


The episode explores how hobbies can shift from enjoyable learning into exhausting, status-driven, productivity-optimized “work,” and how Americans’ Protestant work ethic and capitalism make free time feel like something to manage. Mahika Barua, a journalist who runs clubs, swims, does tennis/dance, skiing, archery, acting, and improv, describes overfilling her calendar and a strenuous adventure trip (paddleboarding, hiking, paragliding) that left her popping painkillers and feeling physically limited. John Gwynn-Hill and historian Gary Cross (author of Free Time, The History of an Elusive Ideal) argue hobbies historically helped structure time—e.g., men returning home in the late 1800s, and Depression-era unemployment—while free time became “wasted” under the work ethic. Jenny O’Dell (How to Do Nothing; Saving Time) and C.T. Nguyen’s The Score are used to critique scoring/optimization (e.g., “words per day”) and to suggest playful, failure-friendly approaches (games, “write with your left hand,” giving yourself permission to rest). Notable examples include marathon/social media “push your body” culture, binge-watching vs run-club guilt, and photography failure (film rolls).
Mahika Barua; Gary Cross; Jenny O’Dell.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on how hobbies can sometimes feel like work.
“I think I had to really assess what my body's limits are.”
Explore the historical context of hobbies and leisure time.
“because it went from being a fun thing that I was good at to stressful.”
Explore the historical context of productivity and how it affects our leisure time.
“And that's one of the reasons why you have the eight-hour day.”
Discuss the impact of societal expectations on personal hobbies and enjoyment.
“I started getting back into reading after my undergrad when I had time again.”
Understand the importance of failure in the context of hobbies and personal growth.
“We spoke with this historian earlier, and he said part of the reason we relate to our free time in this particular way in America specifically is because of the history of the Protestant work ethic.”
Learn strategies to reconnect with the joy of hobbies after feeling pressured to perform.
“and like I'm here to tell you like it is like I feel like I am like actively now seeking out things that I'm bad at just so I can have that feeling I'm a failure addict.”
Learn how to let go of the perfectionist grip on hobbies and rediscover joy.
“But I think like when people get into that sort of posture with hobbies, it's often something that it's like a habit that has formed over time.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Today, Explained, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Jonquilyn Hill: Support for Explain It To Me comes from Fetch Pet Insurance. Are you a pet owner? Every six seconds, a pet owner in the U.S. gets hit with a vet bill over$1 ,000. Always an unwelcome surprise. That's according to a study from a pet insurance company. That's where Fetch comes in. Fetch is the most complete pet insurance for dogs and cats, according to ConsumerAdvocate.org. You get paid back up to 90 % of vet bills at any vet in the U.S. and Canada with claims paid back in as little as two days. Go to FetchPet.com slash save right now for your free quote. That's FetchPet.com slash save.
0:45Jonquilyn Hill: Support for the show comes from Verizon's Community Disaster Resilience Initiative. According to research from United Way Worldwide and Verizon, 6 in 10 Americans are concerned about a natural disaster affecting their household, but only 15 % feel very prepared. Preparing for a natural disaster sounds expensive, but there are actually lots of ways you can prepare that cost nothing. To help you get started, Verizon and United Way Worldwide are providing free workshops, disaster go-bags, and online preparedness resources. The nation's resilience network starts here. Learn more about Verizon's Community Disaster Resilience Initiative at verizon.com slash community resilience.
1:29The hobbies I have are probably considered brain hobbies. The hobby was becoming more work than just going for a regular walk. I am now firmly in don't let your hobbies become your job territory.
1:45Jonquilyn Hill: Mahika Barua knows how to keep busy. I do a lot of things for fun. So right now I'm focusing on running and run clubs, learning to swim. In the summer, I was doing tennis and dance classes. In the winter, I love skiing. And then here and there, I've dabbled in other things like archery classes. or acting classes or improv classes for the fun of it. So I'm always looking to try new things, but I think in the past it's definitely filled up my calendar where every single day I was doing something where I was just very, very exhausted.
2:41Jonquilyn Hill: Mahiga's a journalist. She wrote about her love of hobbies for Time magazine and how sometimes her hobbies didn't exactly love her back. So I went on this adventure trip. I did not know how strenuous it would be. So on the first day, it was, I would say, like four or five hours of paddle boarding. And the second day, again, we did paddle boarding for, I would say, two or three hours. and on the third day it was a hike which was it wasn't your general hill it was so strenuous and then after the hike we had the paragliding by that point I was popping paracetamols to keep up we do the paragliding I definitely get sick after like 10 minutes of it and I was the only one like a lot of people threw up as well it was strenuous
3:41Jonquilyn Hill: We pick up hobbies hoping to add some fun to our lives.
4:09Jonquilyn Hill: But sometimes they can start to feel like work. I'm John Gwynn-Hill, and this week on Explain It To Me from Vox, what happens when our hobbies take over?
4:24I think I had to really assess what my body's limits are. And I also had to make room for rest and leisure. I can't be pushing my body as much as I was there is so much social media content out there about like how much you can push your body like in terms of marathon runners and stuff like that I ran 180 kilometers in the weekend and here are five quick fire backyard option tips ultra marathon training is about being uncomfortable and being on your feet for a long period of time I just ran a 50 mile ultra marathon and if that sounds crazy to you what's even crazier is that it's something that you can do if you want to do it.
5:06And I was always like, well, I'm not even doing half of that. I'm not running a marathon. Like I am probably not pushing my body that much. So I was kind of gaslighting myself being like, you'll be fine. Like you're not doing that much. But I think I was still doing a lot and it was exhausting. I do love like doing new things and getting better at it especially something I try and I'm like wow this is so addictive but at the same time I would say there was a lot of like social performative aspect of it as well like I was always known by my friends and like people around me as like that cool person who's always doing new things like she's jumping off a hill or like she'll take up a new hobby and like every time someone met me they were like wow you have a lot of hobbies like you're always doing a lot of like different things and I think that got very addictive just to be known as the cool person and somewhere along the line I also discovered accidentally that I feel like having hobbies is now apparently seen as like a social status because right now with inflation and everything we're going through the cost of living crisis.
6:33So if you do have hobbies, it shows that you have the time, energy, and money and resources to pour into it regularly. I guess that performative bit got to me. And then I really had to sit down with myself and be like, what are your values? Like, do you really care about this stuff?
6:54Jonquilyn Hill: Up next, why we have such a strong urge to fill up all our free time.
7:07Support for today's explain comes from Framer. Framer is an AI website builder that helps creators, teams, and businesses ship production-ready sites faster than ever while getting every detail right. Prompt, inspect, edit, and publish in one place at a whole new pace. Agents and humans work in tandem on Framer. Agents can bring speed and scale while humans bring taste, judgment, and control. Agents can solve the gap between AI-generated ideas and production-ready website work. The agent works in the same place where the real site is designed, managed, reviewed, and published. It lands on the canvas, stays editable, and can be published when the team is ready.
7:41Here's everything that can happen when your team and agents collaborate. You can build custom code components, create and manage CMS content, optimize SEO settings, audit for issues, and ship everything in one place. Learn how you can get more out of your site from a Framer specialist or get started building for free today at Framer.com slash explained for 30 percent off a Framer pro annual plan. That's Framer.com slash explained. Rules and restrictions may apply.
8:13Jonquilyn Hill: Support for the show comes from NPR's Machine Gods podcast. AI news comes at you nonstop. But what does any of it actually mean for you? Machine Gods from NPR helps you make sense of it. It's hosted by Kevin Roos and Casey Newton, two of the best tech journalists on the beat. They give you unmatched access to the industry, and they're fun to listen to, too. Casey and Kevin take an AI realism approach. They report on AI as it is. They don't cheerlead for it or panic about it. The show explores what AI means for work, for life, and all of our futures. Weekly episodes mix interviews and industry news analysis so you can be in the know from all angles.
8:56Jonquilyn Hill: And you don't need an AI expert to listen to Machine Gods. It's made for smart, curious people who want to understand what's happening without the hype. Because regardless of how you feel about AI, we can all agree that it's important to keep yourself informed. And you might as well be entertained while you're at it. That's exactly what Casey and Kevin are committed to doing. Listen to Machine Gods in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
9:47because it went from being a fun thing that I was good at to stressful.
9:59Jonquilyn Hill: I'm JQ. We're back with more Explain It To Me. Gary Cross is a historian who studies how we spend our downtime and wrote a book all about it. It's called Free Time, The History of an Elusive Ideal. He says our obsession with productivity may feel new, but Americans in particular have been trying to make the most of our time for a while now. What happens, particularly toward the end of the 19th century, is that a lot of people are beginning to feel, particularly men, a lot of this applies particularly to men, were uneasy or didn't feel like they had a place in the home because most of their lives were out in the office or the factory or the field.
10:47And so hobbies were in certain ways inducements to bring men back into the home around their workshops, around gardening. I can relate to them about to plant a couple of shrubs in the backyard. And also hobbies become important during the Depression when so many people are unemployed. And there was a great push to get people, unemployed people or unsettled people, to develop a kind of a more structured day, a much structured life by developing hobbies, stamp collecting, woodworking and so forth. For women, hobbies are often kind of, at least in that period, were often about reviving or perpetuating old crafts that had been common to women in pre -modern times, you know, quilting and crocheting and the like.
11:50But they all are really about filling time and giving people a sense of accomplishment, particularly in a world where their work was fragmented and sometimes isolating. You know, you could build something all by yourself. And that was very appealing to people.
12:14Jonquilyn Hill: You've written this book about the history of leisure time. I want to know what it used to be like. How did people think about free time before, you know, our modern idea of productivity entered the picture? Well, free time almost didn't exist as a concept. Either you were working or you weren't because of the seasons or because you were experiencing sacred time, like in festivals or church time and the like. But the work time was often intermittent rather than, say, a full day. So people might be working from sunup to sundown, but they would take times during the day to gamble, to drink, to visit with their friends.
13:04Or particularly women take care of children. They might spend for some hours at a spinning wheel. But what has happened in the last several centuries is that work time has become the most dominant meaning of time. And free time is what could be work time.
13:29Jonquilyn Hill: How did we get that? How did that shift take place? In the course of the last two and a half centuries, work becomes more intense and more productive because of machines and because of the fact that employers have learned how to control labor more effectively. Instead of working at home and perhaps having a business relationship with somebody far away, people began to work in factories. And so work became more intense. and that led workers to want to reduce the time that they were expected to be at work. And that's one of the reasons why you have the eight-hour day. The old labor slogan was eight hours for work, eight hours for rest, eight hours for what we will.
14:20That was a chorus to a song about the eight-hour day in the 1880s. Eight hours for work, eight hours for rest, And that becomes a kind of a basis for the division between free time and work time.
14:41Jonquilyn Hill: Why does it feel like our ideas around productivity at work have kind of seeped their way into our ideas about productivity and leisure time? A lot of it is that old Protestant work ethic that was part of the early migration to the U.S. They were predominantly Protestant Christians who saw work as a kind of a special calling from God, really. That what you did and how efficient you were was what God wanted you to be. In following your proper calling, no work will be so mean and sordid as to not have a splendor and value in the eye of God. John Calvin, 1559. The idea that productivity was the most important thing that you can do, basically associated with capitalism.
15:39Capitalists really were all about increasing productivity. Time away from work begins to be seen as, in some ways, wasted time. Free time develops a kind of a very negative kind of reputation because it's time for people to drink and carouse and to be basically unproductive. Remember that time is money. He that can earn 10 shillings a day by his labor and goes abroad or sits idle one half of that day, though he spends but sixpence during his diversion or idleness, ought not to reckon that the only expense. He has really spent or rather thrown away five shillings besides. Benjamin Franklin, 1748.
16:27And the problem was that free time never got the kind of attention and the kind of systematic effort to improve it as work time did. And so instead of wasting time, many people who have this work ethic begin to make their free time into time to improve themselves, to make money, to be busy. And so we have a world where people are often as busy in their free time as they are in their work time.
17:08Jonquilyn Hill: We recently did an episode all about AI agents and the promise of technology giving us our time back. And something that came up is that when we have more time, we often spend it working even more. Do you think that we'll get to a point where we learn how to just enjoy our free time and try not to optimize it? Or is human nature just, hey, if I've got more time, I'm going to try to be more productive? Well, it depends on what you mean by productive. I mean, a lot of free time productivity is devoted to consuming things and to engage in media. Back in 1970, a Swedish economist named Staffan Linder talked about a hairy leisure class that was emerging.
18:05We have always expected one of the beneficent results of economic affluence to be a tranquil and harmonious manner of life, a life in Arcadia. What has happened is the exact opposite. The pace is quickening, and our lives, in fact, are becoming steadily more hectic. We live in a world that doesn't train people, doesn't educate people for life. We educate people for work productivity, for jobs. And we also look upon free time as something that is simply a free choice. And that often leaves people with the choices of speeding things up and engaging in this kind of fast consumer culture that really is so dominant today.
18:57Jonquilyn Hill: Up next, how to slow down and really, truly do something just for fun.
19:15Are you a pet owner? Every six seconds, a pet owner in the U.S. gets hit with a vet bill over$1 ,000. Always an unwelcome surprise. That's where Fetch comes in. Fetch is the most complete pet insurance for dogs and cats, according to ConsumerAdvocate.org. You get paid back up to 90 % of vet bills at any vet in the U.S. and Canada, with claims paid back in as little as two days. Go to FetchPet.com slash save right now for your free quote. That's FetchPet.com slash save.
19:55Jonquilyn Hill: Support for the show comes from Shopify. Starting a business takes a lot of hard work. So it's always a welcome surprise when you can take advantage of some naturally occurring momentum. Well, online traffic from Black Friday is just about the best kind you can get. Shopify can get you up and running fast to take advantage of it. Shopify helps you launch a store and start selling in a few simple steps without needing to be an e-commerce expert. Sidekick, Shopify's AI assistant, can help with business tasks along the way, from store setup to planning promotions. Shopify's pre-built themes and AI site builder can make it easier to create a professional storefront.
20:33Jonquilyn Hill: And Shopify's mobile app lets you manage key parts of your store from anywhere, including inventory, customer support, and payments. Launch before Black Friday, a time of year when more people are already shopping and ready to buy. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com slash explain it to start your free trial. That's Shopify.com slash explain it. Go to Shopify.com slash explain it today to hear your first.
21:05Hi, my name is Lily. I started getting back into reading after my undergrad when I had time again. And very quickly, my feed was just surrounded by people who would marathon read. and I got so overwhelmed with all the book suggestions and compared how much I was reading to other people. And it just went from like, oh, this is fun to do to, oh my God, I need to do the best and be the best. And that's how it's been with a lot of things.
21:42Jonquilyn Hill: This is Explained It to Me. I'm J.Q. I'm Jenny O'Dell. I'm a writer and I am the author of How to Do Nothing and Saving Time. Jenny's books are about how we use time and how we relate to it. And that got her thinking more and more about our free time. I think hobbies are a place where you can see different ways of thinking about time kind of battling each other. I think, like, there's a very fine line between someone who pursues a hobby for the sake of doing it versus someone who feels that they need to optimize it, perhaps even make money off of it. Not that there's anything wrong with that, but, you know, like there's kind of, these are different ways of thinking about the activity that you're doing.
22:29You know, people read the title, How to Do Nothing, and they think that I'm a person who, you know, like literally doesn't do anything. I love to do things, and I love to learn things, and I think a lot of people start hobbies because they want to learn. And I think that in American culture, like a lot of us stop being given opportunities to learn after we're children or after we're students. And I think it's really beautiful that adults seek out, you know, ways to learn, often leading into communities where they're learning with other people. Like, I think that's amazing. And learning has progress in it.
22:59Like, you do get better at things when you learn them. My feeling is just that that sense of forward movement and learning maybe just gets co-opted by this larger culture that we exist in that is also very American of needing to have something to show for your time. So what starts out as wanting to learn something and wanting to progress through different ways of knowing how to do something turns into something that you're sort of like giving yourself a score on without your ever having decided to do that.
23:30Jonquilyn Hill: We spoke with this historian earlier, and he said part of the reason we relate to our free time in this particular way in America specifically is because of the history of the Protestant work ethic. It's just so ingrained in us. How do you help yourself break out of that mentality? I actually, I have to shout out this book called The Score by C.T. Nguyen. I really, really recommend it because he talks about this very question. Games are designed for fun and pleasure and joy a lot of the times. and institutional scoring systems are designed for something else, typically something like optimizing productivity or maybe at best accountability, but they sure as hell aren't designed for fun or freedom.
24:16And in that book, he talks about games and how when you play a game, you take on a whole new set of values, like a whole new objective, and you do that for whatever, a couple hours, and then you put it away. And it's kind of this practice in taking values, putting them on, taking them off, putting them away. The pleasure of games is having an experience of value clarity, right? You know exactly what gets you one point, what gets you two points, and what gets you three points. The values are clear. There are no questions about who won. and so I think for me actually like either literally playing games or just kind of trying to have like a more playful experimental mindset about what it is that I'm doing it can sort of break that cycle because again it's so familiar to us like when you get closer to it it gets more and more seductive like I want a higher number I want a higher number and then you just need something to kind of like break you out of that and be like what is this number even measuring, you know, like for me, I'm a writer words per day.
25:15That's a measure, right? Like one would think you want more words per day, but all words are not the same. And like, there have been moments where I was like, I am trying to optimize for words per day without, I just started doing that, you know, and then I have to kind of stop myself and sort of think about what are other ways that I could value the situation? Like, what were those words? Like, did I make some sort of breakthrough? Like, did I, you know, there's all these other different ways that you can think about what it is that you're doing that are not this kind of standard one. And so that's kind of what's been helpful for me.
25:47Jonquilyn Hill: Something I think a lot about when it comes to hobbies is failure. For instance, I'm getting back into photography. I did film photography in high school. And this year I was like, OK, I'm going to pick it back up. I am going to do one roll of film a month. The year's almost over. I've done three rolls of film, one of which I must have unloaded incorrectly because it was completely blown out. And I'm just like, oh my gosh, not me making this rookie mistake. What role does failure play in our hobbies and how we interact with that? I love failure. I think it's so underrated. And games are, again, very useful here.
26:29Like, we fail all the time in games. You actually play games in order to fail, like, in a fun way, right?
26:35Jonquilyn Hill: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, as long as you're not playing with someone too competitive. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah. Like a good sportsman, right? A sports person is open to failure and knows that that's fun. And I think that along with not having opportunities to learn as adults, we also aren't given opportunities to fail. and like I'm here to tell you like it is like I feel like I am like actively now seeking out things that I'm bad at just so I can have that feeling I'm a failure addict. Yeah, that is true. I mean, once we leave school, once that's done, it's like what opportunities do we have to safely learn things and fail and try it again?
27:21Yeah, it's also just like I don't know. I don't know how else to describe it. It's really fun to be bad at something. Like, once you accept that you are bad at it, your reason for doing it has to be something else. Like, I've been going to this native plant restoration thing for two and a half years now. So I definitely like know my weeds and I am better than the day that I showed up. But I don't go there to be so good at something, to be the best at something. Like, it's so irrelevant to my concerns when I'm there.
27:50Jonquilyn Hill: What's a way to help yourself fall back in love with hobbies if it's been a while or if you've optimized so much you want to find the joy in it again? I want to say like do the equivalent of if you're right-handed it's like do the equivalent of trying to write with your left hand like anything you can do to sort of relax the grip that you have on this thing that's like perfectionist grip and I think that means like kind of throwing obstacles in your way in your own way or like trying to do things just in a way that you've never done them before like sort of rediscover the same thing from a new angle or you know in a different context with new people, like whatever it is.
28:34But I think like when people get into that sort of posture with hobbies, it's often something that it's like a habit that has formed over time. It's almost like a posture that you're sitting in and you just need to like stand up.
28:49Jonquilyn Hill: Remember Majika? After her disastrous trip, she saw a video that really shifted her perspective about her own leisure time. You could even say it was divine intervention. So it's a nun podcast that has gone viral on TikTok. And two nuns were talking where one nun said to the other, Do you have a hobby, sister? And this other nun said, I do not have a hobby. Okay. I want to just like hang out and talk to people. I don't want to be doing something. And that felt so liberating to me because a year ago, if someone said to me they have no hobbies, I would think they're a sloth in human form. After she realized she maxed out on hobbies, she gave herself permission to take a step back.
29:39I allow myself to say no and take, like, a day off or change my mind. Like, if I, let's say, said to myself, I'm gonna go to the run club, I am gonna wake up in the morning at 8 a.m. and then I'm watching like nobody wants this on Netflix I'm like it is 12 a.m I should go to bed but then I want to watch the whole series so I allow myself to watch the series and not go to the run club that's okay whereas previously I was like no you cannot do this you have to wake up in the morning we can't binge watch Netflix we have to go to bed so I was very strict like you know I'm scolding a child or something whereas now I'm like you know what it's not a big deal I'll go next week or I'll go you know during midweek it's not the end of the world so the way I speak to myself and the way I allow myself to kind of like you know take it at a slow pace is not something I was doing before
30:55Jonquilyn Hill: That's it for this week. We'd love your help with a show we're working on about men and friendship. There's been a lot of discussion about the male loneliness epidemic. If you're a guy, have you had any trouble making and keeping friends? If you've got a guy in your life, is this impacting you? give us a call at 1-800-618-8545 or shoot an email to askvox at vox.com. Oh, and here's a new hobby idea. Listening to this podcast ad-free. All you have to do is become a Vox member. It's the best way to support us and comes with a ton of cool perks. Head to vox.com slash members to learn more. This episode was produced by Danielle Hewitt.
31:40Jonquilyn Hill: It was edited by Avishai Artsy. fact-checked by Melissa Hirsch, engineered by David Tattashore, our executive producer is Miranda Kennedy, and I'm your host, John Glyn Hill. Thank you so much for listening. I'll talk to you soon. Bye!
32:39Progressive's Accident Response in California. Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions. Afternoon glare totally ruined my watch party for the big game. That's when my buddy recommended Blinds.com. With custom window treatments made to fit your style, space, and budget, customers who shop at Blinds.com experienced overwhelming satisfaction. Side effects may include a fuller, deeper night's sleep and the sudden urge to host the watch party again. Blinds.com isn't a medication, but it can improve how you feel about your home.
33:13Shop Black Friday all month long at Blinds.com. Don't miss huge deals dropping every week.
If you've optimized your free time so much that it feels like work, maybe it’s time to rethink how you craft and kayak.
This episode was produced by Danielle Hewitt, edited by Avishay Artsy, fact-checked by Melissa Hirsch, engineered by David Tatasciore, and hosted by Jonquilyn Hill.
A woman athlete catching her breath and holding a padel racket on a blue court. Photo via Noko LTD/Getty Images.
If you have a question, give us a call at 1-800-618-8545 or email [email protected].
Listen to Explain It to Me ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: vox.com/members.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices