Cracking the Code of the Rich, with Seth Stephens-Davidowitz

21 Sep 2023 · 48 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Summary: Afford Anything - Episode #462: Cracking the Code of the Rich with Seth Stephens-Davidowitz

Podcast Overview Afford Anything explores how to make smarter decisions about money, time, energy, and focus, emphasizing critical thinking and understanding our behavioral blind spots. Hosted by Paula Pant, the podcast features interviews with experts and addresses listeners' questions regarding decision-making frameworks.

Episode Highlights This episode features Dr. Seth Stephens-Davidowitz, a data scientist and bestselling author, who discusses the misleading narratives surrounding wealth and success. He uses data to illuminate the truth about wealth accumulation in America.

Key Discussions

  1. Who Gets Secretly Rich?
  2. The typical wealthy Americans are often business owners of mid-sized regional firms (e.g., beverage distributors, auto dealership owners) rather than well-known celebrities or athletes.
  3. These business owners often have legal protections that create a competitive edge, reducing the threat of price undercutting.
  1. The Myth of Young Entrepreneurs
  2. The average age of startup founders is actually 42, challenging the belief that youth is required for entrepreneurial success.
  3. A positive correlation exists between age and success, particularly up to age 60.
  1. Types of Businesses That Foster Wealth
  2. Successful business categories include:
  3. Market Research: Requires specialized expertise and connections.
  4. Real Estate Investing: Offers favorable tax write-offs.
  5. Independent Creatives: Artists, writers, and other creatives can achieve wealth through brand loyalty and creative output.
  6. Conversely, industries with high competition and low profitability (e.g., architecture, toy stores, gas stations) are less likely to create wealth.

Actionable Takeaways

  • Identify Your Protection: When considering business ventures, assess what legal or brand protection you can leverage against competition.
  • Increase Your Luck Surface Area: Actively seek opportunities to showcase your work, whether in creative fields or entrepreneurship. The more you put yourself out there, the higher your chance of success.
  • Avoid the Seduction of Compelling Stories: While engaging narratives can inspire, they might not represent typical outcomes. Focus on data-driven decisions rather than popular myths.

Cognitive Biases in Decision Making

  • Duration Neglect: People often forget the time duration of experiences when reflecting on their pain or pleasure, impacting how we remember challenging situations like career choices or job satisfaction.
  • Peak-End Rule: People tend to remember the peak moments and the end of an experience more than the duration, which can distort their perception of overall happiness.

Conclusion The episode urges listeners to challenge common beliefs about wealth and entrepreneurship. It emphasizes the importance of critically evaluating the stories we hear in media, drawing from data to guide successful decisions in business and personal life.

Key Takeaways

  1. Age and Entrepreneurship: It's never too late to start a business; experience can be an asset.
  2. Wealth Accumulation: Understand the types of businesses that are more likely to lead to millionaire status.
  3. Data vs. Narrative: Rely on data for decision-making rather than enticing but misleading stories.

For more insights, visit the show notes at [Afford Anything](https://affordanything.com/episode462).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00There is endless media coverage about how to become rich and how to stay rich. What if these stories that we hear are actually misleading us? That's the topic of conversation in today's podcast episode with Seth Stevens-Davidowitz, who has a PhD in economics from Harvard. He works as a data scientist and has studied the counterintuitive things that data shows us about wealth, which we would not glean simply from news stories alone. Welcome to the Afford Anything podcast. This is a show that understands you can afford anything, but not everything. Every choice that you make is a trade-off against something else.

0:41That doesn't just apply to your money. That applies to any limited resource you need to manage, your time, your focus, your energy. So what matters most? And how do you make decisions accordingly? Answering both of those questions is a lifetime practice. And that's what this podcast is here to explore. My name is Paula Pant. I am the host of the show. And again, New York Times bestselling author. and PhD economist, Seth Stevens-Davidowitz, is here to discuss with us what we can learn from data that we can apply to our lives that we would not, and this is information that we would not necessarily know based on what is commonly or popularly understood by the stories that we hear.

1:25Here he is. Enjoy.

1:31Hi, Seth. It's great to talk to you. Hi, Paula. Great to talk to you. Seth, who is secretly rich in America? Beverage distributors and auto dealership owners. Wow. Not the answer I was expecting. Why middlemen? Why beverage distributors? Why auto dealership owners? Why not the people that we more often think of? Celebrities, athletes, people who had financial services firms? Well, some of those people obviously are rich as well. I came across a paper. It was in the Corley Journal of Economics, capitalists in the 21st century, and they studied the entire universe of taxpayers in the United States.

2:09And they said, who's the typical member of the top 0.1 % kind of people earning$1.3 million a year, really rich people. And they had this sentence that just shocked me. They said, basically, the typical rich American is the owner of a mid-sized regional firm, such as an auto dealership or beverage distributor. And I'm just like, whoa, like, why is that? I had the same question you did. I'm like, to be honest, and people made fun of me because I have a PhD in economics. I didn't know what a beverage distributor was. And when I said that, I said that in a New York Times article, and I was just hammered.

2:41I went viral on Twitter for being the world's biggest idiot. They're like, are we just handing out PhDs? I was honest. I did not know. I had not known what a beverage distributor was, kind of a middleman in the beverage industry. And it turns out that beverage distributors and auto dealers have some legal protection. They're kind of local monopolies, regulated monopolies that you can't just start, you can't just move to Colorado and start a beverage distribution company, kind of Heineken and Corona and all the companies have their own beverage distributor and they're kind of locked in and then they can, you know, the beverage distributors can take a nice cut going from the companies to the actual stores and they have connections with everybody.

3:20So the lesson I took from that is getting rich is really, really hard because everybody wants to be rich, basically. You need something to kind of help you, to give you a nudge to avoid ruthless competition. Many industries, if you start a company, if you're a pest control company in New York City, there's nothing to stop someone else from starting a new company and just undercutting you on price and taking away all your profits. It's capitalism is just a ruthless, ferocious game that a lot of rich people have some protection from that game that gives them an edge, which also implications just if you want to get rich, thinking through what's going to be your protection.

4:00Right. So then how would an ordinary individual, somebody listening to this podcast who wants to start a business, find ideas of what could be productive businesses? Or conversely, what are some of the never get rich or rarely get rich businesses based on the data sets? Yeah. So a lot of things, basically anything that just has perfect competition where there's, you're just selling a commodity in whatever form, you're kind of very unlikely to get rich that way. So you need some sort of protection. Now the protection doesn't have to be legal protection. Brand protection is a big one. So one of the things that kind of surprised me in the data, we know that there are some celebrities that are rich that are making tens of millions of dollars a year, hundreds of millions of dollars a year these days, sometimes there are more celebrities than I thought making, you know, 400 ,000, 500 ,000, 600 ,000, a million dollars a year.

4:53I kind of went into this research thinking, don't try to be a celebrity, an artist, a podcast host, a painter, a writer. I'm just like, this is the stupidest thing you can ever do. Like we all know those long shot dreams don't come true. And when you actually look at the data, the odds are low, but they're not as low as I would have thought. It's more like a one in 20 bet than like a one in a thousand or one in a million bet that I would have thought it was. So I think going all in in a creative career isn't necessarily as risky. It gives you a shot of having that protection from competition, that brand, that those fans that can allow you to make a good amount of money.

5:31To back this up a little bit, the premise of this conversation is that we know from the data that the majority of millionaires in the United States are business owners. That is the number one way to become a millionaire. But we also know, and this is one thing that really came out in some of the research that you've been able to collect, that there are certain businesses that do disproportionately make people rich. And so independent creatives, as you were just discussing, artists, writers, independent creatives are actually one of those, what you call the big six of industries in which people can become wealthy and stay wealthy because of that brand protection.

6:16You also talk about, in addition to the independent creatives and auto dealerships, real estate, investing, market research, and then middlemen, such as beverage distributors. Why is there protection around market research, investing, and real estate? How do those fit in? Well, market research, you have the protection that you've kind of built a very specialized expertise, hopefully over a long period of time. So you've maybe collected some proprietary data, you have some connections, an amazing network you've built over years, and then you know something about a particular industry that nobody else knows.

6:52And you write these reports, you sell them to everybody for an exorbitant fee. And it's very, very hard for someone to just out of nowhere, build up this same knowledge base that you had created over such a long period of time. It's kind of like being an independent creative, but just for more boring topics, you know, an independent creative of the aluminum industry or something. Intellectual entrepreneur, intellectual entrepreneur, I would say. And then And real estate investing, I don't know if they fit in quite with the local monopoly, but I mean, their complication investing has great tax write-offs.

7:25Real estate has great tax write-offs. So it's a little more complicated than that. But I think investing in real estate, they do tend to stay localized to those markets. So a lot of the biggest industries are dominated by a few behemoths. So social media, for example. Right. You know, it's Twitter. It's Meta. Or X, sorry. Yeah, it's X and Meta now. It's Facebook. Now it's Meta. It's TikTok. There are a few giants. There are really these niche companies, but things like real estate investing, they're more disaggregated. There's not one investment firm or two investment firms that just dominate everything.

7:58You have specialists. You have all kinds of different strategies, all kinds of different expertise. And similarly with real estate, they do tend to play to local markets in various ways. So I think that's kind of another consideration is, is it an industry that's just dominated by a few global behemoths? Or do you have a chance of building kind of a small specialty? A lot of times when we think of getting rich, we think of the really richest people, you know, Mark Zuckerberg or Elon Musk, Bill Gates. It is dangerous to learn lessons from them because they're one in a billion outcomes. To be the very, very top five on billionaire, you have to dominate a global industry.

8:36That's very, very unlikely. But to be a millionaire, you want to have some sort of local industry that isn't dominated by a global industry. So it's kind of a different game and a more realistic game to play. Right. And see, that makes total sense to me because I remember from investing in real estate, when we would see these big hedge funds come in and we'd see Wall Street come in and try to buy up rental real estate in these neighborhoods in Atlanta, it was clear that they didn't understand the nuance of the neighborhoods. And so local investors, boots on the ground investors and their friends, you know, like either you yourself are a boots on the ground investor in Atlanta or you live in Indianapolis, but you've got a bunch of friends who are boots on the ground investors in Atlanta.

9:22It's that local one to one where people had the informational advantage. advantage. Yeah, exactly. And there has to be some reason that it's not just dominated by one big firm. And all these kind of fields that have a disproportionate number of millionaires have something that's keeping it localized. Right. Now, one of the other myths that many people believe about entrepreneurship is that entrepreneurs tend to be young. A lot of people, when surveyed, say that 27 is what they imagine the average age of a startup founder to be. It's actually 42. And there's a positive correlation between advancing age and probability of success up until you reach about 60.

10:05Yeah, that's wild. Nobody thinks of a 60 year old entrepreneur, but they're crushing it. They're like the most successful out there. And sometimes you look at the data and it's kind of obvious and yet also goes against what people think, which is really interesting. One thing I learned is that sometimes surprising stories just capture our attention are so exciting and so sexy that we think they're more common than they are. So Mark Zuckerberg starts Facebook at the age of 19 and Aaron Sorkin writes a movie about him. Right. And the social network is one of the most popular movies of all time. And everyone wants to be the next Mark Zuckerberg.

10:43Well, the reason that movie was so popular, the reason Mark Zuckerberg story stays in our mind is because it's so surprising that a 19-year-old is running a media empire. And it's actually incredibly rare and the exception. And more common are the 50-year-olds, the 60-year-olds, the beverage distributors, the auto dealerships, the person who spent his or her career in an industry and launches a market research based on all their context and all the information they've learned over two decades, starts a market research firm at the age of 50. That's common. But who's going to make a movie about that?

11:17Yeah. That's so boring. Yeah. That we kind of forget. And then we make mistakes in our lives where we try to follow the stories we see in movies, which are actually unlikely. The reason they're made into movies is because they're so surprising. They're so off market. They're so unlikely. Right. The man bites dog rather than the dog bites man, which is what makes the headlines. Exactly. So 19 year old starts company rather than 45 year old starts company. And then so many 19 year olds, you see after the social network came out, a large rise in businesses started by teenagers and people dropping out of college because Mark Zuckerberg dropped out of college.

11:57And that's just not a smart play. It's a dangerous thing in life is we're so drawn to the great stories that capture our attention and don't kind of step back and think about how likely they are. What's interesting to me is that there are certain businesses, because it's easy to look at the data and say, hey, the data shows that the majority of millionaires are business owners in the United States. And so if I pivot to entrepreneurship, that gives me the greatest chance of building sustainable wealth. But then deeper inside of that, there are certain businesses where you're just unlikely to have a lot of monetary success.

12:37So for example, and this surprised me. Architecture and engineering services. There are high barriers to entry to becoming an architect or an engineer, which you would think would lower competition. Why? I think there's just like endless supply of people who want to be architects is a big part of that. And it is hard to really stand out. You know, I think a lot of architects think there may be more independent creatives in that, you know, they are doing something, you know, using their creativity. But it's not quite like an independent creative where you actually have fans and like a brand, you know, except in very extreme circumstances.

13:19You know, there are thousands of independent creatives, tens of thousands of independent creatives who have a small group of fans who know their names, who follow them on Twitter, who if they come into town are going to want to meet them or go to their show. That's not really true for architects. So it's hard to escape the ruthless competition of capitalism. Right. What about other industries like owning gas stations or personal care services like beauty salons? Well, the worst businesses by far, except for independent creatives, are things that are cool and like that, again, movies are made of.

13:55So there's a study of which businesses go out of business the fastest. and the number one to fail it was from you know five ten years ago so it was when these still existed but record stores was the worst i mean two or three movies about record stores and everyone watched this and like that's the dream i'm gonna start a record store and then you know two three years you're done and similarly uh toy stores clothing stores beauty stores like they're just horrible awful disastrous businesses there's basically no way to escape competition and everybody's trying to do it because it seems so fun, a game store.

14:33I don't want to just crush everyone's dream, but it is dangerous to enter some of these fields that are really sexy. But then there are some things that are not sexy, but also it's hard to escape competition. You know, mowing people's lawns or pest control, gas stations. Gas stations is a little complicated because the study uses tax data. And I think some of these businesses, they're hiding a little bit of their money. So I think gas stations may be a business where the tax data may just be missing how many millionaires there are in those businesses. Some of these industries shield their tax money a little bit, but gas station definitely is hard to escape competition.

15:09I think of the town I grew up in, there was one gas station, he was killing it. He basically had a gas station right off the major exit of the highway where everyone had to go when they were coming back from work. And then somebody realized he was killing it and just put a gas station right next to him. And they just were in a price for the entire time of my childhood. That's kind of a classic gas station experience. It's very hard to escape competition. I think just everybody in business just has to be thinking way more than they sometimes do about what's going to allow you to avoid someone just coming in to your business and charging a lower price.

15:46So essentially what I'm hearing is you ask yourself, what is the moat, right? What is the economic moat that's around my business and also how high are the barriers to entry and also how desirable is the business how much cachet is there so the optimal business would be low cachet high moat high barrier to entry that's right yeah there's this phrase in business use your unfair advantage we were talking about this before we started the actual recording the podcast that since you've been a child, people have been telling you you had a voice for radio or podcasting before podcasting existed. So that's kind of an unfair advantage that you have in this field that allows you to separate yourself.

16:30A lot of these businesses like auto dealerships or beer distributors, your unfair advantage is that your dad or grandfather started the business when that was possible and you can just inherit it. So that's obviously a good way to get into one of these fields of the barrier entry. But yeah, I think market research, your unfair advantage is the expertise that you built up over and the expertise and connections you built up over 10, 15, 20 years in the industry. Right. And that points to another kind of counterintuitive finding that the data bears out, which is that the best employees often make the best entrepreneurs, which is kind of the social myth that we have about entrepreneurship is that It's the rebels, it's the iconoclasts, it's the people who never did well in school and maybe can't fit in at a regular job.

17:18That rebel without a cause, you know, caricature. Yeah, there was a study of the profits of various businesses using tax data compared to their the wages that the entrepreneur had made as an employee. and you see that it's just like a curve going way up that, you know, when you get to the 98, 99th percentile, 99.9th percentile of employee income, you're just way more likely to have a successful business, to have a lot of profit, uh, to succeed in, you know, however you measure it, uh, which does go against this idea that, you know, Oh, he's just an employee. He can't make it on his own as an entrepreneur.

17:55She can't make it on her own as an entrepreneur in the data. You know, the best entrepreneurs tend to have been the best employees in park because they've learned a lot of relevant information. You know, another finding in the data is that the best entrepreneurs, most successful entrepreneurs tend to start a firm in a very narrow field where they've already had a lot of expertise where they've been successful employees. So, you know, that's another idea that, oh, I'm just going to come out of nowhere and be the ultimate outsider and transform a field because I'm going to see it from a different angle.

18:26And that sometimes happens, but it's rare relative to someone who's been knee deep in the weeds of that business for an extended period of time. That's right. And well, that goes back to another social myth that's often born of storytelling. The inventor of potpourri does not have any background in chemistry and yet was quite successful at inventing potpourri, first at noticing the need to mask fecal odor and then at inventing a solution for it and then scaling that and distributing it. But that outsider approach that the potpourri inventor took is the anomaly. Yeah, I almost think like in deciding whether to try a business, whether it's a good idea.

19:11The potpourri woman I learned about in The New Yorker. I think if you read about it in the New Yorker, it's a bad. It's like the inverse New Yorker correlation. Yeah, it's a bad business. Like if it's in the New Yorker, don't try it. New Yorker articles aren't necessarily made about someone who's writing market research reports about real estate and making, you know, spent a decade in real estate firm and now built up some data and now is selling their reports and making$2 million a year. that's so much more boring than the random woman who decided at a party that she was going to cure the odor of feces with no training in this background.

19:54She crushed it. She's made hundreds of millions of dollars, one of the wealthiest women in the world. So good for her, but you only get one life and you kind of have to make your bets. Hopefully you may take calculated risks and make smart bets. And if it's kind of an amazing story, it's usually not representative of the data. Yeah. Right. Okay. So the, the inverse New Yorker index. Yeah. I mean, not just New Yorker, you know, today show, uh, 60 minutes, anytime it's, yeah. Someone's kind of getting a lot of attention for what they did. Cause it's the reason that happened is because it's so surprising and surprising things frequently aren't representative.

20:35And then so many people just try it, you know, how many people read that story and then just said, oh, maybe I'll cure the odor from urine. You know, people are, you read these stories and you think, well, that seems fun. That seems quirky. That seems interesting. And that's a dangerous way to make decisions.

20:57We'll come back to this episode after this word from our sponsors. This year, give a gift that goes far beyond the moment, an Invest 529 account. Whether it's a child, grandchild, or someone just starting out, you're helping them safe for education that can open doors for a lifetime. Invest 529 is a tax-advantaged way to help save for college, trade school, or even apprenticeship programs. It's flexible, easy to start, and you can contribute any amount, big or small. because the money can grow tax-free. It's a gift that can really build value over time. So instead of giving something that gets used up or set aside, give the gift that can change a life.

21:38Start an Invest 529 account today. Go to invest529.com to learn more and get started. Investments involve risk. Results vary. Consult with your financial and tax professionals. Administered by Commonwealth Savers Plan. You know, when you're a kid, you dream about being an astronaut or working with wildlife or all these cool things. And then when you grow up, you think about not just what you want to do, but also you think about this other layer to it, which is how do I want to impact the world? What legacy do I want to leave behind? And how do I want to do that through my work? For a lot of people, that's when you start dreaming about owning your own business.

22:17But to do that, you're going to need a website, a payment system, a logo, a way to find new customers. And that can be really overwhelming and it's a big workload. That's where today's sponsor, Shopify, comes in. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10 % of all e-commerce in the U.S., ranging from household names like Mattel and Gymshark to brands that are just getting started. If you need a website, Shopify's got you from the get-go with beautiful ready-to-go templates. You can get help with everyday tasks like writing product descriptions, generating discount codes.

22:51Shopify can help you find your customers with easy-to-run email and social media campaigns. And they have award-winning 24-7 customer support. Turn those dreams into and give them the best shot at success with Shopify. Sign up for your one-month,$1 per month trial period and start selling today at shopify.com slash paula. Go to shopify.com slash paula. Shopify.com slash paula. Hiring isn't just about finding someone willing to take the job. I need the right person with the right background who can move our business forward. A couple months ago, I wanted candidates who matched what I was looking for.

23:29And so I trusted Indeed Sponsored Jobs. And I used Indeed to hire two people. I hired an executive assistant and I hired a customer support and operations assistant. And for both roles, we had the posting up for 48 hours. We got so many applications, 125 for one of the posts. and over 700 for the other post. We pulled the posts within 48 hours because we had what we needed. You don't need to struggle to get your job posts seen on other sites. With Indeed Sponsored Jobs, you stand out, you can hire quality candidates who drive the results you need, you can reach the exact people you want faster, sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 90 % more likely to report a hire than non-sponsored jobs, and over 1.6 million companies sponsor their jobs with Indeed.

24:11You only pay for results, no monthly subscriptions, no long-term contracts. In the minute I've been talking to you, 27 hires were made on Indeed. Spend more time interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress, less time, more results now with Indeed-sponsored jobs. And listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at Indeed.com slash Paula. Just go to Indeed.com slash Paula right now and support our show by saying, you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash Paula. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring? Do it the right way with Indeed.

24:54The data also shows when it comes to going back to our topic of independent artists, which we were talking about earlier, or any type of independent creative, that there is a correlation between being prolific and being successful. to have great quality. You must produce great quantity. But also, it isn't sufficient to be prolific if only one localized area sees the result of your work. You actually need to travel quite far and wide to have your work exposed to multiple markets. And that's sort of different. That's the opposite of what we were talking about with real estate, where you want to be hyperlocal.

Read the full transcript

25:34Why is that? Yeah, well, with something like art, there's so much randomness in what catches on. You know, we like to think that the artists who are most famous are the greatest, but there are all these studies that there's, you know, it's very hard for even experts to say that, you know, this painting was really better than that painting. Or if what catches on has such a random component, you kind of need to increase your luck surface area, you need to basically increase the chances that your painting or song or podcast is selected among all the other ones that they're not the same, but they're just, you know, it's hard to say that yours is better than other people's.

26:16And I think a mistake that a lot of artists make and a lot of people make, and this is probably true, even some business people make this mistake too, is just hoping that, you know, the world's going to find you and any way you can get more of your stuff out there in the world, whether putting a lot of it out there, traveling to much wider, being on more shows, being on in more galleries, that just dramatically increases your chances of stumbling on one of these big breaks that could make your career. And, you know, the thing about art and careers in general is once you're in, you're kind of, it's kind of a snowball rolling down a hill phenomenon so you know before you're known you got to just hustle like mad to get known and take any opportunity you have whether you know it's in the other side of the country other side of the world and you know the study that I that I really loved the study of painters where they found that the biggest predictor of unknown the success of unknown painters is how widely they travel to galleries to showing.

27:19So there are some painters and it seems crazy that they try this, but they, they're not having success and they just show their work at the same gallery over and over again. It's like, it didn't work. You know, it hasn't worked yet. It's not going to ultimately work. And then there are other painters that are just constantly both accepting invitations and just hustling to get invitations. And they're going all around the world and they're not at the level where they're being invited to the Guggenheim or the Art Institute of Chicago or the top museums, but it doesn't matter. They're just, they're hustling.

27:48They're out and about in the world. They're in Berlin today and Tokyo tomorrow and New York City, you know, the day after that. And maybe that's not even possible, but they're all over the place. And those ones tend to be the artists who then break in the inner circle of made artists who then can go to all the top galleries and make a fortune from their art. So it's a very important lesson. Pretty much everybody I told this to are like, I need to show this to my friend because everyone has a friend who is just hoping to be found. You know, the artist is just doing the same thing over and over again and not allowing luck to work for them and just hoping that they're presenting the same thing the same way they've always done it and looking for their big break.

28:36And that's not the way to do it. Right, right. Increasing your luck surface area. But But one thing that is notable within art is that sometimes fluke accidents can create the biggest reputational bump. So the Mona Lisa, for example, was a relatively unknown painting until it was stolen. And the news of its theft was the thing that propelled it into a position of fame. And it's now the most famous, arguably the most famous painting in the world. I think that's right. That's another reason that quantity is so important in art, because there's such a random component in what explodes on, you know, yeah, the random employee at the Louvre, he stole it.

29:16People thought Pablo Picasso had stolen the Mona Lisa. People thought JP Morgan had stolen it. It was like crazy. It was like the OJ Simpson trial at that time. And then, you know, everyone's reading about this painting. Oh my God. There was a rumor that Picasso had stolen it because he wanted to destroy his rival's career. And they're like, wow, this painting is so good that Picasso wanted to steal it. It's just random, basically, that the Mona Lisa was the one that got stolen. But the key is, if you produce a lot of art, you kind of have more of a chance for one of them to get stolen. Yes. I mean, that's the lesson I took, right?

29:49I mean, the other lesson you could take is like, convince someone to steal your piece of art to get attention, which I think a lot of artists do, too. Not like that, but the equivalent of fake drama or getting in the news in some way to get more attention for their pieces of art. Banksy shredding his own painting at the auction. Yeah. Kind of a thing. Yeah. Right. What's interesting about what I'm hearing you say is that we often make the mistake of assuming that the stories we hear are representative of the truth. But in fact, those stories are the anomalies. They're the exceptions. And if we actually look at data, the data paints a completely different picture.

30:26But also because of the fact that stories can create self-fulfilling prophecies, we can actually use storytelling to, as you talk about, create buzz around any product or any service, any entrepreneurial or creative venture. Yeah, that's a great point. I hadn't even thought of that. Yeah. So stories are dangerous to make decisions based on, but they are useful for catapulting your career. Yeah. If you're an independent creative, you should use storytelling in building your independent creative career. And that was a challenge in writing this book because part of my point was that stories are not representative.

31:01But there's a reason these stories keep coming out. And, you know, like I argued against I'm a big fan of David Epstein. He wrote this book, Range. Oh, yeah. He's been on this podcast. Yeah. And he has a chapter in his book, The Outsider's Advantage. And he says, you know, all these people come from outside a field and they look at things from a new angle. I don't think he used the story of the Poopery Woman, but he uses I forget which stories he used. but he's just like, look at these people who knew nothing about that field and then revolutionize the field. And people just eat that stuff up.

31:34And the point I want to make is that's actually not true. You know, look at the data. Someone is way more likely to revolutionize the field if they've been experts in that field for a long time. But that's so much less exciting. So it's a little it's just like it's a challenge that what gets hooked in our mind isn't necessarily the truth. It's the best story. And then, so we're all kind of a little bit misled about how the world works. It's a challenge as a data scientist who's trying to be a nonfiction author as well. Well, how do I make the non-sexy data compelling to people so, you know, stay in their minds that they can make better decisions?

32:19And that's not easy. How do you make the non-exciting exciting or compelling so that people, so it sticks and people remember that they're not misled by these amazing stories that they're hearing all the time that just, it's not trivial. You know, there are people, the social network came out. There was a huge rise in people dropping out of college, starting businesses. You know, now it's been 15 years from that. A lot of those people, their careers are ruined. And they're trying to get back on their feet 15 years later from a decision they made because they saw a movie that was completely unrepresentative of how the world works.

32:54So it's very dangerous, you know, our draw to stories and exciting, unrepresentative stories. Right. Yeah. I mean, and you'd see that in investing, too. You know, somebody gets rich off of crypto and you hear that story or somebody gets rich off of the GameStop AMC meme stonk thing. You hear a few stories and all of a sudden the stories become really compelling. And when it comes to actual investing itself, outside of career, when it comes to monetary investing, oftentimes we hear these stories, these runaway stories of success. When the data shows that passively managed index fund investing actually presents the best shot at growing a multimillion dollar portfolio.

33:43deal it's a great example but it's hard like i feel like i follow the data as well as anyone but i invested a little bit in bitcoin when it was at like 60k or something it was just so hard because my entire it's called twitter back then twitter feed yeah just all these people like saying how much money they had made right in bitcoin and just hearing it from everywhere like similar the path to entrepreneurial success is basically mastering a field over 20 years so you start as an employee in a very narrow field, you know, when you're 25, 26, and then when you're 42, 43, 44, 45, maybe even 60, the idea hits, it's your time, you have all the knowledge, you have all the connections, and you boom, you're ready to launch your massive business in middle age.

34:34And that's hard because it's kind of the equivalent of an index fund for your career in that it's the boring long-term strategy, and it's not going to be the single most successful. So while you're going about this, while you're still an employee at 34, 35, 36, some of your friends are going to have hit it big. They're going to have started a company, and they're going to have had a massive windfall, a huge success, and they're going to have the Bitcoin of entrepreneurship. And you're going to have to put your head down, say, I'm following the data, it doesn't matter. And in 10 years, you're going to get the payoff.

35:17Right. And part of the reason that we struggle so much to follow the data, and we are more drawn to story is due to cognitive biases that we hold. Can you talk about some of these cognitive biases? I know you've highlighted duration neglect, as well as the peak end experience. We'll start with duration neglect. Yeah, well, that's a study of when we're trying to remember how painful something was. We forget how long it lasted. Yeah, which is a big part of how painful it was. So you know, we minimize it was a study of colonoscopies of all things, back when those were really painful. And turns out that Danny Kahneman won the Nobel Prize in economics.

35:58He gave people different colonoscopies. He asked them during their colonoscopy how painful it was. And then after the fact, he said, looking back on it, how painful it was. And it turns out people totally neglected how long it took in their memory of it. So it's really important to keep in mind that's a huge factor in how painful or pleasurable something is, how long it lasted. Right. And that can be applied going back to what we were talking about with the index fund investing strategy of your career. That can also be applied to our memory of what a particular job was like or our memory of a particular work experience.

36:33Yeah, I think this kind of goes against part of what I recommend is that people maybe grind out as an employee for a while. But from your happiness perspective, there are studies that show that people aren't quitting jobs enough, that if people are indifferent, if you're indifferent between quitting your job and not quitting your job, if you quit it, you're going to be much happier in six months or longer. the data is sometimes conflicting. Making money may not be good for what makes you happy. And it's not like there's one life strategy that is the right answer for all these questions. And I think people kind of wrestle with the complexities of decision-making and know that, okay, maybe if I stick with this job for 10, 15 years, I'm more likely to be a successful entrepreneur later.

37:20But also if I don't like this job, the data says if I quit it, I'm more likely be happy in six months or a year and then you can make a decision based on that well how important is the chance of being successful entrepreneur in your life how important is happiness in your life and and go from there we'll come back to the show in just a second but first you know when i was a kid i remember on christmas morning i got lots of toys lots of books lots of clothes gifts the books were always my favorite i'd spend all of christmas day just reading and reading and reading. But you know, none of those are things that I have anymore.

37:57They were wonderful in the moment. But decades later, I have no idea where any of those things went. But by contrast, when you give a gift that brings somebody financial security, that's something that lasts a lifetime. Now, when it comes to financial security, nearly half of American adults say that if they lost their primary income earner, they would suffer financial hardship within six months. And so if you want to secure your future before the new year begins, lock in your life insurance today because that's something that you don't buy for yourself. You buy it for your loved ones. You buy it so that in the event that the worst were to happen, your loved ones would have some financial security.

38:38PolicyGenius helps you find your most affordable policy that meets your needs. They answer questions, handle paperwork. Their license team helps you find what you need in terms of coverage amounts, prices, terms. They have thousands of five-star reviews on Google and Trustpilot. With PolicyGenius, real users have gotten 20-year,$2 million policies for just$53 a month. Don't wait until next year. Give your family the gift of security today with PolicyGenius. Head to PolicyGenius.com to compare life insurance quotes from top companies and see how much you could save. That's PolicyGenius.com. You know, we've all set health goals.

39:16Maybe we want to exercise more or eat better or lose weight, but without a plan, they often fade. That's where Prolon comes in. Its five-day fasting mimicking diet gives you a science-backed, structured approach to stay on track and see real results. So Prolon offers an injection-free way to get help to lose weight, get help to burn fat while protecting lean muscle. And in just five days, it can help activate fasting pathways to help support metabolic health and rejuvenate cells, all while letting you enjoy real food. Prolon is a plant-based nutrition program featuring soups, snacks, and beverages designed to help nourish the body while keeping it in a fasting state.

39:55It's been shown to support biological age reduction, metabolic health, fat loss, and energy. And NextGen builds on the original Prolon with 100 % organic soups and teas, a richer taste, and ready-to-eat meals. I have definitely eaten way too much junk food over Thanksgiving, and so I'm actually planning on starting the five-day program because I need a reset. For a limited time, Prolon is offering listeners 15 % off site-wide plus a$40 bonus gift when you subscribe to their five-day program. Just visit prolonlife.com slash Paula. That's P-R-O-L-O-N-L-I-F-E dot com slash Paula to claim your 15 % discount and your bonus gift.

40:34prolonlife.com slash Paula. These statements and products have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or condition.

40:56let's say somebody who's listening to this is trying to make a decision about some element of their life whether it's their career or where they live where they raise their kids what kind of business they start they're trying to make that decision and so they start digging into the data, but they find conflicting studies. And also they find studies in which the subjects, the data set, doesn't, it's kind of maybe somewhat comparable, but there are also notable differences between their own situation and what the study actually looked at, right? What does a person do when they find essentially either conflicting data or slightly irrelevant data?

41:37You just have to be more comfortable with making decisions under uncertainty. And it's very rare that a decision is 100 % chance of being the right decision. It's more like it's a 60-40 decision, or 70-30 decision, 80-20 if you're really lucky. And what the data is supposed to do is just push you from like 50-50 to 60-40. So I think you have to have lower expectations of what the data is supposed to do. It's not a hundred percent of the data is moving this direction, but I've seen some data and it seems to suggest that on balance, you know, so let's say I'm thinking of starting a toy store. My friend started a toy store as a big success.

42:22Okay. Well, I need to know that toy store is the third most likely to go out of business quickly. Or I think, I think that was in the chart of maybe fourth, whatever it was. It was right near the top. One of the worst businesses you can have the average toy store is out of business in three years. The average dentist this business last 20 years, three years or 20 years. Like this is very different, a very bad on average business. Right. That has to play into your decision-making that doesn't, now you might have, let's say, you know, that you've just created a toy that is blowing up the world and it's gone viral.

42:57And Oprah just talked about your toy. Then you have so much momentum where these rules don't apply to you. Okay, fine, that's okay. But you need to know no matter where you are, no matter what other factors you have in the equation, that this is on balance, terrible business. Just know that and then make decision with that in your head. And it's not this ends the debate. And you know, what activities tend to make people happy? On balance, it turns out that people, when they're watching TV, watching Netflix, on social media, playing computer games are less happy than they think they're going to be.

43:41That's like a pattern in the data on average, significantly less happy. And when they're exercising, hang out with friends out about the world at the museum, at a show, they're way happier than they expect to be, than they would have thought they'd be. Now that's very important to keep in mind as you're going through life. If a friend invites you, do you want to go to this Bruce Springsteen concert? Well, you know, I'm tired. I want to lie in bed and watch TV. You need to keep in mind that on average, people who stay and watch TV end up less happy than they think they're going to be. And people who go out to the show with their friends end up happier than they expect to be.

44:24That doesn't mean 100 % of the time you have to go to the show. But if you're like close, you have to keep in mind that this bias that reveals itself in the data. Right. Well, we're coming to the end of our time. Are there any additional key points that you want the audience to remember? Well, we didn't get as much to happiness as I would have liked to have gotten because I have all this stuff on how to get rich and how to get famous. And then when you review the data on happiness, it really is shocking. The things that make people happy are so freaking simple. It's being with your friends, being with a romantic partner, being married, taking a walk, being near a beautiful body of water.

45:07These very simple, very affordable things in life tend to make people happy. So I think, you know, there is a danger in devoting your life to the accumulation of resources or accumulation of fame, accumulation of attention. it's not necessarily the best bet for happiness. You also need to keep in mind all the research on the best strategies for being happy. Be with your love on an 80 degree and sunny day, overlooking a beautiful body of water, having sex. That is all, that's the happiest activity is intimacy, making love, the happiest weather, 80 degrees and sunny, happiest location near a body of water, happiest person to be with, a romantic partner.

45:51That kind of sums up everything in the data we know about happiness. So that's important to keep in mind as well as you're going through life. That is a lot easier to achieve than owning an auto dealership, owning a beverage distributor company, starting a market research company. That's hard. Being with someone you care about near a lake, hanging out or whatever, is not as difficult to achieve. Nice. Well, thank you again for spending this time with us. Where can people find you if they'd like to hear more? I'm on X at Seth S underscore D. I have a hyphenated name, Seth SD. And Don't Trust Your Gut and Everybody Lies are my books.

46:30And I have another book coming out in about a month. They'll be called Who Makes the NBA? And it's about a passion of mine, basketball. Excellent. And we will link to all of that in the show notes as well. Great. Well, thank you. Thanks. Thank you to Seth. What are three key takeaways that we got from this conversation? Number one, stop counting yourself out just because you've gotten older. We here at Afford Anything see this in our inbox a lot. We get so many emails from people who think their time has passed and think that they can't create anything at this juncture of their lives because, oh, I'm already 40 or 50 or 60 or 70 or however old it is.

47:12The reality is their experience and their knowledge could actually help them be more successful. And if we stop believing this myth that entrepreneurship belongs to the young, and that's a myth that's perpetuated by news stories, but is not actually backed by data. Nobody thinks of a 60-year-old entrepreneur, but they're crushing it. They're like the most successful out there. and the 50-year-olds, the 60-year-olds, the beverage distributors, the auto dealerships, the person who spent his or her career in an industry and launches a market research based on all their context and all the information they've learned over two decades, starts a market research firm at the age of 50.

47:52That's common, but who's going to make a movie about that? That's so boring that we kind of forget. So get rid of the myth that entrepreneurs tend to be young because people, when surveyed, say that 27 is the age that they imagine a startup founder to be. In reality, it's actually 42. And in addition, there's a positive correlation between aging and the probability of success up until 60. And don't you dare email me and say, well, I'm 61, so it's too late for me. Okay. If there's a positive correlation up until 60 and you're 61 or 65 or 68, guess what? You're actually still very, very young. 68 is the new 28.

48:38All right. That's the first key takeaway. Second key takeaway. People want to be rich, but they think that being rich is out of their grasp because there are these connotations around the kinds of people who are rich or what it takes to get there, right? People often think that to be rich, you need to have a spaceship. And, you know, what we know from the data and what we can actually prove from the data is very different. A lot of times when we think of getting rich, we think of the really richest people, you know, Mark Zuckerberg or Elon Musk, Bill Gates. It is dangerous to learn lessons from them because they're one in a billion outcomes.

49:14And yeah, to be the very, very top five on billionaire, you have to dominate a global industry. That's very, very unlikely. But to be a millionaire, you want to have some sort of local industry that isn't dominated by a global industry. Things like real estate investing, they're more disaggregated. There's not one investment firm or two investment firms that just dominate everything. You know, you can be a specialist, you have all kinds of different strategies, all kinds of different expertise. And similarly with real estate, they do tend to play to local markets in various ways. So that is the second key takeaway.

49:48Finally, key takeaway number three. You need to increase your luck surface area. Being successful means putting yourself out there a lot. And that goes far beyond the creative field, right? It means trying out different side hustles for viable businesses. It means buying more investment properties if the first one that you bought isn't a home run, or even if it is, right? Your first time at base is rarely going to be a home run. And you need to be at bat. You need to be swinging. You kind of need to increase your luck surface area. You need to basically increase the chances that your painting or song or podcast is selected.

50:28Among all the other ones, people make this mistake too, is just hoping the world's going to find you. you got to just hustle like mad to get known and take any opportunity you have whether you know it's in the other side of the country other side of the world and you know the study that i really loved the study of painters where they found that the biggest predictor of unknown the success of unknown painters is how widely they travel to galleries to showing so there are some painters and it seems crazy that they try this but they they're not having success they just show their work at the same gallery over and over again.

51:04It's like, you know, it hasn't worked yet. It's not going to ultimately work. And then there are other painters that are just constantly both accepting invitations and just hustling to get invitations. And they're going all around the world and they're not at the level where they're being invited to the Guggenheim or the Art Institute of Chicago or the, you know, the top museums, but it doesn't matter. They're just, they're hustling. They're out and about in the world. They're in Berlin today and Tokyo tomorrow and New York City, you know, the day after that. And maybe that's not even possible, but they're all over the place.

51:35And those ones tend to be the artists who then break in the inner circle of made artists who then can go to all the top galleries and make a fortune from their art. So those are three key takeaways from Harvard PhD economist, Seth Stevens-Davidowitz. Thank you so much for listening to the show. If you enjoyed this episode, share it with a friend or a family member and subscribe to our show notes, affordanything.com slash show notes. My name is Paula Pamp. This is the Afford Anything podcast, and I will catch you in the next episode.

52:12Yeah, the Mona Lisa, some random guy at the Louvre. This is off topic and you can cut this, but it's just a pet peeve of mine that I was on a podcast and I said Louvre. And they just I got hammered. Like this guy doesn't know how to pronounce the Louvre. And then I looked it up and I think there is an argument that it is pronounced Louvre, not Louvre. So, but anyway, it was a random employee at the Louvre, as I say.

From the publisher

#462: As a society, we’re fascinated by stories of the rich. We hear news, see social media posts, and read books about how others become wealthy, how to maintain that status, and what their lifestyles look like.
But what if the media we’re consuming is misleading us?
Dr. Seth Stephens-Davidowitz’s research shows that the stories about the rich that dominate the popular press are misleading.
Stephens-Davidowitz holds a PhD in economics from Harvard University. He’s a data scientist and a New York Times bestselling author. 
In today’s episode, we discuss the misleading stories around the rich. We unearth the truth behind those stories, using data rather than narrative. 
We explore the types of businesses that quietly make people millionaires. We describe the ages, occupations and locations of people that become rich, and the unexpected paths they take to achieve this. And we share actionable takeaways that will help you do the same.
Discussion as of September 2023:
01:38: Who gets secretly rich?
02:18: The kind of protection you need if you want to be rich
04:10: The number one way to become a millionaire
08:44: What is takes to be a successful entrepreneur
09:19: The detrimental impact of some stories
12:48: The worst kind of businesses
17:14: Who makes up the best entrepreneurs?
21:18: Increase your luck surface area
27:57: How to revolutionize a field
30:37: The ACTUAL path to entrepreneurial success
32:08: The role of duration neglect in decision making

For more information, visit the show notes at https://affordanything.com/episode462
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Afford Anything | Get Smarter With Money

All 334 episodes
Cracking the Code of the Rich, with Seth Stephens-DavidowitzAfford Anything | Get Smarter With Money · 48 min
Listen in VO