In short
Podcast Notes: Raoul Pal - The Journey Man
Episode
Mark Hart on Bitcoin, Space, and Geopolitical Risks Recorded on: October 7, 2024 Podcast Host: Raoul Pal Guest: Mark Hart, CEO, CIO, and Chairman of Corriente Advisors Podcast Description: Explore the intersection of macroeconomics, technology, and cryptocurrency, uncovering investment opportunities and economic risks.
---
Summary
In this episode, Raoul Pal engages in a deep conversation with Mark Hart, a prominent investor known for his macroeconomic insights. The dialogue covers a range of topics, including:
- Geopolitical Risks: Hart expresses concerns about rising tensions, particularly related to China and the geopolitical positioning of the U.S.
- The Exponential Age: The discussion highlights the implications of technological advancements and how they impact investment strategies.
- Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency: Hart shares his evolving perspective on Bitcoin, emphasizing its disruptive potential against traditional financial systems.
- Space Investments: Hart discusses his interest in space as an investment frontier and its opportunities.
---
Key Concepts and Themes
- Geopolitical Risks
- U.S. vs. China:
- Hart critiques the U.S.'s geopolitical posture, stressing the need to secure supply chains and build domestic strengths.
- Concerns about China's ambitions and potential for coercion in achieving its goals.
- Potential Conflicts:
- Hart warns of the risk of escalating geopolitical tensions, predicting possible conflicts on multiple fronts.
- Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency
- Value Proposition of Bitcoin:
- Hart discusses Bitcoin's characteristics that could disrupt the incumbent financial system, including access, security, and use as collateral.
- He outlines a framework for evaluating asset value that includes awareness, return on investment, and patina (perceived value).
- Corporate Adoption:
- Hart notes that despite barriers, there is a growing trend of companies adding Bitcoin to their balance sheets.
- Investing in Space
- Cost Reduction in Launching:
- The significant drop in launch costs due to advancements from companies like SpaceX opens up numerous opportunities for new businesses.
- Various Applications:
- Hart sees potential in satellite networks, energy collection in space, and even asteroid mining.
- The Exponential Age
- Hart emphasizes the acceleration of technological advancements and how they transform industries.
- He believes that investing in technologies that challenge incumbencies can yield significant returns.
---
Investment Philosophy
- Macro Framework:
- Hart operates with a long-term macroeconomic perspective, focusing on societal trends, technological advancements, and geopolitical conditions.
- Barbell Strategy:
- His investment approach balances liquid public securities with long-term private equity investments, allowing flexibility in capital allocation.
- Focus on Disruption:
- Hart's philosophy centers around identifying and investing in disruptions to traditional industries, leveraging a network of experts for insights.
---
Notable Quotes
- “The more value you bring to a network, the more valuable it is to you in the end.”
- “I wouldn’t say that I’m like religious about Bitcoin per se, but I do think it has the potential to be extraordinarily disruptive.”
- “The hard part is fighting the incumbents, which is the same story you’ve said every time.”
---
Recommended Reading
- "The Holographic Universe" – A thought-provoking book that explores the nature of reality, suggesting that our perception of the world may not be as solid as it seems.
- LBJ Biographies by Robert Caro – Offers insights into political power and economic change, with implications for understanding modern Texas.
---
Conclusion Raoul Pal and Mark Hart present a compelling discussion that challenges listeners to consider the broader implications of geopolitical tensions, technological advancements, and investment opportunities within the context of a rapidly changing world. The episode serves as a reminder of the importance of having a well-rounded perspective when approaching investments in today's complex landscape.
For further insights and investment strategies, listeners are encouraged to join the Real Vision community and engage with the broader network of informed investors.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:28I'm excited to show you an app I've been using for a while. will win, you can currently buy them winning for 50 cents. So you can buy 100 shares at 50 cents each. So that's$50 for 100 shares. If you are right, you will get$100 back and double your money. You can also sell early if their odds of winning go up to, say, 70%. You can sell for 70 cents each and lock in$70. If you don't want to trade, you can also look at the live odds to see who is more likely to win the race. Kulshi is the first legal exchange in the U.S. to trade on these kind of events. The election markets are now live to trade and they are the first regulated place where you can do this.
1:04I'm proud to have Kulshi as a sponsor and I hope you check them out. You can sign up using my link in the description and the first 500 traders who deposit$50 will get a free$20 credit. Hi, I'm Ralph Hough and welcome to my show, The Journeyman. And as you all well know by now, this is my exploration where I take you on that journey to the nexus of understanding between macro, crypto, and the exponential age of technology. Now, I've always found that doing these interviews is immensely helpful for me because I get to learn from other people and you get to lean over my shoulder and learn as I go along.
1:45But sometimes in your life, you get the odd person who changes your life. And those people change your trajectory and you're very lucky to find them. They only happen a few times. And that, I think, is the serendipitous journey of building a network. Building a network is one of the most important things that we can do in our lives. It really adds value to you, and you do it by adding value to other people. The more value you bring to a network, the more valuable it is to you in the end and to everybody else. And that's one of the things at Real Vision that we do so much is we We have this whole Real Vision network, which is our members, tens of thousands of members in pretty much every country in the world.
2:29And we organize Real Vision meetups where people get together in person. They talk to each other on the website. There's chats. There's regional chats. There's macro chats. There's crypto chats. We encourage a vibrant network. And we've got the incredible crypto gathering event in Miami at the end of January. Now, all of this stuff is available for you if you are a Real Vision member. So make sure you do join that network as you join Real Vision. Those of you watching this on YouTube, you're missing out on really what's important. So realvision.com, sign up for that because network for me is the most powerful thing.
3:04For me, one of the most powerful things, the best thing that happened to me was working at Goldman Sachs. I couldn't get in after university. My CV was not good enough. I went to a crappy university. I had no chance, but I worked my way up there. In fact, I focused on working there. Every day when I was working my prior jobs, I thought, well, one day I want to work at Goldman. And then one day I got a message from the head of equity derivatives at Goldman who said, look, we want you to come and build a hedge fund business here. And that was what I try and do is manifest a destiny, manifest a future by thinking about it and focusing on it.
3:39So the paths are coming in front of you. You're trying to take paths that go into the choice of where you want to go. Now, it doesn't always work, and that's fine. It's not expected to be foolproof, but I think it really helps. You kind of ask the universe and give into the universe to make that happen. When I left the hedge fund industry, I started Global Macro Investor, my kind of premium research service. That's read by family offices, high net worths, sovereign wealth funds, asset managers, RAAs, and hedge funds. I think without question by now, I've got the best track record of any research service in the world.
4:15I've been writing for 20 years. I'm immensely proud of it. We had our ups and downs too. Obviously, you go to globalmacroinvestor.com and check it out. You can read the story there. But it's not about the story of GMI. But the fact was, is my next guest was the third ever person to sign up. After GLG, who was my ex-employer, and Goldman, my employer prior to that, this guy signed up out of the blue. And he's been with me, and we've been close friends ever since. this guy not only showed me what a great macro investor can look like i mean he without being very public about it was one of the main players behind the cds trade you know the big short trade he did exceptionally well he saw it and he ran money for some very famous people and did extremely well.
5:12The European Sovereign Crisis. He got that one too well before anybody else saw it coming. He was the guy. So this person, Mark Hart, has been on Real Vision several times. In fact, many of you have seen his original Masterclass interview where he talks about some of those stories of old. But Mark's bigger than that. He's in fact probably one of the most influential people in my life. When I grow up, I want to be Mark Hart. You see, when I launched Real Vision, Mark was very helpful with Real Vision. And obviously it was one of the first key interviews that we had and people didn't know him and people were blown away.
5:52But he also introduced me to Tim Ferriss and said, Hey, I've been doing this with my life and re-engineering my life. And Tim Ferriss was on Real Vision and I was on Tim's podcast. And And Tim's is one of the biggest podcasts in the world. But that started me a journey of health and wellness. And that was Mark that started that for me. Also, Mark, you go to his office and his whole office is set up around wellness, learning, art. Incredible. He's kind of a bit of a Renaissance guy. And I've always been jealous of that of him. But every time I see him, he comes with new perspectives. I mean, whether it's talking about flow state, whether it's space.
6:34I remember he came to a Real Vision event and started talking about how his big investment thesis was space. And this was like 2017. I'm like, what the fuck are you talking about, Mark? Obviously, he was dead right. And that's been a big thesis for many people. And we've seen what has happened since. Mark has the ability to see in the future, seeing the subprime, seeing the situation with Europe, seeing space, seeing many, many things. Mark sees well ahead of anybody I've ever met. Now, it doesn't mean he's always right. None of us are. But he really is one of the most brilliant thinkers I've ever met.
7:16And it's a pleasure for me to have a conversation with all of you with Mark Hart. And as I said, when I grow up, I want to be Mark. Join me, Raoul Powell, as I go on a journey of discovery through the macro, crypto, and exponential age landscapes. In The Journeyman, I talk to the smartest people in the world so we can all become smarter together.
7:45mark hart how the devil are you wonderful ral uh uh thank you for asking how have you done i've been great and i've been so looking forward to this because you and i good friends we never get a chance to get together enough and we always have great conversations when we do and i know people at real vision always love it when you come on and you're you're very scarce when you come on, but everybody hangs on every word just because you always think of the world in a very different way. And so it's always a pleasure. So Mark, give us your big, we're going to dig into a lot of things because you and I have a lot to talk about, but let's, what's your overall framework right now?
8:27How are you thinking about your investing life and how that focuses your attention or what matters to you right now? Well, I guess that I have been thinking a lot about, you know, the world. We have an election obviously coming up, and it's kind of, I guess the sort of two sides couldn't be, you know, further apart in terms of kind of the world that we're going to get. And I worry, you know, quite a bit about rising axis led by China in a sort of a clash of, I don't know, civilizations. I think that the United States has put itself in a fairly weak position or has ended up in a weak position as we've geopolitically stretched ourselves out, overcommitted, not secured supply chains or a number of things, whether it's, you know, critical commodities or whether it's finished goods.
9:36And, you know, on the other side of the world, you've had China who has domesticated supply chains, who has focused their growth on military. And the economy in China, for instance, is something that we've talked about a lot, has been very lopsided and in many ways driven by a massive real estate boom, real estate property boom that seems to be in the process of unwinding and it probably gotten much larger. And so, you know, economically, I think it's more difficult for, you know, China to kind of win the battle with the United States to, you know, for instance, make the yuan a global or a digital yuan a global currency.
10:32And it seems as though there's a risk right now of China pivoting to sort of achieve its goals kind of through conquest and coercion instead of through direct competition. So I'm afraid that, I'm very afraid, I mean, it's maybe a fat tail risk, but I'm very concerned that you have, whether it's in months or years, a kind of simmering sort of geopolitical, already multiple wars on multiple fronts, really kind of accelerating. And so I've talked a long time about the U.S. needing to secure supply chains, the U.S. needing to basically build up its own strengths in order to counter this. And I don't think that the U.S.
11:32has done a particularly good job. So without diving too deep into kind of my geopolitical take, I've thought, I guess, maybe from a career perspective, that trying to focus on investing in a way that can help the US build up its strengths maybe is kind of the best use of my time and my thinking. So my focus is in a couple of areas. As you know, I've done a long-term bull on Bitcoin and kind of Bitcoin-related investments. I haven't gone nearly down the rabbit hole that you have, but I think that there are a lot of ways to, I guess, take advantage of that particular sea change. And I think that it really is that the world right now is sort of, I know I'm all over the map, but you have like, like progress is typically like achieved by, you know, breaking through, you know, incumbencies, breaking through oligopolies.
12:46And whether those are, you know, kind of, you know, government oligopolies or whether it's, you know, particular industry that, you know, shuns competition, i.e. shuns, you know, technological advancement because it's a threat to incumbents. So I guess throughout my career, I've tried to find, I guess, incumbencies that are sort of overstretched or vulnerable to disruption and then tried to find ways to invest in that. So let's talk a little bit about your Bitcoin view. So what is your kind of overarching, before we go into all of the other technology and other stuff you're investing in, what's your overall thesis on it?
13:39Why does it matter to you? Yeah, well, I wouldn't say that I'm like religious about Bitcoin per se. I do think it has the potential and Bitcoin related to be extraordinarily disruptive to the sort of incumbent financial system. And I think that's why you get sort of the shrieking attacks on it as an incumbent is sort of under threat. but I guess to me I've talked about this I think on here it's like trying to understand sort of the value of Bitcoin or a value of any kind of asset and what makes it what gives it value and I guess the sort of six characteristics that I've outlined before that kind of define the value of any asset are access awareness security patina, kind of, you know, return on investment and use as collateral.
14:47And, you know, I've talked about this, but where I think we are now is as Bitcoin is kind of continuing to be adopted, there are a couple of those areas, like we think about to cut the back. So access, how easy is it to access something? And I think that as Bitcoin is spreading globally, that access is improving maybe relative to other currencies, other stores of value, et cetera. Awareness is continuing to improve. And it's always changes in the six factors that will drive the price. Security, obviously, Bitcoin security at this point can be pretty well perfected. One of the problems with alternate assets like the dollar is, in fact, a lack of security.
15:36It doesn't mean that there's no value in dollars or there won't continue to be value in dollars for a long time, but there's a tax on dollars. I've pointed out that I think the tax is the sum of productivity gains and inflation. So that's sort of your bogeys that you have to hit, or that's the tax on holding a dollar. So I'll walk through the little explanation. I like to get a basket of goods that are$100 beginning of the year,$102 at the end of the year, then you've had kind of 2 % CPI inflation. But if productivity gains on farm productivity had been, say, 2 % over the year, then that basket theoretically would have been worth$98 at the end of the year.
16:22And so it's that delta is sort of the axe that holders of dollars are paying right now with Bitcoin. I guess it's a little over 1 % inflation and supply. And so that security seems to be much better for Bitcoin. and looking forward with expected significant deficits and debt to continue to be run up in the developed world, you would expect a monetary policy or monetary policies that would facilitate that debt growth. And that's the world we've been living in for a long time. But I think that from Bitcoin's perspective and gold and other types of fixed supply assets do particularly well you know, kind of in that environment.
17:10You know, patina is just simply the gloss, the feeling maybe that you get. Status almost. Status, right. And it could be, you know, like there are different reasons to hold, you know, kind of different assets. That's maybe Tesla has maybe been overvalued for a long time because of the personality and the image that Elon Musk puts out. And I think Bitcoin has some of that. I think, though, that and then return on investment. There's not a well, actually, there can be a return on Bitcoin. Typically, you think of Bitcoin as you're holding it in your wallet and it just sits there and inflates. Or you hold it in an ETF and there's a small negative carry holding that, but it benefits.
18:09I think that one thing that's interesting, though, on return on investment is that Bitcoin, like on the balance sheet of a corporation or in the hands of a more sophisticated player, is actually worth a lot more than a Bitcoin in an exchange. What do you mean by that? Well, I mean, for instance, you know, there are companies out there that, you know, buy Bitcoin and they hold it on balance sheet. Universally, those companies sort of traded a premium to the Bitcoin on their balance sheet. So, and of course, the volatility of this company is through the roof. So there are opportunities to do all kinds of things, whether it's if you have a constant strategy of acquiring Bitcoin, you can sell puts and acquire more as it comes into you, or you can monetize that volatility.
19:04There's a correlation, obviously, between interest rate and volatility. And the higher the ball, the higher demand for return. So corporations can either use their Bitcoin and lend it out at a higher rate or use – there's some companies that are out there that are selling convertible preferred type. And the other side of that trade, because I don't fully understand the other side, is the convertible ARB guys, right? So what are they doing? Selling vol against it?
19:59little as$100 once your account is approved. And the great thing is that in addition to crypto, Plus500 gives you access to a wide range of instruments, S &P 500, NASDAQ, gas, and much more. Explore equity indices, energy, metals, Forex, and beyond. With a simple and intuitive platform, you could trade anytime, anywhere. Experience the fast, accessible futures trading you've been waiting for with Plus500. With over 20 years of experience, Plus500 is your gateway way to the markets. Visit us.plus500.com to learn more. Trading in futures involves the risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone.
20:32Not all applicants will qualify. Plus 500, it's trading with a plus. Or what is the trade that they're doing that's absorbing billions and billions of dollars of this? Sure. Well, so I guess like a convertible bond has like two, it's basically two components to it. One is a bond that fast and you get a rate of return and interest. And then there's also this component of optionality, which is you basically have a bond and an option. And the option is to convert that bond into equity at another price. So because of the very high volatility of Bitcoin and the high volatility of companies that hold the stock prices of companies that hold Bitcoin on balance sheet leads to very high realized vol.
21:22And so the value of that option component of the convert in a much higher volatility environment is worth much more. So the play on, of course, the company side is a company. You own Bitcoin, and the number goes up, and your stop price goes up, and eventually those bonds are converted into equity. They're no longer a liability, but you've kind of sold that option at a Bitcoin price equivalent, Bitcoin per share price equivalent, at a massive premium to the actual price of Bitcoin. You take the proceeds, turn around and buy Bitcoin and you rinse and repeat. from the ARB's perspective, they can get a steady return with this gigantic call option.
22:14And what they would do is they would buy the convert and then they would delta hedge their position, short out the stock by the convert to some extent. But the possibility is, of course, that you have your downside protected as the buyer of one of those, and then you have this. So is he selling the volatility cheap? Is that what's going on? So therefore, they buy this, hedge out the Delta, and run the long vol. I mean, what's he doing to make it so attractive? Well, I mean, when you say he, I see you're talking about CEO of a particular company. I'm trying to be a little bit more generic. But yeah, I mean, and maybe I don't understand the question exactly.
23:00I mean, the opportunity is essentially to raise a lot of capital at an implied Bitcoin price that's extremely high and then take that capital and buy Bitcoin at market, which is a massive discount, that price where you're effectively raising. Yeah, but I'm wondering why, if the vol is priced so richly, why the ARBs are taking the other side of it? Or are these companies underpricing the vol facility? I think the R's are making an opinion on whether vol is overpriced or underpriced. I guess that, I mean, maybe they are at times, but historically volatility has, and any equity that holds Bitcoin on balance sheet, has been extremely high.
23:47So I don't necessarily think that there's an expectation that volatility is going to collapse really well over time. But the likelihood of collapsing, it's probably more in an environment where, you know, Bitcoin has grown dramatically and market cap. And as it gets bigger, obviously, volatility gets smushed. But in that scenario, you know, the price has gone up probably. You said that there's more value of this on a corporate balance sheet maybe than in other forms of holding Bitcoin. Do you think we'll see more people using, I mean, whether, I mean, the banks aren't really allowed to. But do we think at a broader level, we'll see people adopting this?
24:26I mean, there's a company in Japan that's been doing it. There's several smaller companies. Maybe Michael Dell is doing it. We don't know yet. It's kind of, it's getting interesting. Do you think it spreads more in this cycle? I do. I mean, the success that corporations have had in taking on Bitcoin has been pretty dramatic. And stock price performance has been really incredible. And I think that a CFO of a company has to think about that tax on dollars as well. And in a low inflation environment, holding dollars is fine. It makes a lot of sense. Right now, you're going to lose half the value of your dollar in 10 years if it just sits on your balance sheet.
25:11So I think that there is an incentive to protect the balance sheet better. And maybe just using cash isn't the most important thing. But I talked to some CEOs of some of the largest companies in the world about this. And I'm like, what do you do with the cash on your balance sheet? And they're like, well, usually it's to either acquire other companies or to invest in off space, manufacturing space, whatever it is. And I'm like, but those things go up in line with the debasement of currency. So they get more expensive every year, but your cash doesn't. And they're like, yeah, we understand that our cash is worth less every year, particularly in the assets that they buy with that cash.
25:56It's almost mystifying that there hasn't been much more corporate adoption of Bitcoin on balance sheet. I think part of it has to do probably with the way it's accounted for, where you don't recognize gains in the price of Bitcoin on your balance sheet as earnings. You recognize losses. that accounting treatment, I believe, is going to be changing at the end of the year. People have the ability to mark their positions in the market. I think that'll be a change. But I think that generally speaking, the psychology, it's kind of tough to go as a CFO of a company or a CEO of a company and do something that's so out of the mainstream.
26:43dream. And, you know, if you fail, you want to fail together, or most people do. And right now, you're kind of on an island if you're out there, you know, pursuing that strategy. And there are probably a lot of other kind of hidden forces that are, you know, also discouraging corporations from, you know, holding Bitcoin on balance sheet. I mean, the math for a bank, they can't custody via Bitcoin. It eats up their capital for doing it for kind of no return. And that's actually kind of what I was getting at is the number six factor that gives value to any asset is used as collateral. And it was obviously tulips back in the tulip bubble.
27:35The reason tulips went to mind-boggling prices wasn't because they were pretty or anything. It was because people were able to use those tulips as collateral to borrow money. So the demand for them increased pretty significantly. Back, for instance, during the European sovereign debt crisis, One of the things I was wondering a lot about was why are the bonds of different countries that have completely different demographics, different fiscal positions, why are their bonds all trading the same? And the reason was that it is, is that the European Central Bank will accept any EMU government debt as risk-free.
28:28So you can get 100 % loan from the ECB on against any European bond that you buy. And so even Greece ended up defaulting and it was a 30 some odd cent recovery. But it didn't look like they were going to fall for a long time because why would they if every time they issue bonds, the buyers know that they can take those bonds and immediately post them as collateral to the ECB and receive cash? And then they also know that in future issuances, they'll always be able to get them done and always be able to refinance as the ECB will always accept it. And so, you know, that that use is collateral really can can drive kind of exponential moves as as as any asset is is goes from not being used as collateral to being used as collateral.
29:25The price performance can be pretty, you know, extraordinary. And one of the things that some corporate companies have done is if you issue a convert, you're not explicitly, but you're not necessarily setting aside Bitcoin as collateral, but it is the Bitcoin that you're planning to buy that effectively is the reason you're able to borrow that money. And in fact, some corporations have been able to specifically use Bitcoin on their balance sheet as collateral to borrow money. so i think that that trend it's it's barely begun and i think that it's it's likely to you know accelerate um and i think that the implications for the price would be pretty kind of yeah we see that on private sector level i had dinner here in cayman with a guy who dan tapiero is invested you you know and um what they're doing is is bitcoin lending and a lot of it is for houses.
30:27People have huge amounts of Bitcoin on their balance sheets and they want to go buy a nice house. And so they just borrow against the Bitcoin. So we're seeing it being used as collateral significantly already in the kind of DeFi or CeFi sector. But we've already seen micro strategies borrow, I think, from JP Morgan or lend to JP Morgan. So it's showing that at the banking system level, as you're saying, we're starting to see the early signs of this is a collateralized product and therefore you know the demand can go up significantly because it's not dead money i think that's right i mean and and you know you have like not to mention and so i totally agree with that and i think that that corporations will you vastly increase their holdings you know over time and maybe other crypto assets i don't you know exactly um and then at the same time you know you're getting adoption you know by sovereigns and i think the um the uh incentives for sovereigns to uh to hold you know bitcoin in a fracturing world kind of only increase and you're seeing it you know again like corporate and sovereign adoption seems to have just begun but is starting to accelerate and these are kind of the gigantic you know pockets one of the things was interesting to me is I was, I don't want to name the guy, but the CIO of a sovereign wealth fund from a G10 nation, a Western developed nation.
31:53And there's not that many who've got sovereign wealth funds, so people can figure it out. But I was talking about Bitcoin and stuff. He's like, I cannot put it on the balance sheet. I said, why is that? He goes, I can't turn up to a G10 meeting. Right. Because we're then questioning the system, which is going to lead us back into this whole question of why it matters for geopolitics. Yeah, no, there are definitely, you know, strong forces that exist, that are somewhat hidden, that, you know, have dramatically slowed kind of the adoption of Bitcoin. I mean, it seems a little odd. It's literally, why would anybody care what a sovereign wealth fund does with their money?
32:39You know, but obviously they do, And obviously, there are consequences, you know, if you kind of get off sides on something like that. So I don't exactly know what those consequences are or why, you know, there is so much slow adoption. I've seen it, you know, somewhere. I mean, I guess, you know, but essentially you have like an incumbency that doesn't want to be supplanted. And breaking through that incumbency is kind of how you, you know, society and the world sort of, you know, moves forward. And so there's certainly a battle as to on one side trying to slow or halt adoption and on another side trying to accelerate it.
Read the full transcript
33:26I mean, that makes sense. And it's one of your investment philosophies is you're looking for those opportunities where there's an incumbent that's under threat, that there's a potential change. How does it fit into how does Bitcoin fit into your geopolitical process? Because you said, okay, this is your overriding thought process, you're investing in things that that fit in with that geopolitical structure. How does Bitcoin fit into that? Yeah. Well, I guess there are a couple of ways. One is, obviously, I expect much more sovereign adoption. You have competing blocks who want to, for instance, the United States prefers that the dollar be the world reserve currency.
34:07You have China who wants maybe a digital yuan be that. And probably you have a lot of countries, maybe particularly in the Middle East, who wouldn't mind sort of, you know, writing this one out and having sort of a little bit of protection, you know, in terms of holding reserve assets, regardless of the ways that the world goes. Also, you know, in the world in which we live, you know, obviously the stock market has been strong and it's been strong for a long time but what has accompanied that is you know an accelerating rise in global government debt and um and there's really only one way to to deal with that you know i guess you could come in and just slash spending cut bureaucracies etc but you know what's more likely in the past that we've kind of continued on down is simply you know um central banks kind of facilitating that growth through growing money.
35:06So I think that the tax on dollars and on fiat currencies is more likely to increase rather than decrease. Whereas the inflation tax on Bitcoin, obviously, is reduced every 10 minutes. So I think that, I guess from that angle, You know, just a continuation of the current situation of large deficits and debt issued to replace that as a gigantic, you know, kind of tailwind for the industry. And then, you know, obviously, if the world devolves and geopolitical tensions turn more into, you know, kinetic World War III or something, you know, along those lines, a lot of, you know, different historical, you know, stores of value, certain equities, you know, etc.
36:02could, you know, be disrupted considerably. And that might be the time to add something more like gold or Bitcoin or something that is somewhat limited in supply. So just switching on to broader topics now. When I first met you, you were a very focused macro guy, right? And you still are. But you kind of changed my entire thinking of the world because you went through looking at these macro tail risk opportunities, and then you kind of pivoted to the upside tail risk of technology investing and some longer term themes, which was not traditional for your peer group at the time, right? It was very non-traditional.
36:46I never forget you coming to an event, I don't know, 2016 saying, well, space is a big thing. Everyone's like, what the hell is Mark talking about? It always takes everybody five years to catch up with you, at least five years. So talk me through that transition from just being the kind of traditional guy. What changed you into thinking about technology and other investing that is less common or was less common? I think 2009 was a real, it was one of my worst years as an animator. After having had big success, I guess in 2008 was my best year ever. And 2009 was probably my worst. And I was trying to understand, like, what did I miss?
37:34And obviously, the rally in equities was very tech-led. And it was very clear that the technology, broad technology sector, software, etc., is growing at a much faster clip than the overall economy. And it was quite set to continue to do that regardless of the direction of the world over the long term. over the long term and so i started to try to i mean you know 09 when you have a terrible year you have to do kind of a post-mortem or a you know analysis as you're as you're dying and it seemed to me that this was the area you know um technology and accelerating and knowledge yeah but sorry just to interrupt but as macro guys we were cynics yeah and it was a very hard thing to become the opposite i mean everybody had become kind of a cynic at that point you know as well i mean uh people were looking for the next you know i mean i was as well after the you know so prime european sovereign crisis everybody was looking for the next kind of shoot a drop and um and yet the markets were telling us you know something different i guess it was uh um 2012 maybe when Mark Andreessen wrote his essay, Why Software is Eating the World, that pretty much completely blew me away.
39:01It was sort of the roadmap that I was kind of looking for. So I ended up trying to use, I guess, whatever notoriety I had to build out networks in Silicon Valley and meet venture capitalists, meet founders, and try to figure out how to take advantage of this huge theme regardless of the fat tail risks going on in the world and the potential downside of, you name, what kind of crisis could come along. Over the long term, it seemed very clear to me that we're accelerating technologically. And so the key was really to try to figure out my position, how I could be a part of that, not being a fact I, but wanting to invest in.
39:51And so, but you're running two frameworks in your head at the same time. One is there's a really dangerous tail risk out there. And the other side is I'm going to take the tail risk of the upside because I think there's a huge secular trend that people, I mean, that's quite hard to do for most people. Most people let the downside crowd their investments and they, they stop investing. But you're not doing that at all, right? No, that's definitely not. Well, even in a really dystopian world, you can have gigantic corporations that sort of control it or that do well. Or you can have technology companies that can do well.
40:35I mean, it's those technologies, in fact, that some of them that makes the dystopian world. and so you know i i felt like i guess regardless of of of what happens you know humanity's going to move on and accelerate unless there's you know something you know destroys the planet or whatever even this is the launch of trend and so uh and i knew it was what i was missing and i felt like it was um i felt like it was certainly you know kind of underappreciated i guess in and uh in macro circles anyway. I still think it is. So if you look at the balance of your investments between privates and public, to express this view and other views, what's the kind of balance?
41:22Because I've seen you going much more towards privates than you used to be. I mean, you've always been a direct investor in all sorts of stuff, all sorts of stuff from logistics businesses through to technology businesses. But where's your balance of you allocating capital now? Are you more private, more or still a large part of kind of public kind of macro style stuff? Well, I have more private investments than I do, you know, public. I guess I have a bucket of, you know, highly liquid, you know, assets, public securities cash etc um that kind of gives me my you know peace of mind and liquidity and then that you know um and and they're obviously um public market themes um that actually aren't even technology driven per se that that i think are really interesting let's let's do that and then we'll talk about the privates because that that's a whole other interesting thing so let's talk about the public side how do you how are you kind of positioned and thinking about the world Well, I think there are a few different areas that are particularly interesting.
42:33Obviously, what I call a Bitcoin-related theme is interesting. I think there are a lot of interesting public vehicles for expressing that theme. Another theme that's been one of the worst themes I've ever traded, but I still think it's pretty compelling is legal cannabis in the United States. And why has that been such a dog? I mean, you've been investing in that space for a long time. There was a big rally, then it all fell apart. Is it just this banking, this federal banking issue that's the issue? Yeah, that's for it. I mean, again, you make, you know, say, you know, hidden forces. I mean, the market has grown dramatically, you know, consistently.
43:18the total market in the U.S. as long as I've done on this theme. But I guess there's three different groups that capture that upside. And so one is the illicit market, which is probably at least, you know, has probably two-thirds market share. And then you have the legal regulated market, which is maybe a third. And those are rough numbers that could be off. And then, of course, you have government that takes their toll. And, you know, currently it's the illicit mostly and the, you know, kind of government sectors that have basically been reaping all of the rewards for the extremely rapid growth that we kind of correctly predicted.
44:18So the cost of capital, I mean, it's an access issue where, you know, a lot of most of the cannabis names don't trade in major exchanges. And a lot of institutions have a tough time. There's really no institutional ownership. And several of the large brokers, you know, world custody, legal cannabis. Obviously, you have a much higher tax regime for legal cannabis where they pay taxes on federal taxes on gross receipts because cannabis is still a Schedule I drug. But I think the way to frame it is that you have the illicit sector that has probably two-thirds market share. They don't pay taxes. They don't have to worry about environmental impact of what they do.
45:27They don't have to worry about any of the regulatory issues. Certainly have coerced or extremely cheap labor. um that are able to pay health care and so um so what happens when you have two-thirds of the of the market basically has these gigantic structural uh advantages over the you know over the legal market it it you know if the marginal producer is the illicit sector and they're producing at a much lower cost than the legal sector, you know, it, it pushes, it pushes down both, you know, top line and bottom line, it squeezes. And that's, you know, definitely been happening. And you have obviously the tailwinds of new states allowing medical or allowing legal, you have the tailwinds of, you know, increased consumption kind of across the warp to go among, you know, older people.
46:26So they're definitely large tailwinds. But I guess it's sort of the biggest problem is probably the way that the playing field, the current kind of legal environment really builds the playing field in favor of the illicit sector. And so are you comfortable holding a position to allow this to be kind of rectified for something to change for the catalyst or do you just trade it in and out of it now how do you how do you manage that because you know you've got tailwinds of the clear there's a secular trend problem is you've got these headwinds yeah i mean it's a it's been a a terrible trade you know and in hindsight it shouldn't have held the longer in term positions but i've it's not it's not a I mean it certainly was a much bigger exposure for me a couple of years ago than it is you know now and it's not a it's not a theme I think that that has to have you know federal reform obviously that would be great but you know demand is really inelastic you could have simply enforcement of laws that would that could really test them or you know the illegal immigration, for instance, in the United States has really fortified this sort of illicit sector.
47:53And I think, you know, any type of crackdown on lawlessness is a huge, you know, would be a huge boost kind of to the sector. And all the while, you know, the companies in the sector, the ones that still exist, because many of them have failed, You know, they find themselves in a relatively sparse landscape of legal competition. And they've had, you know, years to sort of optimize their operations and adapt to kind of the current environment. And I now think you have a sector that many of the companies have, short of their balance sheets, been able to achieve growth despite the headwinds and are kind of poised for what I think is sort of tremendous growth and probably appreciation and stock price with the right catalyst.
48:48And I don't know that it, you know, when it comes and I can't say that I love this theme, for instance, more than, you know, Bitcoin related. But it is an industry that has, you know, fully domestic supply chains. It is an industry that I think does a real positive good. You have big drops in things like opioid abuse, even just the number of prescription drugs prescribed in places where cannabis is legal, either for medical or adult use, recreational. What else is in your public book that interests you? What themes are also there? Well, I think that one of the big things, kind of how when we went from, we had to build a new internet in a sense to accommodate the growth in technology.
49:54And when I say a new internet, like the last time, you know, going from kind of dial up to, you know, high speed across the board. And it took a gigantic amount of capital investment. You probably remember all the CLEX, the competitive local exchange carriers that took on gigantic amounts of debt and built out all this, you know, last mile of fiber optic infrastructure. sure they all went you know bankrupt but then the system you know kind of had that uh had that uh you know backbone that it could build on and i mean i think that actually back down in the you know in the i think it was in 2000 january of 2000 when maybe the last select had a had a failed offering before the whole thing just kind of went went to shit um but we built up like a gigantic kind of surplus of broadband capacity that we've been consuming all this time without really thinking about, well, will we always have that excess capacity?
50:56And now we're getting to a point where this sort of needs to be rebuilt again.
51:04And literally the whole tech stack to accommodate AI and to accommodate the massive consumption of electricity and of data. And it needs to be, I think,
51:22more or less centralized. And so I think you're talking about building out sort of satellite networks and data storage like off planet and in a distributed way. So I really think that networking and all of the different technologies associated with building better switches, building out that type of capacity is interesting. So, I mean, I've definitely been focused on networking stocks. It's also kind of a driver in some of the private stuff. And any traditional kind of macro bets or you're mainly kind of equity focused right now? Well, I think the most compelling macro bet out there, which has been my view maybe for a long time, is this, you know, kind of migration inside of the United States.
52:16And I think that it's, you know, specifically coming to Texas, Florida, maybe some other places. And obviously there are a lot of things that, you know, hurdles, but for instance, the talent pool in California versus here. But, I mean, I live in Fort Worth, which would shock most people to know that Fort Worth is now the 10th largest city in the United States. and people still think of it as a small cow town yeah and it is you know it's there's not a huge amount of industry here but the amount of that i've just witnessed of kind of human and you know financial capital moving here and the business environment is you know pretty dramatic pretty uh it's it's uh it's massively more friendly than a lot of uh other jurisdictions and i kind of I think we've sort of set off like a little bit of a feedback loop of migration coming here.
53:14And not just to Fort Worth, although I think Fort Worth is the optimal place for a lot of this capital to come. It already has, you know, quite a bit of wealth. And you have some, I guess Fort Worth is probably like the largest city in the country without a major research institution located there. And that's changing dramatically here with Texas A &M is building out a gigantic campus, actually, in downtown Fort Worth. Texas A &M is probably the largest university in the world. It's not in a major metropolitan area. I think it's the second or so largest school in the country right now. And so, for instance, A &M wants to build Kendall Square in downtown Fort Worth where they can help accelerate companies.
54:05Spending$700 million just building out their campus over the next four years, UT Arlington is now setting up a new campus for 8 ,000 engineers just in West Fort Worth. And the kind of ecosystem is being built here. Obviously, that ecosystem exists in Austin. It exists to some extent in Dallas as well. and so um you know just from this gigantic migration i think there's just so many different ways to play it whether it's through real estate you have a lot of real estate here um in texas in fort word i mean how does it work with commercial real estate because you're fighting another trend there as well so there may be university real estate that's required but even that's not clear over time whether in a more digital world how much that's needed how do you think that through versus obviously if people are moving there there's obviously just housing i mean that's a another big thing how do you think about this yeah well i mean just to be clear like my my experience in commercial real estate is i simply own the building that i my my office is and it's a great building i love your yours is the coolest office in the world yeah that's all i want to say it is it is good it is very good um and that's something you can actually get in Fort Worth.
55:21I mean, can you imagine having, you know, something like this in Dallas or LA or something? You just, you know, you can't do that. Fort Worth does have a lot of, I mean, it's sparsely populated. It's a gigantic and with lots of, you know, kind of potential for urban infill. I think that the idea like for A &M, it's not spending$700 million building out a campus, you know, it's that they envision this as, you know, holding maybe some of their most important intellectual property so they're uh you know attracting kind of top you know academics attracting kind of top you know companies who can partner with them on r &d or can partner with them on um you know finding capital to build manufacturing or or whatever it is and and and a &m can actually kind of program the the the school around um around you know those sort of opportunities, this corporate collaboration opportunity.
56:20So I think that's their idea. In terms of commercial real estate, I mean, obviously it's been overbuilt in a lot of places. Austin and Dallas are two very obvious ones. Has it happened in Fort Worth necessarily? much lower vacancy rates here. But I don't know. I mean, it's not the angle that I'm... What is your angle then? Because what you're saying to me in typical Mark terms is I've seen a secular trend that's starting. People haven't seen it yet. It's going to have spin off lots of opportunity. I mean, this is very typical of you. You'll come in with something, everyone's going, what's he talking about?
57:05They'll realize in five or seven years time, what you were talking about because you're always ahead on this stuff so yeah how do you play this well i think that gigantic or i mean there's just a gigantic arbitrage for any company to move to texas you know from i mean there's no income tax here there's no capital gains tax texas two dollars cheaper for a gallon of gasoline than it is you know california um it's the the business environment is is tremendous so literally just a corporation moving and picking on of California, I mean, it may have kind of the worst governance of any of the states in my mind.
57:42So, I mean, being in California a little bit, that's also where, you know, some of the greatest companies are, you know, the arbitrage in terms of, you know, the quality of life arbitrage for employees, the cost of living arbitrage for employees, the cost of doing business for the companies is gigantic. So, I mean, I really spend a lot of my time trying to convince portfolio companies that i'm okay see what you're saying is companies in your in your portfolio your private companies you're saying listen come here because it's going to make a dramatic difference to the potential outcome of the company right absolutely and yeah they're they're huge incentives you know government incentives and local incentives as as well to come here i mean i think this is Like if I were, you know, trying to say, I mean, I do, I'm not, I'm not like, I do make venture investments.
58:34I'm not part of a venture fund and I'm not really looking to become like some, you know, venture capitalist or anything. um uh or but but um it does seem like you know if you're starting in venture um you know kind of the way it's done is is you know there's sort of a model for you know each round and how how the the vcs come in and how they uh you know they want to see certain things they want to see certain growth, certain metrics, and it's kind of a moving business where, you know, you find a company, you get to the next round, hopefully liquidity, you raise a new fund, you find new companies.
59:16And to me, the opportunity is like finding companies and helping sort of, you know, negotiate some of the macro risks, supply chain risks that may come up and figuring out how they can become much more efficient and more prosperous.
59:39I think like facilitating sort of instead of instead of. well, I guess I would just say, I think, you know, helping facilitate those types of moves, there's just a gigantic opportunity. So it's in venture, help your portfolio companies to, you know, relocate if you're a corporate CEO, you know, you want to think about, you know, I mean, I think we'll continue to think about moving to kind of these, you know, more where where you're appreciated a little bit as a company. And, um, and so I can't say that there's, you know, there's some like specific individual, like incredible investments that you could make.
1:00:20I mean, I'm sure, you know, I'm really Mark. There's one thing that people don't realize just at the simple tax level, the hurdle rate that you have to be of a person in Texas versus as a person in California in the exact same trade, it is an incredible difference over time what it means to you. And people don't think this through. They think they're different, but it actually is a driver of returns over time is taxation. And so optimizing for that allows you to outperform over time. And it's the same with companies. If you optimize for taxation, you will outperform over time. You'll have more free cash flow to do other things.
1:01:06That's right. And so I think that that is the opportunity, I think, for companies. But I think that's where to bat. And then obviously there's all kinds of other sort of ancillary kind of businesses that all do well, like when you have, you know, the type of population growth. I just think that the bottom line is you're going to have, you're going to have an increasing flood of, you know, kind of people and capital moving here. And there are a lot of ways to sort of, you know, capture that value. I'm blown away, obviously, by what Texas A &M is doing. I try to spend a lot of time talking to the people over there, figuring out how I can, you know leverage um or how i can collaborate with uh with them and helping them you know build their vision and and and do the same so let's talk about some of the kind of um private investments you've been doing because they're always interesting what is your let's start with space because you know again most people would never have thought the cynical macro guy who was betting on crises is the next minute is investing in space.
1:02:32What is your, what's your thesis there? And what got you to look at this? Because, you know, it's now becoming apparent things like rocket labs as a public company and obviously Tesla and SpaceX, everyone's now becoming fully aware with, but when you started talking about this stuff, everyone's like, what is he talking about? Yeah. Well, it was purely launch class. You know, You could see when SpaceX was able to land and reuse rockets, essentially the cost of launch dropped by a factor of 10. And talking with everybody in the industry for a long time, it seemed poised to continue to just collapse.
1:03:13And so that just, I couldn't even imagine all the different types of, um it's kind of like going from from dial up to high speed you know it it opens up all kinds of markets that um that may not exist the starting point is there's this just gigantic tailwind of absolutely collapsing launch costs that why do people want to go into space this is what people don't yet understand they're like oh yeah but sure this was a government thing and governments did it the pride of nations stuff, but it's now, it's a corporate enterprise. What is going on? Well, I mean, there are obvious things like, you know, communications or, you know, energy or, you know, acquiring energy in space or building distributed networks of, you know, in space where they're not in a fixed location.
1:04:08um uh i mean their manufacturing in space is is taking off the company i've invested in that found that they can you know manufacture different things much more specifically like we're more uh exactly like yeah exactly um there is you know down the road which people laugh at me a lot about but you know asteroid mining um which is certainly uh uh something that happens long term there is the moon which has you know fuel that can you know whether it's you know helium three that can uh that that will be used for you know fusion energy or whether it's just simply exploring you know beyond space is kind of like it's the frontier and it's frontier investing in a place where you don't have so much the incumbencies um you know preventing growth i mean the incumbent Well, you did have the incumbency.
1:05:05It's very much like Bitcoin, right? You had the incumbency of this massive state architecture that was hugely inefficient. Then suddenly out of nowhere, the private sector just took it. I mean, 90 % of all launches are now private sector. That's right. And so that incumbency has, for the most part, kind of been broken through. And so it's in many ways a land grab. And obviously, SpaceX is the early mover and the wealth that obviously they've achieved is spectacular. It's one of the most exciting companies ever. But there are innumerable types of applying different technologies to space and using innumerable use cases.
1:05:49And it's literally how we grow, and it is the frontier. So I've definitely been focused. And a lot of, I mean, I don't know if there's any specific companies to go into and explain sort of the thesis. Yeah, let's move into other themes that you've been investing on the private side as well. Because again, you always find stupidly interesting stuff really early. You and I had a dinner in San Francisco 10 years ago when we launched Real Vision. It's almost 10 years ago today, pretty close. And I met this company and they're doing just groundbreaking stuff. And you see all sorts of really interesting stuff.
1:06:28What are the things that are interesting you that you want to invest in? Well, I mean, that particular story is probably my, that we had is maybe the most exciting investment that I've made. That was a company called Misapplied Sciences. And you and I met the two of the three founders in the lobby of the Mandarin Oriental Hotel. And they had just left Microsoft in the Applied Sciences group. And they had an idea of creating a screen where every individual person looking at the screen without any kind of visual aid or any kind of wearable device would see something different on that screen. And for us at the time, the technology was you either see a light or you don't see a light.
1:07:20um and but the kind of the long-term potential of a company like that is that you know if they you know succeed then you have you know every single screen becomes a smart screen that can deliver you know uh personalized content to each person that looks at it or even you know can be we're not talking here television screens or computer screens we're talking gigantic display screens where i'm sitting next to you and i see a different thing on that screen than you do which is like a bizarro quantum world yeah uh yeah that's that's what it was and i mean this particular investment misapplied sciences um which i can't talk about i'm on the board of the company but you know they basically you know after we invested they went dark for five years and they built their technology and then they came out in the 2020 Electronics Show with Delta Airlines, who's one of the investors there.
1:08:17Delta had the keynote address and they announced how they were going to be using this tech. Now if you go to the Wayne County, the Detroit International Airport, the Delta Terminal, you can go there and you log in or you opt down and you see this big screen and it delivers all your personalized information. there'd be a hundred people standing next to you and they don't see what you're looking at they see what what they're looking at uh and it's the content that's that's just for them and i mean the technology now is such that the screens are fully interactive so you can sit here you can manipulate the screen that you look at fingers phone web games on it um personalized content can be delivered at the same.
1:09:03And it is basically, though, an array of smaller LCD screens. And so you can theoretically make these kind of any size and you can adjust the views. But the potential of a company like this is to have these screens kind of, you know, I mean, it's like in every hotel lobby or every floor of every hospital Or the Intuit Dome, for instance, which is Steve Ballmer's LA Clippers new$2 billion arena there in LA. They installed one of these screens kind of for their VIP customers in one of the areas where you go in and it is personal content delivered to every single person that walks in there. It can tell you where to get your food or it can tell you whatever can advertise to you.
1:09:56And doing this, I mean, what's interesting to me is they can build these screens for essentially the same cost, regular dumb, you know, big LCD monitor and just plug it into the wall kind of power. But, you know, the potential is to really replace, you know, any and every screen. I mean, that's certainly in a public place where 85 % of money is spent actually, you know, away from the home, away from the screen. I mean, it's just kind of one technology. It's incredible. Okay, give me another example of something you've invested in, and then I'm going to ask you some questions about how you do this.
1:10:35But give me another example of something you found that you're excited about, where you can talk about it. So obviously some stuff you can't, but whatever you think you can talk about, either in broad brushstrokes or whatever, or specific. Well, I would say there are a couple of investments that I've made that, and they're interesting. One is a company that has figured out how to edit the genes of crops like corn and soybeans in a way that improves yield. And so this is a company, again, that I invested in a long time. But is that not just standard genetic modified kind of seeds and stuff, or is it very different?
1:11:22Well, it's not. You're not taking, like, genetics from another species and then planting it in this species. You're actually just altering the genetics of a particular species. And, you know, this particular company, for instance, has been going for a long time. that they've proven that they can take elite germ and alter it and improve crop yield by 10 plus percent. So if you think of which is gigantic, it's creating a new Argentina worth of corn and soybeans or whatever. And I guess it is a cautionary tale in this particular company, and it certainly can be a very successful company. But, you know, we just assumed that once you prove, I mean, this is Norman Borlaug level stuff.
1:12:15This is, you know, this isn't just, you know, making a crop like a little more resistant to drought or whatever else. This is literally creating the same amount of product with 10 % less land, 10 % less fertilizer, you know, et cetera. And what's really crazy about it is there are these hidden forces that sort of prevent it from accelerating. And who knows if it will now, where they're basically two seed companies. They don't want a value. They don't want the technology, the commodity aggregators. They aren't going to sell. they're going to take in a crop that's come from these germ plasms because it's not commoditized the standard way.
1:13:06There's specifications if you want to sell into China or you want to sell into somewhere else. You can't just sell any corn or any crop. It has to be a specific kind of strain. And so I don't know really if there's much of a conclusion here other than the easy part was editing a gene to massively increase crop yield. That was the easy part. Hard part is fighting the incumbents, which is the same story you've said every time. Yeah, that's the hard part is fighting the incumbents. And then that's literally pretty much every single major investment I've done. It tries to do that in one way or another.
1:13:48it's fighting, sometimes it's a disaster, like shorting the Chinese yuan, even though I feel like my work was good. Sometimes, you know, you break through the income. Sometimes you don't, yeah. Those are the kind of things that I'm looking for anyway. Just the, and they're really, you know, the sort of the, if you're right, you know, it's world changing. So I want to ask you a bit about that. How do you source opportunities
1:14:19in the private side? Because this is cutting-edge technology. These are very small companies. You don't get to know them. It's a network and stuff. And then how have you transitioned your mind to investing in this stuff, which is longer duration, sort of different measurements, or do you just think of it as the same kind of tail risk investing you've always done, and there's a bit of in-the-middle stuff where there's no price? How do you think about that? I think it's very similar to the stuff that I've always done. It's kind of tail-wrist stuff. How to transition to it, it's oftentimes like hiring.
1:14:54A company that I'm working on right now, my good friend Dan Babbage, who worked for Kyle Bass for many years. Dan's a Harvard physics PhD, two years as a postdoc, Gordon Betty Moore postdoc fellow at Caltech in physics. And so, you know, to understand a company, sometimes you have to go and bring somebody like that on to really, you know, do the deep dive because it's certainly nothing that I'm, you know. Because that's a very, I mean, you and I have spoken about the company. It's a very technologically complicated thing. Right. Yeah. So you just bring on an expert to help you. Yeah. Oftentimes, you know, you know, have to have to do that.
1:15:41but you know really it is simply i guess the network that i've i've built i mean i see for whatever reason i have like an insane amount of you know deal flow that that that comes across my desk um and you know i think it's probably because you know i've invested in this stuff and met a lot of founders and it's just sort of kind of word of mouth but how do you select them then you've got deal flow it's not like you're a you know a hundred person team or anything how do you how do you do this well um it's there's not a good process i mean specifically it's just like it's it is it i have a you know a macro framework of kind of where i think the world's going what i think is going on in terms of regulatory environment in terms of you know demographics in terms of geopolitics in terms of monetary policy in terms of how i see the future and then i sort of try to find you know the types of of companies that i could envision you know and that and that future yeah because most macro people tend to be too short term you have to have a long-term macro view if you've got long-term long-duration investments yeah and that's all i've always said you know i mean i always think of macro in the very long long term i mean it's really difficult to trade or operate in the short term you know these days anyway like with algos and whatnot.
1:17:04They're much smarter than I am. So, yeah, that's one of the things is I've had, you have to kind of increase your time horizon in order to compete with, you know, computers. Yeah. And that's all I did as well. I just went just longer and longer term and there's much less competition and it's easier to capture a secular trend. Yeah. And it's, that's not how people are investing. I mean, if, you know, I'll invest in something that I expect to have zero liquidity for 10 years even if it's even if it's successful um and i just want to make like a lot of those bets and and then see if i can add any value you know taking a board seat or being involved with you know helping you know being management typically have their core competencies and then they try to fill in the gaps with you know um with outside consultants or employees or whatnot.
1:17:55I think it's really a fraught macro environment that to some extent we can help out. And you run essentially a barbell strategy. You've got liquidity because of your public's portfolio and cash and all the other stuff, and then you have privates. Do you purposely, like profits that you make in one get reinvested in the long term, or are they just two discrete things that they just happen to balance nicely and give you what you need i mean it's much more um it's no it's i don't have like a specific sort of process i mean i'm just trying to read a lot and interact a lot with a lot of people and just keep an open mind and you know hope that you know the right opportunities will come and then when they do just or when something does come along that's appealing than trying to dive deep and see if it works.
1:18:51But there's not a specific process. There's not an allocation percentage between - Sort of trade by trade basis, you look at it. No, trade by trade basis. And it's kind of three buckets, I guess. There's real estate, which is mostly my office and my house and some other kind of little things that I think will do well over the long term. And then there's kind of private equity, which venture sort of investing. And then there's the public bucket. Excuse me, those change quite a bit. I mean, I guess I have the lecture of not... I mean, I'm not trying to build like a... A giant firm or... Right, a firm at all, or any kind of family office type situation that's targeting certain returns and certain risks.
1:19:41I mean, sometimes the risk I'm taking on is massively higher. And maybe that's to my detriment. No, I think for me it's inspiring. Okay, I've got two questions for you before we wrap up because you're just brilliant at all of these things. What's the best thing you've read recently? Or what should people read that they probably haven't read yet? Because you're always reading interesting stuff. well i guess blew your mind recently it can be really crazy because i know you read some crazy shit as well the the well i mean the crazy and the most interesting thing uh and i can't go down the rabbit hole but um just a crazy book that that like might blow your mind is called the holographic universe um and i sounds right up my street because i'm this is the kind of a holographic universe okay holographic universe uh and i can't remember the the author of it's it's not a it's not a new book but uh i really i don't think i could even begin to describe gosh i should have had a i should have had like several uh answers ready for you can come but you can come back because it'll come into your head but holographic universe there's one okay the other thing that you completely led the path on again which is so irritating how good you are at this stuff is you did the whole longevity lifestyle thing literally six seven years before it was on anybody else's radar screen obviously tim ferris you and tim were on real vision back in the very early days where are you with that now what is your kind of your general you know mark operational health and wellness setup now what do you what do you do what's your protocol um well i guess it's uh yeah i mean i have like a you know my diet is pretty like hard or i would say for the most part and it's similar to like the the kind of the tim ferris diet it's not that uh you know kind of no carbs except cheat on the weekends um a lot of weight lifting a lot of so it's a low carb sort of tim ferris style diet not not keto which i do on and off but it's low carb and slow carb slow carb and a lot of protein a lot of protein um i mean i have a variety of different like so i mean i take a ton of supplements just to check what's your favorite supplements well i mean i don't know like what did a couple that i've started one i've started taking like cilantro and um and i think a lot of like turmeric trying to eat foods yeah um uh but cilantro is kind of like apparently helps like um purge like heavy metals from the body a lot of mushrooms yeah and what about um the kind of nmn the david sinclair style stuff the nad plus all of that kind of stuff that longevity stuff yeah so i take all of that so i have a particular um uh yeah kind of protein powder that he's called momentum i mean i don't know i think it's really good but i i don't know if there's probably lots of other stuff better has a lot of those um including the dad plots uh in there um i do uh have read sauna several times a week um yeah a lot of like brazilian jiu-jitsu obviously um you're still doing yoga as well i don't really do yoga i mean i'm like certainly kind of lumber i do a lot of like stretching out when i mean really just you know meditation and jujitsu or sort of lifting weights are kind of my main sort of you know protocols i guess i love you know cold plunges i do that a lot um but uh i also um uh do you know what a one wheel is or you know one you've ridden one of my before ain't i yeah for to get into flow state and balance all of that stuff yeah so like electric skateboards e-foils one wheels like surfing all these kind of things just to sort of like try to get into flow you know um that's another thing you were very early on was the whole flow state idea and how to channel it and almost teach yourself to channel it yeah i mean i just sort of just pursue those sort of things um you know for a long time i mean i think meditation is one of the most important things, I guess.
1:24:17And the other one you're big into, sunlight. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I mean, anytime it's, I go outside every day, just take my shirt off, soak up the sun. If there's any free vitamin D on offer, I'm a buyer. It's one reason I love living here in Texas. Even in the winter, you get 70 degrees sunny days. Do you do testing? I'm actually going to go to the fountain life, the Peter Diamandis, Tony Robbins thing. Do you do testing of all of this stuff or do you just observe your protocol and presume you're getting it roughly right? Well, I do like a couple of times or maybe three times a year. I get, you know, massive blood draw and just look at, you know, different levels of various things in my body and will, you know, have someone I consult with that helps me like kind of tweak my, you know, supplement intake.
1:25:20But I am probably, you know, I'm not sort of at the cutting edge at all. You're not Brian Johnson, no. Oh, no, no, no. I mean, I think it's fascinating what, I mean, started chugging like, uh, Brian Johnson's olive oil. I've watched him on a daily basis, actually. But no, no, I'm not there. It's, I'm not that interested in, and, you know, going that far. Yeah. Mark, as ever, a absolute pleasure. We talked about an incredible array of things, including your frameworks, how you think about the world, uh, how you're living your life. you only gave us one book but i'll forgive you because i've never heard of the book so i'm going to order it right now and i'm sure it'll be great because everything you do you always jump these things oh you gave me the fourth turning i mean yeah you are i mean i i have to give you a credit for a lot of things and you know fourth turning was one of them you you always find stuff that nobody's ever looking at and suddenly it's like well here you go so i'll tell you a book i'll tell you the book i'd read it um i read a long time ago or all of them but um so robert carrow is one of many consider that the greatest biographer um of all time well lbj is the his primary subject and he's written four biographies on lbj and apparently maybe a system's out or is coming out um and uh in the first one um i mean they're they're brilliant but the first uh lbj biography goes through lbj's childhood and through the through the um through the 20s and 30s and as he got into politics and um his relationship with fdr his relationship with sam rayburn who was the Texas head of the house from Texas back in the day.
1:27:15And Texas probably in 1935 was the poorest state in the union. And at that time they found oil. They were able to break through the sort of standard oil kind of monopoly because it was on the frontier so far away. And so wealth was able to be produced and it was essentially channeled into you know political power um and i think that like the the history of the state of texas is is i mean you get a better understanding of why texas is what it is today from that individual book the first of the caro biographies of lbj than than anything else that i've read yeah it reminds me and i'd love to read that as well of just reading lee kwan yu's books about building Singapore.
1:28:02Yeah. It was just like the same thing. It was just, it was a swamp with no natural resources and no opportunities. And he turned it into literally the most advanced society on earth in one generation. Staggering. Yeah. Although maybe arguably the most important choke point in the world. Okay. I mean, optimal geography anyway, for Singapore, but really, I think that's the case with Texas. Well, I mean, Texas is the frontier, and it always has been. Like, as the population, you know, moved east and the U.S. population moved west, it kind of stopped, you know, right here in Texas, in the middle of Texas, which is basically I-35, because west of here, you know, it becomes like high deserts.
1:28:52You have poor soil, little amounts of rain. So this way you have like San Antonio, Austin, Waco, Fort Worth, Duton, Oklahoma City. No, that's where basically the population stops. And that is kind of the frontier and it still is. Well, I just have to come back down and see you. I haven't been to Texas for a while, so I need to come and see you at some point. I would love to see you. We have great hotels here in Fort Worth now, incidentally, that we hadn't had before. We have a Crescent and that. And then a bear is just right around. Well, I'll find an excuse to come down and see you, my friend.
1:29:24But listen, thank you for coming on Real Vision. Thank you for sharing your thoughts with the world. I really appreciate it, as ever. Ralph, thank you so much. It's a pleasure being here. Always great to catch up with you and hope to see you on Fort Worth soon. So as you can see, Mark can talk about everything. We could have talked for hours and hours. The things that focus his attention, he has this geopolitical framework, which is actually very risk averse. It's like geopolitics is dangerous. I'm nervous about it. Personally, I have an opposite view on all of this, but that doesn't matter. Mark is an incredible thinker.
1:29:57He could be right, I could be wrong, or somewhere between the two. Doesn't matter. The point being is that he's got that framework, and of which he then builds an incredibly optimistic framework, a framework of abundance, technology, of the future, whilst also having this geopolitical framework. And then he makes sure his bets fit within that by being kind of proof or proofed against something terrible happening. Now, obviously, over the long run, not in the short run, obviously, markets go up and down with cyclicality, macro factors. But what he's trying to do is move out duration, which is what I've done as well.
1:30:42I found I've become a longer term investor and the real returns lie there. And Mark has gone from being an event-specific catalyst macro guy to this big secular thesis macro guy well before I got there, obviously, because it's Mark. Anyway, I hope you learned something about how great investors think. And it's a real pleasure for me to be able to do this. Obviously, those of you who haven't joined Real Vision, make sure you do, because there's many of these there, obviously, all of the AI summaries. But also, once you've upgraded into the plus tier, you'll realize that amongst you all are lots of great investors.
1:31:21When you see the performance for the trade competition, I mean, several people up nearly 100 % of time of filming this in a month. There's some really smart people in Real Vision. You get access to them and their trade ideas and their research notes in Real Vision Plus. So make sure you keep that journey, level up, and get from information where you are today, if you're watching this on YouTube or watching this on Real Vision, or you get to level up to knowledge and then up to wisdom as you get through pro tiers. It's a journey we're trying to take you on so we can really help you in your investing lives.
1:32:05Realize that future vision of yourself, that manifesting of your destiny. You have to take the steps. It's not going to happen without you taking those steps. So go manifest. Go to RealVision.com and I'll see you next time. Picture yourself on a beach, retired early and enjoying financial freedom. If this is your dream, then now's the time to level up your investing game and Real Vision can help you. We arm you with the knowledge, the tools and the network to succeed on your financial journey on your own terms. Take control of your future and visit realvision.com forward slash free. That's realvision.com forward slash free.
1:33:01Have you ever wanted to trade Bitcoin but haven't dared try? With Plus500 Futures, you can trade crypto without the hassle of opening a wallet. With just a few clicks, you can register and start practicing with their free and unlimited demo. See a trading opportunity? You'll be able to trade it in just two clicks. Feel ready? You can move to real money with as little as$100 once your account is approved. And the great thing is that in addition to crypto, Plus 500 gives you access to a wide range of instruments, S &P 500, NASDAQ, gas, and much more. Explore equity indices, energy, metals, forex, and beyond.
1:33:34With a simple and intuitive platform, you can trade anytime, anywhere. Experience the fast, accessible futures trading you've been waiting for with Plus 500. With over 20 years of experience, Plus 500 is your gateway to the markets. Visit us.plus500.com to learn more. Trading in futures involves the risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone. Not all applicants will qualify. Plus 500. It's trading with a plus.
From the publisher
👉 Be one of the first 500 traders to get a $20 credit when you deposit $50. Use this link kalshi.com/realvision
Raoul Pal welcomes Real Vision favorite Mark Hart, CEO, CIO, and chairman of Corriente Advisors, for a wide-ranging conversation on bitcoin, global macro headwinds, the Exponential Age, and much more. Get those notepads ready because this is one you'll want to watch twice. Recorded on October 7, 2024
This episode is brought to you thanks to Kalshi. Be one of the first 500 traders to get a $20 credit when you deposit $50. Use this link kalshi.com/realvision
Connect with me:
Twitter (X): https://twitter.com/RaoulGMI
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/raoulgmi/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/raoul-pal-real-vision/
Newsletter: https://raoulpal.substack.com
My other work:
Real Vision: https://rvtv.io/3LHYIaH
Global Macro Investor: https://globalmacroinvestor.com
EXPAAM: https://expaam.com
Connect with Real Vision™ Online:
Twitter: https://rvtv.io/twitter
Instagram: https://rvtv.io/instagram
Web: 🔥 https://rvtv.io/3Y4t5Pw
Disclaimer: https://media.realvision.com/wp/20231004185303/Disclaimer-1.pdf
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices


