In short
Afford Anything Podcast Episode #636: How to Talk to Your Parents About Money
Episode Overview In this episode, behavioral economist Etinosa Agbonlahor joins host Paula Pant to discuss the concept of "money scripts"—the unconscious beliefs we inherit or develop regarding finances. Agbonlahor emphasizes how these scripts can create challenges when discussing money with family, particularly parents.
Key Guest Information
- Etinosa Agbonlahor:
- CEO of Decision Alpha
- Former Director of Behavioral Science Research at Fidelity Investments
- Author of *How to Talk to Your Parents About Money*
Main Themes and Discussions
- Understanding Money Scripts
- Definition: Money scripts are unconscious beliefs about finances that dictate our behavior regarding saving, spending, and investing.
- Impact: These scripts often vary between individuals, leading to misunderstandings during financial discussions.
- Example: A mother’s anxiety about spending post-divorce led her to instill extreme frugality in her children—a reflection of her trauma around financial insecurity.
- The Importance of Care, Curiosity, and Cooperation
- Effective Communication: Productive financial conversations with parents should be approached with:
- Care: Empathy and understanding rather than judgment.
- Curiosity: Open-ended questions to explore their financial beliefs.
- Cooperation: Collaboratively seeking solutions rather than taking a savior role.
- Key Topics for Family Financial Discussions
- Essential Topics:
- Debt: Approach discussions about existing debts compassionately.
- Retirement Planning: Understand parents' visions and expectations for retirement.
- Long-term Care: Discuss preferences for care as they age, including retirement communities or in-home care.
- Estate Planning: Encourage dialogues around wills and power of attorney, ideally with a professional if necessary.
Practical Steps for Conversations
- Timing: Start discussions early before crises arise.
- Use of “I” Statements: Frame conversations with personal reflections to create vulnerability and open dialogue.
- Sample Questions:
- "I’ve been thinking about savings. What are your thoughts on financial security for the future?"
- "What are your feelings about retirement—what do you envision?"
- Handling Resistance
- Dealing with Stonewalling: If parents refuse to engage in money conversations, look for trusted intermediaries who might facilitate discussions.
- Acknowledging Emotional Triggers: Understand that grief or trauma may affect readiness to discuss financial matters.
Key Takeaways
- Key Takeaway #1: Money scripts shape financial behavior and can lead to miscommunication. Acknowledging these scripts is essential for productive discussions.
- Key Takeaway #2: Start conversations with vulnerability rather than a directive approach. Open-ended questions encourage dialogue.
- Key Takeaway #3: If parents are unwilling to discuss finances, consider enlisting a trusted friend or advisor to help facilitate.
Resources Mentioned
- Book: *How to Talk to Your Parents About Money* by Etinosa Agbonlahor
- Community Forum: The Humble Dollar Forum
Timestamps
- (00:00) Introduction to money scripts
- (09:32) Adult trauma responses and personality
- (15:17) Debt conversation approach
- (27:53) Using "I" statements
- (43:35) Parents' money frameworks
- (56:46) Long-term care planning
Conclusion The episode emphasizes the importance of understanding one’s own money beliefs while fostering open, empathetic conversations about finances with family members. Engaging these discussions thoughtfully can help bridge gaps and address financial concerns collaboratively.
For more insights, visit the show notes at [Afford Anything Episode 636](https://affordanything.com/episode636).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00We all have deeply ingrained money scripts that operate below the level of our conscious, our attitudes, our habits around how we manage money. How do we recognize those scripts? And importantly, how do we talk to other people about their scripts, particularly when those other people are our parents or grandparents or uncles or step parents or people who are very, very close to us who we worry about? To discuss this today, we are joined by behavioral economist Etiosa Agban Lahore, who is the author of the book, How to Talk to Your Parents About Money. Welcome to the Afford Anything podcast, the show that knows you can afford anything, not everything.
0:43This show covers five pillars, financial psychology, increasing your income, investing, real estate, and entrepreneurship. It's double I fire. And today we're going to talk about the letter F, financial psychology. Etiosa trained in financial management at Cornell. She is the CEO of Decision Alpha, a behavioral pricing firm. Prior to that, she was the director of behavioral science research at Fidelity Investments. She's also worked as a behavioral economist at the Commonwealth Bank of Australia. She is the author of the book, How to Talk to Your Parents About Money. Welcome, Etty. Thank you for having me, Paul.
1:15I'm excited to be here. Thank you for being here. Etty, what is behavioral economics and how does it tie into the question of how do you talk to your parents about money? Behavioral economics is essentially the study behind how people make financial decisions. More technically, you might think about behavioral science looks at how do we make decisions overall. Behavioral finance looks at how do we make investment decisions. Behavioral economics looks at how do we make household economic decisions, savings, spending, etc. I've been a behavioral economist for almost a decade. As part of my work, I was working with a very big investment bank, talking with financial advisors who'd have conversations with everyone from people who were in the middle class to very ultra high net worth of people.
1:59And they'd come back to me around every time these people talk or every time our clients talk about conversations with their children or with their parents about money, it gets really awkward. No one is sure what to do. The kids don't want to ask for fear of looking a little bit like we're excited for the estate. And the parents are awkward about revealing what they have set up because they just have that anxiety around how do we have this conversation without breaking our relationship. So I was hearing that from the financial advisory side of things, but I also had friends who were transitioning and having parents were starting to retire.
2:33And so they were also coming to me and asking, how do I have this conversation with my parents about retirement and about what to expect? Now, naturally, any kind of conversation about money has its hangups. We bring our biases to money. There's a lot of psychological implications that we bring to our money. And so me being a behavioral economist and having studied what is the psychology behind how we make financial decisions, it was almost an easy way of having an insight or having those specific insights into, okay, there's a way that we can have these conversations with our parents without necessarily breaking the relationship.
3:06And there's a way we can have them being mindful of the way we all make financial decisions and the psychology behind that. So let's unpack some of the psychology behind financial decisions because some of the money scripts that we learn, we're not necessarily aware of. Can you talk about that? Absolutely. So when we talk about money scripts, we're talking about some of the hidden, unconscious, subconscious beliefs that we have either inherited or that we have adopted about money. Now, they are unconscious or they are hidden because we think that then this is where behavior economics comes into it, right?
3:37Confirmation bias. Assume that everybody else thinks like us. And so when we go out into the world, we're looking for confirmation around our beliefs. Everybody must believe saving is the right thing to do. Of course, how could you not save, right? How could you not be in the fire movement? That's the only way to do it. And so because we have some of these subconscious scripts, when we sit down to have conversations with other people about finances, it can be easy for our scripts to start to leak out. Our beliefs start to be, this is the standard. How could you not be saving for retirement? What are you doing instead?
4:05And that can then bring the accusation and kind of crumble the conversation. And so when we talk about money scripts, it's just being aware that we all have these hidden biases. We all have these beliefs around money. And because our society doesn't necessarily encourage us discussing money in the open like you do every day, Paula, because society doesn't necessarily encourage that, it can be very easy to overlook the fact that our beliefs are our beliefs and they're not universal beliefs. And so being cognizant of what is the money scripts that I have, what are my beliefs about money, and how do I then make sure I'm keeping those in mind?
4:40Those are my beliefs. They might not be global beliefs. They might not be principles, right? that just beliefs I have. Let me keep those in check when I'm having conversations with other people about how they do their money. What are some examples of deeply ingrained money scripts that you've seen? Things like having, and this is an interesting one. I had a friend whose parents are missionaries. And so her whole life, she grew up with the script of, oh, God will provide. And so their whole life, they never quite necessarily had to have enough because things just happened. Truly, like things were just like, there's no food in the fridge one day, the next day somebody stops by and has a visit with them and brings them food.
5:19There's no money in the bank. The foundation remembers them and sends a check. So she grew up with this belief of you don't need to think about it or worry about it because like God is going to provide. She grows up, she becomes a doctor, she's making six figures for the first time in her life and she doesn't know where the money is going. We had to have a sit down session and go through and go, where is this money disappearing and she realized part of the reason that she couldn't pinpoint where her money was going was because she had this inherited belief around I don't need to keep an eye on my money because things are always going to be provided for me it's just always going to work out somehow so I don't need any financial discipline I don't need to know where things are going it's always going to work out fortunately unfortunately things were necessarily working out for her and so we had to sit down and go through that but that's an example of a money script where she had inherited from her parents this notion of things are just going to work themselves out.
6:12I don't need to pay attention to my finances. It's going to be fine. For them, it worked their whole life. They were fine, at least up to now. But for her, not quite the same, right? So that's an example of a money script that subconsciously, until we sat down and went, oh, that's the problem. That's why you're making all this money and not holding on to any of it. It was difficult for her to understand what was going on. And there can also be the opposite type of money manuscript that sometimes forms in which people are a little too anxious. Absolutely. So there's also manuscripts around if I don't track every single penny.
6:46I had a funny story around this. Actually, I was hiking the Grand Canyon last year. I was on a group trip. So, you know, show up and you meet a bunch of like new people. And I was having a conversation with this lady because as soon as I don't know if this happens to you, but as soon as you mentioned that you're in finance in any way possible, give people 30 minutes, they're going to spill everything to you. I don't know. It happens with me all the time. I meet somebody within minutes. They're telling me like, this is what's actually going on with the money. But she was saying to me that, so she has two daughters.
7:12Now they're adults, like in their twenties, they're doing really well. One is in medicine. They're both in medicine. Anyway, they're doing very well. But when they were younger, her husband walked out on her. And so she found herself raising these two young daughters and having to go back to scratch and figure out how do I build a career? How do I be a single parent? And she had this deep anxiety around money because for the first time in her life, she found that she was basically floundering financially. Her daughters were teenagers and one of them wanted to buy this pair of shoes and it was like$82 or something.
7:42They were really expensive shoes. And she just was like, absolutely not. I'm not going to spend that on shoes. Daughters being teenagers, they prevail. She buys the shoes and she's so furious about having to have bought those shoes for her daughter. And it wasn't until we're on this, like on the grand canyon, like maybe a decade later that she's like, I think what it was was that I was so worried about them finding themselves in the same position that I had found myself in, where I was experiencing this deep lack, this deep anxiety, this deep having to like figure things out financially for the first time.
8:13And I was so worried that I was going to, if I didn't teach them to be frugal, if I didn't teach them, like, you can't just have everything you want. If I didn't teach them to scrimp and save and prepare for the worst possible thing happening, they would turn out and they would not be able to handle a situation like I had found myself in. So she was trying to impart to her daughters, they are not wanting to buy them expensive shoes, this notion of you must crimp, you must save, you must track and you must hold on to everything with that kind of like tight-fistedness. When in reality, she's like, they're fine.
8:40They're okay. Like it worked out okay. But that's another example of having a money script where because of what she had gone through, her approach to money was track everything, be very, very careful about it, that anxiety, and was informed by the things she had gone through in her life. So at the heart of it, all money scripts is really, what have we gone through? What did we learn? What have our experiences put in front of us? Those then inform and influence our subconscious approaches to money. I'm hearing a couple of things right now. One is that I'm hearing that money scripts are not just formed in childhood.
9:12They're also formed in adulthood. They're formed throughout life, often as an in adulthood that can often be as a trauma response. The second thing that I'm hearing, and actually this is one thing I'm kind of wondering, how does the concept of money scripts relate or overlap with personality? Because we might learn a certain set of money scripts, but then also there are some of us who just kind of naturally have a proclivity towards being a little bit more chill or a little bit more high strung. In the big five personality paradigm, which has the acronym of OCEAN, the quality of neuroticism is one of the big five personality traits.
9:48So how does that overlap? This is really an interesting question because there's a great paper and it's called The Ant and the Grassoper. It is about how some people have a personal savings orientation. And so some people naturally are predisposed to being better at just saving better. Because what is saving? Saving is you're giving up present rewards for future gain. And some people have a natural proclivity towards being able to do that. It's just easier for them to save. I feel like I'm one of those people who I remember when I was seven, I had a little like storage tin and we lived in Nigeria at the time.
10:22So we get like little, we'll get an allowance in like Naira notes. And at some point in my storage tin, I had like a stack of bills, just a stack of Naira notes. There wasn't any need to do that. My parents provided for me like there was no real need to like save the money. What was I going to spend it on? Dolls? I don't know what that money went to. But the paper suggests that some people actually have proclivity towards saving. Again, this is like exploratory research. They built a personal savings orientation score. I think it's pretty cool. I try to have us incorporating some of our work in some of the organizations I worked with.
10:55But it's not yet a fact. I'm not saying that it exists for sure. I'm just saying it's a really interesting idea. And similar to what you're saying, it's an interesting idea that our personality type, right? So are you more neurotic? Are you more open? Et cetera. Does that then inform and influence how we interact with our money? The thing about money is that we use money as a way of explaining who we are, right? It's almost like we project onto money our personhood. And I've talked about this a couple of times where sometimes people associate debt with guilt because they look at having debt as being a bad person.
11:32And money is not an extension of your personality. It should be a tool that helps you live the life that you want to live. But if we treat money as an extension of who we are, then it does make sense that maybe if I'm more neurotic, then that also then plays out in my counting pennies and making sure I know where every single dollar went. And maybe if I feel more relaxed, if I feel more in control, et cetera, maybe that means that I'm a little bit more open. I think there's some personality, there's some learned behavior, right? What makes a human being is what ends up being reflected in how that human being interacts with money.
12:08But other parts of it are absolutely what did you go through and what did you learn from what you went through, right? That ends up being reflected in your finances as well. Is it possible that you go through something that is so traumatic that it changes your personality? Absolutely. 100%. There are studies in psychology of a really long time ago. This man, I can't remember his name, was working on a plant, has this horrific accident where like a pipe kind of goes through his skull. he goes from being this relaxed chill person to he's irritable all the time he's angry he's literally a different person is this like a phineas gage type of a thing exactly exactly now obviously part of what happened is like his actual brain chemistry changed right but we know from neuroscience that when we go through things it can affect and change our brain chemistry as well so the fact that our personality can change as a result of having gone through traumatic events I think that also probably it would be interesting to see if that then plays out and how people interact with their money.
13:05Right. If somebody goes through some sort of traumatic event, does that mean that they change how they used to interact with their money? Probably does. Right. It probably does. Right. So my next question then would be knowing that our personality could change, our money scripts could change, our attitudes towards money could change and therefore our behaviors and habits around money could change. How do we safeguard ourselves? Let's say right now you're in a spot where you're generally responsible with money. Given that those things could change, how do you protect against the possibility that one day you might not be as responsible as you are right now?
13:46that's interesting it's sort of like saying how do i protect against the fact that right now the version of a teosa who sits across from you has hated bungee jumping would never go bungee jumping i cannot imagine the thought of jumping out of anything in my life i'm not gonna ever but i might get to 70 and be like i've done all the things let's jump off a plane right i can't necessarily protect against that i just accept that one day there'll be a version of you that might want to do something that you never thought you would do, but bringing it more seriously into the domain of money. I think that the best that you can do is make sure that you have resources that empower every decision you're going to make or that you might want to make across the different stages of your life.
14:27Meaning that in my early 20s, I had a job where I was working down the road. Wasn't making a lot of money, but I knew I wanted to save up for a master's, a PhD. I wanted to do something else. So I made the choice to live with my parents for a long time and just kind of save up those funds. Those funds allowed me to go to grad school in the UK. Going to grad school in the UK allowed me to do something else and build my career and on and on, right? While I'm in my career, I'm making the choice of like, hey, one day I might want to jump off of the corporate ladder. And so I'm scrambling away money and just putting money away and aside so that one day when I do make the jump, I'm like, all right, you have XYZ years of runway, like don't do crazy things, but also I've empowered you, right, future teaser, to be able to make decisions that you want to make in the future.
15:11So knowing that you can't necessarily control for who you're going to be in the future, right? But what you can do is make decisions around how am I saving, how am I investing, what am I putting my money in that then allow my future me to have options and to be able to make, if you want to go bungee jumping, like go for it. But like, I'm going to do what I can do to make sure you have the money to take care of yourself afterwards, right? Right. You mentioned earlier that many people feel a lot of shame around debt. You were talking about debt a few minutes ago. One of the tough conversations that people often have with their parents is, hey, mom and dad, do you have any debt?
15:50Or, hey, mom and dad, I know that you have debt and I'm worried about that because you're 75. How do you approach that conversation without sounding judgmental? Mm, that's a big one. With debt, because there can often be the shame, this guilt, because we tie our personalities so finely to money in a way that I honestly think is a little bit unhealthy. But with debt, approaching that conversation, it has to be from a perspective of care, from a perspective of empathy, also from normalization. A lot of Americans have debt, right? There was a study that came out a couple of years ago, and it said that even people who make six figures are living paycheck to paycheck, which means one paycheck falls apart and that's it.
16:35They're officially in debt with the rest of the country. And so I think that it's, first of all, starting by normalizing this. Hey, a lot of people have debt. It's not something to be ashamed of. But it's almost like if your house is on fire, you don't go outside and go, oh, my God, house is on fire. I'm such a terrible person. You go, the house is on fire. Let's work to put it out. So it's the same approach, approaching with empathy, approaching with care. First of all, normalizing it, something a lot of people have. Second of all, what does it look like right now? Let's just understand what the situation is.
17:05We're approaching this with curiosity, which means we're not making judgmental statements. We're not approaching a conversation as though we are the savior who needs to come in and fix it. We're curious. You and your parent are going to come to a solution together. I talk about care, curiosity, and cooperation. So care is, I'm coming in with empathy. I'm normalizing the situation. I'm making sure you don't feel like your back is up against the wall or like the parent doesn't feel like the child is coming in to attack them, point their fingers or anything. That's care. Curiosity is asking open-ended questions.
17:37We want to explore what is the debt? What are the holdings? And then cooperation. What can we do? What are the solutions? A lot of times when parents and adults shouldn't have these financial conversations, I think adult children often feel the burden of being the savior. I must have all the answers before I start this conversation. I must be able to point to, you can do this or this or this. No, they're also adults. And so we get to come up with a solution together. And so approaching that conversation around debt is just starting with that empathy. It's also normalizing it. And then it's also curious how, where do things stand right now?
18:14And what can we do to start to tackle it in a way that's psychologically comfortable for your parent? At what point should that conversation happen? As adult children of aging parents, which I think describes the majority of people who are listening to this, when is it none of your business and when is it time for you to have a conversation with them? When is your parents' health none of your business? At what age does it officially become responsible for you to care about your parents' health? Hmm. Probably around. I mean, I know that's supposed to be a rhetorical question, but if I were to answer that literally, I would say when there is a reasonable chance that you yourself are going to have to modify your own life in order to caretake for them.
19:01Yes. And financial conversations, if possible, should start at least one step or so before that, because you want to understand how are they managing things right now? Before we are at the position of we're 85 and there's big debt, how are they managing things? What is the lifestyle? What do they want to do in the future? Right. What are they working with? Just trying to understand that even before there's an issue, even before you're responsible for modifying your life. We want to try and have these conversations early enough that if you will have to modify your life down the line, you're aware of that and you can prepare for that.
19:37Versus we're having a conversation, you're 85 and now I'm worried about, well, how do I pay for the kids soccer camp and also pay for you to live in a safe place? So it's better to have those conversations earlier before you even think you need to be having them. Your parents are starting to approach retirement maybe a couple of years before. start the conversation even earlier, just start and normalize having those conversations around money so that when it does really matter, you already have that habit of you have the trust, you have the transparency, you have the language as well to speak to each other around it.
20:11On that note, then, what are some good ways of approaching, you know, we talked earlier about debt, but more broadly, approaching the conversation of mom and dad, how prepared are you for the future? How prepared are you for retirement? I talk about using iScripts. So I've been thinking about savings. I've been thinking about investing. I've been exploring student loans. And wow, did you know so many people in this country carry student loans? Isn't that crazy? When you guys were my age, how did you do it? How did you think about navigating the situation? How are you thinking about what are you looking forward to in the next XYZ with regards to your money?
20:49How do you feel about retirement, right? Curiosity. but we started a conversation with an I statement. And why you want to start with I is that you are also being vulnerable. You're starting with your own vulnerability because what you're about to have is a vulnerable conversation, right? Money is deep, it carries trauma, et cetera, et cetera. So you're asking them to have a vulnerable conversation. So you want to start by you being vulnerable, which is the I statement, something about yourself and what you've been exploring. And then with care, with curiosity, you open it up to them. What do you think?
21:17The other reason that you want to start with the I statement and have the conversations like, what do you think? How do you explore? How have you thought about this? It's because instead of then there being you in the position of a teacher trying to help fix your parents' errors, you both have this seesaw of you're giving them advice, they're giving you advice, you're giving them a perspective, they're giving you a perspective. So there's that seesaw of like the roles that you're playing as well. But I do recommend you start with the I statement to open up those conversations. Can we walk through a couple of sort of sample scripts?
21:46Because these conversations, you can open them with an I statement, but very quickly, they can often devolve. Either the parent clams up and doesn't want to talk about it, or the parent gets defensive, changes the subject. There are a lot of kind of different ways in which that can devolve and there, you need to sort of be prepared. So can we walk through a few of those examples? Yeah, absolutely. And before we do that, I also want to highlight, there's two main things. First of all, expect a series of conversation, right? It's not going to be one major conversation that takes care of all the finances and then we never have to talk about this ever again.
22:24It's going to be baby steps. Maybe you get to two sentences in the first conversation and they're like, all right, let's talk about the garden. You know, and maybe it's, we get a little bit here, a little bit there, expect a series of conversations and plan to have ongoing continuous conversations. The second one is these conversations are hard, period. You're not going to get it right, necessarily. There's no getting it right. They're difficult, period. And so give yourself grace. Give yourself grace for the first one might be awkward. The first one might devolve. The first one might not quite get to where we're trying to get to.
22:54But giving yourself that grace and understanding this is a hard thing to do. And so we're just going to keep trying until we feel like we've got into a good place together. So let's say that you try to approach a money conversation with your parents. Let's say maybe one parent passed away and you want to talk to the surviving parent about what their plan moving forward is. And already it's a highly charged emotional time. You then approach the surviving parent and say, hey, mom or dad, I know that you're processing a lot and this is a really difficult time, but I want to know how are your finances looking?
23:32Are you in debt? Are you secure? I don't know anything about your financial situation. I want to make sure that you're okay. Let's say that you approach it like that and the parent immediately says, I'm overwhelmed. I can't handle this right now. And shuts that conversation down. What do you do? Is it urgent that they have the conversation right then? I guess you don't know because you don't know anything about their financial situation. Okay. Because when people have experienced grief, and I know this is more of like in general, a stonewall in conversation, When people have experienced grief, I always say like don't allow them to make any major financial decisions for a couple of months until they've kind of, it's just a grief is complex, grief is big.
Read the full transcript
24:14You want to give them a chance to process, work through it and kind of be at a place of, okay, before you touch anything, just kind of have a chance to sit in the grief and then we can talk about and work through things. I actually have an example in the book of a mom who was grieving her husband and just wasn't in a place to discuss finances for a couple of months until they were at a place of like, okay, now I'm open. Now let's talk about, can you help me with this bill? Can you help me? Like, let's talk about the balancing checkbooks or however that plays out. But in terms of when people stonewall and say, I'm not ready to have that conversation or brush it off, it's okay to step back and bring it back up at a different time.
24:56You do want to be persistent. You do definitely want to bring it back up again so they understand, like, we are going to have this conversation. It might not be right now. And also exploring different tactics and different openings, right? In general, that vulnerable. I've been thinking about my finances and how things are going. I'm worried about. or how are you feeling about your finances? How do you think everything, how prepared do you feel now that we're like in this position with this partner passing away? Do you need any help? Can we help you with anything financially? Are things okay? And it might even just be that offer of help to start with, right?
25:32Do you need anything? Do you need any help with anything financially? And that allows them to then say, actually, yes, he handled all the bills. I have no idea what's going on. Or he said, if anything happened, I should go talk to Gary, the financial advisor And so I have a meeting with Gary on Friday and we'll know where things are. But starting with that offer of help might be a good way to start by approaching that or getting around the stonewalling. What do you do if you bring it back up over and over, but they just continue to stonewall? I once gave the example of I live in a neighborhood that has a lot of dogs, but I don't have dogs, so I don't know how it works.
26:06But sometimes I see someone like trying to take the dog on a walk and the dog just sits on a pavement. They have no intention of moving at all. And what does the person do? They stand there until the dog is ready to move. They try with a leash and they jack and eventually they're like, all right, when you're ready, I'm ready. That's eventually what happens. You can't force people to have conversations they don't want to have. That's the truth. And so this book only works to the extent that your parent is open and cooperative and you're able to get around the stonewall and unable to have vulnerability and empathy and care for each other enough to get to a good financial discussion or financial plan together.
26:38where a parent is absolutely not willing to discuss that, then who do they want to talk to? Who do they trust? Do they have a best friend who they trust? Do they have a spiritual leader who they trust? Do they have, is there anybody else in their community who they look up to and who they would be willing to have a conversation with? Because then you might have to go to that person and say, they're not going to talk to me about the money. I'm worried about blah, blah, blah. Could you take them out for lunch and just ask a couple of questions? I have a mentor who a while ago, one of their children was going through something and they were teenagers.
27:10So my mentor wasn't quite sure how to like, they just don't talk to her. And so she invited a psychologist that this teenager really liked. They just got along as like buddies. She invited a psychologist to dinner and said, I would like to know this, this, and this. If you could find a way to bring it up during the conversation, I just want to know what's going on. And so the psychologist came as a friend of the family. They had dinner together and just casually, oh, what do you think about this? How would you, So, you know, it just brought up the bits and pieces that my friend was able to understand.
27:37Ah, okay. Nothing to worry about. It's okay. Right. So sometimes it might not be you who has a conversation. If your parent absolutely refuses to speak to you about it, you might have to get somebody else who they like, who they trust, who they respect to have that conversation. Right. I can imagine that for many parents, it would be awkward to talk to their children, their adult children about money because to an extent they view their adult children as children children. Exactly. Like, it's like I told you how to brush your teeth and put your shoes on. What are you talking about? My money. But it's also why you want to start those conversations early.
28:12And, you know, that position of let them teach you what they're doing with their money, because then it gives you insight into how they manage it. Right. And over time, that kind of balance of like, oh, this is what I'm thinking about doing. What did you do? Oh, I'm investing in this property. What did you buy? You know, over and over and over. eventually you build trust at the point of them being like yeah this is how we're thinking about retirement this is what we have kind of saved up this is how we're like it might not be actual numbers it might just be like vaguely like yeah we're gonna buy this house we're thinking we might do half the time here half the time there or we've been handed by student loans for the last 60 years and we're not quite sure what we're going to do about it but we'll cross that bridge when we get to it and then that might be like okay let's have a real conversation and figure it out but over time, slowly is how the conversations develop.
29:04The kids are back in school now, and I finally have some extra time to plan a weekend getaway for just us. We've been wanting to visit Lancaster County, Pennsylvania for a while now, because I've heard so many people rave about it. We love exploring new places, finding the cutest shops, and eating at restaurants that the locals love. discoverlankaster.com is the best place to learn about the unique things to do and upcoming events plan your trip alongside us at discoverlankaster.com slash amplified introducing your new dell pc with the intel core ultra processor it helps you handle a lot even when your holiday to-do list gets to be a lot like organizing your holiday shopping and searching for great holiday deals and customer questions and customers requesting custom things plus planning the perfect holiday dinner for vegans, vegetarians, pescatarians, and Uncle Mike's carnivore diet.
29:54Luckily, you can get a PC with all-day battery life to help you get it all done. That's the power of a Dell PC with Intel inside, backed by Dell's price match guarantee. Get yours today at dell.com slash deals. Terms and conditions apply. See dell.com for details. I want to shout out to all the small business owners out there. You wear a million hats, you're doing a lot of things and you show up for your team every single day. Gusto can help you take some of that load off, especially when it comes to payroll, benefits, and compliance. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses.
30:34It's all in one, remote friendly, and incredibly easy to use. So you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. We're talking about automatic payroll tax filing, simple direct deposits, health benefits, commuter benefits, workers' comp, 401k, you name it, Gusto makes it simple. One monthly price, no hidden fees, and you get automated tools that are built right in. Offer letters, onboarding materials. So you save lots of time. You get direct access to certified HR experts, and it's quick and simple to switch. I've been using Gusto since 2017 or 18. It's been a long time. I remember I was living in Las Vegas at the time and I brought on my first team member, a woman by the name of Erin, who ended up working with us for six years.
31:19That was when I got on Gusto and I'm still there today. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash Paula and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash Paula. One more time, gusto.com slash Paula, G-U-S-T-O.com slash P-A-U-L-A.
31:49We've touched on debt and retirement planning. Some of the questions that you do want to ask go beyond the obvious. So with retirement, for example, there's sort of the obvious, all right, have you saved enough for retirement? But then beyond that, going a little bit deeper into it, there are some more philosophical questions around, look, are you prioritizing security or are you prioritizing legacy or are you prioritizing adventure? You know, like kind of getting a sense of their values as well. Can you talk about that? Absolutely. So with the retirement conversation, the earlier conversations are really about what is the life you want to leave in retirement?
32:27Is it more adventure? Do you want to travel all over Europe? Is it more hunker down, leave a legacy? Is it more this guy wrote this book, Die With Zero, I believe it was. Is it more of a direct zero, you know, let's understand what is the life that you want to live in retirement. Okay. Where are you now with relation to that, right? What is the gap between what you want to do a couple of years from now and where you are? If it's, oh yeah, we're good. Well, we bought the house, we bought, you know, everything was secure. We're okay with that. Then it's a conversation of, okay, let's keep going.
32:59Let's keep checking in. And, you know, if you need my help with anything, I can lean in, happy to like help out. Or as you get closer to retirement, there might be decisions around things like with your investments, you know, distributions, things like that. We can have those conversations or you can tell me what you're learning and teach me about it as well. If it's on the other side of just want to get into retirement and hopefully social security can't like help me not live on cat food, then let's talk about that and let's figure out, okay, maybe you need to work a little bit longer. Maybe it's, can we help you out for a while, so you defer taking Social Security for as long as you can before, so it grows a little bit more.
33:37But the depth of conversations around retirement, it starts with what is the vision? What do they want to do in retirement? What do they envision it being like? What is the difference between what they want and where they are right now? The next level then is, can we bridge that gap if there is a gap? Or if you've crossed the gap, you're okay, great. What are the things that you're going to need my help with or for as you get to that place, right? Like let's keep talking. Or sometimes you just bring it. Maybe you feel like they're okay. Every now and then you bring the conversation up and you just do a bit of a brief check-in.
34:10But those kind of clear themes around what do you want, where are you now, what do we need to do to like bridge that gap if there is a gap can help you understand the depth and the breadth of the conversation around the retirement planning. Another element of having effective financial conversations with parents is understanding at a more broad level, the parents' framework, their philosophy on money, the lens through which they view this. Can you talk about that? So in the same way, before you have those conversations, you want to be aware of the lens through which you view money, your biases, your beliefs, etc.
34:49it's also important to understand how your parent also thinks about and what their approach to money is right and also being aware that that can change over time right so when they were raising you their priorities might have been to scrimp and save and so they had that kind of focus because the season of life that they were in required it right it's like if we need to take care of you guys we need to make sure we hit all the marks and we have to be careful with the money around that maybe in a different season of life, they've done all the things they wanted to do. And so they're in a place of, I'm investing more in the grandchildren's education.
35:25I'm spending money in ways that may not resonate or that you may not recognize from when I was raising you, but those are decisions I'm making now. So being aware that those scripts and those beliefs can also change over time in the conversations around money, it's also what you're also trying to do is understand what is the framework, right? I understand that, you know, the fishbowl analogy, right? What is water? I understand the water I'm swimming in. What is the water that they're swimming in now? Right. I want to understand that because then we're not talking at cross purposes. I'm not talking as if you should be saving and, you know, scrimping and making sure that all your investments, you're maximizing it.
36:00Whereas they're more in the space of, I did all of that and now I'm going to spend it all. So it allows us to just understand and have empathy for the lens to which one is viewing the money at least. And so fundamentally, this goes back to money scripts. right? It's kind of the recognizing what money scripts your parents hold. What money script they hold, what phase of life they're in, what they want to do and how they're viewing the money. It's really interesting. Sometimes the money scripts don't necessarily change. One of my parents, for example, it has always been, I would rather fly economy even if I could fly first class forever.
36:37I'd rather fly economy and just like, because I'm used to that. That's just BAU, like business as usual. That's almost a habit, right? It's less of a, I believe that by flying in Calamia, I can save a few hundred more dollars that maybe my estate and my legacy plan doesn't need. But it's just a habit. That's what I do. I fly the cheapest way possible. And so the conversations we have with that parent is like, hey, did you know that comfort is a real thing? And it's okay for you to try and experience that when you fly long distance. We're not saying doing it every time, but every now and then, like, you know, live a little, like breathe.
37:07And so going back to the idea of everything at the end of the day is, is manuscripts, is our habits, it's also having these conversations allows us to start to open our parents' manuscripts a bit, right? While we're learning them and we're like understanding where they're coming from, what is a habit, what's a belief, what is a manuscript, it also allows us to put things in front of them they may not have thought of. Like, you could try this, you could do that. Have you thought about a walk-in group? Oh, maybe you're at the place where you actually do need a financial advisor. Maybe now is the time to start to think about estate planning.
37:38Maybe you should have some of those properties in trust, right? In the same way, they're also allowed to look at our lives and say, I feel like you should have my insurance for the kind of life you're living. So it's also that kind of give and take. And that comes from that base belief of, or that base understanding of where you're now, what is the way of you in the world when it comes to your money and vice versa. What are some good questions that you can ask your parents to prompt a better understanding of their money scripts and their place in life? what makes you feel good now like in terms of spending money what are you saving for what are you saving for what makes you feel good now what are some lessons that you've learned about money throughout your life and have they changed what does success look like for if you could live not even success what does a good life look like to you now moving forward what are the things you still want to experience i'm not asking like what is your manuscript what are your values We express those in the things that we buy.
38:35We express those in the things that we forego buy. We express those in the things we invest in. Our financial decisions reveal our values and our beliefs, right? And so having conversations around, what are you spending? What are you saving? What do you still want to do? Allows you to start to understand, okay, they're in a place now where the script is, they're moving slowly away from that. Everything is abundance, abundance, abundance script, and I can just do whatever. And it looks like they're moving more towards, we're thinking about you guys and how do we support you guys financially. And so we're thinking about legacy and that's impacting our financial decisions, et cetera.
39:09So just bringing it back to what are you saving and what are you spending and what are you looking for to those financial decisions, asking questions with curiosity, not condemnation, allows you to start to understand what are the beliefs, what's sitting behind those financial decisions. Yeah. What does financial success mean to you? What's your definition, your personal definition of financial success? Moving off of the topic of money scripts, so we've talked about asking them about their debts, asking them about their retirement planning, and also more broadly, getting an understanding of their money scripts.
39:45All of those topics that we've covered so far have been fairly general. What about more specific conversations around long-term care, long-term planning? advanced health directives. I mean, these are things people really don't, some people really don't want to talk about. How do we approach and what questions should we be asking? When it comes to down the line, what do you want? Do you want to live at home and have like a nurse who's with you if you need a nurse? Do you feel like you might want to be in like a retirement community with other people who are your age? Do you want to downsize? Do you want to listen to your episode where you're recommending somebody live in Ecuador?
40:29Do you want to do your arbitrage and live in a different country? If you're from a different country, do you want to go back home? It's the first broad question of what do you want? What do you envision in your latter days? Do you want to be at home? Do you want to be somewhere else? What's your plan? And the reasons, one of the reasons you want to have these conversations early enough is that you can actually work towards a plan versus if you're asking it when the plan is, whatever we talk about we have to implement in a year. Maybe that's not the right time. But if you're at that place, it's also, okay, I know what you would like to do.
41:02What can we afford to do? What is reasonable? Maybe we actually can't afford to have a full-time nurse in the house with you unless we downsized and took some of that money and then used it to pay a nurse. Maybe there's trade-offs we're making, but we start with what do they actually want to do? Next level around the POA, advanced directives, all of those things, those come with the estate planning conversation. Want to highlight that not everybody's ready for that conversation. I still have a parent who absolutely refuses to deal with it. And I have written a book on it that they've read. So when they are ready to have that conversation, and it might not be, you know, I know the book is how to talk to your parents about money, but sometimes it could be how to have another expert talk to your parents about money.
41:47and so it could be your friend marlene has a great financial advisor or has a great estate planning lawyer who she was raving about maybe you guys can grab coffee and you can just have a chat with that lawyer and the lawyer the estate planning lawyer can walk them through okay this is why you need a poa this is why you need an advance directive this is why you need this part and that part this is how everything comes together and makes sense you don't have to be the expert in the room all the time and so that allows you to then go okay it's important that you have an estate plan. Maybe you don't do everything at once.
42:18Maybe you do the power of attorney to start with, because health-wise, we just want to make sure that everything is okay. I can sign for you. I can help you make the decisions that you would want to make if you were not able to. So maybe we start with, I have a very limited power of attorney to help you execute certain things. And then we kind of go from there. With the very specific niche kind of conversations, it's either, you know, use the book. We talk through like all of the different elements and angles you might want to talk or think through or have an expert an estate planning lawyer somebody else who can sit down with them and go step by step by step by step this is how you think about it this is why it makes sense this is how everything fits together I remember when I was doing my estate plan and I will say I have a friend who's a lawyer and she's very successful high powered all the good things has run her own law firm for decades and she says the day you turn 18 you should have a will, you should have everything.
43:13As soon as you become an adult, you absolutely need to have that. And if you don't have that, the government will make one for you. So it is very important that every human being listening to this, if you can go get all of that stuff taken care of, all of that to say, where you don't know what it is that you should be talking to your parents about with regards to things like estate planning, wills, power of attorneys, you can talk to an actual attorney. You can talk to somebody who's qualified to do this and it can help you out with that as well. There's the estate planning piece and then there's the end of life care piece.
43:42And you touched on this a little bit earlier because there's the option of at-home healthcare, there's also assisted living, and then there's also nursing homes and those are all different. But I think a lot of people don't necessarily even know like, okay, what is the difference between assisted living versus a nursing home? And what are the costs for all of this? And how do we even start to wrap our heads around the just enormous costs that are associated with this. In addition to the difficulty of even broaching that conversation with your parents, there's also, let's say in the best case scenario, your parents are eager and open and happy to talk about it.
44:20There's also the very real dilemma of, this is all really expensive. How do we solve this? research start with the and they're really great websites out there there's humble dollar it's um jennifer clements and it's a community of adults who are older or aging talking about what they're experiencing they talk about things like we chose assisted living because over time it transitions into as we get older and we need more and more help that help is available to us as we kind of get older in the system, right? So we might start out with, we have a nurse who stops by once a week, three, four, five, six, seven years later, it's transitioned into, we have somebody who's around the house full-time, right?
45:07And it's like an assisted living program. People talk about what is the reality of what they're experiencing. Or we've chosen to downsize. And so this is what it looks like for us to sell a big house that we raise a lot of children in. And now we're in a smaller community, it's 55 plus. And so here's what we experienced with the HOA. Here's what they actually talk about. the granularities, the actual day-to-day. So it's not theoretical. It's people who are your parents' age talking about what they're experiencing day-to-day. And that's the Humboldollar community? The Humboldollar community. Jennifer Clements runs it, but it's fantastic.
45:37And it's a great place to go and just kind of poke around. Also ask questions because it would be answered, presumably by people who are in the same stage of life as your parents. Outside of websites like that, even just going, just typing in the basic question of, My parents is this age. If we don't have a lot of money, what are our options? What are the options that are available to us in terms of helping them retire or live comfortably? What are the insurance options? Will Medicaid cover some of it? Just understanding what are the options that are available to us. There's a lot of great websites out there that can help you do that.
46:13And just starting with that basic, the searching of it. You talked earlier about estate planning attorneys and how important they are as part of this. Are there other experts who can help with this component of it? Outside of financial advisors, I can only think about people like maybe in the insurance industry who can help or actually going directly to the nursing homes, the assisted living facilities, actually going to the 55 plus, the program directors for the 55 plus communities, and understanding what is the difference between what you offer, what does it look like to live in a 55 plus community, Who is it best for?
46:51What level of health do I need to have? Versus what if it was assisted living? What does that cost? How do the costs change year over year as my health needs get deeper and more complex? I feel like it's a little bit fragmented. There might be professionals who bring all of this together and can put it into one place, but I'm not aware of. Doesn't mean it don't exist. I just don't know. Yeah. But a fee-only fiduciary financial advisor is always a good first step. I will say, I lived in a 55-plus community when I was 19. How? My parents had a house there. They used it as a second home. And so they were rarely there.
47:25And so I just kind of moved there and set up shop. And I was the 19 year old in the 55 plus community. It was great. Everyone just loved you. Yeah, it was so great. I was like everyone's collective grandchild. Oh man, that must have been amazing. Did you just like had dinner prepared for you there? Dinner, breakfast, lunches, everything. Yeah, the neighbors loved me. It was wonderful.
47:54So imagine it's midnight. You're on the couch. You're scrolling through this new website, hitting the add to cart button, and you decide to check out, but you remember that your wallet or your credit card is in the other room and you don't want to get off the couch. That's okay. You don't need to because there's that big, iconic purple shop button. You know the one. With that shop button, that's Shopify. And there's a reason that so many businesses sell with it because it makes everything easier from checkout to creating your own storefront. Shopify is the commerce platform behind 10 % of all e-commerce in the U.S., from household names like Mattel and Gymshark to brands that are just getting started.
48:32Shopify will give you a leg up from the beginning with beautiful ready-to-go templates to express your brand. And you don't need to know how to code. You can handle everything in one place from inventory to payments to analytics. and they've got built-in marketing and email tools and that iconic purple ShopPay button used by millions of businesses around the world. If you want to see less carts being abandoned, it's time for you to head over to Shopify. Sign up for your one month,$1 per month trial period and start selling today at shopify.com slash paula. Go to shopify.com slash paula. Shopify.com slash paula.
49:13This episode brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever find yourself playing the budgeting game? Shifting a little money here, a little there, and hoping it all works out? Well, with the Name Your Price tool from Progressive, you can get a better budgeter and potentially lower your insurance bill too. You tell Progressive what you want to pay for car insurance, and they'll help find you options within your budget. Try it today at Progressive.com, Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state law. Not available in all states.
49:50This Friday, the NBA on Prime tips off with their debut doubleheader. First up, Boston brings the action to the Garden as the Celtics face the New York Knicks. Then out west, it's a battle of the superpowers. as the Lakers try to poster the relentless pace of the Minnesota Timberwolves. The Celtics and Knicks, who has the most hustle in defense? This game will come down to who wants it more. And the Timberwolves and the Lakers, it's two Western Conference heavyweights going toe-to-toe. Buckle up, folks. This one's going to be electric. Celtics-Knicks, T-Wolves and Lakers. Coverage starts Friday, 7 o 'clock Eastern, only on Prime.
50:41one thing that strikes me as we've talked about having financial conversations with your parents is that it's clear that this is as you said in the beginning this is not just a conversation this is a series of ongoing conversations should there be some sort of structure or routine around this? Should there be like quarterly check-ins or is it more organic? I think it can be more organic, but it also depends on your family and what their nuances are. Some people, like my Dutch friend, would strongly prefer to have very structured check-ins with her family. It depends on your family, but as long as they're consistent, right?
51:18And it doesn't have to be a formal, we're going to sit down and talk about the money stuff today, more organic, you know, but in the back of your mind, you know, okay, when I see them at Thanksgiving, we're going to have a conversation about finances. Maybe we'll talk about where they are in terms of, and it's also important actually, before you have these conversations, any conversation, just understanding what it is you want to get out of the conversation. Do you want to learn something about what your financial position is? Do you want to understand where they're looking forward to get to in the future?
51:46Or is it just, where are you right now? How's everything going? Do you need my help with anything? Right. So understanding what it is that you specifically would like to get out of the conversation also helps it not be a muddled conversation where nothing really gets accomplished and no one is quite sure what's going on or you know you get the brush off and that's it going back to the routine of it it doesn't have to be like a formal every Tuesday we sit down and talk about it it can be a little bit more organic it could be hey if you don't live in the same state or in the same area as your parents it could be whenever I see them you know if we're together for Thanksgiving, if we're together for Christmas, if we're together over Easter or whatever that looks like, we'll have a brief, a light kind of, how are things going?
52:30It might be that you initiate the first couple of times, you know, just a light sort of check-in, right? My parents are Nigerian, for example. And so in Nigerian culture, we don't have direct conversations. We kind of go around, go around the room to like get to the issue. And so we might go around the issue and like get to a place of like, well, by the way, you're going to do X, Y, Z with this properties. Like, where did you get to with that? Oh, you know, you know, I can ask those questions that I built on because I have knowledge from the last conversations that we had. And so in the same way, as you continue to have those conversations, those routine conversations, it's not always that there's a formal agenda.
53:05You might want to do that if there's something you are both working towards. But if everyone is in a good place and you're not necessarily working towards something specifically, then it could be just that checking of where are you, how are things going? etc. But you're doing that with some sort of cadence, right? It's not a formal set calendarized date, but it is whenever I see them or every so often. Every quarter, I have a brief, just kind of like a light check-in. It doesn't have to feel like an overt thing. It's the same way you have a casual conversation about their health. You're doing the same thing about their finances.
53:37How often should you ask your parents about their health? A lot. All the time. I will So occasionally one of my parents would tell me something that freaks me out. I'm like, what? Why didn't I know you were doing this? Just health-wise, I banged the drum about gyms and walking until they finally were like, all right, if we sign up for a gym, maybe she'll shut up. So we won that battle. But I think when you care about somebody, and we assume that everyone who's listening to this and has been plugged into this for however long we've been talking cares about their parents, which is why they've stayed around and stuck around for the conversation.
54:13But when you care about somebody, you don't need a formal structure to express that care. Right. There's a way of just as I'm checking in with you as we're catching up on what's going on with our lives. I'm like, how are you feeling? They say something on like your ear kind of like, why are you having trouble walking? Why are your knees hurting? Tell me more about that. Right. It's the same way it happens with the money. Oh, you bought a new car. Tell me more. How should you approach? You know, it's one thing to have a conversation with your parents, but when it comes to step parents, particularly step parents that maybe a person only met when they were older, a step parent that you didn't necessarily grow up with from early childhood, should any of these recommendations be modified?
54:58And if so, how? It depends on the depth of the relationship they have with the step parent. If they are very close and they're checking with each other often, and it's almost like the step parent has become like a sort of surrogate parent then you can sort of copy and paste all of these things to it if it's more of uh there's one step removed so the depth of relationship isn't there then maybe the conversation is more with the actual parent and less with the the step parent it depends on what that depth of relationship is and how open they are also to because you're not necessarily you're not their child do they see you as their child right are they open to having that conversation with you because if not then maybe you're not the best person to have the conversation with them about it i think part of all of this is understanding and it's having that self-awareness right of even though i feel like i have opinions about what this person should do am i the right person to brush that with them i might have opinions about what my step-parents should do i might write presence to have that conversation if yes then like i have the scripts and i have the tools with which to have those conversations we have an okayish relationship but maybe they'll be more upon if this was coming from one of their children that they gave birth to.
56:10Maybe I have a conversation with that person instead around, hey, just so you know, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. You know, I'm having this conversation with my dad. Maybe you want to have it with your mom as well. So just understanding and having that self-awareness of what is your role and what is the depth of relationship will help you make an informed judgment about how to approach conversations with step-parents or other types of relatives or friends. Right. Yeah, because I was thinking that actually as we were talking. For a lot of people, there are people who play a parental role in their life who are not technically parents.
56:42So for example, maybe you were raised by a grandparent or you were raised by an uncle and aunt, or maybe you even have an older brother or sister who is significantly older than you, maybe a sibling who is 10 or 15 years older than you. and so you actually have more of a parent-child relationship with your eldest sibling you know if there's a big age gap between the the kids yeah absolutely and it all goes back to what is the depth of relationship right what is the kind of relationship i have with them would i be open to this kind of conversation maybe i broach it with some of those i statements being vulnerable and see where things go if it's a shutdown immediately then somebody else needs to have this conversation with them right if you're open to it then yes let's have the conversation with that care with that curiosity and let's cooperate on a financial plan that makes sense for them.
57:31Even if their financial plan is, let's get you a financial advisor. Right. Well, thank you for spending this time with us. Where can people find you if they'd like to know more? They can find me at etiosa.com and that's E-T-I-N-O-S-A-A.com. And the book, How to Talk to Your Parents About Money is on Amazon in the print and in the digital form. Perfect. Thank you. Thank you for having me. Thank you. I'm a big fan of Team Afford Anything. I think there's a level of excellence that you guys have brought to everything that you've done. And I'm a massive, massive fan of that. As you know, love Sunny.
58:04Love all the work you guys do. Oh, thank you. Thank you. And you are a student in your first rental property. I am. I am. Loved it. And I still have a bunch of properties now. I'm not going to say how many. But I still have the very first one I bought because of the course. Wow. Yeah. Yeah. Just chugging along, doing well. Same tenant for all these years. How many years have you had the same tenant? It's been like five years. Can you believe it? It's been almost five years because I think I took the course in 2020. I registered for it in 2019. I took it in 2020, if I'm correct. Yeah, I think we're like in COVID lockdown.
58:35So I sat down and I took the course and bought the property while I was in Australia buying a house in America. It was a crazy experience. But yeah, I still have the house five years later. It's done very well for itself. Wow, that's incredible. I love hearing the success stories like this from our YFRP students. Are you your first rental property students? Yes, yes, yes, yes. And we've done many more since then. So it's been good for us. Congratulations. Thank you. I appreciate it. Thank you, Etiosa. What are three key takeaways that we got from this conversation? Key takeaway number one, your financial scripts are invisible, but they're powerful.
59:15So we all carry these hidden beliefs about money that we're not even aware of, right? And these are called, quote unquote, money scripts. And these money scripts shape every financial decision that we make from how much you save to whether or not you feel guilty about spending. You know, it goes beyond just spending. It goes into retirement planning and the way that you invest. Like these are all shaped by your invisible money scripts. And the problem is we assume that everybody shares those same hidden money scripts. And that creates conflict when we talk to family members who operate under a completely different set of invisible scripts.
59:53And so unlocking these unconscious assumptions, these hidden money scripts, is a big part of being able to have productive conversations with other people, including your parents, about money. Confirmation bias. Assume that everybody else thinks like us. And so when we go out into the world, we're looking for confirmation around our beliefs. Everybody must believe saving is the right thing to do. Of course, how could you not save, right? How could you not be in the fire movement? That's the only way to do it. And so because we have some of these subconscious scripts, when we sit down to have conversations with other people about finances, it can be easy for our scripts to start to leak out, right?
1:00:27Our beliefs start to be this. It's the standard. How could you not be saving for retirement? What are you doing instead? And that can then bring the accusation and kind of crumble the conversation. So that's the first key takeaway. Key takeaway number two, start money conversations with vulnerability rather than advice. The secret to having really productive financial conversations is not to have all the answers, but rather to ask the right questions. And in doing so, share some of your financial struggles, share some of your financial story. This creates a more collaborative dynamic, a give and take, like a mutuality, a reciprocity, so that you're learning from each other rather than lecturing your parents.
1:01:13I talk about using iScripts. So I've been thinking about savings. I've been thinking about investing. I've been exploring student loans. And wow, did you know so many people in this country carry student loans? Isn't that crazy? When you guys were my age, how did you do it? How did you think about navigating the situation? How are you thinking about it? What are you looking forward to in the next XYZ with regards to your money? How do you feel about retirement, right? Curiosity. But we started a conversation with an I statement. And why you want to start with I is that you are also being vulnerable.
1:01:46Finally, key takeaway number three. You can't force people to have financial conversations if they don't want to have them. because some people are going to refuse to discuss money no matter how carefully you try to approach the topic. And so when that happens, you just have to accept that you can't control other people's willingness to talk about money because money is a really sensitive topic. But maybe if they are not willing to talk to you about it, if your parents aren't willing to talk to you about it, maybe they're willing to talk to somebody else, a trusted friend, a trusted advisor. As long as someone is having that conversation, a trusted someone, ultimately what matters is that your parents are taken care of.
1:02:28And ensuring that someone is having those conversations with them paves the road for that. I once gave the example of I live in a neighborhood that has a lot of dogs, but I don't have dogs, so I don't know how it works. But sometimes I see someone like trying to take the dog on a walk and the dog just sits on a pavement. They absolutely have no intention of moving at all. And what does the person do? They stand there until the dog is ready to move. They try with a leash and a jack and eventually they're like, all right, when you're ready, I'm ready. That's eventually what happens. You can't force people to have conversations they don't want to have.
1:02:58Those are three key takeaways from this conversation with Etiosa Agbon Lahore. Thank you so much for being part of the Afford Anything community. If you enjoyed this episode, please do three things. Subscribe to our newsletter, affordanything.com slash newsletter. Leave us a review in your favorite podcast playing app. and share this with friends, family, with your parents. Share this with your parents. Share it with parents, step-parents, grandparents, uncles, aunts. Share this with that elder generation in your family. Thank you again for tuning in. This is the Afford Anything Podcast. I'm Paula Pant, and I'll meet you in the next episode.
From the publisher
#636: Behavioral economist Etinosa Agbonlahor joins us to discuss "money scripts" — the unconscious beliefs we inherit or develop about finances.
Agbonlahor, CEO of Decision Alpha and former Director of Behavioral Science Research at Fidelity Investments, is the author of "How to Talk to Your Parents About Money."
She studied financial management at Cornell University and explains how these hidden biases create problems when we try to discuss finances with family members.
You might assume everyone thinks saving money makes sense, while your parents operate under completely different beliefs. These conflicting scripts can derail conversations before they start.
Agbonlahor shares the story of a single mother who became so anxious about money after her divorce that she refused to buy her teenager expensive shoes. Years later, she realized she was trying to teach extreme frugality to protect her daughters from the financial insecurity she experienced.
The key to productive money conversations lies in three principles: care, curiosity and cooperation. You approach with empathy rather than judgment, ask open-ended questions to understand their situation, and work together toward solutions instead of trying to be the financial savior.
The conversation covers specific topics you should address with aging parents: debt, retirement planning, long-term care preferences, and estate planning. Agbonlahor emphasizes starting these discussions early, before a crisis hits.
You want to understand their vision for retirement — whether they prioritize security, adventure or leaving a legacy — and then assess the gap between their goals and current reality.
When parents refuse to discuss finances, you might need to involve trusted friends, spiritual leaders or professional advisors who can have these conversations instead.
Resources Mentioned:
Book: How to Talk to Your Parents About Money, by Etinosa Agbonlahor
The Humble Dollar Forum
Timestamps:
Note: Timestamps will vary on individual listening devices based on dynamic advertising run times. The provided timestamps are approximate and may be several minutes off due to changing ad lengths.
(00:00) Introduction to money scripts
(00:56) What behavioral economics studies
(03:03) Hidden money beliefs
(04:34) Money script examples
(06:16) Adult trauma responses
(09:32) Personality and money
(11:57) Trauma changes personality
(12:55) Protecting future habits
(15:17) Debt conversation approach
(22:03) When to start conversations
(27:53) Using "I" statements
(29:51) Sample conversation scripts
(33:36) Handling resistance
(43:35) Parents' money frameworks
(56:46) Long-term care planning
(58:02) Stepparent conversations
For more information, visit the show notes at https://affordanything.com/episode636
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
