


Episode topic: “Common knowledge” in the technical sense—situations where everyone knows something, knows that others know it, and so on—used to explain coordination, social relationships, misinformation, and market bubbles.
Stephen Pinker, author of a book on common knowledge (background: political-science and game-theory style analysis; uses examples from economics, politics, and communication).
Common knowledge enables coordination (e.g., driving on the right/left, choosing to stay home on weekends). Public signals can generate it and can also sustain “common pretense” (pluralistic ignorance/spiral of silence; Abilene paradox). In markets and investing, people act based on beliefs about other people’s beliefs (Keynesian beauty contest; greater fool theory). Media fragmentation can create separate “common knowledge” pools.
Emperor’s New Clothes; fraternity drinking norms; Saudi women driving beliefs; meme stocks; Super Bowl crypto ads; Apple’s 1984 Macintosh ad; Monster.com and Discover card network effects; COVID toilet paper “bank run” hoarding; blank-sign protests in authoritarian regimes.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Introduction of Stephen and his book on common knowledge.
“For 125 years, Nordstrom has been part of your story.”
Discussion on the concept of common knowledge and its implications.
“So your book is about common knowledge, sort of what it is and how we use it in ways that we're aware of and in ways that we aren't aware of.”
Explaining how the story illustrates the concept of common knowledge.
“Well, I begin the book with the story of The Emperor's New Clothes because there's a sense in which it's a story about common knowledge.”
Exploring how social relationships are influenced by common knowledge.
“It was originally studied in a fraternity where all the frat guys said privately that it's really stupid to drink until you puke and pass out.”
Discussion on pluralistic ignorance and its real-world implications.
“There are a lot of, you know, prisoners' dilemmas, things like that.”
Examining how common knowledge affects market behavior and speculation.
“But the fact that other people know that he's talking it up and they know that still other people are talking it up means that it really can appreciate, at least for a while.”
Analysis of how advertising creates common knowledge for products.
“For 125 years, Nordstrom has been part of your story.”
Discussing the toilet paper shortage as an example of common knowledge in action.
“on networks, they're prestige goods that depend on other people that you respect also consuming that product.”
Explore the reasons behind the toilet paper shortage during COVID and its implications.
“where it was known that a lot of people were to watch them.”
Discuss the role of common knowledge in negotiations and decision-making.
“But then that created a shortage of toilet paper when everyone ran out to buy it.”
Examine how competing narratives affect societal interactions today.
“it seems a different era than where we are now.”
Learn strategies for fostering positive common knowledge within organizations.
“Okay, so this concept of kind of common knowledge existing in different ways, in different forms of relationships.”
Explore how collective action can overpower regimes through common knowledge.
“Because it's either complete control or no control.”
Learn about the subversive nature of common knowledge through a Soviet joke.
“So there's a joke from the Soviet Union about a man handing out leaflets in Red Square.”
Understand how coordination drives human interactions across various contexts.
“And in a case of life imitating a joke, Russia's, Putin's police force has arrested a number of people for carrying blank signs.”
Discuss how politeness serves as a form of benign hypocrisy in social interactions.
“Any corporation, any institution, any school, any relationship, any couple, any friendship, any family, these are all people trying to coordinate.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Harvard Business Review, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This episode is brought to you by Nordstrom. For 125 years, Nordstrom has been part of your story. The stylist who found the perfect outfit for your big interview. The first pair of walking shoes for your one-year-old. The tomato soup you shared with your sister at the cafe. These are the moments that make Nordstrom, Nordstrom. Big or small, we're here for all of it. Celebrating 125 years with new moments still add. Discover it all in Nordstrom stores and at Nordstrom.com. When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications, and more.
0:42Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. That's Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
1:08All right, so Stephen, thank you for being with us today.
1:11Steven Pinker: Thanks for having me. Great. So your book is about common knowledge, sort of what it is and how we use it in ways that we're aware of and in ways that we aren't aware of. So, you know, for the audience, what are you getting at with common knowledge and why should we care about that? I'm using the term in a specialized sense, not to refer to conventional wisdom or something that is widely known, but to something that is known to be known. That is, I know something, you know it, you know that I know it, I know that you know it, you know that I know that you know it, and so on ad infinitum. So that's common knowledge in the technical sense.
1:44Steven Pinker: It's important because it's necessary for coordination, for people, two or more people to be on the same page, to make choices that might be arbitrary, but it works for everyone as long as everyone makes the same choice. Do you stay home on Saturday or Sunday? Do you drive on the right or drive on the left? Now for common knowledge to work, you don't literally have to think, I know that she knows it, I know that she knows, because your head starts to spin after one or two levels. And we have a sense of common knowledge when something is conspicuous or self-evident or public or out there, if I see it while I see you seeing it, then I kind of know that you know that I know that you know it.
2:24Steven Pinker: So this is The Emperor Has No Clothes. Well, I begin the book with the story of The Emperor's New Clothes because there's a sense in which it's a story about common knowledge. Because when the little boy said the emperor was naked, he wasn't telling anyone anything they didn't already know. But he's changed the state of their knowledge nonetheless, because by blurting out what everyone could see with an earshot of everyone else, at that moment, everyone knew that everyone Everyone else knew that everyone else knew that the emperor was naked. And another point in the book is that just like driving on the right or driving on the left is a solution to a coordination problem, or staying home Saturday or staying home Sunday, or respecting paper currency, I suggest that our informal social relationships—are we friends?
3:08Steven Pinker: Do I defer to you? Are we transactional partners? Are we lovers? all of those are matters of common knowledge as well. They're coordination games, and we solidify them by generating some public signal that we both see that inaugurates the relationship. But there can be forms of common belief, common misconception, common pretense, where you do have assumptions about what other people are thinking and vice versa, that in some cases may not actually be reality. So in the case of a common pretense, where we refer to that by saying we're ignoring the elephant in the room. The metaphor is that an elephant in the room is something you can't ignore, but we're pretending to ignore it.
3:53Steven Pinker: There is a phenomenon called pluralistic ignorance or a spiral of silence. In economics, it's sometimes called the Abilene paradox, where no one actually believes something, but everyone thinks that everyone else believes it, but no one actually does. Is there an easy example of that? Sure. It was originally studied in a fraternity where all the frat guys said privately that it's really stupid to drink until you puke and pass out. But they said, what can I do about it? All the other guys think it's cool. And it turns out none of them thought it was cool, but everyone thought that everyone else thought it was cool.
4:30Steven Pinker: I think there have been many phenomena like that. It turns out that in Saudi Arabia, most of the men think that women should have the right to work and drive, but they couldn't allow their wives to do it because they mistakenly thought that all the other men thought that it was impermissible. So I want to lead this conversation, you know, sort of mainly into economic, financial, sort of market areas, because we are the HBR IdeaCast. But, you know, your book is, I'd say it's challenging in some ways. There's a lot of brain teasers. There are a lot of, you know, prisoners' dilemmas, things like that.
5:03But it's also fun. I mean, there are a lot of, you know, popular references, jokes, cartoons, and then examples. Really interesting, you know, kind of game-playing examples. So one of the things you talk about is, you know, the Keynesian beauty contest, which, and if I get it wrong, you'll correct me, but where, you know, a judge is rated... A judge doesn't simply select the contestant that he or she thinks is most attractive, but rather is rewarded on selecting based on what he thinks he or she thinks the other judges will select, right?
5:35Steven Pinker: Who are engaged in the same puzzle. They're guessing what everyone else will judge to be the prettiest face, which is different from the old Miss Rheingold competition where people voted on the prettiest face in the beauty contest that Keynes hinted might have been in the newspapers in his days. This would be London in the 20s. No one can ever actually verify whether there really was such a contest. But it was a great example because for Keynes, where he said everyone is trying to outguess other people, outguessing still other people. He said that's the way speculative investing works. They buy the security because they think they can sell it at a higher price to other people who think it's underpriced, who in turn will want to sell it to still other people.
6:20Steven Pinker: And so speculative bubbles, crypto perhaps being one of the most recent examples, are cases where people think that other people will, in the future, will want to buy in. Sometimes it's called the greater fool theory of investing, that you invest because you think other people will invest because they think that still other people will invest. The thing is, of course, bubbles can pop when the market starts to run out of the greater fools who think that it'll continue to appreciate forever. But this can all get started when there is some public signal, like in the case of the emperor's new clothes, the boy blurting it out, or like a public ceremony or a public signal, where if there is just a rumor or some reason to think that other people are getting in, that can cause other people to get in.
7:09Steven Pinker: A couple of recent examples are meme stocks, where an influencer might talk up a stock, even if the fundamentals are crummy. But the fact that other people know that he's talking it up and they know that still other people are talking it up means that it really can appreciate, at least for a while. Or in two Super Bowls ago, there were a number of high concept ads for crypto exchanges, which mentioned nothing about the advantages of crypto. These are the Larry David ads. The Larry David, the Matt Damon, where the point of the ads were, everyone's getting into crypto, don't be left out. And in fact, the punchline to the Larry David comic ad was, don't be like Larry, don't be left out.
7:57So this sounds like a tool that people who understand the psychology could and probably do benefit from, right? Yes. And this episode is brought to you by Nordstrom. For 125 years, Nordstrom has been part of your story. The stylist who found the perfect outfit for your big interview. The first pair of walking shoes for your one-year-old. The tomato soup you shared with your sister at the cafe. These are the moments that make Nordstrom, Nordstrom. Big or small, we're here for all of it. Celebrating 125 years with new moments still add. Discover it all in Nordstrom stores and at Nordstrom.com. When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
8:43It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications and more. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. That's Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
9:32falls best dressed. Make your move. Order on the Sweetgreen app.
9:37Steven Pinker: Getting back to marketing, I talk about an analysis by a political scientist like Michael Chua, who's in some ways my predecessor in writing a book about common knowledge, where he analyzed the most famous and most expensive ad in history. This was the 1984 ad directed by Ridley Scott of Blade Runner and Alien fame, ran exactly once during the 1984 Super Bowl, and it was to introduce the Apple Macintosh. So it's a revolutionary new product. Unlike those of us who remember the first personal computers, remember it had a little screen with 24 lines of 80 characters, and you had to type in alphanumeric commands, like, you know, Dell, Foo.bar.
10:23Steven Pinker: dot, uh, food dot bar. Um, and they were clumsy. So Apple's coming out this, you know, insanely great new product with windows and menus and icons and a mouse. But they realized that no one would buy it if they thought they were the only one buying it because the price wouldn't come down because of demand. There wouldn't be a community of, um, users and experts and, um, markets for peripherals and consumables. So how do you break the knot and cut the knot, I mean, and get people to buy something that they'll only buy if enough other people are buying it? And the answer is the Super Bowl is an annual right in American culture.
11:07Steven Pinker: You know that a lot of people are watching it, and you know that a lot of people know that a lot of people are watching it. It is a common knowledge generator. And to break the logjam, Apple paid for this ad. It said nothing about the Apple computer. For those of you who have seen it, it played off the fact that it was January 1984, the date of George Orwell's novel. And so it showed a grim corporate meeting where gray drones trudge into a cavernous hall and listen to drivel from a voice on the screen intercut with scenes of a live young woman in bright red gym shorts and a singlet carrying a mallet and she bursts into the corporate meeting kind of hammer throws the mallet into the screen which explodes in a fireball revealing the crawl that says on January 25th Apple will introduce the Macintosh, and you'll see why 1984 won't be like 1984.
12:11Steven Pinker: Now, the point of the ad was not to advertise the product. It didn't say anything about the product, but to advertise the potential buyership. It generated common knowledge. I'm seeing the ad. I know lots of other companies are seeing the ad. And what Choua showed, this is, I mean, it's a story. How did he prove it? Well, he looked, because you can't, I mean, that's just a sample of one. So he looked did other products that only work if enough other people adopt it, products that depend on network effects. But Monster.com was one of the first job-seeking ads. Now, why would anyone look for a job on Monster.com unless they thought that lots of employers were posting there?
12:54Steven Pinker: Why would employers post there unless they thought a lot of job seekers were looking for jobs there? Monster.com was introduced at the Super Bowl. So they're companies that depend on network effects that have to generate common knowledge. Everyone has to know that everyone knows about them. Another example is the Discover credit card, which was a great credit card, rebates and high limits, but didn't matter if you were the only one who had a Discover card because no merchant would accept it, and no merchant would accept it unless they thought enough people were going to carry it introduced in the Super Bowl.
13:27Steven Pinker: And Chua argued that it was another category, aside from products that inherently depend on networks, they're prestige goods that depend on other people that you respect also consuming that product. Products that are consumed in public and where the brand image is important also tend to advertise in the Super Bowl. And crucially, what Chua showed was not so much that advertisers were willing to pay per eyeball, but they're willing to pay a premium for venues that were common knowledge generators, where it was known that a lot of people were to watch them. They're willing to pay more per eyeball for products that were consumed in public or that depended on network effects.
14:16Yeah. So the phenomenon... Maybe the flip side of this phenomenon is the toilet paper shortage during COVID, which was, you know, not this, not network effects, but an assumption that I know what you know that I know that you know.
14:32Steven Pinker: Well, yes. Justin Wolfers speculated that the great COVID toilet paper shortage was like a bank run, where people withdraw their money, not necessarily because they think that there's anything wrong with the bank, but they have heard that other people think there might be something wrong, unsound, and they may just have heard that other people think that might be something that's unsound. So you get this reverberant doubt, and no one wants to be the last customer withdrawing at a point where the bank no longer can cover its deposits. So people rush to the bank to withdraw their savings, which actually causes the bank to fail, which otherwise it wouldn't.
15:07Steven Pinker: Likewise, Wilford suggested that when there actually wasn't a toilet paper shortage, it's true that people were staying home, so they were using six packs of Charmin instead of the big jumbo rolls in their workplace. But Kimberly Clark quickly stepped up production to meet the demand. But somehow people just know that in an emergency, people hoard toilet paper, which can cause the very shortage that leads people to hoard toilet paper. And so they did hoard toilet paper. A lot of retailers then posted signs, max three rolls per customer. That will reinforce it, yeah. Not... And that ended the shortage, not so much because people didn't strip the shelves, because they couldn't, but they were reassured that since no one else could buy more than three rolls, there was no reason for them to panic.
16:00Steven Pinker: And again, getting back to common knowledge, how did this originate? At least according to one history, it all started with another common knowledge generator, The Tonight Show, which back in the three-network era, Johnny Carson was the king of late night. He had not only a huge audience, but people knew that people were watching Johnny Carson, which is why catchphrases from the show like, here's Johnny, everyone recognized it. So one night, I think it was 1973, he said, you know, there have been all kinds of shortages lately. And this is an era where there were lines to get gasoline because of the Arab oil embargo.
16:37Steven Pinker: And there was a meat shortage and a coffee shortage. Anyway, he said, have you heard the latest? I read it in the papers. This episode is brought to you by Nordstrom. For 125 years, Nordstrom has been part of your story. The stylist who found the perfect outfit for your big interview. The first pair of walking shoes for your one-year-old. The tomato soup you shared with your sister at the cafe. These are the moments that make Nordstrom, Nordstrom. Big or small, we're here for all of it. Celebrating 125 years with new moments still add. Discover it all in Nordstrom stores and at Nordstrom.com. When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
17:19It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications and more. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. That's Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Fall has never looked or tasted this good. Sweetgreen's fall harvest menu is back with seasonal favorites dressed to impress and made to be devoured. Warm roasted sweet potatoes, crisp apples, maple glazed Brussels, and crave worthy flavors in the autumn harvest bowl, maple glazed salmon plate, and roasted bacon Brussels side.
18:05The season's most desirable menu has returned to Sweetgreen, featuring fall's best dressed. Make your move. Order on the Sweetgreen app.
18:13Steven Pinker: There's a shortage of toilet paper. Now, it turned out it wasn't true at the time. There was no shortage of toilet paper. But then that created a shortage of toilet paper when everyone ran out to buy it. And since then, at least according to the story, it's hard to prove, it's just become conventional wisdom that people, that toilet paper becomes scarce in an emergency. Yeah, that is fascinating. So all of this must be very valuable for people who are in negotiation, right? Because negotiation is always, you know, what is it that we both know and what is it that only I know? And, you know, I mean, that's how you win.
18:50But, yeah, talk about, yeah, to what extent I know you know. I mean, that's the fundamental of, and the people who negotiate better probably understand this concept.
19:01Steven Pinker: Yes, a negotiation is one of a number of kinds of games in the game theory sense. Meaning, my best option depends on what you do and vice versa. And in any time in which there can be multiple equilibria, cases where everyone is better off if they both do something, but it isn't preordained what they'll do. So, negotiation is what's sometimes called a battle of the sexes, is the technical term. It has nothing actually to do with the sexes, but it refers to a hypothetical couple where they like to spend time together. He would prefer that they go to the hockey game. She would prefer they go to the opera.
19:42Steven Pinker: They'd rather go to either than not do something together. So, the question is, which one do they go to? Both of them are equilibria. In the case of negotiation, let's say a car salesman and a buyer, there's a range of prices in which the salesman makes a profit and the customer pays what they're willing to pay to get the car. But within that range, the highest the customer is willing to pay, the lowest the seller is willing to sell for, how do they decide? Obviously, the seller wants it as high as possible, the buyer wants it as low as possible. If either of them walks away from the deal, then they're both worse off.
20:22Steven Pinker: So how do they decide? So there are many predicaments in life like this, where there are many ways of doing something, but both parties are better off if they can figure out some way to do it. In the case of a negotiation, it's interesting. This is something pointed out many years ago by the political scientist Thomas Schelling, who won a Nobel Prize for this and other work, that often a buyer and seller will, in order to find somewhere, anywhere to land on that the other guy will agree with, they'll pick something like a splitting the difference or a round number. He notes that the salesman who announced that his rock bottom price for the car is$30 ,007.26 is pretty much pleading to be relieved of$7.26.
21:11Steven Pinker: It's like, oh, come on. So why a round number? I mean, what's so special about a round number? What's special is other people can think it's special or can expect each other to recognize it as special. And so these points, focal points, sometimes called shelling points, points that pop out in the minds of both parties and that's all they need to come to an agreement are often where negotiations end up. So when you talk about common knowledge, particularly some of the earlier references, it seems a different era than where we are now. I mean, you know, and maybe this was never true, but people my age will look back and say, well, you know, we used to agree on facts.
21:52We probably didn't all together, but we kind of did, right? As you say, there were only three networks. There wasn't this sort of ubiquity of opinion and everything. You know, now we're really in an era where they're competing truths. And I would assume, right, competing common knowledges... Obviously, there are various common knowledges between people and in relationships, but sort of at a larger level... I guess my question is, is that eroding the kind of common knowledge that enables social interaction, et cetera, et cetera? Is that a concern for you?
22:24Steven Pinker: There is that fear, although, as you say, and I often point out, the best explanation for the good old days is a bad memory. There's a lot of polarization in the 60s, too, and riots and terrorist bombings and assassinations and so on. Duly not romanticizing the past. There does seem to be an increase in negative polarization. That is, not just that people disagree, but each thinks that the other is evil. And it's plausible that one of the contributors was the fragmentation of the media markets. So that instead of everyone watching Walter Cronkite or Huntley and Brinkley, first with cable news, with Fox News, whose business model was to cultivate a highly partisan audience that wants to hear a certain kind of spin on everything, and with social media, where the networks of posting and reposting and tweeting and retweeting and linking and relinking has been shown to take place within two or more closed networks with not much interaction between, that there could be separate pools of common belief within each of these communities, something that's easier to happen when there isn't one public signal, kind of a Super Bowl with Johnny Carson, a Walter Cronkite that everyone knows, that everyone knows is aware of.
23:49Okay, so this concept of kind of common knowledge existing in different ways, in different forms of relationships. So within a company, if an executive, if a leader wants to create a sort of common knowledge that he or she imagines would be beneficial for the culture of the company. Is there a playbook almost for how to create a kind of positive common knowledge within this environment?
24:15Steven Pinker: Well, in general, common knowledge is generated by something that is conspicuous, public. So face-to-face meetings can generate common knowledge in a way that, say, remote meetings don't. That is, when you're in a room, you see everyone else, they say you. You know that they're seeing each other and seeing the speaker or the leader. So I think there is still, that's one of the reasons that, you know, as with the Super Bowl, which is a broadcast version, but there is an important role for publicly conspicuous notices. Sometimes pronouncements, going back to the economy as a whole. The reason that statements from the Fed are scrutinized and poured over like rabbis parsing the Talmud is that anything that the chairman of the Fed says can create its own reality when people, knowing that other people have heard it, will act on it.
25:19This episode is brought to you by Nordstrom. For 125 years, Nordstrom has been part of your story. The stylist who found the perfect outfit for your big interview. The first pair of walking shoes for your one-year-old. The tomato soup you shared with your sister at the cafe. These are the moments that make Nordstrom, Nordstrom. Big or small, we're here for all of it. Celebrating 125 years with new moments still add. Discover it all in Nordstrom stores and at Nordstrom.com. When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications and more.
26:02Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. That's Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Brussels clean up nicely at Sweetgreen. Maple glazed, roasted, and edges perfectly caramelized. Sweetgreen's fall harvest is back on the menu, and the season's most overlooked little green vegetable is dressed to be devoured. You know what to do. Order on the Sweetgreen app.
26:40Steven Pinker: Out of anticipation of what other people will do, which can then feed on itself and create a bubble, a recession. So I quote Alan Greenspan, who at one point said, since I've become chair of the Fed, I've learned to mumble with great incoherence. If I seem clear to you, you must have misunderstood what I said. Because a signal that, say, a recession is ahead will create that recession because companies won't hire out of fear that they'll have to lay off employees. Consumers won't buy out of fear that they might lose their jobs, each of which then creates the reality of the other. And so the chairman of that has to be very, very careful as to what she or he says.
27:25Yeah, what's interesting in all this, and you talk about politics in some ways, you talk about authoritarian politics. And, you know, I lived in China and I lived in Russia. And, you know, you did have the phenomenon that you described, which is everybody knows that the regime is rotten, but nobody says it because you can't be certain if you take to the streets, there's gonna be anybody else with you, even though everybody sort of knows. And then you understand why authoritarian, why you have to control everything, because, you know, the moment you loosen up anything, it allows for this possibility of kind of communication and understanding and, you know...
28:03It's like that moment when Ceausescu fell in Romania, and he'd controlled everything, and suddenly, you know, there are a few people shouting in the back as he's giving his speech, and some stuff's happening, he realizes it's over. Because it's either complete control or no control. Well, in particular...
28:18Steven Pinker: So control has to be... Since no dictator can control every last member of the population, there just isn't enough firepower, there aren't enough informants. And as I quote the character of Gandhi in the movie by that name, who at one point tells a British colonial officer, in the end you will leave because 100 ,000 Englishmen simply cannot control 350 million Indians if the Indians refuse to cooperate. He could have said refuse to coordinate or are unable to coordinate. So people can overpower a regime if they all stand up at the same time, if they all storm the palace, if they all stop work.
29:01Steven Pinker: But how can they do it if each one is afraid that he'll be the only one? And if he stands up, he can be picked off or bundled off to prison. If everyone protests at the same time, then there's the safety in numbers. But there's safety in coordination. And so there has to be a way of generating the common knowledge. Now's the time that we all stand up together. And so a protest in a public square where everyone sees everyone else seeing everyone else can often do it, which is why dictators are often terrified of public protests. Or if there is a widely circulated magazine, TV show, radio show, which is why they clamp down on the media.
29:42Talk about the blank paper. Oh, yes.
29:45Steven Pinker: So there's a joke from the Soviet Union about a man handing out leaflets in Red Square. Of course, the KGB arrest him. They bundle him off to police headquarters, only to discover that the leaflets are blank sheets of paper. And they confront him. They demand, what is the meaning of this? And he says, what's there to say? It's so obvious. So the point of the joke was he was generating common knowledge. He didn't need to say anything because people already knew it, but they didn't know that everyone else knew it. And all the people accepting the leaflets were then generating the common knowledge that everyone knew that everyone knew it, which is why it was so subversive.
30:21Steven Pinker: And in a case of life imitating a joke, Russia's, Putin's police force has arrested a number of people for carrying blank signs. Yeah. Well, I wonder if it was for it. So that in China, you know, where it's very dangerous to protest and very dangerous to, you know, to dissent publicly after the mishandling of COVID. There were famously blank paper protests. Oh, interesting. Possibly inspired by the original Soviet joke, yeah. So the book is fascinating, and you put your finger on sort of, you know, common knowledge and how we know what we know and how we think about certain things and how we operate.
31:01What are we supposed to do with all that?
31:03Steven Pinker: Well, it's hard to answer that question because I didn't write it kind of as a how-to book. or as a manual or self-help. It's kind of a work in fundamental science and logic and philosophy with lots and lots of applications. How you work it out in a particular case often depends on the particular payoffs. What would happen if you fail to coordinate? What do you gain if you do coordinate? If there are multiple ways of coordinating, who gains, who loses? So there's no kind of single formula, but it is a lens with which to view the world simply because coordination is so ubiquitous in human affairs.
31:44Steven Pinker: Any corporation, any institution, any school, any relationship, any couple, any friendship, any family, these are all people trying to coordinate. And they always have to coordinate with some signal of common knowledge. They often, in order to preserve the relationship, have to keep things out of common knowledge. And so all the phenomena of politeness, euphemism, innuendo, tact, pretending not to see the elephant in the room, beating around the bush, hypocrisy, genteel hypocrisy. All of those I consider to be cases where people are privately know something, but there's some reason to keep it out of common knowledge.
32:32Steven Pinker: The reason being something in common knowledge changes the relationship. Sometimes you don't want to change the relationship or you don't want to signal the wrong relationship. So just to give a couple of examples, I mean, the most common case of systematic hypocrisy is politeness. If you could pass the salt, that would be awesome. What? If you think about it literally, it really doesn't make a whole lot of sense. But we... Could you pass the salt? Do you think you might pass the salt? Why do we go through those rituals? It's because we don't want to boss each other around. I don't want to give you a command as if you're the butler, assuming that we're friends, or for that matter, strangers.
33:14That's really interesting. So benign hypocrisy, or some of these protocols, they may not be direct, they may not be honest, but they're kind of what we need to function.
33:24Steven Pinker: They're what we need to preserve our relationships, because our relationships are coordination games which depend on common knowledge. Sometimes we don't want to blow up a relationship, so we avoid the common knowledge. Steven Pinker, thank you for being on IdeaCast. Thanks for having me.
33:47Fall never arrives all at once. first the air then the light and slowly the things you love begin to find each other a jacket meets a dress a hoodie slips beneath a blazer an old cap finds a new scarf because you don't simply step into the season you create it layer by layer until it finally feels like fall find fall your way at Ross
34:16fall has never looked or tasted this good Sweet Green's fall harvest menu is back with seasonal favorites dressed to impress and made to be devoured. Warm roasted sweet potatoes, crisp apples, maple glazed Brussels and crave worthy flavors in the autumn harvest bowl, maple glazed salmon plate and roasted bacon Brussels side. The season's most desirable menu has returned to Sweet Green featuring fall's best dressed. Make your move. Order on the Sweet Green app. finding a doctor is hard enough finding the right doctor even harder someone who takes your insurance has an available appointment when you need one and feels like someone you can actually open up to that's where ZocDoc comes in download the ZocDoc app to search and compare doctors by specialty insurance and availability read real patient reviews find the right fit for you and book instantly because getting seen by the right doctor matters ZocDoc, ready to be seen?
35:13Download the ZocDoc app today.
Knowing That Everyone Else Knows
7 Nov 2025
---
What do Super Bowl ads, crypto bubbles, toilet paper shortages, and negotiations have in common? According to Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker, they all come down to a hidden force called common knowledge — what we know everyone else knows. In this episode of HBR IdeaCast, Pinker discusses his new book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows and explains how common knowledge shapes money, power, leadership, and everyday life. From Apple’s famous “1984” ad to the psychology of dictatorships, discover how understanding this invisible force can change the way you lead, negotiate, and influence others.
#stevenpinker #Psychology #Leadership #HBR #BusinessStrategy
Books, tools, and more: store.hbr.org
Follow us:
https://hbr.org/
https://www.linkedin.com/company/harvard-business-review/
https://www.facebook.com/HBR/
https://twitter.com/HarvardBiz
https://www.instagram.com/harvard_business_review
Sign up for Newsletters: https://hbr.org/email-newsletters
#HarvardBusinessReview #YourCareer #Career #Job #Work #Business #Harvard #HarvardBusinessSchool
Copyright © 2025 Harvard Business School Publishing. All rights reserved.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices