at least a little bit of leverage. But the real question was, what was the shutdown going to be about? And there were a lot of Democratic members of Congress who wanted it to be about, you know, authoritarianism or corruption. They wanted to be at all these different issues. And Jeffries was really insistent that we need to make this about one issue and we need to make it about health care. Americans know that they need us to stand up and save their health care.

10:03There is a Republican health care crisis that is devastating the American people. And we're going to continue to stand up for everyday Americans. Donald Trump and Republicans have barreled us into a shutdown because they refuse to protect Americans' health care. And, you know, the Democrats are the one who caused the shutdown. And normally, in the way shutdowns have worked in the past, it's the party that causes the shutdown that gets the heat from the public. But this time around, I think because Democrats were so consistent in saying this is about health care and Republicans were so stattered in their own messaging and their own explanations of what was going on, Democrats, you know, their polling numbers went up.

10:44Trump's and Republicans went down. And that was a real victory for Jeffries. Did that whole incident put Jeffries on the president's radar in a way that he wasn't? It doesn't seem like the president really talks about Hakeem Jeffries very much. No, it comes and it goes. For a long time, like he wouldn't mention Jeffries at all. I mean, I think Jeffries told me something like the first time he ever – the first time he believes Trump ever said his name publicly was just last year. You know, the way – I guess the way to tell if Trump is thinking about you is if he posts about you on Truth Social.

11:21And he, you know, he was he started to post about Jeffries a lot, you know, and all the usual kind of insults he lobs, especially of black politicians, you know, that Jeffries was low IQ and a thug. Truth Social. This lunatic Hakeem low IQ Jeffries should be charged with inciting violence. The radical left Democrats actually want to destroy our country. President DJT. But yeah, he does seem to be paying a little bit more to Jeffries now than he was before. And do we think Jeffries is ready to go toe-to-toe with the president of the United States if that's what voters decide he's to do this November?

12:02In his mind, he's ready. And I think in his own stilted, rehearsed, steady fashion, he will go toe-to-toe with Donald Trump. He will talk about affordability and he'll talk about corruption and he'll talk about the so-called president. I don't think it will necessarily be satisfying for a lot of Democratic voters out there and Democratic partisans. But I think Jeffries, I don't think you're going to see a new Hakeem Jeffries if he's Speaker. I think he's going to especially rhetorically perform the same way he has before. But I think it's going to take him a little while to figure out how to do the job.

12:51What Hakim's going to do with all that power when we're back on Today Explained.

13:11Support for Today Explained comes from Bilt. Did you know that you can get rewards for paying your rent or mortgage? Having a home is its own reward, they say. But with Built, you can earn points on every housing payment, no matter where you live. You can redeem Built points for flights, hotels, Lyft rides, Amazon.com purchases, future housing payments, so much more. Built also gives every member access to its agentic neighborhood concierge in the Built app. It's basically an assistant that's connected to both your home and over 50 ,000 merchant partners. So you can ask it to pay your rent, make a dinner reservation, book a fitness class, schedule a Lyft, so much more.

13:44It helps you out while automatically applying your member benefits along the way. Built is not just for renters. It works for mortgages, too. So when your housing payment is one of your biggest monthly expenses, you might as well earn points on it. You can download the Built app and join the membership for where you live at joinbuilt.com slash explained. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash explained. Use our link so they know we sent you.

14:12Hi, everyone. I'm Kara Swisher. And I'm Sky Galloway. Twice a week, we get together on Pivot to sort through the biggest stories in tech, business, and politics. And we're taking the show back on the road for a live tour in November. So we'll bring hot takes, I'll bring the insight, and the dick jokes, and Kara will try. Keyword is try to keep me in check. You'll get to see her hit me in person live. I'll do it. If someone has to do it. We'll cover AI, whatever chaos Washington has cooked up that week, and every billionaire misbehaving. That's all of them. And you'll also get to participate in audience Q &A, so bring your best questions.

14:48Scott will probably answer ones you didn't ask. We also have secret special guests, which you'll enjoy for every city. Get tickets at PivotTour.com. That's PivotTour.com. We are selling out, so don't wait, and we look forward to seeing you.

15:05Support for JXplain comes from Shopify. As the holidays approach, on one hand, it might seem like a strange time to jump into an intense new process, like starting a business. But on the other hand, Black Friday is approaching, so there will be lots of online traffic to take advantage of. Shopify can help you make it all happen. It's a platform to use for record-breaking, reliable holiday selling season, and it works for businesses at every stage. Shopify's pre-built website themes and AI Site Builder make it easy to launch a professional-looking website. They also have a mobile app that lets you run your store from anywhere.

15:34And their AI e-commerce expert sidekick can help you manage almost any business task with a single prompt, including holiday discounts. With Shopify, you can easily sell everywhere people shop, online, in person, across social media, and even in AI chats. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com slash explain to start your free trial. That's Shopify.com slash explain. Go to Shopify.com slash explain today to hear your first.

16:05hopefully we're in a situation after the november 3rd election to pull the plug on today explained okay now we're joined by mariana sotomayor who's the capitol hill correspondent for puck news mariana What are the vibes in the House around these midterms right now? The vibes, if you ask Democrats, are incredibly strong. I mean, if anything, it's mostly Democrats trying to tell each other, like, don't oversell how amazing of a night we're going to have. Wow. Yes. And like genuinely in the number of conversations that I've been having with strategists, lawmakers, those seeking office themselves, like the question isn't any more like will Democrats flip the House majority?

16:53It's Democrats will flip the House majority. How big is that majority going to be? They want to play in like deep Trump districts. And they've been doing that in like Trump plus five, Trump plus 10 districts that he won in 24. Now they're like, what about Trump plus 21 districts? And some people are like, whoa, whoa, whoa, guys, let's not get too overly excited because also everybody kind of has some PTSD from the 22 midterms. That's when Republicans ended up taking up the House. And Republicans were in the same place around this time where they're like, oh, my gosh, we're going to flip 30 plus seats.

17:27Republicans did not see the red wave they predicted. I've heard it called, you know, the red sprinkler. I've heard it called the red splash, the red puddle. And then they only gained a five-seat majority. And we saw how difficult that was for Republicans and frankly continues to be. You would think that the Democrats would be trying to sell themselves based on like, here's what we're going to do if we flip the House and the Senate. But I don't hear a ton of that kind of talk, maybe by design, because they just want to focus all their energies on what they don't like about what this administration's doing, because that's the more popular approach.

18:02But what is this party's priorities if they take back the House? You are totally spot on on that. It is more or less vague in some ways. I'm sure Democrats would argue, no, we're being really specific. And sure, we do know that if they take the majority, there's three planks. And this is what Jeffries outlined even a year ago. And Schumer, to some extent, has also adopted these planks. They want to tackle affordability, health care and corruption. We're fighting to lower the high costs of groceries, gas and goods. We're fighting to make health care affordable for every single American. And we certainly will fight to hold the crooks accountable.

18:49Affordability means a number of different things. And the way that Jeffries is looking at it is you have your first 100 hours, your 100 days and then your first year. And we don't really know what is going to come up in those 100 days and in the first year. But within those 100 hours, he's starting to give us some hints. We've established five working groups on affordability. A working group on housing, a working group on health care, a working group on child care, a working group on groceries and goods and a working group on gas and utilities. And there are some issues where they could easily probably very quickly pass, right?

19:34Like those Medicaid tax credits that are going to expire just in the next couple of months because of the one big, beautiful bill. We have to reverse the Medicaid cuts. We should extend the Affordable Care Act tax credits. Also, you have the corruption part of this where Democrats already for months, a number of committee Democrats have been one taking notes. It's like, oh, the Trump admin did that. OK, going to write that down so I can remember to circle back when we have the majority. But I've been told to expect subpoenas to start being sent out to administration officials, to cabinet officials, to potential like corporations that have cozied up too close to the Trump administration pretty much after the House majority is declared.

20:25But again, still pretty vague. We don't have the line by line items yet. This entire episode we're making is premised upon the idea that if the Democrats win or win big, Hakeem Jeffries becomes the Speaker. But of course, in recent history, we have seen a planned succession go sideways for, let's say, I don't know, Kevin McCarthy. Is it all but certain that Hakeem Jeffries will indeed be Speaker if the Democrats win or win big? Yeah, look, from inside of the Capitol, All that I've heard is that he is going to be speaker. And I haven't heard anything from the number of lawmakers who've already been elected that they are going to try to, you know, cause any kind of issues ahead of a speakership election.

21:13That being said, a number of progressives like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Delio Ramirez, a number of those members are already talking to a number of the progressives who are coming in who are kind of being a little coy with whether they're going to vote for Jeffries. And their message has been, look, Democrats need to stay united. We have difference of opinions on a number of fronts, but we need to be united. We need to govern. And we can't get to any of that until we elect a speaker. You know, Jason, who we heard from earlier in the show, who profiled Hakeem for The New Yorker, was saying how he's definitely going to be learning a lot on the job.

21:51And I remember Nancy Pelosi didn't really want to spend, you know, the years of Trump, one, investigating and impeaching. But the nature of Trump, one, like forced her to ultimately do that. Do you think Jeffries has learned anything from how his predecessor approached the president? Because we don't know what these next two years will bring. We don't know how this presidency is going to end. Some people are still worried that the president may not step down. Yeah. No, to your question about impeachment, it is fascinating to see where House Democrats are right now versus like where they were back then.

22:30I do not hear let's impeach Trump that much from like again the 200 and something Democrats that are currently in office and the reason why is because one there is the thinking like okay the Constitution says he can only be a two-term president like truly it's going to be ridiculous and probably the Supreme Court's in a rule like he can't run again so let's not get into that but But because Democrats are already thinking, planning, strategizing all of their investigations, I think we should expect possible impeachments against cabinet officials, particularly Pete Hegseth is a name I keep hearing a lot because there's a number of Republicans who are incredibly upset with him.

23:14So Democrats are kind of thinking a little bit more strategically in terms of if we are going to impeach or if we're really going to try and subpoena or hold people in contempt of Congress, et cetera. Will we have Republicans backing us up in those certain cases or if they don't just create a tough vote for them? I mean, these three planks, affordability, health care and holding the crooks accountable or investigations, whatever it might be. Those could have been the planks like in month one or month two of the second Trump go round. I wonder how much motivation there is in the caucus to like take on some of the issues that have come up in maybe the last year or so.

23:56I mean, ICE comes to mind. We do not consent, nor will we enable VHS and ISIS lawlessness. Iran. Donald Trump has taken America to war without authorization, without explanation, without a strategy or an exit plan. Spending billions of dollars on vanity projects around D.C. Trump is trying to rename everything after himself to please his incredible ego, even winner, profanes our fallen heroes and desecrates the sacred ground. Making billions of dollars off of his own name and brand while in office. I mean, how much are Democrats pushing for the issues that maybe have struck a chord more recently?

24:40Behind the scenes, actually, they've been pushing those things a lot. But my understanding is, is that Jeffries doesn't necessarily want to broadcast anything that could show any divisions among Democrats right now. Like he really just wants to project that Democrats are united on these three issues. Here's how we're going to tackle those three issues. But everybody else is like, OK, but there's so many more things that we have to prove and we should get done and we should show contrast with Republicans moving forward. And my understanding is his idea of it is we will get to those issues after the election.

25:19Not even worth debating pre-election because first we have to win. No one is trying to sugarcoat how hard it is going to be to basically tackle a number of these issues where Democrats aren't united on. And there's conversations of how does the size of the majority affect that, right? Because if you have a bigger majority, that means likely Democrats flip seats in districts that Trump won by a whole lot. So you're going to get a lot more centrist Democrats in the caucus. If it's a smaller majority, that's really going to help a number of those Democratic Socialist candidates coming in have a much stronger voice, right?

26:01Because they can, in a larger majority, it's possible that their votes could be canceled out. So all of those dynamics are going to be on full display. And it all, again, is determinative on what happens in November.

26:22Read Mariana at puck.news. Read Jason's Hakeem profile at newyorker.com or fish the issue out of your pile. Danielle Hewitt produced, Jolie Myers edited, Gabriel Donatov fact-checked, Bridger Dunnigan and David Tattashore Mixed. I'm Sean Ramos-Burm. If you enjoyed listening to me today, but really wish you could be watching me this whole time, great news. I'm going to be talking to my Vox colleague, Andrew Prokop, about these midterms on Substack Live this Wednesday. And if you're like, what's a Substack Live? You can find out at Vox's Substack. This is Today Explained.

27:06Thank you.

From the publisher

Hakeem Jeffries will almost certainly be the next Democratic speaker of the House. What will he and his party do with all that power?

This episode was produced by Danielle Hewitt, edited by Jolie Myers, fact-checked by Gabriel Dunatov, engineered by David Tatasciore and Bridger Dunnagan, and hosted by Sean Rameswaram.

U.S. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) speaks to the press on the steps of the U.S. Capitol on September 30, 2026 in Washington, DC. Photo by Finn Gomez/Getty Images.

Listen to Today, Explained ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: vox.com/members. New Vox members get $20 off their membership right now. Transcript at ⁠⁠vox.com/today-explained-podcast⁠.⁠
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Today, Explained

All episodes