In short
Podcast Summary: Raoul Pal: The Journey Man - The Real Estate Bubble and Targeting Innovation
Episode Overview In this episode, Raoul Pal interviews Matt Halstead and Michael Lazorik, investment directors at the Teacher Retirement System of Texas (TRS). The discussion revolves around macroeconomics, crypto, real estate, and artificial intelligence (AI), focusing on how these elements combine to impact investment strategies in the Exponential Age. Recorded on September 8, 2023, this conversation highlights TRS's innovative approach to investment in a rapidly evolving financial landscape.
Key Themes and Topics
- The Exponential Age Thesis
- Macro Trends: Halstead and Lazorik explain how the Exponential Age refers to the accelerating pace of change in technology, finance, and society.
- Institutional Adoption: TRS is at the forefront, integrating emerging tech and crypto into their investment framework to secure higher returns.
- Investment Strategies
- Focus on Innovation: Halstead emphasizes that targeting innovation is essential for achieving double-digit returns amidst rising interest rates.
- Identifying Big Markets: The importance of identifying large markets that can yield substantial returns, especially in areas affected by technological disruption, is discussed.
- Real Estate Perspective
- Challenges and Opportunities: The conversation delves into the evolving real estate landscape, particularly how e-commerce and remote work are reshaping demand for physical spaces like malls and offices.
- Future of Offices: While the demand for office space is declining, there is a recognition of potential opportunities for creative repurposing and innovation in the sector.
- Navigating the Crypto Landscape
- Crypto as an Alternative Asset Class: TRS has begun investing in digital assets and is actively exploring blockchain applications in their investment strategy.
- Long-Term Vision: The speakers express optimism about the crypto market's growth potential and its integration with traditional finance.
- AI's Impact on Investment
- AI and Portfolio Management: The need for institutional investors to incorporate AI into their strategies is highlighted as essential for maintaining competitive advantage.
- Risks and Opportunities: The speakers discuss the balance between leveraging AI for efficiency while being cautious about its implications and inherent risks.
- Energy Challenges in Investment
- Electricity and Infrastructure: The conversation touches on Texas's energy challenges and the importance of reliable power for future investments, particularly in real estate and tech sectors.
- Innovative Solutions: Both Halstead and Lazorik acknowledge the need for innovative energy solutions that align with their investment objectives.
Key Takeaways
- Innovation is Crucial: For TRS, focusing on innovative technologies in their investment strategy is essential for meeting the long-term needs of pensioners.
- Real Estate Transformation: The real estate sector must adapt to changing consumer behaviors and technological advancements, leading to opportunities for repurposing and redefining spaces.
- Crypto's Growing Importance: As digital assets become a larger part of the investment landscape, institutions like TRS are actively exploring this space for potential high returns.
- Integrative Approach: Combining insights from macroeconomic trends, crypto, and AI will be vital for navigating the complexities of modern investment.
Conclusion Raoul Pal's discussion with Matt Halstead and Michael Lazorik offers a forward-looking perspective on how major pension funds are adapting to the rapidly changing economic landscape. Their focus on innovation, the evolving nature of real estate, and the integration of digital assets reflect a broader trend among institutional investors as they seek to capitalize on the opportunities presented by the Exponential Age. As these discussions continue to unfold, it becomes evident that the financial ecosystem is in a state of transformation, and those willing to embrace change will be best positioned for success.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:02Hey, everyone. If you like this podcast, go behind the paywall to get privilege access to the smartest minds in finance. Visit realvision.com slash rvpod and use the promo code podcast10 to get 10 % off our essential membership for the first year. Join the Real Vision community and learn how to become a better investor. And now to today's episode of Raoul Pal Real Vision.
0:32Hi, I'm Raoul, and I'm the host of The Journeyman, my podcast which takes you through my journey to the nexus of macro, crypto, and technology. You see, these are really important things for us to focus on as all of these megatrends come together. And in this episode coming up, I'm speaking to a surprising group, Matt and Mike from Texas Teachers Retirement System. Now, these guys are at the forefront of institutional adoption, both of crypto, but also technology, and how it affects the broader landscape. And it's a real honor because they've not done any podcast before, but they're good friends of mine.
1:22They're great thinkers. And I really want you to see how far people are thinking this through and where the big money lies in all of this equation. It's been the start of their journey. They've been the journey for a couple of years now, but it's only going to accelerate. So I think you'll find it fascinating. You see, the crypto world is endlessly fascinating because so many people just kind of look at price all day and think that price is everything. But a good friend of mine, John Burbank, used to say that price is a liar. And what that means is sometimes price doesn't reflect the fullness of the information at hand.
1:58And the fullness of the information at hand is, yes, crypto is driven by liquidity and liquidity is tight, as we're talking in September 2023. but I've just come back from Mainnet, a big event in New York and there I could see institutions. I mean, Matt was there again, had a coffee with him chatting through where Texas teachers are but also with people like Colleen Sullivan from Brevin Howard and she's talking about all the people building in gaming and culture. There were people talking about payment systems, security systems, ID. There's people talking about regulation. there's people building real world assets.
2:37Franklin Templeton who've been on Real Vision talking about how they're putting real world financial assets on the blockchain. They've got a tokenized money market fund for example. What we're finding or what I'm finding is yeah we all see the price on the screen but it doesn't make you appreciate how many incredible people are in this space and what they're building. They're all breaking down a component part of the financial system or the internet itself and addressing that. And when you've got thousands of teams of literally the smartest people on the planet all doing the same thing, you'd rather back those than fade it.
3:17And that's why I'm always fascinated by this space, because I've been around the finance industry. When I was at Goldman, most people that they would hire came out of the top universities. We were absorbing more scientists into finance than any other place, which didn't make sense because then people weren't innovating, but the money was big in finance and there was a megatrend. But now we're seeing a nexus of, I think, even smarter people because we've got creators, artists, technologists, macro people, finance people, everybody coming together to build this ecosystem kind of in this distributed mechanism.
3:55It's truly amazing. and the VC money that powered the space back in 2020, 2021 and 2022 is funding these projects as they're all going to come through the other side and it'll change the face of it forever. Anyway, let's get back in, dig in with Matt and Mike from Texas Teachers to understand how they're seeing this. And as ever, make sure if you're on the Real Vision platform that you take notes, Let's get the AI to summarize some of this stuff and take notes. And obviously, if there's bits you don't understand, you can use the AI for that too. But as I said, the note-taking is a superpower. It'll collect your thoughts.
4:34It'll help you gather all the information at hand and make good investment decisions. Anyway, let's go to the interview. Join me, Raoul Pal, as I go on a journey of discovery through the macro, crypto, and exponential age landscapes. In The Journeyman, I talk to the smartest people in the world so we can all become smarter together.
5:00Matt, Mike, finally get you on Real Vision. Welcome. Thank you, Al. So this is an interesting conversation because here we are going to be talking from your perspective, which is the Texas retirement system, but we're going to be talking, which to most people sounds like it's something kind of stodgy and an old institution. But yet we're going to actually talk about exponential age and how it applies and how you guys are thinking about it. Because it's fascinating. I've gotten to know you guys over the years now. And I just think it's a great story in what you guys are thinking. So first, give a bit of background about yourselves and then maybe one of you can talk about what TRS does to frame it all up.
5:44and then we'll kick off from there. I'll kick it off since I'm the older of the two of us. I have less time here. But first of all, the future is so bright for crypto and other innovative technologies that I do have to wear sunglasses to work every day. But I will take them off for the purpose. But we really do try and focus on emerging technologies. And my background is just that. I think my crowding achievement in my life that was finding and investing$20 million in VMware at a$200 million pre, which is now owned by Broadcom at$80 billion. So when you see stuff like that, you have to pay attention.
6:26And it also taught me something that I'll say before I cut over to Matt, which is when the future is bright, it usually is dim for somebody else. There's a lot of doubters. When I looked at that investment, I called Intel. I called Microsoft. Both of them told me that it was of the devil, that this was black magic, that the technology was causing problems and didn't work. And once I heard that and I talked to end users and people that really valued what VMware was doing and virtualizing operating systems, I realized that they were on to something. So I think it's just important that when you see stuff over the years.
7:02I worked at Dell for a long time and did some corporate venture there, which was also very innovative. and before that I was at a maybe too innovative company called Lehman Brothers that innovated themselves right out off the planet. So I appreciate that there's innovation for better and for worse but most importantly my job at TRS is to do our co-investment program focusing on technology for private equity venture and growth which is why I got paired up with Matt who I will turn over to now who got us on the crypto train pretty early for a U.S. pension plan. Yeah, I didn't start there. So I started my career working for an ability of Goldman Sachs doing real estate private equity, that is public private markets, which was an incredible place to be trained.
7:52I had, I think, the good fortune to start in 2007 and so saw the tail end of the run-up just prior to the global financial crisis and got to see the industry get reorganized and work on a lot of workouts. It was nice to not have risk on but to be able to benefit from that experience. um but i but i also just kind of looked at the at the firm and didn't see a a lifestyle that i wanted to model mine after for for no reason one way or the next and decided i wanted to live abroad and so moved to argentina um worked in the wine business worked for a startup down there was uh really with the goal of seeing the world very differently than we lived here in the united States and was down there for two years.
8:47And at that point in time, we're at 2012 and Argentina was about to go through another unfortunate devaluation and just decided it was time to move back to the States. I was with my girlfriend at the time, now my wife, and we decided we wanted to be entrepreneurs. And so moved to Austin, Texas to start a chocolate factory, which is what we did and made, in my opinion, some of the best fine chocolates in the world for eight years, but just decided, hey, one of us should get a job. And that was me. And one of my mentors just recommended, hey, take a look at Texas teachers. They're trying to do things a bit differently now.
9:24They need to build out a real estate team trying to do more principal investing, more direct investing. You should check it out. And then that was 11 years ago. So I've worked on the real estate team here, focused on a variety of different things. And real estate has slowly blended into real assets. Can talk about that a bit later. But in 2020, I had a friend of mine that was starting a business in crypto. Hadn't paid attention to it, but very quickly was convinced that it was going to be a big market and we weren't currently focusing on it at the fund. And so spent the better part of 2020 researching the space, became convinced that it was something that we need to be organized, needed a dedicated effort to have a chance at being successful, pitched our management team.
10:18And we've been, I would say, among the more active investors in the United States for the last couple of years. So that leads us to where we're at today. It's bizarre that a real estate guy ends up being... It makes no sense. Yeah, it makes no sense. It almost sounds like a joke, right? A real estate guy and a tech guy on the way to talk to our CIO about this innovative thing called blockchain and crypto. And here we are. We both still have jobs. We're both still focused on it. And like I said, most importantly, TRS is a long-term firm. We're focused on innovation. And we know it's not always easy to find innovation.
10:57There's all kinds of stories. Talk me through that a bit is how, why TRS focused on innovation? Because a lot of pension systems don't. They kind of just say, listen, we're just going to service our pension holders and we'll just get on with it. Why, how did it foster that culture? Mike, I guess you've been around that long enough. I mean, I'll start with the most obvious, which is, you know, we're just in the era that you well know of interest rates climbing to a point where you might be able to create some fixed income streams that could fund pension annuities. But the reality is, whether it's private equity, whether it's venture, whatever it may be, alts in general, and I think crypto clearly is a new alt asset category at some point now or in the future, we recognize that we have to be playing in the areas that are going to deliver at least a double-digit return because we have to fund these pension activities.
11:53Finding little opportunities to make money is easy. It really is. But if you've got real money to put to work at scale, that's much more difficult. And I think it very much is akin to venture capital where first and foremost, it's about targeting big markets and ideally getting in front of those big markets before they're as a parent to everyone else. And so if you just talk about innovation at large, well, that's what is the force driving change in the world. And that is going to inform existing markets that create different investment opportunities and the new markets where money will be made at scale in the future.
12:34So I don't really know how you can invest at scale and not have innovation at the forefront of how you think about the world. I mean, we have big, complex problems in the world today that have to be solved. Much of that solution does need to come through a combination of public and private capital, and it's going to need to be addressed through technology, or it's going to be hard to make it work. Hey, everyone. We're going to take a quick pause and hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back. Your favorite neighborhood spot grows with Square. Indeed, my favorite neighborhood spot has quickly become Todd Snyder in Williamsburg.
13:13Todd Snyder is one of my favorite menswear shops and has supplied me with all the clothes I have needed this quite hot summer. Every business has different goals, but Square is the business platform that supports them all. From opening a new location, selling something new, or just expanding their reach. Indeed, I've seen it with Todd Snyder. In Square, also, you can get real-time insights, so don't wait for end-of-day reports. Go to square.com forward slash go forward slash realvision to learn more about how your business can grow with Square. That's S-Q-U-A-R-E dot com slash G-O slash R-E-A-L-V-I-S-I-O-N.
14:02So let's talk about that. Let's talk about both of your investment framework. What is that problem set? Because it sounds like you want to get early ahead of the big wave because that's where the real returns come, which is why you're early stage in a lot of stuff. What is your framework of understanding of the world that you guys have built to say, okay, these are where we want to place our bets? In general, the necessity, aside from just getting greater returns, to be focused on innovation also impacts existing portfolios. So the framework is, and we can use AI as an example of an innovation that is being adopted very quickly, maybe faster than various crypto and blockchain technologies at this moment in time.
14:47But it has real implications for companies. We've seen companies suffer, and we see companies spending an immense amount of money in order to stay competitive. So if you were to ignore AI, you're probably ignoring your portfolio. So innovation, but people fail to realize, and Matt's point is valid, it impacts money in the ground in a way that can be very detrimental if you're not moving ahead of that curve. And I think the real estate market is probably fraught with all kinds of innovative problems and opportunities right now that people like Matt understand. And if you're not understanding it, then you're investing in the rear view mirror.
15:27You're investing in the rear view mirror. That's dangerous. Valuations always lag the innovation. On all these things, Raul, it's like, what are the fundamental long-term trends? Let's start there and then think about these trends as systems. And what's been the most helpful approach that I've taken, if you want to talk about a framework, is think about the high-level trend, look at it as a system, try to understand how the different pieces of the system fit together and identify both opportunity and risk, and then use that to inform how you want to be positioned with an investment strategy. So, I mean, some of the big long-term trends that seem apparent is that we're becoming an increasingly energy-consumptive world that is powering all of technology, the velocity of movement of people is accelerating at a way that the existing infrastructure and real estate market has not been well suited to to adapt to that rate of change how we look at things like blockchain and see the ability for open global systems to be built in a way that hasn't been possible to date so at the same time the built world is becoming increasingly regionalized and this theme of reshoring on sharing is real um the information uh in the world is becoming more globalized and if you think about the what is plausible what is possible with ai in my view it is it leads to an increasingly automated and intelligent internet and it leads to the amplification of people who have differentiated ideas um and it does it in a globally connected way and we can go on and on there's a bunch of these big big trends and themes that are present in the world today the ones of these the ones i want to get before we dig into a lot of that stuff and get really meaty on that is i want to um talk about because you and i have talked about this is how you're applying this framework to real estate which people wouldn't ordinarily think of, but this is how you think real estate now.
17:38You've kind of got a very clear idea. How are you thinking through it? Well, we went through the better part of the last century with virtually no product obsolescence and limited market obsolescence. And really all that was happening was that new investable categories were being added. And that changed markedly. I guess the first observation of that was how e-commerce changed demand for retail, for physical storefronts. And that really occurred, call it 15 years ago, where we saw shopping malls get hit, power centers get hit. And over the span of, call it five years, you saw incredible value destruction in the space.
18:24That's clearly happening in offices today. And I think that's going to accelerate. And so applying that lens to real estate says, I need to understand what we own that has the ability to be disintermediated by technology. I need to understand what big markets are going to be created by technology. And I think we need to think from a differentiated approach to investing in these businesses versus just being tactical. So the typical thing you will see in institutional real estate, I think, is someone that will identify a short-term trend or a long-term trend. They'll raise a capital, a pool of capital around it, a fund.
19:10But it tends to be, let me invest in this product right now. And I think the world is changing so quickly that it merits a different approach to think about building businesses around these themes. And so we're seeing the convergence of private equity, real estate and infrastructure, venture capital all happening at once. You're a Mike's world here, right? Because you're saying we can be the fund capital to create this new future. Yeah. And there's just more of an operating need for the new product that's being created. So rather than putting up a physical structure and viewing the operations as commodity, most of the opportunity on the go forward requires very real operating and private equity expertise.
20:00And that is new to the industry. And traditionally, the capital markets and real estate have not rewarded that they've required a discount for that. you look at hospitality, you look at more service-related businesses around real estate, and the valuations have always suffered relative to sticks and bricks. And I think that could change. And in the private equity slash early stage venture world and everything in between, if you're not focused on innovation, like I said, you're missing the point. And innovation is not just blockchain. Virtualization is innovation. Crypto is innovation. AI is innovation.
20:40Putting two companies together and taking out a bunch of costs is innovation. So I think it's important that you identify innovation all around your world because it is all around us. It is true that some of the more important innovations are clearly tied to software technology in terms of game-changing innovations. But innovation is just something that has to be embedded in everything that you do yeah i mean you have to assume that the world changes and innovation is catching up or leading the change matt on the question of shopping malls and now offices what the hell is going to happen i mean there is no way people are going back to work you know this is an obvious trend that there's there's no way i mean here we all are in different places and we it doesn't matter to us.
21:33We've met in real life, but we also meet in different digital formats all the time. And it's like, there's no real reason to go to work often. There's really no reason to go to a mall. What's going to happen to all of that? And obviously the banks are sitting on vast amounts of this. So it's a very prescient thing as well. I'm not as negative on offices maybe as the broader market or when I perceive the broader market's opinion to be today. I think it's clear that demand is less. So starting there, we have less demand for office space for a variety of reasons. Some business models clearly do not need physical space.
22:12A big user of suburban office in the past would have been a call center. No reason why you need that operating expense in your business. I think for professional services, it's less clear. What is clear is that demand is less and product preference is changing. And I think that like most things, it will get oversold and there will actually be a pretty interesting opportunity to position yourself differently. I believe we're going to see per service, you know, driven businesses for like we have an apprentice business here at Texas Teachers. And so I think that's very difficult to replicate with a remote model.
22:53I think we're more effective when we're in person together. And I think people will continue experimenting on how to use space, how to have teams work together. And there will be a bunch of different models that are adapted over time. But I do think that more of a residential experience, more of a hospitality and service infused offering will be demanded. And I do think a lot of the product that's existing today is largely obsolete. but I don't think that we're going to look at a world in 10 years out and all of a sudden we need half the space that we need today I don't I don't believe that is true I think the wild card there will likely be AI and seeing the the implementation of AI in large-scale businesses for things like accounting, legal, middle and back office.
23:48Will these be traditional heavy office uses that are vulnerable? That's very possible. So I think it's unclear. But what is clear is you're not getting paid to go first here. You're not getting paid today to be a first mover. and I think investors that are looking at a way to invest in the office category will be best off letting out a bit. But you're right, Raul, there's shortage of exposure to the sector from traditional lenders. It's very clear that lenders do not want this product back. There will be likely a very interesting opportunity that people will make a lot of money on I'm trying to right-size capital structures, create new product offerings.
24:39But from my perspective, it's a largely uninteresting place to be an investor today. Yeah. I mean, living in Austin, no one will tell you that real estate's going the way of the dodo. And when you look at all the farmland turning into, whether it's rocket facilities, parts of Tesla, SpaceX, all the industries moving here, and the people that work in those companies. and factories. In factories, they have to be there. They need a place to live. So the real estate model here in Texas, as evidence was happening in Austin, is pretty clear. I spent three days in New York City. I feel like trend is heading the right way.
25:15It is an apprenticeship business. I spent a lot of time with our partners. A lot of them were adding floors, whether they hired people to show up at the office or not. There were people in the offices talking, comparing notes, you could just get the vibe of an office and a culture and decisions being made. So I feel like the pendulum is swinging back. I think you're going to see more people coming back into the office. But I acknowledge fully what Matt said and what you're implying, which is the future is not going to look like the past at all. It's about repurposing. Here in Texas, it's about growing.
25:50Yeah. New York, Texas is very different because it's a fast growing economy. me we're seeing a few of those i go to new york and it feels i mean the difference between the vibe in austin versus new york is so different new york is empty boarded up shops in midtown because there's no office workers to go to the bodega or go to the little snack place and you know it's like i don't know how that recovers without prices clearing at a lower level again and people be able to come back like they did with Brooklyn and make it a bit funkier, a bit more fun, get young people back. I just don't see it. Well, that point's the right point.
26:30So you go to Soho today, you go to Brooklyn today, and they're thriving. At the same time, Midtown's dead. You made the comment on retail, and I can say as a retailer with my prior family business, the rent can be free, and it's still too high if there's no traffic. your operating costs don't make sense. And we're going to see that continue with retail and see that continue with offices as well. In long term, there's likely going to have to be a reset to valuations where redevelopment makes sense. And it's very expensive to demolish these big structures in Midtown. But at a certain point, if there is no demand...
27:12So is the mega trend here There is a re-understanding of what midtowns and downtowns mean in the United States. You know, because those big steel buildings with lots of insurance companies and that kind of stuff. Feels like there's probably 30 % less workers going to be in those places at best. So what else could you do if you're thinking forward on the big mega trend? How could cities be reimagined? Well, there'll be random deals one-off. Like I said, I think if you have a small enough amount of capital to invest, you can apply your creativity and make money. We've seen people try to position some of these as residential.
27:52You know, if it has power, maybe it's a data center. There's a variety of different strategies that are site-specific that could work. But that's not going to be re-envisioning Midtown. But what you have is you've got Grand Central, which isn't moving. You have the park, which isn't moving. You have the museums and institutions, which aren't moving. And so, you know, I think this needs to look something like a public-private partnership. And, you know, on a lot of these large-scale mixed-use deals, one thing I've learned over just the years through making mistakes is that early phases of large-scale real estate projects almost always need some amount of public support because of the infrastructure that is required to be built all at once.
28:37and the way capital is organized in the United States for real estate is largely IRR and shorter trial return driven. And that is not congruous with world-class mixed-use projects. And that's where I think we're going to need to rethink how the public sector and the private sector works together to solve these big problems. And I think if you have forward-thinking cities, states, and municipalities that are willing to embrace that, you could have an incredible solution. And if you don't, I think it can take quite some time for at the bottom and recover because the math, it just won't make sense.
29:16So it's going to depend on regional governments, really, and city municipalities to find people who are forward-thinking. Yeah, it's a local business. And if you want to have something that you're really proud of, hire incredible architects, feature inspiring design, that doesn't work with a merchant-billed real estate development model. That's why you see value engineering, you see in a lot of new cities, very uninspiring design. You can feel it. Walk in Soho, walk in London versus walking around, I don't know, I'll pick on Austin. There's just not, there's not much there. And there's a reason why, because it was built over the last couple decades with money that wanted to make a short-term return.
Read the full transcript
30:05And so all of those design features are engineered out because you don't make enough money on the early leasing activity to justify the expense. It's why you see the same tenants in every new shopping center that is institutionally built, because it's the safe thing to do. It trades on a short-term income statement that assumes that these cash flows will be durable, and they're not. And the market has to penalize that before you see a change in programming. And so if we're on our way down in the commercial real estate cycle, it gets interesting for you once we start getting to more distress levels where things become opportunistic that you can put capital at work for people to repurpose stuff, create a new future.
30:58That sounds like innovation, bro. It does. Yeah. I mean, right now, prices haven't adjusted. You haven't had enough for selling yet. And so you're basically being required to make a call on rates because capital structures are inverted. I mean, you're borrowing at 7, 8, 9 % today. I'm not even sure that rates, even if they come down, if even at the end this all nets out the 25 % less occupancy in offices, I mean, that's a big hole. Oh, in the office sector, yes. I'm saying product where demand is much better understood. So to say residential, the pricing still makes absolutely no sense in the world today to be a buyer.
31:45No, that's right. Absolutely no sense. So, Mike, what gets you excited in what you're looking at? Because it's really difficult in your space. People ask me about VC and I'm like, I'm the world's worst because everything that looks amazing usually goes to zero and everything that looks terrible does really well. What are you looking at here? Because there's a lot going on. Yeah. And I think, unfortunately, like Matt said, sometimes innovation is in the form of rational pricing, meaning that you can't just keep raising your next round at a higher and higher price without any kind of thought about the turmoil value or what your business looks like once you finally sell it to the general public, which is the only real way to get liquid in this world.
32:32Even if you're doing M &A with a large company, you're ultimately selling to public shareholders. So I would say, first of all, everyone at the moment is still rethinking where things are. As you see companies peeking their head out, because we get well beyond the two-year fundraising cycle that most companies are in in a rational environment, I think you're seeing them, the good ones are popping their head up, getting ahead of things, coming out with rational numbers, looking for investors that are along for the ride, and frankly, taking advantage of the ones that want to go away. So the capital structure is still getting figured out.
33:10But to your point about what we're ultimately looking for, I mean, scalable businesses that can ride the wave, that are CapEx efficient, that utilize innovation, The ability to use your credit card anywhere and everywhere and facilitate transactions clearly has a place for the blockchain and innovation. But we'll back the clock 10, 20 years, we're much more of a cash society. So I think looking at those megatrends and finding companies that are taking advantage, smart management teams that know what they're doing and have a vision. And you're right, Roel, like the great ideas are never the ones that you and I come up with.
33:52I remember the banker that took, he said, I met this woman, Meg Whitman. I'm taking her company called eBay Public. What's eBay? Well, two people meet online and they sell something. And I was like, that's a stupid idea. Who's going to buy something from somebody they don't know? There's no trust. And I could go through all the reasons why that was never going to work, which obviously blockchain, the internet. And frankly, it's just a better way to buy and sell things. I didn't recognize it. And I think that is the reason why we try and find great GPs, because it is just a handful of people that can really manifest what's going to happen.
34:29So you tend to form it out to other managers as opposed to direct yourself? We do a mix. Well, we don't have the time or resources, given what Matt said, to really be doing it ourselves. We are a partnership model here. That doesn't mean we're going to blindly give money. And what I do and what a lot of institutions are doing now, we're doing co-investments alongside it, where we let them think about what's going on and construct a blind fund and have the good ideas, find the people that are innovating and get the money in the ground in a way that's going to create an acceptable return for the risks they're taking.
35:04and as those ideas bubble up, they tend to attract more investors. We try to position ourselves as an attractive investor for those situations to try and get the best opportunities. So, we're very much relying on our partner network and then we do take a view about certain things and decide to lean in and that's how we end up selecting certain investments based on our views. How are you dealing with AI? Because it's a gold rush of which everything is super expensive already. We kind of all know that we have to be involved. It's hard. Yeah. And we are involved. We're investors in a lot of the AI companies, whether it's software, Matt could talk about some of the infrastructure, but we are a big believer that this is not a flash in the pan.
35:53I do think it bodes well for blockchain and crypto. I think it creates a lot of innovation. and Matt can talk more about that. But the short answer is, if you're not thinking about AI, you're in trouble. And frankly, I work a lot in the enterprise software world where I think it's going to be very interesting where they're going to have to root out inefficiencies in their businesses. Most enterprise software companies are basically a database and a front end. So when you peel back the onion, no matter how innovative some piece of enterprise software is, it's about the use cases and what problems are solving in the real world.
36:31I believe that AI has a place in a lot of those worlds and it is a fundamentally different set of tools and technologies, whether it's running it yourself, using it as a service, how you implement it, what you're solving for. And frankly, I'll say this, this is the conversation. How much trust do we have in AI? When you allow AI to point out a problem and then solve it without any human intervention, that's a good thing. That is a scary thing too. And so I think there's caution. I think the reality is the lack of innovation in enterprise software is going to rear its ugly head now and you're going to see companies that are going to charge ahead and suddenly their offerings are going to be way differentiated than these enterprise software companies that are basically a database and a front end.
37:18So I think it has huge implications for a number of more traditional technology businesses. And then from there, it just keeps going into different areas, like the Berkshire Hathaway story about sanding cabinets and just using AI to train robots and those types of things to do physical labor. There's robots serving drinks in bars in Las Vegas. Well, you know, what a perfect place. you know if they know what kind of drink you like and they actually have an idea about how to innovate it you're like that's the best damn drink i've ever had because this robot has somehow figured out exactly what i want i mean so i'm what i'm also saying is you know the old world enterprise software is frankly dealing with it head-on and it's not going to be pretty for everybody and those that figure it out are going to really innovate and win but let's not forget about robots serving us cocktails that we love like there's lots of use cases that people have not even thought about.
38:15And to get to... I don't think I need a robot to tell me I love a frozen margarita mic, but it's an interesting point. I mean, Raul, we've looked at it a bunch of different ways. This is undeniably a mega trend, if not the most important trend that I think all professional investors need to study. I don't think I have a particularly... I don't have any reason to win this category. And so where I focused on it is our core competency of real estate and real assets. And so we've spent the better part of a year trying to understand, again, the system, like what is required to deliver these applications to maximize the potential of the technology.
38:59So it's clear that you're going to need a lot more power. You're going to need a lot more compute. And like just starting there from the perspective of real assets, it's pretty clear to us that it's going to be uneconomic for any application, mostly to not be on the cloud. I think it's also interesting from a venture perspective that the costs to play as a startup in AI, I believe, are underestimated by most institutions. And both the access to training data and the access to compute are going to be substantial for any startup trying to play in the space. And so it's hard for me to see where the winners will be with respect to startups that are competing with the established players in the space, the Amazons, the Microsofts, the Apples of the world.
39:55Just the scarcity of compute alone is hard enough. Yeah, and so that's where we focus. Like, all right, we have a core competency here. Let's try to understand how we can participate in this theme. And so I think people should really be paying attention to what's required with respect our and computing infrastructure, also networking infrastructure. And I think there's going to be a huge tailwind in the real estate business and infrastructure business into just call it data centers writ large. I think there's going to be a lot of money made and a lot of capital destroyed because it's not straightforward.
40:37And so that has our attention. That's probably the most direct way I'm focused on AI. And then from a startup perspective, you know, the digital asset venture funds that we've invested in, there's a number of different ways that you could envision blockchain and crypto being highly complementary to the the infrastructure and the architecture of these systems as AI becomes much more broadly adopted. And so it feels like it, it really confirms the base case that we had that web three is the future of how the internet works. And AI is kind of the reason why it has to happen. So with, I mean, if you can, if you can envision a world where, you know, the multiple billion people on earth that currently do not have internet have it through any number of different delivery mechanisms.
41:32Traveling's doing a pretty good job of that. I've got it in Little Cayman now. It's incredible. Yeah, and you can envision mesh networks. You see the cost coming down for mobile devices, and you say, hey, we have billions of people that are going to come online in the coming decades. They're going to be mobile first. They're going to be connected. Wow, what an interesting, you know, sorts of productivity that's going to come online. And it's going to be in a world where you have an increasingly connected global internet. And if you believe that blockchain can evolve into the financial rails for this internet, they're going to be connected both through value and through information.
42:13And so I think that as a starting point is an interesting trend. And then if you believe in an increasingly automated and intelligent internet, that's where this theme of tokenization, it's called real-world assets in the crypto world. It's really the idea that we standardize information. We have a common underlying technology that defines ownership. And we have to create these systems that allow automated market participants to be the most effective. Just think of it as bots for the financial system. But you're not being asked to pay a very high price for it based upon the market cap of crypto today.
42:56That's what captures my imagination. Yeah, I mean. And I have to add, too, I mean, we can't forget about AI as it impacts our investment world directly, our managers. So, you know, I'll take the two signals of the world. The folks that are very fast in and out of the market doing things, AI enabling that set of technologies for players in liquid, public, fast-moving markets, well, that's a phenomenon you can't ignore. I'll take the other side of that, private equity. Private equity is about information asymmetry. It's about fighting a needle in a haystack. It's about not missing a needle in a haystack.
43:33And frankly, I'll tell you, as a co-investor, the day that I don't see a goal seek for a 20 % IRR on a deal, 20.000065 when it's pasted into the cell is a good day because a lot of the innovation that AI brings to folks that have resources, have data, and have the ability to apply AI. And this is where right now we're early. One extreme you have groups that say, we're going to have an AI investment committee member. Like we're going to use AI to write memos. Like AI, we're going to harness AI to innovate our industry and give it a seat at the table. You have others that are completely ignoring it and saying that this is a crap business.
44:15We really can't rely on AI. But, you know, maybe I'll take some AI data here or there or some suggestions. So I think it's very early and it's going to be interesting to see how it plays out. But our investment universe, our managers really need to be focused on AI as well. Hey, everyone. We're going to take another quick break and hear a word from our partners, and then we'll be right back.
44:40Yeah, and I just think it plays into that core thesis of blockchain technology so much. The blockchain element, here's a question I've not asked you, Matt, is have you guys talked to people like whoever, Franklin Templeton or Fidelity and said, look, you know, we're happy to test one of your blockchain money market funds or we're happy to test a bond offering that's done on Ethereum. How active are you in actually using within the business, let alone investing with it? So spoken with all of them, have a lot of respect for those groups you just mentioned, but we have not been active in piloting or being a participant in the technology yet.
45:20We've started investing in venture capital through dedicated digital asset and crypto investment managers. and I think it's a very logical next step is to think about how we can become a more active participant using the technology in our organization. I mean, don't forget, if you guys say, look, you know, we're happy to give this a go. The more people like you who do it, the more activity is on chain, the better your portfolio goes up, the better your pensioners are, everybody wins, right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it's just being mentioned, we have to be very cautious as we integrate new technologies into our business.
46:05I'm a big believer in the value that will be created by all of those different things you just mentioned, Raul. And my job is to continue to develop more knowledge, use our network, and to deliver that type of an incremental next step. and manage those risks so that people understand, all right, guys, here's what we're doing. Here's why we're doing it. It just takes time. Yeah, it takes time. And I mean, I was fed and clothed by the mainframe. I mean, my dad worked at EDS early days with the Ross Perot. And I started ringing Adele and I was like, dad, the PC's going to crush the mainframe. The mainframe's toast and the mainframe is not toast.
46:52The mainframe, you know, Most of our general ledger transactions at most banking systems around the world run on mainframes. So this idea that the financial world is ready for innovation, well, it's never been more ready. And the mainframe may eventually go away. But the reality is that what you're saying is so true, that the lack of innovation there, because of the risk return to go and do some of the things you need to do, step off the mainframe and step into a blockchain-enabled world. It's happening in pockets. I'll credit Apollo as a great organization that's moving ahead to do that. And I think there's major first mover advantage for the organization's technologies that can jump that risk chasm to get tokenization, to get repos to settle at blockchain.
47:39The list of inefficiencies is locked. I mean, I'll tell you a great story. I had my global macro investor roundtable. We were in Majorca, and one of the guys has been a member for a long time, Ozzy. he ran like trading treasury and everything else at one of the big Aussie banks and he just retired and he said you know I've been really busy with blockchain stuff I'm like what are you you know what are you looking at what are you doing there he goes oh we built five stable coins in different currencies I'm like what's the point he's like oh you don't understand the US is going to t plus one settlement we're in Australia FX is t plus two plus we've got the overnight issue he said sometimes is three-day settlement.
48:22And in which case, we have to pay, we have to give tens of billions of dollars to like Morgan Stanley or Goldman as our broker to settle stuff on time, which we don't want to do because it's an inefficient use of capital. So we had to set up stable coins. I'm like, okay, that's really interesting. Yeah. Yeah. And we go to bed at night knowing that the money's in our checking account. So the general ledger works, but you're absolutely right as interest rates go up or these t-plus whatever problems and the legal realities around them as well as the cost what's the tipping point comes over i think these technologies are going to flood it and i think crypto is going to be the big one over there yeah i think so so matt how are you investing in the space are you holding bitcoin in the funds or or are you all vc or you know explain to people how you're approaching this space at this phase in the journey because you It's a big organization.
49:18It takes time to get stuff through. But whereabouts are you in that journey? Yeah, so we began almost three years ago presenting a broader business plan to our management team about how we thought a professional digital assets investment portfolio should look. And just in an oversimplified format, it is early stage, small specialist blockchain venture funds paired with effectively a public portfolio or a token portfolio, giving you exposure to really the complete market at that point in time. Where we made a decision to begin and start investing, start learning was in the venture space. So we've made quite a few investments in crypto specialist venture funds that are focused primarily on the pre-seed seed and to a lesser extent, series A financing rounds in blockchain venture.
50:24Over time, I would expect that to broaden dramatically. I do think it's important to have the ability to invest in both the public and private markets in anything. And digital assets are no exception to that. What do you think when you talk about public markets and digital assets, you'll talk about holding the other one. Like you said, Bitcoin, Ether, Solana, whatever it might be. And we're going to see a growing number of interesting protocols, applications, companies that are going to be investable. Yeah. I mean, the day we get to pay our 1.3 or 1.4 million at growing daily beneficiaries that rely on TRS and Bitcoin, that would change our strategy.
51:05But we are not there. We are very much paying people's pensions in dollars. And so we have to be focused on that. Our CIO is very aware of that. And I think putting this in the venture bucket, which is an area that gives us a lot more latitude, take more risks because it's a venture portfolio, puts us in position to have good visibility to where things are going. Because to Matt's point, it's going to become a more stable part of our portfolio at some point. It's really simple. And again, where we started, our job is to target big markets. And it's pretty clear, I think, at this point that it is conceivable or plausible that the digital asset industry, crypto, blockchain, whatever you want to call it, could plausibly be an enormous market.
51:54and very very simplistically we looked at it and said there is a bunch of different verticals and companies that can be built out of this you have a lot of different ways to win you have very sound downside protection unless you get the entire category wrong off of today's prices but you know this is open source software and in many cases the cost to build You know, winning companies or protocols is generally people and compute, maybe data as well now. And so we thought that value would disproportionately accrue to the pre-seed and seed financing rounds and that it was unclear whether or not there were going to be enormous growth capital needs for many of the big winners in the space.
52:44and so the value in going early and going first and our view was going to be rewarded at the same time you had a global pandemic that was creating you know a very different approach to working you have a very different culture in crypto that's very young it's global it is not the i don't know how mike fits in there i've no i'm trying i'm trying to stay young i mean i'm not afraid to fail. That's me trying to ride the wave. I embrace technologies and I appreciate that I might fail. And by the way, I will point out the obvious that there is some wisdom that can be applied to crypto. I'm not going to point to all the faults that we've experienced in the industry so far, but some of them may have been avoided with a little bit of wisdom.
53:31so people are learning and it's a young industry um you know it's it's this it's this brave new market structure that's it's very crazy and how how it's organized um and you have it's a cultural movement as well in many ways um which a lot of that i love about it um but it has had very bad branding like any new marketplace there are a lot of frauds and scams there were in the past there still are today. By the way, that's what's to be expected. Yeah. It's what's to be expected. Yeah, exactly. Mobile phones and the internet are like the essence of frauds. Absolutely. I just think like, look, you need to continue improving.
54:14You need to learn from the mistakes of the past. There's an increasing amount of professionalization that's coming into the business. But I do believe that there's a bunch of winners that will happen in the future that are not the legacy Silicon Valley venture funds. And so we also saw an opportunity to back the new talent and new firms that are going to be big winners in the future. Our view is that if we're a good partner, we'll be rewarded with a long-term opportunity to grow with these winners as the industry evolves. And we think there's a shot that there's a changing of the guard in many ways.
54:50And I think you have to pay attention to that. I mean, credit derivatives took down Lehman Brothers, right? So there is definitely, you know, but credit derivatives are still around. You know, I've never seen an 11 ,000 year prison sentence, but one just got handed down last night in Turkey. So I'm just saying some of the bad behavior is good as coming out of the system. But we have to stay focused on innovators. You know, and Yatsu, who handed me his business card, like this is a business card. I mean, And I love Yap, right? And Yap Tom is a cool guy. Been in the industry since he was doing coding for Atari, but I now have to be able to figure out how this turns into a business card.
55:30So it's important that you just find the right people is what I'm saying. I think you have to find the people that are the innovators, people that have character and frankly business models that are sustainable that you have to look through and think things through and there will be some great opportunities for us to invest there. And that's our focus. Yeah, I think a lot of institutions feel like, hey, they can pick firms that are going to outperform. And I guess it's possible. It's really hard to do. I think our job is to identify the markets, understand the underlying market dynamics, and understand where risk is present.
56:11And then just find partners that have an aligned vision that you can get the appropriate incentive structure with, that you think have a culture that are built the right way. And if you get the first two right, you should do well enough. I think it's very hard to just go out there and say, I'm going to pick the one or two venture funds that are going to win. Maybe that was true in the past with the Sequoias and benchmarks of the world. I think that's very difficult to do in crypto. And so you see that reflected in our portfolio and partnerships with, you know, a lot higher quantity of investments we've made, much smaller investment sizes than we would traditionally do.
56:51And that's just a reflection of it's early and we're learning. Yeah. And if the mega trend is big enough, you'll be fine. You don't need to nail it. You don't need the alpha when the beta alone is good enough. Right. Yeah. And the biggest mistake I think institutions have made and should be careful of making is not embracing the fundamental change in what it takes to invest in crypto. It's like you want to have this bridge between traditional finance and crypto and that doesn't work. That's what has led a lot of these frauds like Celsius and FTX to get capitalized. And it was done for reasons that are understandable, but you can't go halfway.
57:34If you're going to invest in crypto and blockchain, I think you have to understand the technology. It's fundamentally different than traditional markets. And you need to invest with people. It's not a traditional market wrapper. It's different. No, no, it's very different. The Uniswap ruling showed that, actually. That was really interesting, the regulatory ruling on Uniswap. Basically, you said code. And you see the groups that financed it were crypto-native funds. That's who got the 1 ,000x on Uniswap. Something that goes to your point, Mike, is right at the very beginning is like, mostly when people think you're slightly crazy and nobody understands it, is usually the time.
58:13Like Josh Wolf talks about this. It's like, if it sounds the most ridiculous idea, but your kids are doing it, you better pay attention. Yep. My kids were making videos on Musical.ly and showing me how cool they were. I was like, oh, that's so cute. Great. Which was acquired, became TikTok. So, yes. Yes. The future is in the kit. Final question for you. One of them's come up a reasonable amount. One was mentioned in passing. Electricity. Energy. Big problem. I just learned that there are several organizations trying to build a more distributed grid here in Texas using batteries. There's obviously wind and sources of energy.
59:02Electricity is a problem. It's going to be 108 degrees today, a record smashing number for September 8th here in Austin, Texas. And we're getting regular pings from our grid that we need to be conserving power. So hopefully our state is working to solve this and we're going to be there to help find the innovative products to help them. Yeah, it feels like in your bucket, Matt, this fits Swayle in there as well. Yeah, I mean, I'm as bullish on the potential of Texas as anyone. and this is very clearly the number one issue that has to be addressed by the state is reliability of the grid. But this is unique to Texas.
59:41I think power and water will be the two big ones that have to be thought about to invest. And how fast is the renewables part of Texas going? And what you're observing in the U.S. and then the nuclear mix, you know, people are talking about it. it's early stage it's just interesting it feels like it's in your kind of wheelhouse as well yeah and i'm not an expert by any means on on power but i'm trying to learn as much as i possibly can because it's become increasingly clear that for us to be successful investing in real estate we now have to understand power water and natural resources in a way that just weren't as relevant it's the it's the velocity of of migration to new markets you know it is the acceleration of the consumption of power for for computing and for um all the technology needs that are are becoming increasingly clear and so you know the short answer ral is i don't know but we are spending an enormous amount of time in an area that has not been relevant to our core business No, because Texas had energy and everything's fine, but it's not fine.
1:00:59That's right. It's not fine. I mean, Texas, we are a carbon-first state, and that's going to be the way it is for a long time. Obviously, Europe, with natural gas at the whim of the Russians, has become a problem. And I would just say for us here in the investment world, innovation, fusion, fission, wind, hydro, we'll look at all of them. I think you have to be very open-minded and not pick which of those alternatives is going to be the worst. And the distributed system, I think, is the important one here. And that's a great point. Not have single points of failure. That's right. You can have the best generation capacity in the world, but if it's all bleeding off or you don't have the transmission lines or the proper grid technology.
1:01:43And the other issue is we've got cyber, right? There's cyber attacks all the time. And if you have central points of failure for a state like Texas, that's a huge problem. But yes, we definitely have to be thinking about cyber, about the sources of power, and just being very thoughtful because it's a very important point. Final question. Are you seeing, because again, it's very relevant to Texas. Are you doing much in the VC side in space? It's a really interesting market. Love it. Can't get enough. I think there's winners. They're obvious who they are, and we are very focused on investing with winners.
1:02:17We like to win. but overall that industry is exploding no pun intended you don't want it to explode that's the one thing you don't want to explode but frankly the supply demand imbalance and the number of ideas and frankly the innovation in space some of the things i've seen heard are just things that you couldn't have even thought about because all the technologies and again this is my concept of riding the wave we're at the point now with lower lower cost lift we're at the point now with innovations in underlying technologies. Quantum computing fits into space as well. But we're at a point now where the convergence of all these is going to open up brand new markets that will be game-changing for humanity.
1:03:01That's my view. Not just getting on Mars, but I think here on Earth, it's going to help improve the quality of life for people that didn't tend to stay on Earth, which I do. Matt, do you think all of this changes the productivity? Does it get us out of the trap? Again, you and I have talked about this, the kind of trap of low GDP growth, high debt growth, aging populations. And yeah, we're seeing it everywhere. Do we think we're on the edge over the next 10, 15, 20 years where suddenly we finally see per capita GDP rising? Obviously, populations are going to shrink somewhat and growth coming back and productivity leading because of all of these technologies.
1:03:48Hard to say. I don't know, Raul. I do think it's interesting to think about GDP. It's always been people physically, you know, within our borders. One of the things that I wonder about that captures my imagination with networking and blockchain is, do you have the ability now to pull in productivity from people outside of your borders? to identify talent, to educate talent everywhere across the world, reward that talent in dollars, and to avoid all the strain on the physical infrastructure that makes immigration, I think, a political issue. I think it's plausible that you could envision a world where that productivity is harnessed by the United States or by other countries in a kind of like call it distributed GDP.
1:04:50I don't know. Well, I'm writing an article on this. I'm analyzing Ethereum as if it was an economy that digital nation-state idea. Because if we look at that nation-state, it's a bunch of immigrants, of which we're all part of those immigrants. We spend time in the nation-state. There's GDP. There's a financial system. There's asset system. There's everything there. And maybe what we think of as GDP is just the physical nation state we live in. But as you were suggesting, Matt, there's a whole distributed global connected world that this technology now deals with. Yeah. And I mean, there's thinkers like, you know, Balaji has talked about this and the network state.
1:05:29I think there's some really interesting ideas out there by people that have explored this design space that are worth paying attention to. So it certainly doesn't seem like there's any solution with respect to population growth that's going to get things moving in the direction that you describe. You know, productivity in general has been kind of underwhelming for quite some time, even with what's perceived as very large technological advances. I do think AI is different with respect to the ability to power discovery. So I don't know, your guess is as good as mine there. But I think this theme of how do we as nation states work with the most productive people in the world, create more productive people, and capture that in an ecosystem in a way that was not possible prior to these technological advances.
1:06:29I think that's interesting, but no idea, no idea what that means. Mike, Jimmy? But I do know that people out at Burning Man aren't going to solve this problem. Like enabling the people of Africa to contribute to a global society and have the types of things the Western world has had, you know, helping to improve our climate, like that, what Matt and you were alluding to is definitely helpful. and Ruel, I just want to say, Ronald, thank you, because without you, Matt and I would have been a lot more lost than we were in navigating the maze of getting into this space. You were very helpful along the way, your insights, your support.
1:07:08So I just want to thank you on air that you were very instrumental in helping us get on our way. So thank you very much. Thank you. And thank you for you guys for always sharing your journey as well, because we're all on the journey together, right? That's the whole point, is we've got this new frontier, this new emerging digital nation states, whatever's going on, and we're in it together. It's fun. It's just fun. It is fun. It's each other's brains thinking, hey, you think about this? What does that mean? It's great. Yeah. So thank you guys as well. Yes. Everything's bigger in Texas. Thank you.
1:07:36And thank you for coming on Real Vision. I appreciate it. And it's just interesting because I don't think a lot of people will realize what you guys have been up to. You're real pioneers and people will look back in 10, 20 years time and go, these people were pioneers and they didn't realize it. That's our hope. And TRS will be here long after we're gone. I mean, we're definitely an institution that's serving the people of Texas long after we're done. So, be careful for serving others. Brilliant, guys. Thanks for saying that, Raoul. Thanks so much. See, it's amazing when you talk to a prestigious large institution.
1:08:13They're in the top six largest pension funds in the United States. And people think of pension funds as stayed and out of date. And here we are with Texas at the center of everything. And it's amazing to see. And they've just started their journey. I love how they're thinking through, how does this impact real estate? And not at the superficial level, but really, what is the structure? What do they need? What can they finance that's going to help this new economy, the exponential age develop? and how can they use crypto to better the opportunity set for their pension holders? Because that's what they do.
1:08:55I mean, they're not VCs who do random stuff. I mean, their job is to make sure the pension holders get a good pension. And they've realized that the opportunity set in technology and crypto is higher than other areas. Yes, it comes with risks, but the risk-adjusted returns over time are essentially what drives their decisions in this space. so I think it's amazing and I know many of you ask me all the time well when are the institutions coming they're here and I keep bringing them on real vision and everyone still asks the same question when are the institutions coming they're here but they're in the first 10 % of their journey and over the next cycle they'll be at 50 % of their journey and more people will join them so all it is is a matter of momentum and price to bring people back into the market more fully and some more liquidity conditions.
1:09:45Because again, here in September 2023, liquidity is tight. But as liquidity starts to come back, and we start looking through recession and looking to recovery, we'll see money flowing back into the space where the harsh returns lie. Anyway, I hope you enjoy it. And I will take you back down the rabbit hole at the nexus of macro, crypto, and technology in the next episode.
1:10:14what's up revolutionaries thanks for tuning in for more content like this head over to realvision.com and get unfiltered access to the very best brightest and biggest names in finance
From the publisher
馃敟 Ledger x RV: The Next Digital Assets Wave. Get Your FREE Ticket https://rvtv.io/3rPaoBz
In this week鈥檚 episode, Matt Halstead and Michael Lazorik, investment directors at Teacher Retirement System of Texas, join Raoul for a fascinating conversation on macro, crypto, real estate, and AI. In particular, Matt and Michael discuss how the Exponential Age thesis influences their framework at one of the world's largest pension funds, why innovation will drive the largest returns, and what the future of real estate investing looks like. Recorded on September 8, 2023.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

